KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
US Sanctions Against the ICC on Nobel Day: What the 9 October 2026 Measures Change for France and Europe

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

US Sanctions Against the ICC on Nobel Day: What the 9 October 2026 Measures Change for France and Europe

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 9 October 2026, the same day the Nobel Peace Prize went to a former judge of the International Criminal Court, the United States imposed sanctions on the Court itself. Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced that Washington would, in his words, ban transactions with what he called a rogue court, cut off its resources and cripple its ability to operate. Within hours, the Court answered from The Hague: the sanctions must be condemned, its deputy prosecutor told Reuters, but the work will continue across all situations, investigations and prosecutions. For readers in France and Europe, the shock is not only diplomatic. The Court sits in the Netherlands, counts every EU country among its members, and works daily with European banks, contractors, witnesses and counsel. When Washington punishes companies that provide services to the tribunal, the conflict of laws lands directly in Paris boardrooms, bank compliance departments and law offices. This article explains what Washington decided, why the Nobel timing matters, and what France and Europe can still do when the world’s criminal court is placed under sanctions.

I. What did the United States decide against the ICC on 9 October 2026?

A. Can the United States ban transactions with the International Criminal Court?

Yes, under its own domestic sanctions machinery, and that is exactly what it did on Friday 9 October 2026. According to Reuters, which first reported the statement, Secretary of State Marco Rubio declared that President Trump would never allow the International Criminal Court to prosecute Americans. Washington, he said, was therefore sanctioning the Court itself, banning transactions with a tribunal he described as rogue in order to cut off its resources and cripple its operations. The wording matters for anyone doing business with the Court from Europe. Washington is not only targeting named individuals this time. The measure is described as potentially punishing companies that provide services to the Court itself, which means banks processing its payments, software vendors hosting its evidence, telecom operators carrying its communications, and contractors maintaining its premises could all fall within the announced ban. The administration has been hostile to the tribunal since its creation in 2002 to prosecute war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide, and it had already sanctioned prosecutors and judges of the Court in earlier rounds. Friday’s move goes further because it aims at the institution as such rather than at a list of natural persons.

Two features of the announcement deserve close attention from a European vantage point. First, Washington structured the sanctions to leave the door ajar. Rubio said the measures had been designed to give the Court and its member states an opportunity to address American concerns, and the United States expects its allies to rein in the Court. Shortly after the announcement, the US Treasury issued four general licenses covering certain transactions linked to telecommunications, software and pension payments of the Court, as well as transactions connected to persons detained by it. General licenses of this kind are familiar tools of American sanctions practice: they carve out lifeline transactions while keeping the general prohibition in place, and they can be narrowed, widened or revoked at short notice. Anyone relying on them from Paris must therefore read their exact scope rather than assume that routine business with the Court is safe. A payment labelled as software support may be covered while an adjacent service contract is not, and banks tend to read such licenses restrictively when the penalty for an error is exclusion from the dollar system.

Second, the grievances invoked by Washington are identified. The administration denounced the arrest warrants issued for Israeli officials including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and a past investigation into the actions of American soldiers in Afghanistan, an investigation the Court has since closed. These references explain the political logic of the measure but they do not change its legal mechanics in Europe. An American sanctions designation does not create an obligation under French or EU law to stop dealing with the designated person or entity. It creates a risk: the risk of American secondary measures, loss of correspondent banking relationships, and contractual default clauses triggered by sanctions events. European operators therefore face a genuine conflict of applicable rules, and that conflict is precisely what the rest of this article addresses. The Court itself framed the stakes in institutional terms, calling the move an attempt to obstruct justice and to prevent the Court from doing what it was created to do, and describing it as an assault on the rule of law and on the foundations of the international legal order. It added a warning that European governments cannot ignore: the Court could not stand alone, and its fate rested in the hands of the states that created it. The tribunal counts 125 member states, including every EU country and every NATO member apart from the United States and Turkey, and it sits in the Netherlands, an EU and NATO member. When the Court calls on its members to make sure it has the means necessary to operate, the appeal is directed first and foremost at European capitals, Paris included.

Deputy Prosecutor Nazhat Shameem Khan gave the judicial response in uncompromising terms. She told Reuters the sanctions were intended to undermine the rule of law internationally and the work of an independent judicial institution, while pledging that the work of the prosecution would continue across all situations, investigations and prosecutions. That promise will be tested in practical ways that matter to practitioners: arrest warrants must still be executed, witnesses must still be protected and relocated, defence counsel must still be paid, and victims must still be able to participate. Only days earlier, the Court had provided further details on arrest warrants issued for two Taliban leaders, a reminder that its docket does not pause for political pressure. If service providers withdraw one by one out of fear of American measures, the continuation of that work will depend on whether European states build concrete financial and logistical bridges, a question examined in the second part of this article.

B. Why did the Nobel Peace Prize land in the middle of the sanctions announcement?

Because the laureate is one of the Court’s own. Earlier on the same Friday, the Norwegian Nobel Committee awarded the 2026 Peace Prize to Navanethem “Navi” Pillay, the South African jurist who sat as a judge in the Appeals Chamber of the International Criminal Court from 2003 to 2008, after serving as UN High Commissioner for Human Rights and as a judge of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. The Committee stated openly that in naming her it had sought to send a reminder at a time when judges and institutions of international law face political attack. Its citation presented an international legal system in which war criminals are held to account and victims see justice served as a precondition for a peaceful world. The message could hardly have been more direct, and the American answer arrived within hours. Whatever view one takes of the underlying political disputes, the sequence turns an abstract debate about international justice into a concrete question of institutional survival: what happens to trials, warrants and victim participation when the judicial institution itself is financially besieged on the day its former judge is celebrated in Oslo.

For a French lawyer, three features of the Nobel context carry practical weight. First, Pillay’s career embodies the complementarity between national courts and international tribunals that structures the entire system. She moved from the South African domestic bench to the Rwanda tribunal, then to the ICC Appeals Chamber, then to UN human rights leadership. That trajectory illustrates that international criminal justice was never designed to replace domestic courts but to backstop them when they are unwilling or unable to act. If the ICC’s operational capacity shrinks under sanctions, the backstop weakens, and the burden shifts back to national jurisdictions, including France, whose universal jurisdiction machinery is examined below. Clients sometimes assume that an ICC investigation suspends all national exposure. The opposite dynamic now applies: pressure on The Hague increases the relevance of Paris, where complaints for war crimes, crimes against humanity and torture can be filed and investigated under French procedural rules.

Second, the Nobel ceremony gives European states political cover to act. The Court warned that this was not only about defending one institution but about safeguarding the international order grounded upon the rule of law, adding that history would judge this moment. Governments that might otherwise have treated the American measures as a bilateral quarrel between Washington and The Hague now face a public record: a Nobel Prize honouring international justice on the very day sanctions sought to cripple its principal criminal court. France, which presents itself as a steadfast supporter of the fight against impunity, will be judged by international media and civil society on the concrete steps it takes in the coming weeks, from voluntary contributions to the Court’s budget to practical arrangements for banking and procurement. Symbolic statements of support cost nothing; keeping the Court’s accounts, contracts and field operations running in euros is the test that counts.

Third, the timing sharpens the question of deterrence. Arrest warrants only deter if potential perpetrators believe they may one day be enforced. The warrants for the Taliban leadership, the proceedings concerning the situations in which European victims and witnesses are involved, and the cooperation requests pending before national authorities all depend on a functioning registry, a functioning prosecution office and a functioning system for the protection of witnesses. Deputy Prosecutor Khan’s pledge that the work will continue is a statement of institutional will, not a statement of financial fact. Defence teams, victims’ representatives and NGOs working with the Court from France should therefore prepare for a period of operational friction: delayed payments, cautious banks, renegotiated contracts and additional compliance questionnaires. Anticipating that friction, rather than discovering it file by file, is the responsible course, and it begins with understanding what French law already allows domestic courts to do on their own.

II. What can France and Europe still do if the ICC cannot operate normally?

A. Can French courts prosecute war crimes and crimes against humanity if the ICC is blocked?

Yes, within defined conditions, and this is where French procedure becomes the quiet safety net of the Rome Statute system. The ICC was built on complementarity: it intervenes only when states are unwilling or unable to prosecute genuinely. France has equipped its own courts with a universal jurisdiction regime that allows prosecution in France of atrocity crimes committed abroad, even without any territorial or nationality link, provided strict statutory conditions are met. The centrepiece is article 689-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which provides that “peut être poursuivie et jugée par les juridictions françaises toute personne soupçonnée d’avoir commis à l’étranger l’une des infractions suivantes”, namely genocide, other crimes against humanity, and war crimes and misdemeanours. The same article adds a residence condition: the text requires the suspect to be habitually resident on French territory. It further provides that “La poursuite de ces crimes ne peut être exercée qu’à la requête du procureur de la République antiterroriste et si aucune juridiction internationale ou nationale ne demande la remise ou l’extradition de la personne”, with the prosecution service verifying that the ICC is not already seized and that no other competent international court has requested surrender and no other state has requested extradition. In plain terms, Paris can step in, but only through the national anti-terrorism prosecution office, only against a suspect genuinely anchored in France, and only where no international or foreign court claims the person first.

The general architecture surrounding that provision confirms the seriousness of the French commitment. Article 689 of the same Code states the broader principle: “Les auteurs ou complices d’infractions commises hors du territoire de la République peuvent être poursuivis et jugés par les juridictions françaises”, where the statute so provides. For torture, article 689-2 organises prosecution “Pour l’application de la convention contre la torture et autres peines ou traitements cruels, inhumains ou dégradants, adoptée à New York le 10 décembre 1984”, and the underlying offence is defined by article 222-1 of the Criminal Code: “Le fait de soumettre une personne à des tortures ou à des actes de barbarie est puni de quinze ans de réclusion criminelle.” The substantive definitions of the core crimes are equally precise. Genocide is defined by article 211-1 of the Criminal Code as “le fait, en exécution d’un plan concerté tendant à la destruction totale ou partielle d’un groupe national, ethnique, racial ou religieux, ou d’un groupe déterminé à partir de tout autre critère arbitraire, de commettre ou de faire commettre, à l’encontre de membres de ce groupe”, one of the listed acts, and it carries life imprisonment. Crimes against humanity are defined by article 212-1, which punishes with life imprisonment “l’un des actes ci-après commis en exécution d’un plan concerté à l’encontre d’un groupe de population civile dans le cadre d’une attaque généralisée ou systématique”. War crimes are defined by article 461-1 as the offences of that book “commises, lors d’un conflit armé international ou non international et en relation avec ce conflit, en violation des lois et coutumes de la guerre ou des conventions internationales applicables aux conflits armés”. A victim, witness or association in France is therefore not left without a forum if The Hague slows down: the definitions exist, the penalties exist, and the procedural channel exists.

The courts have given these texts teeth, and the leading decision deserves to be read closely. On 12 May 2023, the Court of Cassation sitting in plenary assembly, on appeal no. 22-82.468, rejected a challenge to French universal jurisdiction in a case concerning torture, enforced disappearances and war crimes imputed in the Syrian context. On the residence condition, the Court held that habitual residence within the meaning of article 689-11 requires a sufficient connecting link with France, assessed through a bundle of indicators such as the current or foreseeable duration of the stay, the conditions and reasons for the person’s presence on French territory, the wish they express to settle or remain there, and their family, social, material or professional ties. In that case, a presence of just over three months, documented by student cards, transport passes, telephone subscriptions and observed daily life, was enough for the investigating chamber to characterise habitual residence, and the plenary assembly upheld that assessment as a matter of sovereign fact-finding. The lesson for today is direct: the French residence threshold is demanding but not insurmountable, and it is assessed through a bundle of indicators rather than a fixed duration. On double criminality, the same decision recalled that the article requires acts prosecuted in France as crimes against humanity, other than genocide, or as war crimes to be punishable under the law of the state where they were committed, while leaving room for the contextual elements of those offences to be assessed under French characterisation. Practitioners should therefore build universal jurisdiction files methodically: proof of presence and anchoring in France, precise legal characterisation under articles 211-1, 212-1 and 461-1, and a conflicts check confirming that neither the ICC nor another state claims the suspect.

None of this means that French courts can simply replace the ICC. The monopoly of the anti-terrorism prosecution office over article 689-11 cases, the subsidiarity check in favour of the ICC or an extradition request, and the practical limits of investigating facts thousands of kilometres away all constrain what Paris can achieve alone. But the direction of travel is clear, and clients should understand it. If American sanctions degrade the Court’s capacity to open new investigations or to support the execution of its warrants, the rational response for victims and counsel in France is to prepare parallel domestic avenues early: complaints with constitution de partie civile where admissible, reports to the specialised prosecution office, preservation of evidence held in France, and coordination with associations already active before the specialised courts. The ICC’s troubles do not extinguish liability; they redistribute the forum. A suspect who can no longer be tried efficiently in The Hague may still face a French investigating judge, provided the statutory anchors hold, and that prospect itself sustains a measure of deterrence while the institutional crisis lasts.

B. Can a company or a bank in France keep working with the ICC despite American sanctions?

Under French and EU law, yes as a matter of principle, but only with careful compliance engineering, because the applicable American and European rules point in opposite directions. European law starts from the premise that foreign sanctions do not bind European operators. The EU Blocking Statute, Regulation 2271/96, prohibits EU persons from complying with certain listed foreign sanctions laws, and it offers a mechanism to recover damages caused by their extraterritorial application. Whether the October 2026 measures against the ICC will be brought within the operative scope of that instrument is a political decision for the Council and the Commission, but the legal toolbox exists and has been used in comparable transatlantic confrontations. At a minimum, no French statute obliges a bank in Paris to close the account of the ICC, to reject a transfer financing witness protection, or to terminate a software contract hosting judicial evidence, merely because Washington has designated the Court. French domestic freezing law works the other way round: article L. 562-2 of the Monetary and Financial Code allows the Minister for the Economy and the Minister of the Interior to order, jointly, “pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques” of designated persons, a targeted national mechanism that has nothing to do with giving effect to American designations in France. A French compliance officer who confuses an American designation with a French or EU freeze commits a legal error with commercial consequences, and that distinction should be the first line of every internal memo written in Paris this month.

The difficulty is that legality and risk are not the same thing. A French bank that processes euro payments for the Court commits no offence under French law by that fact alone, yet it may fear losing its dollar correspondent banking lines, facing American enforcement action against its own US operations, or triggering contractual clauses in which counterparties warrant compliance with American sanctions. This is the classic secondary sanctions dilemma, and it explains why service providers sometimes over-comply, withdrawing from entirely lawful business out of caution. Companies and institutions in France that work with the Court, or intend to bid for its contracts, should therefore adopt a documented posture rather than improvising. First, map every touchpoint with the American prohibitions: which payments clear in dollars, which contracts contain American sanctions clauses, which suppliers or insurers impose their own restrictions. Second, read the four American general licenses in their exact terms, since telecommunications, software, pension and detention-related transactions benefit from carve-outs that must be verified transaction by transaction and preserved in the compliance file with their dates and reference numbers, because licenses can change. Third, renegotiate where possible in euros, through European banks with limited American exposure, and insert balanced clauses allocating the sanctions risk expressly instead of relying on vague boilerplate that a counterparty may invoke to walk away. Fourth, keep a complete evidentiary trail of the European legal basis for continuing lawful business, including the absence of any applicable EU or French freeze against the Court, so that any later accusation of recklessness can be answered with documents rather than assertions.

Banks deserve a specific word, because they are the choke point. If French and European banks as a group refuse ICC business, the Court’s pledges to continue its work become theoretical, whatever the judges decide. European governments can address this bottleneck without dramatic gestures: public guidance to the banking sector confirming that ICC-related euro business is lawful, dialogue between supervisors and systemically important banks on de-risking excesses, and, where needed, the use of public financial institutions for sensitive transfers. France has recent experience with targeted national freezes and with the litigation they generate, and its courts know how to review them; readers facing an EU listing or a frozen account in a related sanctions context will find the method explained in our analysis of how to challenge an EU listing and frozen funds from France. The same discipline applies here in reverse: where an American measure, rather than a European one, purports to freeze lawful European activity, the answer is structured compliance, documented reliance on applicable law, and, where a European bank wrongly extends a foreign freeze to French territory, a firm reminder of which sovereign’s law governs the account. Individuals and companies whose funds are frozen under European or French measures have judicial remedies before the EU courts and the French courts; operators pressured to apply foreign measures that have no domestic legal basis have contractual and regulatory arguments that should be deployed early, before positions harden.

Two further practical tracks complete the picture. One is funding. The Court asked its member states to ensure it has the means to operate, and assessed contributions paid in full and on time are the simplest answer. France can also consider voluntary contributions earmarked for functions most exposed to sanctions friction, such as victim participation, witness protection and defence legal aid, provided such earmarking respects the Court’s independence. The other track is procurement and staffing. European nationals employed by the Court, pensioners receiving its payments, and contractors delivering services from EU territory need clarity on their personal exposure under American measures and reassurance that their home states stand behind them. Law firms advising such persons from Paris should examine travel exposure, asset exposure in American jurisdiction, and the interplay with professional secrecy and independence obligations, rather than offering blanket comfort. Each file is different: a French national with no American assets and no travel plans faces a different risk matrix from a dual-national contractor paid in dollars through an American bank. Granular advice, file by file, is the only honest product in this environment.

Conclusion

The events of 9 October 2026 will be remembered as the day the United States sanctioned the International Criminal Court within hours of the Nobel Peace Prize honouring one of its former judges. The American measures aim to ban transactions with the Court and to deter companies from serving it, softened only by general licenses whose scope must be verified case by case. The Court answered that its work across all situations, investigations and prosecutions will continue, and it placed its fate in the hands of the states that created it. For France and Europe, that appeal translates into three concrete duties. First, keep the Court financially alive through contributions, lawful euro banking channels and clear public guidance to operators. Second, activate the domestic safety net where the conditions are met, using the universal jurisdiction of article 689-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the definitions of articles 211-1, 212-1 and 461-1 of the Criminal Code, and the case law of the plenary assembly of 12 May 2023, so that impunity does not profit from institutional pressure. Third, refuse the confusion between American designations and European obligations: no French or EU freeze applies to the Court by virtue of the Washington announcement, and the EU Blocking Statute exists precisely for conflicts of this kind. History will judge this moment, as the Court said. It will judge governments on budgets and banking channels, counsel on the files they prepared rather than the statements they signed, and all of us on whether the promise made in Oslo, that war criminals are held to account and victims see justice served, survived its hardest test.

📄 Official circular