KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Should an American Buying a House in France Use an SCI? Taxes, Heirs, and the IRS

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Should an American Buying a House in France Use an SCI? Taxes, Heirs, and the IRS

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

If you are an American buying a house in France, someone will tell you to buy it through an SCI before the ink on the preliminary contract is dry. The seller’s agent mentions it. The mortgage broker mentions it. Sometimes even the notaire, the French public officer who authenticates every real estate sale, mentions it. An SCI, short for société civile immobilière, is a French non-trading property company, a private company whose only business is owning and managing real estate. For a few hundred euros in set-up costs, the story goes, you get smoother inheritance, shared ownership without co-ownership fights, and clever tax options.

Some of that story is true. Some of it is dangerously incomplete for an American. An SCI does not move your French house out of France for tax purposes. It does not defeat the forced inheritance rights of your children. It does not hide the house from the French wealth tax. And on the American side of the Atlantic, the Internal Revenue Service may treat your little French family company as a foreign corporation, with yearly reporting forms and penalties that dwarf anything you saved in France.

This guide explains, in plain English, what a French SCI really is, what it changes for a US buyer at purchase, during ownership, at death, and on the US tax return, and when you are better off buying the house in your own name. Every decisive French rule below is quoted from the statute or the court decision that states it, with a link to the official text, because a cross-border ownership structure is exactly the kind of decision you should never make on blog summaries alone.

I. What a French SCI really is and why Americans are told to use one

A. How do I buy a French house through an SCI and what does it cost me upfront

An SCI is a company with civil, meaning non-commercial, character. Article 1845 of the French Civil Code states the test in one sentence:

“Ont le caractère civil toutes les sociétés auxquelles la loi n’attribue pas un autre caractère à raison de leur forme, de leur nature, ou de leur objet.” (Légifrance official text)

In other words, a company formed to buy, hold, and rent out a house, without a commercial trade, is a civil company, and the special chapter of the Civil Code on civil companies governs it. You can read Article 1845 of the Civil Code on Légifrance in its current version. In practice, two spouses, two siblings, or a parent and children sign written articles of association, called statuts, contribute cash, and the company, once registered, buys the house. Instead of owning the walls directly, each family member owns shares, called parts sociales, in the company that owns the walls.

For an American buyer, the purchase timetable looks almost identical to a direct purchase, and you should read it together with our step-by-step account of how an American buys a French house, from the preliminary contract to the notaire closing. The preliminary contract, the compromis de vente, can be signed in the name of the SCI once it exists, or in your own name with a substitution clause letting the future company take your place at closing. The ten-day cooling-off period, the conditional clauses for loan approval, and the three-month window to closing work the same way. What changes is the buyer on the final deed, the acte authentique: the SCI, represented by its manager, the gérant. The notaire still collects the transfer taxes, still publishes the deed at the land registry, and still charges fees on the same scale. Forming the company adds its own layer of cost: drafting the statuts, registering the company, publishing a formation notice, and paying the notaire for any extra structuring. Expect roughly one to three thousand euros all-in for a simple family SCI, on top of the standard purchase costs.

Banks treat an SCI borrower differently, and American buyers feel that difference first. Our guide to French mortgages for Americans, from the loan offer to the notaire closing explains the baseline; with an SCI, most French banks ask every shareholder to stand as joint personal guarantor, called a caution, and they take security over the property itself. Some lenders refuse to lend to an SCI whose shareholders live outside France, or they price the loan higher. Get the bank’s answer in writing before you pay to form the company, because an SCI that cannot borrow is an expensive detour.

The single most misunderstood feature of the SCI is liability. Shareholders are not shielded the way shareholders of an American LLC are. Article 1857 of the Civil Code provides:

“A l’égard des tiers, les associés répondent indéfiniment des dettes sociales à proportion de leur part dans le capital social à la date de l’exigibilité ou au jour de la cessation des paiements.” (Légifrance official text)

See Article 1857 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. Toward outside creditors, each shareholder answers without limit for the company’s debts, in proportion to his or her share. If the SCI defaults on a 400,000 euro loan and you hold half the shares, the bank can pursue you personally for 200,000 euros. Creditors must chase the company first, but the backstop is your personal assets. Anyone who sells you an SCI as an asset-protection device against French creditors is selling you the opposite of the law.

The second structural feature is the lock-in on the shares. Article 1861 of the Civil Code states the default rule:

“Les parts sociales ne peuvent être cédées qu’avec l’agrément de tous les associés.” (Légifrance official text)

Full text at Article 1861 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. By default, you cannot sell or give your SCI shares to an outsider without the approval, the agrément, of all the other shareholders. The statuts can soften this, for example by requiring only a majority, or by waiving approval for transfers between shareholders or to a spouse, but the starting point is unanimity. This is a feature when you want to keep the family house inside the family, and it is a trap when you fall out with your co-owners and discover that nobody has to let your buyer in.

B. Can an SCI keep me out of French co-ownership fights and forced sale

The strongest honest argument for an SCI is about people, not taxes. When several Americans inherit or buy a French house directly in their own names, they fall into indivision, the French regime of undivided co-ownership. Any co-owner can force a sale at auction at any time, and daily decisions require difficult majorities. Our guide to how an American co-heir exits indivision, forces the sale, or claims occupation rent shows how expensive that freedom becomes when siblings disagree across an ocean. An SCI replaces that regime with company rules you write yourselves: who manages the house, who decides on repairs, who can use it in August, how a departing member cashes out, and what happens when someone dies.

Death is where the SCI earns its reputation. Under Article 1870 of the Civil Code:

“La société n’est pas dissoute par le décès d’un associé, mais continue avec ses héritiers ou légataires, sauf à prévoir dans les statuts qu’ils doivent être agréés par les associés.” (Légifrance official text)

See Article 1870 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. The company survives the death of a shareholder and continues with his or her heirs, unless the statuts require those heirs to be approved. Compare that with a direct holding, where the death freezes the property in a cross-border estate settlement, the règlement de succession, run by the notaire while American heirs produce apostilled documents. With an SCI, the house never changes hands. Only the shares move, and the surviving manager keeps paying the bills, collecting the rent, and maintaining the insurance without interruption.

But the company’s survival does not mean a free exit for whoever wants out, and France’s highest civil court enforces that discipline strictly. In a 2023 decision about the SCI du Cherche Midi, the Third Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, appeal number 22-17.246, dealt with a shareholder who had started an agreed withdrawal procedure, a retrait with a buyback of his shares, and then, impatient, sold those same shares to an outside buyer. The Court approved the annulment of that side sale, holding:

“la procédure de cession desdites parts à un tiers, initiée par M. [C] [T] en méconnaissance de la procédure de retrait en cours acceptée par la SCI, devait être annulée.” (Court of Cassation decision)

Read Court of Cassation, Third Civil Chamber, 25 May 2023, appeal 22-17.246 on Légifrance. Once you commit to the company’s exit procedure, you must see it through. You cannot freelance a sale to an outsider behind the company’s back. For an American family, the lesson runs both ways. Draft the exit mechanics, valuation method, payment timetable, and approval rules into the statuts on day one, while everyone still likes each other, because the courts will hold you to the procedure you chose.

Creditors, too, can reach the shares, and a second recent decision shows the price of sloppy procedure. When pledged shares of a civil company are forcibly auctioned, the First Civil Chamber held on 19 March 2025, appeal number 22-20.861, concerning the SCI Renaissance 12:

“il incombe au créancier poursuivant la vente forcée de parts sociales de société civile nanties à son profit, pour pouvoir se prévaloir de l’agrément du cessionnaire, de rapporter la preuve que la réalisation forcée des parts sociales, soit la date de l’adjudication, a été notifiée un mois avant la vente tant à la société qu’aux associés.” (Court of Cassation decision)

Read Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, 19 March 2025, appeal 22-20.861 on Légifrance. A creditor who seizes and auctions pledged SCI shares must prove the forced sale was notified one month before the auction both to the company and to the shareholders, failing which the transfer is void for lack of approval. Shares in an SCI are therefore seizable assets, not a vault. They simply change hands through a procedure the family can partly control, provided the paperwork is right.

Weigh this against the alternatives before you incorporate. An unmarried American couple buying together sometimes does better with a tontine clause, which passes the whole house to the survivor, as explained in our guide to how an unmarried American couple protects the survivor with a tontine. A married couple may do better with a gift between spouses, the donation au dernier vivant, covered in our guide to how the surviving spouse keeps the French home. The SCI is the right tool when three or more people, across two generations or two households, need durable governance of one roof. For a couple buying alone, it is often machinery without a job.

II. What an SCI changes for French taxes, your heirs, and the IRS

A. Does an SCI lower my French income, wealth, gift, and inheritance tax

Start with the disappointment, because it saves the most money. For income tax, a family SCI that only rents out an unfurnished house is normally tax-transparent: the company itself pays no income tax, and each shareholder is taxed personally on his or her slice of the rental profit. Article 8 of the French Tax Code states the mechanism:

“les associés des sociétés en nom collectif et les commandités des sociétés en commandite simple sont, lorsque ces sociétés n’ont pas opté pour le régime fiscal des sociétés de capitaux, personnellement soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu pour la part de bénéfices sociaux correspondant à leurs droits dans la société.” (Légifrance official text)

See Article 8 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance, which extends the same treatment, under the same conditions, to members of civil companies. An American shareholder living in France declares that slice on the French return; an American shareholder living in the United States is taxed in France on French-source rental income just as if he or she owned the walls directly. Transparency means no French corporate shield and no American-style pass-through election to file. It is automatic, and the Franco-American income tax treaty then decides which country taxes what, with a foreign tax credit softening double taxation.

The SCI can elect to pay French corporate income tax instead, under the corporate-tax field defined by Article 206 of the Tax Code, which lists the companies liable to that tax. See Article 206 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance. Electing corporate tax lets the company deduct depreciation and carry a different timing of profit, which sometimes suits a heavily indebted rental. But the election is generally irrevocable, it converts future capital gains on the house into corporate gains taxed at company level plus a second layer of tax when profits come out, and for an American it deepens the mismatch with the US return, where the IRS may already see a corporation. Never elect corporate tax on a French family SCI without a written Franco-American tax simulation covering both countries over the full holding period, including the sale year.

For the French real estate wealth tax, the IFI, the SCI changes nothing about the taxable base. Shares in a company holding French residential property count as taxable real estate assets in the shareholder’s hands, proportionally. Our guide to IFI liability, calculation, and challenges for Americans walks through the thresholds and the valuation fight; read it as if the SCI were glass, because for IFI purposes it is. Debt taken on to buy the house can still be deducted under the same capped conditions, whether it sits on the shareholder or on the company, but the reporting sits on the individual return, and the penalties for omission are personal.

For gifts and inheritances, the decisive point is that French transfer tax follows the real estate, not the wrapper. Article 750 ter of the Tax Code draws a deliberately wide net:

“Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit : 1° Les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France, […] lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B” (Légifrance official text)

Full text at Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code on Légifrance, which also taxes property located in France even when the deceased or donor lives abroad. A French house held through an SCI is still a French house. Giving SCI shares to your children while alive, or leaving them at death, triggers the same French gift and inheritance tax as giving the house itself, computed on the value of the underlying property. The allowances are personal and familiar: Article 779 of the Tax Code provides that:

“Pour la perception des droits de mutation à titre gratuit, il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.” (Légifrance official text)

See Article 779 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance. Each parent can currently give each child 100,000 euros free of French gift tax, renewable on a fifteen-year cycle, and the surviving tariff is the progressive family scale set by Article 777. See Article 777 of the General Tax Code on Légifrance, which opens with the rule that:

“Les droits de mutation à titre gratuit sont fixés aux taux indiqués dans les tableaux ci-après, pour la part nette revenant à chaque ayant droit” (Légifrance official text)

followed by the progressive brackets for the direct line. Our guide to giving a French house to your children while alive, with gift tax, split ownership, and IRS rules works through the numbers; everything it says about allowances, fifteen-year reminders, and keeping the use of the house while giving away the bare ownership applies identically to gifts of SCI shares, which is precisely why families use them.

Where the SCI genuinely helps at inheritance is mechanics, not rates. Shares divide cleanly. A parent can give one child shares this year and another child shares next year, can split ownership between use and bare title across generations, and can use a donation-partage, the French deed by which a parent divides property among the presumptive heirs in one act. Article 1075 of the Civil Code authorizes it in plain terms:

“Toute personne peut faire, entre ses héritiers présomptifs, la distribution et le partage de ses biens et de ses droits.” (Légifrance official text)

See Article 1075 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. A donation-partage of SCI shares, signed before a notaire, freezes values at the date of the gift for the later estate accounting, which is how a family locks in who gets what while the parents are alive to enforce the bargain. And none of this lets a parent disinherit a child. The forced share, the réserve héréditaire, follows the value wherever it sits. Article 913 of the Civil Code sets the ceiling:

“Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” (Légifrance official text)

See Article 913 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. Gifts of SCI shares that invade a child’s forced share can be clawed back at death through the reduction action, exactly as our guide to how an American child claws back the forced share after a sibling got the French house describes for direct gifts.

One cross-border refinement matters for Americans who also hold assets in the United States. The European Succession Regulation lets a person choose the law of his or her nationality to govern the whole estate, which is how an American can elect US law for the French house and blunt some forced-share mechanics for directly held property, as our estate guides explain. Shares in an SCI sit inside that same estate, and the choice-of-law clause in your will should name them expressly. But the choice of succession law never moves the house out of the French gift and inheritance tax net described above. Succession law decides who gets what. Tax law decides what Paris takes. Keep those two questions on separate pages of your file, because advisers who merge them are the source of half the expensive SCI mistakes Americans bring to our Paris office.

B. How does the IRS treat my French SCI and what must I file in America

Everything above is the French half of the file. The American half is where small SCIs become expensive, and it is the half most French formation agents never mention. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income and taxes certain foreign entities as if they were American corporations, partnerships, or disregarded branches, regardless of what French law calls them. A French SCI has no exact American equivalent, so classification depends on its features and elections, and different practitioners reach different answers on identical facts. Treat the following as the checklist to put to your US CPA before you sign the statuts, not as a filing conclusion.

First, information reporting. If the IRS views your SCI as a foreign corporation, each American shareholder who owns enough of it generally files Form 5471, the information return for certain foreign corporations, every year, with penalties that start at 10,000 dollars per missed form. Read the official IRS presentation of Form 5471 and ask your CPA whether your shareholding crosses the filing threshold. If instead the SCI is viewed as a foreign entity disregarded from its owner, the American owner generally files Form 8858 with the yearly return. Read the official IRS presentation of Form 8858 the same way. A married couple holding all the shares jointly, a parent holding shares for minor children, and three siblings holding equal thirds can each land in a different reporting box. Map every shareholder, every percentage, and every change during the year before the CPA classifies anything.

Second, the income mismatch. France taxes each shareholder yearly on the SCI’s rental slice under transparency. The United States may tax the same dollars under different rules, in a different year, or in the hands of a different person, especially if the SCI elected French corporate tax or if the IRS treats it as a corporation while France treats it as transparent. The US-France tax treaty, whose official documents the IRS publishes on its France treaty documents page, allocates taxing rights on real estate income and gains to France first and offers relief mechanisms, but treaty relief smooths double taxation only when both countries see the same income in the same hands at the same time. Hybrid-entity mismatches are exactly where treaty relief frays. Ask for a year-by-year simulation of a rental year and of a sale year, in both currencies, before you choose transparency or corporate tax in France.

Third, the sale. When the SCI sells the French house, France taxes the capital gain under French rules for the shareholders or the company, depending on the tax posture, and the notaire withholds at closing for nonresident sellers, as our guide to selling mechanics and the capital-gains process describe. The United States then taxes the American shareholder on the gain under US rules, with a foreign tax credit for the French tax, but the credit has baskets, limits, and timing conditions, and currency movements between purchase and sale create a separate US gain or loss that France never sees. When the shareholders sell their SCI shares instead of having the company sell the house, buyers discount the price for the latent French tax inside the company, lenders hesitate, and the French registration duty on share sales still bites. Price both exit routes, share sale and asset sale, with numbers, before you decide the SCI was worth it.

Fourth, gifts and death on the US side. Giving SCI shares to your children is a gift for US gift tax purposes, reported on Form 709 when thresholds are met, and it carries over your tax basis in a way that can surprise families who assumed a fresh start. At death, the US estate tax return may need the SCI valued with discounts or premiums that French law ignores, while France taxes the underlying house at its market value. Coordinate the American estate attorney and the French notaire on a single balance sheet, in both languages, before anyone signs a donation-partage or a will.

Fifth, the bank account problem you already know. An SCI needs its own French bank account, and French banks apply the same identity, tax-residence, and American-status checks to the company and to each shareholder. Our guide to a French bank refusing an American over FATCA and the right-to-an-account procedure applies word for word when the refuser’s letter names your SCI instead of you. Open the account early, keep the paper trail of every refusal letter, and remember that the legal right to an account runs through the Banque de France designation procedure, not through charm.

Pull this together into a decision rule. A family SCI is usually worth its cost for Americans when three conditions hold together: several people will co-own one French house for a long time and need written governance; someone has mapped the French tax posture, transparency versus corporate tax, over the full holding period including the sale; and a US CPA has classified the entity, assigned the yearly forms to named humans, and priced both exit routes. If any of the three is missing, buy in your own name, regulate the couple’s situation with the lighter tools, the tontine or the gift between spouses, and revisit the SCI question when the family, not the agent’s brochure, gives you a reason. The company is a good servant of a clear family plan and a cruel master of a vague one.

Conclusion

An SCI does not make a French house American, and it does not make French tax disappear. It changes the legal shape of ownership from co-owned walls to company shares, and that change buys governance, continuity at death, and divisible gifts, at the price of unlimited shareholder liability for company debts, locked-in shares that need approval to leave the family, yearly French transparency with its own returns, and a full American reporting life of its own. The families who benefit are the ones who needed the governance anyway: siblings keeping a parents’ house together, parents organizing a shared holiday home for two households, partners protecting children from different marriages. The buyers who regret it are the ones who incorporated for a tax miracle nobody could write down, elected corporate tax without a two-country simulation, or discovered Form 5471 three years late. Bring your family plan, your French notaire simulation, and your CPA’s classification memo to the same table before the compromis, and the SCI becomes what it should be: a quiet piece of paperwork that lets everyone enjoy the house.

📄 Official circular