KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Thames Valley Police Detective Gross Misconduct: What the Conduct Rules Require in England and Wales

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Thames Valley Police Detective Gross Misconduct: What the Conduct Rules Require in England and Wales

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

“Thames Valley Police detective gross misconduct” is being searched in the United Kingdom. No official document read for this article establishes the facts of any particular detective, hearing or finding. The search is the occasion for the legal question, not evidence of what any officer did. The method set out below is of general scope. It explains the rules for police officers in England and Wales. It does not describe any named officer, and it makes no finding about any allegation.

A detective has no separate disciplinary code. The Police (Conduct) Regulations 2020 define a police officer as a member of a police force or a special constable. A detective who is a member of a police force falls under those Regulations once an allegation reaches the appropriate authority. The revised text, including amendments noted as taking effect on 7 May 2024, 28 May 2025 and 13 July 2026, was read on 19 November 2026, together with the Police Appeals Tribunals Rules 2020, the Police Barred List and Police Advisory List Regulations 2017 and the Police (Complaints and Misconduct) Regulations 2020.

The Conduct Regulations mark their provisions E+W, and the preamble records that a draft was supplied to the Police Advisory Board for England and Wales. They are not the code for Scotland or Northern Ireland. This is general information on foreign law, prepared in Paris. It is not a claim to practise in England and Wales, and it is not an assessment of any individual hearing.

I. What gross misconduct means, and which officers the rules cover

A. The definitions, the Standards, and the first assessment

The starting point is the definition, not the label in a headline. In regulation 2 of the Conduct Regulations, misconduct, subject to two cross-references that use the word in a different statutory sense, means a breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour that is so serious as to justify disciplinary action. Gross misconduct means a breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour that is so serious as to justify dismissal. Since 28 May 2025 the same definition adds that, for the purposes of these Regulations, conduct which has resulted in conviction of an indictable-only offence is to be taken to constitute such a breach. That addition is an amendment note in the revised text. It does not mean that every criminal conviction is gross misconduct. It is confined to conviction of an indictable-only offence, and it operates inside these Regulations.

Disciplinary action is defined in ascending order of seriousness. It is a written warning, a final written warning, reduction in rank, or dismissal without notice. The gap between misconduct and gross misconduct is therefore the gap between a breach serious enough to justify one of those actions and a breach serious enough to justify the last of them. A reader who has only heard the words “gross misconduct” still has to ask which Standard is said to have been breached, and why the breach, if proved, would justify dismissal rather than a lesser action or no disciplinary action at all.

Conduct, in the same regulation, includes acts, omissions, statements and decisions, whether actual, alleged or inferred. An allegation about a detective can therefore concern something not done, something said, or a decision, as well as a physical act. The Regulations do not require the conduct to have occurred on duty before it can be assessed. The Discreditable Conduct standard, set out below, expressly covers behaviour on or off duty.

The Standards themselves are in Schedule 2. They are short, and they are the measure against which the severity assessment is made. Honesty and Integrity requires that police officers are honest, act with integrity and do not compromise or abuse their position. Authority, Respect and Courtesy requires self-control and tolerance, and forbids abuse of powers or authority. Equality and Diversity requires fairness and impartiality, and forbids unlawful or unfair discrimination. Use of Force, in the wording substituted from 30 June 2026, requires that force be used only when the officer honestly believes it to be necessary, and that the force used be necessary, proportionate and reasonable. Orders and Instructions require officers to give and carry out only lawful orders, and to abide by police regulations, force policies and lawful orders. Duties and Responsibilities require diligence, and appropriate cooperation during investigations, inquiries and formal proceedings, including when the officer is identified as a witness.

Confidentiality requires that police officers treat information with respect and access or disclose it only in the proper course of police duties. That standard matters in any case about a detective, because a detective’s work is the handling of information, but the standard is not confined to detectives. Fitness for Duty requires that an officer on duty, or presenting for duty, be fit to carry out the responsibilities of the role. Discreditable Conduct requires that police officers behave in a manner which does not discredit the police service or undermine public confidence in it, whether on or off duty. The same standard requires officers to report any action taken against them for a criminal offence, any conditions imposed by a court, and the receipt of any penalty notice. Challenging and Reporting Improper Conduct requires officers to report, challenge or take action against the conduct of colleagues which has fallen below the Standards.

None of those sentences is a finding. They are the yardstick. An allegation that a detective misused information is tested against Confidentiality and, where the facts reach it, against Honesty and Integrity or Discreditable Conduct. An allegation about an off-duty incident is not outside the code merely because it was off duty. Whether it is misconduct, gross misconduct, practice requiring improvement, or none of those, is a separate assessment.

That assessment is regulation 14. The appropriate authority must assess whether the conduct which is the subject matter of the allegation, if proved, would amount to misconduct or gross misconduct or neither. That is the severity assessment. Where the assessment is that the conduct, if proved, would amount to neither, the authority must then assess whether it would amount to practice requiring improvement, whether it should be referred under the Vetting Regulations or the Performance Regulations, or whether no further action should be taken. Before an assessment of practice requiring improvement, a vetting referral or a performance referral, the authority must consult the officer’s line manager. Where the conduct, if proved, would amount to practice requiring improvement, the matter must be referred to the reflective practice review process in Part 6.

Two consequences follow for a reader. First, the word “gross” is not applied at the end of the hearing only. It is a hypothesis at the start: what the conduct would amount to if proved. Second, a case that does not meet the misconduct threshold is not automatically closed. It may move to reflective practice, vetting or performance. Those other instruments are named in the Conduct Regulations. Their detailed procedures were not the texts read for this article, so they are not restated here. What can be said from the Conduct Regulations alone is that the authority must make the assessment and, in the stated cases, must consult the line manager before sending the matter down one of those other routes.

The appropriate authority, for an officer who is not the chief officer or acting chief officer, is the chief officer of police of the police force concerned. For the chief officer or acting chief officer, it is the local policing body. A detective who is not the chief officer is therefore dealt with, at this stage, by the chief officer of that officer’s force, subject to the later rules on delegation and on presentation of the case by the Director General. The Regulations do not create a different appropriate authority because the officer is a detective.

B. Serving officers, former officers, and the line with a criminal case

Regulation 4 states the field of application. Subject to a transitional paragraph, the Regulations apply where an allegation comes to the attention of an appropriate authority which indicates that the conduct of a police officer may amount to misconduct, gross misconduct or practice requiring improvement. The trigger is an indication in the allegation, not a proved breach. A detective who is still a member of the force is inside that paragraph in the ordinary way.

The Regulations also reach some former officers, but only for gross misconduct, and only if a further condition is met. They apply, with modifications in Schedule 1, where an allegation indicates that the conduct of a person who was a police officer at the time of the alleged conduct may amount to gross misconduct, and condition A, B or C is satisfied. Condition A is that the person ceased to be a police officer after the allegation first came to the attention of a relevant body. Condition B is that the person ceased to be an officer before the allegation first came to attention, and the period between those dates did not exceed 12 months. Condition C is that the period exceeded 12 months and the Director General makes a Condition C special determination, under the modified Part 1A, that taking disciplinary proceedings in respect of the alleged gross misconduct would be reasonable and proportionate.

That former-officer route is closed in two situations stated in regulation 4(8). It does not apply to a person who ceased to be a police officer before 15 December 2017. It also does not apply if the proceedings would not be the first disciplinary proceedings for that alleged gross misconduct, unless they result from a re-investigation that begins not later than 12 months after the person ceased to be an officer. A reader who is asking about an officer who has already left therefore has to date two events: the day the person ceased to be an officer, and the day the allegation first came to the attention of a chief officer, a local policing body, or the Director General. Those are the relevant bodies named in regulation 4(10). A gap of more than 12 months does not by itself end the matter. It moves the case into the Director General’s special determination, and only if the person left on or after 15 December 2017.

Several allegations about the same officer may be taken together and treated as a single allegation for any provision that requires an assessment, finding, determination or decision. A detective facing two linked complaints is not entitled, under this regulation, to insist that each be assessed in isolation.

The Regulations do not apply to a pre-commencement allegation, or to a later allegation about a matter that is already being handled under the earlier regime, subject to the Director General’s re-investigation and old-case powers in regulation 4(7). The instrument itself came into force on 1 February 2020. The citation provision states that these Regulations may be cited as the Police (Conduct) Regulations 2020 and come into force on 1st February 2020. The revised text read on 19 November 2026 is the text that includes the later amendments. A case still being handled under the pre-2020 regulations is not moved onto the 2020 text merely because a new search uses the words “gross misconduct”.

Criminal proceedings are a parallel track, not a substitute. Regulation 10 requires proceedings under the Conduct Regulations to proceed without delay, subject to that regulation. Before referring a case to misconduct proceedings or an accelerated misconduct hearing, the appropriate authority must decide whether those proceedings would prejudice any criminal proceedings. For any period during which the authority considers that they would, no such proceedings or accelerated hearing may take place. Where a witness in the disciplinary case is or may be a witness in criminal proceedings, the authority must consult the relevant prosecutor before making that decision, and must inform the prosecutor of the names and addresses of all such witnesses. The relevant prosecutor is the Director of Public Prosecutions or any other person who has, or is likely to have, responsibility for the criminal proceedings.

The practical point is easy to miss. A delay is not automatic because a criminal investigation exists. The authority must decide whether the disciplinary hearing would prejudice the criminal proceedings. When that prejudice is no longer considered to exist, or when the criminal proceedings have concluded whatever their outcome, regulation 23 requires a further determination, as soon as practicable, of case to answer and of the form of proceedings. An acquittal does not, by itself, erase a disciplinary case. A conviction does not, by itself, choose the disciplinary outcome, except for the specific rule, already noted, that conviction of an indictable-only offence is taken to constitute a breach serious enough to justify dismissal.

Not every complaint about a detective must be referred to the Director General. Regulation 4 of the Complaints and Misconduct Regulations specifies the complaints which must be referred to the Director General. They include a complaint alleging conduct which constitutes a serious assault, a serious sexual offence, or serious corruption, including abuse of position for a sexual purpose or for pursuing an improper emotional relationship, in each case as determined in guidance issued by the Director General. They also include a criminal offence or behaviour liable to lead to disciplinary proceedings which was aggravated by discriminatory behaviour on the grounds of a person’s race, sex, religion or other status, again as determined in that guidance, and a relevant offence. A complaint arising from the same incident as one of those matters must also be referred. A complaint about a chief officer, or the Deputy Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis, must be referred where the appropriate authority cannot satisfy itself from the complaint alone that the conduct, if proved, would not justify criminal or disciplinary proceedings.

Where referral is required under the provisions that correspond to paragraph 4(1)(a) or (b) of Schedule 3 to the Police Reform Act 2002, it must be made without delay and in any event not later than the end of the day following the day on which it becomes clear that the complaint is one to which that duty applies. The guidance that determines what counts as a serious assault, a serious sexual offence or serious corruption was not a document read for this article. The regulation itself is. A reader should not treat every gross misconduct allegation as an automatic Director General case, and should not treat the absence of a referral as proof that the allegation is minor. The duty depends on the description in regulation 4, not on the single word “gross”.

This account was prepared by a Paris law firm as general information on the law of England and Wales. It does not replace the notice, the investigator’s report or the decision in any individual case.

II. From the notice to the outcome, the appeal and the barred list

A. The hearing, the accelerated route, suspension and the available outcomes

Once an investigator is appointed, regulation 17 requires a written notice to the officer, as soon as reasonably practicable, subject to the harm test and to a limited exception. The notice must state the conduct that is the subject matter of the allegation and how that conduct is alleged to fall below the Standards. It must state that there is to be an investigation and identify the investigator. It must state the result of the severity assessment, and the result of any assessment of whether proceedings would likely be a meeting or a hearing. It must state that if the officer is dismissed, information including the officer’s full name and a description of the conduct which led to dismissal will be added to the police barred list and may be subject to publication for a period of up to five years. It must state the right to seek advice from the officer’s staff association or any other body, and the effect of the police-friend and representation rules. It must also state that whilst the officer does not have to say anything it may harm the officer’s case if the officer does not mention, when interviewed or when providing information under the stated regulations, something later relied on in any disciplinary proceedings.

That last sentence is a disciplinary caution, not a criminal caution. It sits inside the Conduct Regulations. A detective who is both a suspect in a criminal investigation and the officer concerned in a disciplinary investigation has two different processes. The disciplinary notice does not replace the criminal process, and the criminal process does not replace the notice. The harm test can limit what is given. Where it applies, the officer may not receive every document at the first step. The regulation still requires the notice itself, subject to the stated exceptions.

On receipt of the investigator’s report, regulation 23 requires the appropriate authority, as soon as practicable, to determine whether the officer has a case to answer in respect of misconduct or gross misconduct, or has no case to answer; if there is a case to answer, whether misconduct proceedings should be brought; and if so, what form they should take. The form is not left open once gross misconduct is the assessment. Where the authority determines to refer the case to misconduct proceedings, having determined that the officer concerned has a case to answer in respect of gross misconduct, those proceedings must be a misconduct hearing. The same regulation requires a hearing, rather than a meeting, where the officer had a final written warning in force at the date of the severity assessment, and where the officer has been reduced in rank under the 2004 or 2020 Conduct Regulations less than two years before that assessment. Where there is a case to answer in respect of misconduct and none of those hearing triggers applies, the proceedings must be a misconduct meeting.

The distinction is structural. A misconduct meeting determines whether the conduct amounts to misconduct or not, and if it does, what disciplinary action should be imposed. A misconduct hearing determines whether the conduct amounts to misconduct, gross misconduct or neither, and if it amounts to either, what disciplinary action should be imposed. Gross misconduct is not determined at a meeting. A reader who has been told that a detective “faces a meeting” has been told, if the Regulations are being applied, that the case to answer was not assessed as gross misconduct and that the warning and rank triggers for a hearing were not met. A reader who has been told that the case is gross misconduct should expect a hearing, unless the accelerated route below is certified instead.

For an officer other than a senior officer, regulation 28 requires the hearing to be conducted by a panel of three persons. A senior officer, in regulation 2, is a member of a police force holding a rank above that of chief superintendent. A detective is a designation, not that rank. Unless the officer in fact holds a rank above chief superintendent, the non-senior panel applies. In the text substituted from 7 May 2024, and subject to the delegation power in regulation 2(4A), the panel comprises a chair, who must be the chief officer of police of the police force concerned, and two persons appointed by the local policing body. The chief officer may delegate the responsibility for chairing the hearing to a senior officer, to a former senior officer who last served as a senior officer no more than five years before the delegation, or, unless the case substantially involves operational policing matters, to a police staff member whom the chief officer considers to be of at least a similar level of seniority to a senior officer. One of those two must have qualifications or experience relevant to disciplinary proceedings. The other need not. Both must be lay persons within the meaning set out in paragraph 10(aa) of Schedule 6 to the Police Act 1996, and both must be selected on a fair and transparent basis from the lists maintained for that purpose. A legally qualified person is appointed by the local policing body as an adviser to the chair and the panel, and must give advice on legal or procedural issues when the chair requests it. The panel must have regard to that advice. The adviser is appointed in addition to the panel of three. The regulation requires the panel to have regard to the advice. It does not describe the adviser as a member of the panel. At a panel, any decision must be based on a majority, and must not indicate whether it was unanimous or by a majority.

The officer may object to a panel member other than the chair. The objection must be in writing to the chair before the end of three working days beginning with the first working day after the officer is given notice of the person’s name, and it must set out the grounds. The chair notifies the officer whether the objection is upheld or rejected. If it is upheld, the person is replaced. A further notice and a further objection route then apply to the replacement. These are procedural rights. They are not a right to choose the panel.

Subject to the exclusion power, a misconduct hearing must be in public. The regulation states the rule in these words: Subject to paragraph (3), a misconduct hearing must be in public. A misconduct meeting, by contrast, must be in private, subject to the attendance rules for the Director General, the investigator, a complainant and interested persons. The chair of a hearing may exclude a person from all or part of the hearing, impose conditions on attendance, and give directions prohibiting publication of any matter, after considering representations. Public notification of the hearing is not automatic in the sense that every detail must be posted. Regulation 36 allows the chair to require notice containing the officer’s name, the date, time and place, and the conduct alleged. Where the chair requires that notice, the authority must publish it on its website as soon as practicable after the hearing notice is given under regulation 35. A reader who cannot find a public notice has not, from that fact alone, established that the hearing is unlawful. The chair may not have required notice, or a reporting restriction may apply. Equally, the absence of a notice is not a reason to invent the facts of the case.

The finding rule is in regulation 41. The persons conducting the proceedings must not find that the conduct amounts to misconduct or gross misconduct unless they are satisfied on the balance of probabilities that this is the case, or the officer admits it. The balance of probabilities is the civil standard stated in the regulation. It is not the criminal standard. An admission removes the need for that satisfaction. An admission also has a later effect on appeal, noted below. The finding and the outcome are separate steps. A finding of gross misconduct does not, by itself, type the sanction. Regulation 42 then requires disciplinary action to be imposed where the finding is misconduct or gross misconduct, subject to the limits in that regulation.

At a misconduct meeting, the available actions are a written warning or a final written warning. At a misconduct hearing, if the finding is misconduct, the available actions are a written warning, a final written warning, and, where a further paragraph applies, reduction in rank or dismissal without notice. Those further paragraphs apply where a final written warning was in force on the date of the severity assessment, or where the misconduct finding is based on conduct arising from more than one incident and those incidents are not closely factually connected. If a written warning was already in force at the severity assessment, a written warning must not be given. If a final written warning was already in force, neither a written warning nor a final written warning may be given.

If the finding at a hearing is gross misconduct, the current text of regulation 42(3)(b), substituted from 28 May 2025, makes dismissal without notice the primary action. The alternative is available only if the person or persons conducting the misconduct proceedings are satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances which justify it. In that case the action may be a final written warning or reduction in rank. The regulation does not define exceptional circumstances. It requires the panel to be satisfied that they exist before it steps down from dismissal without notice. A reader should not treat dismissal as inevitable in every gross misconduct finding, and should not treat a final written warning after a gross misconduct finding as the ordinary result. The ordinary result, on the words of the regulation, is dismissal without notice, unless that satisfaction is reached.

Disciplinary action under regulation 42(3) has effect from the date on which it is notified to the officer. A written warning remains in force for 18 months beginning with the day it was notified. A final written warning remains in force for two years beginning with that day. Where a final written warning is given under paragraph (3), that two-year period may be extended to a maximum of five years. Time on a career break under the Police Regulations does not count. Reduction in rank may be imposed only where the persons imposing it consider it an appropriate sanction, taking into account the views of the appropriate authority or the originating authority, including on the likely operational impact. If the officer had already been reduced in rank under the 2004 or 2020 Conduct Regulations on the date of the severity assessment, a further reduction in rank may not be imposed.

There is a faster route. Regulation 49 allows the appropriate authority, after the investigator’s report, to determine whether the special conditions are satisfied, but not on or after the date of a misconduct meeting or hearing once the case has been referred to ordinary proceedings. The special conditions are two. First, there is sufficient evidence, in the form of written statements or other documents, to establish on the balance of probabilities that the conduct of the officer concerned constitutes gross misconduct. Second, it is in the public interest for the officer concerned to cease to be a member of a police force or a special constable without delay. If the authority determines that both conditions are satisfied, then unless it considers the circumstances such as to make certification inappropriate, it must certify the case and, subject to the criminal-prejudice bar, refer it to an accelerated misconduct hearing. If the conditions are not satisfied, or certification is inappropriate, the case returns to the investigator if the investigation was incomplete, or otherwise proceeds under Part 4. An accelerated misconduct hearing must also be in public, subject to the exclusion power in regulation 59.

The officer concerned has the right to be legally represented, by a relevant lawyer of the officer’s choice, at a misconduct hearing or an accelerated misconduct hearing. The unavailability of one or more preferred lawyers is not a valid ground for delaying the hearing where an alternative relevant lawyer can be found. If the officer chooses not to be legally represented, the officer may still be dismissed or receive any other outcome under regulation 42 or 62. At a meeting, or where the officer does not choose legal representation at a hearing, representation is by a police friend only. The authority may be represented by an officer or a police staff member, and at a hearing or accelerated hearing by a relevant lawyer, whether or not the officer chooses to be represented.

Suspension is not the same thing as a finding. Regulation 11, in the text substituted from 13 July 2026, requires the appropriate authority to suspend the officer if the suspension condition is met and the officer is not already suspended. The condition is that the effective investigation may be prejudiced unless the officer is suspended, or that the public interest otherwise requires suspension. When deciding whether the condition is met, the authority must consider whether temporary redeployment to alternative duties or an alternative location is an appropriate alternative. Suspension under this regulation must be with pay. It is effective from notification, which must be in writing with a summary of the reasons, or oral with written confirmation before the end of three working days beginning with the first working day after the suspension. An officer who is suspended remains a police officer for the purposes of these Regulations and the Vetting Regulations.

A separate rule applies where the officer is charged with a relevant offence. Regulation 11C(5) defines a relevant offence as an offence listed in Schedule 3, or an attempt or conspiracy to commit a listed offence. Schedule 3, inserted from 13 July 2026, lists specified offences. They include possession of an indecent photograph of a child, specified stalking offences, forced-marriage offences, offences under the Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003, sexual offences under Part 1 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 and the related breach and Schedule 3 provisions named in the list, specified image and grooming offences, the offence of breaching a stalking protection order, and specified offences under the Domestic Abuse Act 2021. The list is the Schedule. It is not a general category of “any serious crime”. Regulation 11F then deals with charge. Where the officer was not already suspended, and had been given the written notice before the day of charge, the officer is automatically suspended from the date and time of notification of the charge, and the authority must notify the officer of that suspension without delay and in any event before the end of the first working day after the suspension. That suspension continues until the officer ceases to be charged because the criminal proceedings are discontinued or the officer is found not guilty. Paragraphs (2) and (3) of regulation 11 apply, so the suspension remains with pay and the officer remains a police officer for these Regulations.

A charge with an offence that is not on Schedule 3 does not, by that fact alone, trigger regulation 11F. Arrest or questioning under caution for a non-listed offence can still engage a domestic-abuse assessment under regulation 11E, which applies the relevant-offence machinery where the authority assesses that the conduct would, if proved, amount to domestic abuse within section 1 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021. Other allegations remain under the ordinary suspension condition. A reader should separate three questions that the Regulations separate: whether the officer is suspended, whether there is a case to answer, and whether gross misconduct is proved.

B. The appeal, the barred list, and the documents that decide the case

A finding at a hearing is not the last statutory step. Rule 4 of the Police Appeals Tribunals Rules 2020 allows a police officer to appeal to a tribunal against a finding made under the Conduct Regulations, and against any decision to impose disciplinary action in consequence of that finding, on the grounds in that rule. For an officer other than a senior officer, the findings that open the appeal are a finding of misconduct or gross misconduct at a misconduct hearing, and a finding of gross misconduct at an accelerated misconduct hearing. A senior officer has a wider meeting route, which does not change the position of a detective who is not a senior officer. A former officer has a parallel appeal under rule 6 against a finding of misconduct or gross misconduct at a misconduct hearing, and against a finding of gross misconduct at an accelerated misconduct hearing.

There is a hard limit. A police officer may not appeal to a tribunal against such a finding where that finding was made following acceptance by the officer that the officer’s conduct amounted to misconduct or gross misconduct. The same bar applies to a former officer who accepted the conduct. An admission at the hearing can therefore close the tribunal route against the finding. It is a reason to treat the admission, and the record of whether the finding followed that acceptance, as a document that matters.

Where the appeal is open, the grounds are narrow. They are that the finding or decision to impose disciplinary action was unreasonable; that there is evidence that could not reasonably have been considered at the original hearing which could have materially affected the finding or decision; or that there was a breach of the procedures set out in the Conduct Regulations, the Complaints and Misconduct Regulations or Part 2 of the Police Reform Act 2002, or unfairness, which could have materially affected the finding or decision. The Rules do not create a fresh hearing of every fact because the officer disagrees with the panel. The ground has to be unreasonableness, new evidence that could not reasonably have been considered and that could have materially affected the result, or a procedural breach or unfairness with that same material effect.

The time limit is short. Subject to the out-of-time rule, a police officer or a former police officer who wishes to appeal must give notice of the appeal before the end of 10 working days beginning with the first working day after the day on which the officer is first supplied with a written copy of the relevant decision. The notice must be in writing to the relevant local policing body. The officer may request a transcript in that notice. After the 10 working days, notice may still be given within a reasonable time, but it must be accompanied by the reasons why it was not given in time and the reasons for the view that it has been given within a reasonable time. The chair must then determine whether it was reasonably practicable to give notice in time, and whether the later notice was given within a reasonable time. If the chair determines either that it was reasonably practicable for the notice to be given within that period, or that the notice has not been given within a reasonable time after the end of that period, rule 10(5) requires that the appeal must be dismissed. Where the appeal is not dismissed on that ground, rule 10(6) requires the appeal to proceed.

The chair determines whether an appeal that has not been dismissed should be dealt with at a hearing. The chair may determine that it should be dealt with without a hearing only if the appellant has consented. Where there is a hearing, the chair must cause written notice of the date, time and place to be given at least 20 working days before the hearing, or such shorter period as both parties agree. Either party may apply for disclosure of a document relevant to the appeal. A party who does not comply must give reasons for non-disclosure in writing. These are the procedural landmarks. They are not a promise that any particular appeal will succeed.

Dismissal, or a finding that a former officer would have been dismissed, has a consequence outside the hearing room. The barred-list Regulations require the relevant authority, where it must report a person to the College under section 88A(1) of the Police Act 1996, to do so before the end of five working days beginning with the date of the relevant dismissal or the relevant finding. The report must include the person’s full name, the police force concerned, the date of birth, whether the person was an officer, a former officer or a civilian employee, the rank and any warrant or identification number, a description of the conduct which led to the dismissal or finding, any Standard breached, and the date of the dismissal or finding. Regulation 4 of those Regulations then requires that information to be included in the barred list.

Publication is a further step, and it is not universal. Regulation 10 applies section 88G to a person included in the barred list by a report under section 88A(1)(a) or (b) where, for a report under (a), the person was dismissed at proceedings under the Police (Conduct) Regulations 2020, or, for a report under (b), the relevant finding was made at proceedings under those Regulations. The College must publish specified information no later than the last working day of the month following the month of inclusion. The specified information is the subset identified in regulation 10(2), not every field in the report. The College must not publish any of that information if to do so would be against the interests of national security, might prejudice the investigation or prosecution of a criminal offence or any civil proceedings, or would result in a significant risk of harm to any person (including the person listed). In considering that bar, the College must have regard, among other things, to information included in the report for that purpose and to the extent to which the information has already been made public.

The publication is not permanent by default. Regulation 11 defines the required period as the period for which the College is required to publish the specified information under section 88G(3)(c), ending on the date five years after the date on which that information was first published by the College under section 88G(2). If the College removes the person from the barred list, it must cease to publish all of the specified information. It must also cease publication if continued publication would have one of the harms in regulation 11(2), and it must do so before the end of five working days after that determination. A review can be prompted by a matter that comes to the College’s attention, including representations in a written statement under the Appeals Rules.

Removal from the list on the person’s own application is not immediate. The relevant minimum period, in regulation 7, is three years where the person was reported under section 88A(1)(a) or (c) and the reason for dismissal related to a finding that performance constituted gross incompetence. In any other case, including a conduct dismissal, the relevant minimum period means five years. Gross incompetence has the meaning given in the Performance Regulations. A conduct dismissal is the “any other case”. The five-year publication period and the five-year minimum period before an application for removal are related but not identical. One governs how long specified information stays published. The other governs when the person may apply to be removed from the list itself.

A reader who wants to test a real case, rather than the general rules, has a short list of documents. The written notice should identify the conduct and the Standard allegedly breached, and it should state the severity assessment. The investigator’s report, subject to the harm test, is the basis for the case-to-answer decision. The referral notice should show whether the case was sent to a meeting, a hearing or an accelerated hearing. If the case was certified for the accelerated route, the special conditions should be identifiable: written evidence capable of establishing gross misconduct on the balance of probabilities, and the public-interest condition about ceasing to be a member without delay. The outcome decision should state the finding, whether it followed an admission, and, if gross misconduct was found and dismissal without notice was not imposed, whether the panel was satisfied that exceptional circumstances justified a final written warning or reduction in rank. The date the written decision was first supplied starts the 10-working-day appeal count. The report to the College, if dismissal followed, should have been made within five working days, and publication, if it occurs, is subject to the harms bar and to the five-year required period.

What those documents do not do is establish the facts of a case that has not been read. An allegation is not a finding. A suspension is not a finding. A referral to the Director General is not a finding. A public notice of a hearing is not a finding. The Regulations require the panel, or the person conducting an accelerated hearing, to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities, or to have an admission, before misconduct or gross misconduct is found. Until that step, the conduct remains alleged. After that step, the finding is the finding recorded in the decision, not the finding repeated in a search query.

Conclusion

In England and Wales, a detective who is a member of a police force is a police officer for the Conduct Regulations. Gross misconduct means a breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour so serious as to justify dismissal, and a conviction for an indictable-only offence is taken, inside those Regulations, to constitute such a breach. A case to answer on gross misconduct must go to a misconduct hearing, which must be in public unless an exclusion is ordered, unless the accelerated route is certified because the special conditions are met. The ordinary outcome of a gross misconduct finding at a hearing is dismissal without notice, unless the panel is satisfied that exceptional circumstances justify a final written warning or reduction in rank. The finding is made on the balance of probabilities, or by admission.

A non-senior officer may appeal a hearing finding, and a gross misconduct finding at an accelerated hearing, within 10 working days of being supplied with the written decision, on the three grounds in the Appeals Rules, and not where the finding followed acceptance of the conduct. Dismissal can lead to a report to the College of Policing within five working days, inclusion on the barred list, and publication of specified information for a required period that ends five years after first publication, subject to the harms bar. None of those rules describes a particular officer or a particular force. The facts of any individual allegation remain to be established by the notices and the decision in that case, read against the revised text in force on the day of the decision.

📄 Official circular