KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Buying a French House With Your Partner as an American: How the Tontine Clause Hands the Survivor the Whole House and Beats Forced Heirship

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Buying a French House With Your Partner as an American: How the Tontine Clause Hands the Survivor the Whole House and Beats Forced Heirship

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Sarah from Austin and her French partner Marc are buying a stone house in the Dordogne for 400,000 euros, half each. Sarah has one worry that keeps her up at night. Marc has two children from a first marriage. If Marc dies first, do his children take half the house, force a sale, and leave her with nothing but a co-ownership dispute in a language she barely reads? A standard French co-ownership deed produces exactly that outcome. But the purchase deed can carry a three-line clause that changes everything: the tontine pact, called in French the pacte tontinier or clause d’accroissement. With that clause, the first partner to die is deemed never to have owned the house, the survivor is treated as the owner from day one, and the deceased partner’s children and heirs have no claim on the property at all. This article explains how that clause works, what tax the survivor pays, and where courts destroy badly built tontines, using two 2025 and 2026 rulings that every American buyer should know before signing. Every legal proposition below is tied to the exact official text or decision it comes from.

I. Buying a French House Together as an American Couple: How Does the Surviving Partner Keep the Whole House?

A. Why Ordinary Co-Ownership Leaves the Survivor Exposed to the Deceased Partner’s Heirs

Two people who buy a French house together without special planning become owners en indivision, meaning joint undivided co-ownership, typically half each. The arrangement feels safe while both partners are alive. It collapses the day one of them dies. The deceased partner’s half falls into that partner’s succession, and whoever inherits under the applicable succession law, children, a surviving spouse, sometimes parents or siblings, steps into the dead partner’s shoes as the new co-owner sitting across the table from the survivor. Any co-owner can demand a partition, and where the house cannot be split in two, the court orders a sale and divides the price. For Sarah, that means Marc’s children could force the sale of the Dordogne house within months of his death. An American will cannot prevent this, because the devolution of French real estate follows the succession law designated by the European rules, and a foreign will, even one declared enforceable in France, does not erase the rights French law gives over French buildings. The Court of Cassation confirmed the principle on July 4, 2018, in decision No. 17-16.515, published in the Bulletin, holding that “que la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire, laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel”. The transfer of those buildings on death had to respect the forced-heirship rules, which, as domestic public policy, could not be brushed aside by testamentary dispositions made under the law of the deceased’s domicile. Read the full ruling: Cass. 1st Civil Chamber, July 4, 2018, No. 17-16.515.

The scale of the children’s claim surprises most Americans. Where French law governs, children cannot be disinherited at all. The Civil Code defines the protection in Article 912 of the Civil Code: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” The réserve héréditaire, the reserved share, is the slice of the estate the law guarantees to protected heirs, and the quotité disponible, the disposable portion, is everything else. The guaranteed slice is large: under Article 913 of the Civil Code, gifts “ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Gifts cannot exceed one half with one child, one third with two children, and one quarter with three or more. Marc’s two children are therefore guaranteed two thirds of his estate between them, and his half of the Dordogne house sits squarely inside their target. Families who want the wider picture on beating forced heirship through a choice of American law should read our guide on choosing US law for a French house by professio juris and its forced-heirship limits. But a choice of law reshapes a succession; it does not protect a surviving unmarried partner. Only a property-law device signed at purchase does that, and the tontine is the classic one.

B. The Tontine Pact That Makes the Survivor the Owner From Day One

The tontine works through a double bet written into the purchase deed itself. Each buyer takes the house subject to two mirror-image conditions, a legal mechanism the Civil Code describes in Article 1304 of the Civil Code: “L’obligation est conditionnelle lorsqu’elle dépend d’un événement futur et incertain. La condition est suspensive lorsque son accomplissement rend l’obligation pure et simple. Elle est résolutoire lorsque son accomplissement entraîne l’anéantissement de l’obligation.” An obligation is conditional where it depends on a future and uncertain event. Each buyer’s full ownership is suspended on surviving the other, and each buyer’s half-ownership is wiped out on dying first. The Court of Cassation gave the textbook definition on April 9, 2026, in decision No. 25-12.992, published in the Bulletin: “La clause de tontine ou d’accroissement stipulée dans les statuts d’une société civile est celle qui attribue au dernier survivant, de manière rétroactive, la propriété des parts incluses dans le pacte tontinier.” The tontine or accrual clause awards the last survivor, retroactively, the ownership of the shares covered by the pact. The same retroactive logic applies to the purchase-deed tontine between co-buyers. Full text: Cass. 3rd Civil Chamber, April 9, 2026, No. 25-12.992.

Retroactivity is the whole magic. The first buyer to die is legally deemed never to have owned the house at all, and the survivor is deemed to have owned all of it since the purchase date. Because the deceased partner never owned anything, nothing falls into the succession, the forced-heirship machinery has nothing to bite on, and the children cannot even launch the compensatory levy introduced in 2021, since there are no French-situs assets of the deceased left to levy. The French notarial profession summarizes the effect for buyers: the predeceased buyer is declared never to have purchased, only the surviving buyer counts as owner from the start, and the deceased’s heirs hold no rights in the property because it never formed part of the deceased’s estate (see the profession’s guide, tontine advantages for real-estate purchase). For Sarah, the clause means that if Marc dies first, she owns the entire Dordogne house outright, and his children inherit everything else he owned but not one stone of that house. If she dies first, the mirror applies and Marc keeps everything. There is no middle outcome, which is why the clause suits couples who want all-or-nothing protection and horrifies buyers who want flexibility.

American buyers sometimes ask whether holding the house the American way, as joint tenants with right of survivorship, achieves the same result without French paperwork. It does not. The deed that transfers French land is the French authentic deed, and the French land registry records what that deed says, not what a Florida deed or a Texas will recites. A survivorship clause drafted under American law has no predictable effect on French-situs real estate, while the French tontine clause, signed before the French notaire and published with the deed, is the instrument French courts and French tax offices actually apply. Paying for an American-law workaround on top of the French purchase is money spent on an illusion. Spend that budget instead on the French clause drafted correctly the first time.

Three practical points decide whether the clause fits an American couple. First, it must be inserted in the authentic purchase deed signed before the French notaire, the public officer who conveys French real estate. It cannot be added later by a private letter or an American will. Raise it with the notaire before the preliminary contract, the compromis de vente, is even drafted, because the financing structure must match the clause from day one. Second, it works for any two or more buyers: two Americans, an American and a French partner, married, pacsé, or simple cohabitants. Marriage and PACS already give the survivor other protections, so the tontine matters most for unmarried couples, exactly the buyers French default law protects least. Third, the clause covers the house only. Bank accounts, investments, and furniture still pass through the succession normally, so the couple still needs wills and the broader estate planning our succession guides describe. The tontine is a scalpel for the house, not a full estate plan.

II. What Tax Does the Survivor Pay, and When Do Courts Tear the Tontine Apart?

A. Calculating the Survivor’s Tax Bill on the French House Share

Surviving everything does not mean inheriting tax-free. The survivor pays transfer duties on the share picked up through the tontine, and the bill depends entirely on the legal bond between the buyers. The notarial profession’s guide states the scale: duties are computed on the kinship between survivor and deceased applied to the value of the share received, with no duties between spouses or PACS partners, 60 percent between cohabitants after a 1,594 euro allowance, and a narrow exception where the property was the buyers’ main residence at death and worth under 76,000 euros, in which case only onerous transfer duties at a maximum legal rate of 5.81 percent apply. The 60 percent rate for unrelated persons sits in the statute itself, in Article 777 of the General Tax Code: “Entre parents au-delà du 4e degré et entre personnes non-parentes 60” Sixty percent between distant relatives and unrelated persons.

Couples who flinch at the unmarried-partner bill sometimes consider marrying or signing a PACS purely for the tax saving. That choice carries consequences far beyond this house: marriage changes the matrimonial property regime, meaning the default ownership rules for everything the couple earns and buys afterwards, while a PACS creates a lighter but still binding framework with its own inheritance and tax effects. Our guide for American partners entering a PACS with a French partner walks through the property and succession side of that decision. The right sequence is to compare all three roads, plain co-ownership, co-ownership with tontine, and marriage or PACS with or without tontine, price each in duties and in legal rigidity, and then sign. What must never happen is discovering the 60 percent bill at the settlement meeting after a death, when every planning window has closed.

Run Sarah’s numbers. The Dordogne house is worth 400,000 euros, bought half each. Marc dies first. Sarah, his unmarried partner, picks up his 200,000 euro half through the tontine. Subtract the 1,594 euro allowance, leaving 198,406 euros taxable at 60 percent, which is about 119,044 euros of duties. That bill lands within months of the death, on top of grief and paperwork, and many couples discover it only at the notaire’s office. Had Sarah and Marc been married or PACSed, the same transfer would cost nothing in duties. The lesson is blunt: for an unmarried American couple, the tontine guarantees the roof but not the price, and the price must be budgeted, financed, or insured in advance. Couples who marry or sign a PACS before or after purchase change the tax picture completely, which is why the tontine conversation should always happen together with the marriage-versus-PACS conversation, not instead of it. On the American side, coordinate early with United States counsel about any federal or state reporting tied to the French transfer and about credits for French duties paid, bringing the French tax assessments and proof of payment; this article states no American tax conclusion, because that analysis belongs to qualified United States advisers on the complete file.

B. Funding Proof, Age Gaps, and the Company Trap That Kills Bad Tontines

A tontine is a gamble, and courts void gambles that were never real. For the clause to stand, the purchase must be genuinely onerous and genuinely aleatory: each buyer must actually pay a real share of the price, and at signing day neither buyer may be a near-certain loser. Where those ingredients are missing, judges reclassify the tontine as a disguised gift, a donation déguisée, which falls back into the succession and can be cut down by the children’s reduction action. The Court of Appeal of Poitiers applied exactly that test on April 17, 2025, in case No. 23/02749, where a deceased man’s children attacked the tontine in their father’s 1998 purchase deed with his wife, arguing she had paid with his money and that a large age gap removed all uncertainty. The court restated the rule: a tontine must show onerous and aleatory character, it is reclassified as a gift where the facts wipe out the uncertainty, and uncertainty disappears where one party funded everything or nearly everything, or where a wide age gap or diverging health conditions stack the deck. Uncertainty is judged at the purchase date, never with hindsight at death.

On the facts, the widow won and the tontine stood, for reasons American buyers should memorize. The deed’s statement of fund origins showed a genuine fifty-fifty split: her cash from savings plus a documented loan from her husband, repaid in monthly instalments over years, with bank records to prove it. The children could not prove her payments came from their father’s own money, and bare assertions about who paid the household bills were not evidence. On age, the twenty-year gap was not enough by itself: general life-expectancy statistics showing men die younger did not prove the husband’s survival was illusory at signing, the husband in fact lived to 88, and scattered medical history, a 1990s intestinal episode and blood pressure treated years after purchase, did not amount to a specific risk profile in 1998. The court confirmed the trial judgment in full and ordered the children to pay costs plus 5,000 euros under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The message for American couples is concrete: fund your half with traceable money, sign a real loan where one exists and repay it by bank transfer, keep every record forever, and understand that a big age difference alone does not doom the clause, while one-sided funding plus fragile health at signing will.

Borrowing together deserves the same discipline as paying cash. Where the couple finances the purchase with a French mortgage, both partners should be co-borrowers in matching shares, each repaying from a personal account by visible transfer, so the bank statements later prove genuine shared funding. A loan taken by one partner alone, with the other merely living in the house, looks exactly like the one-sided funding pattern that invites reclassification, even where the couple shared everything informally. Our walkthrough of how Americans borrow a French mortgage to buy a house details the insurance, guarantee, and currency questions that come with French lending. Keep the mortgage paperwork consistent with the tontine from the first application: equal borrowers, equal shares, equal traces.

One more trap comes from the April 2026 Cassation ruling itself, and it concerns buyers who hold the house through a French property company, the société civile immobilière or SCI. In that case two cohabiting partners had placed a tontine clause over all the shares of their two-person SCI. The Court held that such a clause, covering everything, reunites all shares in one hand retroactively at the company’s birth, which collides with Article 1832 of the Civil Code, under which “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter.” A company is formed by two or more persons pooling assets for a common enterprise. The reunion of all shares in one hand during the company’s life is normally harmless, because Article 1844-5 of the Civil Code provides that “La réunion de toutes les parts sociales en une seule main n’entraîne pas la dissolution de plein droit de la société.” But the tontine’s reunion operates retroactively at formation, not during corporate life, so that safety valve does not apply. The Court therefore ruled, in Cass. 3rd Civil Chamber, April 9, 2026, No. 25-12.992, that “Lorsqu’elle porte sur l’ensemble des parts, elle emporte leur réunion en une seule main au décès de l’avant-dernier tontinier” and drew the consequence: “Une telle clause entraîne ainsi la nullité de la société” A blanket tontine over every share voids the company itself. American buyers using an SCI must therefore never copy a deed tontine into the company statutes wholesale; the protection belongs in the purchase deed or in carefully drafted share-level provisions reviewed line by line, never as a blanket clause.

The signing checklist that follows from these rulings is short. Buy at genuinely shared cost with paper trails for every euro. Prefer partners of broadly comparable age and health, or accept a higher litigation risk and document the uncertainty that remains. Never fund your partner’s half secretly and call it a tontine. Keep the clause in the purchase deed, not scattered across side letters. Review the structure with the notaire before the preliminary contract, and revisit it if you later move the property into a company. Contracts already signed take priority over any general analysis here, no official source reports any accident or damage finding connected to this device, and only the seized judge decides whether a given tontine stands or falls.

Conclusion

For an American buying a French house with a partner, the tontine clause is the strongest shield French law offers the survivor: one clause in the purchase deed, and the first to die is deemed never to have owned the house while the survivor owns it all from day one, beyond the reach of children, wills, and forced-heirship claims. The shield has a price tag and conditions. The survivor pays duties on the share received, nothing between spouses or PACS partners, 60 percent between unmarried partners after the small allowance, on a bill the couple must anticipate. The clause survives only where both partners truly paid and the outcome was truly uncertain at signing, judged with the eyes of the purchase date, and a blanket copy into a two-person property company’s statutes destroys the company instead of protecting it. Couples who fund equally, document everything, and sign early get the protection they wanted. Couples who fake the gamble hand their children the requalification lawsuit. Choose before the preliminary contract, fund cleanly, and let the notaire draft the bet both partners actually mean.

📄 Official circular