KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Kavala v. Türkiye No. 2: What the ECHR’s 25 August Ruling Could Change

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Kavala v. Türkiye No. 2: What the ECHR’s 25 August Ruling Could Change

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The European Court of Human Rights is due to deliver a Grand Chamber ruling on 25 August 2026 in Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2), application no. 2170/24. The Court’s own calendar says that the case concerns Osman Kavala’s detention after its 2019 judgment and the criminal proceedings that ended with an aggravated life sentence. That timing makes the case more than another Strasbourg headline. It tests what remains legally possible when a State has already been found, in separate infringement proceedings, to have failed to comply with a final human-rights judgment. The practical question for lawyers is not whether Strasbourg can send officers to release a detainee. It cannot. The question is how a new judgment will interact with the binding force of the Convention, the Committee of Ministers’ execution machinery, domestic remedies and any later extradition or protection decision in France. The distinction matters for journalists, human-rights organisations, foreign counsel and anyone arrested in France on a request from a State whose record is at issue. A Grand Chamber ruling may strengthen the legal record, clarify the individual measures required and increase diplomatic pressure, but it will not replace the French or Turkish procedural acts that determine where a person is held. This analysis separates those tracks and identifies the documents and deadlines that should be prepared before the 25 August ruling.

I. What can the ECHR decide in Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2) on 25 August?

A. Why is the new Grand Chamber case different from the 2019 Kavala judgment?

The starting point is the procedural identity of the case. The ECHR announced that the Grand Chamber ruling will concern application no. 2170/24, not a reopening of application no. 28749/18. In its official case information, the Court describes the new proceedings as concerning detention after the judgment delivered in 2019 and the ensuing criminal proceedings in which Mr Kavala was sentenced to aggravated life imprisonment. The Court has already held a Grand Chamber hearing on 25 March 2026. The delivery date, 25 August 2026 at Strasbourg, is therefore a procedural fact published by the Court, not a forecast based on press coverage. The ECHR case page for Kavala and its calendar should be treated as the primary source for the timetable.

The 2019 judgment remains the legal baseline. In Kavala v. Turkey, application no. 28749/18, delivered on 10 December 2019, the Chamber found violations of Article 5 § 1 and Article 5 § 4 of the Convention. It also found, by six votes to one, a violation of Article 18 taken together with Article 5 § 1. The Registry’s official press release stated that Türkiye had to take “every measure to put an end to the applicant’s detention and to secure his immediate release”. The judgment therefore did more than criticise the length of detention. It identified an improper purpose in the restriction of liberty and specified the individual consequence that the Court considered necessary. The official 2019 ECHR press release and judgment materials record the findings and the release measure.

Türkiye did not end the detention in a manner that satisfied the execution body. The Committee of Ministers referred the question of compliance to the Court under Article 46 § 4 of the Convention. On 11 July 2022, the Grand Chamber held, by 16 votes to one, that Türkiye had violated Article 46 § 1 by failing to abide by the 2019 judgment. The Court explained that the domestic steps and action plans presented by the Government did not make the protection of the Convention rights practical and effective. Its official release described the result as a failure “to fulfil its obligation under Article 46 § 1”. This is not a political slogan. It is a final judicial finding within the Convention’s execution system. The 2022 Grand Chamber judgment on compliance is the authoritative document for that stage.

Application no. 2170/24 addresses what happened after that first judgment and after the infringement ruling. The ECHR’s public information identifies the continuing detention and the aggravated life sentence as the subject of the new case. The Commissioner for Human Rights’ written intervention before the Grand Chamber also describes concerns about the effectiveness and speed of domestic constitutional remedies, the implementation of domestic judgments and the use of new detention orders after release decisions. Those observations are not the judgment and do not predetermine the result. They show why the Court is examining a later period rather than simply repeating its 2019 reasoning. The Commissioner’s official account of the 2026 hearing must therefore be read as third-party material, not as a ruling.

The distinction affects the legal questions. The Court may need to examine whether later criminal proceedings and the conviction were connected to the same improper purpose already identified in 2019, whether the detention had an adequate legal and evidential basis, whether the domestic remedies were effective, and whether the Convention rights relied upon by the applicant were violated during the later period. The public reporting of the application refers to Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11 and 18, but the Court alone will determine the admissibility and merits of the complaints. A lawyer should not convert the list of alleged violations into a prediction that every allegation will be upheld. The proper method is to identify the Court’s operative paragraphs, the time period examined, the individual measures required and any finding about domestic remedies.

Nor is the new application an appeal on the merits of the Turkish criminal case in the ordinary sense. Strasbourg does not function as a fourth instance that reassesses every witness and every item of evidence. Its task is to determine whether the State complied with the Convention obligations, including the requirements that detention be lawful, non-arbitrary, reviewable and compatible with the purpose of the rights relied upon. Where Article 18 is pleaded, the Court examines whether a restriction was applied for an ulterior purpose rather than for a purpose permitted by the Convention. Where Article 6 is pleaded, it examines fairness and procedural safeguards rather than replacing the domestic trial judge. That framing will matter when the judgment is used in an extradition file: a Strasbourg finding about arbitrary detention or an ulterior purpose can be highly relevant, but it is not itself a French criminal judgment quashing a Turkish conviction.

The pending ruling also has to be read with the Convention rules on finality. Grand Chamber judgments are final under Article 44 of the Convention. Article 46 § 1 requires the High Contracting Parties to abide by final judgments in cases to which they are parties. The 2022 infringement judgment already applied that binding-force rule to the 2019 judgment. If the 25 August ruling finds new violations, it will create another final judicial record once the judgment becomes final, and the execution question will again move into the Committee of Ministers’ supervision. The immediate legal task after delivery will be to distinguish the date of delivery, the date of finality, any operative individual measure and the information sent to the Committee of Ministers. A headline saying “Kavala wins” or “Türkiye loses” is not a substitute for that reading.

B. What can Article 46 of the Convention do if detention continues?

Article 46 creates a chain of responsibility rather than a supranational police power. Under Article 46 § 1, the respondent State must abide by the final judgment. Under Article 46 § 2, execution is supervised by the Committee of Ministers. Under Article 46 § 4, the Committee may refer to the Court the question whether a State has failed to fulfil that obligation after giving formal notice. The Court then decides the infringement question. Under Article 46 § 5, the Committee of Ministers receives the case if the Court finds a failure. The 2022 Kavala judgment illustrates the sequence: the Committee referred the matter, the Grand Chamber found a violation of Article 46 § 1, and execution remained under the Committee’s supervision.

This architecture explains both the strength and the limit of the 25 August ruling. A finding of violation can make the legal obligation clearer, identify the measures required to repair the individual harm and remove the argument that the issue is merely a disagreement over domestic judicial interpretation. It can also guide the Committee of Ministers when it evaluates action plans, interim resolutions and information from the applicant. It cannot, by itself, command the French police, a Turkish prison director or a private bank to take an operational step outside the respondent State’s legal order. The Court’s authority is judicial and treaty-based; the implementation of the remedy still requires acts by national authorities and the execution machinery of the Council of Europe.

The 2022 judgment is instructive because it did not treat formal documents as proof of compliance. The Court considered the domestic orders, the acquittal, the continued detention and the Government’s action plans together. It asked whether the measures made the Convention rights practical and effective and whether the State had acted in good faith in a manner compatible with the conclusions and spirit of the earlier judgment. Counsel reading the new ruling should look for the same functional analysis. Has the State removed the legal and factual basis that caused the violation? Has it ended the detention or conviction that perpetuates the harm? Has it provided a remedy capable of changing the person’s position, rather than a document that leaves the same restriction in place under a new label?

If the Court finds no violation, that outcome would not retrospectively erase the 2019 and 2022 judgments. It would mean that the later complaints, as examined within the admissibility and merits limits of application no. 2170/24, did not establish a further Convention breach. If the Court finds one or more violations, the operative part will still need to be read carefully. The Court may identify individual measures, general measures or both. It may address the relationship between the conviction, the detention and the earlier judgment. It may make a declaration without awarding the remedy that an advocate or political campaign expected. The operative paragraphs, not the press reaction, determine what the State must execute.

The case is also a warning against treating the Committee of Ministers as an appeal court. The Committee does not replace the ECHR’s merits assessment, and the ECHR does not supervise every detail of prison administration. The Committee assesses whether the State has adopted measures that comply with the judgment. Its work includes dialogue with the Government, submissions from the applicant and civil society, and decisions at human-rights meetings. A lawyer seeking practical movement must submit a document that connects the judgment’s operative paragraph to a concrete continuing measure: a detention order, a conviction, an unimplemented release decision, a procedural refusal or a remedy that cannot operate in time.

For foreign counsel, the most useful output from the ruling will be a stable legal record. It should include the application number, the judgment date, the Convention articles found to be violated, the individual measure, the finality date and the execution status. It should also identify what the Court did not decide. That record can be used in a French extradition proceeding, a protection claim, a detention challenge, a request for interim relief or a submission to a financial institution assessing the legal risk of dealing with the person. It should not be presented as a warrant, a French judgment or an automatic prohibition on every contact with Turkish authorities.

France is not a party to the Kavala proceedings and cannot enforce the ECHR judgment in Türkiye through a French release order. Its legal significance in France nevertheless follows from the status of the Convention. Article 55 of the French Constitution gives regularly ratified and published treaties authority superior to statutes, subject to reciprocity. The official text of Article 55 of the Constitution does not turn every foreign judgment into a domestic order, but it requires French authorities and courts to apply the Convention within their jurisdiction. A French judge examining an extradition request therefore has to consider the Convention risk and the relevant Strasbourg material without pretending that the French court is the ECHR’s execution arm.

II. What can French and EU lawyers do if the detention continues?

A. How would a French extradition court use a new Kavala ruling?

The first answer is jurisdictional: a French court cannot release Mr Kavala from a Turkish prison merely because it has read the 25 August judgment. The French question arises if a person is present in France and a foreign State asks France to arrest and extradite that person, or if a person protected in France faces a request for surrender to the State concerned. The court then applies the French Code of Criminal Procedure, the applicable extradition treaty, the Convention and the evidence specific to the individual. A general Strasbourg judgment may strengthen the context, but the applicant still needs to show why the foreign request creates a legally relevant risk in the case before the French court.

The French procedural route should be read alongside the existing French extradition decree challenge procedure. That page addresses the domestic challenge to the executive act; this analysis adds the Strasbourg and Convention evidence that may shape the challenge. Keeping those routes distinct helps counsel identify whether the immediate target is the chamber of instruction’s opinion, the person’s extradition custody or the later decree.

Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure gives the French court a direct statutory filter. It states that “L’extradition n’est pas accordée” in the listed situations, including where the offence is political, where the penalty or security measure is contrary to French public policy, or where the requested person would be tried by a tribunal that does not provide fundamental guarantees of procedure and defence rights. The current text is available on Légifrance, Article 696-4. The provision does not create an automatic Türkiye bar. It requires a legal and evidential analysis of the request, the alleged conduct, the court process and the individual risk.

Article 3 of the Convention is central when the evidence points to a real risk of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment. The French Court of Cassation has stated that the chamber of instruction must refuse extradition when the person faces that risk. In its judgment of 13 January 2021, no. 20-81.359, the Court held that the chamber “doit donner un avis défavorable” where the risk is established, and it described the risk as established where the person held subsidiary protection for the country of origin, for as long as that protection had not ended. The official Cour de cassation decision, appeal no. 20-81.359, links Article 3 of the Convention, Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the French protection regime.

The reference to subsidiary protection is not a shortcut in every case. A person must establish the individual and current risk, and the court must assess the material supplied about detention, trial guarantees and treatment in the requesting State. The current French protection provision, Article L. 512-1 of the Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners and the Right of Asylum, describes serious and established reasons to believe that a person faces a real risk of the death penalty, torture or inhuman or degrading treatment. It is linked on Légifrance, Article L. 512-1. The 2021 judgment used the former numbering, Article L. 712-1; a current pleading should explain the renumbering rather than cite an obsolete provision as if it were still in force.

French procedure also protects the person at the first hearing. Article 696-10 requires a person arrested on an extradition request to be brought before the competent prosecutor general within forty-eight hours. The person must be informed, in a language understood, of the existence and content of the request, the right to counsel and the right to consult the file immediately. The official Article 696-10 text also records the right to consent or oppose extradition and the consequences of that choice. Article 696-11 governs the decision to place the person under extradition custody or, where representation is sufficiently guaranteed, under judicial supervision or electronic house arrest. Its safeguards are set out in Article 696-11 on Légifrance.

When the person opposes extradition, Article 696-15 sends the case promptly to the chamber of instruction. The person must appear within ten working days of presentation to the prosecutor general, and the chamber gives a reasoned opinion unless further investigation is ordered. The opinion is unfavourable if the legal conditions are not met or there is an obvious error. The exact wording and timing appear in Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This is where a new ECHR ruling can be converted into a structured French argument: identify the Convention finding, map it to Article 3, Article 5 or Article 6 risk, attach the foreign decisions and prison evidence, and explain why the risk is personal and current.

A definitive adverse opinion has a specific effect. Article 696-17 provides that when the chamber of instruction has rejected the extradition request and the opinion is final, extradition cannot be granted; if the person is not held for another reason, the person is released automatically. The rule is reproduced in Article 696-17 on Légifrance. If the process instead leads to a Prime Minister’s extradition decree, Article 696-18 provides a one-month time limit for an application for judicial review and states that a prior administrative appeal does not interrupt the contentious deadline. The official Article 696-18 text is therefore a document to calendar on the day the decree is notified, not after a diplomatic exchange has ended.

Liberty must be litigated separately from the merits of the request. Article 696-19 allows an application for release at any time and sets a maximum period for the chamber of instruction to decide, reduced when the application is made within forty-eight hours of extradition custody. The provision appears in Article 696-19 on Légifrance. The lawyer’s application should address flight risk, residence, reporting obligations, electronic monitoring and any other measure that can secure appearance. A Strasbourg judgment may be persuasive on the legal risk of return, but the French court still needs a proportionate domestic custody solution and a complete record of the person’s circumstances.

Other Cour de cassation decisions show why the new ruling should be used with precision. In a 20 May 2014 judgment, appeal no. 14-83.138, the Criminal Chamber accepted that a judicial authority may refuse execution of a European arrest warrant where the evidence against the person was obtained in violation of Article 3. The official decision no. 14-83.138 concerns mutual recognition within the European Union, not Turkish extradition, but it confirms that fundamental-rights analysis can affect surrender. In a 19 February 2019 judgment, appeal no. 18-82.495, the Court examined Article 8 and the proportionality of extradition in light of family and professional ties. The official decision no. 18-82.495 warns against arguing that residence in France alone defeats every extradition request: the assessment depends on the gravity of the conduct and the exceptional character of the private and family consequences.

B. Which evidence and remedies should be prepared before 25 August?

The first file should be a judgment file, not a press-clipping file. Download the ECHR’s official 2019 materials, the 2022 infringement judgment, the final text delivered on 25 August and the operative paragraphs in the Court’s official languages. Record the application number, the Convention provisions, the findings, the individual measures and the finality date. Keep the official English or French version beside any translation used in France. A headline may say that Türkiye must release a person; only the operative part shows whether the Court ordered an individual measure, repeated an earlier measure, found a violation without a new release direction or left execution to the Committee of Ministers.

The second file is a chronology. It should identify each detention order, indictment, conviction, appeal, release decision, constitutional application, Committee of Ministers resolution and ECHR communication after 10 December 2019. Each event should have a source, a date, the authority involved and its effect on liberty. The chronology should distinguish a judicial decision from a political statement and an application from a final judgment. For an extradition court, the key question is whether the evidence shows a present risk in the requesting State. For an ECHR execution submission, the key question is whether the State has taken measures that make the prior judgment practical and effective. The same document may support both arguments, but the legal tests are not identical.

The third file should explain the domestic remedy position. If the requesting State says that a constitutional court or supreme court application is pending, obtain the application number, the date of filing, the procedural stage and any evidence about the remedy’s ability to order release in time. If the ECHR’s 25 August judgment addresses the effectiveness of that remedy, quote the operative reasoning accurately and do not paraphrase a general criticism as a finding in the individual case. The Commissioner’s 2026 intervention raised concerns about speed and implementation of constitutional judgments, but it is not a substitute for the Grand Chamber’s analysis. The ECHR’s official case page should remain the first link in the chronology.

The fourth file is the country and prison evidence tied to the individual. It should cover the place of detention, the conditions in which the person will be held, access to counsel, medical care, family contact, disciplinary measures, trial access and the ability of domestic judges to review detention. A general human-rights report may support the context, but it should be connected to the person’s age, health, conviction, status and likely detention facility. The French Court of Cassation’s 2021 approach illustrates the importance of a real risk rather than a political label. The phrase “un tel risque est avéré” in the judgment is a reminder that counsel must show why the risk is established for this applicant, at this time, on this route.

The fifth file is the French procedural map. If the person is arrested on a request, counsel must be ready for the forty-eight-hour presentation under Article 696-10, the custody decision under Article 696-11, the ten-working-day appearance and the one-month opinion timetable under Article 696-15. The file should already contain a written opposition to consent, a request for access to the full dossier, a request for an interpreter and a proposed alternative to custody. If the chamber issues an adverse opinion, Article 696-17 is central. If the Government issues a decree, the one-month deadline under Article 696-18 is independent. If the immediate problem is custody, Article 696-19 supplies a separate release route.

The sixth file should avoid a common category error. The ECHR can find that Türkiye violated the Convention, but a French administrative court cannot order Türkiye to execute that judgment. The French chamber of instruction can refuse extradition under the French Code and the Convention, but it cannot annul a Turkish conviction. The Committee of Ministers can supervise execution, but it does not decide whether a French bank, French employer or French immigration authority must maintain a private relationship with the person. The correct pleading names the decision-maker, the legal power requested and the evidence needed for that power. Precision prevents a strong Strasbourg finding from being presented to the wrong judge in the wrong form.

There is also a timing question. The 25 August ruling will arrive before every later domestic step has occurred. A person at risk should not wait for the delivery date to collect translations, certified decisions, medical records or proof of family ties. Counsel should prepare a short emergency note that can be updated on the day of delivery: what the Court held, what is final, what individual measure is required, what the Committee of Ministers will supervise and what French procedure is available. If the judgment confirms a continuing risk but does not itself create a French remedy, the note should state that limitation plainly and move to the appropriate chamber of instruction, administrative court or protection authority.

Finally, every quotation must be checked against the official text. The 2019 release’s reference to immediate release, the 2022 finding under Article 46 § 1 and the wording of the 25 August operative part should not be blended into one sentence. The same discipline applies to French provisions: Article 696-4 is not a general political exception; Article 696-15 is not a merits appeal; Article 696-18’s one-month deadline is not extended by a non-suspensive administrative request; and Article 696-19 concerns release from French extradition custody, not release from a foreign prison. A reliable file makes the difference between an argument that attracts attention and one that survives judicial scrutiny.

Conclusion

The 25 August 2026 Grand Chamber ruling in Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2) will be important because it tests the Convention system after a first judgment, an infringement finding and years of continuing detention. It may clarify whether the later detention and criminal proceedings created new violations, what individual measures are required and how the execution body should assess the State’s response. It will not create a French release order or give Strasbourg a police force. The legal consequence will depend on the operative paragraphs, finality, the Committee of Ministers’ supervision and the national authorities that must act.

For a person facing a Turkish request in France, the practical route is different but connected. Article 3 risk, the fundamental-guarantees safeguard in Article 696-4, the hearing rights in Articles 696-10 and 696-15, the definitive adverse opinion under Article 696-17, the one-month decree challenge under Article 696-18 and the release application under Article 696-19 must be placed on a dated procedural map. A new Strasbourg judgment can be powerful evidence. It becomes an effective defence only when its exact findings are linked to the individual, the French decision being challenged and the remedy the court is authorised to grant.

📄 Official circular