KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EPPO Calypso Auction: What French Companies Must Check After a Cross-Border VAT Seizure

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EPPO Calypso Auction: What French Companies Must Check After a Cross-Border VAT Seizure

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 25 August 2026, the European Public Prosecutor’s Office (EPPO) announced that more than 10,000 electric bicycles and scooters seized in France during the Calypso investigation had been sold at a public auction. The sale, organised by AGRASC, produced €1,853,800. EPPO says the underlying networks managed the route from Chinese imports to distribution and final sales across the European Union while evading customs duties, committing large-scale VAT fraud and allegedly laundering the proceeds. The mechanism had operated for at least eight years, with estimated losses of at least €350 million in customs duties and €450 million in VAT. The official announcement also stresses that everyone concerned remains presumed innocent. The primary source is the EPPO Calypso release of 25 August 2026.

The legal signal is more important than the headline price. France has converted a cross-border seizure into cash before a final judgment, preserving value while leaving the criminal question open. That creates an immediate problem for an importer, warehouse operator, distributor, lender, lessor, buyer or innocent owner whose property has entered the same evidential chain. The right questions are procedural: which authority ordered the seizure, which route permits the sale, what must be proved about title and good faith, which deadline applies, and how is the money protected if the case ends without confiscation? This analysis focuses on those French-law pressure points for an international business audience.

I. What the Calypso auction actually changes in a French file

A. Why EPPO can turn a cross-border VAT investigation into a French seizure

Calypso illustrates the reason EPPO cases do not remain confined to the country where containers first arrive. The alleged scheme described by EPPO was a chain: goods imported from China, customs declarations and duties, movements between Member States, distribution, sales to end customers, VAT accounting and the return of profits. Evidence, bank accounts, stock and people can therefore be spread across several jurisdictions even when a decisive stockholding or warehouse operation is located in France.

The French legal gateway is not a general power to make every commercial dispute an EPPO case. Article 696-108 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, in the version consulted on Légifrance for this analysis, gives European delegated prosecutors competence across the national territory to investigate, prosecute and send to trial authors and accomplices of offences harming the Union’s financial interests under Regulation (EU) 2017/1939. The wording is broad in geography but bounded by the Union-financial-interest requirement. Its key phrase is “compétents sur l’ensemble du territoire national”. That means a French warehouse, account or company can sit inside a case directed from the EPPO architecture even if the suspected accounting conduct, customs entry or ultimate beneficiaries are elsewhere.

Article 696-109 of the same Code gives the delegated European prosecutor, for matters within EPPO competence, the powers of the French public prosecutor and the public prosecutor attached to a court of appeal, including the exercise of remedies. The provision also expressly allows a delegated European prosecutor to create a joint investigation team with the consent of the other Member State or States concerned. The relevant sentence is “le procureur européen délégué peut constituer une équipe commune d’enquête”. This is why a French company should not treat a request from a foreign customs authority, an EPPO contact or a French search as an isolated administrative event. The surrounding file may include coordinated searches, banking requests, stock reconciliations and interviews in several countries.

The ordinary French cooperation mechanism points in the same direction. Article 695-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure permits a joint investigation team where a complex French investigation concerns other Member States or where several Member States are investigating offences that require coordinated action. In a Calypso-type file, the team may compare customs declarations, invoices, shipping records, VAT numbers, warehouse movements and payments rather than looking at a single invoice in isolation. A document that appears regular on the French side can acquire a different evidential meaning when matched against a foreign manifest or a supplier’s bank account.

French procedure still controls the act carried out in France. Article 696-113 provides that, in matters within its competence, the delegated European prosecutor conducts investigations under the rules applicable to a flagrant or preliminary investigation and, where relevant, under the Customs Code. When the investigation requires acts available only in a judicial investigation, the EPPO framework moves into the relevant instruction rules. The practical consequence is that “EPPO” does not erase French safeguards. It identifies the prosecutorial framework; the legality, scope, notification and challenge of a French seizure still depend on the French procedural route used in the file.

The jurisdictional detail matters as well. Article 696-110 places the judgment jurisdiction for procedures handled by delegated European prosecutors in Paris, at first instance and on appeal, subject to the statutory design of the EPPO procedure. A business based abroad may therefore face a French court and a French seizure mechanism even when its commercial team has never dealt with a French criminal court. The address for service, the identity of the magistrate, the language of documents and the calculation of a short French time limit become operational issues, not background details.

None of this establishes that a company involved in a Calypso-related supply chain committed an offence. EPPO’s release itself preserves the presumption of innocence. It does show, however, that the financial investigation is designed to follow the whole commercial circuit. A French operator should map its role with precision: importer of record, customs representative, consignee, owner of stock, logistics provider, platform seller, lender, insurer, repairer or final buyer. Each status can generate different documents and different rights. The most dangerous assumption is that the absence of a criminal charge automatically protects property held by the business. The question is whether the object is evidence, an instrument, a product, an asset available to a suspect, or property belonging to a third party who can prove a better right.

B. Why €1.85 million in auction proceeds is not a final confiscation

The Calypso announcement describes a public auction and says that the proceeds may ultimately be redistributed subject to a final court judgment. Under French law, that is the logic of an anticipatory sale. A seizure is a provisional measure. A confiscation is a penalty or a final asset measure decided under the conditions of the applicable offence. Selling a deteriorating or costly movable item before judgment changes the form of the asset from a physical object into money; it does not by itself decide who is guilty or who will ultimately lose the value.

Article 41-5 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, in the version used for this analysis, allows the public prosecutor to send seized movable property to AGRASC for disposal when keeping it in its original form is no longer necessary to establish the truth and the law provides for confiscation. The provision now also covers a situation in which continued custody could reduce the value, create disproportionate preservation costs compared with the economic value, or require particular expertise for maintenance. These are concrete triggers. A large fleet of bicycles and scooters is a natural example: storage, battery management, depreciation, serial-number tracking and market obsolescence can all affect the value and the evidential usefulness of keeping every item in its original form.

The statutory safeguard is direct. Article 41-5 says, “S’il est procédé à la vente du bien, le produit de celle-ci est consigné.” The money is therefore not treated as an ordinary revenue stream available for immediate distribution. The same article provides for notification to people known to have rights in the property and to people implicated in the case. It also gives them a short contestation route: five days from notification, before the first president of the court of appeal or the designated judge, with suspensive effect. A business that receives a notification must calculate the deadline from the actual date and method of service, preserve proof of receipt and obtain the full decision, not merely a summary from a warehouse or auction operator.

The parallel instruction mechanism is Article 99-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It addresses the same practical problem during a judicial investigation: a movable asset no longer needs to remain in kind for the search for truth, but it may be confiscable and may lose value or generate disproportionate conservation costs. Its text expressly links the transfer to AGRASC, protects third-party rights and provides for consignment of the sale proceeds. The version of the provision examined on Légifrance states that, where the case ends in a dismissal, acquittal or no confiscation, the owner may request return of the proceeds, subject to the statutory non-return exceptions. The procedural label matters: a public-prosecutor sale under Article 41-5 and a judicial-investigation sale under Article 99-2 do not create the same decision-maker or the same challenge route.

AGRASC is the asset-management link rather than the court deciding criminal liability. Article 706-160 of the Code of Criminal Procedure assigns the agency the management of property entrusted to it under a criminal procedure, the centralised management of seized sums and the disposal of property ordered or authorised under Articles 41-5 and 99-2. The article also states that AGRASC can manage, sell and distribute sale proceeds in execution of a request for mutual assistance or cooperation from a foreign judicial authority. That last function is crucial to a cross-border case: the asset can be physically sold in France while the legal and financial consequences remain connected to another Member State or to a foreign judicial request.

Article 706-161 of the Code adds AGRASC’s guidance and information functions. It allows the agency to provide courts and prosecutors with legal and practical assistance for seizures and confiscations and to inform victims, when appropriate, about assets returned under a judicial decision. For a business, that means the agency’s involvement is not a replacement for a property claim before the competent magistrate. AGRASC manages the asset within the mandate it receives. It does not decide, by itself, whether an invoice proves ownership, whether a company acted in good faith or whether the French authorities were entitled to seize a particular batch.

The difference between seizure, sale and confiscation protects both the investigation and the owner, but only if the paper trail remains usable. The official EPPO announcement says the €1,853,800 is a financial result of the auction and that the sum may be redistributed after a final judgment. That is not a declaration that the auctioned goods were the proceeds of a crime. It is an asset-preservation step taken against a background of suspected customs and VAT fraud. The same distinction explains why an innocent owner should act quickly: a later claim may concern money rather than the original goods, and the value of money is easier to preserve than the identity and condition of thousands of physical products, but only if the claimant can link the money to a specific legal right.

The chronology also explains why a business should separate three files from the first day: the criminal seizure file, the commercial title file and the tax or customs file. The criminal file addresses the authority and purpose of the seizure. The title file proves who bought, financed, leased, stored or possessed each item. The tax file explains declarations, VAT treatment, customs value, origin, transport and payments. Mixing them produces a vague denial. A coherent defence shows the exact lot, the exact document, the exact payment and the exact procedural request.

II. What a business, buyer or third party should do now

A. How to preserve evidence and challenge a seizure before the sale becomes irreversible

The first task is classification. Ask for the seizure record, the decision authorising or confirming it, the inventory, the seal or serial-number list, the identity of the magistrate and the text of any AGRASC transfer. A seizure made to preserve evidence is not identical to a seizure intended to secure a later confiscation. A physical stock seizure is not identical to a patrimonial seizure targeting property whose origin cannot be established. A sale decision is not identical to the underlying seizure decision. The appeal route and the argument available at each stage can change.

For a patrimonial seizure, Article 706-148 of the Code of Criminal Procedure permits a judge of liberties and detention, on the public prosecutor’s application, to order a motivated seizure where the investigation concerns an offence punishable by at least five years and the law permits confiscation under the relevant provisions of Article 131-21 of the Criminal Code, or where the origin of the assets cannot be established. The investigating judge can order the seizure under the conditions set out in the article. The decisions are notified to the public prosecutor, the owner and known third parties with rights, who can refer them to the investigation chamber within ten days. The text provides that this appeal is not suspensive.

That ten-day period is not the five-day period for challenging a disposal decision under Article 41-5. It is not a reason to wait for the auction. A company should determine which document was served and what it orders. If the complaint is that the seizure itself is unjustified, the argument belongs in the seizure challenge. If the complaint is that a sale was ordered even though a short-lived asset could have been preserved or a third-party title was ignored, the argument must address the disposal decision and the evidence known to the magistrate at that moment.

Article 706-143 shows why possession and title should be separated. Until release or confiscation, the owner, or failing the owner the holder, is responsible for maintenance and preservation, subject to the statutory exceptions. If that person is unavailable or fails to act, the public prosecutor or investigating judge may entrust the asset to AGRASC for conservation, maintenance and valuation. The provision protects “les droits des tiers de bonne foi”. A logistics company storing goods may be a holder without being the owner. A finance company may have a title or security interest without having physical possession. A distributor may have paid for stock without being the importer of record. The submission should state which role is asserted and prove it separately.

Article 706-144 identifies the magistrate who ordered or authorised the seizure, or the investigating judge where an investigation was opened after the seizure, as the authority competent to decide requests concerning execution of the seizure, without prejudice to the special rules on destruction and disposal. It gives the applicant and public prosecutor ten days from notification to appeal that decision to the investigation chamber, with suspensive effect. In practice, a petition should not be addressed to an attractive but incompetent court merely because the company is headquartered abroad or the goods are stored near Paris. The order and the procedural stage determine the correct forum.

The file should then be rebuilt at item level. Useful evidence includes:

  • purchase orders, commercial invoices, payment confirmations and the contract terms governing retention of title;
  • customs declarations, commodity classifications, declared values, origin documents, transport documents and the identity of the customs representative;
  • VAT registrations, returns, ledgers, intra-Union reporting and correspondence with tax advisers;
  • warehouse intake records, barcode or serial-number exports, photographs, repair records, battery records and delivery notes;
  • leasing, pledge, insurance and financing documents showing a third party’s legal or economic interest;
  • emails, messaging records and compliance checks showing what the company knew about suppliers, routes, prices and intermediaries; and
  • an itemised reconciliation connecting each claimed object to the seizure inventory and, if sold, to the relevant lot and proceeds.

The recent case law makes the quality of that reconciliation decisive. In Cour de cassation, Criminal Chamber, 1 July 2026, no. 25-85.504, a third party produced invoices for luxury watches seized at another person’s home. The Court quashed the decision because the judge had to examine the invoices and ownership before deciding the third party’s good faith. The Court stated that “il lui appartenait, avant de conclure que M. [L] n’était pas propriétaire des montres, de s’expliquer sur les factures”. The facts involved watches, not bicycles, but the procedural lesson is direct: an invoice must be matched to the seized object, and the court must explain why it accepts or rejects that match.

In Cour de cassation, Criminal Chamber, 15 November 2023, no. 22-84.784, the seized asset was an articulated vehicle owned by a business while another person had its use. The Court held that the decision could not confirm the transfer to AGRASC without addressing the owner’s good-faith argument. Its reasoning refers to the requirement that the court respond to the essential arguments and preserve “les droits du propriétaire de bonne foi”. The judgment was a cassation. A commercial owner therefore should not rely on its corporate name alone; it should put the ownership, the use granted to the suspect, the commercial purpose and the absence of knowledge of the alleged fraud into a documented chronology.

The timing of the request matters even before the auction. In Cour de cassation, Criminal Chamber, 11 October 2017, no. 17-82.132, the Court held that an AGRASC transfer order was not enforceable while a prior restitution request by the owner had not been finally decided. The operative phrase is “l’ordonnance de remise à l’AGRASC d’un bien saisi n’est pas exécutoire tant qu’il n’a pas été définitivement statué” on the earlier restitution request. This does not create a universal right to stop every sale, but it shows why a restitution request cannot be left informal or postponed until after disposal. The request, its date, its proof of filing and its relationship to the sale order must be visible in the record.

There is also a warning about choosing the right remedy. In Cour de cassation, Criminal Chamber, 13 June 2018, no. 17-82.278, concerning vehicles owned by transport companies, the Court rejected an attempt to use an appeal against the AGRASC transfer to attack the underlying seizure. It described that issue as “cette question relevant du contentieux de la saisie proprement dite”. The practical sequence is therefore: challenge the seizure on its own legal and proportionality grounds; challenge the sale or transfer on its own statutory conditions; and bring the title and good-faith evidence in the procedural vehicle that can hear it.

For an international business, the filing should also address language and service. Request a complete copy of the order and inventory, preserve the French original, prepare a precise translation for the foreign board or insurer, and nominate one person to calculate deadlines in French time. Do not allow several advisers in different countries to send inconsistent ownership descriptions. A customs broker’s statement that it was “only an intermediary” does not answer whether it had custody, authority, records or knowledge. A foreign parent’s certificate of ownership does not answer whether the French entity paid for the goods or had them at its free disposal. The court needs the legal relationship at the time of seizure, supported by contemporaneous records.

B. How VAT, customs and money-laundering exposure travels across the Union

Calypso’s commercial route creates a second layer of risk. A company can be outside the criminal core and still face frozen stock, a tax audit, a request for documents, a loss of resale capacity or a dispute over the sale proceeds. The business response must separate three questions: did the company commit or assist an offence; can the asset be seized or confiscated even if the company is not charged; and what tax or customs adjustment can the administration pursue independently of the criminal case?

The French confiscation framework is deliberately wider than a simple test of whose name appears on an invoice. Article 131-21 of the Criminal Code allows confiscation in the circumstances provided by law, including property that served to commit an offence or was intended for that purpose, and, subject to the rights of a good-faith owner, property at the convicted person’s free disposal. The text also permits confiscation in value and protects a person who has a property right from a final confiscation unless that person, known or claiming that status during the proceedings, has been given an opportunity to present observations on the proposed measure. The statutory wording includes “sous réserve des droits du propriétaire de bonne foi”.

This creates two distinct defence theories. The first is ownership: the company owns the goods and the suspect did not have the legal or economic power to dispose of them. The second is good faith: even if the suspect exercised practical control, the company held a right without knowledge of the criminal origin or purpose and can show normal commercial conduct. Those theories should not be blurred. Ownership is proved by title, payment, delivery and contractual risk. Good faith is proved by due diligence, pricing, supplier checks, transport records, compliance controls, absence of warnings and the company’s conduct after learning of the investigation.

The money-laundering angle can widen the evidential field. Article 324-1 of the Criminal Code defines laundering as facilitating by any means a false justification of the origin of assets or income derived from an offence, and also covers participation in placing, concealing or converting the direct or indirect proceeds of an offence. The short statutory description is “Le blanchiment est le fait de faciliter”. In a cross-border supply chain, a payment instruction, a circular invoice, an interposed company or a transfer through a third country may be examined as part of the money trail. That does not make a routine payment criminal by itself. It means the company should preserve the commercial reason, the delivered value and the approval path for each material transfer.

French tax law may add an independent criminal track where intentional evasion is alleged. Article 1741 of the General Tax Code addresses fraudulent avoidance or attempted avoidance of the establishment or payment of taxes and increases the penalties in circumstances such as organised conduct, foreign accounts, foreign interposed entities, false documents or fictitious foreign domiciliation. The relevant statutory language begins “quiconque s’est frauduleusement soustrait ou a tenté de se soustraire frauduleusement”. For a company responding to a Calypso-related request, the immediate point is not to self-label the facts. It is to preserve the VAT calculation, the customs valuation, the supply route and the decision-maker’s knowledge so that the legal and tax analyses can be made on a documented factual base.

The size of the alleged network matters because EPPO’s evidence can combine national powers with Union cooperation. The French provision on delegated European prosecutors links their work to Regulation (EU) 2017/1939, while the official EUR-Lex text of that Regulation supplies the Union framework for investigating and prosecuting offences against the Union budget. The French Code’s joint-investigation rule, Article 695-2, permits coordinated action when several Member States are involved. A French company should expect that an answer already given to customs in one country may be compared with documents held by a foreign tax authority, bank, platform or logistics provider.

That is why the first substantive request to counsel should be a cross-border evidence map rather than a generic request for “the file”. The map should identify the country of importation, the customs declaration, the person responsible for the entry, the first purchaser, each intra-Union movement, the VAT number used, the warehouse location, the onward buyer and the account receiving the payment. Then identify which element is alleged to be false: origin, value, quantity, importer, VAT regime, invoice, delivery, payment or beneficiary. The answer determines whether the company’s strongest defence is a factual correction, a property claim, a good-faith claim, a challenge to proportionality or a request to separate its goods from the wider batch.

A second request should concern the money after sale. Ask whether the inventory was sold as a single lot or separated, how the price was allocated, what auction record identifies the items, where the proceeds are consigned, and which authority will decide any later distribution or restitution. Article 706-160 recognises AGRASC’s role in managing property and sums and in executing certain foreign judicial-assistance requests. Article 41-5 requires consignment and provides a return mechanism if the case ends without confiscation, subject to the exceptions in the text. A third party should not accept a statement that “the goods have been sold” as the end of the claim. The claim may have moved from the object to an identifiable share of the consigned proceeds.

There are limits to what the auction purchaser can rely on. Buying at a public auction does not turn an uncertain criminal title into a finding that no third-party right ever existed. The purchaser should keep the auction notice, lot description, invoices, payment proof, delivery evidence and any disclaimer about ownership or regulatory compliance. If the products are resold, the purchaser should verify product safety, traceability, battery rules and customs or VAT documentation. Those issues may be separate from the criminal seizure, but a buyer who destroys serial-number data or merges lots loses evidence that may later be needed by the court or a legitimate owner.

There are also limits to a company’s internal investigation. Employees should not delete chats, rewrite invoices, backdate supplier confirmations or move remaining stock after a seizure. Such actions can create new evidence and may undermine a good-faith argument. The company should impose a litigation hold, preserve original metadata, secure its accounting export and record who collected each document. If a foreign parent controls the servers, the French team should preserve a local mirror and document the transfer. Requests from EPPO, customs or tax authorities should be routed through a controlled response process that distinguishes voluntary cooperation, compelled production, professional privilege and data-protection limits.

The recent decisions also caution against reducing proportionality to the value of the goods. In Cour de cassation, Criminal Chamber, 15 January 2025, no. 24-80.694, the Court held that, where a seizure reaches property at a person’s free disposal, the judge must first establish that third-party right holders are not in good faith and must then assess the proportionality of the interference with the property rights of both the person with free disposal and the third parties. The Court’s formulation requires that good faith be addressed before the proportionality assessment. Although the case concerned an immovable property and a divided ownership structure, the sequence is valuable for commercial stock: identify the third-party right, prove its good faith, then explain why retaining or selling the goods would impose a disproportionate burden compared with the investigative and confiscation objective.

The same discipline applies when the company is not French. A foreign entity with goods in France cannot assume that its foreign incorporation places title outside French seizure law. Conversely, the French authorities cannot treat a foreign invoice as irrelevant merely because the goods were physically found in France. The analysis follows the asset, the legal title, the economic control, the suspected offence and the procedural order. The right response is therefore neither “France has no jurisdiction” nor “EPPO can take everything”. It is a precise objection tied to the seizure decision, the object, the evidence and the legal remedy available at that stage.

For a board or general counsel, the immediate action list is short:

  • freeze destruction, deletion and resale of all records connected with the goods, suppliers, customs entries and payments;
  • obtain the French seizure and AGRASC decisions, the full inventory and proof of notification;
  • calculate both the five-day sale challenge and the ten-day seizure or execution deadlines that may apply;
  • appoint one factual owner for the item-by-item title and good-faith reconciliation;
  • separate the criminal, customs, VAT, insurance, financing and commercial consequences in the advice to management; and
  • request confirmation of the consignment and the procedure for identifying and claiming the relevant sale proceeds.

These steps do not prejudge the merits of Calypso or any other EPPO investigation. They prevent a provisional seizure from becoming an evidential vacuum. In a cross-border file, the company that can show exactly what it bought, from whom, under which customs and VAT treatment, where it went, who paid for it and what it knew will be in a far stronger position than a company that relies on a general assertion of innocence after the auction catalogue has closed.

Conclusion

The Calypso auction is a live example of a new practical reality for international commerce: a French asset can be seized in an EPPO investigation, transferred to AGRASC and converted into consigned proceeds before a final judgment, while the underlying cross-border VAT and customs allegations remain contested. The €1,853,800 result is therefore not a final confiscation and not a finding of guilt. It is a warning that the property and evidence questions must be litigated early.

For an importer, distributor, warehouse operator, finance company or buyer, the decisive work is to identify the exact procedural route, preserve the five- and ten-day deadlines, prove title and good faith at item level, and keep the commercial, tax and criminal evidence consistent. French law protects third-party rights, but the protection is exercised through a notified decision, a competent court, a defined remedy and documents that connect the claimant to the seized property or its sale proceeds.

This article relies on the EPPO’s release of 25 August 2026 and on the versions of the French provisions and decisions linked inline. The Légifrance chronology shows that several cited provisions are scheduled for recodification from 1 January 2029; the analysis concerns the procedure applicable on 30 August 2026.

📄 Official circular