Kohen Avocats — Tax law
Research tax credit lawyer in Paris, France
The firm advises companies in France on the research tax credit (crédit d’impôt recherche, CIR) and the innovation tax credit (CII): preparing the claim, tax rulings, refunds and defence during a tax audit.
Have you received a request for supporting documents, a proposed tax reassessment or a refusal to refund? Send us the letter and the date you received it.
Research tax credit · Paris
Have your file reviewed
Technical file, tax returns, expenditure and letters received: send the documents you have so that we can review your situation and the steps to take.
File
Research
and innovation
In brief
Whether your company is preparing a research tax credit claim, awaiting its refund or facing a challenge from the tax authorities, the firm steps in according to your situation. Our review compares the work described by your teams, the expenditure claimed and the correspondence exchanged, before defining the appropriate engagement.
Preparing your file
We examine the eligibility conditions, the supporting evidence and whether a tax ruling (rescrit) is worth requesting, working with your research team and your chartered accountant. This work forms part of the services of our tax law firm in Paris.
Responding to a tax audit
We analyse the grounds of challenge, the safeguards that apply and the documents needed for your defence, project by project. Our page on tax audits in France sets out the general framework of this work.
Challenging a refusal to refund
We distinguish a challenge to your tax credit claim from a tax reassessment, then prepare the reply or appeal suited to the documents received. Our page on tax litigation completes this overview.
Kohen Avocats, Paris
Preparing and defending your research tax credit claim

Tax law · Paris 16th
Your research tax credit lawyer in Paris
- Paris Bar
- Companies and research teams
- Paris and the Paris region
- CIR, CII and tax rulings
Hassan Kohen, avocat at the Paris Bar, examines the tax questions raised by your research work, from preparing the file to challenging a decision. The firm brings together your company’s technical arguments, the accounting entries and the legal requirements specific to the claim.
Your team describes the work actually carried out; your chartered accountant helps reconcile the expenditure and the tax returns with the available supporting documents. The lawyer organises their legal analysis, identifies evidential difficulties and prepares the exchanges that fall within the scope of the engagement.
You can send your documents through the form or call the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45. A preliminary review of the file at €80 incl. VAT can lead to a written analysis within 24 working hours.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB)Office at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Your research tax credit file: at what stage does the lawyer step in?
Before filing the claim
The firm examines the operations presented, the expenditure and any missing items, then assesses whether a tax ruling request suits your project.
During exchanges with the tax authorities
Our work covers understanding the requests received, preparing the supporting documents and ensuring that the answers given by your company are consistent.
After a challenge
The firm distinguishes a tax reassessment from a refusal to refund, examines the documented arguments and agrees with you on the steps to take.
Documents to send, stages of the engagement and fees
Send the scientific file, the tax returns, the expenditure tables, the accounting evidence and the correspondence with the tax authorities, together with the dates you received it. After review, the firm sets out the work entrusted to it, the documents required and the fee arrangements in a proposal tailored to your situation.
Research and innovation
Securing project eligibility and the expenditure claimed
The file must explain the research work and link each item of expenditure claimed to the operations your company actually carried out.
Eligibility is assessed under Article 244 quater B of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts) and Article 49 septies F of Annex III to the General Tax Code. The commercial novelty of a product does not, on its own, prove that research work giving entitlement to the CIR was carried out.
Describing the work
Your team sets out the state of the art, the difficulties encountered, the hypotheses examined and the tests carried out during the project. The firm checks that this description allows the tax qualification to be discussed, without taking the place of your teams’ scientific expertise.
Substantiating the expenditure
Salaries, depreciation and outsourced services must be matched to the projects concerned, with their accounting records and technical evidence. The qualification of staff is discussed in particular under Article 49 septies G of Annex III to the General Tax Code.
Identifying the contestable points
An invoice, a job description or a summary table does not necessarily replace proof of the work actually done. The firm identifies inconsistencies and the documents to gather before presenting a position to the tax authorities.
For subcontracted expenditure, the analysis also covers approval of the subcontractor, the nature of the services and their contribution to the research operations. The rules on the basis of the credit must be assessed in the version of the text applicable to the expenditure, without automatically transposing an older solution.
Research and innovation
Preparing a research tax credit ruling request
A tax ruling requires a precisely worded question and a complete presentation of the project; its scope depends on the situation actually described.
Article L. 80 B of the French Tax Procedure Code (Livre des procédures fiscales) distinguishes the tax ruling (rescrit fiscal) from the consultation on the scientific and technical nature of the research. The firm examines the recipient, the filing conditions and the consistency of the information before preparing your request.
Defining the question
The file specifies the planned work, the technical uncertainties and the expenditure concerned, so as to pin down the position sought from the tax authorities. An overly general request makes it difficult to identify the points on which the company seeks a guarantee.
Choosing the right route
The tax ruling may concern the CIR or the CII, whereas the specific scientific route does not cover the CII. A favourable scientific opinion does not necessarily settle the other tax conditions to which entitlement to the credit remains subject.
Preserving the scope of the answer
We compare the work carried out with the description submitted and keep the requests, annexes and answers that explain the position obtained. Any change in the project calls for a fresh review of whether that position still matches your situation.
Silence on a refund claim must not be treated as the mechanism specific to tax rulings provided for by the text. The firm first identifies the nature of the step taken, then checks the conditions for relying on an answer or on silence.
Research and innovation
Tax audit and research tax credit reassessment: organising the defence
The defence rests on a careful reading of the objections raised, the chronology of the exchanges and the supporting documents available for each disputed operation.
Article L. 45 B of the Tax Procedure Code distinguishes the scientific review from the implementation of the tax reassessment procedures. Where that procedure is initiated, the firm examines in particular the statement of reasons required by Article L. 57 of the Tax Procedure Code.
Analysing the objections
We separate the criticisms concerning the nature of the work, the expenditure, the staff and the quality of the supporting documents provided by the company. Each answer is linked to the relevant documents, with the further explanations your team can provide.
Checking the expert review
Article R. 45 B-1 of the Tax Procedure Code governs requests for supporting documents and exchanges with the officials in charge of research. The firm examines the procedure actually followed, without presenting a site visit or an interview as a systematic obligation.
Preparing the next steps
If disagreement persists, the conditions for referring the matter to the advisory committee are examined in the light of the questions actually in dispute. Article L. 59 D of the Tax Procedure Code concerns whether the expenditure was genuinely allocated to research; the committee does not decide questions of law.
Our page on tax audits in Paris covers the other aspects of our support in dealings with the tax authorities. For your CIR, the analysis remains focused on the work, the expenditure and the procedure shown in the documents received.
Research and innovation
Research tax credit refund claims: dealing with difficulties
The right to a refund, the substantiation of the tax credit claim and the means of challenge must be examined separately on the basis of the file.
The rules for using the tax credit claim are set out in Article 199 ter B of the General Tax Code, to which Article 220 B of the General Tax Code refers for the companies concerned. The possibility of an immediate refund does not mean that payment is made without prior review of the conditions and the expenditure.
Claim to be completed
The firm compares the claim with the tax returns, the supporting documents and the conditions relied on to obtain repayment of the tax credit claim. It identifies the missing documents and prepares the reply to the tax authorities’ requests, with your team and your chartered accountant.
Refusal to be challenged
A refund claim constitutes a tax claim (réclamation) governed by Article L. 190 of the Tax Procedure Code. A refusal is not the same as a tax reassessment. The arguments and safeguards must be chosen according to this qualification, then tested against the grounds actually given.
Tax credit claim and appeals to follow
The dates of the claim, of receipt of the decisions and of payment make it possible to examine the options available and the deadlines specific to the file. An assignment of the claim to a bank also requires a fresh look at the deeds and the steps already taken by each party.
Our page on tax litigation sets out the general framework for challenging an administrative decision. The firm separately assesses any claim for interest under Article L. 208 of the Tax Procedure Code and in the light of the refund timeline.
Research and innovation
Innovation tax credit: distinguishing the CII from the CIR
The innovation tax credit (crédit d’impôt innovation) has its own conditions; examining it cannot be replaced by examining eligibility for the CIR.
The CII provided for by Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code covers certain innovation expenditure incurred by companies that meet the European definition of SMEs. The analysis focuses in particular on prototypes or pilot installations of new products, with a documented comparison of their performance on the market.
Identifying the product
You need to specify the product concerned, its availability on the market and the performance claimed compared with competing products. An internal improvement or a new feature is not, in itself, enough to show that the conditions of the scheme are met.
Documenting the tests
Mock-ups, test versions and documents describing the work make it possible to distinguish the design of the prototype from other commercial activities. The firm examines the legal qualification on the basis of these elements and the explanations provided by your teams.
Separating the expenditure
The work presented for the CIR and the work falling under the CII must be identified according to their respective conditions, with the corresponding supporting documents. The fact that expenditure is accepted under one scheme does not automatically prove its eligibility under the other.
For software, the firm examines the nature of the product, the versions developed and the evidence allowing its performance to be compared with the market. A ruling request must follow the appropriate tax route, without extending the specific scientific consultation to the CII.
Your questions
Frequently asked questions on research tax credit (CIR) and CII support
Is an innovative project enough to qualify for the French research tax credit?
The novelty of your product is not enough to establish that research work giving entitlement to the tax credit was carried out. Article 49 septies F of Annex III to the General Tax Code defines the activities concerned, while Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code governs the scheme and the eligible expenditure.
Your file must explain the available knowledge, the scientific or technical difficulties encountered and the approach taken to try to resolve them. A commercial presentation, however detailed, does not replace test reports, the hypotheses examined and the results actually obtained.
The firm compares this description with your company’s documents, then identifies the assertions that remain insufficiently supported before any reply to the tax authorities. In a case concerning software, the Lyon Administrative Court of Appeal noted that the state of the art and the obstacles encountered had not been explained. This decision calls for the work itself to be documented; it does not mean that every software project is excluded from the CIR.
“it does not set out what the state of the art was on this question and the scientific, technical or technological obstacles it had to overcome.” (our translation) CAA Lyon, 21 January 2021, No. 20LY01158.
Can depreciation of a prototype be included in my research tax credit?
Being a prototype is not enough to exclude depreciation from the CIR, but nor does it make all expenditure eligible. Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code requires an examination of the nature of the fixed asset and whether it is directly allocated to the research operations concerned.
The firm compares the fixed-asset entries, the purchase records and the documents describing the use of the prototype in your company’s tests. This comparison makes it possible to separate the tax argument from mere labels used in a budget, a technical presentation or a sales report.
In the Green Big case, the Council of State (Conseil d’État) overturned an exclusion based solely on the prototype nature of the fixed assets in question. It set aside the contested decision and referred the case back, without itself granting a final refund of the credit claimed by the company.
Your file must therefore establish the other applicable conditions, taking into account the period of the expenditure and the evidence actually available. The firm prepares an argument that reflects this distinction without turning the decision into a general guarantee that the expenditure will be accepted.
“and the fact that these fixed assets may be prototypes has no bearing.” (our translation) Conseil d’État, 17 June 2026, No. 507371.
Can an employee without a researcher’s degree be counted?
A degree is not the only factor in assessing the duties actually performed by an employee in your company’s research operations. Article 49 septies G of Annex III to the General Tax Code defines the researchers and technicians concerned and provides for certain equivalences based on qualifications acquired.
You need to document the tasks performed, why they were necessary for the research work and the actual collaboration with the people conducting it. A general job description is not always enough to explain the time actually devoted to the project during the period under review.
In the Germicopa case, the Nantes Administrative Court of Appeal accepted the tasks of seasonal workers working with the researchers under an experimental protocol. Its decision rests on the work established in that case, without making all pay allocated to a technical team generally eligible.
The firm reviews with you the protocols, reports, qualification records and monitoring documents that describe this contribution. This analysis helps defend the substantiated expenditure and identify the items whose link to research remains insufficiently shown.
“This work thus constitutes the technical support essential to the company’s research work.” (our translation) CAA Nantes, 28 November 2019, No. 18NT00348.
Are timesheets enough to substantiate staff costs?
Timesheets can contribute to the evidence, but their existence does not automatically show the nature of the work actually done. Article 49 septies G of Annex III to the General Tax Code requires an examination of the research duties or the essential technical support provided to the operations concerned.
The firm matches the time declared to the projects, the tasks described and the operational documents that allow its consistency to be checked. Test reports, staff assignments and technical exchanges can shed light on this exercise, depending on how your company is actually organised.
In the Otico case, the Paris Administrative Court of Appeal held that the evidence produced was insufficient to establish the employees’ participation in the work relied on. Nor does an opinion concerning another period replace the supporting documents specific to the expenditure and work now in dispute.
You therefore need to explain what each document establishes and keep the material that makes the tables sent to the tax authorities understandable. The firm organises this presentation with your teams, without artificially recreating supporting documents that would not reflect the work done.
“This evidence is not sufficient to consider that the seven employees concerned carried out operations necessary for the research work under the direction of researchers.” (our translation) CAA Paris, 12 July 2024, No. 22PA03074.
Can tests outsourced to a service provider be included in the research tax credit?
An outsourced service must be examined in terms of its contribution to your company’s research operations and the applicable conditions. Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code governs, in particular, subcontracted expenditure; the subcontractor’s approval and the contractual evidence must be checked in each file.
The Council of State has accepted that analyses and tests necessary for research may be taken into account under certain conditions. It specified that their qualification did not depend solely on whether the services, considered in isolation, amounted to research.
The firm examines the contract, the invoices, the deliverables and the technical documents showing that the services were necessary for your own work. An invoice describing only a general assignment does not always make that link, or the operations actually carried out, clear.
The decision cited concerned an earlier regime; it does not remove the need to check the rules on the basis of the credit that apply to your company’s expenditure. We therefore separate what it says about the link with research from the rules that now govern how such services are taken into account financially.
“even if the subcontracted services, taken in isolation, would not constitute research operations.” (our translation) Conseil d’État, 22 July 2020, No. 428127.
What should a research tax credit ruling request contain?
Your request must present the project precisely and completely, so that the tax authorities can rule on the situation actually envisaged. Article L. 80 B of the Tax Procedure Code governs tax rulings and distinguishes several routes whose purpose and scope must be identified.
The file describes the work, the scientific or technical difficulties, the resources deployed and the expenditure to which the tax question relates. The annexes must make the statements in the main letter understandable, without leaving the tax office to piece your project together.
The firm also considers the stage of the tax return and the filing conditions before choosing the approach that meets your needs. The specific scientific consultation does not settle all the tax conditions of the credit and, unlike the tax ruling, does not cover the CII.
Once the answer is obtained, the actual situation must be compared with the one described, particularly where the work or the expenditure changes. We keep the exchanges and annexes to determine exactly what was asked and the scope of the tax authorities’ position. A favourable answer therefore cannot be presented as a blanket guarantee for all your company’s activities.
Does silence from the tax authorities mean my research tax credit is approved?
Silence does not have the same effect depending on whether you submitted a ruling request, claimed a refund or sent supporting documents. Article L. 80 B of the Tax Procedure Code provides for a mechanism specific to tax rulings, subject to conditions that must be examined on the basis of your request.
The firm checks the nature of the letter, its recipient, its date of receipt and the information provided with the annexes to the file. These elements determine whether you can rely on a guarantee, rather than inferring approval from the mere absence of a reply.
The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal rejected the argument of a taxpayer who treated silence on her refund claim as implicit acceptance. Such a claim is not the same as the prior tax ruling procedure designed to obtain a position on the project presented.
You must therefore keep the requests and proofs of receipt, then have the step properly qualified before drawing any tax consequence from it. The firm examines the possible next steps and the scope of the exchanges, without promising an acceptance based on the mere passage of time.
“did not amount to implicit acceptance by the tax authorities and did not constitute an increase in earlier assessments” (our translation) CAA Paris, 22 March 2018, No. 16PA02001.
How should I respond when the expert disputes my research work?
The response must identify the scientific or technical criticisms, then match them with the explanations and documents that allow them to be discussed. Article R. 45 B-1 of the Tax Procedure Code governs exchanges with the officials responsible for checking whether the expenditure was genuinely allocated to research.
The firm reconstructs the requests sent to your company, the answers provided and the material on which the expert’s opinion is based. It distinguishes a lack of evidence on the merits from a problem concerning compliance with the safeguards provided by the applicable procedure.
In the Zoomici case, the Council of State found that the company had been deprived of a safeguard where the necessary requests had not been sent to it. This decision does not mean that every expert review must include an interview or a site visit, regardless of how the exchanges unfolded.
Your team remains responsible for explaining the work actually carried out; the lawyer organises its presentation and assesses the procedural arguments that may be raised. The response must take into account the applicable version of the text and the audit documents, without mechanically transposing an older solution.
“had sent it neither a request for supporting documents nor requests for further information that would have enabled it to complete its expert review” (our translation) Conseil d’État, 3 February 2021, No. 431253.
Must a refusal to refund follow the tax reassessment procedure?
The refusal of a refund claim is not the same as a tax reassessment, even if the same expenditure is in dispute. The claim constitutes a tax claim (réclamation) governed by Article L. 190 of the Tax Procedure Code; its qualification determines which safeguards and means of challenge apply.
The Douai Administrative Court of Appeal restated this distinction when rejecting the arguments of a company that relied on the safeguards specific to reassessment. The tax authorities may examine whether the claim is well founded before making the refund, including where the company requests immediate repayment.
The firm reads the decision received, the requests for supporting documents and the tax return concerned to determine what the tax office actually refused. It then prepares a discussion of the refund conditions, the reality of the work or the expenditure, depending on the grounds given.
This analysis avoids building the defence on a procedure that does not match your file or overlooking the supporting documents expected. The dates of receipt and the steps already taken remain necessary to examine the possible next steps for your claim.
“the decision by which the tax authorities reject all or part of the claim constituted by a request for the refund of a research tax credit does not have the character of a recovery or reassessment procedure.” (our translation) CAA Douai, 30 December 2020, No. 18DA02271.
Does an immediate refund mean I will be paid without any audit?
Immediate refund describes a way of using the tax credit claim; it does not guarantee payment without the tax authorities reviewing the file. Article 199 ter B of the General Tax Code lists the categories concerned, with the cross-reference in Article 220 B of the General Tax Code for corporate income tax.
The firm checks the conditions your company relies on, then compares the claim with the tax returns and the supporting documents available for the expenditure. SME status under the European definition must, in particular, be assessed with the relevant evidence, not inferred from the everyday language the company uses.
The Douai Administrative Court of Appeal distinguished the right to claim repayment from the tax authorities’ power to check whether the claim is well founded. An incomplete file or a discussion about the work may therefore require exchanges before the claim receives an answer.
You need to keep the letters received, respond on the points raised and separate the conditions for repayment from questions of eligibility for the credit. The firm assists you with this analysis, without announcing a payment date that the documents and the procedure do not allow to be established.
“the decision by which the tax authorities reject all or part of the claim constituted by a request for the refund of a research tax credit does not have the character of a recovery or reassessment procedure.” (our translation) CAA Douai, 30 December 2020, No. 18DA02271.
Can I claim interest after a late research tax credit refund?
A claim for interest requires reconstructing the timeline of the tax claim, of any rejection and of the refund actually made. Article L. 208 of the Tax Procedure Code governs late-payment interest (intérêts moratoires); its application does not allow interest to be promised for every wait for payment.
In the Groupe ESA case, the Council of State distinguished the initial acceptance of the claim from a refund made after an express or implied rejection. In the latter situation, it awarded interest running from the refund claim, under the conditions examined in the judgment.
The firm checks the date of the claim, the decisions received, the subsequent exchanges and the documents identifying the payment made. These documents show whether the situation matches the legal basis relied on and what further claim can be put to the tax authorities.
This question must also be separated from the eligibility of the expenditure, which may have been settled or may still be disputed on certain points. No rate or amount should be put forward before this review and the verification of the information needed for the calculation in your file.
“consequently gives entitlement to the payment of late-payment interest from the date of the refund claim.” (our translation) Conseil d’État, 11 May 2021, No. 442936.
I assigned my tax credit claim to a bank: can I still challenge the refusal?
The assignment of your tax credit claim requires an examination of the deeds and of the steps already taken by the bank before deciding on any litigation. The refund claim is governed by Article L. 190 of the Tax Procedure Code, but the standing of the parties and the subject of their claim must be established.
In the RAGT Semences case, the Council of State accepted that the company could rely on the prior claim filed by the assignee institution. It set aside the contested judgments and referred the cases back, without finally deciding the eligibility of the expenditure or the amount of the credit.
The firm therefore asks for the deed of assignment, the tax returns, the bank’s claim and the administrative decisions concerning the tax credit claim. Reading them makes it possible to compare the sums and the claims concerned, then identify the challenge your company actually intends to pursue.
This decision does not replace an examination of the regime applicable to your assignment or of the admissibility conditions specific to your file. The firm coordinates the analysis of the documents to avoid a step that would ignore the exchanges already held between the bank and the tax authorities.
“the assignor company may rely on the prior claim submitted by the assignee institution to the tax authorities, having regard to its subject matter.” (our translation) Conseil d’État, 15 January 2025, No. 489721.
Can a new version of my software qualify for the innovation tax credit (CII)?
A new version may warrant examination under the CII, but an update is not enough to establish eligibility. Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code requires a new product and performance that sets it apart from the products available on the market.
In the Equadex case, the Toulouse Administrative Court of Appeal examined the improvements to the software package, the mock-ups and the test versions produced by the company. It allowed the benefit of the scheme in the circumstances established, without laying down a general rule for every new software feature.
The firm brings together the descriptions of the versions, the tests and the comparison documents that explain the novelty and the performance claimed. Requests made by your customers do not replace this demonstration, even when they shed light on your company’s commercial objectives.
The prototype design operations must also be distinguished from operating or adaptation work that does not meet the same conditions. Your file must make this distinction clear and link the expenditure presented to the work actually carried out during the period concerned.
“the new versions of the software package incorporating these improvements may be classified as a new product” (our translation) CAA Toulouse, 10 April 2025, No. 23TL00138.
Is improving my platform enough to justify an innovation tax credit?
Improving your own platform does not necessarily show novelty or superior performance compared with the products on the market. Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code requires the CII conditions to be examined beyond the internal progress observed by your company.
In the Allovoisins case, the Nantes Administrative Court of Appeal rejected the features relied on, having regard to the novelty of the product and the work presented. This decision calls for documenting the comparison with the market and the design of the prototype, without confusing an improved service with an eligible product.
The firm examines the exact nature of the innovation, the relevant competing products and the documents describing the prototypes or test versions. A presentation focused on user satisfaction or commercial growth is not enough to show that the tax conditions concerned are met.
Your team must explain the performance claimed and how it can be compared, with documents reflecting the work actually carried out. We identify the arguments that can be supported and those that need further evidence before a tax return or a reply to the tax authorities.
“Such services with new features, which amount to a limited adaptation of existing products, do not meet the condition of novelty of a product” (our translation) CAA Nantes, 8 October 2024, No. 23NT02360.
Can I rely on the BOFiP (official tax guidance) against a refusal to refund?
Administrative guidance must be read in the light of the applicable text, the situation concerned and the nature of the contested decision. Article L. 80 A of the Tax Procedure Code provides safeguards against an upward reassessment; it does not automatically cover every refusal to refund the CIR.
The Douai Administrative Court of Appeal restated that the rejection of a refund claim was not a recovery or reassessment procedure. This distinction makes it necessary to check the legal basis relied on, even where the company believes it followed an interpretation published in the official tax guidance.
The firm looks in your file for the guidance actually applied, the operations concerned and the exchanges that explain the tax office’s position. It separates the explanation useful for analysing the conditions of the credit from the specific question of whether an administrative interpretation can be relied on against the tax authorities.
An isolated quotation is therefore not enough to guarantee the refund claimed or to rule out the tax authorities’ review of the documents. The argument must remain suited to the procedure and the facts, with the relevant references and the supporting documents specific to your company’s work.
“the decision by which the tax authorities reject all or part of the claim constituted by a request for the refund of a research tax credit does not have the character of a recovery or reassessment procedure.” (our translation) CAA Douai, 30 December 2020, No. 18DA02271.
Can the advisory committee settle my research tax credit dispute?
The committee acts within a defined scope; it does not replace the court and does not itself decide questions of law. Article L. 59 D of the Tax Procedure Code covers disagreements on whether the expenditure concerned by the credit was genuinely allocated to research.
Article L. 59 of the Tax Procedure Code organises the referral to the competent body in the event of persistent disagreement, where the taxpayer so requests. The firm checks whether the questions raised in your audit fall within this framework and what material can usefully be presented.
The file must distinguish the facts to be established, the expenditure in dispute and the legal arguments that remain a matter for the competent authorities. Article L. 60 of the Tax Procedure Code provides for the tax authorities’ report and the documents supporting their position to be made available, subject to the stated reservations.
We prepare a presentation of the operations and supporting documents that explains the disagreement, with the technical explanations provided by your team. Whether this step is worthwhile depends on the nature of the dispute and the procedure followed; no favourable opinion can be announced in advance.
Which documents should I send the lawyer for my research tax credit file?
Send the tax returns concerned, the scientific file, the expenditure tables and the letters from the tax authorities, together with the dates you received them. These documents show whether you need help with preparing the credit, an expert review, a reassessment or a refund.
Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code governs the categories of expenditure; Article 49 septies G of Annex III to the General Tax Code sheds light in particular on the review of research staff. The accounting documents must be capable of being matched to the work, the people involved and the periods to which the expenditure actually relates.
After reading the file, the firm tells you what additional material would help, without asking you to manufacture a technical file that would not reflect the operations carried out. Existing protocols, reports and monitoring records can explain the summary tables and help discuss the tax authorities’ criticisms.
The Otico decision shows the limits of tables that do not sufficiently demonstrate the employees’ actual contribution to the research work relied on. Also send the replies already given, so that our new involvement takes account of the statements and supporting documents previously provided to the tax office.
“This evidence is not sufficient to consider that the seven employees concerned carried out operations necessary for the research work under the direction of researchers.” (our translation) CAA Paris, 12 July 2024, No. 22PA03074.
Can my chartered accountant keep working alongside my lawyer?
The lawyer’s work can be organised with your chartered accountant and your research team, with the role of each clearly defined. The conditions of Article 244 quater B of the General Tax Code require the qualification of the work, the expenditure recorded in the accounts and the supporting documents produced to be reconciled.
Your team describes the scientific or technical difficulties, the tests and the results obtained; the chartered accountant helps ensure the financial information is consistent. The lawyer examines the legal conditions, the safeguards and the arguments to be presented, according to the agreed engagement and the state of the file.
This division of roles should make it possible to answer the tax authorities’ specific questions, without presenting each party’s skills as interchangeable or presuming scientific expertise. In the event of a reassessment, Article L. 57 of the Tax Procedure Code calls in particular for an examination of the statement of reasons and of the observations that may be made.
The firm agrees with you on the documents to gather and the exchanges required, then sets out the scope of the work in its engagement proposal. The tax returns and replies already sent must be shared among the parties concerned to avoid inconsistencies and to keep an accurate account of the operations carried out.
Sources and further reading
Legal texts and related pages
The references below give access to the texts cited; how they apply depends on the expenditure concerned and the procedure actually followed.
Further reading
Tax law in Paris
See our main page on French tax law for the other situations in which the firm assists clients.
Tax audits and disputes
Our pages on tax audits and tax litigation complement the steps specific to the CIR.
Analyses of the CIR
Our articles on defending the CIR in the current budget context and on research tax credit refunds for SMEs (in French) cover these topics in detail.
A research tax credit file to review?
Send the tax returns, the technical supporting documents and the letters received. The firm reviews your situation and the steps to take.