On Saturday 17 October 2026, more than half a million people demonstrated across France against rising living costs and the decline of public services, and the day ended in some of the worst scenes of public disorder in the country’s recent history. The BBC’s Europe editor, reporting from Paris, described about 1,500 shops and businesses looted or destroyed, some 1,000 police officers injured, seven of them seriously, and riot police answering projectiles, burning barricades and looting with tear gas, water cannon and baton charges. Clashes continued into Sunday around the Place de la Republique, where the capital’s symbolic statue was defaced. All weekend, rumours circulated that President Emmanuel Macron would answer the violence with a temporary curfew in parts of the country, or even a state of emergency. In the end, as the BBC reported on 19 October, he used a televised Sunday address to call for national unity and to promise that the perpetrators would be punished, while Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu convened a crisis cabinet meeting for Monday and the president of the National Assembly called for a parliamentary inquiry. For the thousands of foreigners who live in, work in or were simply visiting Paris that weekend, one document mattered more than any rumour: the day before the demonstrations, the Paris prefect of police signed a detailed public-order order banning undeclared gatherings inside mapped perimeters of the capital, backed by weapons, fireworks and fuel bans, reinforced identity and bag checks, and a ladder of criminal penalties running from small fines to one year in prison. This analysis explains, for an international reader, what that order actually banned, what the police were entitled to do to anyone found inside the perimeters, and how a foreign national who was stopped, fined or held can challenge the measure and defend the criminal case.
I. What the Paris 17 October 2026 police order actually bans
A. Which gatherings, weapons and objects were banned inside the Paris perimeters
The starting point is a real, published administrative act: order number 2026-01358 of the prefect of police, signed in Paris on 16 October 2026 and laying down the policing measures applicable in the capital on 17 October 2026. The full text of the order was posted on the official website of the prefecture de police, with its annexed map, and sent to the Paris public prosecutor. Anyone who wants to argue about what happened in Paris that Saturday must start from this document, not from social media rumours, because it alone defines who was forbidden to be where, with what, and on pain of which penalty.
The order rests on the special policing regime of the capital. In Paris, general public-order policing belongs to the prefect of police rather than to the mayor, and the order cites that architecture expressly. The governing statute provides, in Article L.2512-13 of the general code of local authorities, that “Dans la Ville de Paris, le préfet de police exerce les pouvoirs et attributions qui lui sont conférés par l’arrêté des consuls du 12 messidor an VIII qui détermine les fonctions du préfet de police à Paris et par les textes qui l’ont modifié” The order also invokes the Interior Security Code, the decree of 29 April 2004 on prefectoral powers, and a series of criminal provisions that supply the penalties. For a foreign reader, the practical translation is simple: on public-order questions in Paris, the signature that counts is the prefect of police’s, and his orders have the force of law within the capital.
Article 1 of the order is the heart of the measure. It provides that presence in, and movement through, the mapped perimeters is forbidden in Paris on Saturday 17 October 2026 from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. for anyone taking part in a procession, march or gathering that was not declared as the law requires. Three features deserve attention. First, the ban is targeted, not general: it covers only people taking part in processions, marches and gatherings that were not declared as the law requires. A tourist walking to a museum, a student going to class or a cook going to work was not, as such, banned from the streets. Second, the ban is bounded in time and space: Saturday 17 October from 7 in the morning to 10 at night, inside mapped perimeters only. Third, the perimeters are part of the order itself through the annexed map, which means anyone challenging the measure can demand to see exactly where the line ran and whether they were truly inside it.
Article 2 adds a second layer that applied at the edges and inside of any procession, march or gathering within those perimeters: a ban on carrying or transporting, without a legitimate reason, weapons by nature and any object capable of constituting a weapon within the meaning of Article 132-75 of the Criminal Code, recreational fireworks and pyrotechnic articles, dangerous, flammable or corrosive substances in individual containers such as petrol, oil, gas, methylated spirits, methanol, turpentine or solvents, and protective equipment designed to defeat all or part of the means used by law enforcement to keep order. The weapons ban covers arms by nature and any object capable of constituting a weapon within the meaning of Article 132-75 of the Criminal Code. For foreigners, the sting is in the breadth: a box cutter in a work bag, a can of fuel, a mask or padding carried “just in case” can each turn a routine check into a seizure and a prosecution file, even where the person never touched a barricade.
The order explains at length why the prefect considered these restrictions necessary, and the recital reads like a situation report. It describes a national protest movement of school and university students that began with school blockades and degenerated into urban violence, with successive days of action on 29 September and 1, 6, 8 and 13 October 2026, systematically ending in clashes with mortar fire, projectiles, burning bins, damage to street furniture and shops. For Paris alone, the order states that since the start of the movement there had been 1,314 arrests, many of them minors, 286 injured members of the internal security forces and 20 injured education staff, and that on Tuesday 13 October alone there were 17 arrests including 8 minors placed in custody, 71 injured officers, 10 damaged shopfronts and 2 burned vehicles. It adds that radical activists were likely to join the announced mobilisation of Saturday 17 October, itself expected to draw a very large crowd, and that there was a serious risk of undeclared gatherings liable to disturb public order, in a context where the Vigipirate “urgence attentat” plan had been in force since 24 March 2024. A court reviewing the order will weigh exactly this motivation against the liberties restricted, so every line of it matters to a future challenge.
Two clarifications protect readers against the weekend’s two biggest misunderstandings. First, this order imposed no curfew. Nobody was ordered to stay home at night; the measure banned participation in undeclared gatherings inside defined areas between 7 a.m. and 10 p.m. The curfew remained what the BBC accurately called it: a rumour, which the President chose not to act on, preferring a televised appeal for unity. Any article or advocate claiming that a general Paris curfew was in force on 17 October is contradicting both the published order and the reporting of the weekend. Second, the order is not a state of emergency. No emergency regime was declared; the prefect acted under his ordinary public-order powers. That distinction controls which judge hears which challenge and which penalty applies, as the rest of this analysis shows.
B. Can the prefect ban a demonstration that was never declared?
Yes, and this is the point most foreign observers get wrong. Many visitors from common-law countries assume that a demonstration which was never declared cannot be “banned”, because there is nothing to ban. French law works the other way round: the declaration is compulsory, and the absence of a declaration makes the gathering unlawful while still leaving the prefect free to prohibit it expressly where public order is at stake.
The declaration duty is set by Article L.211-1 of the Interior Security Code, which provides that “Sont soumis à l’obligation d’une déclaration préalable tous cortèges, défilés et rassemblements de personnes, et, d’une façon générale, toutes manifestations sur la voie publique.” Only outings on the public highway in keeping with local custom are exempt. Organisers must therefore declare the march in advance; marching without declaring is itself the first illegality, before any question of violence arises.
The banning power sits in Article L.211-4 of the same code: “Si l’autorité investie des pouvoirs de police estime que la manifestation projetée est de nature à troubler l’ordre public, elle l’interdit par un arrêté qu’elle notifie immédiatement aux signataires de la déclaration au domicile élu.” The wording speaks of notifying the signatories of the declaration, which once led defendants to argue that an undeclared demonstration could not be banned under this text at all. The Court of Cassation closed that escape route in a judgment every defence lawyer in this field knows. On 16 March 2021, in case number 20-85.603, the criminal chamber rejected the appeal of a man convicted by the Epinal police court and fined 135 euros for taking part in a demonstration that a prefectoral order of 28 March 2019 had prohibited for 30 March from 8 a.m. to 11 p.m., even though that demonstration had never been declared. The Court held, in terms worth quoting exactly, that “l’autorité de police compétente peut toujours interdire, par arrêté pris sur le fondement de l’article L. 211-4 du code de la sécurité intérieure, une manifestation soumise à déclaration, dès lors qu’elle estime que la manifestation projetée est de nature à troubler l’ordre public, peu important que celle-ci ait fait ou non l’objet d’une telle déclaration.” In plain English: whether or not anyone filed a declaration, the prefect may prohibit a demonstration he judges liable to disturb public order, and walking into it afterwards is punishable.
That power is broad but not unlimited, and the limit is proportionality. In its landmark ruling of 13 June 2020, case number 440846, the Council of State’s interim-relief judge recalled that restrictions on fundamental freedoms must be necessary, adapted and proportionate, holding that “Ces mesures, qui peuvent limiter l’exercice des droits et libertés fondamentaux doivent, dans cette mesure, être nécessaires, adaptées et proportionnées à l’objectif de sauvegarde de la santé publique qu’elles poursuivent.” Applying that test, the judge found that a general and absolute ban on demonstrations could not stand, reasoning that “l’interdiction posée au I de l’article 3 du décret du 31 mai 2020, dont il résulte de ce qui a été dit précédemment qu’elle doit être regardée comme présentant un caractère général et absolu à l’égard des manifestations sur la voie publique, ne peut, à ce jour, être regardée comme une mesure nécessaire et adaptée, et, ce faisant, proportionnée à l’objectif de préservation de la santé publique qu’elle poursuit”, and accordingly ordered that “L’exécution des dispositions du I de l’article 3 du décret du 31 mai 2020 est suspendue en tant qu’elle s’applique aux manifestations sur la voie publique soumises à l’obligation d’une déclaration préalable en vertu de l’article L. 211-1 du code de la sécurité intérieure.” The 2020 context was a health emergency, not riots, but the method transfers directly: a Paris order that is bounded in time, mapped street by street and aimed at gatherings with a documented record of violence stands a far better chance before the administrative judge than a blanket city-wide ban would. Conversely, any part of a future order that overshoots, banning declared peaceful marches far from any trouble spot, is vulnerable on exactly this ground.
On the criminal side, French law punishes organisers far more severely than mere participants, and a second Court of Cassation decision draws a line that matters enormously to foreigners who were simply there. Article 431-9 of the Criminal Code provides that “Est puni de six mois d’emprisonnement et de 7 500 euros d’amende le fait : 1° D’avoir organisé une manifestation sur la voie publique n’ayant pas fait l’objet d’une déclaration préalable dans les conditions fixées par la loi ; 2° D’avoir organisé une manifestation sur la voie publique ayant été interdite dans les conditions fixées par la loi ;” Six months in prison and a 7,500 euro fine is a delict, a real criminal offence, and it targets organisation: sending the calls, leading the cortege, giving the orders. On 17 March 2020, in case number 19-82.117, the criminal chamber confirmed the acquittal of several men prosecuted for organising an undeclared festive musical gathering, holding that “seuls les organisateurs encourent les peines prévues pour l’infraction d’organisation sans déclaration préalable d’un rassemblement exclusivement festif à caractère musical.” Only the organisers incur the penalty; a sound-system user who is not an organiser is not criminally liable. The lesson for a foreign student or tourist is symmetrical: do not let an investigator reclassify presence as organisation, and do not supply, through messages or megaphones, the evidence that would support such a reclassification.
Simple participation in a banned gathering is punished more lightly but still bites. Article R.644-5 of the Criminal Code provides that “Sont punis de l’amende prévue pour les contraventions de la 4e classe la violation des interdictions et le manquement aux obligations édictées par des décrets et arrêtés pris sur le fondement des pouvoirs de police générale des autorités compétentes qui, à l’occasion d’événements comportant des risques d’atteinte à la sécurité publique : 1° Réglementent la consommation d’alcool sur la voie publique ; 2° Réglementent l’usage des artifices de divertissement sur la voie publique ; 3° Réglementent le transport de récipients contenant du carburant.” Behind that technical wording sits the Epinal precedent: participation in a prohibited demonstration draws a fourth-class fine, 135 euros in the decided case. Violations of police orders more generally fall under Article R.610-5, which states that “La violation des interdictions ou le manquement aux obligations édictées par les décrets et arrêtés de police sont punis de l’amende prévue pour les contraventions de la 2e classe.” Two further provisions raise the stakes where the situation degenerates. Concealing all or part of one’s face without a legitimate reason at or near a demonstration where public-order trouble is committed or risks being committed carries one year in prison and a 15,000 euro fine, since Article 431-9-1 punishes the fact that “Est puni d’un an d’emprisonnement et de 15 000 € d’amende le fait pour une personne, au sein ou aux abords immédiats d’une manifestation sur la voie publique, au cours ou à l’issue de laquelle des troubles à l’ordre public sont commis ou risquent d’être commis, de dissimuler volontairement tout ou partie de son visage sans motif légitime.” And where a crowd becomes an “attroupement”, meaning, under Article 431-3, that “Constitue un attroupement tout rassemblement de personnes sur la voie publique ou dans un lieu public susceptible de troubler l’ordre public”, remaining voluntarily after the dispersal summons is punished by Article 431-4: “Le fait, pour celui qui n’est pas porteur d’une arme, de continuer volontairement à participer à un attroupement après les sommations est puni d’un an d’emprisonnement et de 15 000 € d’amende.” A scarf pulled over the nose or a refusal to leave when the loudhailer orders dispersal can therefore transform a minor fine into a prison-risk prosecution, which is precisely why the behaviour on the street matters as much as the law in the books.
II. Stopped, searched or held: what happens to a foreign national and how to fight back
A. Identity checks, bag searches and custody: your rights, including interpreters and consuls
Inside and around the perimeters, the 16 October order expressly mobilised two reinforced search regimes, and foreigners should understand both before judging whether what happened to them was lawful. Article 78-2-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows senior officers, and junior officers acting on their orders and under their responsibility, to prevent a serious threat to the safety of persons and property: “Pour prévenir une atteinte grave à la sécurité des personnes et des biens, les officiers de police judiciaire et, sur l’ordre et sous la responsabilité de ceux-ci, les agents de police judiciaire et les agents de police judiciaire adjoints mentionnés aux 1°, 1° bis et 1° ter de l’article 21 peuvent procéder non seulement aux contrôles d’identité prévus au huitième alinéa de l’article 78-2 mais aussi, avec l’accord du conducteur ou du propriétaire du bagage ou, à défaut, sur instructions du procureur de la République communiquées par tous moyens, à : 1° La visite des véhicules circulant, arrêtés ou stationnant sur la voie publique ou dans des lieux accessibles au public ; 2° L’inspection visuelle des bagages ou leur fouille.” Alongside it, Article 78-2-5 targets demonstration sites specifically: searches of bags and vehicles may be carried out “sur réquisitions écrites du procureur de la République” and officers may then “procéder sur les lieux d’une manifestation sur la voie publique et à ses abords immédiats” to visually inspect and search luggage and to inspect vehicles. In practice, a foreigner stopped near a perimeter on 17 October could lawfully be asked for identity papers, have a backpack opened and a car inspected, provided the operation stayed within one of these frameworks and, for the demonstration regime, rested on the prosecutor’s written requisitions. Asking, politely, under which regime the check is being conducted and noting the answer is not defiance; it is evidence-gathering.
Where the check turns up an offence, or where officers consider it necessary for the investigation, the next stage is custody, and here the safeguard structure is detailed. Custody is defined by Article 62-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “La garde à vue est une mesure de contrainte décidée par un officier de police judiciaire, sous le contrôle de l’autorité judiciaire, par laquelle une personne à l’encontre de laquelle il existe une ou plusieurs raisons plausibles de soupçonner qu’elle a commis ou tenté de commettre un crime ou un délit puni d’une peine d’emprisonnement est maintenue à la disposition des enquêteurs.” Two consequences follow that many foreigners miss. First, custody requires plausible reasons to suspect a crime or delict carrying imprisonment: a simple contravention, such as mere participation in the banned gathering, does not by itself justify custody, whereas organising under Article 431-9, face-concealment under Article 431-9-1 or remaining in an attroupement under Article 431-4 all do. Second, the measure must be the only way to reach at least one of the statutory aims, since “Cette mesure doit constituer l’unique moyen de parvenir à l’un au moins des objectifs suivants”, which include carrying out investigations requiring the person’s presence, bringing the person before the prosecutor, preventing interference with evidence, pressure on witnesses or victims, collusion with co-authors or accomplices, and guaranteeing the implementation of measures to stop the trouble. A lawyer challenging custody will test each of these links: was there really a suspected imprisonable offence, and was holding this person really the only means?
For a foreign national, the rights notification is the most important moment of the custody, and the statute is explicit that language is part of it. Article 63-1 requires that “La personne placée en garde à vue est immédiatement informée par un officier de police judiciaire ou, sous le contrôle de celui-ci, par un agent de police judiciaire, dans une langue qu’elle comprend” of the placement, its duration and possible extensions, the suspected qualification, date and place, and the reasons for the measure. The same article lists the core rights: “du droit de faire prévenir un proche et son employeur ainsi que, si elle est de nationalité étrangère, les autorités consulaires de l’Etat dont elle est ressortissante”, the right to a medical examination, the assistance of a lawyer, “du droit d’être assistée par un interprète”, access to the file documents, observations to the prosecutor on any extension, and, during questioning after stating identity, the right “de faire des déclarations, de répondre aux questions qui lui sont posées ou de se taire.” Each of these phrases is a practical instruction. A non-French speaker should ask for the interpreter immediately and give no substantive answers until the interpreter is present. A foreign resident should ask for the consulate to be notified, which creates an external record of the detention. Anyone with a medical condition should ask for the doctor at once rather than at the end. And everyone should remember that silence after declining identity is a right, not an aggravating circumstance, while false statements about identity are a separate and serious mistake.
A short practical checklist closes this part, drawn from how these files are actually defended. Carry, or keep a photograph on your phone of, your passport or residence permit, your hotel booking or proof of address, your return ticket, and any proof of why you were in the area: a work rota, a university timetable, a restaurant reservation, a metro or ride receipt. If you live or are staying inside a perimeter, that fact is your best defence against a participation charge, so preserve it the same day. At a check, comply physically, identify yourself truthfully, and ask calmly for the legal basis of the measure and for a receipt or report number. In custody, use the interpreter, see the lawyer before any detailed interview, read or have translated every statement before signing, and keep copies of all summonses, medical certificates and inventory slips. The order itself records that 8 minors were placed in custody on 13 October alone, which shows how widely the net was cast; reinforced protections exist for minors, and families in that situation should seek counsel without delay rather than signing documents they do not understand.
B. How to challenge the order and the penalty: judges, deadlines and evidence
Challenging a French public-order measure means fighting on two fronts at once: against the administrative order itself before the administrative judge, and against any penalty before the criminal judge. The two tracks are independent, and winning on one does not automatically win the other, but each can feed the other.
The administrative track starts with the remedies printed at the foot of the order, which every recipient should read as a deadline notice. The order states that within two months of its posting or publication, a person may file a gracious appeal to the prefect of police, a hierarchical appeal to the Minister of the Interior, or a contentious appeal to the competent administrative court, and it warns that none of these suspends the measure. The two-month rule is statutory: Article R.421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice provides that “La juridiction ne peut être saisie que par voie de recours formé contre une décision, et ce, dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée.” Miss that window and the order becomes unchallengeable even if it was unlawful, which is why anyone considering a challenge to the 16 October order should calendar the deadline from the date of posting at the prefecture and publication in the official bulletin, and file in time.
Because a one-day order is over long before a merits judgment could arrive, the useful weapons are the interim-relief procedures. Article L.521-1 allows the interim judge, when an annulment action has been filed, to suspend the order where urgency justifies it and a ground raised creates serious doubt about legality: “Quand une décision administrative, même de rejet, fait l’objet d’une requête en annulation ou en réformation, le juge des référés, saisi d’une demande en ce sens, peut ordonner la suspension de l’exécution de cette décision, ou de certains de ses effets, lorsque l’urgence le justifie et qu’il est fait état d’un moyen propre à créer, en l’état de l’instruction, un doute sérieux quant à la légalité de la décision.” Where a fundamental freedom such as the freedom to demonstrate is at stake, Article L.521-2 goes further: “Saisi d’une demande en ce sens justifiée par l’urgence, le juge des référés peut ordonner toutes mesures nécessaires à la sauvegarde d’une liberté fondamentale à laquelle une personne morale de droit public ou un organisme de droit privé chargé de la gestion d’un service public aurait porté, dans l’exercice d’un de ses pouvoirs, une atteinte grave et manifestement illégale.” and “Le juge des référés se prononce dans un délai de quarante-huit heures.” Forty-eight hours is the fastest door in French administrative law, and it is the one associations used successfully in June 2020 to suspend the general demonstration ban.
What arguments can actually succeed against a perimeter order of this type? Four have real traction. First, proportionality in the Council of State’s sense: the wider, vaguer or longer the ban relative to the documented threat, the weaker it is, and any extension to peaceful declared marches far from the violence would invite the June 2020 treatment. Second, precision and publication: the perimeters must be defined by the annexed map, published and knowable in advance; a person fined outside a correctly mapped line, or under a map published too late to be known, has a serious legality argument. Third, personal situation: a resident, hotel guest, employee or student who had to cross a perimeter is not a participant, and the order by its own terms bans only participation in undeclared processions and gatherings. Fourth, procedure: competence of the author, statement of reasons, and transmission to the prosecutor are all reviewable, and the order’s heavy factual recital, useful to the administration, also gives the judge concrete claims to verify. None of these arguments suspends the order by itself, and none authorises deliberately defying the police on the day; they are made to the judge, with exhibits, within the deadlines.
The criminal track concerns the fine or prosecution that followed the street encounter, and it is here that the two Court of Cassation precedents bite. A fourth-class participation fine of the Epinal type is tried by the police court, as the 2021 case shows, and the defence file should methodically separate presence from participation: transport tickets, timestamped receipts, hotel keys, work messages, photographs showing the person shopping or commuting rather than marching, and witnesses. The prosecution must prove that the person was taking part in the prohibited gathering inside the perimeter at the prohibited time, not merely nearby. Where the charge is upgraded to organisation under Article 431-9, the 2020 acquittal precedent is the shield: presence plus a sound system, a flag or loud words does not make an organiser, and investigators must prove acts of organisation. Where face-concealment under Article 431-9-1 is charged, a scarf worn against tear gas or cold becomes the central factual dispute: was the face hidden voluntarily and without legitimate reason, at or near a demonstration where trouble was committed or risked? Medical reasons, documented in the custody medical certificate, matter here. And where remaining in an attroupement after summons is charged under Article 431-4, everything turns on whether the summons were actually issued in the required form and heard where the defendant stood, a point on which video evidence from the day now routinely decides cases.
Foreign residents should also weigh the immigration shadow of any criminal outcome, a subject developed in this site’s companion analysis of how a riots conviction affects a foreigner’s visa, residence permit and removal risk. The principle is straightforward and needs no embellishment: a delict conviction weighs far more heavily on renewals, naturalisation and removal decisions than a contravention fine, which is one more reason to fight an inflated qualification, such as organisation or attroupement, down to what the evidence actually shows. Keep every judgment, receipt and certificate, because any future prefectural file will ask for them.
One final practical warning concerns the next round. The BBC reports that new mass demonstrations have been announced within weeks, the Prime Minister is managing the crisis at cabinet level, and Parliament may open an inquiry. Perimeter orders of the 16 October type are quick to draft and quicker to publish, and the next one may cover different streets on a different Saturday. Foreigners living in or visiting Paris should therefore treat the method, not just the single order, as the lesson: check the prefecture’s published orders before any announced demonstration day, read the map, keep proof of where you must be, and carry nothing the order bans. The law gives the prefect strong tools for a violent weekend, but it gives the individual, French or foreign, a judge, a deadline and a language to answer in.
Conclusion
The weekend of 17 and 18 October 2026 confronted France with coordinated festive protest and organised urban violence on a scale that injured a thousand officers, destroyed or looted some 1,500 businesses, and pushed rumours of curfews and emergency rule to the top of the news in Britain, America, Canada and Australia. The state’s actual answer in Paris was narrower and more lawyerly than the rumours: a one-day prefectoral order banning undeclared gatherings inside mapped perimeters, banning weapons, fireworks, fuel and protective gear around any gathering, and channelling violations toward fines and, for organisers, masked participants and those who defy dispersal orders, toward prison-risk prosecutions. That architecture is lawful in principle. The Court of Cassation allows the prefect to prohibit even an undeclared demonstration where public order is threatened, and it punishes participation, while reserving the heavy penalties for organisers and requiring proof of that role. But every element is reviewable: the Council of State demands measures that are necessary, adapted and proportionate, suspends general and absolute bans, and decides liberty cases within forty-eight hours; the police court tests whether this person really participated, organised, concealed a face or ignored a summons; and the foreign defendant has the same procedural arsenal as anyone else, plus the interpreter, the consulate and the right to silence. For the international audience watching France, the message of the weekend is therefore double. The violence was real, the restrictions were real, and new demonstrations are already announced. Yet no curfew was imposed, no emergency declared, and the rule of law did not close for the weekend: the order carried its own appeal notice, the judges kept their doors open, and the best protection for any foreigner caught in the next perimeter remains what it was on 17 October, papers in order, conduct beyond reproach, and a challenge filed in time and in the right court.