KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Will Scharf: How congressional subpoenas and contempt enforcement work

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Will Scharf: How congressional subpoenas and contempt enforcement work

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

A letter dated November 9, 2026, bearing the signature of White House Counsel Will Scharf, addressed a member of Congress about congressional oversight. In the letter, reproduced in full by a news organization, the counsel argued that congressional investigations and subpoenas must serve a legitimate legislative purpose. The letter states a position. It does not establish that a particular subpoena has been issued or that a court has found anyone responsible for a crime.

The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about Scharf’s situation. For a person who actually receives a congressional subpoena, the immediate task is to identify the issuing body, what it demands and the response date, and then distinguish a legal objection from simply ignoring the demand. A subpoena, a committee vote, a referral for possible prosecution, an indictment, and a conviction are different events. Each has its own record and decision maker.

Federal law and decisions of the Supreme Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit provide the framework below. The precise result depends on the issuing chamber, the recipient, the information requested, and any properly presented privilege. A public dispute over possible future oversight does not answer those questions for an individual witness.

I. What should a recipient check when Congress seeks testimony or documents?

A. Identify the actual demand and the committee’s authority

Start with the document itself. A public statement that a committee intends to investigate is not the same as a subpoena addressed to a particular person. A voluntary request may also differ from a compulsory demand. Read the cover letter, attachments, definitions, schedules, and any instructions together. Identify whether the document calls for testimony, documents, a deposition, or a combination. Note the person or organization named as recipient, the subjects, the place or method of response, and the date specified for each item.

Then identify the source of the issuing authority. Congressional committees do not all operate under the same delegated power or procedures. The relevant chamber’s rules, the resolution creating a select committee, and the committee’s own rules may each matter. For example, the House Oversight Committee rules for the 119th Congress address subpoena authority, depositions, witness representation, and privilege assertions. Those are rules for that committee and Congress; they are not a substitute for the rules governing another committee or a later Congress.

Under those 119th Congress rules, the committee chair has authority to issue subpoenas as provided in the cited House rule. The same committee’s deposition rules allow a witness to be accompanied by two designated personal, nongovernmental attorneys. The rules also describe a process for objections and a chair’s ruling on privilege. A recipient should check the version attached to the demand or otherwise applicable to the proceeding, rather than assume that every hearing and every deposition follows this example.

Keep the envelope or electronic transmission, the complete demand, and subsequent correspondence. If pages are missing or an attachment cannot be opened, record the problem and ask the issuing office for the complete material. Identify who in an organization holds the relevant records, who received the demand, and whether the demand is directed to an individual, an entity, or both. Those practical distinctions help prevent a response from overlooking a category of material or confusing personal records with organizational records.

Do not edit, delete, or alter potentially responsive material while deciding how to respond. A useful first inventory describes where records are held, the people who may control them, and which categories appear to be requested. A factual inventory is different from a legal conclusion that all records must be produced. It also makes a request for clarification more concrete: a recipient can identify a particular period, system, or category that is difficult to understand instead of sending a general objection with no reference to the demand.

Check whether the committee requests information about conduct in a personal capacity or material created in an official role. The distinction can matter when a claim concerns government confidentiality. It can also matter whether a record is a communication with a government official, an attachment, a personal note, or a document already made public. Labeling everything with the same objection obscures those differences. Preserve the context and keep a record of any proposal to narrow or clarify the request.

A response date on the face of a demand is a practical fact to record, not proof that a particular extension or legal consequence automatically applies. If compliance will be difficult, explain the specific problem to the issuing office and obtain any agreed change in writing. A conversation about a possible accommodation is not itself the same as a written change to the demand. Keep both the original and the response so the sequence is clear.

B. Separate legislative purpose, personal rights, and executive privilege

Congressional inquiry is connected to Congress’s legislative work, but that does not mean every demand is evaluated in the same way. The federal Constitution creates the legislative branch and includes the Speech or Debate Clause. A court considering a particular dispute looks at the legal question before it, the recipient, and the circumstances, rather than deciding the validity of all future investigations at once.

In Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP, 591 U.S. 848 (2020), the Supreme Court of the United States on July 9, 2020, addressed congressional subpoenas seeking a sitting President’s personal financial information from third parties. It vacated the lower courts’ judgments and remanded for a more careful separation-of-powers analysis, identifying the legislative purpose, breadth, supporting evidence, and burdens on the President as relevant considerations. For a reader, the decision shows why the identity of the recipient and the precise records sought matter when assessing a subpoena involving a President. In Trump v. Slaughter, No. 25-332 (Supreme Court June 29, 2026), the Supreme Court of the United States considered the removal of a Federal Trade Commission commissioner; a dissent cited Mazars on the weight of historical practice in separation-of-powers disputes. That later citation was in a dissent and did not decide a congressional subpoena dispute.

The four considerations discussed in that Supreme Court decision arose in a particular conflict involving the President’s personal information. A recipient should not assume the identical analysis automatically decides an ordinary demand to a private witness or a request for confidential government communications. The decision also recognized that recipients can raise relevant constitutional and common-law privileges. The practical check is to identify the specific interest at stake and the facts that support it, rather than rely on a slogan about congressional power or presidential power.

The Fifth Amendment provides that no person shall be compelled in a criminal case to be a witness against themselves. How that protection applies to a particular question or requested material requires attention to the facts and the applicable proceeding. The amendment is not the same thing as executive privilege. One concerns a person’s protection against compelled self-incrimination; the other concerns government confidentiality and separation of powers. A single demand can raise more than one question, but the factual basis and the person entitled to assert each protection may differ.

For an executive-branch record, identify the particular communication, the people involved, their roles, and the privilege being asserted. In the 119th Congress rules linked above, the House Oversight Committee states what information it expects in a document privilege log and says the chair will consider an executive-privilege assertion made in writing by an executive official authorized to assert it. That is the committee’s rule for its own process; it does not by itself resolve whether a privilege applies or whether a court would sustain a particular claim.

For testimony, a recipient can separate the question of appearing from the question of answering a particular question. Those are not interchangeable steps. The scope of an objection, what was communicated to the committee, and any ruling or later judicial proceeding can all matter. Retaining a copy of the actual demand and the precise written objections allows those questions to be assessed against a real record.

If an issuing office offers an accommodation, document its terms. A narrower set of topics, a different date, a proposal for a privilege log, or a discussion about format may change what is practically at issue. Do not describe a proposal as an agreement until the parties have actually agreed to it. Likewise, producing some unprivileged material does not require an unsupported statement that every remaining item is privileged; each category should be assessed on its own facts.

II. What can happen if a congressional subpoena is disputed?

A. Follow the steps from a committee’s referral to a criminal case

The federal criminal contempt statute is 2 U.S.C. § 192. It addresses a person summoned by the authority of either House who willfully defaults, and a person who appears but refuses to answer a question pertinent to the inquiry. The statute describes a misdemeanor. Its text should be read with applicable judicial decisions and the actual facts; a committee’s announcement alone does not establish that its requirements have been proved in a criminal case.

The referral process is addressed separately in 2 U.S.C. § 194. When the circumstances specified there are met, the statute directs certification of a statement of facts to the appropriate U.S. attorney and says that the matter is to be brought before a grand jury for its action. A committee report, a chamber action, and a prosecutor’s decision are therefore separate parts of the sequence. The statutory language and the actual procedural record matter more than a headline saying someone has been held in contempt.

In United States v. Navarro, No. 24-3006 (D.C. Cir. July 21, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit affirmed two federal contempt convictions on July 21, 2026. The court sustained the trial court’s finding that executive privilege had not been invoked for the subpoena in question and concluded that the evidence did not excuse the complete failure to respond. For a subpoena recipient, the decision shows why the record of an authorized privilege assertion and the difference between specific objections and a wholesale default can be decisive.

That opinion also described the meaning of willfulness under the precedents it applied: deliberate and intentional default was sufficient on the record before the court, even though the defendant asserted a mistaken belief that executive privilege excused compliance. The court did not decide that an authorized privilege assertion could never protect a particular communication. Its analysis turned on the finding that the privilege had not been invoked for that demand and on the case’s other facts. The decision is a federal appellate ruling from the D.C. Circuit; the facts and controlling law must be checked for a different proceeding.

The case record is useful because it distinguishes several events that are often compressed into one sentence. The committee first sought information and issued a subpoena. The House later voted on contempt. A grand jury indicted, a jury convicted, and the appellate court reviewed the conviction. A person reading only the committee action would not yet know the outcome of the later criminal proceedings. In another matter, a referral may not lead to the same sequence or result.

For a recipient, maintain a chronology with copies of each demand, response, clarification, and ruling. If the dispute concerns documents, identify which categories were produced and which were withheld, together with the basis communicated for withholding. If the dispute concerns attendance, retain the notice and any written agreement changing the appearance. The point is not to manufacture a perfect narrative afterward; it is to make the actual record available while decisions are being made.

A subpoena recipient should also distinguish the committee’s assessment from a criminal court’s determination. A committee can state that it considers a response inadequate, but a criminal prosecution requires its own process and proof. Conversely, disagreement with the committee is not itself a ruling that a recipient can disregard the subpoena. The prudent next check is the precise procedural status: is there only a request, a formal subpoena, a committee resolution, a referral, an indictment, or an actual court order?

That status changes what documents a reader needs. For a demand, obtain the subpoena and applicable rules. For a referral, obtain the committee report and any chamber action. For a criminal case, look at the charging document and court orders rather than treating a political statement as a judicial finding. If a court has ruled, read what the court decided and at what stage; a holding about one record does not settle every different dispute.

B. Understand the limits of a suit against legislators and prepare a focused response

In de la Torre v. Cassidy, No. 25-5353 (D.C. Cir. July 31, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit affirmed dismissal on July 31, 2026, of a witness’s civil suit against a Senate committee and its members. The court held that the challenged subpoena-related acts and votes fell within Speech or Debate Clause immunity on the record before it. For a witness, the decision shows why identifying the defendant, the challenged act, and the procedural route matters before assuming a suit against legislators will resolve a subpoena dispute.

That decision also rejected the argument that a broad invocation of the Fifth Amendment excused nonappearance in the circumstances before the court. It explained that the witness could assert the protection in response to questions and could raise a constitutional defense if a contempt prosecution proceeded. The opinion did not erase the Fifth Amendment or decide that every possible subpoena is valid. It addressed a specific civil suit in the D.C. Circuit, where the witness had conceded the underlying inquiry fell within the committee’s jurisdiction.

A claim against a legislator for protected legislative acts, a challenge to a demand, a defense in a criminal case, and a proceeding to enforce a demand are different procedural situations. The court’s discussion of immunity should be read with the relief actually requested in the case. Before choosing a response, identify who is seeking what from whom. Is a witness asking a court to stop particular action? Has a chamber sought judicial enforcement? Has the government charged a crime? The answer determines which documents and legal questions are relevant.

In a dispute about testimony, prepare a question-by-question record when the governing process calls for one. Identify the question asked, the protection asserted, and any ruling on that assertion. An objection to one question should not be silently converted into an assumption about every other question. If the dispute concerns documents, an itemized description can distinguish an alleged confidential communication from a public document, an administrative record, or a record unrelated to the asserted basis.

The 119th Congress House Oversight Committee rules provide one concrete example. They describe how a witness states a privilege claim for testimony and what a privilege log should include for a document. They also allow the committee chair to waive or modify the listed requirements to facilitate cooperation. A reader facing another committee’s demand must check that committee’s own rules; an example from one body is not a nationwide procedural form.

For a deposition under the 119th Congress House Oversight Committee rules, the distinction between an objection and a ruling is especially concrete. The rules call for objections to be stated concisely and provide a process for a chair to rule when a witness refuses to answer to preserve a privilege. They also describe how a ruling made after a recess is provided to the witness and members before a reconvened deposition. A witness should retain the transcript, any written ruling, and the relevant committee rules together, because each can explain a different step in the sequence. This example is limited to those committee rules; it does not supply a universal timetable or determine whether any individual claim of privilege succeeds.

Organizations should decide who has authority to coordinate a response and keep that role distinct from ownership of any individual privilege. An employee, an agency, and an outside institution may have different interests in the same set of communications. Record where a document came from and who received it. Avoid describing a communication as personal merely because it is in a personal account, or official merely because a government employee received it; its content and context require examination.

There may also be a difference between keeping records and disclosing them. A recipient can preserve potentially responsive information while asking for clarification about scope or evaluating a supported objection. Preservation helps avoid losing the information needed to explain the dispute. A response that identifies concrete categories and proposes a workable sequence gives the committee an opportunity to address the actual problem, but any accommodation must be confirmed rather than assumed.

Public commentary may use the word contempt for a proposed vote, an adopted resolution, a court sanction, or a criminal conviction. Those are not interchangeable. When assessing any report, check its date, the official body that acted, and the underlying document. A cited court opinion can establish what that court decided in that case; it cannot establish that the same evidence or result exists in a separate current investigation.

Finally, keep the legal source’s reach in view. The Supreme Court’s separation-of-powers decision applies to the kind of interbranch conflict it considered. The two D.C. Circuit opinions describe federal litigation on the records presented to that court. Neither a letter announcing a legal position nor a search result replaces the text of a subpoena, a committee rule, or a court order. When the record is incomplete, the next useful step is to obtain the actual document and identify the unresolved issue, not to predict the outcome from a headline.

Conclusion

A congressional subpoena should be assessed from its actual terms, its issuing authority, the information requested, and any properly supported objection. Federal law distinguishes a committee’s actions and referral from a grand jury’s action and a court’s judgment. The cited decisions show that a claimed privilege, the capacity in which information was created, and the procedural route can affect the analysis. Keep the complete record, identify the precise question in dispute, and follow the rules governing the particular proceeding.

📄 Official circular