KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
UK Jails Vietnamese Smuggling Ring Busted With France: Will the 16 Arrested in France Be Surrendered or Tried in Bobigny?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

UK Jails Vietnamese Smuggling Ring Busted With France: Will the 16 Arrested in France Be Surrendered or Tried in Bobigny?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 17 September 2026, Eurojust announced that five people had been convicted in the United Kingdom for running a Vietnamese migrant-smuggling network and laundering more than 1.8 million euros through over 800 bank transfers back to Vietnam. Sentencing took place in London on 14 and 15 September: twelve years down to four years for facilitating smuggling, eight years down to two years for money laundering. The investigation started with a seizure by French customs officers of a package containing 22 Vietnamese passports, and it was run as a joint investigation team bringing together Belgium, France and the United Kingdom, with Eurojust and Europol coordinating. During a coordinated action day in March 2026, sixteen suspects were arrested in France and three in the United Kingdom. The French side of the case is handled by an investigative judge and the prosecution office of the Bobigny court, alongside the Central Office Against Migrant Smuggling based in Roissy, known as OLTIM. For an international reader, the striking feature of this case is how evidence collected on French soil ends up grounding convictions in a British courtroom after Brexit, and what happens next to the sixteen people arrested in France. Will London ask for their surrender, or will Bobigny try them? This article explains, from a French criminal lawyer’s point of view, how the joint team worked, how French evidence is used abroad, and which French charges and sentences the suspects arrested in France now face.

I. How a Franco-British joint team turned 22 passports into UK convictions

A. Why the French seizure of 22 Vietnamese passports decided the whole case

Every major smuggling prosecution has a starting point, and here it was French. According to Eurojust, the investigation began after French customs officers seized a package containing 22 Vietnamese passports. Those passports belonged to migrants travelling from France to the United Kingdom by small boats and lorries. That single seizure did three things at once: it identified the route, it identified the nationality of the victims, and it anchored French territorial jurisdiction over acts that were partly committed abroad. From that moment, the French authorities were not helping a foreign case from the outside. They were investigating their own case, on their own soil, for acts that French law punishes severely.

The business model described by Eurojust is the classic economics of organised smuggling. Migrants were charged up to 20,000 euros for the journey across the Channel. Those unable to pay were forced to work for the criminal group in what Eurojust calls debt bondage. Criminal proceeds of over 1.8 million euros were then laundered back to Vietnam through more than 800 bank transactions. Investigators spent over fifteen months tracing that laundered money through money transfer bureaus. Forensic examination of the phones seized during the arrests uncovered messages about the smuggling operation, sent through social media channels, in which the group discussed prices, flights, routes and vehicles, as well as the various workplaces where the migrants were forced to work under debt bondage. The suspects were arrested in late 2025, the case went to trial in August 2026, and sentencing followed on 14 and 15 September.

Under French law, the starting point for charging this kind of conduct is Article L. 823-1 of the Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners and the Right of Asylum, which provides that, subject to the exemptions in Article L. 823-9, “est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 30 000 euros d’amende le fait, pour toute personne, de faciliter ou de tenter de faciliter, par aide directe ou indirecte, l’entrée, la circulation ou le séjour irréguliers d’un étranger en France”. The same article expressly applies even where the acts are committed from the territory of another State party to the Schengen Convention, which matters directly here because the network moved people across borders and handled money from abroad. Five years and 30,000 euros is only the floor. Article L. 823-2 extends the same punishment to facilitation toward other Schengen States, and Article L. 823-3 raises the penalty dramatically where aggravating circumstances exist: “Sont punies de dix ans d’emprisonnement et de 750 000 euros d’amende les infractions définies aux articles L. 823-1 et L. 823-2 lorsque les faits : 1° Sont commis en bande organisée ; 2° Sont commis dans des circonstances qui exposent directement les étrangers à un risque immédiat de mort ou de blessures”. A structured group moving migrants across the Channel by small boat ticks both boxes at once: organised gang and direct exposure to a risk of death at sea. That is why, had the French leg of this network been tried in Bobigny rather than London, the prosecution would have been looking at the ten-year bracket from the outset.

One nuance must be stated clearly, because it protects the wrong people from the wrong charge. Article L. 823-9 provides that “L’aide à la circulation ou au séjour irréguliers d’un étranger ne peut donner lieu à des poursuites pénales sur le fondement des articles L. 823-1 ou L. 823-2 lorsqu’elle est le fait : 1° Des ascendants ou descendants de l’étranger, de leur conjoint, des frères et sœurs de l’étranger ou de leur conjoint”, and the article continues with further family and humanitarian exemptions. Family members who help a relative, and humanitarian actors who provide disinterested assistance, are sheltered. Professional smugglers who charge 20,000 euros a head and impose forced labour on those who cannot pay are the exact opposite of that shelter, and no court in France would extend the exemption to them.

The debt-bondage dimension deserves separate attention because it changes the legal qualification. Eurojust reports that migrants unable to pay were forced to work for the group. In French law, that pattern points beyond smuggling toward trafficking in human beings. Article 225-4-1 of the Criminal Code defines trafficking as “le fait de recruter une personne, de la transporter, de la transférer, de l’héberger ou de l’accueillir à des fins d’exploitation” in listed circumstances, including “en échange ou par l’octroi d’une rémunération ou de tout autre avantage ou d’une promesse de rémunération ou d’avantage”. The base penalty is seven years and 150,000 euros. Where the offence is committed with aggravating circumstances, Article 225-4-2 raises it to ten years of imprisonment and a 1,500,000 euro fine, and Article 225-4-3 provides that “L’infraction prévue à l’article 225-4-1 est punie de vingt ans de réclusion criminelle et de 3 000 000 euros d’amende lorsqu’elle est commise en bande organisée”. Twenty years and three million euros: that is the ceiling the ringleaders of a network like this one would face in a French assize court.

French case law has already closed one escape route the defence might try on the trafficking point. In a judgment of 26 November 2024, No. 23-85.798, the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected the appeals of defendants convicted of trafficking, forced concealed labour and employment of a foreigner without a work permit, and held, and I quote the Court word for word: “il ressort tant des termes de l’article 225-4-1 du code pénal dans sa version issue de la loi n° 2013-711 du 5 août 2013 que des travaux préparatoires de cette dernière que la traite d’être humain peut être caractérisée par le fait de recruter, transporter, héberger une personne ou de l’accueillir à des fins d’exploitation, en échange ou par l’octroi ou la promesse d’une rémunération à celle-ci, sans qu’il soit besoin de constater que l’auteur a agi ainsi en échange d’une rémunération ou de la promesse d’une rémunération”. In plain terms, paying exploited workers a derisory wage, or dangling the promise of one, does not defeat a trafficking charge. It confirms it. The Vietnamese migrants put to work in workplaces identified through the seized phones, under debt bondage, fit that pattern exactly, and the Court even ordered the convicted defendants to pay 2,500 euros to the victims’ association admitted as a civil party, which shows how French courts pair punishment with compensation.

B. Can evidence gathered in France convict in London, and how can it be challenged in Bobigny

The second striking feature of this case is procedural. Eurojust states that international judicial cooperation was key, that it coordinated the cooperation through a joint investigation team involving the Belgian, French and British authorities, and that the team enabled fast and efficient collaboration as well as the smooth exchange of information and evidence. A joint investigation team, called équipe commune d’enquête in French practice, is the instrument created precisely for this kind of case: investigators and magistrates from several countries work on the same file at the same time, share what they find in real time, and agree in advance how each piece of evidence will be used in each national proceedings. The French member of such a team acts within a European framework in which Eurojust supports the setting up and running of the teams, and the evidence each country collects can then be introduced before the other countries’ courts without starting a separate mutual-assistance request for every document.

That matters enormously after Brexit, because the United Kingdom no longer participates in the European Arrest Warrant or the European Investigation Order as a Member State, and every transfer of evidence and every surrender now runs through the European Union-United Kingdom Trade and Cooperation Agreement of 24 December 2020 and classic mutual legal assistance. The fact that London secured convictions in August 2026 on the back of a file opened by a French customs seizure shows that the post-Brexit machinery works when a joint team is set up early. The 22 passports seized in France, the money-transfer records traced over fifteen months, the phone extractions and the social-media messages about prices, flights, routes, vehicles and forced-labour workplaces all travelled from the French and Belgian files into the British trial, and the jury or court that convicted the five defendants plainly accepted them.

For the defence, that cross-border journey of the evidence is also the first battlefield. Evidence lawfully gathered in France does not become unchallengeable simply because it is presented in London, and evidence gathered for London does not become unchallengeable simply because it sits in a Bobigny file. In France, unlawfully obtained evidence can be annulled by the investigating chamber on a motion for nullity, and seasoned defence lawyers in a joint-team case systematically audit four things: whether each search, seizure, interception and phone extraction respected the French Code of Criminal Procedure; whether the foreign acts carried out by British or Belgian officers on French territory stayed within the powers the joint-team agreement gave them; whether the chain of custody of the 800 bank transfers and the phone data is complete; and whether the accused were informed of their rights at every stage, including during the coordinated arrests of March 2026. A gap at any of these points can lead to the annulment of specific exhibits, and in a case built on documents and data, losing exhibits can collapse counts.

The money-laundering leg of the case illustrates why the tracing work mattered so much. French courts do not allow laundering convictions to rest on cash alone. On 25 June 2025, in No. 24-85.882, the Criminal Chamber quashed a Rennes appeal judgment that had convicted defendants of laundering merely because one of them had been found carrying large bundles of banknotes in a bag, recalling word for word: “Selon ce texte, constitue notamment un blanchiment le fait d’apporter son concours à une opération de dissimulation du produit direct ou indirect d’un crime ou d’un délit”, and holding that the mere transport of sums, even hidden in a bag, is not enough to characterise an act of placement, concealment or conversion. That is exactly why fifteen months of tracing through money transfer bureaus changes everything: 800 documented transfers from the smuggling proceeds back to Vietnam show placement, layering and conversion, not mere possession of cash. Whoever defends the sixteen people arrested in France will have to answer those 800 transfers one by one, because French law defines laundering as “le fait de faciliter, par tout moyen, la justification mensongère de l’origine des biens ou des revenus de l’auteur d’un crime ou d’un délit ayant procuré à celui-ci un profit direct ou indirect” and as “le fait d’apporter un concours à une opération de placement, de dissimulation ou de conversion du produit direct ou indirect d’un crime ou d’un délit”, punishable by five years of imprisonment and a 375,000 euro fine, rising under Article 324-2 to ten years and 750,000 euros where it is committed habitually, through professional facilities, or in an organised gang. A network that moved 1.8 million euros in 800 operations through bureaus de change sits squarely in the aggravated bracket.

On the British side of the mirror, the convictions rest on the same conduct described in different statutory language. Section 2 of the Modern Slavery Act 2015 provides that “A person commits an offence if the person arranges or facilitates the travel of another person (“V”) with a view to V being exploited”, adding that “It is irrelevant whether V consents to the travel (whether V is an adult or a child)”, and the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 punishes anyone who conceals, disguises, converts, transfers or removes criminal property from the jurisdiction. The sentences imposed in London, up to twelve years for the smuggling counts and up to eight for the laundering counts, show how seriously British courts treat the combination. The European framework behind the French charges is the same policy expressed in EU law, in particular the Anti-Trafficking Directive 2011/36/EU and the Framework Decision on the European Arrest Warrant 2002/584/JHA, whose current texts are available on EUR-Lex for the trafficking directive and on EUR-Lex for the arrest-warrant framework decision. One criminal business, three national procedures, one coordinated file: that is what a joint investigation team is for.

II. The sixteen arrested in France: surrender to London or trial before French courts

A. Will France hand its suspects to the United Kingdom after Brexit

Sixteen suspects were arrested in France during the coordinated action day of March 2026, against three in the United Kingdom. The five defendants convicted in London are therefore only part of the network. The question every family of the French arrestees is asking now is simple: will France surrender them to the United Kingdom for a second trial, or will France try them itself? The answer runs through the post-Brexit surrender regime, and recent French case law gives a clear preview of how the Bobigny investigating chamber and the Paris Court of Appeal would reason.

Since 1 January 2021, surrenders between France and the United Kingdom are governed exclusively by the surrender title of the Trade and Cooperation Agreement of 24 December 2020, not by the European Arrest Warrant Framework Decision, which no longer binds London. The procedure looks familiar to anyone who knows the warrant system: a British judicial authority issues an arrest warrant, the French prosecution office refers it to the investigating chamber, the person sought can consent or fight, detention pending surrender is decided by the chamber, and the Court of Cassation reviews points of law. But the grounds for refusing surrender are those listed in the Agreement, interpreted by French courts, and they are narrower than many defendants hope. This firm recently analysed how France executes European surrenders in practice, including the 29 July 2026 decision clearing the surrender of Romania’s Prince Paul, which shows that Paris courts order surrender swiftly once the legal conditions are met.

The most important recent precedent for the sixteen is a Criminal Chamber judgment of 2 May 2024, No. 24-82.116, which rejected the appeal of a man whose surrender to the United Kingdom had been ordered under the Agreement. He argued that the sentence he might receive in Britain would be disproportionate by French standards and contrary to French public policy. The Court answered, word for word: “le caractère éventuellement disproportionné de la peine encourue dans l’État d’émission ne figure pas parmi les motifs de non-exécution d’un mandat d’arrêt décerné en application de l’Accord de commerce et de coopération entre l’Union européenne et le Royaume-Uni du 24 décembre 2020”. In other words, the French surrender judge does not compare the British sentence scale with the French one, and the fact that London has just imposed twelve-year sentences on this network’s operatives gives the sixteen no argument against being sent across the Channel. The Court added that the Agreement provides no refusal ground based on a penalty contrary to French public policy, and that the surrender procedure is governed solely by the Agreement’s provisions.

That does not mean surrender is automatic. Three practical defences remain open, and each must be prepared from the first appearance. First, nationality and residence: Article 603 of the Agreement lets a State notify that its own nationals will not be surrendered, or will be surrendered only under specified conditions, and in that case requires it to consider prosecuting them at home instead, so the personal situation of each of the sixteen must be mapped immediately against Article 603 of the surrender title of the Trade and Cooperation Agreement. Second, the specialty rule and the applicable penalty threshold: surrender can only be granted for offences meeting the Agreement’s seriousness conditions, and the French chamber verifies the description of the facts against the warrant. Third, fundamental rights: where surrender would expose the person to inhuman detention conditions or a flagrant denial of justice, French courts can and do refuse or seek guarantees, as the litigation over French prison overcrowding before Dutch courts this summer has shown in the mirror direction, with Amsterdam refusing surrenders to France and a French interim ruling of 10 September 2026 answering it. A defence team in Bobigny should therefore prepare two files in parallel from day one: the fight against surrender in Paris, and the fight on the merits in case surrender is ordered or France decides to prosecute itself.

There is also a strategic choice that belongs to the prosecution, not the defence, and Eurojust exists precisely to arbitrate it: which country is best placed to prosecute. With convictions already secured in London for five defendants, the British authorities could request the sixteen for a joint trial, or France could keep them and open its own trial in Bobigny or before the Paris criminal court, using the very same joint-team evidence. Double jeopardy rules forbid trying the same person twice for the same facts once a final judgment exists, but the sixteen have not been tried yet, so both options remain legally open. Eurojust’s coordination meetings are where that decision is taken, and the defence must make its voice heard there through the French prosecution office, arguing where appropriate that a trial in France, closer to the evidence, the witnesses and the families, serves justice better than a second transfer to London.

B. If Bobigny prosecutes: trafficking, smuggling and laundering sentences in French courts

If France keeps the case, the sixteen face a French criminal trial built on the joint-team file, and the charges available to the Bobigny prosecution are heavier than many realise. Start with smuggling proper. As shown above, Article L. 823-1 punishes facilitation of irregular entry, movement or residence by five years and 30,000 euros, Article L. 823-2 extends it across Schengen borders, and Article L. 823-3 takes it to ten years and 750,000 euros for organised-gang commission or direct exposure of foreigners to an immediate risk of death or mutilating injury. Small-boat crossings of the Channel, repeatedly described as one of the world’s most dangerous maritime smuggling routes, make the second aggravating circumstance almost self-evident, and a joint team that documents sixteen arrests in one country and a coordinated structure across three makes the first one hard to contest. Each crossing, each lorry load, each set of passports can be charged as a separate count, and French courts routinely impose consecutive reasoning that pushes total sentences far above the single-count figure.

Add trafficking where debt bondage is proved. The migrants forced to work to repay their 20,000 euro passage are not merely smuggled customers. They are exploited workers, and Article 225-4-1 covers recruitment, transport, transfer, harbouring or receipt for exploitation purposes. The 2024 Court of Cassation ruling quoted above means the defence cannot escape by showing the workers received some money: derisory pay or its promise confirms trafficking rather than negating it. At ten years and 1,500,000 euros in aggravated form under Article 225-4-2, and twenty years of criminal imprisonment and a 3,000,000 euro fine in an organised gang under Article 225-4-3, trafficking is the charge that turns a smuggling file into an assize-court file. Ringleaders who organised routes, set prices, ran the money circuit and assigned forced workplaces face that ceiling. Drivers, lookouts, passport handlers and money collectors face lower but still severe sentences as accomplices or gang members, and French law on organised gangs allows the court to capture the whole pyramid.

Add laundering, and the financial investigation becomes the second pillar of the trial. The 800 transfers totalling 1.8 million euros, traced over fifteen months through money transfer bureaus, are the kind of documentary evidence French courts expect after the Court of Cassation’s warning that cash alone does not prove laundering. Each transfer can support a count of assisting the placement, concealment or conversion of criminal proceeds, aggravated to ten years and 750,000 euros where committed habitually or in an organised gang. And conviction opens the door to confiscation on a scale that dwarfs the fines. Article 324-7 lists the additional penalties for laundering, including “La confiscation de la chose qui a servi ou était destinée à commettre l’infraction ou de la chose qui en est le produit” and “La confiscation de tout ou partie des biens du condamné”, whatever their nature, movable or immovable, divided or undivided. Vehicles, boats, safe houses, bank balances, money-service accounts: everything the network touched can be seized and ultimately confiscated, and French courts use these provisions aggressively in organised-crime cases.

Two categories of people present in this file must be treated differently, and a careful lawyer insists on the distinction from the first police interview. The migrants themselves, including those who worked under debt bondage, are victims and witnesses, not defendants, even if they initially paid for the crossing. French practice, consistent with European standards, treats coerced consent as no consent, exactly as section 2 of the British Modern Slavery Act does when it says the victim’s consent to travel is irrelevant. Pressuring victims risks losing their testimony and violating their protection. The second category is the small hands of the network: drivers, landlords of safe houses, couriers. They face real prison time, but their cases are also the ones where cooperation with justice, restitution of proceeds and demonstrated exit from the network can meaningfully reduce sentences. In a sixteen-defendant French trial, the race to cooperate starts early, and the first ones to give a full and sincere account of the hierarchy, the money circuit and the workplaces are the ones judges remember at sentencing.

Conclusion

The Eurojust announcement of 17 September 2026 closes one chapter and opens another. Five smugglers convicted in London, sentences up to twelve years, 1.8 million euros traced through 800 transfers: the joint investigation team of Belgium, France and the United Kingdom worked, and it worked after Brexit. But sixteen suspects arrested in France in March 2026 are still waiting to learn their fate, and their cases will test the post-Brexit surrender machinery, the French law of smuggling and trafficking, and the courts’ willingness to confiscate every euro of a cross-Channel criminal business. Whether they are surrendered to London under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement or tried in Bobigny and Paris, the file built from 22 Vietnamese passports seized by French customs will follow them. Anyone arrested, questioned or sought in a case like this one needs a lawyer who understands both sides of the Channel from day one: the surrender fight and the trial fight, the nullity motions and the money trail, the victims to protect and the sentences to reduce. That double preparation is what decides, in these cross-border cases, between a second conviction and a second chance.

📄 Official circular