KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
WestJet Flight Schedule Change Dispute: A Canadian Ruling and Your Rights on France–Canada Flights

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

WestJet Flight Schedule Change Dispute: A Canadian Ruling and Your Rights on France–Canada Flights

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The Civil Resolution Tribunal of British Columbia published a November 13, 2026 decision involving WestJet, 2026 BCCRT 1623. The decision concerns a cancelled flight and overnight rerouting on a 2024 trip from Cancún to Kamloops. The tribunal recorded that the airline rerouted the travellers and acknowledged their entitlement to reimbursement for meal expenses, while disputing the amount. It awarded compensation and part of the claimed expenses. The Canadian Press reported the ruling on November 16, in coverage carried by CBC News.

The coverage raises a separate practical question for Canadians holding tickets between France and Canada. Can you ask for a different flight, a refund or payment for expenses if the carrier changes the schedule? The answer turns on where the affected flight starts, who actually operates it, what the change does to the original flight and what you can document. A flight leaving Paris and the return from Canada can fall under different rules even when both appear on the same ticket.

The guidance below describes the checks that apply in comparable situations and makes no finding about the airline, its France–Canada services or any other booking. The published decision concerns the specified itinerary and claim. The sources cited establish no accident or injury. Your booking and applicable fare terms matter, subject to mandatory passenger protections. Only the court or tribunal hearing a disputed claim can determine liability in that case.

I. Flight schedule change dispute on a France–Canada ticket

A. Which flight and which airline operated it?

Start with the original booking confirmation. Mark the flight that changed, its departure airport, the scheduled arrival at the destination on that booking and the operating carrier. If the confirmation lists two airlines, find the line that says operated by. The airline whose code appears first, the travel agency that took the payment and the airline operating the aircraft can be three different businesses. Keep both carrier names in your file. Under Articles 2(b) and 3(5) of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, the duties at issue fall on the transporteur aérien effectif (operating air carrier), including when it performs the flight on behalf of an undertaking that contracted with the passenger.

A flight from Paris to Canada falls geographically within Article 3(1)(a), including when operated by a Canadian airline. On a direct Canada-to-Paris flight, Article 3(1)(b) requires an EU carrier and separately addresses whether the passenger received benefits or compensation and assistance in the country of departure. A direct return actually operated by a Canadian airline therefore does not qualify under that provision merely because it lands in France, carries a European marketing code or was bought with the outbound ticket. If a European airline operates the return, check whether any assistance or compensation was already received in Canada before assessing that claim. The Paris Judicial Court, March 26, 2026, No 25/04687, applied this geographic distinction to a return to Charles de Gaulle on a non-EU carrier and examined the claim for expenses under the Montreal Convention.

Look at the legs separately when the itinerary changes at an intermediate airport. For example, on a Paris–Toronto itinerary sold through to another Canadian city, the confirmation for the complete trip helps establish the original final destination. Article 2(h) of the regulation defines the final destination by reference to the ticket presented at check-in or, for directly connecting flights, the destination of the last flight. A train or flight purchased independently to continue the trip should be recorded separately. Keep its confirmation and refund terms. Its cost may be relevant to a claim for proven loss, while the time you finally reached that separate destination should not simply replace the scheduled arrival on the airline reservation when calculating the regulatory claim.

A return sold on the same receipt can still be a different flight for territorial coverage. The question is especially important if a new itinerary interchanges a codeshare or gives you a flight number without specifying the operator. Compare the operator for the disrupted original service and the operator of any replacement. Keep the confirmation that was in force before the airline changed the booking. The arrival information on the replacement itinerary shows what was offered, while the old confirmation provides the comparison for the schedule you initially booked. When the airport or the operator changes and the status remains unclear, ask the carrier to confirm in writing whether the original flight operated and on what schedule.

Keep ticket numbers, proof of payment and the date of the first notice. The lead passenger in a family booking should save the message before a travel app overwrites the itinerary. If one person received messages for the entire reservation, record which names were on it. Screenshots of airport departure information can corroborate a change, and the original confirmation establishes what you personally booked. If the agency and the carrier send different messages, keep both along with their timestamps and time zones. The sequence may explain why one passenger took a different flight or paid for an overnight stay.

B. Can you get a refund or a different flight when the schedule changes?

Read the old and new departure times in local time, then ask what happened to the original service. A cancellation has a specific definition in Article 2(l): « le fait qu’un vol qui était prévu initialement et sur lequel au moins une place était réservée n’a pas été effectué » (the non-operation of a flight that was previously planned and on which at least one seat was reserved). A generic schedule-change notification could describe an adjustment, the cancellation of the booked service and a transfer to another flight, or a substantial move to an earlier departure. The airline’s email subject is evidence of what it told you. The old and new itineraries and actual operation help establish which rules apply.

A move to a departure more than one hour earlier is treated as a cancellation under EU law, as the Court of Justice held on December 21, 2021 in Azurair and Others, joined cases including C‑146/20, and as the Beauvais Judicial Court, December 18, 2025, No 24/01552, recalls. An itinerary originally scheduled to leave Paris at 16:00 and advanced to 14:45 illustrates that rule. A 16:00 flight moved to 15:30 does not cross that threshold by itself. There can still be a cancellation if the original service is dropped and the traveller is moved to a different flight. Check both the size of the shift and whether the original flight actually operated.

For an in-scope cancellation, Article 8(1) of the regulation provides a choice. The passenger may seek reimbursement for the unused parts of the ticket and for parts already used if the flight no longer serves the original travel plan, with a return to the initial point of departure when relevant. The other options are rerouting to the final destination under comparable conditions at the earliest opportunity or at a later date convenient to the passenger, subject to seat availability. Ask for the earliest rerouting if you still need to travel. If the trip has lost its purpose, explain why and identify the portions of the ticket for which you seek a refund.

Before pressing a refund button, read the page that describes what the button does. A form may offer to return the fare and remove the reservation. A travel credit may have separate terms. If the earliest option offered leaves you stranded for an extra night and other departures are available, write to the carrier with specific alternatives, including dates, flight numbers and current availability. If you later buy a replacement, retain both the request and the reply, or a screenshot showing that no workable offer was available. Record what the second ticket covered and whether part of the original fare was returned. The evidence will explain why the expense was incurred and help distinguish a rerouting issue from a refund the passenger already elected.

For a cancellation covered by the regulation, a refund or rerouting is a separate question from standard compensation. Article 5(1)(c) and (4), also discussed in Beauvais, No 24/01552, make the timing of notification and the departure and arrival times of the replacement relevant to the compensation claim. For example, notification at least two weeks before scheduled departure excludes standard compensation for cancellation under Article 5(1)(c)(i). Article 8 still governs the reimbursement or rerouting choice. Article 5(3) provides a separate defence to standard compensation where the carrier proves extraordinary circumstances that could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken. Keep the time the notice reached you and the specific explanation the airline gave. A change of schedule itself does not establish whether a defence is available.

Article 7 sets a standard amount of €600 for a qualifying Paris–Canada cancellation on a route longer than 3,500 km, subject to the conditions and applicable exceptions. Under Article 7(2)(c), a rerouting whose arrival does not exceed the original scheduled arrival by four hours can allow a reduction of half in the situations covered by that provision. The Azurair judgment rules out using that reduction solely because the substantially advanced flight arrives early. Specify the relevant basis in your claim and avoid quoting a headline amount without checking the carrier, the disrupted flight and the evidence of notification.

II. Flight delay compensation and expenses on a transatlantic booking

A. What can you claim for meals, a hotel or a missed booking?

Put the expenses into two groups. The first is what you needed while waiting for a flight, such as a meal at the departure airport or a hotel needed for an overnight rerouting. The second is what you lost or had to purchase because you reached your destination late, such as a room paid for and unusable or a replacement onward ticket. The reason for each expense matters. The price of a room on a hotel invoice says nothing about whether it was bought during an overnight wait, booked as part of the original trip or used on arrival after other transport had stopped running.

For a covered cancellation or a delay that triggers the relevant provisions, Articles 5, 6 and 9 set out the right to care, including meals and refreshments in a reasonable relation to waiting time and, when the conditions are met, accommodation and transfers. In Cour de cassation, February 14, 2018, No 16‑20.354, France’s highest civil court distinguished care during an overnight wait from an individual claim for hotel costs incurred after arrival. It set aside the dismissal of the latter claim because the passenger relied on Article 19 of the Montreal Convention. It left the claim to be decided on remand. It did not simply order payment of the hotel bill. The judgment explains why you should identify the legal basis and the moment at which the expense became necessary.

Article 19 of the Montreal Convention addresses proven damage from delay in international carriage. The Toulouse Judicial Court, June 26, 2026, No 25/04997, quotes the rule as follows: « Le transporteur est responsable du dommage résultant d’un retard dans le transport aérien de passagers, de bagages ou de marchandises. » (The carrier is liable for damage occasioned by delay in the carriage by air of passengers, baggage or cargo.) The rest of Article 19 permits a defence if the carrier proves that it and those acting for it took all measures reasonably required to avoid the damage or that it was impossible to take them. Toulouse awarded damages on the evidence in that particular case. The award supplies no fixed tariff for a future France–Canada claim.

The Paris judgment No 25/04687 shows how the claim can work for an inbound flight outside EU261. The passengers submitted evidence of expenses for their onward journey and the court assessed which costs resulted from the disruption. Compare that with Paris Judicial Court, January 8, 2026, No 25/04538. There, the court rejected a claim that relied by analogy on the EU flat amount without explaining the actual replacement arrangements or the financial or psychological consequences of the cancellation. In another decision of January 8, 2026, No 25/04537, a claim referring essentially to the duration of a delay and a flat amount failed for want of evidence of the loss and its value.

For example, if you land a day late in Paris and miss a prepaid train, keep its ticket, fare conditions, evidence of any amount refunded and proof of the new booking. If you were offered a hotel but bought another room, record when and where the room was offered, how you could get there and why you needed an alternative. If you claim for a room lost at the destination, keep the original reservation, its cancellation terms and the hotel’s response to a request for a refund or change. Use the same approach for other costs: record what you would have paid anyway, the extra amount actually paid, the reason for the difference and any money already recovered. Save itemized receipts in the original currency and the corresponding payment record.

Courts can assess documented costs and the particular consequences of a delay without importing the EU flat rate. The Nantes Judicial Court, March 27, 2026, No 24/02029, distinguished the two regimes and specifically addressed meal receipts. Under Montreal, the liability limit is a ceiling and evidence still determines the loss. The International Civil Aviation Organization’s notice on the revised limits gives the passenger-delay limit as 6,303 Special Drawing Rights from December 28, 2024. Special Drawing Rights are an international unit of account. The original convention text and some published judgments reproduce earlier figures. For a current claim, check which limit applies to the date in question. When both EU compensation and a separate loss are claimed, Article 12 of EU261 allows the EU compensation to be deducted from further compensation. Identify all amounts already received and the expense or entitlement to which they relate.

B. How do you put a flight schedule change claim together?

Send the carrier a single chronology that starts with the booking you paid for. Give the affected flight number, original departure and arrival, date and time of the first change message, replacement offered and actual arrival if you travelled. State what you asked for and what the carrier provided. A screenshot of a booking application may be useful, but keep the original confirmation email, a PDF receipt and a copy of your submission as well. France’s Code of Civil Procedure, Article 9, states: « Il incombe à chaque partie de prouver conformément à la loi les faits nécessaires au succès de sa prétention. » (Each party must prove, in accordance with the law, the facts necessary for its claim to succeed.) Documents that show both the booking and what actually happened make the claim easier to assess.

Put a separate amount beside each request. For a ticket refund, identify the unused journey and payments already returned. For care expenses, list the meals, nights and transfers by date. For delay damages, describe why each additional expense resulted from the disruption and attach the supporting documents. For a standard EU payment, identify the flight, the operating carrier and the applicable circumstances so the airline can answer that request separately. If the booking covered three people but only one paid for the room, identify the payer and enter the invoice once. Record each traveller’s identity and booking reference where an entitlement is individual. If you accept a voucher or a partial payment, keep the exact terms and state which head of claim it addresses.

If a carrier refuses payment because the itinerary was arranged by an agency or sold under a partner airline’s code, ask which company operated the disrupted original flight and which booking records support that conclusion. If the refusal cites weather or a restriction, ask the carrier to identify the flight and the event to which it refers. Keep the reply with the original request. A refusal that deals with a claim for standard compensation does not by itself account for separately requested care or loss. For an in-scope EU departure, the carrier is the first point of contact for a claim. France’s aviation regulator can be approached about compliance for French departures under the enforcement framework in Article 16 of EU261. A regulatory report and a court claim for payment serve different purposes.

If the claim is for damages under the Montreal Convention, identify the potential court separately. Article 33(1) lists alternatives connected to the carrier’s domicile, principal place of business, place of business through which the contract was made, or place of destination, within a State Party. The Toulouse judgment No 25/04997 applied the destination ground to the itinerary before it. Keep the complete booking for a round trip or a route with connections before deciding where the contractual destination lies. Article 35 provides that the right to damages is extinguished if an action is not brought within two years, counted from arrival at destination, the date the aircraft ought to have arrived, or the date carriage stopped, as applicable. The Paris Court of Appeal, October 3, 2024, No 23/03263, applies that rule. The starting point concerns the transport identified in the claim, so establish it from the documents and assess the court filing date separately from the date of your correspondence with the airline.

For further context on the rules applicable in France, see the firm’s French aviation law practice page. Keep the carrier’s final reply, the claim reference and the original files together. A short note of what remains disputed helps if the booking involves more than one party or if the airline refunds one part of the claim while declining the rest.

Conclusion

For a changed France–Canada itinerary, identify the disrupted original flight, its operator and the passenger’s final destination before choosing what to request. On an eligible departure from Paris, EU261 can support rerouting or a refund and, where the conditions are satisfied, care or a standard payment. For a return operated by a Canadian carrier, a claim under the Montreal Convention can address evidenced losses from delay. Save the old booking, the change notice, the replacement offer and the receipts. Set out each expense and payment separately. The cited proceedings establish no accident or injury on the France–Canada services discussed here. The applicable booking terms and mandatory rules govern the individual claim, and any contested liability is for the competent court to decide.

📄 Official circular