KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Abramovich Sanctions Defeat and Frozen French Villas: How to Challenge an EU Listing and Unfreeze Assets from France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Abramovich Sanctions Defeat and Frozen French Villas: How to Challenge an EU Listing and Unfreeze Assets from France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 12 October 2026, The Guardian published an investigation based on leaked files suggesting that aides of Russian billionaire Roman Abramovich backdated contractual paperwork and produced misleading accounts in Cyprus between 1999 and 2013, in what one London financial-crime KC characterised, in comments reported alongside the files, as an arrangement designed to keep assets away from legitimate taxation. Lawyers for Mr Abramovich denied any wrongdoing, saying he had properly relied on the advice of his professional advisers, and his aides and the Cypriot audit firm involved issued similar denials, with the firm stating that it complies with applicable law. One month earlier, in September 2026, the EU General Court dismissed Mr Abramovich’s latest challenge to the European Union sanctions imposed on him after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, upholding asset freezes and travel restrictions extended through September 2025 and March 2026, according to the Court’s press statement reported by Politico. In France, the story has a concrete footprint: in April 2022 the French finance ministry announced the freezing of 33 properties, including about a dozen linked to Mr Abramovich such as the Château de la Croë in Antibes, while in the United Kingdom the government is seeking to direct the 2.5 billion pounds in proceeds from the sale of Chelsea Football Club. The analysis below is general in scope: it describes the verification steps, court remedies and release procedures useful in any comparable situation and makes no finding about Mr Abramovich’s own position, on which this article takes no view.

I. Challenging an EU sanctions listing: why courts uphold most listings and when they annul them

The September 2026 defeat illustrates how the EU courts review sanctions, and it contrasts with recent annulments that show where challenges can succeed. Anyone listed, and any bank, business partner or family member affected in France, needs to understand both sides before spending years in Luxembourg.

A. Why did the General Court keep this listing when other oligarchs won theirs

The EU sanctions against Russian interests rest principally on Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 concerning restrictive measures in respect of actions undermining Ukraine, which freezes the funds and economic resources of designated persons, and on Council Regulation (EU) No 833/2014 imposing sectoral restrictions. The Council renews the individual designations every six months, and each renewal is a separate legal act that can be challenged. In the September 2026 ruling, the General Court held that the Council acted within its powers when it extended the measures, finding that the sanctions criteria met the standards of objectivity, precision and proportionality, as reported by Politico from the Court’s statement. The judges accepted that the listing targets prominent businesspeople operating in Russia, particularly those active in sectors providing significant revenue to the Russian government, and dismissed the argument that the designation rested on public notoriety, noting that the measures were imposed because of the capital holding rather than any wish to exploit public notoriety. The Court also rejected the procedural argument that the measures had effectively been decided by Council working groups rather than by the member states themselves, recalling that preparatory work does not displace the Council’s final decision.

This reasoning should be read alongside the annulments that other listed persons obtained and that this desk has analysed in detail. In two 2026 cases, the EU courts annulled listings where the Council’s statement of reasons was too thin or the evidence too stale, opening a path to the release of frozen funds that our analysis of the Avetisyan annulment and relisting practice and our analysis of the Tkach frozen-asset ruling explain step by step. A further practical point concerns evidence. The Council typically relies on a mix of open-source material, member-state proposals and, occasionally, confidential information that it summarises but does not fully disclose. The General Court has accepted that security considerations can justify limited disclosure, yet it still requires that the person be told the essence of the grounds so that an effective defence is possible. Where the file contains only undated press articles or assertions carried over unchanged from one renewal to the next, the reasoning plea gains real traction, and several annulments turned precisely on that evidentiary hollowness. Conversely, where the file documents current shareholdings, board positions or dividend flows with registry extracts and audited statements, the manifest-error plea collapses, because the Court will not substitute its own economic assessment for the Council’s. Applicants should therefore commission, from the outset, certified corporate and banking records covering the entire listing period, so that every factual allegation in the statement of reasons meets a dated, sourced rebuttal.

The lesson for any listed person is therefore a double one. A challenge built only on public profile, on the alleged disproportionality of wealth destruction, or on the internal division of labour inside the Council fails, as the September 2026 judgment confirms. A challenge built on the insufficiency of the individual statement of reasons, on evidence that predates the listing period, or on a manifest error in the assessment of the person’s current economic role can succeed, as the annulment cases show. Our pillar guide to the extended EU Russia sanctions regime and how to challenge a listing from France maps the full decisional practice behind this distinction, and it remains the starting point before any filing.

B. How to file a listing challenge that the EU courts will actually examine

A credible challenge follows a fixed sequence, and each step has its own deadline and its own forum. The first step is administrative, not judicial: the listed person writes to the Council to request reconsideration and to obtain the file, identifying precisely which designation acts are contested and asking for disclosure of the evidence. This request interrupts nothing, but it frames the later court action and sometimes produces a delisting without litigation. The second step is the action for annulment before the General Court under Article 263 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which must be lodged within two months of the notification or publication of the contested renewal, plus a ten-day extension on account of distance. Because the Council renews listings every six months, practitioners routinely file against each successive renewal and ask the Court to join the cases, so that at least one live act is always before the judges.

The pleas that the Court entertains fall into a stable typology. The plea of insufficient reasoning attacks the individual statement of reasons accompanying the listing: the Council must explain, for each person, which criterion is met and on which facts it relies, and formulaic repetition of the criterion is not enough. The plea of manifest error of assessment invites the Court to verify whether the facts relied upon are materially accurate and capable of supporting the conclusion; here the Court exercises a real, deferential, review, and it has annulled listings where shareholdings had been divested or where the revenue-to-the-state link was assumed rather than shown. Fundamental-rights pleas invoke the right to property, the freedom to conduct a business and the right to an effective remedy under the Charter of Fundamental Rights, and they succeed only where the measure goes beyond what is necessary, which is why proportionality arguments work better against the scope of a freeze than against the principle of listing. Alongside the annulment action, counsel should systematically apply for interim measures to suspend the freeze pending judgment where urgency and a prima facie case can be shown, and should calendar the next renewal, because a delisting obtained against one act does not automatically erase the successor acts. Applicants should also budget realistically for time and cost. An annulment action in Luxembourg commonly runs between eighteen and twenty-four months to first judgment, with appeals to the Court of Justice adding a further year, and each six-monthly renewal can generate a parallel case that must be maintained or strategically withdrawn. Legal fees for the Luxembourg proceedings themselves require an authorisation under the freeze regulations, applied for before the work is invoiced, and counselstructure fee agreements in tranches aligned with those authorisations. The language of the case, chosen at filing and often English or French for these matters, determines translation costs for annexes, which in oligarch files routinely run to thousands of pages. None of this removes the strategic value of filing: a pending action strengthens the administrative reconsideration request, signals seriousness to banks handling licence applications, and preserves the only route to retroactive annulment with its consequences for damages claims against the Union.

Throughout, every factual assertion must be documented from primary sources, because the Court disregards press clippings offered as proof and, symmetrically, penalises the Council when its file contains only press clippings.

II. Frozen assets in France: what the freeze blocks and how funds can lawfully be released

Whatever happens in Luxembourg, the freeze bites in Paris, Antibes and every French bank counter from the day the EU regulation is published, because EU regulations apply directly and the French authorities add a national enforcement layer with criminal teeth. Understanding that layer is what separates a lawful release from a circumvention prosecution.

A. What a freeze changes for banks, notaires, debtors and creditors of a listed person

Under French law, the economy minister implements and polices asset freezes through Chapter II of Title VI of the Monetary and Financial Code. Article L562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code covers funds belonging to, possessed, held or controlled by persons designated under United Nations Chapter VII resolutions or under acts adopted pursuant to Article 29 of the Treaty on European Union, which is the legal basis that relays EU designations into the French domestic order. Once the freeze attaches, Article L562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides that the persons concerned must apply the freeze measures and the prohibitions on making available or using funds “sans délai”, that is, without delay, and inform the economy minister immediately, and it extends that duty to every individual on national territory, to the regulated professionals listed in Article L561-2, and to legal persons operating in France, including French companies for their activities abroad and foreign companies for their activities in France. The prohibition itself is drafted in deliberately wide terms: Article L562-5 of the Monetary and Financial Code states that “Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel”, and Article L562-6 of the Monetary and Financial Code adds that “Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de participer, sciemment et volontairement, à des activités ayant pour objet ou pour effet de contourner les mesures”. In practice, this means that a French bank must freeze the accounts, a notaire must refuse to complete a sale of a frozen villa, an employer must not pay salary to the frozen account for the person’s use, and family members or business partners who route money around the freeze expose themselves to the same prohibitions as the listed person.

The criminal exposure behind these prohibitions is severe, and it extends well beyond sanctions practitioners to intermediaries, advisers and relatives. Article L574-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code punishes with the penalties of Article L542-1 of the Customs Code anyone who evades the resulting obligations or obstructs their implementation, using the formula “de se soustraire aux obligations en résultant ou de faire obstacle à sa mise en oeuvre”. Parallel general offences then stack on top. Article 324-1 of the Criminal Code defines money laundering as “le fait de faciliter, par tout moyen, la justification mensongère de l’origine des biens ou des revenus de l’auteur d’un crime ou d’un délit”, adds that “Constitue également un blanchiment le fait d’apporter un concours à une opération de placement, de dissimulation ou de conversion du produit direct ou indirect d’un crime ou d’un délit”, and sets the penalty at “cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 375 000 euros d’amende”. The Court of Cassation gives that second paragraph a broad reach: in its judgment of 18 March 2020, No. 18-86.491, published in the Bulletin, the Criminal Chamber held that “Il s’en déduit que le transfert de fonds, sans qu’ait été respectée l’obligation déclarative résultant des articles 464 du code des douanes et L. 152-1 du code monétaire et financier, doit être considéré comme une opération de dissimulation au sens de l’article 324-1 du code pénal”, as recorded at Court of Cassation, Criminal Chamber, 18 March 2020, No. 18-86.491, while adding the symmetrical safeguard that “la caractérisation du délit de blanchiment, si elle n’implique pas que les auteurs de l’infraction principale soient connus, ni les circonstances de la commission de celle-ci entièrement déterminées, nécessite que soit établie l’origine frauduleuse des biens blanchis”. A more recent ruling extends the same logic to family assistance schemes, as shown at Court of Cassation, Criminal Chamber, 25 June 2025, No. 24-85.882. Article 321-1 of the Criminal Code separately punishes receiving, defined as concealing, holding or transmitting a thing while knowing it comes from a crime or delict, and Article 441-1 of the Criminal Code defines forgery as “toute altération frauduleuse de la vérité, de nature à causer un préjudice et accomplie par quelque moyen que ce soit, dans un écrit ou tout autre support d’expression de la pensée qui a pour objet ou qui peut avoir pour effet d’établir la preuve d’un droit ou d’un fait ayant des conséquences juridiques”, punishable by “trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 45 000 euros d’amende”. For offshore structures of the kind described in the recent press revelations, including backdated contracts and reconstructed accounts, these three provisions are the ones prosecutors reach for first, and the audit-trail questions they raise for Cypriot and other service providers are exactly those examined in our analysis of audit-firm liability after the Cyprus Confidential disclosures. Creditors face a mirror-image trap: in its landmark Bank Sepah ruling of 10 July 2020, Nos. 18-18.542 and 18-21.814, the Court of Cassation sitting in plenary assembly asked the Court of Justice of the European Union whether EU freeze regulations preclude enforcement, without prior authorisation from the competent national authority, of “une mesure dépourvue d’effet attributif, telle une sûreté judiciaire ou une saisie conservatoire”, a question recorded at Court of Cassation, Plenary Assembly, 10 July 2020, Nos. 18-18.542 and 18-21.814, which means that even a creditor with a final judgment cannot simply seize frozen Paris assets without going through the authorisation circuit first.

B. How frozen funds can be lawfully released or used from France

A freeze is not a confiscation, and EU law provides several lawful exits that practitioners in France use every week. The first exit is the authorisation regime built into the EU regulations themselves: Regulation 269/2014 allows the competent national authority, in France the Directorate General of the Treasury, to release funds for basic needs, legal fees, maintenance of frozen property, or the satisfaction of pre-listing judicial decisions, provided the authorisation is notified to the other member states and the Commission and no objection follows. Applications must document the exact amount, the payee, the purpose and the absence of any indirect benefit to the listed person beyond the authorised purpose, and they must be renewed as circumstances change. The second exit is delisting, whether through the Council’s periodic review, where observations filed before each renewal can persuade the Council not to re-list, or through a General Court annulment, which the Council sometimes implements by re-listing on a supplemented statement of reasons, as the Avetisyan sequence demonstrates, so that victory in court must be followed by monitoring of the next Official Journal. The third exit concerns third parties: banks that froze too broadly, employers holding wages, tenants paying rent on frozen property, and buyers stuck in a suspended conveyance can apply for specific licences or bring proceedings before the French courts to establish that particular assets are not owned, held or controlled by the listed person, a factual demonstration that requires corporate registries, bank statements and trust deeds rather than bare assertions.

For anyone dealing with a frozen position in France, the practical checklist runs in a fixed order. First, identify the exact legal basis of the freeze, meaning the EU regulation number, the designation entry and its statement of reasons, plus any French ministerial order, because different bases trigger different authorisation routes. Second, map every affected asset and every person touching it, since the prohibitions on making available and on circumvention catch indirect transfers through relatives, companies and advisers. Third, stop all non-authorised movements immediately and file the required notification to the minister, because continued use of frozen funds converts a sanctions file into a criminal file under the money-laundering and receiving provisions. Fourth, prepare the authorisation or licence application with complete supporting documents, including invoices for legal fees, property tax demands for frozen villas, and loan statements, quantifying each request to the euro. Fifth, calendar the Council’s renewal dates and the two-month annulment deadline for each new act, so that the administrative track and the judicial track advance together. French over-compliance deserves a paragraph of its own, because it is the most frequent source of unjustified harm to third parties. Banks, insurers and notaires, fearing the criminal penalties described above, routinely freeze more broadly than the regulation requires: joint accounts of non-listed spouses, operating accounts of companies merely sharing an address, or sale proceeds where the listed person’s interest is disputed. A third party in that position should not accept a verbal refusal. The remedy is a written request identifying the precise designation, followed by documentary proof of independent ownership or control, meaning share registers, loan agreements, tax filings and bank histories showing the origin of the funds, and then, if the institution persists, an application to the competent authority for a comfort confirmation or a specific licence. Courts in France have repeatedly reminded institutions that a freeze targets designated persons and the assets they own, hold or control, not entire family or commercial ecosystems by association. Documented, persistent and precisely scoped requests therefore unlock more files than threats, and they create the paper trail on which later liability claims against an over-freezing institution can be built if the blockage caused compensable loss.

Parties that follow this sequence preserve both their liberty and their assets; parties that improvise payment circuits, backdate documents or interpose nominees discover that the freeze was only the first chapter.

Conclusion

EU sanctions litigation rewards precision and punishes improvisation. Listings fall when the Council’s reasoning is thin, stale or disconnected from the person’s present economic role, and they stand when the criterion of prominent business activity financing state revenue is documented, as the contrasting 2026 rulings show. In France, the freeze then operates through an uncompromising national machinery of immediate compliance, sweeping prohibitions on making funds available, and criminal penalties for evasion, obstruction, laundering, receiving and forgery, while creditors learn that even conservatory measures over frozen assets require prior authorisation. The lawful way out runs through Treasury authorisations, targeted licences, third-party ownership proceedings and timely annulment actions, each documented to the euro and filed before its deadline. That discipline, applied from the first day of the designation, is what turns a frozen position from a trap into a file that can actually be won.

📄 Official circular