My Ex Took Our Child Abroad Without My Permission: How France Orders the Return Under the 1980 Hague Convention — Expats Guide
Your former partner has taken your child to another country, or has kept your child there after a holiday, and you did not agree. Or the reverse has happened: your ex has brought your child to France without your consent and you are abroad, asking how to get your child back. Panic is natural, but the first days decide much of the outcome. France applies a fast, specialised track for these cases: the 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, completed inside Europe by Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter, and framed in domestic law by the Civil Code rules on parental authority (autorité parentale, the set of rights and duties both parents hold over the person and property of their minor child) and by the Criminal Code provisions on child removal. This guide explains, entirely from verifiable official sources, when France treats the move as wrongful, which judge orders the return, how to file in the first hours, which defences the other parent can raise, and what happens in practice in Paris and Île-de-France.
I. Is what happened to your child an international abduction that France will reverse
A return order is not granted simply because one parent is unhappy. The judge checks three questions in order: was the child habitually resident in a State that applies the return mechanism, did the move breach custody rights that were actually being exercised, and was the return application filed in time. Only when each answer points the same way does the court order what French practice calls the retour immédiat, the immediate return of the child.
A. Wrongful removal or retention: habitual residence, custody rights and the one-year clock
The starting point is Article 3 of the 1980 Hague Convention, provides that a removal or retention is wrongful when it breaches custody rights attributed, alone or jointly, under the law of the State where the child was habitually resident immediately before the move, where those rights were actually being exercised at that time (1980 Hague Convention, full official text, HCCH). Two factual situations fall under this definition. Removal means one parent takes the child from the country of habitual residence without the consent of the other holder of custody rights. Retention means the child travelled lawfully, for instance for school holidays, and the parent abroad then refuses to send the child back. Both are treated identically.
Habitual residence (résidence habituelle, the country where the child actually lives on a stable basis, goes to school and has family and social ties) is a question of fact, not of nationality or of the parents’ immigration status. A child can be habitually resident in France even where both parents are foreign nationals, and a child of French nationality can be habitually resident abroad. What matters is where daily life was anchored immediately before the disputed move. Parents who shared daily care under French law will normally both hold custody rights, because separation itself changes nothing: Article 373-2 of the Civil Code states that separation of the parents has no effect on the rules governing the exercise of parental authority, and adds “Tout changement de résidence de l’un des parents, dès lors qu’il modifie les modalités d’exercice de l’autorité parentale, doit faire l’objet d’une information préalable et en temps utile de l’autre parent.” In substance, any change of residence by one parent that alters how parental authority is exercised must be notified to the other parent in advance and in good time. (Article 373-2, Code civil, Légifrance). A parent who moves the child abroad without that prior information therefore starts from a weak position.
Joint exercise of parental authority is the default in France. Article 373-2-1 of the Civil Code confirms that even where the judge entrusts the exercise of parental authority to one parent, the other keeps a right of supervision and must be informed of important choices concerning the child (Article 373-2-1, Code civil, Légifrance). In most expatriate families, both parents jointly hold custody rights within the meaning of the Hague Convention, so either parent can trigger the return mechanism when the other moves the child unilaterally.
Timing then controls the outcome. Article 12 of the Convention provides that where less than one year has elapsed between the wrongful move and the application, the authority concerned orders the immediate return of the child (Article 12, 1980 Hague Convention, HCCH). After one year, the judge must still order the return unless it is shown that the child has settled into the new environment. Every week therefore counts twice: it brings the one-year threshold closer, and it lets the other parent argue that the child has put down roots, started school and learned the language. Filing within days, not months, keeps the presumption of immediate return fully on your side. Readers looking for a shorter overview of the same mechanism can also consult our companion guide to Hague return proceedings for expats in France.
One boundary deserves emphasis because it regularly misleads parents. Where the 1980 Convention does not apply, for instance because one of the two States has not ratified it, the 1996 Hague Convention on parental responsibility cannot be used as a substitute return track. The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation, the supreme court for civil and criminal matters, which quashes decisions that misapply the law) held on 10 July 2024, appeal No. 23-22.272, published in the Bulletin, that “Elle en a exactement déduit que Mme [X] ne pouvait se fonder sur la Convention de La Haye du 19 octobre 1996, pour solliciter le retour de l’enfant, au titre du déplacement illicite.” In substance, the court deduced that the mother could not rely on the 1996 Convention to seek the return of the child for a wrongful removal. (Cass. 1re civ., 10 July 2024, No. 23-22.272, courdecassation.fr). Parents must therefore check first whether both countries are parties to the 1980 Convention, using the official status table held by the Hague Conference (Contracting States and Central Authorities, HCCH), rather than building a case on the wrong treaty.
B. Which court decides and which rules apply: Hague, Brussels II ter and French parental authority
Three layers of rules combine. The Hague Convention decides whether the child must be sent back. Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, Brussels II ter, adds procedure and time limits for moves between EU Member States and is directly available on EUR-Lex (Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, Brussels II ter, OJ L 178 of 2 July 2019, CELEX 32019R1111). French domestic law governs parental authority, protective measures and criminal exposure. The return judge does not decide who should have custody in the long term; that question belongs to the court of the country of habitual residence. The return judge answers a narrower question: must the child go back now so that the proper court can decide custody later.
In France, return applications concerning a child located on French territory are brought before the family judge (juge aux affaires familiales, abbreviated JAF, the dedicated judge of the judicial court who decides custody, residence, maintenance and related measures). The case is normally channelled through the public prosecutor (procureur de la République, the magistrate who represents the public interest and who acts on behalf of the requesting Central Authority). The practical route is described by the Ministry of Justice, which explains that a parent abroad seeking the return of a child wrongfully taken to or kept in France applies through the Central Authority system (International child abduction and cross-border access, justice.fr). Where the child has been taken from France to another country, the French Central Authority, located at the Ministry of Justice, forwards the file to its counterpart abroad, and the Foreign Ministry publishes a parallel guide for French families in that mirror situation (Child abduction abroad, France Diplomatie).
Inside the European Union, Brussels II ter tightens the timetable: the court of the State of refuge must decide within six weeks, allow the parties to be heard, and issue a reasoned decision that can circulate with a certificate. The Regulation also narrows the most invoked defence, grave risk, by requiring the judge to examine whether adequate protective arrangements exist in the country of origin before refusing return. That articulation between the Convention and the Regulation was decisive in a case decided on 14 October 2021: three children who had lived in Portugal were taken to France by their mother, the father sought return, and the Poitiers Court of Appeal refused. The Court of Cassation, appeal No. 21-15.811, upheld the refusal after recalling Article 13(b) of the Convention and Article 11(4) of the former Brussels II bis Regulation, which provides: “Une juridiction ne peut pas refuser le retour de l’enfant en vertu de l’article 13, point b), de la Convention de La Haye de 1980 s’il est établi que des dispositions adéquates ont été prises pour assurer la protection de l’enfant après son retour.” In substance, a court cannot refuse return on grave-risk grounds where adequate arrangements to protect the child after return are established. (Cass. 1re civ., 14 October 2021, No. 21-15.811, courdecassation.fr). Because the father had lived in France since March 2020, had lost contact with Portuguese services and could show no concrete protective arrangement, the refusal was legally justified. The lesson for expatriate parents is direct: whoever seeks return should arrive with tangible guarantees for housing, schooling and safety, not bare assertions.
French domestic law adds preventive tools before any abduction happens. The family judge may order an exit ban (interdiction de sortie du territoire, an order entered on the wanted-persons file that blocks the child from leaving France without both parents’ consent): “Il peut notamment ordonner l’interdiction de sortie de l’enfant du territoire français sans l’autorisation des deux parents.” In substance, the judge may prohibit the child from leaving French territory without the authorisation of both parents. (Article 373-2-6, Code civil, Légifrance). Parents who sense a risk during separation proceedings should ask for this measure immediately, together with a penalty payment (astreinte, a daily sum due for each day of non-compliance) to secure enforcement. Where residence of the child is disputed, the judge can fix alternating residence or residence with one parent and organise access rights, including supervised handover in a supervised contact centre (espace de rencontre, a neutral venue where handovers or visits take place under supervision) where direct handover would endanger a parent (Article 373-2-9, Code civil, Légifrance). Readers facing a custody dispute that has not yet crossed a border will find the broader framework in our guide to moving away with a child and relocation disputes in France, and parents confronting a dangerous former partner should read our analysis of withdrawal of parental authority where a parent endangers the child.
II. How to get your child back through France: first steps, procedure and defences
Speed, documents and the correct channel matter more than long letters of complaint. The procedure is free of court fees at the Central Authority stage, moves quickly, and concentrates on six to eight weeks of evidence. Understanding each step lets you act in the first 48 hours instead of losing months to the wrong forum.
A. The first 48 hours and the return application: Central Authority, prosecutor and the family judge
Begin with four actions in parallel. First, write down the exact timeline: date and place of the removal or of the scheduled return that never happened, flight or train details, messages in which the other parent announced the move or refused the return, and the child’s habitual address, school and doctor before the move. Second, gather custody documents: the French divorce or custody judgment, the approved parenting agreement, or the foreign order with its translation, plus birth certificates and proof of habitual residence such as school enrolment and medical records. Third, file a report with the police or gendarmerie in France if the child was taken from France, and keep the receipt. Fourth, contact a lawyer experienced in cross-border family cases without waiting, because the application must be precise on habitual residence and custody rights from the first page.
The formal channel then depends on direction. If your child is in France and you live abroad, apply to the Central Authority of your own country, which transmits the file to the French Central Authority; the French prosecutor then seizes the family judge. If your child was taken from France abroad, send your return application to the French Central Authority at the Ministry of Justice with the documents listed above. The Ministry of Justice page details the supporting papers and the transmission circuit (International child abduction and cross-border access, justice.fr), and the Foreign Ministry page covers the mirror case of a child taken out of France (Child abduction abroad, France Diplomatie). The list of foreign Central Authorities, with contact details per Contracting State, is held by the Hague Conference (Contracting States and Central Authorities, HCCH).
Costs are lower than parents fear. Article 26 of the Convention provides that each Central Authority bears its own costs and that Central Authorities and public services impose no charges for applications under the Convention, while allowing claims for the expenses linked to the physical return of the child, since each Central Authority bears its own costs in applying the Convention (Article 26, 1980 Hague Convention, HCCH). Case law adds a strict condition for shifting costs onto the abducting parent: in a judgment of 2 July 2025 concerning a child taken from Belarus to France, appeal No. U 24-21.917, the Court of Cassation quashed an order that had imposed 8,000 euros of costs on the mother under Article 26 while refusing return, holding that such an order presupposes a decision ordering return or ruling on access rights within the Convention framework. Parents who have already obtained a foreign divorce and wonder how France treats it should consult our guide to recognition of foreign divorces in France, since the custody provisions of that judgment often supply the custody rights relied upon in the return application.
Before the family judge, the hearing is focused and fast. The applicant must show habitual residence in the requesting State, joint or sole custody rights including the right to determine the child’s residence, and actual exercise of those rights at the time of the move. The Convention presumes that custody rights attributed by the law of the habitual residence and actually exercised were breached, and Article 12 then requires the authority to order the immediate return of the child (Article 12, 1980 Hague Convention, HCCH). The judge may order enforcement measures, including a penalty payment, and can regulate passports, school enrolment and handover logistics. Appeals exist but do not automatically suspend return, and within the EU the certified return order circulates for enforcement in the other Member State under Brussels II ter (Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, Brussels II ter, OJ L 178 of 2 July 2019, CELEX 32019R1111).
Two frequent mistakes destroy otherwise strong files. The first is negotiating privately for months before filing: delay feeds the settlement defence after one year and suggests acquiescence. The second is filing for custody in the country of refuge instead of seeking return: the return track and the custody track are different cases before different judges, and asking the wrong judge for custody first can complicate the return timetable. If money is part of the dispute, keep it separate: maintenance and the lump-sum payment that compensates the disparity in living standards after divorce (prestation compensatoire, a capital sum or exceptionally an annuity fixed by Article 270 of the Civil Code) belong to the divorce court, as explained in our guide to whether you will have to pay your ex the prestation compensatoire, not to the return judge.
B. Defences, timetable, criminal exposure and life in Paris and Île-de-France during the case
The parent opposing return has only a closed list of defences, and each must be proved by that parent. Article 13 of the Convention states that the authority is not bound to order return where the opposing person establishes one of two situations: first, that the holder of custody was not actually exercising custody at the time, or had consented to or subsequently acquiesced in the move; second, a grave risk that the return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation (Article 13, 1980 Hague Convention, HCCH). The same article allows refusal where a mature child objects to return, and requires the judge to consider information from the authorities of the habitual residence about the child’s social situation.
In practice, grave risk dominates. French courts interpret it strictly: general claims about a better life in France, a new school or a new partner never suffice. Proven domestic violence, documented abuse or a return that would separate a breastfeeding infant from its primary carer without alternative arrangements can succeed, as the 2021 Portugal-France case shows, but the applicant can neutralise the defence by proposing adequate arrangements: separate housing, a non-contact handover protocol, interim maintenance, school continuity and, where needed, a protection order in the requesting State. The Court of Cassation in that case expressly approved the appeal court for verifying concretely that no such arrangements had been shown, quoting the European rule that “Une juridiction ne peut pas refuser le retour de l’enfant en vertu de l’article 13, point b), de la Convention de La Haye de 1980 s’il est établi que des dispositions adéquates ont été prises pour assurer la protection de l’enfant après son retour.” In substance, a court cannot refuse return on grave-risk grounds where adequate arrangements to protect the child after return are established. (Cass. 1re civ., 14 October 2021, No. 21-15.811, courdecassation.fr). Consent and acquiescence also require solid proof: a signed agreement raises no difficulty, whereas ambiguous text messages rarely convince. The child’s objection is heard with care; the judge may hear the child directly or appoint an ad hoc administrator, and weighs age, maturity and possible influence.
Criminal law runs alongside the civil return track and should not be overlooked. Refusing without lawful reason to hand a minor child to the person entitled to claim the child is punishable by one year of imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine: the official text targets “Le fait de refuser indûment de représenter un enfant mineur à la personne qui a le droit de le réclamer”, which in substance targets a parent who wrongfully refuses to hand a minor child to the person entitled to claim the child, (Article 227-5, Code pénal, Légifrance). A parent who removes the child from those exercising parental authority faces the same penalty under Article 227-7 (Article 227-7, Code pénal, Légifrance), and the penalty rises to three years of imprisonment and 45,000 euros where “Si l’enfant mineur est retenu indûment hors du territoire de la République.”, which in substance covers the case where the minor child is wrongfully kept outside French territory, (Article 227-9, Code pénal, Légifrance). Moving house without notifying the other holder of access rights within one month is separately punishable (Article 227-6, Code pénal, Légifrance). A criminal complaint does not replace the civil return application, but it creates a documented record, can support protective measures, and deters further unilateral moves. Parents whose dispute also involves money being hidden or support going unpaid will find the civil enforcement tools in our guides to a spouse who emptied the joint account and an ex who will not pay child support, where pension alimentaire (the periodic maintenance contribution for the child’s upkeep and education) is explained step by step.
For readers in Paris and Île-de-France, three local points matter. Jurisdiction lies with the Paris judicial court (tribunal judiciaire de Paris, the single first-instance civil and criminal court for the capital, sitting at Porte de Clichy) when the child is located in Paris; cases from the inner and outer suburbs go to the judicial courts of Nanterre, Créteil, Bobigny, Évry, Versailles, Pontoise, Melun or Auxerre depending on where the child actually stays. Practically, locating the child quickly means checking school enrolment, municipal records and health coverage, and asking the prosecutor to act before the child is moved again. Timelines in the Paris region are tight but realistic: Central Authority transmission takes days to a few weeks, the family judge typically hears the case within weeks, and the EU six-week target applies between Member States, though appeals and expert assessments extend it. During the proceedings, keep the child in school, comply scrupulously with every interim order, avoid any new unilateral travel, and channel handovers through the designated venue where tensions run high. Judges notice which parent protects the child’s stability while the case runs.
Conclusion
A former partner cannot lawfully relocate your child abroad, or keep your child in France, by unilateral decision where you jointly exercise parental authority and the child was habitually resident elsewhere. The 1980 Hague Convention then commands the immediate return of the child, with only narrow, strictly proven exceptions for non-exercise of custody, consent, grave risk or the mature child’s objection. Brussels II ter adds speed and enforceability inside the European Union, French law supplies preventive exit bans and penalty payments, and criminal provisions punish wrongful retention abroad. Act in the first 48 hours: fix the timeline in writing, gather custody and school records, file through the Central Authority so the prosecutor can seize the family judge, and arrive with concrete protective arrangements rather than general claims. Return proceedings decide where the child must go back now, not who will hold custody for years; that longer question belongs to the court of habitual residence, better prepared once the child is home.