KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My French Renovation Stalled Mid-Job: How Americans Finish the Work, Hold Back Payment, and Claim for Defects

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My French Renovation Stalled Mid-Job: How Americans Finish the Work, Hold Back Payment, and Claim for Defects

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought the stone farmhouse outside Sarlat, or the village house in the Luberon, and the renovation started well. Then the contractor stopped showing up. The tiler finished half a bathroom and vanished. The roofer sent an extra bill you never approved. The site has been silent for two months, rain is getting into the half-open roof, and you are 4,000 miles away in Chicago or Austin trying to get someone on the phone. This guide explains exactly what French law lets you do, in what order, and which paper to send first. France gives the property owner, called the maître de l’ouvrage, powerful tools: you can have the work finished by someone else at the defaulting contractor’s expense, you can terminate a fixed-price contract by your sole will, you can hold back money on every invoice, and after acceptance you benefit from three layers of legal guarantees running one, two, and ten years. Each tool has strict formalities, especially the registered letter called a mise en demeure, and skipping a step can cost you the leverage. Read this before you pay another euro, before you sign any acceptance paper, and before you let a contractor tell you that French guarantees do not apply to renovation work.

I. Your Contractor Stopped Coming: How Do You Legally Take Back Control of the Site?

A. Why do you send a formal demand first, and how do you have the work finished by someone else?

When a French contractor abandons a renovation or leaves serious defects behind, the first reflex of an American owner is to stop paying and hire someone else. That reflex is understandable, but French law asks you to do one thing first: put the contractor formally on notice. The mise en demeure is a written demand, sent by registered letter with return receipt (lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception), ordering the contractor to resume or fix the work within a stated deadline, typically fifteen to thirty days depending on the urgency. From the United States, you can send it through the French post office’s online registered letter service, which produces the same legal proof as a letter posted in France, or you can have a French lawyer or your architect send it. Keep the receipt and a full copy, because every later remedy, finishing the work with another firm, terminating the contract, or claiming penalties, builds on proof that this demand went unanswered.

Once the deadline in your mise en demeure expires with no result, Article 1222 of the Civil Code lets you take the matter into your own hands: “Après mise en demeure, le créancier peut aussi, dans un délai et à un coût raisonnables, faire exécuter lui-même l’obligation ou, sur autorisation préalable du juge, détruire ce qui a été fait en violation de celle-ci. Il peut demander au débiteur le remboursement des sommes engagées à cette fin.” In plain terms, after an unanswered formal demand, you may have the unfinished work completed by another contractor within a reasonable time and at a reasonable cost, and bill the difference to the one who walked away. For straightforward completion work, prior court permission is not required; you only need a judge’s advance authorization if you want to demolish what was badly built. In practice, get two written quotes for the completion, photograph and video the state of the site before anyone touches it, and consider having a court-appointed expert (expert judiciaire) record the defects through a fast-track court procedure if the amounts are large, because that report will carry heavy weight if the contractor later disputes the bill.

American owners sometimes ask whether they can simply terminate the contract instead. The answer depends on the type of contract you signed. If you signed a fixed-price renovation contract (marché à forfait), Article 1794 of the Civil Code gives you a striking right: “Le maître peut résilier, par sa seule volonté, le marché à forfait, quoique l’ouvrage soit déjà commencé, en dédommageant l’entrepreneur de toutes ses dépenses, de tous ses travaux, et de tout ce qu’il aurait pu gagner dans cette entreprise.” You can therefore end a lump-sum contract by your sole will at any time, even mid-job, but you must compensate the contractor for expenses, work done, and lost profit. That compensation is the price of a no-fault exit, and it is why termination under Article 1794 is a poor weapon against a contractor who is already at fault: you should not pay lost profit to a firm that abandoned your roof.

That is exactly the point the Cour de cassation made on June 25, 2026, in decision No. 24-18.064: “Il résulte de la combinaison de ces textes que la faculté de résiliation unilatérale d’un marché à forfait par le maître de l’ouvrage, prévue à l’article 1794 du code civil, ne prive pas celui-ci de la possibilité de résilier le marché dans les conditions du droit commun.” The special no-fault exit does not take away your ordinary right to terminate for the contractor’s fault, for delays, botched work, or site abandonment, without owing lost profit. Concretely, if your contractor walked off the job, you terminate for fault after your mise en demeure, you owe only the value of work properly performed, and you keep the right to claim your extra completion costs as damages. List the faults precisely in the termination letter, reference the unanswered formal demand, and stop all further payments except the documented value of correct work, because any sum you overpay now will have to be recovered later in court.

One warning matters for Americans managing a site from abroad: never terminate by phone or by email alone, and never let the contractor frame the breakup as a mutual agreement without a written breakdown of accounts. A termination for fault must be in writing, state the grounds, and be sent by registered letter. If the contractor owes you money for overpaid advances or for completion overcosts, that letter is the starting point of your claim, and a French court will read it closely. If you hired an architect (architecte) or a project manager (maître d’oeuvre) to supervise the job, loop them in before you terminate: their written site reports (comptes rendus de chantier) noting absences, defects, and missed milestones are the evidence that turns your termination letter from an accusation into a documented fact.

B. How do daily delay penalties, the 5 percent holdback, and staged payments protect your money?

Your second line of defense is money: what you have not yet paid is your strongest leverage, and French law offers three mechanisms to keep it that way. The first is the delay penalty clause (pénalités de retard). Most French work contracts provide a daily sum, often a fraction of the contract price per calendar day of delay, running automatically once the agreed completion date passes. If your contract has no penalty clause, you can still claim damages for delay, but you must prove the loss, which is slower. If it has one, Article 1231-5 of the Civil Code frames it: “Lorsque le contrat stipule que celui qui manquera de l’exécuter paiera une certaine somme à titre de dommages et intérêts, il ne peut être alloué à l’autre partie une somme plus forte ni moindre. Néanmoins, le juge peut, même d’office, modérer ou augmenter la pénalité ainsi convenue si elle est manifestement excessive ou dérisoire.” Penalties therefore apply as written, but a judge can cut them if they are plainly disproportionate, which is why penalty clauses should be firm but realistic, for example tied to your actual carrying costs such as rent, storage, or a hotel, rather than a fantasy number a court would slash. To trigger them, send the mise en demeure first, then compute the days from the contractual deadline, and set the accrued penalties off against the invoices you still owe.

The second mechanism is the holdback on each progress invoice, known as the retenue de garantie. In French private construction practice, the owner may hold back up to 5 percent of the price of the work on every payment during the job, as security for the one-year repair guarantee described below. The retained sums are released one year after acceptance if no covered defects were reported, or earlier if the contractor provides a bank guarantee (caution bancaire) for the same amount. For an American owner, this clause is gold: on a 120,000 euro renovation, it keeps 6,000 euros in your hands instead of in the contractor’s pocket while defects surface. Insist on the clause in writing before work starts, apply it line by line on each invoice (situation de travaux), and never release it early against a handshake promise to come back and fix things. Contractors who know they will only see the last 5 percent after a clean first year return to fix things; contractors who were paid in full do not.

The third mechanism is the payment schedule itself. Under a standard French renovation contract with an independent contractor (marché de travaux d’entreprise), you pay as the work advances, against invoices checked by you or your architect, and you keep a meaningful balance for final acceptance. Be wary of any contractor who demands 50 percent upfront before mobilizing, or full payment of a phase before it is verifiably complete. Large advances with no bank guarantee are how owners end up paying twice: once to the contractor who disappeared, once to the firm that finishes the job. A reasonable pattern is a modest mobilization deposit, monthly progress payments tied to observed completion percentages, the 5 percent holdback on each, and a final balance of 10 to 15 percent payable only at acceptance with no reservations, or after reservations are lifted. If a contractor pressures you to wire the next installment from the US before the corresponding work is done, treat that pressure as information, and answer with a site visit or an architect’s report, not with a wire transfer.

Two paperwork checks belong at the start of the job, not at the crisis stage, but verify them now if you skipped them. First, before any trench is dug or wall opened, ask every contractor for its ten-year liability insurance certificate (attestation d’assurance décennale) with the insurer’s name and contact details. Article L241-1 of the Insurance Code is blunt: “Toute personne physique ou morale, dont la responsabilité décennale peut être engagée sur le fondement de la présomption établie par les articles 1792 et suivants du code civil, doit être couverte par une assurance. A l’ouverture de tout chantier, elle doit justifier qu’elle a souscrit un contrat d’assurance la couvrant pour cette responsabilité.” A contractor with no valid ten-year policy at opening day is a red flag, and if serious structural work is involved, an uninsured contractor can leave you with no solvent party behind the guarantees. Second, if your project is a new individual house built from a plan proposed by the builder, you are likely under the protective single-family house contract (contrat de construction de maison individuelle), which Article L231-1 of the Construction and Housing Code defines as mandatory whenever “Toute personne qui se charge de la construction d’un immeuble à usage d’habitation ou d’un immeuble à usage professionnel et d’habitation ne comportant pas plus de deux logements destinés au même maître de l’ouvrage d’après un plan qu’elle a proposé ou fait proposer doit conclure avec le maître de l’ouvrage un contrat soumis aux dispositions de l’article L. 231-2 .” That regime adds payment caps and a delivery guarantee, which is a different and even more protective world than a plain renovation contract, so identify which contract you signed before choosing your weapons. Owners who bought a new-build home off plan face yet another regime, the forward sale with its own completion guarantees, described in our guide to buying a new-build home off plan in France, from reservation to late delivery and defect claims.

Finally, organize the money trail for a cross-border dispute. Pay every invoice by bank transfer with the invoice number in the reference, never in cash, and keep a simple ledger matching each payment to a dated progress report or photograph set. If the dispute goes to court, the judge will compare sums paid against work actually performed, valued by an expert, and every undocumented cash payment becomes a gift to the contractor’s version of events. If you must advance funds for materials, pay the supplier directly or against delivery slips, not as an unallocated advance to the contractor. And keep your US wire confirmations: they prove dates and amounts, which is exactly what a French court needs to compute overpayments, set off penalties, and order reimbursement.

II. The Work Is Finished but Defective: Which Guarantee Pays for Each Repair?

A. Why does the acceptance inspection decide everything about the first year of repairs?

In French construction law, one single event switches on all the guarantees: the acceptance of the work, called réception. Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code defines it: “La réception est l’acte par lequel le maître de l’ouvrage déclare accepter l’ouvrage avec ou sans réserves.” It takes place at the request of the more diligent party, amicably or through the courts if needed, and in every case both sides must be heard, which means a contractor cannot declare your renovation accepted behind your back, and you cannot be forced to accept sight unseen from abroad without a representative. The acceptance inspection (opérations de réception) ends with a written report (procès-verbal de réception), and the reservations (réserves) you write into that report, every crack, leak, misalignment, missing fixture, or unfinished item, become the contractor’s mandatory punch list. The official service-public.fr guidance warns owners plainly: defects you can see at acceptance but fail to note are treated as accepted, and you lose the right to have them fixed under the guarantees, while hidden defects remain covered according to their nature. For an American owner who cannot attend, the answer is a written power of attorney (pouvoir) to your architect or a trusted representative, with explicit instructions to list every visible defect, no matter how small, and to refuse any pre-printed report stating that the work is accepted with no reservations.

Refusing acceptance is itself a right, not a breach. If the work is so incomplete or defective that it cannot serve its purpose, a leaking new roof, a heating system that never worked, a bathroom with no waterproofing, you may refuse the réception and demand completion first, recording the refusal and its reasons in writing. Contractors sometimes respond by abandoning the site and later claiming the owner tacitly accepted the work by moving in or paying the balance. French courts do recognize tacit acceptance (réception tacite), but they set the bar high, and paying the final invoice alone is not enough. In its November 12, 2020 decision No. 19-18.213, the Third Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation approved judges who “a pu en déduire que la réception tacite résultait de la prise de possession jointe au paiement intégral, de sorte que la date à retenir pour le point de départ de l’action en garantie décennale était le 26 mai 2006.” Tacit acceptance resulted from taking possession combined with full payment, and that combined date started the ten-year guarantee clock. The lesson cuts both ways: if you move into the renovated house and pay the balance without reservations, a court may treat the work as accepted on that date, starting guarantees but also closing the door on complaints about visible defects. If instead you take possession while protesting in writing and withholding the holdback, you preserve your punch list.

Once acceptance is pronounced, with or without reservations, the one-year repair guarantee (garantie de parfait achèvement) begins. Article 1792-6 states: “La garantie de parfait achèvement, à laquelle l’entrepreneur est tenu pendant un délai d’un an, à compter de la réception, s’étend à la réparation de tous les désordres signalés par le maître de l’ouvrage, soit au moyen de réserves mentionnées au procès-verbal de réception, soit par voie de notification écrite pour ceux révélés postérieurement à la réception.” Every disorder noted in the acceptance report, plus every disorder that appears during the following year and is reported in writing, must be repaired by the contractor, with repair deadlines set by mutual agreement, and after an unanswered mise en demeure the work can be done at the defaulting contractor’s expense and risk. Normal wear and use are the only exclusion. Practically, calendar the anniversary: eleven months after acceptance, walk the property with your reservations list, photograph everything, and notify new defects by registered letter before the year expires. Miss that letter and the one-year guarantee dies with the anniversary, leaving you to the narrower guarantees below.

Note that no contract clause can strip these rights away. Article 1792-5 of the Civil Code provides: “Toute clause d’un contrat qui a pour objet, soit d’exclure ou de limiter la responsabilité prévue aux articles 1792 , 1792-1 et 1792-2 , soit d’exclure les garanties prévues aux articles 1792-3 et 1792-6 ou d’en limiter la portée, soit d’écarter ou de limiter la solidarité prévue à l’article 1792-4 , est réputée non écrite.” Any clause excluding or limiting the legal construction guarantees is deemed unwritten, meaning a judge simply ignores it. If your contractor’s standard terms claim the one-year repair duty does not apply to renovation, or cap repairs at some token amount, that sentence has no legal effect, and you should say so in your demand letter, citing the article, because contractors often back down once they see the owner knows the guarantees are a matter of public policy (ordre public).

B. When does the two-year equipment warranty end and the ten-year structural warranty take over?

After the first year, two longer guarantees divide the remaining defects by nature. Separable equipment, radiators that can be unbolted, shutters, faucets, a removable boiler, falls under the two-year proper-functioning warranty (garantie biennale or garantie de bon fonctionnement). Article 1792-3 of the Civil Code states: “Les autres éléments d’équipement de l’ouvrage font l’objet d’une garantie de bon fonctionnement d’une durée minimale de deux ans à compter de sa réception.” If the new heat pump or the electric roller shutters fail in year two, the installer must repair or replace them. Keep purchase invoices and model references, report the failure in writing as soon as it appears, and do not let the contractor recharacterize a year-two equipment failure as a maintenance issue: the warranty covers proper functioning for a minimum of two full years from acceptance.

Everything affecting solidity or fitness for purpose falls under the ten-year warranty (garantie décennale), the heavyweight of French construction law. Article 1792 of the Civil Code provides: “Tout constructeur d’un ouvrage est responsable de plein droit, envers le maître ou l’acquéreur de l’ouvrage, des dommages, même résultant d’un vice du sol, qui compromettent la solidité de l’ouvrage ou qui, l’affectant dans l’un de ses éléments constitutifs ou l’un de ses éléments d’équipement, le rendent impropre à sa destination. Une telle responsabilité n’a point lieu si le constructeur prouve que les dommages proviennent d’une cause étrangère.” Liability is automatic, no need to prove fault, for damage threatening solidity or making the building unfit for its purpose, a collapsed retaining wall, rising damp through a failed membrane, a roof frame that sags, a septic system that never worked. And the circle of liable parties is wide: Article 1792-1 deems a builder (“constructeur”) to include “1° Tout architecte, entrepreneur, technicien ou autre personne liée au maître de l’ouvrage par un contrat de louage d’ouvrage”, so your architect, your general contractor, and your specialized trades all stand behind the ten-year duty, each for their own scope. The 2020 Cour de cassation decision above illustrates the machinery in a renovation setting: an undersized climate system that repeatedly broke down rendered the building unfit for its hotel purpose, and the installer bore ten-year liability from the tacit-acceptance date.

The ten-year clock runs from acceptance, and it runs for ten full years. Article 1792-4-1 of the Civil Code states: “Toute personne physique ou morale dont la responsabilité peut être engagée en vertu des articles 1792 à 1792-4 du présent code est déchargée des responsabilités et garanties pesant sur elle, en application des articles 1792 à 1792-2, après dix ans à compter de la réception des travaux ou, en application de l’article 1792-3 , à l’expiration du délai visé à cet article.” File your claim, or at minimum send the formal demand and start the court expert procedure, before the tenth anniversary of acceptance, because courts enforce the deadline strictly, and the date of acceptance, express or tacit, is where the fight usually happens. This is another reason to pin down the acceptance date in writing now rather than reconstruct it from memory six years later from Texas.

Ten-year liability is only as good as the insurance behind it, which brings two policies every American renovator must verify. The contractor’s ten-year policy (assurance responsabilité décennale), mandatory under Article L241-1 of the Insurance Code quoted above, responds when the builder is liable; always collect the certificate before work starts and confirm with the insurer that the policy covers your type of work and was in force on opening day, because a lapsed or activity-excluded policy is a frequent nasty surprise. Your own policy as owner is the damage-to-works insurance (assurance dommages-ouvrage): Article L242-1 of the Insurance Code requires that “Toute personne physique ou morale qui, agissant en qualité de propriétaire de l’ouvrage, de vendeur ou de mandataire du propriétaire de l’ouvrage, fait réaliser des travaux de construction, doit souscrire avant l’ouverture du chantier, pour son compte ou pour celui des propriétaires successifs, une assurance garantissant, en dehors de toute recherche des responsabilités, le paiement de la totalité des travaux de réparation des dommages de la nature de ceux dont sont responsables les constructeurs au sens de l’article 1792-1”. This policy pays for the repairs first, without waiting for the blame game between contractors and their insurers, and the insurer then chases the liable parties. The official service-public.fr page confirms you must take it out before the site opens for construction, extension, or renovation work done by a firm, and that it covers damage appearing within ten years after acceptance. For major structural renovation, roof, foundations, extensions, waterproofing, going without it means financing the repairs yourself while a multi-year liability lawsuit runs its course, which is exactly the cash-flow trap that ruins an American owner’s renovation budget. If your project is already underway and no such policy was taken out, ask your insurer or broker immediately whether late subscription is still possible, and factor the answer into how aggressively you negotiate with the contractor.

Conclusion

A stalled French renovation feels like a disaster from 4,000 miles away, but it is a solved legal problem with a fixed sequence. Send the mise en demeure by registered letter and calendar the deadline. After that deadline, have the work finished by another firm at a documented reasonable cost, or terminate for the contractor’s fault while keeping every site report and photograph. Enforce the daily penalties your contract provides, keep the 5 percent holdback on every invoice, and stop advances that no longer match work performed. At acceptance, list every visible defect in the written report or refuse acceptance in writing, then use the one-year repair guarantee to its last week, the two-year equipment warranty for what can be unbolted, and the ten-year warranty for everything touching solidity or fitness for purpose. Verify the contractor’s ten-year insurance on day one and take out damage-to-works cover before the site opens. Each step is a letter, a receipt, and a date, and together they turn an abandoned site back into a house. The owners who lose money in French renovations are rarely those with the worst contractors; they are those with the thinnest paper trail.

📄 Official circular