Overnight from 11 to 12 October 2026, hackers seized control of the software that regulates refrigerated display units and cold rooms in several hundred supermarkets across France. According to Euronews, around 150 to 200 stores of one large chain and nearly 100 outlets of another were hit, and the Paris prosecutor confirmed a large-scale attack on the cold rooms of several major food retailers, opening an investigation aimed at establishing the link with reported food losses and fires. Le Monde describes attackers who forced units up to 50C and stretched the overnight defrost cycle from one hour to eight so that alarms would ring later, causing tons of merchandise losses, while the affected retailers ordered all compromised fresh and frozen food thrown away. For a British family spending the half-term week in a French gite or hotel, the question is painfully concrete: a child eats food bought the day before at a local supermarket and spends the night vomiting. Against whom can the family claim when it returns home: the British tour operator that sold the package, the French supermarket that sold the food, or both?
I. Two debtors for the same spoiled meal: the tour operator at home and the seller in France
A. Can the British tour operator be ordered to pay for food it never sold?
Where the holiday was bought as a package in the United Kingdom, the starting point is not French law but the contract with the organiser and the Package Travel and Linked Travel Arrangements Regulations 2018. Regulation 15 implies a term into every package travel contract making the organiser liable to the traveller for the performance of the travel services in the contract, whether the organiser itself or another travel service provider performs them. The official text is published on legislation.gov.uk. In plain terms, the operator cannot hide behind its suppliers: where a contracted travel service fails, the traveller sues the organiser at home, and the organiser sorts out its own remedies against the supplier afterwards.
The French rule says the same thing for packages sold under French law. Article L. 211-16 of the Code du tourisme, in force since 24 May 2019 and verified on Légifrance, provides: « Le professionnel qui vend un forfait touristique mentionné au 1° du I […] est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat, que ces services soient exécutés par lui-même ou par d’autres prestataires de services de voyage, sans préjudice de son droit de recours contre ceux-ci. » (The trader who sells a package mentioned in Article L. 211-1 is automatically liable for the performance of the services provided for in that contract, whether those services are performed by the trader itself or by other travel service providers, without prejudice to its right of recourse against them.) The Cour de cassation applies this automatic liability strictly. In a cruise case decided on 17 February 2021 and published in the Bulletin (Cass. civ. 1re, 17 February 2021, No. 19-18.819), the Court recalled, under the earlier 2009 wording of the same article: « toute personne qui se livre ou apporte son concours aux opérations consistant en l’organisation ou la vente de voyages ou de séjours individuels ou collectifs est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des obligations résultant du contrat conclu avec l’acheteur mais peut toutefois s’exonérer de tout ou partie de sa responsabilité en apportant la preuve que l’inexécution ou la mauvaise exécution du contrat est imputable soit à l’acheteur, soit au fait, imprévisible et insurmontable, d’un tiers étranger à la fourniture des prestations prévues au contrat, soit à un cas de force majeure. » (Any person engaged in organising or selling individual or group travel or stays is automatically liable for performing the obligations under the contract concluded with the buyer, but may escape liability in whole or in part by proving that non-performance is attributable either to the buyer, to the unforeseeable and insurmountable act of a third party unconnected with the contracted services, or to force majeure.) Readers should note the version point: the 2021 decision quotes the pre-2018 wording, while the current Article L. 211-16 keeps the same automatic liability and lists three exits: fault of the traveller, a third party unconnected with the travel services, or exceptional and unavoidable circumstances.
That strength comes with a boundary that must be stated honestly. The operator answers for the travel services included in the contract, not for everything that happens on holiday. Where meals form part of the package, in a hotel restaurant or during an organised excursion, food poisoning can amount to a lack of conformity of a contracted service, and the operator is the natural defendant in a British court. Where the family rented a self-catering gite and bought its own groceries at a French supermarket, the spoiled tray is not a travel service the operator promised: the operator did not sell the food, did not store it and did not break the cold chain. In that configuration, a claim aimed only at the operator, arguing that it should answer for a supermarket fridge, would be fragile. The strong route then runs against the French seller under the law of defective products, set out below, while the operator may still owe information, assistance and, where the holiday itself was ruined, answers on the services it did promise. Sorting the two routes at the start avoids filing the right complaint against the wrong defendant.
One practical consequence follows immediately: notify the operator in writing before leaving France, precisely and quickly. Regulation 15(3) separately requires the traveller to tell the organiser without undue delay about any lack of conformity perceived during a contracted travel service. French law mirrors the duty: « Le voyageur informe l’organisateur ou le détaillant, dans les meilleurs délais eu égard aux circonstances de l’espèce, de toute non-conformité constatée lors de l’exécution d’un service de voyage inclus dans le contrat. » (The traveller informs the organiser or the retailer, as soon as possible in light of the circumstances, of any lack of conformity found during the performance of a travel service included in the contract.) A short dated email describing the symptoms, the product, the shop and the consequences, with the receipt attached, protects both routes at once.
B. What French law says about the unsafe food itself
Food that spent hours at 50C after hackers disabled its refrigeration is, under French and European law, food that should never have reached a shopping basket. European food law prohibits placing unsafe food on the market, and French domestic law repeats the prohibition: « Dès la première mise sur le marché, les produits et les services doivent répondre aux prescriptions en vigueur relatives à la sécurité et à la santé des personnes, à la loyauté des transactions commerciales et à la protection des consommateurs. » (Article L. 411-1 of the Code de la consommation: from their first placing on the market, products and services must comply with the rules on personal safety and health, fair trading and consumer protection.) Products that fail the European general product safety framework are barred under Article L. 422-1 of the same code. The retailers’ decision to throw away the compromised stock, reported by the British and French press, is the visible side of that duty.
The compensation route then runs through the French law of defective products, Articles 1245 to 1245-17 of the Code civil. The principle is stated in Article 1245: « Le producteur est responsable du dommage causé par un défaut de son produit, qu’il soit ou non lié par un contrat avec la victime. » (The producer is liable for damage caused by a defect in its product, whether or not bound by contract with the victim.) A defect is defined in Article 1245-3: « Un produit est défectueux au sens du présent chapitre lorsqu’il n’offre pas la sécurité à laquelle on peut légitimement s’attendre. » (A product is defective where it does not provide the safety which a person is legitimately entitled to expect.) The same article requires all circumstances to be weighed, including « la présentation du produit, de l’usage qui peut en être raisonnablement attendu et du moment de sa mise en circulation » (the presentation of the product, the use which can reasonably be expected of it and the time when it was put into circulation). Chilled food sold from a working refrigerated shelf, eaten within its use-by date, yet carrying a bacterial load multiplied by hours at 50C, is the textbook illustration of a product that did not provide the safety legitimately expected.
Victims do not need to identify the factory that made the food. Article 1245-6 provides: « Si le producteur ne peut être identifié, le vendeur, le loueur, à l’exception du crédit-bailleur ou du loueur assimilable au crédit-bailleur, ou tout autre fournisseur professionnel, est responsable du défaut de sécurité du produit, dans les mêmes conditions que le producteur, à moins qu’il ne désigne son propre fournisseur ou le producteur, dans un délai de trois mois à compter de la date à laquelle la demande de la victime lui a été notifiée. » (Where the producer cannot be identified, the seller or any other professional supplier is liable for the lack of safety of the product on the same terms as the producer, unless it identifies its own supplier or the producer within three months of being notified of the victim’s claim.) The French supermarket that sold the tray is therefore a direct defendant even though it neither manufactured the food nor launched the cyberattack. Where the product carries the retailer’s own brand, Article 1245-5 goes further by treating as a producer any professional who presents itself as such by putting its name or brand on the product.
French courts take breaches of food-safety controls seriously, including against distributors. On 19 September 2024 the Second Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation, in a Bulletin decision concerning minced meat placed on the market after deliberate lightening of bacteriological controls (Cass. civ. 2e, 19 September 2024, No. 22-19.698), approved judges who had found that « en mettant sciemment sur le marché un produit alimentaire potentiellement dangereux et sans faire réaliser les analyses qui s’imposaient, le gérant avait violé de façon manifestement délibérée les obligations de prudence et de sécurité prévues par le règlement CE n° 178/2002 » (by knowingly placing a potentially dangerous food product on the market without having the required analyses carried out, the manager had deliberately breached the duties of care and safety laid down by Regulation EC No. 178/2002). The Court added: « le fait pour le gérant d’avoir ainsi sciemment violé les obligations de prudence et de sécurité s’imposant à la société qu’il dirigeait caractérise la faute dolosive au sens de l’article L. 113-1 du code des assurances, peu important qu’il n’ait pas recherché les dommages qui en ont découlé pour les consommateurs. » (The manager’s knowing breach of the duties of care and safety binding on the company he ran amounts to wilful misconduct within the meaning of Article L. 113-1 of the Insurance Code, regardless of whether he sought the resulting harm to consumers.) That case concerned an insurance guarantee, not this cyberattack, and no finding of any kind is made here against any retailer: the point is methodological, and it matters for victims. Temperature logs, alarm records and control plans will be the decisive documents, because they show who knew what and when. Separately, the criminal side belongs to the prosecutor: « Le fait d’accéder ou de se maintenir, frauduleusement, dans tout ou partie d’un système de traitement automatisé de données est puni de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 100 000 € d’amende. » (Article 323-1 of the Code pénal: fraudulently accessing or remaining in any part of an automated data-processing system carries three years’ imprisonment and a 100,000 euro fine.) A criminal conviction of the hackers, if they are ever identified, would help victims on causation, but civil claims do not wait for it.
II. Turning a ruined holiday into an admissible file: proof, notice and forum
A. What to keep and have noted before leaving France
Food-poisoning files are won or lost on three links: the product, the illness and the causal bridge between them. Each link needs a document, and almost every document must be collected in France before departure. Keep the till receipt, even for a few euros: it proves the shop, the date and, often through the barcode, the batch. Keep the packaging with the use-by date and lot number, and photograph the shelf label if it is still there. If any of the suspect food remains, seal it, freeze it and keep it for analysis rather than throwing it away: a laboratory result on the leftover is the strongest bridge between the product and the illness. Note the names of witnesses, travelling companions who ate the same food, the hotel receptionist warned that night, the pharmacist consulted the next morning. Record the timeline precisely: time of purchase, time of the meal, time of the first symptoms, and everything consumed in between, because the defence will probe every alternative meal.
Medical proof collected in France carries particular weight before both British and French judges. Consult a French doctor promptly, describe exactly what was eaten and when, and ask for a written certificate recording the symptoms, their onset and the suspected diagnosis, with copies of any prescriptions and test results. Where symptoms are severe, go to hospital accident and emergency: admission records, stool or blood analyses and a discharge report transform a family account into a clinical file. The French medical certificate (certificat médical) plays the same role as a general practitioner’s letter at home, with one advantage: it was issued where the food was bought, on dates that match the receipt. Families who wait until they are home to see their general practitioner lose that contemporaneous link, and the gap becomes the defendant’s best argument.
Two notifications should then go out in writing. The first goes to the British tour operator, without undue delay, as Regulation 15(3) requires, with the receipt, the certificate and a short factual account attached. The second, for the French route, is a formal notice to the supermarket customer service identifying the product, the shop, the date and the harm, and requesting the identity of the producer or supplier: that letter starts the three-month period of Article 1245-6, at the end of which the seller that stays silent remains liable as if it were the producer. It is also worth checking the official French recall portal for any withdrawal notice covering the product concerned, since an official withdrawal corroborates the defect from an independent source. Each step should be sent by a traceable means and kept with its proof of dispatch: in cross-border files, the party that can show a dated paper trail usually controls the timetable.
B. Where to bring the claim and what the other side will answer
The choice of forum follows the choice of defendant. A claim against the British organiser under the 2018 Regulations is brought at home, in the English courts, under a familiar procedure and without translating the whole file: that is the practical attraction of the operator route, and the reason for notifying the operator early. A claim against the French seller or producer is brought in France, under Articles 1245 and following, where the evidence sits and where the defect occurred; the companion guide to direct compensation claims in France after food poisoning walks through that French procedure step by step, and a second guide covers refunds and compensation for British shoppers more generally. Nothing prevents running both routes in parallel, provided double recovery is avoided: damages compensate the same harm once, and any sum paid by one debtor is credited against what the other owes. For families whose package included the meals, the operator route usually comes first; for self-catering families, the French seller route carries the file, with the operator answering only for the travel services it promised.
Defendants have three predictable answers, and each has a French-law mirror worth knowing even when suing in England. First, the traveller’s own fault: unwashed hands, food kept unrefrigerated in a hot car, a meal eaten days after opening. The timeline and the medical certificate are the shields here, because they fix the product and the onset. Second, the act of a third party: the operator will point to the hackers, strangers to the travel contract, and argue that a criminal cyberattack was unforeseeable and irresistible. The answer is not obvious either way. A court will ask what the operator and the retailer concretely did: the identified software vulnerability reported by Le Monde, the stretching of the defrost cycle that delayed alarms, and the state of cyber hygiene expected of a professional cold chain all feed that debate, but they are press-reported facts, not judicial findings, and only the judge weighs them. The Cour de cassation’s warning in the 2021 cruise case frames the exercise: « En se déterminant ainsi, sans caractériser en quoi une chute survenue dans de telles circonstances était prévisible et aurait pu être évitée par la société Alsace croisières, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision. » (By ruling as it did, without explaining how a fall in such circumstances was foreseeable and could have been avoided by the cruise company, the court of appeal failed to give its decision a legal basis.) Exoneration is never granted in the abstract; it must be characterised fact by fact. Third, exceptional and unavoidable circumstances: the same fact-by-fact logic applies, and a large-scale attack under active prosecution does not automatically qualify where basic updates were missing.
Deadlines close the subject. Under Article 1245-16 of the Code civil, « L’action en réparation fondée sur les dispositions du présent chapitre se prescrit dans un délai de trois ans à compter de la date à laquelle le demandeur a eu ou aurait dû avoir connaissance du dommage, du défaut et de l’identité du producteur. » (Claims under this chapter expire three years after the date on which the claimant knew or should have known of the damage, the defect and the producer’s identity.) Three years seems long, but the clock starts with knowledge, and evidence fades in weeks: receipts bleach, packaging is discarded, memories blur. English-law claims have their own limitation rules, which differ between contract and injury, so the file should be put in order within weeks of the return home, not months. The family that notifies in France, consults in France and keeps everything returns with options; the family that waits returns with an account.
Conclusion
The October 2026 refrigeration attack gives British package-holiday travellers two distinct legal routes that must not be confused. Where meals formed part of the package, the British organiser answers at home for the failure of its contracted services, under Regulation 15 of the 2018 Regulations and, for French packages, under the automatic liability of Article L. 211-16, subject only to the three characterised exits of traveller fault, unconnected third party or exceptional unavoidable circumstances. Where the family bought its own food, the French seller answers in France for the defective product it placed on the market, under Articles 1245 and following, whether or not it manufactured the food. In both routes, the same file wins: a receipt, a package, a French medical certificate, a prompt written notice and a precise timeline. No accident, intrusion damage or liability has been established by any court at the date of writing, signed contracts prevail over general analysis, and only the judge decides. Built in France within days, the file speaks English in an English court and French in a French one.