On Sunday morning, Paris woke up to burnt-out cars, charred bikes, shattered shopfronts and piles of glass on the pavements, as reported by the BBC’s Paris correspondent in its coverage of the riots following Saturday’s demonstrations (https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c574pdzl0k4no — see the BBC report on the Paris clear-up). According to that coverage, police arrested about 1,800 people on Saturday as some 550,000 demonstrators marched across France, mostly peacefully, against rising fuel prices, the cost of living and deteriorating public services, while groups of rioters in Paris, Marseille and other cities set fire to cars and buildings. If you are an American or British visitor and the torched or smashed car is the one you rented for your trip, two questions arise at once: what does French criminal law do to the rioters, and who pays the rental company — you, the insurer, or the perpetrators? This article answers both, in that order. First, the criminal side: the offences, the penalties, your criminal complaint (plainte, the formal complaint filed with the police or prosecutor) and your civil claim for damages (action civile, the civil claim for compensation attached to the criminal case). Second, the contract side: the rental agreement, the franchise (the deductible or excess left to the renter), and the insurance maze, including the one mandatory extension that most foreign drivers misunderstand.
I. Torched and smashed cars: what French criminal law says
A. What the rioters face: destruction, arson and up to ten years’ imprisonment
French criminal law punishes damage to other people’s property on a graduated scale, and a burning car sits near the top of it. The basic offence is set out in Article 322-1 of the Criminal Code: « La destruction, la dégradation ou la détérioration d’un bien appartenant à autrui est punie de deux ans d’emprisonnement et de 30 000 euros d’amende, sauf s’il n’en est résulté qu’un dommage léger. » (The destruction, degradation or deterioration of property belonging to another person is punished by two years of imprisonment and a 30,000 euro fine, unless only minor damage resulted.) A smashed window, a dented door or a slashed tyre falls under this provision. The rental car does not belong to you, and it does not belong to the rioter either, so the offence is complete as soon as the damage is voluntary.
Fire changes everything. Article 322-6 of the Criminal Code provides: « La destruction, la dégradation ou la détérioration d’un bien appartenant à autrui par l’effet d’une substance explosive, d’un incendie ou de tout autre moyen de nature à créer un danger pour les personnes est punie de dix ans d’emprisonnement et de 150 000 euros d’amende. » (The destruction, degradation or deterioration of property belonging to another person by the effect of an explosive substance, a fire or any other means likely to create a danger for persons is punished by ten years of imprisonment and a 150,000 euro fine.) A car set on fire in a Paris street, next to buildings, parked vehicles and passers-by, is the textbook case: the means creates a danger for persons, and the ten-year penalty applies. The same facts can also support related charges — participation in a group formed with a view to committing violence or damage, for example — but the two destruction offences above are the core of the case, and they are the ones your complaint will cite.
Alongside the prison sentence, the perpetrators owe you money. Article 1240 of the Civil Code states: « Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer. » (Any act of man which causes damage to another obliges the person by whose fault it occurred to repair it.) This general principle of civil liability (responsabilité civile, the obligation to compensate harm caused by one’s fault) is what allows you, the renter who paid the franchise and lost the use of the car, to claim every euro of personal loss from the convicted rioters: the deductible charged by the rental company, the cost of replacement transport, and any additional expense the incident forced on you.
One boundary must be drawn immediately, because it determines which insurance rules apply later in this article. Riot damage is not automatically terrorism. Article 421-1 of the Criminal Code defines terrorist acts as the listed offences « lorsqu’elles sont intentionnellement en relation avec une entreprise individuelle ou collective ayant pour but de troubler gravement l’ordre public par l’intimidation ou la terreur » (when they are intentionally connected with an individual or collective enterprise aimed at seriously disturbing public order through intimidation or terror), a list which includes theft, extortion and destruction offences. Whether the burning of cars during a night of rioting meets that definition is a decision for the prosecutor and the judge, based on the investigation — it is not a label you can stick on the facts yourself, and you should never present a riot as a terrorist attack in your correspondence with insurers. The distinction matters because the only mandatory extension of property insurance to riot-like events covers terrorism, as explained in Part II.
B. Your complaint and your civil claim: plainte and action civile
As a foreign victim, your first step is the criminal complaint, known in French as the plainte. Article 15-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides: « Les officiers et agents de police judiciaire sont tenus de recevoir les plaintes déposées par les victimes d’infractions à la loi pénale, y compris lorsque ces plaintes sont déposées dans un service ou une unité de police judiciaire territorialement incompétents. » (Judicial police officers and agents are required to receive complaints filed by victims of criminal offences, including when those complaints are filed with a judicial police service or unit with no territorial jurisdiction.) In practice, this means you can walk into any police station (commissariat) or gendarmerie in France — in Paris, in the airport town where you return the car, or back home through the French consulate’s guidance — and the officers must take your complaint, forwarding it to the competent unit if necessary. You do not need to know who torched the car: complaints against an unknown person (plainte contre X) are routine, and mass arrests during riots mean perpetrators are regularly identified after the fact from video surveillance and police footage.
File quickly and prepare the file before you go. Bring your passport, the rental agreement, the vehicle return report (état des lieux de restitution, the check-in and check-out condition report), every photograph you took of the burnt or damaged car with time stamps, the police report number if officers attended the scene, and all receipts: the franchise debited from your card, taxi and replacement-car invoices, and any extra hotel night the incident forced you to book. The same Article 15-3 adds that every complaint is recorded in official minutes and immediately gives rise to a receipt for the victim. Ask for that receipt (récépissé de dépôt de plainte) and keep a copy of everything in English and French. If your French is limited, you may be assisted by an interpreter, and nothing prevents you from drafting a written statement in English to attach to the French minutes. The complaint itself costs nothing and starts the criminal investigation; it also establishes your position as a victim for everything that follows.
The second step is the civil claim. Article 2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states: « L’action civile en réparation du dommage causé par un crime, un délit ou une contravention appartient à tous ceux qui ont personnellement souffert du dommage directement causé par l’infraction. » (The civil action for compensation of the damage caused by a felony, a misdemeanour or a petty offence belongs to all those who have personally suffered the damage directly caused by the offence.) You suffered direct personal damage — the franchise, the substitute transport, the ruined travel day — so you can join the criminal proceedings as a civil party (partie civile, the victim participating in the criminal trial to obtain damages). When rioters are tried, often quickly under fast-track procedures after mass arrests, the civil-party claim lets the criminal court order them to pay your documented losses in the same judgment that convicts them. Even if the authors are never found, the complaint remains the indispensable foundation of your insurance claims: every insurer, French or foreign, will ask for it before paying a euro.
A final practical point for travellers: do not sign anything at the rental counter under pressure that characterises your liability before you have the facts. Statements in which the renter admits full responsibility, written into a return report in the chaos of a riot night, are difficult to undo. Sign only the factual description — burnt, smashed, location, time — and write down any disagreement on the document itself. The legal battle over who pays is fought later, on the basis of the contract and the insurance rules examined below, not on the pavement at midnight.
II. The rental company sends you the bill: contract and insurance
A. The contract comes first: franchise, proof and good faith
When the rental company debits your card, it relies on the rental agreement, and French law starts there too. Article 1103 of the Civil Code states: « Les contrats légalement formés tiennent lieu de loi à ceux qui les ont faits. » (Contracts legally formed take the place of law for those who made them.) And Article 1104 of the Civil Code adds: « Les contrats doivent être négociés, formés et exécutés de bonne foi. » (Contracts must be negotiated, formed and performed in good faith.) The Paris Court of Appeal applied exactly these principles to a rental-car dispute on 14 March 2024 (RG 21/03769): the signed conditions — including the franchise clause fixing the deductible left to the renter in case of theft, fire or damage — bind both sides, and both sides must perform them honestly.
That same Paris decision contains three holdings that protect foreign renters directly. First, the insurer’s franchise is not yours. The court refused to enforce against the renter the deductible from the insurance policy taken out by the rental company, on the ground that the renter was not a party to that policy — the direct application of Article 1199 of the Civil Code: « Le contrat ne crée d’obligations qu’entre les parties. » (A contract creates obligations only between the parties.) In plain terms: the rental company cannot bill you the much larger excess from its own fleet policy; only the franchise written in your rental agreement can be charged to you, and only if its conditions are met. Second, proof is on the company. The court confirmed that the rental firm had to prove its contractual claim — the damage, its attribution to the renter, and the amount — and rejected demands built on expert reports drawn up without giving the renter a chance to attend or respond (expertise non contradictoire), as well as immobilisation and loss-of-use fees whose connection to the renter was never demonstrated. Third, damages for breach require a proven breach: citing Article 1231-1 of the Civil Code — « Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts soit à raison de l’inexécution de l’obligation, soit à raison du retard dans l’exécution, s’il ne justifie pas que l’exécution a été empêchée par la force majeure. » (The debtor is ordered, where appropriate, to pay damages either for non-performance of the obligation or for delay in performance, unless they show that performance was prevented by force majeure) — the court threw out a damages claim where no contractual breach had been shown at all.
Apply this to your burnt rental car. Read the franchise clause before paying: what event triggers it, what amount, and what conditions (locked car, alarm, keys and documents returned, theft or fire report within a stated time). The clause is enforceable, but only as written — a fire during a riot is not a theft, and a theft franchise cannot be stretched to cover fire damage. Demand the contradictory inspection: you have the right to be present or represented when the damage is assessed, to receive the itemised repair invoice rather than a round figure, and to challenge any report drawn up behind your back. Contest penalty clauses (clauses pénales) and loss-of-revenue charges that the contract does not provide for, or that the company cannot link to your use of the car. And remember the force-majeure thread running through Article 1231-1: Article 1218 of the Civil Code defines force majeure in contract matters as « un événement échappant au contrôle du débiteur, qui ne pouvait être raisonnablement prévu lors de la conclusion du contrat et dont les effets ne peuvent être évités par des mesures appropriées, empêche l’exécution de son obligation par le débiteur » (an event beyond the control of the debtor, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded and whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures, and which prevents the debtor from performing the obligation). A car torched by rioters while lawfully parked is the archetype of an event beyond the renter’s control. Force majeure does not automatically erase a franchise clause that you validly accepted, but it destroys any claim that you were at fault — and fault is what penalty surcharges, negligence supplements and bad-faith arguments are built on.
B. Insurance: compulsory liability, fire cover and the terrorism boundary
French motor insurance has two floors, and confusing them is the most expensive mistake a foreign driver can make. The ground floor is compulsory third-party liability. Article L211-1 of the Insurance Code provides: « Toute personne physique ou toute personne morale autre que l’Etat, dont la responsabilité civile peut être engagée en raison de dommages subis par des tiers résultant d’atteintes aux personnes ou aux biens dans la réalisation desquels un véhicule est impliqué, doit, pour faire circuler celui-ci, être couverte par une assurance garantissant cette responsabilité, dans les conditions fixées par décret en Conseil d’Etat. » (Any natural or legal person other than the State, whose civil liability may be engaged for damage suffered by third parties resulting from personal injury or property damage in which a vehicle is involved, must, in order to drive it, be covered by insurance guaranteeing such liability, under the conditions set by decree in the Council of State.) This is confirmed at European level by Article 3 of Directive 2009/103/EC on motor insurance: every Member State must ensure that civil liability for the use of vehicles normally based in its territory is covered by insurance, for both property damage and personal injury What this means for you is precise and limited: if the rental car, while in your custody, injures someone or damages someone else’s property, the rental company’s liability policy answers. It does not mean the burnt rental car itself is automatically covered — damage to the vehicle is own-damage cover (garantie dommages), a contractual layer above the compulsory floor.
That contractual layer is where your case is won or lost, and it is read line by line. Open the rental conditions and the insurance schedule and look for three things. First, the fire and damage cover itself: comprehensive (tous risques) policies normally include fire, including criminal fire, while basic packages may cover only liability plus theft, leaving fire damage to the franchise clause discussed above. Second, the exclusions: war — foreign and civil — is routinely excluded, and some policies add exclusions for riots and popular movements (émeutes et mouvements populaires) while others do not. No general rule can be stated here; two rental companies on the same Paris street can have opposite wordings, so the only valid answer is the text of your contract. If the policy is silent on riots, the insurer cannot invent the exclusion afterwards — exclusions are interpreted strictly against the insurer under French law. Third, the notification deadline: Article L113-2 of the Insurance Code obliges the insured « De donner avis à l’assureur, dès qu’il en a eu connaissance et au plus tard dans le délai fixé par le contrat, de tout sinistre de nature à entraîner la garantie de l’assureur. Ce délai ne peut être inférieur à cinq jours ouvrés. » (To notify the insurer, as soon as they become aware of it and at the latest within the time limit set by the contract, of any loss likely to trigger the cover of the insurer. This time limit may not be less than five working days.) In practice the rental company, as the policyholder, notifies its own insurer — but your own duty is to notify the rental company immediately, in writing, with the complaint number, so that no one can blame you for a late declaration. Five working days (jours ouvrés) is the legal minimum the contract must give; your contract may give more, never less.
Finally, the one mandatory extension that everyone invokes and almost no one reads correctly. Article L126-2 of the Insurance Code provides: « Les contrats d’assurance garantissant les dommages d’incendie à des biens situés sur le territoire national ainsi que les dommages aux corps de véhicules terrestres à moteur ouvrent droit à la garantie de l’assuré pour les dommages matériels directs causés aux biens assurés par un attentat ou un acte de terrorisme tel que défini par les articles 421-1 et 421-2 du code pénal subis sur le territoire national. » (Insurance contracts covering fire damage to property located on national territory, as well as damage to the bodies of motor vehicles, give the insured a right to cover for direct material damage caused to the insured property by an attack or an act of terrorism as defined by Articles 421-1 and 421-2 of the Criminal Code suffered on national territory.) This is powerful: if the vehicle has fire or own-damage cover, that cover automatically extends to terrorist attacks, within the franchise and ceiling of the fire cover. But the trigger is strictly an attentat ou acte de terrorisme as legally qualified — not a riot, not looting, not a violent demonstration, however spectacular the television pictures. Unless the prosecutor qualifies the facts as terrorism under Article 421-1, Article L126-2 does not apply, and your claim stands or falls on the contract’s fire cover and its exclusions. Do not let anyone — rental agent, hotline operator, or fellow traveller — tell you that riot damage is automatically covered by French law: no text read for this article says that, and the texts that exist say something more precise.
Two last safety nets complete the picture. Your travel insurance (assurance voyage), if you bought one, may cover the franchise itself — many premium bank-card and standalone travel policies include a rental vehicle excess guarantee, capped per claim, on presentation of the rental agreement, the franchise invoice and the police complaint. Read it before you fly home, because its own notification deadlines are short. And if the damage to the car caused you bodily injury — a burn, a wound from shattered glass — French law treats you as a victim of a criminal offence with dedicated compensation routes; keep every medical certificate (certificat médical) from day one, because bodily injury opens doors that pure property damage does not.
Conclusion
A torched rental car on a riot night in Paris is not a single problem but three files to open in the right order. First, the criminal file: file your plainte at any police station under Article 15-3, even against an unknown author, gather the rental agreement, the return report, timestamped photographs and every receipt, and join the proceedings as partie civile under Article 2 so the criminal court orders the convicted rioters — who face two years under Article 322-1 for damage and ten years under Article 322-6 for arson — to pay your personal losses under Article 1240. Second, the contract file: pay only the franchise written in your own rental agreement, never the rental company’s fleet-policy excess, as the Paris Court of Appeal held on 14 March 2024; demand a contradictory damage assessment and itemised invoices; and answer any negligence surcharge with Article 1218 — a riot fire in a lawfully parked car is beyond your control. Third, the insurance file: remember that compulsory liability under Article L211-1 and Directive 2009/103 covers damage you cause to others, not damage to the rental car; that damage depends on the fire cover and its exclusions, which must be read, not assumed; that the terrorism extension of Article L126-2 applies only to acts qualified under Article 421-1; and that every notification runs fast, with a legal minimum of five working days under Article L113-2. Open the three files the morning after, in this order, and the burnt car becomes an organised claim instead of a ruined trip.