KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
UEFA’s Planned Criminal Complaint Against Infantino: How Swiss Proceedings Could Use French and U.S. Evidence

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

UEFA’s Planned Criminal Complaint Against Infantino: How Swiss Proceedings Could Use French and U.S. Evidence

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

UEFA’s dispute with FIFA over the abandoned FIFA Forward Enterprise has moved from football governance into cross-border evidence gathering. Public reporting on 27 August 2026 said that UEFA was preparing a possible criminal complaint in Switzerland concerning the way the proposed vehicle was conceived, valued and approved, with FIFA President Gianni Infantino and other officials potentially in scope. At the same time, UEFA sought documents and testimony from United States entities under the federal discovery mechanism used to support proceedings abroad. That is a significant development, but it is not yet a conviction, a finding of mismanagement, or even confirmation that a Swiss prosecutor has opened a case. The practical question for French organisations, directors, banks, advisers and witnesses is narrower and more useful: what can be preserved, requested or challenged when the potentially decisive records are split between Switzerland, the United States and France? This analysis separates the political controversy from the legal proof. It explains the Swiss criminal-law theory identified in the filings, the limits of U.S. discovery, the French pre-action evidence tools under the Code of Civil Procedure, and the mutual-assistance route between France and Switzerland. It also identifies the standing, privilege, data and chain-of-custody issues that can determine whether an apparently explosive file becomes admissible evidence or remains only a public allegation.

I. What UEFA’s Swiss complaint means after the FIFA Forward Enterprise collapse

A. What happened, and what has not happened yet

The story concerns the FIFA Forward Enterprise, commonly referred to as FFE. On 28 July, FIFA presented the proposal as a FIFA-owned and controlled subsidiary that would place commercial and operational event-delivery activities in a separate vehicle. FIFA’s public materials described a financing structure of up to 4.2 billion dollars, an initial equity valuation of approximately 20 billion dollars, and a plan that required approval by a majority of FIFA’s 211 member associations as well as the FIFA Council. FIFA described the initiative as a way to increase football-development funding while retaining control over the commercial platform.

The official FIFA announcement is important because it establishes the project’s formal status. It was a proposal subject to approvals, not a completed sale of FIFA’s assets or an executed transfer of future World Cup profits. FIFA later said that “this proposal will not proceed” after criticism and consultation. That language does not answer the governance questions raised by UEFA, but it does prevent a common analytical error: treating the abandoned plan as though the transaction had closed and the alleged loss were already fixed.

UEFA’s response was institutional as well as legal. In its public statement of 27 August, European national-association representatives said they had unanimously mandated UEFA leadership to pursue political, institutional and legal avenues. UEFA also referred to an independent external review with access to relevant documents, and described the FFE as “irrevocably and permanently withdrawn.” The statement reflects a serious governance conflict inside European football. It is not, by itself, a judicial decision or a criminal complaint accepted by a Swiss authority.

Associated Press reported that UEFA lawyers were preparing a possible Swiss criminal proceeding over alleged financial mismanagement and had made applications in United States courts to obtain evidence. One application was directed at FIFA-related entities in the Southern District of Florida. Another application in Manhattan sought material connected with Thrive Capital Management, Joshua Kushner and the proposed investment structure. Reuters separately reported that UEFA was asking for testimony and documents concerning how the transaction was conceived, structured, valued and approved. Those applications are therefore evidence-seeking measures. They do not establish that Infantino, FIFA or any adviser committed an offence, and they do not mean that a Swiss prosecutor has adopted UEFA’s theory.

The distinction matters for every person handling the file. A public accusation, an internal mandate, a U.S. discovery order and a Swiss criminal investigation are four different procedural events. They have different thresholds, different decision-makers and different consequences. The United States judge deciding a discovery application is not deciding whether Swiss criminal law was violated. A Swiss prosecutor considering a complaint is not bound by UEFA’s press statement. An external review commissioned by a sports body can locate documents, but it cannot replace a judicial finding about intent, loss or causation.

The public record also leaves open the future venue in Switzerland. Depending on the facts, the matter could involve the federal prosecution service or a cantonal authority, and jurisdiction may turn on the entity involved, the acts alleged, the location of the conduct and the applicable Swiss rules. The phrase “Swiss complaint” therefore describes a contemplated legal route, not a settled docket. A responsible article must say “planned,” “possible” or “contemplated” until a filing and an opening decision are publicly verified.

That caution does not make the story less important. It identifies where the dispute will be won or lost: not in the headline valuation alone, but in records showing who owed duties to which entity, what information was available at the time, which approvals were required, what alternatives were considered, and whether a decision caused a legally recognisable loss. The evidence trail may include board papers, financial models, valuation instructions, investor communications, legal opinions, minutes, access logs, messaging applications and records held by U.S. subsidiaries or banks. Each category raises a different question about authenticity, relevance, privilege and lawful transfer.

For a French reader, the key point is that proximity to the dispute is not enough. A French federation, sponsor, shareholder, bank, consultant or employee may possess useful material without automatically becoming a party to Swiss proceedings. A French national may have a personal interest without satisfying the requirements for French criminal jurisdiction. Conversely, a French court may preserve evidence before litigation even when the eventual merits case will be heard abroad, provided the statutory conditions are met. The route must be designed around the evidence and the forum rather than around the news cycle.

B. Why Article 158 turns a governance dispute into a criminal evidence question

The legal theory identified in the public filings invokes Article 158 of the Swiss Criminal Code, the provision concerning criminal mismanagement. The official Swiss text is available through Fedlex, Article 158 of the Swiss Criminal Code. The reference is precise, but the label must not be confused with proof. Article 158 does not criminalise every commercial decision that later looks expensive, unpopular or unsuccessful. The prosecution would have to connect the alleged conduct to the statutory elements and prove them to the required criminal standard.

In practical terms, the file would need to address at least five linked questions. First, what property or financial interest was entrusted to the person whose conduct is challenged? Second, what management or fiduciary duty applied to that person in the relevant entity and at the relevant time? Third, what specific act or omission breached that duty? Fourth, what financial loss followed, and how can it be measured? Fifth, what mental element and, where relevant, unlawful gain theory can be established from contemporaneous evidence rather than hindsight? The answers may differ for FIFA itself, an FFE subsidiary, member associations, outside advisers and investors.

A projected valuation is not automatically a loss. A proposal that would have transferred 20 per cent of a subsidiary for 4.2 billion dollars may invite questions about price, control, dilution, opportunity cost and the value of future World Cup-related revenues. But valuation is normally contestable. It requires the underlying assumptions, forecast dates, risk adjustments, comparable transactions, financing terms and approval constraints. A criminal case would need more than a later disagreement between governing bodies about what a fair price should have been.

The same logic applies to the expression “mismanagement.” It is a legal allegation, not a synonym for a governance failure. Evidence might support the theory if it showed that decision-makers concealed a material conflict, ignored a mandatory approval, used a valuation they knew to be false, diverted a corporate opportunity, or acted for a personal or third-party benefit contrary to the entrusted entity’s interests. It might weaken the theory if it showed an open process, independent advice, documented alternatives, member consultation, a rational commercial basis and a decision to withdraw before any transfer occurred. Both types of material belong in the file.

The timing is therefore central. The relevant question is not whether the FFE looked unattractive after the controversy became public. It is what was known, represented and decided when the proposal was prepared and circulated. Emails sent before the announcement, successive versions of valuation models, red-line contracts, instructions to advisers and records of dissent may carry more weight than later explanations. A forensic chronology should separate the date of each decision, the information available then, the person authorised to act, the approval obtained and the financial consequence that can be proved.

The U.S. applications fit this evidentiary problem. Section 1782 of Title 28 of the United States Code allows a U.S. district court, in its discretion, to order a person found in the district to give testimony or produce documents for use in a proceeding in a foreign or international tribunal, including certain criminal investigations before a formal accusation. The applications reported in the FFE dispute seek material located in or controlled by U.S. entities. They do not transfer the Swiss investigation to the United States. They also do not guarantee that every document produced will be admissible in Switzerland, because admissibility, authenticity, privilege and relevance remain matters for the foreign proceeding.

Section 1782 has its own safeguards. The court may consider the nature of the foreign proceeding, whether the person targeted is a participant, whether the request is an attempt to evade foreign restrictions, and whether the demand is burdensome or intrusive. A recipient can raise privilege, confidentiality, overbreadth, relevance and proportionality objections. A discovery order is not a licence to publish every produced document. A protective order, redaction, restricted use and a secure transfer protocol may be necessary even when the application succeeds.

For this reason, the most valuable immediate work may be evidence preservation rather than public accusation. Relevant custodians should be identified, ordinary deletion policies suspended, original files preserved with metadata, and the relationship between each document and each legal issue recorded. A document which proves that a valuation changed is not enough unless the file also explains who ordered the change, why it changed and which approval followed. The same document can support or undermine the alleged breach depending on the surrounding record.

Finally, the potential Swiss complaint remains a process with a presumption of innocence. Infantino’s public role does not establish personal liability, and FIFA’s institutional responsibility does not automatically become the responsibility of every participant. Lawyers, directors, advisers and counterparties should resist broad accusations that collapse corporate identity into individual guilt. The better approach is to map decisions, duties, authorisations, conflicts, loss theories and custodians. That map determines which court can be approached and which request is legally sustainable.

II. What French and European actors should do with evidence held across borders

A. When French courts can preserve or produce records before a Swiss case

French law offers several evidence tools, but they do not all serve the same purpose. The first is Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Its opening condition is: “S’il existe un motif légitime de conserver ou d’établir avant tout procès la preuve de faits dont pourrait dépendre la solution d’un litige.” In English, a person may ask for a legally admissible investigative measure before proceedings when there is a legitimate reason to preserve or establish facts that could affect the outcome of a future dispute. The full current provision is available on Légifrance, Code of Civil Procedure Article 145.

Article 145 can be useful when a French company, bank, consultant or association holds records likely to disappear, be overwritten or become inaccessible before a Swiss civil, commercial or arbitration claim is brought. The applicant must show a real connection between the requested measure and a plausible future dispute. The applicant does not have to prove the merits in advance, but a speculative search through an entire organisation will not become legitimate merely because the matter is in the news. The request should identify the proposed parties, the legal claims under consideration, the custodians, the date range, the document categories and the risk that evidence will be lost.

A recent First Civil Chamber decision, Cour de cassation, docket no. 24-10.385, is useful for the threshold. The decision confirms, in substance, that an applicant seeking an Article 145 measure need not establish the merits of the future action or prove entitlement to compensation at that preliminary stage. That does not remove the requirement for a legitimate reason. It means the judge assesses the need to preserve or establish evidence, not the entire foreign case on the merits. The application still fails if the proposed measure is disconnected, abusive, disproportionate or directed at material protected by an insurmountable legal bar.

Article 145 is not a French version of U.S. discovery. It is a judicial measure connected to a potential dispute and controlled by French courts. It cannot compel a Swiss prosecutor to open an investigation, order a U.S. company with no French presence to produce records, or decide that a future Swiss criminal court must admit the material. Its value is more precise: it can preserve a French evidence node and prevent a relevant record from disappearing while the parties identify the correct foreign procedure.

Once a French civil or commercial case is pending, Articles 138 to 141 of the Code of Civil Procedure provide a second route for third-party records. Under Article 138, a party may ask the judge to order delivery or production of a document held by a third party. Article 139 governs the form of the request and allows the judge to specify whether the original, a copy or an extract must be produced, with safeguards and potentially a penalty. Article 140 makes the decision provisionally enforceable, while Article 141 addresses difficulties, legitimate impediment and a third party’s challenge.

Those provisions matter to a cross-border governance dispute because the evidence may be held by a French auditor, French subsidiary, local adviser, payment institution or employee rather than by the principal foreign entity. A focused request could seek the board pack sent to a French director, the instructions given to a French consultant, or the version history of a valuation model stored in France. It should explain why the identified records bear on a specific issue. “All communications about FIFA” is rarely a defensible formulation. “The valuation instructions and model versions exchanged between these custodians during the approval window” is more likely to permit a meaningful judicial assessment.

The criminal route is different. If Swiss judicial authorities formally seek evidence in France, the request travels through mutual legal assistance mechanisms and is executed under French procedural safeguards. Article 694 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, within the official Légifrance section on international criminal cooperation, identifies the transmission framework for requests. In an urgent situation, Article 694-1 permits the foreign request to be transmitted to the prosecutor or investigating judge through the channels provided by law. Article 694-2 describes execution by the prosecutor or judicial police, with an investigating judge involved when the acts require it.

Article 694-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides the essential procedural safeguard: foreign requests are executed under French rules, while a requested foreign form may be used if it does not reduce the rights or guarantees of the parties. In the statute’s words, acts take place “selon les règles de procédure prévues par le présent code,” meaning under the procedural rules laid down by the French Code. Article 694-4 also matters where public order or essential national interests create a serious obstacle; the issue may be escalated and the assistance refused or limited.

France and Switzerland have a bilateral agreement supplementing the 1959 European Convention on Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters. The official publication is the French decree publishing the France–Switzerland mutual-assistance agreement. Its Article XIV states that requests for judicial assistance “peuvent être adressées, en France, au Procureur général” in the relevant appellate jurisdiction, subject to the agreement’s conditions; in English, the request may be addressed in France to the competent public prosecutor general. The practical consequence is that a Swiss criminal request is not handled like a private letter from a litigant. It must follow the treaty and French execution route, with dual-criminality, necessity, proportionality and rights issues assessed in context.

The correct sequence for a French custodian is therefore not to upload records to a foreign contact or publish them online. The custodian should preserve the material, identify the legal basis under which it is requested, verify the requesting authority, ask whether a treaty request or court order exists, and obtain advice on professional secrecy, personal data and commercial confidentiality. If a Swiss request arrives, the response must respect the French authority’s instructions. If a private party asks for voluntary delivery, the answer may be different, but a voluntary transfer still requires a lawful purpose, a narrow scope and a record of consent or authority.

These rules also explain why the U.S. and French tools can operate in parallel without being interchangeable. Section 1782 may obtain a document from a U.S. entity. Article 145 may preserve a copy or related record in France. A Swiss request under mutual assistance may seek coercive measures or testimony in France. Each route has a different judge, threshold and objection mechanism. A coherent strategy connects them through one evidence matrix so that a document is not requested twice, a privilege position is not waived accidentally, and the origin of every copy remains demonstrable.

B. How to protect standing, privilege and the chain of proof

The first threshold is standing. A French court will ask who is applying, what right or interest is invoked, and what future dispute is genuinely contemplated. Article 2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure gives civil-action standing to a person who has “personnellement souffert du dommage directement causé” by the offence, meaning a person who personally suffered damage directly caused by the offence. The full text is available on Légifrance, Code of Criminal Procedure Article 2. An abstract concern about the integrity of international sport may support an institutional review, but it does not automatically establish a personal French civil action.

That distinction is particularly important for UEFA. UEFA is a Swiss association with its own constitutional structure and cannot simply rely on every French association rule. A French member association, sponsor or investor may have a different position, but it must identify its own direct interest and the applicable contract, statute or fiduciary relationship. A party should not manufacture French standing by describing a general governance concern as a personal financial loss. The application should show the concrete decision affected, the right held by the applicant, and the link between the requested record and the injury alleged.

French criminal jurisdiction is also not automatic merely because one participant lives in France or because a document passed through Paris. Article 113-7 of the Penal Code extends French criminal law to certain offences committed abroad when the victim was French at the time, subject to its conditions. Article 113-8 requires a request by the public prosecutor and, in the relevant cases, a complaint from the victim or an official denunciation by the foreign authority. The provisions can be consulted at Légifrance, Penal Code Article 113-7 and Légifrance, Penal Code Article 113-8. They are jurisdictional filters, not shortcuts around Swiss territorial or institutional competence.

A civil claim may have a separate basis. Article 1240 of the Civil Code provides that a person who causes damage by fault must repair it. Depending on the governing instruments, contractual liability may also be considered under Article 1231-1 of the Civil Code. These provisions do not turn a disputed valuation into a French tort. The applicant would still need a fault recognised by the applicable law, a direct and certain loss, causation, and a French forum with jurisdiction. A legal claim based on a member-association relationship, an advisory engagement or a financing contract must be analysed through that instrument rather than through media coverage.

Governance duties require the same discipline. The Civil Code’s agency provisions state that an agent may be liable for fraud and faults in management under Article 1992, and must account for management and what was received under Article 1993. Those provisions are not a direct statement of Swiss criminal law and cannot be used to declare Infantino liable. They illustrate the type of questions a French judge may ask when an applicant relies on a mandate, an agency relationship or a contractual duty: what authority existed, what was received, what account was rendered, and what precise management act is criticised?

The Article 145 decision with docket no. 24-10.385 provides a second warning against overstatement. The preliminary evidence judge does not decide the final merits, but the applicant still needs a legitimate reason and a measure that is legally admissible. A request aimed at finding whether any wrongdoing exists, without a defined future claim or defined material, risks becoming a prohibited fishing expedition. The request should identify competing explanations and ask for the records capable of distinguishing them. That is especially important where the evidence could either prove a conflict or show that the decision was independently reviewed.

Privilege is the next fault line. Board materials may include legal advice, but a document does not become privileged merely because a lawyer received a copy. The analysis should separate legal advice from commercial advice, drafts from final records, and communications made for litigation from ordinary business communications. A U.S. order may apply a protective regime that does not map perfectly onto French professional secrecy or Swiss procedural law. The receiving party should seek a privilege protocol, a review process and a mechanism for inadvertent production before any large-scale transfer.

Personal data and business secrecy also need a technical plan. Names, bank details, health information, identity documents, private messages and employee data may be irrelevant to the legal issue. Redaction should remove irrelevant sensitive material without destroying the context necessary to understand a decision. Commercially sensitive forecasts may require a confidentiality ring or restricted-access repository. A request for “all records” is likely to create both legal and cybersecurity risk. A date-bounded, custodian-bounded and issue-bounded request is easier to defend and easier to execute.

Chain of custody can decide the evidentiary value of a file. The team should preserve the original source, record the collection date and time, identify the collecting person and tool, retain metadata, calculate a hash where appropriate, log every transfer, and document translations. Screenshots without the underlying message, exported spreadsheets without version history, or PDFs with no record of the source can be challenged. The aim is not to give a document an artificial aura of certainty. It is to allow the foreign court to understand what it is, where it came from, whether it was altered and how it relates to the disputed decision.

A workable evidence schedule for a French actor can be concise:

  • define the legal issue first: duty, conflict, valuation, approval, loss or causation;
  • identify custodians and systems in France, Switzerland and the United States, including personal devices used for business;
  • issue a documented preservation notice and suspend deletion or auto-purge rules within a lawful scope;
  • separate originals, forensic copies, translations, legal advice and commercial material;
  • record the proposed forum, the possible claim, the evidence threshold and the relief sought;
  • select Article 145, Articles 138 to 141, a treaty request, Section 1782 or a coordinated combination;
  • anticipate privilege, data-protection, secrecy, burden and proportionality objections; and
  • prepare a chronology that links each record to a decision, a duty, a financial consequence and a witness.

Public communications should follow the same method. A statement that a review is under way is not proof that a crime occurred. Publishing confidential evidence may prejudice a future proceeding, expose personal data, breach a contract or undermine a request for judicial assistance. If a French organisation believes records are at risk, it should preserve them and use the appropriate court or authority. If it believes it suffered direct harm, it should quantify the harm and identify the legal relationship that creates the claim. These steps protect both the integrity of the investigation and the people who may ultimately have to answer questions.

For international counsel, the French position is therefore neither a blank cheque nor a dead end. France can be a valuable evidence jurisdiction when a genuine dispute, a legitimate preservation need and a precise request are shown. It can also be a demanding jurisdiction where the applicant seeks abstract accountability, conflates corporate and individual responsibility, or ignores privilege and proportionality. The strongest cross-border case will connect the Swiss legal theory, the U.S. discovery record and the French evidence mechanism without pretending that one country’s order resolves the law of another.

Conclusion

The UEFA–FIFA dispute has become legally consequential because the proposed FFE structure created a trail across institutions and borders. The public facts support a story about a planned Swiss complaint and U.S. evidence applications, not a finding that Infantino or FIFA committed criminal mismanagement. Article 158 of the Swiss Criminal Code will require a disciplined analysis of entrusted interests, management duties, breach, loss, causation and intent. The answer will come from contemporaneous records, not from the size of a headline figure or the intensity of the political disagreement.

French actors who hold relevant evidence should preserve it and choose the route that matches the future proceeding. Article 145 can protect a French evidence node before a case is filed; Articles 138 to 141 can address third-party production in a pending civil or commercial case; and Articles 694-1 to 694-4, together with the France–Switzerland agreement, govern formal criminal assistance. U.S. Section 1782 applications can complement those routes, but none of them decides Swiss liability or guarantees admissibility.

The decisive safeguards are standing, narrow requests, privilege review, lawful data handling, reliable metadata and a documented chain of custody. Those safeguards also provide the clearest response to a fast-moving international story: preserve first, define the claim, identify the forum, test the evidence and let the competent authority decide whether the facts justify proceedings. Until then, the planned complaint remains an allegation under preparation, not a judgment.

Sources checked for the factual chronology: the Associated Press report on the planned Swiss complaint and U.S. applications, UEFA’s 27 August statement, and FIFA’s official FFE announcement, presidential explanation and withdrawal statement. The legal sources are linked inline above.

📄 Official circular