KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU Return Hubs by 2027: What a French OQTF Still Cannot Do

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU Return Hubs by 2027: What a French OQTF Still Cannot Do

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Five European governments have announced a new push to make third-country “return hubs” operational by 2027. Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands, Austria and Greece say they will intensify talks with partner countries after a meeting on 4 September 2026. The announcement is politically significant, but it is not, by itself, a French removal order, a European transfer decision or a licence to send every person subject to an OQTF to a country outside the European Union. The Danish government described three conditions: measurable impact, compliance with European and international law, and a mutually beneficial partnership. The official Danish statement and the contemporaneous AP report both present the project as work still in progress.

That distinction matters immediately for anyone who has received a French obligation to leave the territory, or OQTF. A return hub could eventually become a place of transfer, or in some arrangements the final destination of a return. It cannot erase the individual decision that authorises removal, the country-of-return assessment, the right to an effective remedy, or the prohibition on refoulement. The legal question is therefore not whether a political plan has been announced. It is which French decision has been notified, which destination has been selected, what evidence supports that destination, and what can still be placed before the administrative judge.

This analysis separates the provisional EU framework from the law currently in force, then identifies the documents and arguments that can make an urgent challenge concrete. A return hub may change removal logistics, but it does not make the underlying safeguards disappear.

I. What the five-state return-hub plan changes — and what it does not

A. Why a political announcement is not yet a French removal power

The 4 September announcement should be read as a diplomatic and operational initiative. The five participating states intend to send missions, identify partner countries and negotiate arrangements. The Danish statement does not announce that a named country has accepted a fixed number of people, that a French prefect can use that arrangement, or that a person in France can be transferred without an individual decision. Those steps are legally and factually separate.

The broader EU discussion is also unfinished. On 1 June 2026, the Council announced a provisional agreement with the European Parliament on a return framework. The Council explained that the proposed rules could allow return hubs outside the EU, either as a final destination or as a transfer centre, but only under conditions connected with fundamental rights and non-refoulement. It also stated that unaccompanied minors would be excluded from those arrangements. The Council press release expressly described the text as provisional and subject to formal adoption. The European Parliament research briefing likewise treats formal approval and entry into force as steps still required. A provisional political agreement is not a rule that can be applied retrospectively to a person served with an OQTF.

French law starts elsewhere. The administration must identify the legal basis for the removal, the person concerned, and the destination that can lawfully receive that person. Article L. 721-4 of the Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners and the Right of Asylum, or CESEDA, allows the authority to designate the country of nationality, another country with an appropriate travel-document or readmission arrangement, or, with the person’s agreement, another country where the person is legally admissible. The same provision states: “Un étranger ne peut être éloigné à destination d’un pays s’il établit que sa vie ou sa liberté y sont menacées ou qu’il y est exposé à des traitements contraires aux stipulations de l’article 3 de la convention européenne de sauvegarde des droits de l’homme et des libertés fondamentales.” The text is available in the official version of Article L. 721-4 CESEDA.

A hub arrangement therefore cannot substitute for the country-of-return decision. It may provide a possible destination or a logistical stage only if the French authority can connect it to a lawful route. The administration must still explain why that country is available, why the individual can lawfully enter it, and why removal there would not create a real risk of treatment prohibited by Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The word “hub” does not create a new category of person, suspend judicial review or convert a diplomatic memorandum into an enforceable removal order.

The same distinction applies to the OQTF itself. Article L. 611-1 CESEDA authorises the administration to oblige a foreign national to leave in specified situations, including where the person does not or no longer have a right to remain. The official text of Article L. 611-1 is the starting point for the legality of the obligation. It does not, on its own, answer every question about the country to which the person may be removed. An OQTF, a decision fixing the country of destination, a refusal of voluntary departure, a residence-assignment decision and a detention order can have different legal bases and different challenges.

Nor does the political timetable determine the procedural timetable. Under Article L. 612-1 CESEDA, a person normally “dispose d’un délai de départ volontaire de trente jours”, subject to the statutory exceptions. The official text of Article L. 612-1 shows that the thirty-day period is a legal consequence, not a political promise. Article L. 612-2 permits the administration to refuse that period in particular cases, including a threat to public order or a risk of absconding. Its text refers to the situation in which “Il existe un risque que l’étranger se soustraie à la décision portant obligation de quitter le territoire français dont il fait l’objet”; the rule is reproduced in the official version of Article L. 612-2.

Article L. 612-3 then lists circumstances that may establish such a risk. One is that “L’étranger a explicitement déclaré son intention de ne pas se conformer à son obligation de quitter le territoire français.” The official version of Article L. 612-3 also addresses previous evasion, the absence of identity or travel documents, and insufficient guarantees of representation. These provisions may affect whether removal is immediate, but they do not remove the need to establish a lawful destination or to respect the individual’s right to challenge the decision.

For an OQTF recipient, the first practical conclusion is thus negative but important: a headline about return hubs does not itself start a new appeal period, does not prove that the person has been accepted by a third country, and does not authorise an officer to bypass the reasons and remedies stated in the notified decision. The document in the person’s hands remains decisive.

B. Which person could be sent to a third country under the EU design?

A future return-hub system would not operate as one undifferentiated channel. The legal route depends on why the person is removable, whether an asylum claim is pending or exhausted, whether another EU Member State is responsible, whether a third country has agreed to receive the person, and whether the destination creates a foreseeable chain of onward removal. Each classification affects the decision that must be used.

First, a person whose right to remain has ended may be subject to an OQTF under Article L. 611-1 CESEDA. That does not mean that the administration can simply select the most convenient third country. Article L. 721-4 draws a line between the country of nationality, a country covered by an appropriate readmission or travel-document arrangement, and another country where the person is legally admissible with that person’s agreement. A proposed hub that has no demonstrated admission mechanism may be vulnerable on that ground alone. The argument is not that every third-country arrangement is unlawful; it is that the administration must show how this individual can enter and remain there lawfully.

Second, a person whose asylum procedure has ended is not in the same position as a person who has never sought protection. Article L. 542-1 CESEDA governs the end of the right to remain in connection with the asylum procedure, including the consequences of an OFPRA decision, an appeal before the National Court of Asylum, and notification of the relevant decision. The official text of Article L. 542-1 must be read alongside the individual notification and any pending appeal. A return-hub proposal cannot convert a pending asylum remedy into a completed procedure.

Third, the Dublin situation requires particular care. Where another Member State is responsible for examining an asylum application, the appropriate measure may be a transfer decision rather than an ordinary OQTF. In a decision of 31 August 2026, CAA Paris, 4th chamber, no. 25PA04602, the court stated that “la mesure d’éloignement en vue de remettre l’intéressé aux autorités étrangères compétentes pour l’examen de sa demande d’asile ne peut être qu’une décision de transfert prise sur le fondement de ce dernier article.” The decision is available on the official Légifrance record for CAA Paris no. 25PA04602. That ruling is not about a return hub, but it illustrates the controlling principle: the administration must use the legal instrument that corresponds to the actual purpose of the transfer.

Article L. 572-1 CESEDA sets out safeguards for a Dublin transfer, including a written and reasoned decision, notification of the remedies and time limits, and information in a language the person can understand. The provision says that “Toute décision de transfert fait l’objet d’une décision écrite motivée.” It can be read in the official text of Article L. 572-1. If a prefect presents a proposed transfer to a partner country as an ordinary OQTF while the facts actually concern responsibility for an asylum claim, the classification itself becomes a serious ground of challenge.

Fourth, a person’s age is not a minor detail. The Council’s provisional framework excludes unaccompanied minors from the proposed return-hub arrangements. French law separately provides that “L’étranger mineur de dix-huit ans ne peut faire l’objet d’une décision de placement en rétention.” That rule appears in the official text of Article L. 741-5 CESEDA. It does not answer every question about an unaccompanied child’s removal, but it prevents the detention route from being treated as an ordinary administrative shortcut.

The Court of Cassation’s recent decision in no. 24-22.478 illustrates why child-protection safeguards matter at a border. In its 2 September 2026 judgment, the First Civil Chamber held: “Il en résulte que la désignation d’un administrateur ad hoc constitue une exigence légale dont l’absence porte nécessairement atteinte aux intérêts du mineur ainsi privé de protection et vicie la procédure, contrairement à un simple retard de désignation dans des circonstances particulières n’empêchant pas l’administrateur ad hoc de remplir son office.” The exact decision and its official citation, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2026:C100499, are available from the Court of Cassation. The judgment concerned a minor held in a waiting zone, not a return hub. Its relevance is procedural: when a child is exposed to an accelerated cross-border process, the presence and effective role of the legally required representative cannot be treated as administrative decoration.

Finally, a return hub cannot be analysed only by asking whether the host state has signed a political arrangement. The individual risk may arise from the host state itself, from conditions in the facility, from the possibility of onward transfer, or from the inability to obtain an effective remedy there. The EU institutions have repeatedly linked any third-country return arrangement to fundamental-rights guarantees and non-refoulement. In practice, the challenge must identify the concrete chain: France to the hub, the hub’s legal status, the conditions of stay, and any foreseeable onward destination. A generic assertion that a partner country is “safe” will not resolve an individualised Article 3 objection.

II. How to challenge a French route to a return hub

A. The OQTF, country-of-return and non-refoulement challenge

The correct challenge begins by separating the decisions. Read the notification page by page and identify: the OQTF; the decision granting or refusing a voluntary-departure period; the country of destination; any entry ban; any residence assignment; and any detention measure. A return-hub story may be cited in the administration’s reasoning, but the judge will examine the legal act actually adopted. The appeal should state which decision is challenged and why the alleged future arrangement cannot cure a defect in that decision.

The country-of-return ground is often the most direct. Article L. 721-4 CESEDA does not limit the analysis to the formal country name. It requires the authority to confront the risk that removal would expose the person to threats to life or liberty, or to treatment contrary to Article 3 of the Convention. Evidence should address the entire route rather than only the first flight. If a person is sent to a hub with no durable status, the court may need to know whether the host state can detain, deport, transfer or otherwise remove that person onward, and whether a remedy exists before that happens.

A recent CAA Paris decision shows the court applying this protection in an individual case. In no. 25PA05248, decided on 31 August 2026, the court considered an Afghan national and quoted the statutory prohibition that “Un étranger ne peut être éloigné à destination d’un pays s’il établit que sa vie ou sa liberté y sont menacées ou qu’il y est exposé à des traitements contraires aux stipulations de l’article 3”. The court found that the applicant established a risk of inhuman or degrading treatment in Afghanistan and annulled the removal decision insofar as it provided for that return. The official Légifrance record for CAA Paris no. 25PA05248 gives the decision number, date and reasoning.

The lesson for a possible hub is not that every transfer outside the EU must be cancelled. It is that the administration must make a real country assessment. A submission should identify concrete material: current country reports; evidence of the host state’s admission rules; the text or public terms of the readmission arrangement; evidence about detention or reception conditions; medical vulnerabilities; family links; political, religious, ethnic or gender-based risk; and the risk of onward removal. If the person has already been threatened by the proposed host state, that fact should be placed beside the OQTF and not left to an oral explanation.

The OQTF itself may also be challenged. Article L. 611-1 requires the factual and legal conditions for an obligation to leave. The authority must identify the person’s status, the end or absence of a right to remain, and the reasons supporting the decision. An appeal can therefore address an error about an asylum appeal, a family or private-life situation, a pending residence application, a procedural failure, or an assessment that treats a provisional EU plan as if it were already binding law. The precise time limit depends on the type of OQTF, the notification and the person’s circumstances. The notification must be checked immediately; waiting for a future hub decision can cause the ordinary appeal period to expire.

The voluntary-departure decision deserves its own analysis. If the administration refuses the ordinary thirty-day period, the reasoning must fit Article L. 612-2 and, where relevant, Article L. 612-3. A political statement that partner countries are being considered is not automatically proof of a risk of absconding. The authority must connect the statutory ground to the person’s conduct and circumstances. Conversely, if the file contains a prior evasion, a missing passport, or a documented intention not to comply, the response should confront that evidence directly while preserving the separate country-of-return challenge.

An appeal should also distinguish the OQTF from the destination. The court may find that the person is removable in principle but that the selected country is unlawful. That distinction can be decisive in a return-hub scenario. It prevents an argument about the safety or legality of a third country from being lost inside a general denial of every part of the prefectural order. It also creates a clear record if the administration later tries to replace the named destination with a partner country.

Where detention or an imminent removal makes delay dangerous, the litigation strategy must match the urgency. A lawyer should obtain the full prefectural order, its annexes, the proof of notification, the transport information if known, and any document referring to a partner country or hub. The filing should identify the immediate harm and request the relief available in the relevant procedure. A general political objection will be weaker than a short chronology supported by the order, the deadline, the destination evidence and the specific Article 3 risk.

B. The urgent defence file: deadline, Dublin, detention and evidence

The first item in an urgent file is not a press article; it is the notification. Preserve the envelope, electronic message, service report, signature record and every page of the order. Record the exact date and method of service. French immigration litigation uses different time limits depending on the measure and the circumstances. A person should not assume that the thirty-day voluntary-departure period is also the appeal period, or that an appeal against detention automatically challenges the OQTF and destination decision. Each document must be mapped separately.

The second item is the status history. Gather visas, residence permits, asylum registration certificates, OFPRA and CNDA decisions, Dublin notices, previous prefectural orders, identity documents and proof of family life in France. If a Dublin transfer is alleged, obtain the take-charge or take-back communication, the responsible Member State’s acceptance, and the decision identifying the legal route. The reasoning of CAA Paris no. 25PA04602 is a useful warning: the administration cannot use an OQTF instrument to achieve a transfer that legally belongs under the Dublin provisions.

The third item is destination evidence. Ask what “return hub” means in the individual case. Is it a country of nationality, a transit state, a state that has accepted readmission, or only a country mentioned in a political discussion? Has the person agreed to go there? Is the person legally admissible? Does the proposed host state issue a residence document, or can it detain the person indefinitely? Is there a risk of onward transfer to the country from which protection is feared? These questions turn a vague headline into reviewable administrative facts.

The fourth item is the Article 3 record. Medical reports should explain the condition and the treatment that would be unavailable or unsafe. Evidence of threats should identify dates, actors, places and reporting channels. Country evidence should be recent and tied to the person’s profile. If the risk comes from the host state’s treatment of returned migrants rather than from the original country of nationality, the submission must say so expressly. The fact that a return hub is outside the EU does not make the prohibition on refoulement geographically irrelevant to the French decision that sends the person there.

The fifth item is the detention or liberty decision. Article L. 741-1 CESEDA permits the administration to place a foreign national in detention in defined conditions and, in the words of the statute, “pour une durée de quatre-vingt-seize heures”. The official text of Article L. 741-1 requires the absence of effective guarantees of representation and the insufficiency of another measure. The administration must still explain why detention is necessary for this person. A proposed hub does not eliminate the need to consider residence assignment, family circumstances, health, identity, reporting guarantees and the actual prospect of removal.

Article L. 743-3 CESEDA supplies the procedural framework for contesting detention placement, its extension or release. The official version of Article L. 743-3 should be read with the summons and the detention record. If a child is involved, Article L. 741-5’s prohibition on detention must be raised at once, along with the safeguards concerning representation and best interests. If the person is an asylum applicant whose right to remain has ended but whose circumstances permit an alternative, Article L. 752-1 CESEDA addresses residence assignment in a defined situation; its official text is another part of the urgent review.

A file should also preserve the human consequences that the administrative form may omit. A child’s schooling, a dependent relative, pregnancy, serious illness, disability, trauma, employment, language and housing can affect proportionality, guarantees of representation and the practical consequences of removal. These facts do not automatically cancel an OQTF. They allow the judge to test whether the authority actually assessed the individual situation instead of applying a general policy assumption.

For a person intercepted at a border or placed in a waiting zone, the procedural record is especially important. The Cour de cassation’s no. 24-22.478 judgment shows that the absence of a required ad hoc administrator can vitiate the procedure when a minor is deprived of the protection that the representative must provide. The lesson extends beyond that specific case: a hurried cross-border process must still leave proof that legally required safeguards were effective, not merely mentioned.

The defence should finally anticipate the administration’s likely answer. It may say that no hub has yet been selected, that the individual is only subject to an ordinary OQTF, or that the destination can be changed later. The response should then identify the decision already adopted and the harm that would occur before a later challenge. If the order already names a country, attack that country now. If it does not, ask whether the administration has sufficient legal power to create a new destination without a fresh decision and a fresh remedy. The argument must remain anchored in the notified act, because courts decide the legality of an administrative decision rather than the political slogan surrounding it.

Conclusion

The five-state return-hub initiative is a serious policy signal, not yet a self-executing French removal mechanism. The EU framework remains subject to formal adoption, partner-country arrangements and rights conditions. In France, an OQTF still requires an individual legal basis; the selected destination must satisfy Article L. 721-4 CESEDA; asylum and Dublin cases must use the correct procedural instrument; and detention, age, representation and effective remedies remain legally relevant.

For someone facing removal, the useful question is not whether return hubs will exist in 2027. It is what the prefect has already decided, when that decision was served, where it proposes to send the person, and what evidence shows about the entire route. The strongest urgent file joins the notification, the deadline, the status history, the destination documents, the Article 3 evidence and the procedural safeguards. A hub may alter the logistics of return. It cannot turn an unlawful destination into a lawful one, and it cannot replace an effective challenge.

📄 Official circular