You won your case. An administrative court annulled the prefecture’s refusal and ordered it to issue your titre de séjour (residence permit) within a set deadline. Yet weeks or months later, no card has been delivered, your récépissé (provisional receipt) has expired, your employer has suspended your contract, and the prefecture’s only answer is that your file is “being processed”. For expatriates, foreign employees and investors in France, this situation is not hypothetical: in the summer of 2026, administrative courts are issuing more and more judgments that order the delivery of a residence permit, and prefectures are increasingly failing to execute them within the time limits imposed.
The case law has now caught up with the problem. On 19 February 2026, the emergency judge of the Conseil d’État (France’s supreme administrative court) issued an order, CE, juge des référés, 19/02/2026, n° 512245, that is widely considered a turning point: for the first time, the judge ordered, within the framework of a référé-liberté (emergency application to protect a fundamental freedom), not merely a re-examination of the file, but the actual delivery of the multi-year residence card, together with a provisional work authorisation within forty-eight hours. This article explains, in practical terms, what a court judgment ordering the delivery of a residence permit really requires, what tools exist to force the administration to execute it, and the strict conditions under which the 2026 rulings operate.
I. What a Court Judgment Ordering the Delivery of a Residence Permit Actually Requires
A. Annulment, Injunction and the Authority of Chose Jugée (Res Judicata)
When a tribunal administratif (administrative court) annuls a refusal of a residence permit, it does not stop at setting the decision aside. If the applicant asks for it, the court adds an injunction: it orders the prefect to take a specific measure — usually the delivery of the permit — within a fixed deadline. The legal basis is Article L. 911-4 of the Code of Administrative Justice (CJA), which states that “en cas d’inexécution d’un jugement ou d’un arrêt, la partie intéressée peut demander à la juridiction, une fois la décision rendue, d’en assurer l’exécution” (in case of failure to execute a judgment or a ruling, the interested party may ask the court that rendered the decision to ensure its execution). The same article gives the execution judge the power to define the measures to be taken, to set a deadline, and to attach an astreinte (periodic penalty payment) if the judgment did not already provide one.
A concrete example of what such an injunction looks like in immigration matters is the judgment of the tribunal administratif of Marseille of 18 December 2025 (n° 2504444-2509470-2512459), which lies at the origin of the Conseil d’État’s landmark order of 19 February 2026: the tribunal annulled two refusals of a carte de séjour pluriannuelle (multi-year residence card) bearing the mention “vie privée et familiale” (private and family life) and ordered the prefect of the Bouches-du-Rhône “de délivrer à celui-ci un titre de séjour mention « vie privée et familiale » valable deux ans” (to deliver to him a residence permit bearing the “private and family life” mention, valid for two years), within one month of notification. The judgment became final: no appeal was lodged.
The key point for the applicant is that a final judgment is binding, whatever the administration thinks of it. The administrative court of appeal of Paris made this explicit in CAA Paris, 04/06/2026, n° 25PA04038, a case in which a Congolese national, whose renewal of her carte de résident (ten-year resident card) had been ordered by a judgment of 7 November 2024, was instead handed a fresh refusal and a provisional document. The court ruled: “il appartenait au préfet, qui n’est pas intervenu en défense au cours de la procédure devant le tribunal et n’a pas interjeté appel de ce jugement devenu ainsi définitif, de délivrer une carte de résident à Mme B… dans le délai prescrit” (it was for the prefect, who had not appeared in the proceedings and had not appealed the judgment that had become final, to deliver the resident card within the prescribed deadline). The court added that, if the prefect believed there were new grounds for refusing, the lawful route was not to disobey the judgment but to issue the card and, if justified, later withdraw it. In other words: a new refusal letter issued after a final delivery order does not “replace” the judgment.
The same logic appears in CAA Paris, 30/06/2026, n° 25PA05940, where a Turkish cook had obtained, on 4 November 2025, the annulment of the refusal of his admission exceptionnelle au séjour (exceptional admission to residence) and an order to deliver a permit within one month. The prefect of the Val-de-Marne appealed the judgment and, in parallel, did nothing. The court of appeal rejected the prefect’s appeal on the merits and, in the execution phase, noted bluntly: “Le préfet du Val-de-Marne n’a cependant pas, à ce jour, exécuté ledit jugement” (the prefect of the Val-de-Marne has not, to date, executed the said judgment). The court then issued a fresh injunction — delivery within three months — with an astreinte of €50 per day of delay.
B. Provisional Documents Are Not Execution: Récépissé and Autorisation Provisoire de Séjour
A frequent source of confusion is the difference between a provisional document and actual execution of the judgment. French law gives every applicant who files a complete request the right to a récépissé: Article R. 431-12 of the CESEDA (Code of entry and residence of foreigners and of the right of asylum) provides that “l’étranger admis à souscrire une demande de délivrance ou de renouvellement de titre de séjour se voit remettre un récépissé qui autorise sa présence sur le territoire pour la durée qu’il précise” (a foreigner admitted to file an application for the issue or renewal of a residence permit receives a receipt authorising his presence in France for the period it specifies). Similarly, Article L. 431-3 of the CESEDA states that holding such a provisional document authorises presence in France without prejudging the final decision, and warns that, as a rule, “ces documents n’autorisent pas leurs titulaires à exercer une activité professionnelle” (these documents do not authorise their holders to engage in professional activity).
None of these provisional documents, however, amounts to execution of a judgment that ordered the delivery of a permit. The administrative court of appeal of Marseille applied this distinction strictly in CAA Marseille, 29/05/2026, n° 26MA01109. A tribunal had ordered the prefect of the Alpes-Maritimes to re-examine an application within two months and to issue, immediately and without delay, a récépissé. The prefect eventually delivered receipts covering the period from 12 August 2025 to 9 March 2026 — but never ruled on the application itself. The court annulled the first-instance order that had treated the matter as settled, holding that the late delivery of receipts “ne constitue qu’une mesure d’attente qui ne se substitue pas au réexamen de la demande de titre de séjour dont le préfet restait saisi” (is merely a holding measure that does not replace the re-examination of the residence permit application which remained pending before the prefect). Execution of a judgment means a substantive decision — favourable or unfavourable — on the permit requested, not a stream of provisional documents.
The Conseil d’État applied the same reasoning to autorisations provisoires de séjour (provisional residence authorisations, the “APS” delivered to persons under appeal or review) in CE, 05/06/2026, n° 511520. The case concerned a series of emergency orders of the Paris tribunal: suspension of an implied refusal, an order to re-examine the situation within one month, and the delivery of an APS. The prefect of police delivered successive APS valid from 6 August 2025 to 28 January 2026 but never re-examined the file, and the first-instance emergency judge took the view that the APS proved execution of the injunction. The Conseil d’État quashed that reasoning as an error of law: the mere fact that provisional authorisations had been delivered, “alors qu’il n’était pas contesté qu’il n’avait pas été statué sur sa demande de titre de séjour dans le délai imparti” (while it was undisputed that his residence permit application had not been decided within the imposed time limit), could not justify the conclusion that the injunction had been executed. The lesson is practical: if you hold an APS or a récépissé but the permit ordered by the judgment has still not been issued, the judgment has not been executed, whatever the prefecture claims.
II. The Two Routes to Force Execution
A. The Execution Judge: The Request Under Article L. 911-4, the Astreinte and Its Liquidation
The first route is the slow, thorough one: asking the court that rendered the decision to execute it. Under Article L. 911-4 of the CJA, the interested party may file a request with the tribunal or court that issued the judgment — or, if the judgment has been appealed, with the appellate court — asking it to take the measures required for execution. The request is filed in writing, and it does not require a lawyer in the first instance, although the procedure involves the court’s services and, in practice, professional assistance is strongly advisable. There is no strict time limit for filing it; the only practical rule is to act as soon as the deadline set by the judgment has passed.
What the applicant should ask for is precise. First, ask the court to define the measures of execution if the judgment did not already do so: the exact document to be delivered (for example, a two-year carte de séjour with the mention “vie privée et familiale”), and a new deadline. Second, ask for an astreinte — a fixed amount, commonly €50 to €150 per day of delay, payable to the State but imposed on the administration, which creates a real budgetary incentive to act. The case law of 2025-2026 shows this tool working in practice. In CAA Lyon, 02/10/2025, n° 25LY01037, the Lyon court of appeal, having found that the prefect of the Rhône had still not delivered the card one year after the initial injunction, ordered: “il y a lieu d’enjoindre à l’administration d’accorder à l’intéressé ce titre de séjour dans un délai d’un mois à compter de la notification du présent arrêt” (the administration must be ordered to grant the person concerned this residence permit within one month of notification of the present ruling), with an astreinte of €50 per day beyond that deadline. The same amount appears in the Paris cases described above — €50 per day in n° 25PA04038, and again in n° 25PA05940. These are no longer theoretical sanctions: in 2026, they are being imposed regularly against prefectures that fail to execute.
Third, and this is where the Conseil d’État’s June 2026 ruling matters, the applicant can ask the court to liquidate (quantify and collect) the astreinte that has already accrued. Article L. 911-7 of the CJA provides: “en cas d’inexécution totale ou partielle ou d’exécution tardive, la juridiction procède à la liquidation de l’astreinte qu’elle avait prononcée” (in case of total or partial failure to execute, or late execution, the court proceeds with the liquidation of the penalty payment it had imposed). The same article adds a protection for the applicant: “sauf s’il est établi que l’inexécution de la décision provient d’un cas fortuit ou de force majeure, la juridiction ne peut modifier le taux de l’astreinte définitive lors de sa liquidation” (unless it is established that the failure to execute results from a fortuitous event or force majeure, the court may not change the rate of a final penalty payment at the time of liquidation). The execution judge’s power is therefore limited: in CE, 05/06/2026, n° 511520, the Conseil d’État restated that the execution judge, when asked to liquidate a penalty payment, “n’a pas le pouvoir de remettre en cause les mesures décidées par le dispositif de la décision juridictionnelle dont l’exécution est demandée” (does not have the power to call into question the measures decided in the operative part of the judicial decision whose execution is sought).
The same ruling, however, shows the limits of the mechanism: the administration may escape liquidation if it proves that it adopted measures “au moins équivalentes” (at least equivalent) to those ordered. In that specific case, the prefect of police finally granted a one-year carte de séjour temporaire on 27 October 2025 — slightly late, but a substantive decision on the application — and the Conseil d’État concluded that the order had been executed and refused to liquidate the €100-per-day penalty. The message for applicants is twofold: the astreinte is a genuine pressure tool, but it is paid only where there is a real, continuing failure to execute; and the administration can neutralise it by finally delivering the document — even late.
Finally, the liquidation phase is not a free pass in the other direction either. In CAA Versailles, 09/07/2026, n° 23VE02076, a man whose carte de résident permanent (permanent resident card) had been ordered by a judgment of 19 February 2021 — under an astreinte of €50 per day — asked for the liquidation of the penalty. The Versailles court found that the card delivered was the only legally possible execution, because EU Regulation n° 2017/1954 had abolished the mention of unlimited validity on residence documents: the injunctions “ont donné lieu à la seule exécution légalement possible” (gave rise to the only legally possible execution), and the astreinte was therefore suppressed. The practical point: when you file an execution request, anticipate the administration’s arguments — it will claim that what it did was “equivalent” or “the only possible execution” — and be ready to show precisely what the operative part of the judgment required and what is missing.
B. The Référé-Liberté: The Conseil d’État’s Landmark Order of 19 February 2026 and Its Strict Limits
The second route is fast but demanding: the référé-liberté under Article L. 521-2 of the CJA. Under this provision, “le juge des référés peut ordonner toutes mesures nécessaires à la sauvegarde d’une liberté fondamentale à laquelle une personne morale de droit public ou un organisme de droit privé chargé de la gestion d’un service public aurait porté, dans l’exercice d’un de ses pouvoirs, une atteinte grave et manifestement illégale” (the emergency judge may order all measures necessary to safeguard a fundamental freedom to which a public entity would have caused, in the exercise of its powers, a serious and manifestly unlawful interference). The judge must rule within forty-eight hours. Two conditions must be met: urgency, and a serious, manifestly unlawful interference with a fundamental freedom.
For years, the accepted reading was that the référé-liberté could only order provisional measures, pending a decision on the merits. The order of 19 February 2026, CE, juge des référés, 19/02/2026, n° 512245, changed the practical reality of this tool in immigration cases. The applicant was a Moroccan national who had lived in France since the age of one, in a relationship with a French citizen, with two French children born in 2017 and 2018. Following the annulment of two refusals by the judgment of 18 December 2025 of the Marseille tribunal — which ordered the delivery of a two-year card within one month — the prefect’s only step was to ask for documents on 6 January 2026 with a view to issuing an APS. The APS expired on 27 January 2026. On 28 January, the applicant’s employer suspended his contract and his salary: he had become, in practice, without any document and without income.
The first-instance emergency judge rejected the application, considering that the request for documents showed sufficient diligence. The Conseil d’État overturned that reasoning. Point 5 of the order lists the facts that revealed the administration’s passivity: the simple request for documents, the failure to deliver an APS keeping the applicant lawful beyond 27 January 2026, and the failure to send a new card for production — which, the court held, “manifestaient une carence persistante dans l’exécution de la chose jugée par l’administration” (revealed a persistent failure in the execution of the res judicata by the administration). Point 6 draws the legal consequence: “cette situation porte une atteinte grave et manifestement illégale à l’exercice par M. A… des droits et libertés reconnues aux étrangers en situation régulière, notamment le droit au travail” (this situation constitutes a serious and manifestly unlawful interference with Mr A.’s exercise of the rights and freedoms recognised to foreigners in a lawful situation, in particular the right to work). The operative part is the landmark: the State was ordered to deliver an APS authorising work within forty-eight hours, and the actual two-year card within one month — an injunction of delivery, not merely a re-examination. The court noted that the card had still not been handed over even though production had been launched on 9 February 2026, during the proceedings.
What are the practical lessons of this order? First, the trigger: the applicant’s irregularity was caused by the administration itself — the APS expired while the judgment’s deadline was running, and no provisional document was renewed. If you can show that the non-execution has pushed you into irregularity and that you have lost, or risk losing, your job and your income, the conditions of the référé-liberté can be met. Second, the scope: the judge ordered both the provisional measure (the APS with the right to work, within 48 hours) and the definitive measure (the card, within one month). Third, the evidentiary work: the order shows how the Conseil d’État weighed the chronology — the request for documents (6 January), the delivery of documents (8 January), the expiry of the APS (27 January), the suspension of the contract (28 January) — and how each step was documented. Keep copies of every exchange with the prefecture, every APS, every email from your employer.
The same strictness that made this order possible also defines its limits. The référé-liberté is not a full appeal against an OQTF (order to leave French territory) or a refusal; it only catches serious and manifestly unlawful interference with a fundamental freedom. The emergency judge of the Conseil d’État recalled this on 5 August 2026 in CE, juge des référés, 05/08/2026, n° 518408: a young Comorian woman, born in Mayotte and holding no valid document since January 2026, challenged an OQTF with a one-year re-entry ban, invoking her schooling and her family ties. The judge rejected the application, observing in particular that she had not established the reality of the private and family life she alleged, and recalled that a claim of stereotyped reasoning of the measure “n’invoque pas, par ce seul moyen, une atteinte grave et manifestement illégale à une liberté fondamentale” (does not, by that ground alone, invoke a serious and manifestly unlawful interference with a fundamental freedom). Two lessons follow. First, the judge assesses the substance: family ties, employment, insertion must be proven, not alleged. Second, a mere illegality — even a plausible one — is not enough: the interference must be serious and manifest. The référé-liberté is a precision instrument, and it works best when the right is clear (as it was in n° 512245, where the judgment had already ordered delivery) and the harm is concrete (loss of employment and income).
Conclusion
Winning a judgment is only half of the battle; the other half is executing it. The 2026 case law has made the toolkit both sharper and more reliable. If the prefecture does not deliver the permit ordered by a final judgment within the imposed deadline: first, send a written reminder to the prefecture, referring to the judgment and its deadline, and keep proof of receipt; second, file an execution request with the court that rendered the judgment under Article L. 911-4 of the CJA, asking for a new deadline and an astreinte — and, if one was already ordered, ask for its liquidation under Article L. 911-7; third, if the failure pushes you into irregularity and threatens your job or your income, consider the référé-liberté under Article L. 521-2, following the model of the Conseil d’État’s order of 19 February 2026: document the chronology, prove that the administration’s passivity caused the harm, and request both a provisional document with the right to work and the delivery of the card. Keep in mind, finally, the limits: provisional documents are not execution, the astreinte is collected only where the failure is real and continuing, and the emergency judge sanctions only serious and manifestly unlawful interferences. Every case rests on its facts and its evidence; a law firm experienced in administrative litigation can help you assess which route fits your situation — see our immigration law practice in Paris for an overview of the services we provide in this area.