KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Paris Hilton and the DEFIANCE Act: Can You Sue Over a Sexually Explicit Deepfake?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Paris Hilton and the DEFIANCE Act: Can You Sue Over a Sexually Explicit Deepfake?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Searches for Paris Hilton jumped in the United States on November 17 and 18, 2026, and Google Trends grouped the query “defiance act” with them; rising related searches included “paris hilton defiance act” and “paris hilton capitol hill.” The official record behind that interest is short. A press release from the office of Rep. Laurel Lee of Florida states that Reps. Lee and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Ms. Paris Hilton held a press conference with advocates and other members to call for passage of the DEFIANCE Act, a bipartisan bill that would let survivors bring civil actions over nonconsensual sexually explicit digital forgeries. Congress.gov shows that the Senate passed S. 1837, the DEFIANCE Act of 2025, without amendment by unanimous consent on January 13, 2026, and that the bill has been held at the desk in the House since that same day.

The practical question for anyone who finds a fake nude or sexual video of themselves online is what they can do now, while the bill waits. Federal law already makes knowingly publishing such a forgery a crime in defined circumstances and requires covered platforms to take it down within 48 hours of a valid request. The existing federal civil action covers disclosure of intimate images, and federal judges have issued restraining orders and injunctions in cases brought under it, but its text does not mention computer-generated forgeries. Some states, including California, already give a civil claim against people who create or spread sexually explicit deepfakes. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about any person named in it.

I. Can you sue over a sexually explicit deepfake under the laws in force today?

A. What federal law already gives you: a civil action for intimate images and a criminal ban on publishing forgeries

Start with the federal civil statute that exists today. Under 15 U.S.C. § 6851, an individual whose intimate visual depiction is disclosed without consent, by a person who knows or recklessly disregards that the individual has not consented, may sue that person in federal district court. The statute defines “disclose” broadly as to transfer, publish, distribute or make accessible, and it defines an intimate visual depiction by what the image shows: uncovered genitals, pubic area, anus or a post-pubescent female nipple of an identifiable individual, or sexual conduct involving that person. The person must be identifiable by face, likeness, a distinguishing feature such as a birthmark, or information displayed with the image. The provision took effect on October 1, 2022, under the effective-date note printed with the section.

The remedies are concrete. A plaintiff may recover actual damages or liquidated damages of $150,000, plus the cost of the action, including reasonable attorney’s fees. The court may also order a temporary restraining order, a preliminary injunction or a permanent injunction directing the defendant to stop displaying or disclosing the image, and it may let the plaintiff proceed under a pseudonym. Two consent rules matter in almost every case. The statute provides that “the fact that the individual consented to the creation of the depiction shall not establish that the person consented to its distribution,” and sharing an image with one person does not establish consent to further disclosure by that person. There are exceptions, though: no action lies for commercial pornographic content unless it was produced by force, fraud, misrepresentation or coercion, for good-faith disclosures to law enforcement or in a legal proceeding, for a matter of public concern, or for a disclosure reasonably intended to assist the person shown.

The difficulty for a deepfake victim is definitional. The current text of § 6851, as published on the House’s U.S. Code website with laws in effect through Public Law 119-142 of November 10, 2026, does not mention digital forgeries, synthetic images or artificial intelligence. Its definition speaks of a visual depiction that depicts the body of an identifiable individual. Whether a court would treat a computer-generated nude of a real, identifiable person as that person’s “intimate visual depiction” is not answered by the statute’s text or by any of the decisions discussed in this article, all of which involved authentic photographs or videos. A victim of a fabricated image should therefore not assume that § 6851 alone will carry the case, and should look at the criminal and state-law routes below at the same time.

Congress has addressed forgeries directly on the criminal side. The TAKE IT DOWN Act, Public Law 119-12, approved May 19, 2025, added a new subsection (h) to 47 U.S.C. § 223. That federal subsection defines a “digital forgery” as any intimate visual depiction of an identifiable individual created through software, machine learning, artificial intelligence or other technological means, including by altering an authentic image, that a reasonable person viewing it as a whole would find indistinguishable from an authentic depiction. It makes it unlawful to use an interactive computer service to knowingly publish a digital forgery of an identifiable adult when it was published without consent, what it depicts was not voluntarily exposed by the person in a public or commercial setting, it is not a matter of public concern, and the publication is intended to cause harm or causes harm, including psychological, financial or reputational harm. The penalty for an offense involving an adult is a fine, imprisonment of not more than two years, or both. For a minor, the offense turns on intent to abuse, humiliate, harass or degrade the minor or to arouse or gratify sexual desire, and the maximum prison term is three years.

The same subsection separately punishes intentional threats to publish a digital forgery made for intimidation, coercion, extortion or to create mental distress, with up to 18 months for threats involving adults and up to 30 months for threats involving minors. On conviction, the court must order forfeiture of the material and of property derived from or used in the offense, and it must order restitution in the same manner as under 18 U.S.C. § 2264. These are criminal provisions: a prosecutor, not the victim, decides whether to bring charges. They matter to a civil case, however, because a report to law enforcement creates an official record of what was published, where and when. Section 6851 also expressly excludes good-faith disclosures to law enforcement from its own civil liability, so handing the images to investigators is protected.

The second half of the TAKE IT DOWN Act is the one most people can use within days. Under 47 U.S.C. § 223a, a covered platform had to establish, not later than one year after May 19, 2025, a process for an identifiable individual, or an authorized person acting for that individual, to notify the platform of an intimate visual depiction published without consent and to request its removal. A valid request must be in writing and include a physical or electronic signature, information reasonably sufficient to locate the image, a brief good-faith statement that it is not consensual, and contact information. After a valid request, § 223a(a)(3) requires the platform to act “as soon as possible, but not later than 48 hours after receiving such request,” by removing the depiction and making reasonable efforts to identify and remove known identical copies. The removal duty is written in terms of an “intimate visual depiction,” and the statute’s definition of a digital forgery describes a forgery as an intimate visual depiction created by technological means. A failure to reasonably comply is treated as an unfair or deceptive act or practice enforced by the Federal Trade Commission.

B. What the DEFIANCE Act would add, where it stands, and what states already allow

The DEFIANCE Act is a bill, not law. The Senate version, S. 1837 as passed by the Senate on January 13, 2026, would amend § 6851 rather than create a separate statute. It would add a definition of an “intimate digital forgery”: an intimate visual depiction of an identifiable individual that falsely represents the individual or the intimate conduct or content, is created through software, machine learning, artificial intelligence or other technological means, and is indistinguishable from an authentic depiction when viewed as a whole by a reasonable person. The bill states that such a depiction remains a forgery regardless of any label, disclosure or context indicating that it is not authentic, which would close off the argument that a watermark saying “fake” defeats the claim.

The bill would also create two new federal causes of action. The first would run against any person who knowingly produced or possessed an intimate digital forgery with intent to disclose it, knowingly disclosed it, or knowingly solicited and received it, where the identifiable individual did not consent and the person knew or recklessly disregarded that lack of consent. The second would reach a person who knowingly produced the forgery without consent, if the person knew or recklessly disregarded both the lack of consent and that the individual was harmed or reasonably likely to be harmed by the production. Remedies would include liquidated damages of $150,000, rising to $250,000 when the conduct is connected to actual or attempted sexual assault, stalking or harassment, or actual damages that include the defendant’s attributable profits, along with punitive damages, costs and attorney’s fees, and injunctions ordering the defendant to delete, destroy or stop displaying the material. The bill would add a ten-year limitations period, in the text of S. 1837, running from the later of the date the individual reasonably discovers the violation or reaches 18 years of age, and it states that it does not preempt state laws at least as protective of victims.

Where things stand matters for anyone planning a lawsuit now. The congress.gov record for S. 1837 lists six actions, the last of which shows the bill received in the House and held at the desk on January 13, 2026. The House companion, H.R. 3562, sponsored by Rep. Ocasio-Cortez, was introduced and referred to the House Committee on the Judiciary on May 21, 2025, with no later action listed. The current Code text of § 6851 does not contain any of the Senate bill’s amendments. Rep. Lee’s release describes the advocacy for a House vote, including the participation of Ms. Paris Hilton, and states that the bill builds on the TAKE IT DOWN Act signed into law in May 2025. None of the bill’s new remedies, damages tiers or ten-year limitations period can be invoked unless and until Congress passes it and it becomes law.

State law already fills part of the gap for people in some states. California is an example with an express deepfake remedy. Under California Civil Code § 1708.86, as amended by Assembly Bill 621 effective January 1, 2026, a depicted individual has a cause of action against a person who creates and intentionally discloses “digitized sexually explicit material” portraying that individual when the person knows or reasonably should know that the individual did not consent, against a person who intentionally discloses such material created by someone else, and against a person who knowingly facilitates or recklessly aids or abets that conduct. The statute defines digitization to include realistically depicting computer-generated nude body parts as the individual’s, and it presumes that a person operating a “deepfake pornography service” knew the individual did not consent unless that person produces the individual’s express written consent.

California’s statute also sets terms a plaintiff must plan around. A disclaimer saying the person did not participate is not a defense. A prevailing plaintiff may recover the defendant’s monetary gain, economic and noneconomic damages, or instead statutory damages of $1,500 to $50,000 per work, up to $250,000 if the act was committed with malice, plus punitive damages, attorney’s fees and injunctive relief, and public prosecutors may sue for civil penalties. The material is not considered newsworthy solely because the depicted individual is a public figure. Under § 1708.86(g), the California action must be commenced no later than three years from the date the unauthorized creation, development or disclosure was discovered or should have been discovered with reasonable diligence. The section also states that it does not apply to conduct protected by federal law, including Section 230. Other states have their own statutes, so a victim outside California should identify the law of the state where they live and where the person who posted the material can be sued.

II. How do these claims work in court, and whom can you actually sue?

A. What federal judges have ordered when intimate images were shared without consent

The decisions that apply § 6851 show how fast a court can act once the right evidence is in front of it. In Doe v. Serpa, No. 3:25-CV-0057-X (N.D. Tex. Jan. 29, 2025), the United States District Court, Northern District of Texas, converted an ex parte temporary restraining order into a preliminary injunction against a former partner who had sent a sexually explicit photo of the plaintiff to a co-founder of the company that planned to hire him, through a private LinkedIn message. The court walked through each element of § 6851, held that sending the photo by private message was a disclosure in interstate commerce, and inferred knowledge or recklessness about consent from the defendant’s own messages. It restrained the defendant from disclosing the images, destroying evidence of prior disclosures or revealing the plaintiff’s identity. The lesson for a reader is direct: the case was built on screenshots, the recipient’s sworn declaration and the sender’s own words, so preserving the messages around a disclosure can supply the proof of intent that a court needs.

Speed and privacy were the issues in Doe v. Czerepusko, No. 1:26-cv-00792-CNS-NRN (D. Colo. Mar. 20, 2026). There, the United States District Court for the District of Colorado allowed the plaintiff to proceed under a pseudonym, relying on § 6851 and a Colorado statute, and granted an ex parte temporary restraining order before the defendant had been served. The plaintiff alleged that intimate photographs and at least one video from a past relationship had been posted on at least 28 websites with her name and social media accounts. The court found her likely to succeed under Colorado law, which it quoted as giving an identifiable person harmed by the intentional disclosure or threatened disclosure of a private intimate image a cause of action, and observed that “Information, once on the internet, is incredibly difficult to contain or erase.” It excused advance notice because counsel’s affidavit explained the risk that the defendant would destroy evidence or retaliate. For a reader, the practical point is that a sworn affidavit with specific facts and a lawyer’s written explanation of why notice should not be given are what supported an order entered before the defendant was even served.

These cases can also go to verdict. In Doe v. Gipson, No. 25-50615 (5th Cir. July 15, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reviewed a case in which, after a three-day jury trial, the defendant had been found liable for unlawfully disclosing intimate images in violation of § 6851 and Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 98B. The only issue on appeal was whether a prospective juror’s brief remark about an old newspaper article required a mistrial; the court held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion and affirmed. The opinion is not designated for publication under the Fifth Circuit’s rules, so it has limited precedential weight, but it shows that a § 6851 claim can be tried to a jury and that the resulting judgment can withstand an appeal on procedural grounds.

Three cautions follow from these orders. First, each involved authentic images; none of them decided whether a fabricated image qualifies under § 6851, so a deepfake victim should expect that issue to be contested if the case relies on the federal statute alone. Second, preliminary relief depends on a showing of likely success and irreparable harm; courts in Texas and Colorado found that the risk of further dissemination of intimate images met that standard, but each order rested on specific evidence in the record. Third, the text of § 6851 does not itself set a filing deadline, and none of the decisions reviewed here addressed one. That silence is not a promise of unlimited time, and state claims such as California’s carry their own express deadline, so evidence should be gathered and a filing decision made promptly.

B. Why the person who made or posted the image is usually the defendant, and what to do this week

A common instinct is to sue the large company whose servers carried the image. The most recent decision on that question points the other way. In Doe v. Cloudflare, Inc., No. 25-cv-10300-AGT (N.D. Cal. June 23, 2026), the United States District Court, Northern District of California, granted an internet services provider’s motion to dismiss a proposed class action under § 6851. The plaintiff alleged that a former fiancé created fake social-media profiles impersonating her and used them to share her intimate images, and that the provider’s content-delivery services made the posts accessible. The court held that 47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(1) barred the claim because the claim treated the provider as the publisher of content created by a third party, concluded that, on the facts alleged, the provider merely provided access to content created by a third party, did not encourage its development and had no ability to remove it directly from the social network, and rejected the argument that § 6851 falls within Section 230’s intellectual property exception because the statute creates a privacy-based claim. The order allowed the plaintiff to seek leave to amend by July 9, 2026; this article does not report any later ruling. For a reader, the application is that a federal damages claim is most likely to proceed against the individual who created or posted the material, while platforms are best approached through the statutory takedown process.

The same structure appears in the takedown law. Section 223a protects a covered platform from liability for good-faith removal of material claimed to be a nonconsensual intimate visual depiction, and assigns enforcement of the 48-hour duty to the Federal Trade Commission. The covered-platform definition reaches public websites and apps that primarily host user-generated content, or whose regular business includes making nonconsensual intimate images available, and it excludes broadband providers and email. California’s statute takes a different path for businesses that keep a deepfake site running: a service provider that enables the ongoing operation of a deepfake pornography service is presumed to violate the facilitation provision if, after receiving evidence through its designated channel, it fails to take all necessary steps to stop within 30 days. That presumption is a California rule and depends on the conditions written into the statute.

A practical sequence for the first days looks like this. Record each web address, account name and date, and take screenshots that show the content and the surrounding page, without forwarding the image itself to friends. Keep every message from the person you suspect, especially anything that shows knowledge that you did not consent, since that was the evidence the Texas court relied on. Send a written removal request to each covered platform hosting the material with the four elements § 223a requires, and note the time it was sent so the 48-hour clock can be checked. Report the posting, and any threat to post, to law enforcement; the federal crime covers both publication and intentional threats, and good-faith disclosure to police is excluded from civil liability under § 6851.

Then match the facts to the law. If the image is an authentic photo or video, § 6851 gives a federal claim with liquidated damages of $150,000, attorney’s fees and injunctions, and state statutes such as Texas Chapter 98B or Colorado’s law may be pleaded alongside it, as they were in the cases above. If the image is a fabrication, a state statute written for synthetic content, like California’s § 1708.86 with its three-year deadline from discovery, is the clearest civil route today, while the federal criminal provision covers knowing publication and the takedown process covers removal. Consider asking the court for a pseudonym at the outset, as the Colorado court allowed. Finally, follow S. 1837 in the House: if it is enacted in its Senate-passed form, it would add an express federal claim for intimate digital forgeries, a $250,000 liquidated-damages tier for conduct tied to sexual assault, stalking or harassment, and a ten-year limitations period. Until then, those terms remain proposals.

Conclusion

A sexually explicit deepfake is not legally unanswerable today, but the tools are split. Federal criminal law already makes knowingly publishing an intimate digital forgery of an identifiable person a crime when the statutory conditions are met, and it punishes intentional threats to publish one. Covered platforms must remove reported nonconsensual intimate images within 48 hours of a valid request, under Federal Trade Commission enforcement. The existing federal civil action for intimate images offers liquidated damages, fees and fast injunctions, and judges have used it against people who shared real images. Its text does not address forgeries, however, and courts have not resolved that question in the decisions reviewed here.

The Senate-passed DEFIANCE Act would give victims an express federal damages claim for intimate digital forgeries, but it has been waiting in the House since January 13, 2026, and its provisions are not law. Until it is enacted, the strongest civil options for a fabricated image come from state statutes such as California’s, which carry their own deadlines and conditions. Whatever the route, the claim is usually brought against the person who created or posted the material, not the network that carried it, and the outcome depends on evidence preserved early: addresses, dates, screenshots, messages and records of each removal request and police report.

📄 Official circular