Picture the scene. You and your partner, both American citizens living in Austin, fall in love with a stone house in the Dordogne. You are not married, and you have no plans to marry. She pays 70 percent of the price from the sale of her condo; you pay 30 percent from savings. The French notaire asks one question that will shape the next thirty years of your lives: in what shares are you buying, and what happens to the house when the first of you dies?
Under French law, the default answer is co-ownership in undivided shares, a regime called indivision. Each of you owns a slice of the whole house. If one of you dies, that slice does not go to the surviving partner. It goes to the dead partner’s heirs: children first, and if there are none, parents and siblings. The survivor suddenly co-owns the holiday home with their late partner’s family. And if the couple splits up, either side can force a sale of the house at any time. That outcome shocks most American buyers, because it looks nothing like a joint tenancy with right of survivorship back home.
The classic French answer for unmarried buyers is the clause de tontine, also called the clause d’accroissement: a survivorship clause written into the purchase deed itself. When the first partner dies, the survivor is treated as having owned the entire house from day one. No shared ownership with in-laws, no forced division with heirs. But the clause has a price. France taxes the survivor on the share that accretes to them, and children of the dead partner can attack the clause in court if it was really a disguised gift that ate into their protected inheritance. This guide explains both halves: first, how the deed mechanics work, then what the survivor pays and keeps on both sides of the Atlantic.
I. Buying a French house together without being married: indivision shares or a tontine clause
A. What happens to our French house if we split up or one of us dies without a tontine clause?
When two unmarried people buy a house in France without any special clause, they buy in indivision: each owns an undivided share, typically 50/50, though the deed can record any split that matches the financing, such as 70/30. The shares written into the deed are what counts, so tell the notaire exactly who paid what before the deed is signed. If the deed says 50/50 while one partner funded 80 percent, the 50/50 split in the deed governs, and fixing that later means a second transaction with its own tax bill. French co-owners who want to organize their shared ownership in writing sign an indivision agreement, and the law requires precision for that document: Article 1873-2 of the Civil Code provides that “Les coïndivisaires, s’ils y consentent tous, peuvent convenir de demeurer dans l’indivision. A peine de nullité, la convention doit être établie par un écrit comportant la désignation des biens indivis et l’indication des quotes-parts appartenant à chaque indivisaire.”
Daily life in indivision runs on unanimity for important decisions, and French courts enforce that strictly. In a 29 September 2015 ruling, the Third Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation quashed an appeal decision for failing to establish “l’accord unanime des coïndivisaires, exigé par l’article 815-3 du code civil” before recognizing a lease granted over shared property (Cass. civ. 3e, 29 Sept. 2015, No. 14-15.090). For an American couple, the practical lesson is concrete: neither partner can rent out the house, carry out major works, or sell the whole property over the other’s objection. One holdout blocks everything.
The sharper edge of indivision appears when the couple separates. French law refuses to trap anyone in shared ownership: Article 815 of the Civil Code states that “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” Either ex-partner can force a division, which for a single house usually means a buyout of the other’s share or a sale of the whole property with the price split. A written agreement to stay in shared ownership softens that rule only temporarily: Article 1873-3 of the Civil Code provides that “La convention peut être conclue pour une durée déterminée qui ne saurait être supérieure à cinq ans. Elle est renouvelable par une décision expresse des parties.”
And when the relationship ends by separation rather than death, dividing the house has its own tax line. Article 746 of the General Tax Code provides that “Les partages de biens meubles et immeubles entre copropriétaires, cohéritiers et coassociés, à quelque titre que ce soit, pourvu qu’il en soit justifié, sont assujettis à un droit d’enregistrement ou à une taxe de publicité foncière de 2,50 %.” The same article brings the rate down to 1.10 percent since 1 January 2022 for divisions of property interests following a separation from bed and board, a divorce, or the breakup of a PACS civil partnership. For an unmarried couple with no PACS, the full 2.50 percent applies to the value being divided, which is one more reason to settle the shares correctly at purchase rather than at breakup.
Death without a tontine clause is harsher still. The dead partner’s share falls into their estate and passes to their legal heirs, and an unmarried partner is not a legal heir under French intestacy rules. The survivor keeps only their own share and becomes a co-owner with the dead partner’s children, parents, or siblings. A will can repair part of the damage, because liberalities, gifts by will, let the deceased leave property to a non-relative, but children have a legally protected portion of the estate that no will can take away, as explained in Part II below. The English-language service-public portal describes shared ownership between heirs after death in its guide to succession and indivision between heirs, and its home buying and selling guide walks through the purchase steps that lead to the deed. For Americans who want the will route instead, the firm explains how to write a French will that actually works from the United States, with handwritten formalities, deposit, and registration.
So the default regime gives the couple flexibility at purchase and fragility ever after: anyone can force a sale, no one inherits from the other automatically, and every exit passes through the notaire with a tax ticket attached. The tontine clause exists precisely to fix the death scenario, and only that scenario, as the next section shows.
B. How does the tontine clause make the survivor the only owner of our French house?
The tontine clause, or clause d’accroissement, is written into the purchase deed alongside the price and the shares. It provides that when the first buyer dies, the survivor is retroactively deemed to have been the sole owner of the entire property since the purchase date. The dead partner is treated as never having owned it, which means the house never enters their estate: their children, parents, and siblings have no claim on the bricks themselves. In an opinion dated 15 June 2022, published in the Bulletin, the First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation defined the mechanism in these terms: “La clause de tontine, ou clause d’accroissement, est celle par laquelle, lorsque plusieurs personnes acquièrent un bien, le survivant des acquéreurs est réputé avoir été seul propriétaire depuis l’acquisition” (Cass. civ. 1re, advisory opinion No. 21-80.743 and No. 22-70.002, 15 June 2022, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2022:AV09000).
That retroactive sole ownership is the whole point, and it works because the clause is a gamble, a contract whose outcome depends on an uncertain event: who dies first. Each buyer pays their share of the price and accepts the risk of losing everything if they die first, in exchange for the chance of gaining everything if they survive. The Cour de cassation spelled out what each buyer holds while both are alive: “Tant que la condition de survie demeure pendante, un acquéreur en tontine a, sous la réserve de stipulations contraires, la possibilité d’aliéner seul les droits qu’il tient du pacte tontinier et qui consistent, d’une part, en la jouissance indivise du bien, d’autre part, en la propriété du bien conditionnée au prédécès de ses coacquéreurs.” In plain terms, while both partners live, each can sell or mortgage their own tontine rights, but the buyer of those rights only gets shared use now plus full ownership if the original buyer outlives the other. The survival bet stays attached to the original buyer’s lifespan, not the new holder’s.
Because the gamble is the legal foundation, the clause survives only where both sides truly paid and truly risked. Where one partner funded the entire purchase and the other added nothing, courts treat the arrangement as a disguised gift rather than a bet, with the tax and inheritance consequences of a gift. A recent illustration comes from the Poitiers Court of Appeal, which ruled on 17 April 2025 (RG No. 23/02749) on heirs who asked the court to reclassify a 1998 tontine purchase as an indirect gift from the husband to his wife, imputable against her rights and reducible for exceeding the disposable share. The court restated the test, confirmed the trial court’s dismissal of the claim, and ordered the losing heirs to pay costs: the purchase had been documented as financed half and half, with the wife’s half partly covered by an explicit loan from her husband repayable in 180 monthly installments, so the onerous and uncertain character of the deal held. The lesson for American buyers is documentary, not theoretical. Keep bank wires, loan agreements, and the deed’s statement of the origin of funds aligned, with each partner visibly paying their share. A 70/30 tontine where the 30 percent partner’s contribution is real and proven is defensible; a 50/50 deed where one side quietly paid everything invites the exact lawsuit the Poitiers heirs brought.
Three practical consequences follow for couples signing from the United States. First, the clause must be in the purchase deed at signing; it cannot be bolted on years later without a new conveyance, so raise it with the notaire before the preliminary contract is finalized. Second, the clause solves death but not separation: if the couple splits while both live, they are back in ordinary indivision with the forced-sale and division-tax mechanics of Section A. Third, mortgage lenders read the clause carefully, because each borrower’s collateral is conditional on survival; American buyers financing from abroad should confirm in writing that the lender accepts the tontine structure before committing to a closing date. Couples who want a company wrapper around the property instead should compare with the guide to buying a French house through an SCI, with its tax, heir, and IRS reporting analysis.
In short, the tontine clause converts a fragile co-ownership into a winner-takes-all survivorship deal, provided both partners genuinely pay and genuinely gamble. The next question is what the win costs: French tax on the survivor, the rights of the dead partner’s children, and the American tax return.
II. What the survivor keeps and pays: French tax, children, and the American side
A. What French tax does the surviving partner pay on the tontine house?
France does not let the survivor take the house without a tax charge. For tax purposes, the share that accretes to the survivor on the partner’s death is treated as a gift from the dead partner, and gift duties apply. Article 754 A of the General Tax Code states that “Les biens recueillis en vertu d’une clause insérée dans un contrat d’acquisition en commun selon laquelle la part du ou des premiers décédés reviendra aux survivants de telle sorte que le dernier vivant sera considéré comme seul propriétaire de la totalité des biens sont, au point de vue fiscal, réputés transmis à titre gratuit à chacun des bénéficiaires de l’accroissement.” The article adds an exception for a shared main home worth less than 76,000 euros in total, unless the beneficiary opts for death duties instead. Most American-owned French houses exceed that threshold many times over, so plan on the gift-duty treatment applying in full.
The rate then depends on the relationship between the partners, and for an unmarried couple with no family tie, the scale is the harshest one. France taxes transfers between unrelated persons at 60 percent after a small allowance: Article 777 of the General Tax Code sets the Tableau III scale, whose final line reads “Entre parents au-delà du 4e degré et entre personnes non-parentes” next to a 60 percent rate. Take a concrete example. Two partners buy a 400,000 euro house 50/50 with a tontine clause. When the first dies, the survivor is deemed to receive a 200,000 euro gift and owes roughly 60 percent of that amount in gift duties, a six-figure check to the French Treasury on top of grief. That number is the single most underestimated figure in every American tontine purchase, and it should be modeled before signing, not discovered at the notaire’s office after death.
Two comparisons show how much relationship status matters. Married spouses and PACS civil partners who inherit from each other pay nothing: Article 796-0 bis of the General Tax Code provides that “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” An unmarried partner with a tontine clause gets no such exemption and faces the 60 percent scale instead. The PACS also changes the starting point for shares: Article 515-5 of the Civil Code presumes that “Les biens sur lesquels aucun des partenaires ne peut justifier d’une propriété exclusive sont réputés leur appartenir indivisément, à chacun pour moitié.” That presumption protects the partner who cannot paper-trail every payment. By contrast, a married surviving spouse enjoys a lifetime housing right over the family home by statute: Article 764 of the Civil Code grants the surviving spouse who lived in the home “jusqu’à son décès, un droit d’habitation et un droit d’usage sur le mobilier, compris dans la succession, le garnissant.” An unmarried tontine survivor has no equivalent statutory housing right; their protection comes only from the clause itself. Americans weighing whether to sign a PACS before buying should read the guide to signing a PACS in France, covering formation, taxes, property, inheritance, and dissolution.
Children of the dead partner add a second layer of risk on top of the tax bill. French law reserves a fixed portion of every estate for children, called the réserve héréditaire: Article 912 of the Civil Code defines it as “la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” The remainder, the quotité disponible, is the part “dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” The fractions are fixed by statute: Article 913 of the Civil Code provides that “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Where a tontine transfers value beyond that disposable share, the children can sue to reclassify the clause as a disguised gift and claw back the excess, exactly as the Poitiers heirs attempted with their claim for imputation and reduction of the 1998 purchase. Their claim failed because the financing was genuinely shared and documented, which is precisely why Section I.B insisted on aligned bank records. Note the contrast with a surviving spouse, whose gifts from the deceased are simply credited against their inheritance rights by law: Article 758-6 of the Civil Code states that “Les libéralités reçues du défunt par le conjoint survivant s’imputent sur les droits de celui-ci dans la succession.” An unmarried partner has no inheritance rights to impute against, so every euro of tontine accretion is exposed to the children’s claim, with only the clause’s genuine gamble character as a shield.
The practical checklist before signing therefore runs: model the 60 percent gift-duty cost on the accretion and confirm the estate can fund it; verify that neither partner’s children would be pushed below their reserved share by the transfer; keep financing proof that each side paid its stated portion; and consider whether a PACS, a will, or life insurance for the tax bill changes the picture. Couples with children from a prior relationship face the hardest version of this arithmetic, and the analysis for blended families is developed further in the guide to what the American surviving spouse receives, how to choose between usufruct and ownership, and how to stay in the home.
B. What does the United States tax when the survivor keeps the French house?
The survivor’s French victory does not end the story, because the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide transfers and the two countries’ claims overlap on the same house. The good news is that a bilateral treaty organizes that overlap. The United States-France estate and gift tax treaty of 24 November 1978 coordinates which country taxes transfers of French real estate by gift or at death and provides a credit so the same value is not fully taxed twice, as documented in the French tax administration’s official BOFiP commentary on the France-United States tax treaty and the consolidated version of the 1978 convention published by impots.gouv.fr. In practice, the French gift duties analyzed in Section II.A are the first bill to arrive, and the treaty credit is then claimed on the American side, which means the French assessment, the notaire’s valuation, and proof of payment must be preserved in a form the American return can use.
Characterization is where American survivors stumble. The tontine accretion is a creature of French civil law with no exact American equivalent: it is neither classic joint tenancy, nor an inheritance, nor quite a lifetime gift, since the survivor’s full ownership crystallizes only at the partner’s death by retroactive effect. How that accretion is reported for American estate, gift, or income purposes, including the basis the survivor takes in the house for a later sale, depends on an analysis that blends the French deed with American tax concepts, and the answer moves real money. Get that analysis before the French transaction, not after the death, because the deed’s wording, the recorded shares, and the financing trail are fixed at purchase while the tax characterization can still be influenced. Part of the same discipline is keeping the property’s paper trail complete: purchase deed, proof of each partner’s payments, the French tax assessment on the accretion, and records of any rental income or expenses, since the survivor will need every page twice, once for the French file and once for the American one.
Ongoing American reporting duties continue regardless of the treaty. An American who holds French bank accounts used to pay the mortgage, the property tax, and the insurance must track foreign-account filing duties on the American side and the parallel French declaration duty, a double-compliance exercise the firm details in the guide to FBAR, Form 8938, and French Form 3916, with penalties and fix procedures for missed years. Rental income from the house while both partners live, or after the survivor takes full ownership, must likewise be declared in both countries with the treaty allocating the primary taxing right, a mechanics explained for unfurnished rentals in the guide to who taxes the rent, how to file French Forms 2044 and 2042, and how the treaty credit works. None of these filings is optional, and none is replaced by the French gift-duty payment on the accretion.
Finally, coordinate the French deed with the rest of the estate plan. American revocable living trusts do not carry the French house past French forced-heirship and tax rules the way they carry American assets past probate, a trap analyzed in the guide to why France ignores the American living trust over a French house and what heirs must do instead. A French will dealing with the movable property and the survivor’s overall position, drafted with the formalities French courts require, remains the complement to the tontine clause rather than its substitute. The tontine decides who owns the walls; the will, the insurance, and the treaty-credit paperwork decide what that ownership actually costs the family.
Conclusion
For an unmarried American couple buying a French house together, the choice is stark. Plain indivision is easy to enter and painful to leave: anyone can force a sale, the survivor inherits nothing automatically, and every exit carries a tax charge. The tontine clause reverses the death outcome by deeming the survivor sole owner from the purchase date, but it demands two things in return: genuine shared financing that proves the survival gamble was real, and a tax budget built around gift duties at up to 60 percent on the accreted share, with the children’s reserved portion respected. Layer the American side on top through the 1978 treaty credit, complete dual-country reporting, and a will that covers everything the clause does not, and the stone house in the Dordogne becomes what it was supposed to be: a shared home with a certain future, whichever partner survives.