KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
What Should an American Child Do When a French Parent Dies Without a Will? Heir Rights, Choice of Law, and Deadlines

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

What Should an American Child Do When a French Parent Dies Without a Will? Heir Rights, Choice of Law, and Deadlines

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

When a French parent dies without a will, an American child may discover that the estate is governed by a French succession process even though the child lives in the United States, holds an American passport, and has never dealt with a French notary. The first questions are practical: whether the child is an heir, which law controls the estate, what documents prove the family relationship, and how long the child has to accept or refuse the inheritance. A bank account, apartment, life-insurance policy, business interest, or tax bill can all make the situation urgent. A family member’s statement that “there was no will” is not enough to settle the matter. The French notary must identify the heirs, locate any registered testament, determine the governing law, secure the assets, and prepare the documents that allow the estate to be transferred. This guide explains the French terms in plain English and sets out a United States-to-France action plan. It focuses on a child inheriting from a French parent under intestate succession, meaning succession without a valid will. It does not replace an individualized review of residence, nationality, previous gifts, marital status, debts, or the location of each asset.

I. What Rights Does an American Child Have When a French Parent Dies Without a Will?

A. Who inherits first under French intestate succession?

French law treats the opening of a succession as a legal event tied to death and the deceased person’s last domicile. Article 720 of the French Civil Code states: Les successions s’ouvrent par la mort, au dernier domicile du défunt. In English, the estate opens at death, at the deceased person’s last domicile. “Succession” is the French legal word for the transfer of a deceased person’s assets, rights, and liabilities. “Domicile” is not simply a mailing address; the notary may need to examine where the parent actually lived and had the center of personal life at the time of death.

Without a valid testamentary disposition, the legal order of heirs applies. Article 721 of the Civil Code provides: Les successions sont dévolues selon la loi lorsque le défunt n’a pas disposé de ses biens par des libéralités. A libéralité is a voluntary transfer, such as a gift or a testamentary gift. The absence of a document in the parent’s desk does not prove that no will exists. The French notary generally checks the central register of dispositions of last wills and testaments, known as the FCDDV, and asks about notarial wills, handwritten wills, gifts, prior matrimonial arrangements, and other instruments.

The ordinary order is summarized by the current Service-Public guidance on inheritance without a will: children and their descendants are in the first order, subject to the surviving spouse’s rights. The statutory text is Article 734 of the Civil Code, which begins: En l’absence de conjoint successible, les parents sont appelés à succéder ainsi qu’il suit : It then places children and their descendants first, followed by the parents and siblings, then other ascendants and other collateral relatives. Each order excludes the following orders. “Conjoint successible” means a surviving spouse who is legally entitled to inherit; it does not mean every former spouse or every unmarried partner.

For an American child, the first practical consequence is that the child is not pushed behind the deceased parent’s siblings, cousins, or friends merely because the child lives abroad. Article 735 of the Civil Code states: Les enfants ou leurs descendants succèdent à leurs père et mère ou autres ascendants, sans distinction de sexe, ni de primogéniture, même s’ils sont issus d’unions différentes. The rule does not distinguish sons from daughters, older from younger children, or children born from different relationships. A child must still prove the parent-child link, and the analysis can change if the deceased left a spouse, a valid will, a surviving parent, a prior gift, or a legally effective adoption or renunciation.

The method by which the parent-child relationship was established also matters less than many families assume. Article 733 of the Civil Code says that the law does not distinguish according to the modes by which filiation was established and gives adopted filiation the effects provided by the Civil Code. “Filiation” means the legal relationship between a parent and child. A United States birth certificate can be valuable evidence, but it may not be enough by itself if names changed, the parent was adopted, the child was born through an assisted reproduction arrangement, a judgment established parentage, or the civil-status chain contains a gap.

The surviving spouse needs a separate analysis. Under Article 756 of the Civil Code, Le conjoint successible est appelé à la succession, soit seul, soit en concours avec les parents du défunt.Article 757 of the Civil Code gives the surviving spouse an election between usufruct of the whole existing estate and ownership of one quarter of the estate, subject to the facts stated in the statute. Usufruit is a right to use property or receive its income while another person holds the underlying ownership. Nue-propriété is that underlying ownership without the current use or income. The notary must determine which option applies and whether the spouse made a valid election.

That means an American child can be a legal heir without immediately receiving a separate apartment or a check. Several children may own the estate in indivision, the French form of co-ownership after death. The surviving spouse may have usufruct, and a family home may be protected by matrimonial-property rules or a lifetime right of occupation. A child’s share is therefore a legal right in the estate, not necessarily a right to take one particular asset without accounting for the spouse, siblings, creditors, and taxes.

Representation can change who takes a deceased child’s share. Article 751 of the Civil Code describes representation as: La représentation est une fiction juridique qui a pour effet d’appeler à la succession les représentants aux droits du représenté.

Finally, being an heir and being entitled to a reserved share are related but different questions. French réserve héréditaire, or forced heirship, protects certain descendants in some successions, but its application depends on the governing law and the structure of the estate. A child who believes a spouse or beneficiary has received too much should not assume that the French reserved-share rules automatically apply. The Supreme Court’s civil chamber held in First Civil Chamber, 27 September 2017, no. 16-17.198 that, in the circumstances before it, the applicable law was California law and that il n’y a pas lieu d’écarter cette loi au profit de la loi française. That decision does not eliminate French protection in every case; it shows why the governing-law analysis must come before a conclusion about a reserved share.

B. Which law governs the inheritance when the child lives in the United States?

American nationality does not by itself decide which law governs a French parent’s succession. The starting point in many cross-border European successions is Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on international successions. Its general connecting factor is the deceased person’s habitual residence at death. “Habitual residence” is a factual concept that looks at the stability and circumstances of the person’s life, not just the address printed on a passport. A parent who kept a French home but spent years living in the United States may require a careful factual record. A French citizen who retired permanently in France may present the opposite case.

Article 21 of the Regulation generally points to the law of the state where the deceased had habitual residence at death. Article 22 allows a person, in the circumstances described by the Regulation, to choose the law of the state whose nationality the person possesses. A valid choice usually appears in a will or another valid testamentary instrument; it cannot be invented after death by agreement among the children. The American child should therefore ask the notary whether the parent left a will, a valid choice-of-law clause, a prior declaration, or a document whose effect must be assessed under the Regulation.

The Regulation also separates the law governing the succession from the court or authority handling a particular step. Article 4 addresses international jurisdiction, while Articles 21 and 22 address the applicable law. Article 23 describes the scope of the law applicable to the succession, including the determination of beneficiaries, their shares, the powers of heirs, and the transfer of assets. A French notary may handle the estate’s practical formalities even when the governing law requires analysis of another country’s law. A United States probate proceeding does not automatically control a French apartment or French bank account, and a French notarial deed does not answer every question about U.S. assets.

The parent’s nationality, residence, and asset location must therefore be mapped separately. If the parent was habitually resident in France, French succession law may govern the whole succession under the Regulation unless a valid choice of law or another rule changes the result. If the parent was habitually resident in the United States, the applicable law may be different even when the estate contains French real estate. Immovable property still creates French formalities, registration, and tax issues. A child should not confuse “the notary is in France” with “every succession question is governed by French substantive law.”

The California decision illustrates the point for an American family. The court examined the law applicable to the succession and did not replace it with French reserved-share law merely because the estate had a French connection. The decision concerned its own facts, including the deceased’s links to California and the absence of a demonstrated situation of economic precarity. It should not be used as a shortcut for a new case. Its practical lesson is to obtain the complete residence history, the text of any will or trust, the location of the beneficiaries, and the nature of the assets before evaluating a child’s claim.

Choice of law is also not the same as tax residence. The France–United States estate and gift tax treaty allocates taxing rights and offers mechanisms to reduce double taxation; it does not decide whether an American child is an heir under civil law. The official French tax administration list of international conventions identifies the convention with the United States for estates and gifts, and the official consolidated treaty text must be read for the relevant date and asset pattern.

That distinction prevents a common error. A child may be the heir under the applicable civil law but owe no French tax after allowances and treaty relief, or may owe French tax even while disputing whether a person was properly included as an heir. Conversely, a treaty credit may be available to the estate or to a taxpayer without changing the underlying ownership share. Civil-law standing, succession administration, French inheritance tax, and U.S. reporting are four connected but separate workstreams.

Before accepting the family’s informal description of the estate, ask for five items: the parent’s death certificate; the last residence and nationality evidence; the result of the will-register search; every will, trust, gift, or matrimonial agreement located; and a preliminary list of assets and debts by country. If the parent had a U.S. trust, retirement account, or jointly held property, the beneficiary designation may require a separate analysis. A trust may change who receives an asset, but it does not automatically displace the law governing French succession or the legal rights of a child.

II. What Should an American Child Do After a Parent Dies in France?

A. How can the child prove heirship and protect French assets?

The first step is to contact the French notary handling the estate in writing and identify yourself as a possible child and heir. Do not wait for a sibling to “add” you to the file. Tell the notary where you live, provide a reliable email address, explain the parent-child relationship, and ask for the name of the estate file, the date of death, the will-register result, and the documents still needed. If another notary has been appointed, ask for the file to be transferred or for the notaries to coordinate. Keep copies of every message and attach documents in a numbered index.

French law recognizes proof of heirship by different means. Article 730 of the Civil Code states: La preuve de la qualité d’héritier s’établit par tous moyens.

The key instrument is the acte de notoriété, a French notarial deed that identifies the people entitled to inherit. The deed is not the same as a will. It records the notary’s findings about the family and legal status of heirs so banks, land registries, insurers, and other institutions can process the transfer. Article 730-1 of the Civil Code provides: La preuve de la qualité d’héritier peut résulter d’un acte de notoriété dressé par un notaire, à la demande d’un ou plusieurs ayants droit.ayant droit is a person with a legal right in the relevant estate or claim.

The American child should request the notary’s document checklist before ordering expensive copies. The usual evidence file may need the parent’s full death certificate; the child’s long-form birth certificate; documents proving the parent’s identity; marriage, divorce, and name-change records; the civil-status records of siblings; and evidence concerning any deceased sibling whose descendants may inherit by representation. If the parent was born or married in France, French records may be obtainable through the relevant civil-status authority. If the child was born in a U.S. state, the issuing state’s rules determine how to obtain a certified copy and an apostille.

An apostille is a certificate under the Hague Apostille Convention that authenticates the origin of a public document for use in another participating country. It does not translate the document, prove that its contents are true, or decide whether the document establishes filiation under French law. A French notary may also require a sworn French translation. A translation prepared by a family member, an ordinary bilingual service, or an online machine is unlikely to answer that requirement. Ask the notary whether the translator must be a French court-certified translator and whether the notary wants the apostille translated as well.

The chain must be complete. Suppose the child’s birth certificate names “Robert Martin,” the parent later used “Robert J. Martin,” and a marriage record shows “Robert Martin-Smith.” The child should provide the records that connect those names. If the parent’s name was corrected, obtain the correction order. If the parent was adopted or recognized the child after birth, include the judgment or recognition record. If a sibling disputes the relationship, do not send only an informal family tree; ask the notary to state the precise legal deficiency and the evidence that would cure it.

The notary’s deed has evidentiary force, but it is not an irreversible acceptance of the inheritance. Article 730-2 of the Civil Code states: L’affirmation contenue dans l’acte de notoriété n’emporte pas, par elle-même, acceptation de la succession.

A foreign notarial or probate document may be relevant but should not be assumed to replace the French deed. In Second Civil Chamber, 4 June 2020, no. 19-11.419, the published record reproduces reasoning about a foreign acte de notoriété and the conditions under which it may have effects in France, while the disposition of the appeal was a rejection without a specially reasoned merits opinion. The quoted reasoning refers to the possibility that un acte de notoriété dressé à l’étranger, s’il présente certaines conditions d’équivalence, se voit reconnaître des effets en France. Treat this as a document-recognition issue, not as proof that every U.S. probate document automatically transfers French property.

While the heirship file is being assembled, request protective information. Ask the notary for a list of French bank accounts, real estate, company shares, insurance contracts, vehicles, debts, tax notices, and ongoing litigation. Ask whether any property is occupied, rented, insured, or at risk of deterioration. If a French property is vacant, verify insurance and utilities. If rent is being collected by a sibling, request an accounting rather than making an accusation. In an estate held in indivision, a co-heir may not simply treat the asset as personal property.

Do not sign a deed of division, a waiver, a release, a sale mandate, or a power of attorney prepared by a family member without understanding its effect. A power of attorney can be limited to obtaining documents or can authorize a broad sale and distribution. It should identify the asset, the notary, the permitted act, the duration, and whether the agent can receive funds. A U.S. notarization may need an apostille and translation before a French notary will accept it. Send the draft to the French notary before signing, because the notary’s required form and witnessing process matter.

If the notary refuses to recognize the child or proceeds without the child’s documents, ask for the refusal and reasons in writing. Depending on the dispute, the child may need an attorney in France to send a formal notice, seek an evidentiary measure, request an estate accounting, protect a co-ownership right, or bring the appropriate claim before the competent court. The objective is not to turn every family disagreement into litigation. It is to create a record before the estate is distributed, a property is sold, or a bank releases money to the wrong person.

The child can also use the firm’s broader guide to French inheritance law for American families as a starting point for the interaction between reserved shares, treaty relief, and the estate. That broader overview is not a substitute for the present heirship file. The present file should answer a narrower question first: who is legally entitled to act, and what evidence proves that status?

B. Which acceptance, tax, and treaty deadlines must the child meet?

An heir has to decide what to do with the inheritance, not merely prove that the inheritance exists. French law recognizes different options, including acceptance without limitation of liability, acceptance under benefit of inventory, and renunciation. The names used in English translations can hide important differences. An unconditional acceptance can expose the heir to estate liabilities beyond the value of the inherited assets. Acceptance under the benefit of inventory limits the heir’s exposure in the manner provided by French law, but it requires the correct declaration and inventory process. Renunciation means giving up the inheritance and can affect descendants or representation.

Time does not start simply because a sibling sends a text message. Article 771 of the Civil Code provides: L’héritier ne peut être contraint à opter avant l’expiration d’un délai de quatre mois. The four-month protection runs from the opening of the succession. After that period, a creditor, co-heir, or the state may in some circumstances require the heir to choose. Article 772 then provides a two-month period after a valid demand, subject to the statutory mechanism, before the heir may be treated as having accepted without limitation. The child should record the death date, the date of every formal notice, and the date on which documents were received.

The four-month rule is not a reason to ignore the notary. It is time to investigate assets and liabilities before choosing. Request mortgage statements, unpaid tax, property charges, business debts, guarantees, lawsuits, and personal loans. Check whether the parent was a guarantor for a company or another family member. Review French bank statements and property records. Ask whether taxes or social contributions remain due. An estate that looks like a valuable apartment may also contain deferred repairs, a secured loan, a tax reassessment, or an obligation to restore a leased property.

Do not confuse a refusal to sign a distribution deed with a formal renunciation. A person can decline to sign a proposed settlement while preserving heirship, or can sign a document that has the effect of accepting or waiving rights. The notary or lawyer should identify the legal act by its French name and explain whether it changes the child’s option. Keep the original and a certified copy. If the child is in the United States, obtain advice before signing through a consulate, a U.S. notary, a French notary by videoconference where permitted, or a power of attorney.

French inheritance tax has a separate deadline. Article 641 of the French General Tax Code provides: De six mois à compter du décès, lorsque celui dont l’héritage est dévolu est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.

The location of the death is not the only tax question. The French tax analysis may examine the deceased’s domicile, the heir’s domicile, the location and nature of assets, prior gifts, life insurance, usufruct and bare ownership, and treaty provisions. A nonresident American child can still face French reporting or payment obligations for French-situs assets. The child should ask who is preparing the declaration, whether a French tax identification number is needed, who will pay the tax, and whether the estate has enough liquid funds to pay without forcing a premature property sale.

The France–United States estate and gift tax treaty can reduce double taxation, but it does not provide a universal exemption. Article 12 of the official treaty addresses the method for avoiding double taxation. The French text states, in relevant part, La double imposition est évitée de la manière suivante, then sets out different mechanisms according to the deceased or donor’s domicile and the taxes paid. The IRS overview of estate and gift tax treaties should be read together with the official French treaty text, not used instead of it.

Treaty relief requires evidence. Keep the U.S. estate-tax filing, any notice of tax paid, the French inheritance-tax calculation, asset valuations, ownership documents, and the dates of payment. A credit may be limited by the treaty, the type of asset, the taxpayer who paid the tax, and the relationship between the U.S. and French assessments. The child should not reduce a French payment merely because a U.S. accountant expects a credit later. First establish the French liability and payment route; then document the U.S. claim under the applicable filing rules.

There may also be U.S. information-reporting or estate-tax questions. The answer can depend on U.S. citizenship, domicile, the size and composition of the estate, the child’s role, foreign accounts, trusts, and the nature of the inherited asset. A French inheritance is not automatically taxable income to an American recipient under every U.S. rule, but receiving or controlling foreign property can create reporting obligations. The French notary’s statement, treaty calculation, and asset valuation should be sent to a U.S. tax professional who can identify the correct form and deadline. Do not file an invented treaty position merely to meet a calendar date.

A useful deadline calendar has at least six entries: the date of death; the four-month date before a forced option demand can generally be made; any date on which a valid formal demand is served; the two-month response period after that demand; the French inheritance-tax declaration date; and any U.S. estate or information-reporting date. Add deadlines for insurance claims, property insurance, mortgage notices, company filings, and court proceedings. Put the responsible person beside each date. “The notary is handling it” is not a calendar entry, particularly when documents must travel from a U.S. state authority to France.

If the child receives a proposed deed or tax statement late, reply immediately in writing: state that the document is under review, identify missing records, reserve the child’s rights, and ask whether any formal option or tax deadline is running. A prompt reservation is not a substitute for the required legal act, but it avoids silence being misread as consent. If a deadline has already passed, obtain an assessment of the consequences and the available remedy. Do not backdate a declaration, alter a certificate, or ask a family member to omit the American heir from the file.

Once heirship, governing law, debts, and tax are mapped, the child can choose a controlled next step: accept, accept under the protective procedure available under French law, renounce, negotiate a distribution, sell an inherited property, or litigate a disputed share. The decision should be based on a verified asset and liability schedule. If the estate includes a French home and U.S. assets, one coordinated schedule should show the civil-law owner, tax owner, beneficiary, value, debt, and document proving each entry. That schedule makes it easier to compare the French notary’s proposal with U.S. probate and tax advice.

Conclusion

An American child does not lose inheritance rights merely by living in the United States. When a French parent dies without a will, the child should first establish the family relationship, confirm the will-register result, identify the surviving spouse and other descendants, and determine the law governing the succession. French Civil Code provisions place children in the first order in the ordinary intestate case, but residence, nationality, a valid choice-of-law clause, gifts, trusts, matrimonial property, representation, and the spouse’s rights can alter the result.

The safest sequence is evidence first, decision second: contact the notary, build the apostilled and translated civil-status chain, request the full asset and debt list, inspect the proposed acte de notoriété, record the four-month and two-month option periods, and separate inheritance tax from treaty relief and U.S. reporting. A cross-border estate can be resolved from the United States, but it needs a documented process and a person in France who is authorized to act. If the child has been omitted, pressured to sign, or given an incomplete tax or distribution proposal, obtain advice before the estate is transferred or a deadline expires.

📄 Official circular