KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Ryanair Compensation Claim Under EU261 for a France Flight: Suing in the French Courts and Challenging a Biased Judge

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Ryanair Compensation Claim Under EU261 for a France Flight: Suing in the French Courts and Challenging a Biased Judge

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 8 October 2026, at Balbriggan District Court in Ireland, Ryanair asked District Judge Stephanie Coggans to withdraw from every case involving the airline. According to The Irish Times, the company relied on remarks the judge had made in earlier cases, including that it “kills” her to fly with Ryanair, and argued that an objective observer could think the airline would not get a fair hearing before her. The judge said she needed time to consider the evidence and the case law, and will give her decision on 2 December. No finding of bias has been made, and only the court seized of the application can decide it.

Why should this Dublin story matter to a passenger who flies Ryanair between Ireland and France? Because the same two questions arise every week before the French courts: how do you force an airline to pay the European compensation for a delayed or cancelled flight touching France, and what do you do when the judge deciding your small claim looks hostile to one side? French law answers both questions with unusual precision. European Regulation 261/2004 gives you a fixed sum of 250, 400 or 600 euros, the Court of Justice tells you exactly which court can hear you, and the French Code of Judicial Organisation lists the cases in which a judge must stand down, including notorious enmity with a party. This article explains the procedure step by step, starting from the Irish episode as reported by the press and continuing with the French and European rules that apply to your own claim.

I. Claiming EU261 compensation from Ryanair for a flight touching France

A. Which delays and cancellations give you 250, 400 or 600 euros

Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of 11 February 2004 is the single most useful text for an air passenger in Europe. It applies to every flight departing from an airport in the European Union, whatever the airline, and to flights arriving in the Union when they are operated by a Union carrier. A Ryanair flight from Dublin to Paris-Beauvais is covered; a Ryanair flight from Paris-Beauvais to Dublin is covered as well. The key actor under the Regulation is the transporteur aérien effectif (operating air carrier), meaning the airline that actually performs the flight, not the one that merely sold the ticket.

For cancellations, Article 5 of the Regulation states the rule plainly: « ont droit à une indemnisation du transporteur aérien effectif » and « à moins qu’ils soient informés de l’annulation du vol », including « au moins deux semaines avant l’heure de départ prévue », with further conditions in the text (affected passengers have a right to compensation from the operating air carrier, unless they are informed of the cancellation, in particular at least two weeks before the scheduled time of departure, on the conditions that follow). In practice, a cancellation notified the day before departure, with no suitable rerouting, opens the right to the fixed sum. Article 7 then fixes the amounts without any need to prove loss: « les passagers reçoivent une indemnisation dont le montant est fixé » : « 250 euros pour tous les vols de 1500 kilomètres ou moins » ; « 400 euros pour tous les vols intracommunautaires de plus de 1500 kilomètres et pour tous les autres vols de 1500 à 3500 kilomètres » ; « 600 euros pour tous les vols qui ne relèvent pas des points a) ou b). » (passengers receive fixed compensation: 250 euros for flights of 1,500 kilometres or less, 400 euros for intra-Community flights over 1,500 kilometres and other flights between 1,500 and 3,500 kilometres, 600 euros for all other flights). Dublin-Paris is about 780 kilometres as the crow flies, so the standard amount on that route is 250 euros per passenger. Full text: Regulation (EC) No 261/2004.

For delays, the Court of Justice extended the same right in its Sturgeon judgment of 19 November 2009 (Joined Cases C-402/07 and C-432/07): passengers on delayed flights may be treated like passengers on cancelled flights for compensation purposes, so that a loss of time of three hours or more on arrival opens the same Article 7 right (passagers de vols retardés assimilés aux passagers de vols annulés dès trois heures de retard à l’arrivée). What counts is the time the aircraft doors open at arrival, not the take-off delay. A two-hour late departure that still lands two hours and fifty-nine minutes late gives nothing; three hours and one minute gives 250 euros on Dublin-Paris. Judgment of the Court of Justice of 19 November 2009, Joined Cases C-402/07 and C-432/07, Sturgeon.

The airline’s standard defence is “extraordinary circumstances”. The Court of Justice closed most of that door in Wallentin-Hermann (Case C-549/07, 22 December 2008): a technical problem with an aircraft that leads to cancellation is not an extraordinary circumstance unless it stems from events which, by their nature or origin, are not inherent in the normal operation of the carrier and are beyond its actual control (panne technique non inhérente à l’exercice normal de l’activité et échappant à la maîtrise effective du transporteur). A routine engine fault found during maintenance is inherent in running an airline; a hidden manufacturing defect revealed by the manufacturer, or sabotage, can qualify. Keep every document from the day: booking confirmation, boarding pass, photographs of the departure board, the airline’s reason in writing, receipts for meals and hotels. Judgment of the Court of Justice of 22 December 2008, Case C-549/07, Wallentin-Hermann.

One trap deserves emphasis because a Paris court has already punished a passenger who fell into it. On 8 November 2024, the local civil division (pôle civil de proximité, the small-claims division of the court) of the Paris tribunal judiciaire (ordinary civil court) dismissed a 600-euro claim brought against British Airways on the basis of Regulation 261/2004, holding that the claim was misdirected: the airline had only marketed seats on the flight through code-sharing and had no control over its operation (Paris, RG 24/03156, decision: Paris, 8 November 2024). Sue the carrier that operated the aircraft, identified by the flight prefix and the “operated by” notice, not the one whose logo sits on your e-ticket. Against Ryanair the question rarely arises, since Ryanair operates its own flights, but the lesson stands for any connecting itinerary mixing Ryanair with another company. And remember the costs rule of Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure: « Le juge condamne la partie tenue aux dépens ou qui perd son procès à payer : 1° A l’autre partie la somme qu’il détermine, au titre des frais exposés et non compris dans les dépens » (the losing party is ordered to pay the other side a sum set by the judge for expenses not included in the costs), which is why the Paris claimant, duly dismissed, was also ordered to pay 250 euros to the airline (Article 700).

B. Bringing the claim before the French courts from Ireland

The good news for an Ireland-based passenger is that you can choose France. In Rehder (Case C-204/08, 9 July 2009), the Court of Justice held that the court with jurisdiction over a compensation claim founded on the carriage contract and on Regulation No 261/2004 is, at the claimant’s choice, the court of the place of departure or the place of arrival of the aircraft as agreed in the contract (compétence, au choix du demandeur, du lieu de départ ou d’arrivée convenu). For a Dublin to Paris-Beauvais flight, that means the Irish courts or the French courts, at your choice; for the return leg, the same option in reverse. The foundation in the Brussels I bis Regulation (No 1215/2012) is Article 7: « en matière contractuelle, devant la juridiction du lieu d’exécution de l’obligation qui sert de base à la demande » (in contract matters, the courts of the place of performance of the obligation on which the claim is based). Since the airline performs its obligation both where it takes off and where it lands, both places count. Sources: judgment of the Court of Justice of 9 July 2009, Case C-204/08, Rehder; Brussels I bis Regulation.

Inside France, the default domestic rule is Article 42 of the Code of Civil Procedure: « La juridiction territorialement compétente est, sauf disposition contraire, celle du lieu où demeure le défendeur. » (the court with territorial jurisdiction is, unless otherwise provided, the court where the defendant is domiciled). Ryanair’s French establishment and the place of arrival both anchor jurisdiction in practice, and small EU261 claims are heard by the pôle civil de proximité of the tribunal judiciaire, the division that decided the Paris case cited above (Article 42). The procedure is written, fast and cheap: a formal demand letter (mise en demeure, a registered letter ordering the airline to pay within a stated time) giving the flight number, date, booking reference, length of delay and sum claimed, then, if the airline refuses or stays silent, a claim form (requête) filed at the registry with the exhibits attached. Airlines often pay at the demand-letter stage once they see dated proof and the correct legal basis cited.

Three practical points decide most cases. First, identify the operating carrier and keep the contract: the booking confirmation showing Dublin-Paris, the boarding pass, and any message from the airline announcing the disruption. Second, measure the delay at arrival, doors open, against the scheduled arrival time, and claim without letting the file sleep. Third, refuse vouchers imposed as the only option: the Regulation requires payment in cash, by bank transfer or cheque, and a travel credit accepted under pressure does not extinguish the fixed compensation unless you genuinely agreed to it as a settlement. Denied boarding for alleged behaviour follows a neighbouring but distinct regime, which this site has already covered for passengers removed from the aircraft or refused at the gate (see our guide on passengers disembarked or refused boarding and how to challenge the decision).

II. When the judge deciding your airline claim looks biased: recusal in France

A. Every litigant’s right to an impartial tribunal

The Irish episode is, at bottom, an impartiality case. Ryanair’s counsel argued that remarks from the bench revealed “hostility” and “dislike” such that an objective observer would doubt the fairness of any hearing before that judge. French law starts from exactly the same intuition and gives it treaty-level force through the European Convention on Human Rights. Article 6, paragraph 1 of the Convention provides that in the determination of civil rights, everyone is entitled to a fair hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal (European Convention on Human Rights). The French Court of Cassation (Court of Cassation, the supreme court for civil and criminal matters) repeats the formula in its own words: « toute personne a droit à ce que sa cause soit entendue équitablement, publiquement et dans un délai raisonnable par un tribunal indépendant et impartial. » (every person has the right to a fair, public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal), as recalled by the Court of Cassation (Cass., 2nd Civil Chamber, 8 June 2023, No 19-25.101).

Impartiality is tested in two ways. The Court of Cassation explains, following the Strasbourg court: « l’impartialité se définit d’ordinaire par l’absence de préjugé ou de parti pris. » (impartiality usually means the absence of prejudice or bias), in the words used by the Court of Cassation (Cass., 2nd Civil Chamber, 8 June 2023, No 19-25.101). The subjective approach asks what the judge actually thought; personal impartiality is presumed until the contrary is proved, and it is notoriously hard to establish. The objective approach asks whether an outside observer, knowing the facts, could legitimately doubt the court’s neutrality: remarks from the bench, uneven treatment of the parties’ arguments, visible irritation with one side. It is the objective test that decides most cases, and it is the test Ryanair invoked in Dublin with its “objective observer” language. The parallel is direct: a judge who announces from the bench that dealing with an airline “kills” her raises precisely the kind of legitimate doubt the objective test is designed to catch, whatever her true feelings.

The sanction is real. On 8 June 2023, the Second Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation quashed an appeal judgment (No 19-25.101, published in the Bulletin) because the court of appeal had reasoned in terms capable of casting legitimate doubt on bias, incompatible with objective impartiality, in violation of Article 6, paragraph 1 of the Convention (Cass., 2nd Civil Chamber, 8 June 2023, No 19-25.101). The lesson for a passenger is symmetrical: the protection covers you as much as the airline. If the judge hearing your 250-euro claim mocks your screenshots, praises the carrier’s lawyer, or announces the outcome before you have spoken, the judgment that follows carries a defect that an appeal court, and ultimately the Court of Cassation, can punish with quashing. Note what the remedy is not: it is not a second chance to argue the delay or the extraordinary circumstances. It is the annulment of a judgment delivered by a court that did not offer the guarantees of impartiality, followed by a retrial before different judges.

B. How to have a French judge stand down: the récusation procedure

French procedure gives the mechanism a name: récusation (recusal, the formal application asking a judge to stand down from a case). Article 341 of the Code of Civil Procedure states: « Sauf disposition particulière, la récusation d’un juge est admise pour les causes prévues par l’article L. 111-6 du code de l’organisation judiciaire. » (recusal of a judge is allowed on the grounds laid down in Article L. 111-6 of the Code of Judicial Organisation, unless otherwise provided) (Article 341). That article lists nine closed grounds: personal interest of the judge or spouse in the dispute; creditor, debtor, presumed heir or donee relationship with a party; family relationship up to the fourth degree; pending or past proceedings between the judge and a party; prior knowledge of the case as judge, arbitrator or adviser; administration of a party’s property; subordination; and, eighth, « S’il y a amitié ou inimitié notoire entre le juge et l’une des parties » (where there is well-known friendship or enmity between the judge and one of the parties); ninth, a conflict of interests within the meaning of the magistrates’ statute (Article L. 111-6).

Public remarks about an airline map most naturally onto the eighth ground, notorious enmity. “Notorious” means publicly known and provable, not privately felt: press reports of statements made in open court, as in the Dublin affair, are the textbook example of notoriety, since the words were spoken on the record. Timing is strict. Article 342 provides: « La partie qui veut récuser un juge ou demander le renvoi pour cause de suspicion légitime devant une autre juridiction de même nature doit, à peine d’irrecevabilité, le faire dès qu’elle a connaissance de la cause justifiant la demande. En aucun cas la demande ne peut être formée après la clôture des débats. » (a party seeking recusal or transfer for legitimate suspicion must act as soon as it learns of the ground, on pain of inadmissibility, and never after the proceedings close) (Article 342). The application can be made by the party or by an agent holding special authority, and before courts where representation by counsel is compulsory it is filed by a lawyer (Article 343).

Where the application goes is fixed by Article 344: « La demande de récusation ou de renvoi pour cause de suspicion légitime est portée devant le premier président de la cour d’appel. Elle est formée par acte remis au greffe de la cour d’appel. » (the application goes to the First President of the court of appeal, by document filed at that court’s registry). Where the ground comes to light at the hearing itself, the application is made by statement recorded by the registrar; in every case it must state the grounds and include the supporting exhibits, on pain of inadmissibility, and a copy stays in the case file (Article 344). If granted, the case is reassigned and the judge takes no further part. If rejected, the trial continues before the same court. Tactical warning: recusal is a scalpel, not a delaying tactic. An application filed without exhibits, or filed late after the party knew the facts, is rejected as inadmissible, and leaves the litigant facing the same judge with credibility damaged.

Compare the two systems on the facts as reported. In Ireland, the airline asked the judge to step aside from all its cases on the basis of comments made across several hearings, and the judge reserved her decision to 2 December 2026. In France, each récusation targets a specific case and a specific listed ground, brought before the First President of the court of appeal with exhibits attached. But the underlying question is identical, and the Irish press episode illustrates it vividly: justice must not only be done but be seen to be done. For your own French claim, the practical checklist is short. Record exactly what was said, by whom, in which hearing, and who heard it. Distinguish a judge managing the hearing firmly, which is lawful case management, from language showing prejudgment, which is not. Raise the point at once through your representative rather than confronting the bench yourself. And keep the main file strong in parallel: a recusal application decides who judges, never who wins, and the best reply to a sceptical court remains what it always was, a boarding pass, a timestamped photograph of the arrivals board, and the European provisions that decide the case.

Conclusion

The Dublin recusal application, as reported by The Irish Times on 8 October 2026, remains undecided: the judge will rule on 2 December, no bias has been established, and this article makes no finding about it. Its value for a passenger is as a reminder that the mechanism for challenging a partial judge exists in every European courtroom, including the French one where your EU261 claim may land. For a Ryanair delay or cancellation on a flight to or from France, the path is mapped: 250, 400 or 600 euros under Articles 5 and 7 of Regulation 261/2004, three hours of arrival delay equated with cancellation since Sturgeon, technical faults excluded from extraordinary circumstances since Wallentin-Hermann, and your choice of the Irish or the French court since Rehder. Before the French judge, the pôle civil de proximité of the tribunal judiciaire hears these small claims every day, and the combination of objective impartiality under Article 6, paragraph 1 of the Convention with the récusation procedure of Articles 341, 342 and 344 of the Code of Civil Procedure and L. 111-6 of the Code of Judicial Organisation protects whichever side faces a bench that has already made up its mind. Sue the carrier that operated the flight, act as soon as you know the ground for challenge, and attach exhibits to everything. Written contracts and dated evidence decide cases; impressions do not. Only the court seized of a dispute can rule on it.

📄 Official circular