The search term supermarket is trending in the United Kingdom. One practical question for anyone who orders groceries online is what happens when food intended to arrive chilled is warm when the order reaches the door. In England and Wales, that is a question about the condition of what the trader supplied and when the problem arose. A customer who can show that the food fell below the standard required at delivery may have the right to reject it and recover the price. That possibility remains even when the normal change-of-mind cancellation rules do not apply to perishable food.
This article explains the general method under the law in force on 20 November 2026. It covers household purchases from a supermarket that arranges delivery. It does not assume that any particular retailer has had a refrigeration failure or that any named product has been affected. The evidence and remedy can differ between two items in the same basket. The first step is to record what arrived, in what condition and at what time. The second is to decide whether to reject the affected items or ask for replacements. The distinction matters because a short statutory rejection period can be shorter still for food that is reasonably expected to perish quickly.
Hassan Kohen, lawyer at the Paris Bar
I. Establish whether the groceries met the contract when they arrived
A. Assess the condition of each item against what was sold
Section 9 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 puts a satisfactory-quality term into contracts to supply goods. The test asks what a reasonable person would regard as satisfactory in light of the product description, the price where relevant and the other relevant circumstances. The Act expressly includes the state and condition of the goods. Safety and durability are relevant aspects where appropriate. A chilled dessert advertised for refrigerated storage and a jar designed to be kept at room temperature before opening call for different assessments, even if they came out of the same carrier bag.
Start with the particular product and its label. A photograph of storage instructions can explain why the condition mattered. The front of a package may identify a product as fresh or chilled while the back gives the actual storage conditions. The order confirmation can also establish what the shopper selected. If the receipt lists a substitute, record the product actually delivered and the instructions on that product. A complaint about its condition can be explained without deciding every question that might arise about the substitution itself.
An unexpired date is one piece of information. It cannot establish how a product was handled before delivery. In the same way, an intact seal shows something about the package but cannot establish that the food stayed under the specified conditions. The fact that a pack does not feel cold can help explain why the shopper inspected it. A reliable observation, made promptly and described precisely, carries more information than an unqualified statement that an entire basket was unsafe.
It is possible to describe the defect without making a medical or scientific finding. For example, a customer can report that a tray labelled for refrigerated storage was handed over at a given time, that it felt warm when unpacked immediately and that packaging photographs were taken a few minutes later. If a temperature was taken, the record should say how, where and when it was taken. A reading from the surface of the packaging should be recorded as such. It provides a different measurement from a reading of the food itself, and a single reading cannot reconstruct the whole time the food spent in transit. No one needs to open or taste food merely to assemble a complaint.
Suppose a weekly shop contains chilled fish, milk, tins and dry pasta. The fish and milk have storage directions relevant to the complaint. The tins and pasta may be unaffected even if they were handed over in the same delivery. The shopper who identifies the two chilled lines, attaches the labels and explains how quickly they were inspected gives the trader a specific question to answer. If there are several units of the same product, the number affected and the amount charged for them should also be recorded.
Food regulation serves a separate purpose. Section 14 of the Food Safety Act 1990 addresses the sale, to the purchaser’s prejudice, of food whose nature, substance or quality differs from what the purchaser demanded. That provision creates an offence with its own elements. A shopper seeking a contractual refund for an affected item can focus on the satisfactory-quality term and the facts of the delivery. A refund decision does not establish a regulatory offence. Conversely, waiting for an investigation into a particular batch may consume time available to exercise a contract remedy.
B. Identify when the problem arose and keep a record of handover
Under section 29 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, goods in an ordinary sales contract generally remain at the trader’s risk until they come into the physical possession of the consumer or a person the consumer identifies to receive them. Where the supermarket arranged the delivery, the fact that a driver or outside contractor carried the goods does not by itself transfer the risk to the shopper. The section has a different rule where the shopper commissions a carrier that the trader did not name as an option. This article deals with the usual supermarket-arranged service.
The handover rule makes the timeline worth recording. A slot from six to seven in the evening gives less detail than a message confirming delivery at twenty past six and a photograph taken at twenty-four past. If a neighbour received the order by arrangement, record when they took possession, what they did with the goods and when the shopper saw them. If bags were left in a porch, keep the instructions sent to the trader and any delivery photograph or timestamp. Those details help establish what happened without treating an automated delivery notification as a complete account of who took possession and when.
The condition may be evident at the door or become apparent only when shopping bags are unpacked. A delivery signature, photograph or notification can show that something was received, yet may say little about the internal condition of a product. Equally, when the food was apparently chilled at handover and spent a long time in a warm room afterwards, the later observation gives less support for a claim that it was already warm in transit. Document the interval, any storage after receipt and what was observed before the groceries were put away. A record that admits an interval is more informative than one that leaves it out.
An order number, itemised receipt, delivery messages and a brief chronology usually make a sensible starting file. Add photographs of identifying information on the affected packages and retain a copy of any message sent to the trader. If the same order arrived in two deliveries, specify the relevant one. If shopping was handed over together with bags belonging to a separate order, identify which receipt contains the affected items. These details let the trader check the right delivery slot and product line.
Section 19 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 sets out the available remedies and includes a limited evidential rule. For specified repair, replacement and later remedies, lack of conformity appearing within six months of delivery is ordinarily treated as present on delivery. The rule can be displaced if conformity on delivery is established or if the presumption is incompatible with the nature of the goods or the way they fail to conform. It does not apply to the short-term right to reject. In a dispute over quickly perishable food, the time between delivery and observation is much more informative than general references to a six-month period.
A retail complaint can begin while the trail is still fresh. It helps to ask the trader what its record shows about packing or handover if the trader disputes the timing. The shopper may have only an order message and photos. The trader may hold dispatch records and the driver’s handover record. Those sources can complement each other. If they disagree, a written explanation of the difference is more useful than sending the same complaint repeatedly without addressing the disputed fact.
II. Choose the remedy and make the request clear
A. Reject promptly or agree to a replacement on clear terms
For a breach of the satisfactory-quality term, section 19 points to the short-term right to reject, the right to repair or replacement, and the price reduction or final rejection available in specified circumstances. Section 22 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 normally sets a 30-day rejection period beginning the day after the necessary statutory events have all occurred. In a straightforward grocery sale, ownership and delivery are the relevant events. Where goods can reasonably be expected to perish in a shorter period, the short-term rejection limit for those goods ends at the end of that shorter period. The character of each item therefore matters. The same basket can contain goods for which the usual period applies and goods for which it does not.
There is no reason to wait for that period to run if the problem is apparent on delivery. Section 20 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires the consumer to indicate rejection clearly enough for the trader to understand. A message asking whether the temperature was normal may leave it uncertain whether the shopper has actually rejected anything. A message identifying the order and affected lines, recording their condition at receipt, and expressly rejecting those lines and requesting their price back makes the position clearer. Keep the text as sent, including its timestamp, especially when the order portal retains only the response.
Section 21 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 deals with partial rejection. Where it applies, a consumer may keep conforming goods and reject the affected ones, subject to the rule about goods forming a commercial unit. A commercial unit is one whose division would materially impair its value or character. For example, if a sealed meal kit sold as a single unit includes an affected chilled component, consider the kit as sold. The individual contents of that kit may be different from a separately priced loaf in the same delivery. A basket with two affected individual items and ten apparently sound ones should be itemised. If the entire order was allegedly affected, explain what links the condition of every line to the complaint. A failed chilled component does not on its own establish that shelf-stable groceries failed to conform.
Once rejection has been exercised, sections 20 and 21 generally require the shopper to make the goods available for collection or return them as agreed. The trader bears reasonable return costs, with the statutory exception for the consumer’s own costs of returning them in person to the place where physical possession was taken. In a dispute about food that should not be used, give the retailer a prompt opportunity to explain the collection arrangements. If it tells the shopper to dispose of the goods, save that instruction beside the photos and item record. If disposal has already taken place, describe when it happened and what records remain. The fact that disposal was sensible in the circumstances and the ability to prove that the item was defective are separate practical questions.
A shopper who wants a usable replacement for the same day may choose to require replacement under section 23 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015. A remedy cannot be required if it is impossible or disproportionate compared with the other remedy. Where the trader is required to replace the goods, it must do so within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience and at its own necessary cost. What is reasonable depends in part on the nature of the goods and their intended purpose. There is an appreciable difference between a relevant replacement slot that afternoon and an offer to send the food with next week’s routine order.
Asking for or agreeing to replacement affects the timing of short-term rejection. Under section 22, the clock stops during the waiting period. If what is supplied in response still fails to conform, the deadline is seven days after that waiting period ends or the original deadline extended by the waiting period, whichever is later. Section 23 also ordinarily requires giving the trader a reasonable time to replace goods once that option has been requested or agreed, unless waiting would cause significant inconvenience. The date the replacement was requested, what was promised, when it arrived and what condition it was in belong in the same timeline as the original delivery.
The same general distinction between a defect, proof and remedy matters in cross-border consumer disputes. The cabinet’s English-language information on French law concerns a different legal system. The remedy and deadlines explained here are those applicable to the England and Wales grocery purchase described above.
B. Check the refund amount and understand what a refusal means
There are two different clocks. One concerns how quickly the customer must reject the defective item. The other concerns when the retailer must pay once it agrees that the customer is entitled to a refund. Under section 20, that refund is due without undue delay and in any event within 14 days beginning on the day the trader agrees the entitlement. For a money payment, the retailer generally has to return it by the same means of payment unless the shopper expressly agrees otherwise. It cannot charge a fee for making that refund. On an ordinary card purchase, a voucher can be an offer to settle, but a customer is entitled to distinguish that offer from a statutory refund to the card.
A refund calculation should use the amount actually paid for the rejected items, with attention to reductions shown on the final receipt. A promotional price on a previous visit is rarely the best evidence of the price for this transaction. An order confirmation may also show estimated prices which changed when a weighed product was picked or a substitution was made. If the final payment differs from the estimate, keep both documents and identify the amount the trader actually charged for each item. If an allocation is unclear because a promotion covered several items, ask the trader to show how it calculated the figure.
When short-term rejection is no longer available or a replacement has failed, section 24 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 may give a choice between a price reduction and final rejection, subject to its conditions. Those include goods remaining non-conforming after one repair or replacement, neither remedy being available under section 23(3), or breach of the requirement to provide the repair or replacement within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. A price reduction can reach the full price where appropriate. A consumer who has both the right to a price reduction and the final right to reject can exercise only one of them. A missed short-term deadline alone is not proof that the conditions for final rejection have been met.
When the trader relies on a blanket statement that food cannot be returned, identify whether it means a change-of-mind cancellation or a defect claim. Regulation 28(1)(c) of the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 excludes goods liable to deteriorate or expire rapidly from that Part’s ordinary cancellation regime. The supermarket can therefore have a valid answer to a request to return a perfectly satisfactory perishable item merely because it is no longer wanted. A report that chilled goods were supplied in an unsatisfactory condition raises the separate statutory protections of the Consumer Rights Act. The important detail in the trader’s response is which of those two questions it actually answered.
A supermarket can set out a practical process for complaints, including the use of its order portal and requests for evidence. Section 31 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 limits terms that exclude or restrict liability for obligations including satisfactory quality and the passing of risk. It also addresses terms that subject the relevant rights and remedies to restrictive or onerous conditions. A portal’s refusal to accept an entry after its own reporting window does not settle the statutory question. At the same time, a delay can weaken the evidence or leave a short statutory rejection deadline expired. Keep a copy of the first communication and, if the retailer relies on a deadline, ask it to specify the date and the rule it applied.
A refusal on the facts requires a different response from a refusal based on store policy. If the trader says the products were correctly chilled when packed, the remaining question may be their condition at delivery. If it says a shopper did not make the goods available, identify any collection instructions and the response to them. If it accepted that one product arrived warm but declined the other lines, state what evidence ties those lines to the same delivery condition. A short written reply that identifies the unresolved point is easier to assess than a general statement that the whole experience was unacceptable.
It is also possible to distinguish the price of the goods from any other loss alleged. Section 19 preserves other remedies where available and prevents recovery twice for the same loss. An emergency replacement shop, for example, can be documented separately from the amount paid for the defective items. Receipts show the actual expense. They do not by themselves establish that all of it was caused by the original breach or is legally recoverable. Stating one figure for the rejected goods and another for any additional expense makes it possible to understand the dispute even if only the first figure is agreed.
Conclusion
For an online grocery order in England and Wales, a refund for chilled food delivered warm turns on the condition of the affected goods and the remedy used. Check the storage instructions, record the time and circumstances of handover, and identify the lines actually affected. If exercising short-term rejection, say so clearly and promptly. The ordinary 30-day period can be shorter for food reasonably expected to perish sooner.
A request for replacement changes the timeline, so record when it was made and what the supermarket supplied in response. When a statutory refund is agreed, distinguish its payment deadline from the earlier deadline for rejection and check the amount against the final receipt. The most useful record follows the product from delivery to complaint and allows each disputed item to be assessed on its own facts.