KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Theft: what does a pending felony charge mean for a newly elected House member?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Theft: what does a pending felony charge mean for a newly elected House member?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

News reports published on November 5, 2026, described a winning candidate for the United States House of Representatives who still faces a pending state felony charge. That report raises a precise federal question, and it is not whether the underlying accusation is true. A charge is an allegation that a court has not yet decided. The seating question is different: what does a pending charge do, by itself, to a duly elected person’s right to take a House seat?

The short answer from the federal texts and decisions read for this guide is that a pending charge does not add a fourth qualification for House service. The Constitution lists age, citizenship and inhabitancy qualifications for Representatives. The House judges the elections, returns and qualifications of its own members, and it may punish or, by two thirds, expel a member after seating. Those are separate steps. A state criminal case continues under state law in state court, whatever the House does about seating or discipline.

The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about any candidate’s situation. Start with three documents: the certified election result, the constitutional qualifications, and any House resolution that actually concerns seating or discipline. Then read the state charging record for what it is: the start of a criminal case, not a judgment, and not a House vote.

I. Can a newly elected House member with a pending felony charge be seated?

A. Start with the certified election and the three qualifications in Article I

The federal starting point is the text that creates the office. Article I, Section 2, Clause 2 of the United States Constitution provides that no person shall be a Representative who has not reached twenty five years of age, has not been seven years a citizen of the United States, and is not, when elected, an inhabitant of the state in which the person is chosen. The clause states three qualifications. It does not state a clean-record qualification, and it does not say that a person facing an undecided criminal charge cannot be chosen. That silence is the textual fact from which the decided cases begin.

A reader checking a real House race should therefore begin with evidence that answers the textual questions. Was the person duly elected, as shown by the competent election authority’s return or certificate? Does the person meet the age and citizenship qualifications stated in the clause? Was the person, when elected, an inhabitant of the state from which the person was chosen? A news report about a charge answers none of those three questions. It belongs in a different file: the criminal case file, where the issues are the charged offense, the evidence, and the judgment, if any, that a court later enters.

In Powell v. McCormack, 395 U.S. 486 (1969), decided June 16, 1969, the Supreme Court of the United States held that the House had unlawfully excluded a duly elected member-elect whom the House itself found met the standing qualifications of age, citizenship and residence in Article I, Section 2. For a member-elect, the practical point is to separate the seating question from later discipline: Powell treats exclusion as a check on the election and the standing qualifications, not as a substitute punishment vote. In United States v. Rahimi, No. 22-915 (June 21, 2024), decided June 21, 2024, the Supreme Court of the United States included a concurring opinion that cited Powell v. McCormack, 395 U.S. 486, at 546–547, for the proposition that constitutional text controls over contrary history; Rahimi decided a firearms question and did not revisit House exclusion.

The distinction Powell draws is between exclusion and expulsion. Exclusion is the refusal to seat a member-elect. Expulsion is the removal of a member who has been seated. A report by the Congressional Research Service, Expulsion of Members of Congress: Legal Authority and Historical Practice, updated November 7, 2023, explains the same division: exclusion concerns whether a member-elect will be seated at all, while expulsion removes a member after the member has been duly elected and seated, and the report notes that the Supreme Court has held that exclusion cannot be used as a disciplinary tool. The report is a research summary by a legislative support agency, not a court decision. Its value here is organizational. It keeps the reader from merging two procedures that the constitutional text and Powell treat at different moments.

Applied to a pending charge, that division produces a concrete first check. If the dispute is only about seating, ask what election return the House has before it and which of the three stated qualifications is said to fail. A pending charge, without more, is not one of the three. If the dispute is really about fitness, candor or alleged misconduct, Powell points away from exclusion and toward the House’s later disciplinary powers, which Section II below examines. Labels matter. Calling a vote an exclusion does not give it the effect of an expulsion, and calling disapproval a qualification does not write that qualification into Article I.

Powell also carries a limit that a careful reader should keep in view. The case decided the exclusion of a particular member-elect whom the House found met the standing qualifications, after a House investigation into expenditures and related conduct. It did not hold that every later House decision about a member is subject to the same rule, and it did not decide any criminal case. The criminal question in a state prosecution remains for the court that has that case. Powell answers who decides the seating question and by what measure. It does not answer whether charged conduct occurred.

B. A state charge does not add a fourth federal qualification

The next question is whether a state can supply the missing qualification that Article I does not state. A state plainly has its own criminal law, and a state court can decide a state charge. That power over the criminal case is not the same as a power to set the conditions for service in the United States House of Representatives. The Supreme Court addressed state-added conditions for congressional service in the term-limits litigation that followed Powell.

In U. S. Term Limits, Inc. v. Thornton, 514 U.S. 779 (1995), decided May 22, 1995, the Supreme Court of the United States held that an Arkansas ballot-access rule for long-serving members of Congress was an added qualification and reaffirmed that the qualifications in the Constitution are fixed and may not be supplemented by Congress or by the States. For a pending state charge, Thornton directs the reader to ask whether a state rule is being used as an extra condition on federal service, rather than as the criminal law governing the charge itself. In Watson v. Republican National Committee, No. 24-1260 (June 29, 2026), decided June 29, 2026, the Supreme Court of the United States quoted U. S. Term Limits, Inc. v. Thornton, 514 U.S. 779, at 833, for Congress’s power to override state choices on congressional election mechanics; Watson decided a ballot-counting question and added no qualification for House service.

Thornton does not disable a state prosecution. It separates two state roles. As prosecutor, a state applies its criminal statutes to conduct charged under those statutes, and its courts decide guilt or innocence under state procedures and federal constitutional limits that govern criminal cases. As regulator of federal office, a state runs into Thornton when its rule operates as an additional condition that a person must satisfy to serve in Congress beyond the qualifications the federal Constitution states. A pending charge sits in the first role. Treating the mere existence of that charge as a federal disqualification would move it into the second role, and that is the move Thornton forbids for state-added qualifications.

A more recent eligibility decision shows the same need to identify who enforces a federal disqualification and under what text. In Trump v. Anderson, 601 U.S. 100 (2024), decided March 4, 2024, the Supreme Court of the United States reversed a state court order that would have kept a presidential candidate off a state primary ballot under Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment, holding that the Constitution makes Congress, rather than the States, responsible for enforcing Section 3 against federal officeholders and candidates. Anderson did not decide any theft charge or any House seating dispute; its use here is narrower, to show that a state eligibility ruling does not by itself settle who may hold federal office. In United States v. Rahimi, No. 22-915 (June 21, 2024), decided June 21, 2024, the Supreme Court of the United States included a concurring opinion that cited Trump v. Anderson, 601 U.S. 100, at 113–115, as an example of reliance on post-ratification history; that citation addressed interpretive method and did not extend Anderson to criminal charges.

Anderson should not be overstated. Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment is a specific disqualification text, with its own history and its own enforcement provision in Section 5 of that Amendment. A state theft charge is not Section 3, and Anderson does not convert every state criminal allegation into a federal eligibility case. The decision matters here for method. Before treating any state ruling as the end of a federal candidacy, identify the exact federal text said to disqualify, the institution that text charges with enforcement, and the judgment, if any, that has actually been entered. If there is no such text and no such judgment, the state case remains a state case.

State constitutional texts make the same point from the other side, as long as their scope is stated accurately. In North Carolina, for example, Article VI, Section 8 of the North Carolina Constitution lists persons disqualified for office and includes, in its third category, a person who has been adjudged guilty of treason or another felony and has not been restored to the rights of citizenship in the manner prescribed by law. The operative words are adjudged guilty. A charge that a court has not yet decided is not an adjudication of guilt in the language of that state text. The example is a North Carolina rule for the offices it governs. Under Thornton, a state disqualification text cannot be used to supplement the federal qualifications for the United States House of Representatives. It still teaches a useful reading habit: check whether the text under discussion requires a charge, a conviction, or something else, and do not substitute one for the other.

That reading habit resolves a common confusion in election-week reporting. The statement that a candidate faces a felony charge and the statement that a candidate has been convicted of a felony describe different legal events, proved by different records, with different consequences under different texts. The first is proved, if at all, by a charging instrument and a docket showing a pending case. The second requires a judgment. For House seating, Powell and Thornton keep the inquiry on the election return and the three federal qualifications. For the criminal case, only the court hearing the charge can produce the judgment that later texts, including House conduct rules discussed below, may take into account.

II. What can happen after seating, and what should be checked in the state case?

A. After the oath, discipline follows House rules and a two-thirds expulsion vote

Seating is not approval, and it is not immunity from House discipline. Article I, Section 5 of the United States Constitution provides in Clause 1 that each House shall be the judge of the elections, returns and qualifications of its own members. Clause 2 then provides that each House may determine the rules of its proceedings, punish its members for disorderly behaviour, and, with the concurrence of two thirds, expel a member. The order of those clauses tracks the order Powell enforced. Qualifications are judged at the threshold. Punishment and expulsion concern a member, under House rules, after the threshold has been crossed.

The House’s own historical list shows how rarely the most severe step has been taken and how much the stated ground matters. The list of individuals expelled, censured or reprimanded maintained by the Office of the Historian of the United States House of Representatives records that Michael J. Myers was expelled on October 2, 1980, after a bribery conviction, by a vote of 376 to 30, and that James A. Traficant was expelled on July 24, 2002, after convictions that the list summarizes as conspiracy to commit bribery, defrauding the United States, receipt of illegal gratuities, obstruction of justice, filing false tax returns and racketeering, by a vote of 420 to 1, with 9 present. The same list records a different sequence for George Santos, expelled on December 1, 2023, by a vote of 311 to 114, with 2 present, under a resolution that the list summarizes by reference to a federal indictment and to conduct described in the expulsion resolution itself. Santos was a seated member when the House acted. The list therefore does not show that an undecided charge keeps a member-elect out at the threshold. It shows the House using its post-seating disciplinary power, by the required vote, on grounds the House chose to state in a resolution.

Between seating and any expulsion vote, committee practice also matters. The manual published by the House Committee on Ethics, in its section on refraining from legislative activity after conviction, recalls a stated committee policy for statutory-violation allegations: where the charges are known to and are being acted upon by the appropriate authorities, the policy has been to defer action until the judicial proceedings have run their course, rather than undertake duplicative investigations while a judicial resolution is pending. The same passage reserves a different course where the allegation is abuse of a direct representational or legislative position. A policy of deferral is not a constitutional qualification and it is not a judgment in the criminal case. It is a House committee practice, stated by the committee itself, and a reader should check whether the committee has actually opened a matter, deferred it, or reported a resolution, instead of assuming any of those steps from the existence of a charge.

The Congressional Research Service report cited in Section I adds a caution that debate often omits. It observes that the only explicit standards it identifies for expulsion are the supermajority voting requirement and that the person expelled has been formally seated, while the proper grounds for expulsion for conduct that arose before an election have been debated, with institutional integrity on one side and the choice of the constituents on the other. The report is not a court decision and it does not settle that debate. For a voter, a journalist or a member-elect, the practical consequence is modest and important: do not treat expulsion as automatic, and do not treat seating as a ruling that no discipline can follow. Each step needs its own House record: the oath and seating, any committee action, the text of any resolution, and the vote count the Constitution requires for expulsion.

None of this gives a court the House’s disciplinary vote, and none of it gives the House the court’s verdict. A House resolution can state institutional grounds. It cannot enter a criminal judgment. A criminal judgment can resolve the charged offense under state law. It does not, by the texts read here, itself cast the two-thirds vote that Article I, Section 5 requires for expulsion. Keeping those institutions apart is not a formality. It is how a reader knows which public record to demand next.

B. The criminal case, and any conviction, follow a separate track

The state track begins with the state’s own definition of the charged offense. Theft offenses are creatures of state statute in a case of this kind, and their grading turns on what the applicable statute actually says. In North Carolina, North Carolina General Statute Section 14-72 provides in subsection (a) that larceny of goods of the value of more than one thousand dollars is a Class H felony, that receiving or possessing stolen goods of that value with the stated knowledge is also a Class H felony, and that, outside the felony categories the section lists, larceny or receiving or possession where the value is not more than one thousand dollars is a Class 1 misdemeanor. The section then lists categories in which larceny is a felony without regard to value. That is a North Carolina grading rule for the offenses it covers. It does not define a qualification for Congress, it does not prove that any particular charge was filed under that section, and it does not decide the value or the conduct in any person’s case. Those matters are proved, if at all, from the charging instrument and the evidence in the court where the charge is pending.

A useful check of the state record is therefore documentary. Identify the court, the case number and the exact statutory section charged. Read whether the instrument alleges each element that the cited section requires, including any value allegation where value controls the grade under that section. Note what the record does not yet contain: until a court enters a judgment, there is no adjudication of guilt to carry into other texts that use adjudication or conviction language. Campaign statements, opponent advertising and news summaries can point a reader toward the record. They are not substitutes for it, and a careful account attributes any allegation to the instrument that makes it.

If a conviction later occurs, a different House text becomes relevant, and its terms should be read exactly. The Ethics Committee manual section already cited quotes clause 10 of House Rule 23, under which a member, delegate or resident commissioner who has been convicted by a court of record of a crime for which a sentence of two or more years of imprisonment may be imposed should refrain from participation in the business of each committee of which the person is a member, and a member should refrain from voting on any question at a meeting of the House or of the Committee of the Whole House, unless or until later judicial or executive proceedings reinstate the presumption of innocence or the member is reelected after the conviction date stated in the rule. Three features of that language control its use. It begins with a conviction by a court of record, not with a charge. It asks about the sentence that may be imposed for the crime, in the words the rule uses, not only about a sentence already served. And it states what the member should refrain from doing; it is a House conduct rule, enforced through House processes, not a state court judgment and not an expulsion vote by itself.

The manual’s application example confirms that sequence. It recounts that the committee cited the rule in 2002 in a public letter following a member’s conviction in a federal district court on ten felony counts related to public corruption, advising that violation would risk disciplinary action in addition to proceedings connected with the convictions. Whatever a reader thinks of that history, the order is clear in the sources read here: charge, then court judgment if the prosecution proves its case, then the House conduct rule that speaks in terms of conviction, and separately any House decision about punishment or expulsion after seating. Reversing that order, by treating a pending charge as if it were a conviction, misstates every text in the chain.

There is also a federalism check that should be made before importing any state consequence into House service. North Carolina’s Article VI disqualification language, discussed in Section I, speaks of a person adjudged guilty of a felony. House Rule 23 speaks of a person convicted by a court of record. Article I of the federal Constitution speaks of age, citizenship and inhabitancy for Representatives, and of House punishment and two-thirds expulsion for members. Each text has its own trigger and its own institution. A state judgment can supply the trigger that a state text or a House rule expressly requires. It does not rewrite the federal qualifications clause, for the reason Thornton gave, and a House rule does not amend a state criminal statute. The correct question at each step is which text is being applied, by whom, on what record.

For the member-elect, the practical file is therefore short to describe and exacting to keep. Keep the certificate or return that shows the election result. Keep proof that answers the three federal qualifications. Keep the complete state court record, including the charging instrument, every order, and any judgment, without relying on summaries of it. Keep every House document in its own sequence: seating and oath records, committee notices, and the text and vote on any disciplinary resolution. When a public claim mixes those files, for example by treating an allegation in a charging instrument as a House finding, or a House debate as a criminal verdict, the files themselves supply the correction.

Conclusion

A pending felony theft charge does not, by itself, keep a duly elected person who meets the three qualifications in Article I, Section 2 from being seated in the House of Representatives, under the federal texts and decisions read here. Powell reserves exclusion for the election and those qualifications. Thornton bars Congress and the States from supplementing them. Anderson, in a different disqualification setting, confirms the need to identify the federal text and the enforcing institution before a state ruling is treated as decisive for federal office.

After seating, the questions change and so do the decision makers. The House may apply its own rules, its committees may defer or proceed under their stated policies, and expulsion requires the concurrence of two thirds under Article I, Section 5. The state court alone decides the criminal charge, and House conduct language that turns on a conviction applies only when the record contains the conviction it describes. Seating is not exoneration. A charge is not a judgment. Each institution must do its own work, on its own record, before either result can be stated as fact.

📄 Official circular