KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Interpol Meets in Hong Kong as Red-Notice Abuse Claims Grow: How France Blocks a Political Extradition

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Interpol Meets in Hong Kong as Red-Notice Abuse Claims Grow: How France Blocks a Political Extradition

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

From 30 November to 3 December 2026, chiefs of police and senior law enforcement officials from 196 countries will gather in Hong Kong for the 94th session of the INTERPOL General Assembly, the annual meeting of the organisation headquartered in Lyon, France. According to the media invitation published by INTERPOL on 30 September 2026, the event will address global security challenges and foster international police cooperation, while plenary sessions and official proceedings will remain closed to the media. Journalists wishing to attend had to apply for accreditation no later than 30 October 2026. The choice of venue has drawn sharp criticism. When INTERPOL announced the Hong Kong assembly, lawyers and rights activists warned that holding the gathering in China could embolden authoritarian regimes, as reported by Newsweek, which quoted London barrister Ben Keith saying the venue puts one of the world’s worst abusers of Red Notices in the host’s chair. INTERPOL last met in China in 2017, in Beijing. For anyone living in France under the shadow of a foreign prosecution, the Hong Kong session matters for a concrete reason: the Assembly will elect new members of the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files, the body in Lyon that decides whether a Red Notice stays or goes, and France’s own courts have just confirmed, in a judgment of 6 October 2026, that an extradition requested for a political purpose has no place in France. This article explains what happens from the moment a Red Notice leads to an arrest on French soil, how French judges order release from extradition detention, and how they refuse surrender when the requesting state’s motive is political.

I. Arrested in France on a foreign alert: the first hours and the way out of detention

A Red Notice often feels like an international arrest warrant, but in law it is something narrower, and that distinction shapes everything that follows in France. INTERPOL itself defines a Red Notice as a worldwide request to locate and provisionally arrest a person pending extradition or surrender, while warning that such a notice is not an arrest warrant and that INTERPOL cannot compel any national police force to arrest the person concerned. Each member country decides what legal value it gives to a Red Notice. In France, an arrest on the basis of foreign alerts leads into the extradition procedure of the Code of Criminal Procedure, with strict time limits, a lawyer from the first appearance, and a judge who can order release. The Hong Kong debate about abusive notices is therefore not abstract for French practitioners: every contested notice ends up tested against these procedural guarantees.

A. The first 48 hours after arrest: the prosecutor, the lawyer, and the choice to consent or fight

When a person is arrested in France further to an extradition request, the clock starts immediately. Article 696-10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides: “Toute personne appréhendée à la suite d’une demande d’extradition doit être conduite dans les quarante-huit heures devant le procureur général territorialement compétent.” Within those forty-eight hours, the referred provisions on custody apply, and the presentation before the prosecutor general follows a rigid ritual. The prosecutor verifies identity, informs the person, in a language she or he understands, of the existence and content of the extradition request, and tells her or him that a lawyer of her or his choice, or a court-appointed lawyer, may assist, with an immediate private conversation. The lawyer may consult the file at once and communicate freely with the person sought. All of this must appear in the official record, on pain of nullity of the procedure.

The decisive moment of that first appearance is the question of consent. The prosecutor informs the person that she or he may consent to extradition or oppose it, explains the legal consequences of consent, and also informs her or him of the option to waive the rule of speciality, with its consequences. Consent leads to a simplified, rapid procedure; opposition opens the full judicial path. Anyone arrested on this basis in Paris or elsewhere should therefore treat the first appearance as the most important hearing of the case: statements made there are recorded, the choice between consent and opposition structures everything downstream, and the presence of a lawyer who can read the file immediately is a statutory right, not a favour. Families and employers should know that the forty-eight-hour limit is strict, and that any failure to bring the person before the prosecutor in time, or any missing notice in the record, can be raised to seek nullity.

If the prosecutor decides not to leave the person at liberty, the next step is detention under a specific regime. Article 696-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states that the first president of the court of appeal, or a judge designated by her or him, “ordonne l’incarcération et le placement sous écrou extraditionnel de la personne réclamée à la maison d’arrêt du siège de la cour d’appel.” This extradition detention takes place at the prison of the seat of the court of appeal. The same article allows an alternative where representation at every stage appears sufficiently guaranteed: one or more obligations drawn from judicial supervision or electronically monitored house arrest, until appearance before the investigating chamber. That decision can be appealed to the investigating chamber, which must rule within five days. In practice, obtaining liberty with obligations at this early stage depends on demonstrating stable residence in France, travel documents handed over, regular employment or family ties, and concrete guarantees of appearing at every hearing.

Where the person opposes extradition, the investigating chamber takes over. Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that the chamber is seized without delay, that the person appears within ten working days of presentation to the prosecutor general, and that “Si, lors de sa comparution, la personne réclamée déclare ne pas consentir à être extradée, la chambre de l’instruction donne son avis motivé sur la demande d’extradition.” The chamber delivers a reasoned opinion, normally within one month of appearance, and that opinion is unfavourable where the legal conditions are not met or where there is a manifest error. An appeal against the opinion lies only for formal defects capable of depriving it of the essential conditions of its legal existence. The opinion itself does not surrender the person: surrender requires a government decree, which can then be challenged before the administrative courts, as the second part of this article shows.

B. Extradition detention is not ordinary remand: the 20-day rule that sets people at liberty

One of the most misunderstood points, including among lawyers trained only in domestic criminal defence, is that detention for extradition purposes obeys its own release regime. A judgment of the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation of 19 August 2020 (no. 20-82.858) makes the point with unusual clarity, in a case that itself concerned an extradition request from the Russian government for large-scale fraud, diversion of funds and deliberate bankruptcy. The person sought had been placed under extradition detention since November 2019, received a favourable opinion from the investigating chamber in February 2020, and then filed ten requests for release in May 2020. The court of appeal treated those requests as ordinary pre-trial detention litigation and applied extended Covid-era time limits. The Court of Cassation quashed that approach entirely.

The governing text is article 696-19 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “La mise en liberté peut être demandée à tout moment à la chambre de l’instruction” Release may be requested at any time, counsel is summoned at least forty-eight hours before the hearing, and the chamber rules promptly and at the latest within twenty days of receiving the request, or fifteen days where the request was filed within forty-eight hours of placement under extradition detention. Construing that text, the Court of Cassation held in its judgment of 19 August 2020 that “il est mis fin à l’écrou et l’intéressé est mis d’office en liberté, s’il n’est pas détenu pour autre cause.” Failure to rule within twenty days ends the detention automatically, and the person is released by operation of law unless held for another cause.

In the 2020 case the Court added that the Covid ordinance extending time limits applied only to pre-trial detention litigation and had no application where the chamber rules on extradition detention under article 696-19. The cassation was ordered without remand, and the Court stated: “Elle aura pour conséquence la levée de l’écrou extraditionnel et la remise en liberté de M. S… G….” With no remand, the Court applied the rule of law directly and ordered release unless the person was held for another cause. For practitioners, the lesson is operational: file release requests in the correct procedural channel, diary the twenty-day limit from receipt of each request, and challenge any reasoning that confuses extradition detention with ordinary remand detention. For families, the lesson is simpler: prolonged extradition detention without a ruling on a pending release request is itself a ground for release, and it should be raised systematically rather than endured.

This release machinery matters beyond individual cases because it shows how France treats foreign requests: cooperation yes, but inside judicial time limits enforced by the highest court. The same philosophy governs the substantive refusal grounds, which is where the Hong Kong controversy over politically motivated notices meets French law most directly. Readers who want the companion guide to removing an abusive notice at its source, before the Lyon files body, can consult our analysis of INTERPOL files challenges and the Commission for the Control of Files.

II. When the requesting state has a political motive: how France refuses surrender

The sharpest criticism levelled at the Hong Kong assembly is that Red Notices can be turned into instruments against dissidents, journalists, business rivals and exiled opponents. INTERPOL’s Constitution answers that fear in principle. Article 3 of the Constitution strictly forbids the organisation from undertaking any intervention or activity of a political, military, religious or racial character. The Lyon files body applies that prohibition when it deletes notices, and the elections to that Commission at the Hong Kong Assembly, with candidates including France’s own Michel Forst for the human-rights expertise seat and new members set to serve a five-year mandate, will shape how strictly the prohibition is policed in the coming years. But in France, a second shield operates independently of Lyon: even where a notice or a request survives INTERPOL review, French courts and the French government can and do refuse surrender where politics drives the prosecution. Two very recent decisions show how.

A. No surrender for politics: the statute and the courts’ latest word

The statutory shield is article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which lists the cases where extradition is not granted. It opens with nationality and territory, then states the political protection: “L’extradition n’est pas accordée : 1° Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française, cette dernière étant appréciée à l’époque de l’infraction pour laquelle l’extradition est requise ; 2° Lorsque le crime ou le délit à un caractère politique ou lorsqu’il résulte des circonstances que l’extradition est demandée dans un but politique”. The provision then continues with offences committed on French territory, cases already finally tried in France, limitation, penalties contrary to French public policy, trial by a court failing to ensure fundamental guarantees of procedure and defence rights, and purely military offences. Two distinct political protections therefore coexist: the offence itself may be political in character, or the surrounding circumstances may show that the request pursues a political purpose even where the charges are framed as ordinary financial or criminal offences. That second branch is the one most often decisive in cases involving exiled business figures, former officials and opposition-linked defendants.

On 6 October 2026, five days before this article, the Criminal Chamber gave that second branch fresh and powerful illustration in judgment no. 25-83.277. The case concerned a businessman whose extradition had been sought by Kazakhstan for aggravated breach of trust and money laundering allegedly committed between 2005 and 2009, and separately by the Russian Federation. The Court recalled: “Le décret faisant droit à la demande après avis favorable de la chambre de l’instruction a été annulé par le Conseil d’État au motif que l’extradition avait été demandée dans un but politique.” Even a favourable opinion from the investigating chamber had not saved the surrender decree, because the Council of State annulled it on the ground of political purpose. The judgment then clarified the relationship between extradition refusal and France’s ability to prosecute the same facts domestically: “au contraire de l’article 696-4, 2°, du code de procédure pénale qui prévoit que l’extradition n’est pas accordée lorsque, d’une part,le crime ou le délit a un caractère politique, d’autre part, il résulte des circonstances que l’extradition est demandée dans un but politique, l’article 113-8-2 du code pénal, qui, introduisant une dérogation au principe de l’application de la loi pénale française aux infractions commises sur le territoire de la République, doit être interprété strictement, ne vise que le cas où le fait considéré revêt le caractère d’infraction politique.” A refusal based on political purpose therefore blocks surrender without automatically opening French prosecution, since the domestic-prosecution provision covers only offences political in character and must be read strictly.

The administrative courts apply the same vigilance at the decree stage. In a decision of 26 April 2023 (no. 470913), the Council of State reviewed a Prime Minister’s decree granting extradition to Albania and examined the fair-trial guarantee of article 696-4, 7°, under which extradition is refused where the person would be tried by a court failing to ensure fundamental guarantees of procedure and defence rights. The Council recalled that those provisions “ont un caractère supplétif”, applying only in the absence of treaty rules, since the request there fell under the European Extradition Convention and France’s reservation to it. It then set the evidentiary bar for applicants: “ses allégations se fondent sur des éléments de portée générale, sans que soient apportés des éléments circonstanciés de nature à établir la réalité d’atteintes personnelles”. General reports about a foreign justice system are not enough; the applicant must produce detailed material establishing the reality of personal harm, such as the specific conditions of her or his own trial. The decree survived in that case, but the method is the real teaching: document the personal file, not the country file, with judgments, hearing records, prison reports and expert opinions tied to the individual’s situation.

Taken together, these rulings draw the practical map for anyone facing a request that looks political. First, raise the political-purpose argument early before the investigating chamber, with a chronology linking the prosecution to political events, statements by the requesting authorities, the profile of co-defendants, and any INTERPOL deletion decision already obtained. Second, prepare the decree challenge in parallel, collecting personalised evidence on trial guarantees rather than relying on press articles about the requesting state. Third, remember that nationality, territory, limitation and public-policy penalties each provide independent refusal grounds under article 696-4, and that they can be combined. France’s record of annulling surrender decrees for political purpose, confirmed again in the October 2026 case law, is the strongest answer available to the fear that a notice issued abroad automatically means removal from France.

B. Two requests for one person: who chooses between a European warrant and a foreign extradition

A question that arises regularly in Paris practice is what happens when two states want the same person at once: a European Arrest Warrant from an EU Member State and a conventional extradition request from a third country. The answer was given at EU level on 20 March 2025, when the Court of Justice delivered its judgment in Case C-763/22 (Procureur de la République v OP), a case that began before a French court. France had issued a European Arrest Warrant for a French national prosecuted for counterfeiting payment cards committed in France, Thailand and Romania, while Switzerland sought the same person by conventional extradition. Arrested in Spain, the person became the object of a conflict decided by the Spanish Council of Ministers, a government body, which gave precedence to extradition to Switzerland. The French referring court asked whether EU law permits an executive authority, rather than a judge, to resolve such a conflict.

The Court answered yes, but with a condition that matters for every defence. As the case analysis records, the Court held that the wording of article 16 of the Framework Decision distinguishes between the executing judicial authority and the competent authority, leaving Member States discretion to entrust the decision to an executive body where a European warrant coincides with a conventional extradition request, since traditional extradition involves political and diplomatic assessments. On the remedy side, however, the Court required judicial review: executive discretion over precedence must remain subject to an effective remedy, following from article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, because the precedence decision may significantly affect the legal situation of the person concerned. Member States must therefore verify that an effective remedy exists against the precedence decision and legislate where needed. The Advocate General’s opinion in the same case had already pointed in that direction, stating that such a decision must remain open to judicial review under article 1(3) of the Framework Decision and article 47(1) of the Charter, while noting that review of the precedence criteria themselves is limited.

For a person held in France, the practical consequences are threefold. First, where France is the requested state facing parallel requests, the defence should identify early which procedure governs each request and which authority decides precedence, because remedies and time limits differ between the European warrant track and the conventional extradition track. Second, the nationality shield of article 696-4, 1°, and the political-purpose shield of article 696-4, 2°, apply to the conventional request and can determine the outcome regardless of the parallel European procedure. Third, any precedence decision by a government authority must be open to effective judicial review, and the absence of a remedy is itself an argument under article 47 of the Charter. The OP case also shows the human stakes behind precedence rules: the person concerned wanted to face trial in France rather than be extradited to Switzerland, a preference that readers facing similar dilemmas will recognise. Coordinating the European and extradition defences from the first hearing, rather than running them as separate cases, is what allows such a preference to be defended.

Conclusion

The Hong Kong General Assembly will set INTERPOL’s course for the years ahead, from the election of the files-control commissioners to the credibility of the Red Notice system itself. Whatever direction the 196 delegations choose behind closed doors, the position in France is settled by statute and confirmed by the courts within the last few days: a foreign alert is not a warrant, extradition detention ends by operation of law where judges miss the twenty-day limit, and no surrender follows where the offence is political or the request pursues a political purpose. The 6 October 2026 judgment annulling the logic of politically driven surrender, the 2020 ruling ordering release from extradition detention without remand, and the Council of State’s insistence on personalised evidence of fair-trial risk together form a coherent shield. Anyone arrested in France on a foreign request should invoke that shield from the first appearance: demand the file, refuse to consent without advice, diary every time limit, document the political context person by person and hearing by hearing, and challenge each government decision before a judge. International cooperation is the reason INTERPOL exists; judicial control is the reason France can take part in it.

📄 Official circular