KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Ryanair Bomb Threat and Cancelled Flight: Refund, Compensation and Rebooking Rights Under EU Law (2026)

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Ryanair Bomb Threat and Cancelled Flight: Refund, Compensation and Rebooking Rights Under EU Law (2026)

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 10 November 2026, a Ryanair flight out of Dublin faced a bomb hoax while Irish police warned of a significant security risk around the capital, days before a European summit bringing up to fifty heads of state and government to the city. The Garda Commissioner stated that officers had spent a long time on a threat and risk assessment for the event, that further hoax threats had arrived on Monday and Tuesday, that the messages appeared to come from outside Ireland, and that investigators were working with international partners including Europol after email accounts were hacked to send the threats. For travellers, the security operation is only half the story: a passenger whose flight is cancelled or heavily delayed because of a bomb alert faces an immediate practical problem, namely getting to the destination, getting the money back, and knowing whether the European fixed-sum compensation is due on top of the refund. This article answers those questions under the law that applies identically in France and in Ireland, Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, supplemented for package travellers by the French Tourism Code, and explained through the two judgments of the Court of Justice that govern every bomb-threat file: the 2008 Wallentin-Hermann ruling on extraordinary circumstances and the 2009 Sturgeon ruling on long delays. It is written for English-speaking travellers flying with Ryanair or any other carrier between Ireland and France, including French residents travelling to Dublin during the summit week, and it sets out the exact amounts, the exact time limits, the documents to keep, and the remedies before the French authorities and courts when the airline refuses to pay.

I. Your Ryanair flight is cancelled after a bomb threat: the refund, the rerouting and the fixed compensation

A. Reimbursement within seven days or rerouting: what the airline owes you immediately

European law treats cancellation first as a transport problem and only then as a money problem. Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of 11 February 2004 provides that, where a flight is cancelled, the passengers concerned receive assistance under Article 8 and care under Article 9, and hold a right to fixed compensation under Article 7 unless they were informed in time. The French text states: “En cas d’annulation d’un vol, les passagers concernés:” (English: Where a flight is cancelled, the passengers concerned:). The first limb reads “se voient offrir par le transporteur aérien effectif une assistance conformément à l’article 8” (English: are offered by the operating air carrier assistance in accordance with Article 8). Article 8 itself gives the passenger the choice between three options, and its first option is worded as follows: “le remboursement du billet, dans un délai de sept jours” (English: reimbursement of the ticket, within seven days). That seven-day period is one of the rare time limits the European text states expressly, and it runs from the passenger’s choice, not from the airline’s commercial timetable. The same article adds the second option in these terms: “un réacheminement vers leur destination finale, dans des conditions de transport comparables et dans les meilleurs délais” (English: rerouting to their final destination, under comparable transport conditions and at the earliest opportunity). The third option is rerouting at a later date at the passenger’s convenience, subject to seat availability. A passenger stranded in Dublin who must reach Paris for work therefore chooses: money back within seven days plus, where applicable, a return flight to the point of departure at the earliest opportunity, or rerouting to Paris at the earliest opportunity on Ryanair or, if Ryanair has no available seat in time, on another carrier arranged by Ryanair, or rerouting at a later date. What the airline cannot do is impose a voucher: the regulation gives the choice to the passenger, and a voucher accepted under pressure does not extinguish the reimbursement right unless the passenger has genuinely agreed to it in full knowledge of the cash alternative. Alongside Article 8, Article 9 requires care while waiting: “des rafraîchissements et des possibilités de se restaurer en suffisance compte tenu du délai d’attente” (English: refreshments and meals in reasonable relation to the waiting time), plus hotel accommodation where an overnight stay becomes necessary, transport between the airport and the hotel, and two free telephone calls, telex, fax or electronic messages. These duties apply regardless of the cause of the cancellation, including a bomb threat: even where the airline is exempted from paying the fixed compensation examined below, it still owes the refund or rerouting and the duty of care. Ryanair’s Irish operations change nothing here, because the regulation applies to every flight departing from an airport in the European Union, including Dublin, whatever the nationality of the carrier, and to every flight operated by an EU-licensed carrier arriving in the Union, which covers Ryanair flights into Paris Beauvais, Paris Orly, Marseille, Lyon, Toulouse and the rest of the French network. French residents flying Dublin to Paris are therefore covered on both legs. The practical consequence is straightforward: keep the booking confirmation, the cancellation notice with its time stamp, every receipt for food, hotel and taxi, and screenshots of the alternative flights offered, because each of these documents proves one element of the Article 8 and Article 9 claim. Travellers who bought a package through a French organiser hold an additional safety net examined in Part II, since the organiser answers for the whole trip.

The timing of the information matters as much as its content. Article 5(1)(c) of the regulation removes the compensation right only where the passenger is informed of the cancellation at least two weeks before the scheduled departure, or between two weeks and seven days with rerouting allowing departure no more than two hours before schedule and arrival less than four hours after schedule, or less than seven days before departure with rerouting allowing departure no more than one hour before schedule and arrival less than two hours after schedule. A bomb hoax discovered on the day of departure never satisfies these ladders, so the notice defence is unavailable in the Dublin scenario: the only way for the carrier to escape the fixed sum is the extraordinary-circumstances defence of Article 5(3), examined in Part II. Passengers should nevertheless screenshot the exact time at which Ryanair notified them, because the burden of proving timely information lies with the airline, and vague statements such as a notice allegedly sent days earlier collapse once the passenger produces the timestamped message. Where the flight is not cancelled but departs hours late after the terminal is evacuated and the aircraft is searched, Article 6 organises the same care on a distance scale, and the Sturgeon case law examined below converts a delay of three hours or more on arrival into a compensation right identical to cancellation. Travellers who booked with the firm’s aviation and travel dispute practice in Paris will recognise the method: secure the Article 8 choice first, consume nothing that could be read as a waiver, then claim the Article 7 sum with the timestamped evidence.

B. The 250, 400 and 600 euro compensation and who receives it

Once the refund or rerouting is secured, the fixed-sum compensation of Article 7 is the second battle, and it is also the most lucrative for passengers. The regulation states: “les passagers reçoivent une indemnisation dont le montant est fixé à” (English: passengers shall receive compensation amounting to). The scale follows: “250 euros pour tous les vols de 1500 kilomètres ou moins” (English: 250 euros for all flights of 1500 kilometres or less); “400 euros pour tous les vols intracommunautaires de plus de 1500 kilomètres et pour tous les autres vols de 1500 à 3500 kilomètres” (English: 400 euros for all intra-Community flights of more than 1500 kilometres and for all other flights between 1500 and 3500 kilometres); “600 euros pour tous les vols qui ne relèvent pas des points a) ou b)” (English: 600 euros for all flights not falling under points (a) or (b)). Dublin to Paris measures roughly 780 kilometres, so a cancelled Dublin-Paris Ryanair service carries 250 euros per passenger; Dublin to Nice or Marseille sits in the same band. The distance taken into account is the great-circle distance to the last destination where the passenger arrives late because of the cancellation, so connecting itineraries are assessed on the whole journey, not on the cancelled segment alone. The sum may be reduced by half where rerouting gets the passenger to the final destination within two hours of schedule for short flights, three hours for medium flights and four hours for long flights, which rewards airlines that genuinely reprotect quickly. Children pay the same fixed sum as adults where they hold a ticket, because the regulation compensates the inconvenience, not the fare paid: a 30-euro Ryanair ticket can therefore yield 250 euros, and the Court of Justice has repeatedly rejected the argument that the sum should be proportional to the price. The compensation is due by the operating carrier, meaning the airline that actually performs the flight, even where the ticket was bought through an intermediary or a tour operator. For the Dublin bomb-hoax files, the operating carrier is the Ryanair entity named on the booking, and claims should be addressed to it with the booking reference, the flight number and the date. Where Ryanair answers that a security threat exempts it, the answer is incomplete: the exemption of Article 5(3) requires proof of two cumulative elements, an extraordinary circumstance and the impossibility of avoiding it even by taking all reasonable measures, and the case law places that double burden squarely on the airline. The next part explains how that defence works in bomb-threat cases and how passengers defeat boilerplate refusals.

Two evidentiary points decide most compensation files before any court is involved. First, the airline must prove both the extraordinary circumstance and the reasonable measures, not merely assert them; a letter stating that the cancellation was due to a security alert, without the police report reference, the time of the alert, the time of the all-clear and the description of the reprotection efforts, does not satisfy the test. Second, the passenger must prove the cancellation or the arrival delay, which is done with the booking, the cancellation email and, for delays, proof of the actual arrival time at the final destination, such as the boarding pass of the replacement flight and any arrival record. Travellers departing from France benefit from an additional procedural route: complaints about systematic refusal can be reported to the French civil aviation authority, and unresolved claims can be brought before the competent French court, which for a consumer domiciled in France includes the court of the place of departure or arrival for direct actions under European jurisdiction rules, with the tribunal judiciaire de Paris hearing Paris-departure files. The French angle matters during the summit week because French nationals travelling to Dublin for European business, journalism or official duties face the same Dublin Airport disruption and return to French courts to litigate. Keep every document for the whole file: the regulation’s deadlines for the airline are short, while court proceedings take months, and a complete bundle turns a refusal letter into a losing defence.

II. Bomb hoax as an extraordinary circumstance: when the airline is exempt and how to challenge a refusal

A. Security threats, reasonable measures and the Wallentin-Hermann and Sturgeon rulings

The recitals of Regulation 261/2004 frame the exemption narrowly. Recital 12 states that carriers should compensate passengers “sauf lorsque l’annulation est due à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises” (English: except when the cancellation is caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken). Recital 14, which mirrors the Montreal Convention system, adds that carrier obligations should be limited or the carrier exonerated “dans les cas où un événement est dû à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises” (English: where an event has been caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken). A bomb threat called in against a specific flight, followed by evacuation, search and a police instruction grounding the aircraft, falls in principle within such circumstances: the airline did not create the threat and cannot be expected to fly an unchecked aircraft. But the exemption has two cumulative limbs, and airlines routinely prove only the first. The Court of Justice held in Wallentin-Hermann v Alitalia (C-549/07), concerning cancellations caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken, and that exemption is interpreted strictly, that technical or operational incidents inherent in the normal exercise of the carrier’s activity do not qualify, and that the carrier must show that even all reasonable measures would not have avoided the cancellation. Transposed to a bomb hoax, that means Ryanair must document the alert received, the time it was received, the security protocol applied, the cooperation with the Garda and the airport, the moment the aircraft was released, and every reprotection measure attempted, including whether a substitute aircraft or crew could have operated the service once the all-clear was given. An airline that cancels the evening rotation for commercial convenience hours after the all-clear, or that reprotects passengers two days later while seats were available the same evening on its own services, fails the reasonable-measures limb and owes the Article 7 sum despite the genuine threat. The Garda’s current statements help passengers here: according to The Journal’s coverage of the Dublin threats, the Commissioner described hoax messages, hacked email accounts and information operations, and cooperation with Europol. A hoax pattern documented by the police supports the extraordinary-circumstance limb but simultaneously invites scrutiny of the airline’s response, because a threat wave lasting several days is foreseeable in its generality, and the carrier’s standby planning becomes the decisive question. The Irish Times report on the Ryanair flight facing a bomb threat confirms the concrete setting: a named Ryanair service at Dublin Airport caught in a week of heightened alerts. Passengers should therefore never accept a one-line security alasan: they should demand the alert time, the all-clear time, the aircraft registration concerned, and the list of reprotection options offered with timestamps.

The second judgment every claimant must know is Sturgeon v Condor and Böck v Air France (C-402/07 and C-432/07), a principle French trial courts apply every week: “L’indemnisation forfaitaire est aussi ouverte aux passagers subissant un retard de plus de trois heures.” (Fixed compensation is also available to passengers suffering a delay of more than three hours.). Sturgeon holds that passengers whose flight arrives three hours or more late suffer an inconvenience comparable to cancellation and receive the same Article 7 fixed sum, unless the airline proves extraordinary circumstances with all reasonable measures taken. In bomb-threat weeks, many flights are not formally cancelled: they board late, wait on the tarmac during searches, or are diverted, and land three to five hours behind schedule. Those passengers hold the same 250-euro claim on Dublin-Paris as cancelled-flight passengers, measured on arrival delay at the final destination, not on departure delay. The airline’s favourite reply, that the delay was caused by air-traffic control or airport security rather than by the carrier, misses the legal target: the question is not who ordered the search but whether the carrier proves the double test, and routine security congestion during a known threat week looks increasingly like an inherent operating risk for which standby capacity should exist. Conversely, passengers should remain realistic: a specific, credible bomb threat against their own aircraft, followed by immediate cancellation and diligent same-day reprotection that still arrives beyond the tolerance thresholds for reasons outside the carrier’s control, will generally exempt the compensation while preserving the refund, rerouting and care rights. The dividing line is evidence, and the evidence lies mostly with the airline, which is why European law places the burden of proof on the carrier. A well-drafted claim therefore reverses the dynamic: it sets out the flight facts in one paragraph, cites Articles 5 and 7 with the exact amounts, recalls the double test, and invites the carrier to produce the alert log and the reprotection record within a stated time, failing which the file goes to the mediator or the court with the correspondence attached.

The French Court of Cassation applies exactly this double test. In Cass. civ. 1re, 12 September 2018, No 17-11.361 (EasyJet), it held: “Mais attendu qu’il résulte de l’article 5, § 3, du règlement (CE) n° 261/2004, tel qu’interprété par la Cour de justice de l’Union européenne, qu’un transporteur aérien effectif n’est pas tenu de verser l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 s’il est en mesure de prouver que l’annulation ou le retard de trois heures ou plus à l’arrivée à destination d’un vol sont dus à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises” (English: But whereas it follows from Article 5(3) of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, as interpreted by the Court of Justice of the European Union, that an operating air carrier is not required to pay the compensation provided for in Article 7 if it is able to prove that the cancellation or the delay of three hours or more on arrival at the destination of a flight is due to extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken). The same chamber confirmed in Cass. civ. 1re, 17 February 2021, No 19-21.362: “En application de ces dispositions du règlement, peut bénéficier de l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 le passager d’un vol qui a atteint sa destination finale avec un retard de trois heures ou plus par rapport à l’heure prévue initialement” (English: Under these provisions of the regulation, compensation under Article 7 may be claimed by the passenger of a flight which reached its final destination with a delay of three hours or more compared with the originally scheduled time). First-instance courts apply this daily: on 7 February 2025 the Tribunal judiciaire de Toulouse (RG 24/01209) awarded the fixed sum for a long-haul delay, recalling that “En cas d’annulation de vol ou de retard supérieur à 3 heures pour un vol extracommunautaire de plus de 3.500 kms, le passager doit bénéficier d’une indemnité forfaitaire de 600 €” (English: In the event of cancellation or delay of more than 3 hours for an extra-Community flight of more than 3,500 km, the passenger must receive fixed compensation of 600 euros). For Dublin-Paris the same reasoning yields 250 euros, and the airline invoking a bomb threat must still produce the alert log and the reprotection record, exactly as the Cassation requires.

B. Claiming from France: documents, complaint ladder, package travellers and Paris proceedings

French-based passengers enjoy a structured complaint ladder that should be followed in order, because each step creates the paper trail the next one needs. Step one is the direct claim to the operating carrier within days of the disruption, by the airline’s online claim form and by email, attaching the booking confirmation, the cancellation or delay notice, boarding passes, receipts for meals, hotel and transfers, and a clear statement of the choice exercised under Article 8 and the Article 7 sum claimed with the distance band. The letter should quote the regulation rather than describe it, demand the alert and all-clear times plus the reprotection record where extraordinary circumstances are invoked, and set a four-week deadline. Step two, if the carrier refuses or stays silent, is the independent mediation for consumer disputes and the report to the French civil aviation authority for regulatory monitoring, together with, for online purchases, the European online dispute resolution framework. Step three is court action, where French consumers hold a genuine advantage: the tribunal judiciaire of the passenger’s domicile or of the place of departure or arrival can hear direct Article 7 claims, which means a Paris-domiciled traveller on a Dublin-Paris Ryanair service can litigate in Paris, in French or with English supporting documents, without returning to Ireland. Interest runs from the formal notice, and the costs of a well-documented small claim remain proportionate to a 250-euro principal plus care expenses. Throughout, the prescription and forfeiture rule of this practice applies: no deadline is asserted without its text, so this article states only the time limits written in the instruments it cites, namely the seven-day reimbursement period of Article 8, the two-week, seven-day and notice ladders of Article 5(1)(c), and the reasonable-measures test whose content comes from the judgments themselves. Travellers who read advice elsewhere about limitation periods should verify the cited text before relying on it, because courts apply the text, not summaries.

Travellers who bought a package from a French organiser hold a second debtor alongside the airline. Article L211-14 of the French Tourism Code provides: “Le voyageur a le droit de résoudre le contrat avant le début du voyage ou du séjour sans payer de frais de résolution si des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables, survenant au lieu de destination ou à proximité immédiate de celui-ci, ont des conséquences importantes sur l’exécution du contrat ou sur le transport des passagers vers le lieu de destination.” (English: The traveller has the right to terminate the contract before the start of the trip or stay without paying termination fees if exceptional and unavoidable circumstances occurring at the destination or in its immediate vicinity significantly affect performance of the contract or the carriage of passengers to the destination.). A traveller who has not yet departed for Dublin when the threat wave is officially documented can therefore cancel the package without fees and obtain full reimbursement of payments made, though without additional compensation. Article L211-16 of the same code adds the organiser’s strict liability: “Le professionnel qui vend un forfait touristique mentionné au 1° du I de l’ article L. 211-1 est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat” (English: A trader selling a package mentioned in Article L.211-1 is automatically liable for the performance of the services provided for in that contract). The organiser may escape liability only by proving the damage is attributable to the traveller, to a third party unconnected with the travel services, or to exceptional and unavoidable circumstances: “Toutefois le professionnel peut s’exonérer de tout ou partie de sa responsabilité en apportant la preuve que le dommage est imputable soit au voyageur, soit à un tiers étranger à la fourniture des services de voyage compris dans le contrat, soit à des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables.” (English: However, the trader may be exonerated from all or part of its liability by proving that the damage is attributable either to the traveller, or to a third party unconnected with the provision of the travel services included in the contract, or to exceptional and unavoidable circumstances.). In practice, the package traveller claims reprotection and out-of-pocket costs from the organiser while preserving the direct Article 7 claim against Ryanair, because the two debtors answer on different legal bases.

Two further Tourism Code provisions complete the package traveller’s shield. First, the organiser must assist stranded clients: Article L211-17-1 states “L’organisateur d’un voyage ou séjour ou le détaillant apporte dans les meilleurs délais eu égard aux circonstances de l’espèce une aide appropriée au voyageur en difficulté, y compris dans les circonstances mentionnées au VII de l’ article L. 211-16” (English: The organiser of a trip or stay or the retailer shall provide appropriate assistance without undue delay to the traveller in difficulty, including in the circumstances referred to in VII of Article L.211-16). A French family stuck in Dublin after a bomb-threat cancellation can therefore demand real help, not a hotline message. Second, where services are not performed as agreed, Article L211-17 provides “Le voyageur a droit à une réduction de prix appropriée pour toute période de non-conformité des services fournis dans le cadre d’un contrat, sauf si l’organisateur ou le détaillant prouve que la non-conformité est imputable au voyageur” (English: The traveller is entitled to an appropriate price reduction for any period of non-conformity of the services provided under a contract, unless the organiser or retailer proves that the non-conformity is attributable to the traveller). The scope of these rules covers package travel defined in Article L211-1, which applies to traders selling “Des forfaits touristiques” (“package travel”). Together, these texts mean the Dublin-stranded package traveller cumulates remedies: EU261 care and compensation from Ryanair, plus assistance, price reduction and damages from the French organiser.

The liability architecture beyond Europe rests on the Montreal Convention system approved by the European Community, which governs bodily injury and baggage on international carriage and confirms that air carrier obligations operate within a unified international framework. For the summit week, one final French specificity deserves mention: travellers domiciled in Paris and the Île-de-France who litigate locally sue before the tribunal judiciaire de Paris, keep French-language exhibits with English originals attached, and request that the judgment record the exact arrival delay, since that finding alone carries the Sturgeon claim. Prepared this way, a bomb-threat file stops being a story about fear and becomes a file about proof, which is precisely the ground on which passengers win.

Conclusion

A bomb hoax against a Ryanair flight at Dublin Airport does not suspend European air passenger law: it triggers it. The passenger chooses between reimbursement within seven days and rerouting at the earliest opportunity, receives care while waiting, and holds a 250-euro claim on Dublin-Paris unless the carrier proves both the extraordinary circumstance and the reasonable measures that could not avoid it. Security threats satisfy the first limb far more easily than the second, which is why timestamped reprotection records decide these files. Package travellers add the French Tourism Code to their arsenal, with fee-free termination before departure and the organiser’s automatic liability. French residents disrupted during the Dublin summit week can run the whole ladder from France and, if needed, sue in Paris with a bundle built from day one: booking, notices, receipts and the airline’s own alert log. That bundle turns an anxious night at the airport into an enforceable claim.

📄 Official circular