Washington’s latest sanctions against International Criminal Court officials have created a question that is narrower, and more practical, than the political dispute itself: what do the Rome Statute’s privileges and immunities protect when the affected work, lawyer, bank account or document is in France? France’s foreign ministry has condemned the new measures as an attack on the Court and its independence. The United States applies its own sanctions framework, administered through OFAC. Neither statement answers whether a French bank must freeze a payment, whether a French lawyer may continue representing victims, or whether an ICC document can be seized. Those answers begin with Article 48 of the Rome Statute and the Agreement on Privileges and Immunities of the ICC, published in France by Decree No. 2004-707. This is a distinct follow-up to the broader French analysis of the U.S. ICC sanctions and to the separate analysis of the EU Blocking Statute. The focus here is treaty scope, French effect and the file-by-file procedure that an international criminal practice should use before it moves money, transmits evidence or accepts a bank’s refusal.
I. What do Rome Statute privileges mean in France after new U.S. ICC sanctions?
A. Does Article 48 create a French immunity for the ICC and its officials?
The news must first be separated from the legal question. The United States’ ICC-related sanctions programme is built on U.S. executive and statutory authorities, including Executive Order 14203, the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, the National Emergencies Act and 31 CFR Part 528. It can restrict U.S. persons, property within U.S. jurisdiction and transactions with a U.S. nexus. The programme also contains a licensing architecture. A U.S. designation can therefore disrupt a French file even when no French authority has issued a freeze: the payment may pass through a U.S. correspondent, the bank may have U.S. operations, the client may need a U.S. grant or the relevant software and platform may be controlled from the United States.
That practical reach does not change the identity of the French legal instrument. France’s public position is found in the 20 August 2026 statement of the Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs, which condemned the new U.S. measures against the ICC President and a member of the Office of the Prosecutor. A diplomatic condemnation is not itself an injunction to a bank, and a U.S. designation is not automatically a French ministerial decision or a European Union restrictive measure. The treaty analysis must therefore run in parallel with the sanctions analysis.
France authorised ratification of the Rome Statute through Law No. 2000-282 of 30 March 2000. The Statute was published through Decree No. 2002-925 of 6 June 2002. Article 48 is consequently not a political declaration that France may choose to honour when convenient. It is a treaty provision published in the French official legal order, subject to its wording, the other provisions of the Statute and the Agreement that gives operational detail to the protection.
The official French text of Article 48 begins with a deliberately functional formula: La Cour jouit sur le territoire des Etats Parties des privilèges et immunités nécessaires à l’accomplissement de sa mission.
That sentence protects the Court as an international institution on the territory of States Parties. It does not say that every person who has ever communicated with the Court is immune from every law. It also does not make a personal U.S. designation disappear. The legal task is to identify the protected subject, the protected act and the protected forum.
Article 48 then differentiates several groups. Judges, the Prosecutor, deputy prosecutors and the Registrar receive, in the exercise of their functions or in relation to those functions, the privileges and immunities granted to heads of diplomatic missions. After their mandates, they retain immunity for words, writings and acts that fall within their official functions. The Deputy Registrar, the staff of the Office of the Prosecutor and Registry staff receive the protections necessary for their work under the Agreement. Counsel, experts, witnesses and other persons whose presence is required at the Court receive the treatment necessary for the Court’s proper functioning under that Agreement. The categories are not interchangeable, and the source of the protection matters when a bank or public authority asks for proof.
The Agreement published by the annex to Decree No. 2004-707 makes the institutional point even clearer. Article 3 states: La Cour jouit sur le territoire des Etats Parties des privilèges et immunités nécessaires à l’accomplissement de sa mission.
Article 6 adds a specific protection for the Court and its property, funds and assets. The operative text provides: La Cour et ses biens, fonds et avoirs, où qu’ils se trouvent et quel qu’en soit le détenteur, jouissent d’une immunité de juridiction absolue
, subject to an express waiver in a particular case and with the treaty’s limits on execution. It also protects those assets from search, seizure, requisition, confiscation, expropriation and other interference resulting from an administrative, judicial, legislative or enforcement decision.
This distinction is central. A French authority cannot treat an ICC asset as an ordinary private asset merely because a foreign government has announced a sanctions policy. A bank holding funds for the Court must identify the capacity in which it holds them and the legal act it is applying. At the same time, Article 6 is an institutional immunity. It does not convert the personal bank account of an ICC official into the Court’s property, and it does not protect a payment made to a person who is separately designated. An account labelled “ICC” is not enough. Ownership, control, purpose and mandate must be documented.
Article 15 of the Agreement addresses judges, the Prosecutor, deputy prosecutors and the Registrar. Its French text provides: Les juges, le Procureur, les procureurs adjoints et le Greffier jouissent, dans l’exercice de leurs fonctions au service de la Cour et du fait de celles-ci, des privilèges et immunités accordés aux chefs de missions diplomatiques.
That protection is stronger than an ordinary professional privilege, but it remains linked to the office and the treaty’s design. Article 16 uses a different formulation for the Deputy Registrar and staff, granting the immunities and facilities necessary for independent performance. Article 18 protects counsel, including during travel for their service, when the required certificate has been produced.
The French Court of cassation’s recent international-immunity jurisprudence helps explain the structure, even though it concerns a foreign head of State rather than an ICC employee. In Assembly Plenary judgment No. 24-84.393 of 25 July 2025, the Court stated: L’immunité pénale de juridiction procède de l’égalité souveraine des États.
It immediately distinguished the national and international planes: Le principe de l’immunité ne peut être opposé devant les juridictions internationales, dont les statuts écartent expressément toute immunité
. The case is not a shortcut to declare that every ICC official is immune from U.S. restrictions. Its value is methodological: immunity is a procedural allocation of jurisdiction, and the governing international instrument must be read before a national actor assumes that a foreign measure controls the file.
Article 48 also contains a waiver mechanism. The privileges and immunities may be lifted for a judge or the Prosecutor by an absolute majority of the judges, for the Registrar by the Presidency, for deputy prosecutors and Office of the Prosecutor staff by the Prosecutor, and for Registry staff by the Registrar. A bank, a French lawyer or a national prosecutor cannot invent a waiver, and an individual employee cannot waive an institutional immunity that belongs to the Court. Any request should be addressed to the competent ICC organ and retained with the file. A request for cooperation is not the same thing as a waiver of immunity.
The treaty also protects communications and records. Article 7 of the Agreement states that the Court’s archives, papers, documents and materials are inviolable wherever they are and whoever holds them. Article 11 protects official communications and correspondence from censorship. Those provisions do not make every document held by a French lawyer an ICC archive. They do mean that a request for evidence should identify whether the material belongs to the Court, was sent by the Court, is held under a Court mandate or is the lawyer’s own work product. That classification can determine whether the response is a routine production, a request to the Registry or a challenge to the legal basis of an attempted seizure.
The treaty therefore does not answer the headline question with a simple “yes” or “no”. It gives the Court, its property, its officials and procedural participants a layered protection in France. It does not immunise every commercial transaction related to the ICC, does not stop a U.S. bank from applying U.S. law within its own jurisdiction and does not displace a valid French or European freeze. It does require a French authority or financial institution to identify the treaty subject and the legal source before it interferes with the Court’s mission.
B. Does a U.S. listing automatically freeze an ICC-related payment in France?
The answer under French law begins with the scope of the French freeze system. Article L. 562-4 of the Code monétaire et financier lists the persons required to apply the measures of freezing and the prohibitions on making funds or economic resources available. The official provision says: Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre
. It then defines the natural persons and legal persons concerned, including French entities and certain activities carried out in France or abroad. The statutory duty is tied to measures within the French legal framework and to the European acts identified by the provision.
Article L. 562-5 supplies the corresponding prohibition: Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel
. The important words are “font l’objet d’une mesure de gel” under the French provisions identified in the article. A foreign list may create a serious bank-compliance question, but it is not, without more, the legal event that activates every French prohibition.
Publication is also part of the French system. Article L. 562-9 provides that specified ministerial decisions are published by extract in the Journal officiel and become enforceable from publication. In a live file, counsel should therefore request the exact designation or decision, the identifier used by the bank, the date it became enforceable, the person or entity named, and the funds or resources covered. “U.S. sanctions” is a description of a foreign policy. “Article L. 562-3 decision published on [date], naming [identifier]” is a French legal basis capable of being tested.
There is a separate question about disclosure of documents to a foreign authority. Article 1 of Law No. 68-678 of 26 July 1968 begins: Sous réserve des traités ou accords internationaux, il est interdit à toute personne physique de nationalité française ou résidant habituellement sur le territoire français
to communicate to foreign public authorities certain economic, commercial, industrial, financial or technical documents or information whose communication could harm French sovereignty, security, essential economic interests or public order. The provision is not a general refusal power for ICC work, and it is not a substitute for professional secrecy. It is a reason to identify the request, the treaty channel and the nature of the information before a French practice sends a file to a foreign public authority.
Article 86 of the Rome Statute supplies the other side of that analysis. The exact French text says: Conformément aux dispositions du présent Statut, les Etats Parties coopèrent pleinement avec la Cour dans les enquêtes et poursuites qu’elle mène pour les crimes relevant de sa compétence.
Article 87 permits requests through diplomatic channels and, where appropriate, through Interpol or a competent regional organisation. It also requires confidentiality of requests and supporting documents, subject to disclosure necessary to execute the request. These obligations explain why a French lawyer should not equate “foreign request” with “unlawful request”; they also explain why a U.S. sanctions notice cannot silently rewrite the Court’s treaty-based cooperation channel.
For a French bank, the operational risk lies in the overlap between the two systems. A bank may be subject to French freezing rules, EU restrictive measures, U.S. secondary-risk decisions, contractual risk rules and its own internal escalation policy. Those sources can point in different directions. A payment can be lawful in France but refused by a correspondent that will not accept a U.S. nexus. Conversely, a bank cannot describe a French freeze as optional merely because the client invokes Article 48. The proper response is to separate the legal bases, not to collapse them into a single word such as “sanctions”.
The first practical question is therefore whether the payment is to, from or for a protected subject. A payment to the ICC itself, a payment to an ICC official, a legal fee paid by a victims’ organisation and reimbursement of an expert’s travel expenses may all use the same bank but have different treaty and sanctions profiles. The second question is whether the payment is a transfer of funds or economic resources to a designated person. The third is whether a U.S. person, U.S. financial institution, U.S. software provider or U.S. dollar clearing route is involved. The fourth is whether a French or EU measure has been adopted and published. Until all four questions are answered, the firm should not tell a client that the payment is either clearly prohibited or clearly safe.
This is why the U.S. designation can have immediate commercial effect without automatic French legal effect. A bank may pause an outgoing payment to avoid its U.S. exposure. That pause may be a risk decision, not execution of a French freeze. A client may have a contractual claim or an urgent remedy, but the remedy depends on the bank’s status, the terms of the account, the reason given and the existence of a public-law measure. The record should preserve the bank’s actual words. A later tribunal must be able to distinguish a temporary compliance review from a legal seizure or a termination based on a misidentified French prohibition.
The strongest reading of Article 48 is therefore neither maximalist nor empty. It prevents French actors from treating the ICC’s mission, assets and protected procedural participants as ordinary targets of foreign pressure without analysing the treaty. It does not require a French bank to ignore a U.S. rule that binds the bank in the United States, and it does not permit a client to hide a payment behind the Court’s name. The controlling document remains the combination of the treaty category, the transaction, the applicable national or European measure and the payment route.
II. What should French counsel do when a bank or authority relies on the U.S. ICC sanctions?
A. What evidence should a French practice assemble before moving money or documents?
The first step is to build a subject-and-capacity table, not to send an argumentative email. The table should name the Court, the ICC organ, the official, the victims’ organisation, the law firm, the payer, the payee, every account, every intermediary bank and every service provider. It should state whether each participant is a State organ, an international organisation, a natural person, a legal person, counsel, an expert, a witness or a client. It should also record the mandate, the period of work and the exact purpose of the payment or document transfer. This is the factual foundation for Article 48 and the Agreement. Without it, a bank cannot tell an institutional asset from a personal asset, and counsel cannot tell representation from a transfer to a designated individual.
For counsel, the most important document may be the certificate issued under Article 18 of the Agreement. The official text says that counsel’s protections apply sous réserve de la production du certificat visé au paragraphe 2 du présent article
. It then requires a certificate signed by the Registrar for the period necessary to perform the functions. The firm should retain the certificate, the appointment or mandate, the relevant Court filing and the dates of travel or work. If the power or mandate ended early, the certificate is withdrawn under the same provision. A firm should not rely on a historical Court connection where the current mandate cannot be shown.
The file should then map the payment. Record the currency, origin, destination, intermediary, bank branch, beneficial owner, invoice description, client-money status and any U.S. touchpoint. A U.S. dollar route is not the only U.S. nexus, and a euro route is not proof of its absence. The firm should ask the bank which name, identifier, legal rule or screening result caused the alert. If the bank will not disclose its internal scoring, it should at least identify whether it is executing a French or European freeze, applying U.S. law because of a correspondent relationship, or exercising a contractual risk policy. The firm can answer different questions only after the bank states which question it is asking.
Document requests require the same discipline. A request from the ICC under Article 87 is not the same as a request from a foreign executive agency. The Rome Statute states that requests and supporting documents must be treated confidentially, except to the extent disclosure is necessary to give effect to the request. It also provides that a request may be transmitted through diplomatic channels or, where appropriate, Interpol. A French practice should ask for the requesting authority, the treaty or statutory channel, the scope of the request, the language requirement, the confidentiality direction and the document classification. The answer should be limited to what is necessary and should preserve professional secrecy and defence strategy where those protections apply.
Law No. 68-678 reinforces the need to resist informal disclosure. Its Article 1 concerns communication to foreign public authorities of certain information that may harm French sovereignty, security, essential economic interests or public order. The qualification is fact-sensitive, and the statute itself is subject to international treaties and agreements. A client who receives an email asking for the ICC file should not forward it to a U.S. investigator simply because the investigator uses an official address. Counsel should first identify the authority, check the applicable cooperation instrument and decide whether the request should pass through the Court, a French authority or another treaty channel.
The French Court of cassation has shown why an immunity argument must be raised at the correct procedural moment. In Criminal Chamber judgment No. 22-82.235 of 1 February 2023, concerning a special seizure in an investigation into international crimes, the Court held: la chambre de l’instruction … est tenue … d’examiner les éléments soumis par l’intéressé qui invoque l’immunité pénale liée aux fonctions qu’il occupait à la date des faits
. It added that the claimed immunity, if established, could deprive the French court of universal jurisdiction and end the investigation. The facts are not the same as a bank refusal, but the procedural lesson travels: an immunity claim must be documented and placed before the decision-maker whose jurisdiction is affected.
The firm should therefore prepare two separate submissions. The first is a short bank memorandum: who is paid, why, from which source, through which route, under which French, EU and U.S. legal bases, with which document proving the mandate. The second is a confidential legal memorandum: the treaty category, the scope of immunity, the possible waiver, professional secrecy, the client’s instructions and any litigation or regulatory route. Sending the entire second memorandum to a bank can damage the file. Sending only a vague assertion of “ICC immunity” can leave the bank with no verifiable basis. A controlled disclosure that provides the minimum necessary evidence is safer than either extreme.
Where the Court itself is the owner or beneficiary, the file should identify the Agreement’s institutional protections. Article 6 protects the Court’s property, funds and assets from seizure and other interference, while Article 7 protects its archives and documents. The bank or authority should be asked to explain why it believes the asset is personal, why Article 6 does not apply and whether it has contacted the Court or the relevant French authority. Where the asset belongs to a lawyer, a client or a victims’ association, Article 6 cannot simply be copied into the answer. That is the difference between a serious treaty analysis and a label attached to every account.
Finally, the firm should create an escalation clock. Day one should record the bank notice, account status and payment deadline. Within the first working day, counsel should identify the legal basis and the U.S. nexus. The next step should be a request for a hold that preserves the funds without destroying the relationship, coupled with a written request for the documents supporting the alert. If the bank relies on a French or EU freeze, the firm should identify the publication and the available derogation or release procedure. If the bank relies only on U.S. exposure, the file may require U.S. sanctions advice or a compliant alternative route, but the firm should not represent that a French release will solve the U.S. problem.
B. Can France protect ICC work without confusing treaty immunity with a payment licence?
France can protect the ICC’s treaty position through the law that already applies to the Court, its officials and the French financial system. That protection is not the same as a general payment licence. Article 48 and the Agreement prevent interference with the Court’s mission and define the status of protected officials and participants. The Code monétaire et financier identifies when French freezing duties arise. Law No. 68-678 controls certain disclosures to foreign authorities. A bank, a lawyer and a ministry should each apply the instrument that governs its act, while recording any conflict between instruments.
The distinction is especially important when the U.S. measure targets a person who performs an official ICC function. Article 15 protects judges, the Prosecutor, deputy prosecutors and the Registrar for official work. It does not mean that France must provide private banking services without conditions, and it does not erase a U.S. restriction that binds a U.S. person. It does mean that a French authority should not treat an official act as a private commercial act without analysing the treaty. The same reasoning applies to counsel under Article 18, experts under Article 21 and witnesses under Article 19, but the documents proving each status are different.
Article 119 of the Rome Statute supplies a treaty-level route for disputes about interpretation and application. Its first paragraph says: Tout différend relatif aux fonctions judiciaires de la Cour est réglé par décision de la Cour.
For other disputes between States Parties that cannot be resolved through negotiations, the matter goes to the Assembly of States Parties, which may recommend another means of settlement, including referral to the International Court of Justice. Article 119 is not a fast-track injunction for a private account, but it confirms that a national bank should not decide the meaning of the Court’s treaty immunities by itself. The bank can pause and escalate; it cannot rewrite the treaty.
The recent French jurisprudence on international immunity also cautions against treating a treaty question as a slogan. In Assembly Plenary judgment No. 24-84.071 of 25 July 2025, the Court first said that La question de la compétence de la juridiction est préalable à celle de l’immunité.
It later framed the outcome subject to sous réserve des stipulations des conventions internationales, notamment celles relatives aux relations diplomatiques et consulaires
. The judgment concerned functional immunity and international crimes, not the ICC sanctions programme. Its relevance is the sequence of analysis: identify the forum, identify the international rule, then decide whether the national procedure may continue. That sequence is directly useful when a French authority considers seizing a document or imposing a measure that affects Court work.
A public authority’s inaction or interference may also raise an urgent French remedy, but the route must be selected carefully. Article L. 521-2 of the Code de justice administrative authorises the référé judge, where urgency is justified, to order measures necessary to safeguard a fundamental freedom against a serious and manifestly unlawful interference by a public-law person or a private body managing a public service. The official text says the judge rules within forty-eight hours. That procedure is not a universal remedy against a private bank’s commercial decision. The bank’s legal status, the public measure, the freedom invoked and the evidence of urgency must all be established before counsel promises a particular result.
A French or European freeze also cannot be evaded in the name of the Court. Article L. 562-5 prohibits direct or indirect provision of funds or economic resources to a person whose assets are subject to a measure of freezing. Article L. 562-8 permits certain measures to be recorded against property connected with frozen assets. The correct response to a genuine freeze is to identify the authority competent to authorise release, an applicable humanitarian or legal-fee exception, or a derogation under the instrument. It is not to put the money in a personal account, change the invoice, call the payment a “donation” or use a nominee. Such conduct may make the evidential and regulatory position worse.
Nor should treaty immunity be used to hide ordinary client-money problems. A French firm acting for ICC victims still needs a reliable client identity, a source-of-funds record, a written engagement, a conflict check and an account structure that distinguishes fees from funds held for a client. The international nature of the case increases the need for those records. If a bank asks why a transfer is connected with the Court, the answer can describe the mandate and the payment purpose without disclosing witness names or litigation strategy. The firm should be able to show that it is providing legal services and not transferring funds to a designated official.
There is also a diplomatic channel. France may raise the issue with its partners, the ICC and European institutions, and the ICC may seek clarification, a waiver or a procedural accommodation under its own rules. Those steps may reduce operational risk, but they do not replace the French legal analysis of a particular account. A political statement can support an argument about institutional independence. It cannot establish the ownership of a bank balance, prove that a person is covered by Article 15 or demonstrate that a U.S. licence applies to a transaction.
For banks, the defensible policy is a reasoned hold rather than an unexplained permanent refusal. The bank should identify the screening match, check whether the name and identifiers are exact, determine whether the account or payment is actually within the applicable measure, distinguish the Court from an individual and give the customer a channel for supplying evidence. For counsel, the defensible answer is a concise legal pack: treaty status, mandate, payment map, U.S. nexus, French and EU screening result, requested action and confidentiality limits. For public authorities, the defensible approach is to record why the treaty does or does not apply and to communicate with the ICC where institutional property or archives are concerned.
The result is not an abstract compromise. It can keep legitimate ICC work moving. A victims’ lawyer can continue a mandate when the client, service and payment are lawful in France, even though the file must be screened against U.S. exposure. The Court’s property and official records can receive stronger treaty protection than a private account. A bank can refuse a transaction that it cannot lawfully process, but it should not attribute a foreign listing to French law without identifying the domestic or European instrument. A French authority can enforce a real freeze, but it must respect the Court’s published privileges and immunities and give the affected party a procedurally intelligible decision.
The practical test is simple to state and demanding to evidence: who is protected, by which treaty provision, for what act, in which country, through which account or document, against which legal measure? Article 48 answers only part of that question. The Agreement answers more. French financial law, the 1968 disclosure statute and the facts of the payment answer the rest. That is how France can defend the ICC’s independence without turning treaty immunity into a blanket exemption from every sanctions rule.
Conclusion
New U.S. sanctions against ICC officials do not automatically create a French asset freeze, cancel a French lawyer’s mandate or authorise a French authority to seize the Court’s property. Article 48 of the Rome Statute and the Agreement published by Decree No. 2004-707 protect the Court’s mission, its property, official communications and defined categories of judges, prosecutors, staff, counsel, witnesses and experts. The protection is functional and institutional. It must be matched to the actual person, act, document and asset.
The immediate response to a bank refusal or foreign request is a documented matrix: treaty status, mandate, ownership, payment route, French and EU measures, U.S. nexus, confidentiality and remedy. A French or European freeze must be obeyed or challenged through the applicable process. A U.S. restriction must be analysed through its own legal and licensing framework. A French bank should identify which rule it is applying, and counsel should preserve the evidence without disguising a payment or disclosing the protected merits of the case.