KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
US Court-Wide ICC Sanctions Are Coming: What France Must Still Do — Cooperate, Pay and Prosecute From Paris

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

US Court-Wide ICC Sanctions Are Coming: What France Must Still Do — Cooperate, Pay and Prosecute From Paris

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 20 September 2026, Reuters reported that the Trump administration has readied sanctions targeting the ICC as an institution, with an announcement expected soon, citing two sources familiar with the matter speaking on Sunday. The Wall Street Journal added the detail that matters most for anyone doing business with the Court: most transactions with the ICC would be barred once a six-to-seven-month wind-down period expires. Until now, Washington had sanctioned individuals — judges, prosecutors, and in August the Court’s own President Tomoko Akane. Targeting the institution itself is a different order of pressure, aimed at the Court’s bank accounts, software licences, insurance contracts, investigators’ invoices and even the salaries of its American staff. For readers in France, the question is concrete and immediate. French banks clear payments in dollars. French companies supply the Court. French lawyers represent victims and suspects. Witnesses live in France, evidence sits on servers in France, and suspects arrested on French soil are handed to The Hague under French procedural rules. Can Paris keep cooperating with the ICC if the Court itself becomes a sanctioned entity under American law, and what should you do now, during the grace period, to protect a payment, a contract, a case file or a client? This analysis answers from inside French procedure: what Washington has actually prepared, why a transaction ban bites even outside the United States, why French cooperation with the Court is a statutory duty no foreign sanction can repeal, and how France prosecutes these same crimes itself when The Hague is slowed down.

I. What Washington has actually put on the table against the ICC

A. From sanctioned judges to a sanctioned Court: which measures exist and what is being prepared

The legal base is already in force. In early February 2025 the American president signed Executive Order 14203 on the International Criminal Court, opening a new phase of opposition to the institution. The order accuses the Court of illegitimate action against the United States and Israel, citing the arrest warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant and the earlier Afghanistan file. It works through the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, the same statute behind most American asset freezes, and it authorises blocking the property of designated persons and banning transactions with them. Implementation followed through the US Treasury’s International Criminal Court-Related Sanctions Regulations published in the Federal Register in July 2025. In other words, the machinery for court-wide measures already exists; only the designation decision is missing.

The individual designations came first and they set the pattern. The French foreign ministry recorded the count on 19 August 2026: Paris had learned of fresh American listings hitting the ICC President and a member of the Prosecutor’s office, on top of eleven judges already under sanctions. President Akane and senior trial lawyer Abdoulaye Seye were added in August, with the restrictions taking effect on 17 September 2026, days before the current reporting. American media counts run higher — over a dozen judges and prosecutors in total — because deputies and the former chief prosecutor are also listed. Each listing follows the same logic: anyone who assists the Court’s work on the Israel or Afghanistan files risks designation, and every designation has extraterritorial bite because, as Al Jazeera summarised the coming step, sanctioned status would in principle stop American citizens and companies from supplying the Court with funds, goods or services without a Treasury licence. For the judges already listed, that has meant frozen travel, frozen assets and professional isolation. For a French lawyer appearing alongside listed counsel, a French NGO sharing evidence, or a French bank processing a salary payment, the individual sanctions already created daily compliance dilemmas.

The court-wide step now being prepared would multiply those dilemmas by the size of the institution. Reuters describes sanctions against the Court as already prepared, with only the announcement date unclear, possibly during the United Nations General Assembly week in New York. The substance, as reported by the Journal, is a near-total transactions ban once the six-to-seven-month grace period runs out. Legally, that means the Court as an entity would join the US Treasury’s blocked lists, so that any American person — and in practice any bank or company touching the dollar system — dealing with the ICC would need a specific licence or face secondary exposure. Politically, it answers the campaign Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced in July to isolate the Court and press states to withdraw from it. Paris read the move exactly that way, calling the listings an attack on the Court and its 125 member states, incompatible with judicial independence. Readers should keep the sequence in mind, because it drives the rest of this analysis. Individual sanctions punish people for past cooperation with the Court; institution sanctions would punish future cooperation itself, including cooperation coming from France. That grace period is therefore not a waiting room. It is the window in which French banks, suppliers, counsel, victims’ representatives and anyone holding ICC-related funds must restructure payments, licences and contracts before the ban bites.

B. Why an American transaction ban hurts the Court even from Paris

American sanctions work at a distance because the dollar system does. Banks and firms tend to over-comply with American restrictions precisely because they depend on access to the United States financial system. A French bank that clears dollars through a US correspondent, a French insurer with American reinsurance, a French cloud provider running American software under licence — all of them face the same calculation the moment the ICC becomes a blocked entity: process the Court’s payment and risk losing dollar access, or freeze first and ask questions later. The Court’s leadership has spelled out where that logic leads, warning that institution-wide measures could hamper technology and insurance procurement, investigator hiring and routine payments such as American staff salaries. Note the inventory: not fines or travel bans, but the plumbing of a criminal investigation — servers, insurance, investigators, payroll. An international court that cannot pay an investigator, renew a software licence or insure a field mission is a court that slows down, and slowing the Court down is the stated objective. France learned the same lesson from the Russia and Belarus regimes: the freeze lands first through private compliance departments, months before any judge rules.

The Netherlands already ran the experiment, and French readers should study it, because Paris would face the identical mechanics. The ICC sits in The Hague under a Headquarters Agreement that obliges the host state to guarantee the Court’s business continuity, yet American individual sanctions immediately raised the question whether Dutch banks would keep processing the Court’s transactions. Reporting on the Dutch precedent describes talks with banks in The Hague on the conditions for keeping ICC payments flowing, with the banks demanding solid guarantees before staying on. Substitute French banks, the Paris-based accounts of defence teams, victims’ counsel, suppliers and NGOs, and the picture is the same: over-compliance arrives before the law requires it, driven by fear of American enforcement rather than by any European prohibition. More than eighty states jointly pledged undiminished support for the Court’s independence and integrity, and European Union leaders publicly rallied behind it after the August designations — but political statements do not clear payments. A French finance director who must pay an ICC invoice in January needs a licence path, a non-dollar rail, or a documented legal opinion, not a communiqué.

Three practical consequences follow for France, and each will be developed in the second part. First, every existing contract with the ICC — supply, services, expert retainer, legal aid, victim representation — needs a sanctions clause review now, during the grace period, because performance after designation without a US Treasury licence could expose the French counterparty. Second, dollar payments to or from the Court, including salary and pension flows for staff living in France, need rerouting or licensing analysis before banks freeze them unilaterally. Third, evidence and testimony located in France keep their full legal value regardless of American measures: US sanctions cannot repeal French criminal procedure, cannot quash a French surrender order, and cannot stop a French court from trying these crimes itself. That is where French law takes over, and it is the stronger half of this story.

II. What France can and must still do from Paris while Washington squeezes The Hague

A. Cooperating with the Court is a statutory duty in France, not a policy favour

France is one of the 125 states parties to the Rome Statute, and its Constitution provides the domestic anchor: Article 53-2 of the Constitution of 4 October 1958 authorises the Republic to recognise the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court under the 1998 Rome treaty, a recognition the Constitutional Council examined in its decision 98-408 DC of 22 January 1999. Parliament then built the domestic machinery in the Code of Criminal Procedure, in the dedicated section on cooperation with the International Criminal Court, covering arrest, surrender, evidence and enforcement. The flagship rule is Article 627-5: “Toute personne appréhendée en vertu d’une demande d’arrestation aux fins de remise doit être déférée dans les vingt-quatre heures au procureur de la République territorialement compétent.” Within that twenty-four hours the custody safeguards apply, the person is told in a language they understand that an ICC surrender request exists, that they will appear within five days before the prosecutor general at the Paris court of appeal, and that counsel — chosen or court-appointed — can meet them immediately. The surrounding provisions organise detention review by the liberty judge (Article 627-7) and the surrender ruling itself. None of this machinery references American sanctions, and none of it stops because a foreign executive order says so. A French prosecutor who receives an ICC request applies the French code, period.

French judges have already proved it on the most sensitive possible file. In September 2020 the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation reviewed the surrender of Félicien Kabuga — arrested at Asnières-sur-Seine after decades on the run — to the Mechanism for International Criminal Tribunals on genocide and crimes-against-humanity charges (Crim., 30 September 2020, No. 20-83.181). The defence threw everything at the surrender order: irregular transmission bypassing the justice minister, a seven-year-old warrant presented as urgent, Covid-era health risks in detention in Arusha, and the spectre of onward transfer to Rwanda in breach of the legality principle. The Court of Cassation worked through each argument — holding for example that “l’incompatibilité de l’état de santé de M. J… avec la détention n’est pas caractérisée”, that the onward-transfer fear was “une question relative à un transfert purement hypothétique”, and that the chambre de l’instruction “a justifié sa décision” — and ended with the words that define French practice: the Paris court “a ordonné sa remise au Mécanisme pour les tribunaux pénaux internationaux”, and the Court of Cassation itself “REJETTE le pourvoi formé le 10 juin 2020”. The lesson for today is direct. French surrender to an international criminal tribunal is routine judicial business, tested against the Convention, the EU Charter and medical evidence, and decided by French judges applying French statutes. An American designation of the ICC changes nothing in that courtroom: the chambre de l’instruction will still examine identity, health, and rights, and will still order surrender when the file justifies it.

Paris has also made its political position unambiguous, which matters for every discretionary decision around cooperation — visas for witnesses, protection measures, funding for victim participation, police resources for arrests. After the August 2026 designations, the foreign ministry condemned all threats and coercive steps against the Court, its personnel and the civil society organisations supporting it. That last phrase protects the French ecosystem directly: NGOs documenting crimes, lawyers representing victims, journalists and researchers are named as deserving protection, not as sanctions risks. Anyone in France pressured by a bank, an insurer or a business partner to cut ties with the Court over American sanctions should keep that statement in the file, next to the code provisions. It is the French state’s answer, in advance, to the over-compliance reflex: cooperation with the ICC is lawful, encouraged and, where the code commands it, mandatory.

B. If The Hague slows down, Paris can prosecute: universal jurisdiction and the practical checklist

The strongest French answer to pressure on the ICC is that France does not need The Hague to try the core international crimes. Article 689-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that, outside the ICC-cooperation cases, “peut être poursuivie et jugée par les juridictions françaises toute personne soupçonnée d’avoir commis à l’étranger l’une des infractions suivantes”: genocide as defined in Article 211-1 of the Criminal Code, other crimes against humanity under Article 212-1, and war crimes under Articles 461-1 to 461-31. Three conditions frame the power. “La personne soupçonnée doit avoir une résidence habituelle sur le territoire français”, assessed through length and reasons of presence, settlement intent and family, social, material or professional ties. “La poursuite de ces crimes ne peut être exercée qu’à la requête du procureur de la République antiterroriste et si aucune juridiction internationale ou nationale ne demande la remise ou l’extradition de la personne”, with the prosecutor verifying that the ICC is not already seized. In plain terms: suspects living in France can be tried in France for atrocities committed abroad, unless the ICC or another state claims them first. American sanctions against the ICC cannot switch this off; if anything, a slowed Court makes the French track more central, since the prosecutor’s subsidiarity check will more often come back negative.

The Court of Cassation, sitting in plenary assembly — its most solemn formation — has given this jurisdiction teeth precisely where impunity arguments are strongest. In the landmark Syrian case (Ass. plén., 12 May 2023, No. 22-82.468), the Court held that torturers acting for a non-state armed group controlling territory fall within French universal jurisdiction, and it settled the double-criminality rule that governs every file: “La condition d’incrimination par la loi étrangère peut être remplie au travers d’une infraction de droit commun constituant la base du crime poursuivi, tels le meurtre, le viol ou la torture.” No mirror war-crimes statute abroad is needed; ordinary murder, rape or torture provisions suffice. But the Court drew the line honestly the other way too: “en l’absence de renvoi par la loi syrienne aux incriminations des instruments internationaux et de prévision d’une peine par lesdits instruments, le principe de légalité criminelle fait obstacle à ce que des faits soient considérés comme punis, au sens de la loi française, par la législation de l’État étranger à travers de telles normes.” Ratified treaties and political will do not replace a criminal prohibition with a penalty. The appeal was dismissed — “REJETTE le pourvoi” — and the file went back to the investigating judges. For victims and associations filing complaints in Paris while the ICC is under financial siege, this ruling is the roadmap: document the ordinary-law equivalent in the territorial state’s code, anchor habitual residence in France, and address the complaint to the anti-terrorism prosecutor, who alone can trigger the case.

The same protective logic governs the reverse movement — when France is asked to hand someone over. In May 2025 the Criminal Chamber reviewed a Korean extradition request carrying a potential life sentence for financial offences (Crim., 6 May 2025, No. 24-85.773) and restated the test every surrender file in France must pass: “l’extradition doit être refusée lorsque la personne concernée démontre qu’elle est exposée à un risque réel de voir prononcer contre elle une peine manifestement disproportionnée dans l’Etat requérant”, a concept for “une interprétation stricte” reserved for “des cas très exceptionnels”, where “le seul fait que la peine encourue dans l’Etat requérant soit plus sévère que celle qui serait appliquée dans l’Etat requis n’étant pas opérant”. The chambre de l’instruction must verify review and parole mechanisms — in that case, parole after one-third of the sentence and after twenty years for lifers — and the Court of Cassation controls the reasoning without substituting its own assessment. Anyone arrested in France on an ICC or foreign warrant therefore keeps the full shield of Article 3 of the European Convention: health, detention conditions, sentence reviewability and proportionality are examined in Paris before anyone boards a plane. That shield, like the 24-hour presentment rule, operates independently of Washington’s lists.

What, then, should you do in France during the grace period? First, if your bank freezes or questions an ICC-linked transfer, answer in writing with the file: the contract, the invoice, the OFAC licence application or licence, and the French ministry statement condemning coercion against Court partners — banks demanding solid guarantees, as the Dutch precedent showed, often restart payments once counsel documents the legal route. Second, if you supply the Court, amend the contract now: sanctions-hardship clause, euro payment rail, licence-suspension rather than termination, and an explicit allocation of licence-application duties. Third, if you represent victims, suspects or witnesses, keep building the French file in parallel: complaint to the Paris anti-terrorism prosecutor under Article 689-11 where residence anchors exist, civil-party constitution, and preservation requests for evidence held in France, so the case survives any slowdown in The Hague. Fourth, if you are arrested for surrender, use the first hours: demand counsel immediately at the 24-hour presentment, challenge identity and health evidence early, and put proportionality and detention-conditions material before the chambre de l’instruction from day one, following the Kabuga and Korean-case playbooks. One honest caveat on the much-discussed European blocking statute: it bars European firms from obeying American sanctions with extraterritorial reach, but stretching it to cover ICC sanctions would break entirely new ground for that instrument, an option debated in Brussels since spring without adoption. Do not build your compliance plan on a regulation that has not been extended; build it on licences, euro rails, French procedure and, where the crimes qualify, the French courts themselves.

Conclusion

The move being prepared in Washington is the logical endpoint of a campaign that runs from Executive Order 14203 through the listing of eleven judges, a Court president and a senior prosecutor, to the isolation drive of this summer — and now to the institution itself, with a transactions ban after a six-to-seven-month grace period. Its mechanism is financial rather than legal: make the Court too expensive for banks, suppliers, insurers and software vendors to touch, and investigations stall without a single courtroom defeat. But the mechanism stops at the French border in the ways that count for justice. No American regulation can repeal Article 627-5, silence the 24-hour presentment, cancel a Kabuga-style surrender order, or close the Article 689-11 universal-jurisdiction docket that the plenary assembly opened wide in 2023. France’s judges have already shown, case after case, that they examine surrender and extradition files on French terms — identity, health, proportionality, reviewability — and that they try atrocity crimes themselves when the suspect lives here. The grace period is therefore a double deadline. For finance and contracts, use it to licence, reroute and re-paper every ICC-linked flow before banks freeze first. For cases, use it to anchor the French track now: complaints to the anti-terrorism prosecutor, preserved evidence, protected witnesses, funded victim representation. Courts under siege need relay runners, and French procedure was built to be one. Related coverage from this desk includes the arrest-warrant cooperation guide and the blocking-statute analysis for ICC files touching France.

📄 Official circular