Summary. Acquiring French nationality by naturalisation (naturalisation by decree) is a discretionary decision by the French State. The administration enjoys a large pouvoir d’appréciation (broad discretionary power) to grant or refuse an application, even when all statutory conditions are met. For English-speaking expatriates, the process raises specific challenges: the entretien d’assimilation (assimilation interview) is conducted exclusively in French, the civics component tests knowledge of French history and institutions, and the procedural pathway for contesting a refusal is dense and strictly regulated. This article sets out the legal framework applicable in 2026, the key grounds for refusal drawn from recent administrative case law, and the concrete steps to challenge a negative decision before the French administrative courts.
Under article 21-15 of the Code civil, “l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger” (acquisition of French nationality by decision of the public authority results from a naturalisation granted by decree at the request of the foreign national). A naturalisation in France is not a right but a favour: the State may refuse or postpone (ajourner) an application on grounds of opportunité (expediency), even where the applicant meets the objective statutory conditions. Understanding what the administration actually looks at in practice — and how the tribunal administratif de Nantes (sole competent court for naturalisation litigation) reviews those decisions — is essential before filing.
Readers seeking broader context on the French residence permit system may wish to consult our page on immigration law in Paris before proceeding.
I. Eligibility: Residence, Character, and the Assimilation Standard
A. Residence Duration, Resources, and Professional Integration
The first set of conditions concerns the applicant’s presence on French territory and their material self-sufficiency. The administration examines whether the applicant has established their habitual residence in France, whether they possess stable and sufficient resources, and whether they have achieved a meaningful degree of professional integration. These elements are not evaluated in isolation: a weak showing on one dimension can be offset by strength on another, but the administration retains full discretion to weigh them against each other.
A decision rendered by the Cour administrative d’appel de Nantes (Nantes Administrative Court of Appeal) on 24 June 2025 illustrates the boundaries of this discretion with respect to disabled applicants. In CAA Nantes, 5e ch., 24 June 2025, n° 24NT01547, the Minister of the Interior had ajourné (postponed) for two years the naturalisation application of an Algerian national on the grounds that “elle n’avait pas pleinement réalisé son insertion professionnelle et qu’elle ne disposait pas de ressources suffisantes et stables” (she had not fully achieved professional integration and did not have sufficient and stable resources). The applicant, however, suffered from a progressive genetic disease requiring multidisciplinary care and had been continuously receiving the allocation adulte handicapé (disabled adult allowance) since 2010, with a recognised incapacity rate between 50 and 79 percent. The court annulled the postponement, holding that:
“Pour rejeter une demande de naturalisation ou de réintégration dans la nationalité française, l’autorité administrative ne peut se fonder ni sur l’existence d’une maladie ou d’un handicap ni, par suite, sur l’insuffisance des ressources de l’intéressé lorsqu’elle résulte directement d’une maladie ou d’un handicap.”
CAA Nantes, 24 June 2025, n° 24NT01547
This translates as: the administration may not refuse naturalisation based on the existence of an illness or disability, nor on the insufficiency of the applicant’s resources when that insufficiency results directly from an illness or disability. This is a significant protection for applicants whose reduced earning capacity stems from a medical condition, and it illustrates the outer limit of the administration’s pouvoir d’appréciation.
B. Criminal Record, Moral Character, and Identity Requirements
Under article 21-23 of the Code civil, “nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’est pas de bonnes vie et mœurs” (no one may be naturalised if they are not of good character). This moral condition is supplemented by article 21-27 of the Code civil, which bars naturalisation for anyone sentenced to a term of imprisonment of six months or more without a suspended sentence, or for crimes or offences constituting an attack on the fundamental interests of the Nation or an act of terrorism. Importantly, the article 21-27 bar is lifted if the applicant has obtained réhabilitation de plein droit (automatic rehabilitation) under article 133-12 of the Code pénal, or if the conviction has been excluded from bulletin no. 2 of the criminal record.
These provisions were applied in a decision of 9 April 2024 by the Nantes Administrative Court of Appeal. In CAA Nantes, 5e ch., 9 April 2024, n° 22NT03221, the court upheld the irreceivability of a naturalisation application lodged by an Algerian national who had been sentenced on three separate occasions — for complicity in fraud and receiving stolen goods, and twice for driving without a licence. The court found that despite the age of the offences, “de tels faits, dont la matérialité n’est pas contestée, étaient, eu égard à leur nature, à leur réitération et à leur gravité, propres à faire regarder l’intéressé comme n’étant pas, à la date de la décision contestée, de bonnes vie et mœurs”. The English-speaking reader should understand that repeated offences, even if old, can and will be held against an applicant if the court considers their nature and recurrence incompatible with the good character requirement.
Identity is an additional, and often overlooked, eligibility ground. In CAA Nantes, 2e ch., 3 May 2024, n° 22NT01624, the court reversed a first-instance judgment that had annulled a naturalisation refusal based on doubts about the applicant’s identity. The applicant — a recognised refugee — had produced an acte d’état civil (civil status document) issued by the Office français de protection des réfugiés et apatrides (OFPRA, the French Office for the Protection of Refugees and Stateless Persons) under article L. 721-3 of the Code de l’entrée et du séjour des étrangers et du droit d’asile (CESEDA), which stated a particular surname and date of birth. However, the applicant had herself sent letters to the prefecture and OFPRA seeking to correct that very surname and date of birth, before withdrawing the request to avoid interfering with her naturalisation procedure. The appeal court held that the Minister of the Interior had validly relied on the resulting doubt about the applicant’s identity to refuse the application. The practical lesson for English-speaking applicants is clear: any discrepancy in civil status — especially for refugees whose original documents may be unavailable — must be resolved before filing, not during the procedure.
II. The Procedure: Application Timeline, the Assimilation Interview, and Judicial Challenges
A. Filing the Application, the 18-Month Rule, and the Assimilation Interview
The application is filed at the préfecture (prefecture) of the applicant’s place of residence. The file must include a completed cerfa form (the standard administrative form), proof of identity, proof of residence, recent tax notices, and — for employed applicants — employment contracts and pay slips for the preceding months. The administration issues a récépissé (receipt) upon submission of a complete file. From that date, article 21-25-1 of the Code civil imposes a maximum processing period of eighteen months, reduced to twelve months for applicants who have habitually resided in France for at least ten years. These deadlines may be extended once, by a reasoned decision, for a further three months. If no decision is issued within the statutory period, the administration’s silence does not constitute an implicit acceptance: in naturalisation matters, silence on the part of the administration is deemed a rejection, and the applicant must then pursue the mandatory administrative appeal described below.
The centrepiece of the procedure is the entretien d’assimilation, a face-to-face interview conducted by a prefecture agent. Its legal basis lies in article 21-24 of the Code civil, which provides that “nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française, notamment par une connaissance suffisante, selon sa condition, de la langue, de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises” (no one may be naturalised unless they demonstrate assimilation into the French community, notably through sufficient knowledge — according to their condition — of the French language, history, culture, and society). The version of article 21-24 currently in force, applicable since 1 January 2026, further specifies that “l’intéressé justifie d’un niveau de langue lui permettant au moins de comprendre le contenu essentiel de sujets concrets ou abstraits dans un texte complexe, de communiquer avec spontanéité, de s’exprimer de façon claire et détaillée sur une grande variété de sujets”. This language requirement corresponds to what the administration considers to be a B1 level of the Cadre européen commun de référence pour les langues (Common European Framework of Reference for Languages).
The interview also covers history, civics, and the applicant’s understanding of the rights and duties of a French citizen. Article 37 of Decree no. 93-1362 of 30 December 1993 — the regulatory text that operationalises article 21-24 — specifies four domains that are tested: (a) the major historical reference points of France, (b) the principles, symbols, and institutions of the Republic, including laïcité (secularism), equality between men and women, and the organisation of political and administrative power, (c) the exercise of French citizenship, including the rights and duties listed in the charte des droits et devoirs du citoyen français (Charter of Rights and Duties of the French Citizen), which the applicant must sign at the end of the interview, and (d) the place of France in Europe and in the world, including elementary knowledge of the European Union.
Two decisions from the Nantes Administrative Court of Appeal illustrate how strictly these knowledge requirements are enforced. In CAA Nantes, 6e ch., 12 November 2025, n° 24NT02287, the court upheld the refusal of naturalisation for an Algerian national who had lived in France since June 1966 — nearly sixty years — because “les réponses apportées lors de l’entretien témoignaient d’une connaissance insuffisante des éléments fondamentaux relatifs aux règles de vie en société (principes, symboles et institution de la République) et aux principaux devoirs liés à l’exercice de la citoyenneté”. The interview report showed that the applicant had been unable to name the French motto, any symbols of the Republic, or to define the concepts of democracy and secularism. The court explicitly held that “la circonstance que la décision contestée ne mentionne pas le fait que M. A…, alors âgé de 74 ans et arrivé sur le territoire français au mois de juin 1966, à l’âge de 19 ans, est selon ses propres termes ‘parfaitement intégré concernant sa vie sociale, familiale et matérielle en France’ demeure sans incidence”. In other words, decades of material integration do not compensate for a failed assimilation interview: the civics component is independently assessed and failure on that ground alone justifies refusal.
In CAA Nantes, 6e ch., 14 October 2025, n° 24NT02223, the court confirmed the rejection of an application by a Ghanaian national who had held a carte de résident (ten-year residence card) valid until 2033 and had lived in France for more than thirty-five years. The interview report recorded that she could not name “les dates des deux guerres mondiales, le régime politique actuel de la France, l’institution qui vote les lois, le mode de désignation du président de la République, le nom des pays frontaliers de la France et le nombre de pays membres de l’Union européenne” (the dates of the two world wars, the current political regime of France, the institution that votes on laws, the method of designation of the President of the Republic, the names of France’s neighbouring countries, and the number of EU Member States). She also attributed the French Revolution to Charles de Gaulle. The court held that the Minister “a pu, eu égard au large pouvoir d’appréciation dont il dispose pour apprécier l’opportunité d’accorder la nationalité française au ressortissant étranger qui la sollicite, rejeter la demande de naturalisation”.
These two decisions, both rendered in the second half of 2025, confirm that the French administrative judge accords a wide margin of deference to the administration’s assessment of an applicant’s assimilation, and that the civics and history component of the interview is not a formality. For the English-speaking applicant preparing for naturalisation, thorough study of the livret du citoyen (Citizen’s Booklet) — available online and approved by ministerial order — is indispensable. Applicants who have completed a French-language higher education degree should also note that article 21-24, as amended, imposes a minimum language proficiency of B1 regardless of academic credentials; a degree taught in English will not, standing alone, satisfy this requirement.
B. The Two-Tier Challenge: Mandatory Administrative Appeal and Judicial Review
A naturalisation refusal — whether it takes the form of a rejet (outright rejection), an irrecevabilité (finding of inadmissibility), or an ajournement (postponement for a fixed period) — must be motivée (reasoned) under article 27 of the Code civil: “toute décision déclarant irrecevable, ajournant ou rejetant une demande d’acquisition, de naturalisation ou de réintégration par décret ainsi qu’une autorisation de perdre la nationalité française doit être motivée”. The decision must state both the legal basis and the factual considerations on which it rests.
The first procedural step is a recours administratif préalable obligatoire (mandatory prior administrative appeal) before the Minister of the Interior. This is provided for by article 45 of Decree no. 93-1362 of 30 December 1993: “dans les deux mois suivant leur notification, les décisions prises en application des articles (…) 44 peuvent faire l’objet d’un recours auprès du ministre chargé des naturalisations, à l’exclusion de tout autre recours administratif. Ce recours (…) constitue un préalable obligatoire à l’exercice d’un recours contentieux, à peine d’irrecevabilité de ce dernier” (within two months of their notification, decisions taken under articles […] 44 may be the subject of an appeal to the minister responsible for naturalisations, to the exclusion of any other administrative appeal. This appeal constitutes a mandatory prerequisite to the exercise of a contentious appeal, failing which the latter shall be inadmissible).
This rule was applied with full rigour in CAA Nantes, 6e ch., 28 January 2025, n° 24NT00526. The court recalled that “il résulte de ces dispositions que la décision du ministre de l’intérieur, saisi d’un tel recours préalable obligatoire, se substitue à celle initialement prise par le préfet” (it follows from these provisions that the decision of the Minister of the Interior, seized of such a mandatory prior appeal, substitutes itself for the one initially taken by the prefect). The practical consequence is critical: the applicant must lodge a written appeal with the Minister within two months of receiving the prefectural decision; if they file directly before the administrative court without having exhausted this prior administrative remedy, their judicial claim will be declared inadmissible. The Minister then has a period of four months to respond; silence beyond that period constitutes an implicit rejection, which opens the door to judicial review.
Once the administrative appeal has been exhausted — or deemed rejected by silence — the applicant may file a recours contentieux (judicial review application) before the tribunal administratif de Nantes. This court has exclusive territorial jurisdiction over naturalisation litigation, regardless of where the applicant resides. The application must be filed within two months of the notification of the Minister’s express decision, or within a reasonable period after the implicit rejection. The court exercises a contrôle restreint (limited review) over the administration’s appreciation of the applicant’s assimilation and overall suitability: it verifies the absence of erreur de droit (error of law), erreur de fait (error of fact), and erreur manifeste d’appréciation (manifest error of appreciation), but it does not substitute its own judgment for that of the administration.
The decision of 28 January 2025, n° 24NT00526, is also instructive on the distinction between rejection and ajournement. The applicant — an Afghan national — argued that the prefect should have postponed his application rather than reject it outright. The court dismissed this argument, holding that “le rejet de sa demande de naturalisation ne fait pas obstacle, contrairement à une décision d’ajournement, à ce que le postulant forme, sans délai, une nouvelle demande d’acquisition de la nationalité française”. The practical implication is that a rejection — though more severe in appearance than a postponement — actually allows the applicant to re-file immediately without waiting for a fixed period to elapse. This is a strategic consideration that English-speaking applicants and their counsel should weigh carefully when deciding whether to challenge a refusal or to submit a fresh application addressing the grounds for the initial rejection.
Conclusion
French naturalisation is a two-stage process that combines objective eligibility criteria with a discretionary assessment of the applicant’s assimilation into French society. The 2026 reform of article 21-24 has raised the language proficiency threshold to a defined B1 level, and the administrative courts have consistently upheld refusals based on insufficient knowledge of French history, civics, and republican values — even for applicants with decades of residence in France. At the same time, the courts enforce the procedural guarantees that protect applicants: the administration may not discriminate on the basis of disability when assessing professional integration (24NT01547), it must issue a reasoned decision (article 27 of the Code civil), and the applicant must be given the opportunity to exhaust the mandatory administrative appeal before the Minister of the Interior before any litigation can be initiated. For English-speaking applicants, the key takeaways are to prepare thoroughly for the assimilation interview using the livret du citoyen, to resolve any civil status discrepancies before filing, to secure a certificate of language proficiency at B1 level or higher, and — in the event of refusal — to act within the strict two-month deadline for the mandatory administrative appeal, without which no judicial review is possible.
For further guidance on residence permits and immigration procedures in France, see our dedicated page on immigration law services in Paris.