KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
What Happens to a U.S. HSA When an American Moves to France? Reporting, Medical Withdrawals, and Tax Risks

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, employment lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

What Happens to a U.S. HSA When an American Moves to France? Reporting, Medical Withdrawals, and Tax Risks

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

For an American moving to France, a U.S. Health Savings Account (HSA) can look deceptively simple: money was contributed under U.S. rules, the account can pay medical bills, and qualified medical withdrawals may be tax-free in the United States. France does not automatically import that result. The French analysis starts with tax residence, then separates the account itself, contributions, investment income, medical reimbursements, nonqualified withdrawals, and any account closure. Each event can require different evidence and can be treated differently under French domestic law and the France–United States income-tax treaty.

This article is for an American who is, or may become, a French tax resident. It explains what an HSA is, why it should not casually be labeled a French retirement plan, how foreign-account reporting may arise, and how to prepare for a withdrawal used for healthcare in France. It does not give a blanket answer that every HSA balance or every withdrawal is taxable in France. The decisive facts include the custodian’s legal status, the investments held, the date of each contribution and withdrawal, the medical expense, the U.S. tax form issued, and the person’s treaty residence. The safest approach is to build an event-by-event file before the first French return or large transfer.

For the broader residence and retirement context, see our guide to retiring in France as an American. The present guide narrows the question to the HSA, its French reporting risk, and the evidence needed when American and French tax systems do not use the same legal categories.

I. What is a U.S. HSA in French tax terms?

A. What does an HSA do under U.S. law, and does the France–U.S. treaty protect it?

A Health Savings Account is a U.S. tax-advantaged account generally connected to eligibility under a high-deductible health plan, often called an HDHP. The account may receive contributions from an individual or an employer, may hold cash or permitted investments, and may be used to pay qualified medical expenses. The account is not the same thing as the health-insurance policy: the HDHP concerns insurance eligibility, while the HSA is the savings or custodial account that holds the funds. An American can therefore have an HSA that remains open after employment ends or after the person stops making new contributions.

The U.S. rules should be documented from an official source rather than inferred from a bank statement. The IRS explains in Publication 969, Health Savings Accounts and Other Tax-Favored Health Plans that an HSA is a tax-exempt trust or custodial account established to pay or reimburse qualified medical expenses. The same publication distinguishes qualified medical distributions from other distributions and explains the U.S. information forms used by an HSA trustee or custodian. Those U.S. labels are relevant evidence, but they do not turn the account into a French tax wrapper.

France has no general domestic category that automatically mirrors every feature of a U.S. HSA. An HSA should not be presented as a French plan d’épargne retraite (PER), a French retirement savings plan, merely because the money can remain invested for years. It is also not automatically a French assurance-vie, a life-insurance investment contract, or a plan d’épargne en actions (PEA), the French equity savings wrapper. Those French products have their own statutory conditions, reporting rules, and tax treatment. Calling an HSA by one of those names without analyzing its legal documents can create the wrong filing position.

The France–U.S. treaty must be read with the same discipline. Article 18 of the official English treaty refers to pensions and other similar remuneration, including distributions from pension and other retirement arrangements. The treaty text is available from the IRS copy of the France–United States income-tax treaty, and the official French version is available in the French tax administration’s treaty publication. The protocol’s list of U.S. arrangements generally corresponding to French pension arrangements includes retirement plans and individual retirement arrangements. It does not expressly identify an HSA.

That omission does not by itself answer every HSA question. It does, however, prevent a taxpayer from assuming that Article 18 automatically gives an HSA the treaty treatment of a 401(k) or an individual retirement account. A 401(k) is designed as a retirement arrangement; an HSA is designed to pay or reimburse healthcare costs and may also hold investments. The legal classification of an HSA distribution therefore requires a careful comparison of the payment, the account documents, the U.S. tax treatment, and the relevant French rule. An HSA balance should not be described to the French administration as “pension income” simply because a U.S. custodian uses the word tax-advantaged.

The first domestic question is whether France is the taxpayer’s tax residence. Article 4 A of the French General Tax Code, or Code général des impôts (CGI), states: Les personnes qui ont en France leur domicile fiscal sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu en raison de l’ensemble de leurs revenus. The official text is found at Article 4 A of the CGI. In plain English, French tax residence can bring worldwide income into the French income-tax analysis; it is not limited to money paid by a French bank.

Article 4 B provides the domestic residence tests. It identifies, among other factors, a person’s home or principal place of stay, regular professional activity, and center of economic interests. The current text begins: Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A. See Article 4 B of the CGI. The familiar 183-day idea is not a universal safe harbor. A person may become French-resident because of the overall facts even without a simple 183-day calculation, and a treaty tie-breaker may still be needed if both countries claim residence.

For treaty purposes, Article 4 of the France–U.S. treaty examines the permanent home, the closer personal and economic relations, the habitual abode, nationality, and, if necessary, an agreement between the competent authorities. An American should assemble arrival and departure dates, leases or property records, family location, work arrangements, insurance, bank activity, and the place where economic decisions are made. The HSA cannot be analyzed in isolation from that residence chronology.

B. What can France examine: contributions, earnings, account value, and foreign-account reporting?

French tax law does not generally treat the label on a foreign account as the taxable event. Article 12 of the CGI states: L’impôt est dû chaque année à raison des bénéfices ou revenus que le contribuable réalise ou dont il dispose au cours de la même année. The official text appears at Article 12 of the CGI. That rule directs attention to what was realized or made available during the year, rather than automatically taxing the entire historical balance when an American moves to France.

Article 13 adds that taxable income is made up of gross proceeds, including benefits in kind, after expenses incurred to acquire and preserve the income. Its opening wording is: Le bénéfice ou revenu imposable est constitué par l’excédent du produit brut. See the official Article 13 of the CGI. For an HSA, that means the French file should identify interest, dividends, distributions, sales, fees, and withdrawals separately. A contribution is not the same event as investment income, and a transfer between HSA investments is not automatically the same event as a distribution to the account holder.

The broader calculation rules matter too. Article 156 provides that French income tax is established from the total annual net income available to the tax household; the official provision is at Article 156 of the CGI. Article 158 states that the net income categories are assessed without distinguishing whether the income has its source in France or outside France, as shown in the official Article 158 of the CGI. These provisions explain why a French-resident American must review the U.S. account even when no money was transferred to a French bank account.

The account balance itself still needs to be described correctly. A cash balance that existed before French residence is not the same as a dividend paid after French residence. An investment gain that has not been realized is not automatically identical to a distribution. A withdrawal that merely reimburses a documented medical expense may raise a different question from a withdrawal of accumulated earnings for a personal purchase. The taxpayer should preserve the custodian’s transaction history rather than reporting a single annual number called “HSA income.”

Foreign-account reporting is a separate obligation from income tax. Article 1649 A of the CGI requires French-domiciled individuals and certain entities to declare the references of accounts opened, held, used, or closed abroad. The official text states that taxpayers are tenues de déclarer, en même temps que leur déclaration de revenus ou de résultats, les références des comptes ouverts, détenus, utilisés ou clos à l’étranger. Consult Article 1649 A of the CGI and the French tax administration’s practical page, How to declare accounts and life-insurance contracts held abroad.

Whether a particular HSA must be reported on Form 3916 or Form 3916-bis depends on the legal nature of the account and its custodian. The French administration’s guidance discusses bank accounts, investment accounts, and other foreign arrangements, but an HSA can sit at the boundary between a medical-benefit trust, a custodial account, and an investment platform. The absence of an HSA-specific box is not permission to ignore it. The correct step is to identify the institution, account agreement, account number, opening and closing dates, and available reporting form, then obtain a written position where the classification is uncertain.

Annual income reporting is also distinct. Article 170 of the CGI requires an income-taxable person to file a detailed declaration for establishing income tax. The official provision begins: En vue de l’établissement de l’impôt sur le revenu, toute personne imposable audit impôt est tenue de souscrire. See Article 170 of the CGI. Depending on the event, a foreign-income schedule such as Form 2047 may need to be considered alongside Form 2042. The form choice should follow the payment’s legal character, not the fact that the custodian is American.

The following working table keeps the analysis separate:

HSA event Question for France Evidence to preserve
Balance existing before French residence What was the balance and what income arose after residence began? Opening statement, arrival date, cost and income history
New contribution Is it a contribution, an employer benefit, or another payment under French rules? Payroll record, Form 5498-SA, contribution date and source
Interest, dividends, or investment sale Was income realized or made available while French-resident? Custodian ledger, tax statement, transaction and currency data
Medical withdrawal Does the withdrawal match a documented medical expense, and what portion is principal or income? Invoice, prescription or reimbursement record, withdrawal notice
Nonqualified withdrawal What was paid out, why, and how did the United States tax it? Form 1099-SA, Form 8889, U.S. return, custodian explanation
Closure or transfer Was there a distribution, a sale, or only a permitted transfer to another HSA? Closing statement, transfer form, final valuation, exchange rate

A foreign-account penalty can be material even when the account generated little income. Article 1729 B of the CGI provides for an amende when a required document or declaration is not produced within the prescribed period; the official text is available at Article 1729 B of the CGI. The existence of a penalty rule is not a conclusion that every HSA is automatically within every form. It is a reason to resolve the account classification before the return is filed and to keep proof of the position taken.

II. How should an American handle HSA withdrawals and French filing?

A. Are medical withdrawals tax-free in France, and what happens to nonqualified distributions?

Under U.S. rules, an HSA distribution used for a qualified medical expense can receive favorable treatment. The medical expense must fit the applicable U.S. definition, and the account holder must keep records showing the expense and the payment. A qualified expense can arise in France, but the fact that a French doctor or pharmacy issued the invoice does not make the French treatment automatic. The U.S. qualification and the French income-tax characterization are separate legal questions.

The first practical distinction is between reimbursement of a documented expense and a withdrawal that releases investment value. Suppose an American paid a French medical bill personally, retained the invoice and proof of payment, and later withdrew an equal amount from the HSA. The file should show the date, amount, currency conversion, and relationship between the bill and the reimbursement. That chronology is materially different from taking a large cash withdrawal for living costs while describing it as “medical” without a matching invoice.

The second distinction is between the account holder’s contributions and income generated inside the account. If the HSA contains only previously contributed cash and the withdrawal reimburses a real qualified expense, the analysis is not the same as withdrawing dividends or gains that accumulated after French residence. If the account holds mutual funds or other investments, the custodian’s year-end statement and transaction ledger are essential. A French tax return should not be built from the gross amount on Form 1099-SA alone when the account history shows different components.

France has no general HSA exemption that can be invoked merely by presenting a U.S. Form 1099-SA. At the same time, it would be equally unsafe to state that every medical withdrawal is automatically ordinary taxable income. French law requires the payment to be characterized on its facts. The purpose of the withdrawal, the account’s legal documents, the nature of the underlying funds, the existence of a medical expense, and the U.S. reporting position all matter. A written analysis should state which portion is claimed to be reimbursement, which portion is income, and which portion remains uncertain.

Nonqualified withdrawals require a separate review. The United States may include the amount in income and may apply an additional charge under its domestic rules. France will not necessarily follow the U.S. penalty as if it were a French income-tax category. The French question remains: what payment was made available, from what account, with what underlying income or capital, while the recipient was French-resident? A statement that “the United States taxed it” does not by itself establish a French exemption or a French credit.

Article 24 of the treaty addresses relief from double taxation. In the French treaty text, the relevant mechanism says that certain U.S.-source income is pris en compte pour le calcul de l’impôt français and can give rise to a credit under the conditions stated in the treaty. Read the full article in the official French treaty PDF and compare it with the official English treaty text. A credit is not created simply because a U.S. form shows withholding. It depends on the treaty provision, the tax actually imposed, the income category, timing, and the limits of the foreign-tax-credit rules.

Article 18 should not be used as a shortcut. Its retirement wording covers retirement arrangements, and the 2004 protocol’s enumerated examples are useful for a 401(k), IRA, or comparable pension plan. An HSA is organized around healthcare expenses, not retirement distributions. If the taxpayer believes that a particular HSA arrangement should receive treatment similar to a retirement arrangement, the file should explain why, cite the account’s governing provisions, and address the fact that HSAs are not expressly named in the treaty list. A silent assumption is difficult to defend if the administration asks why Article 18 was used.

Contributions after arrival in France also need care. An American may remain eligible for U.S. HSA contributions in a particular year only if the U.S. requirements are met, including the relevant health-plan and eligibility rules. French public healthcare coverage is not automatically the same as a U.S. qualifying HDHP. A contribution made through a U.S. employer, a contribution made personally, and an investment return are different entries in the French analysis. The U.S. tax deduction or exclusion does not automatically create a French deduction.

Finally, do not close an HSA merely to make the paperwork disappear. Closing the account can create a distribution, crystallize investment transactions, trigger U.S. information reporting, and leave no future ability to reimburse old medical expenses from the account. Before closure, obtain the complete statement, classify the holdings, record the French residence dates, reconcile the U.S. forms, and determine whether the account can be transferred to another HSA without a distribution. The best answer may be to keep the account open with no new contributions, but that depends on custodian rules, fees, investment policy, and the taxpayer’s documented French position.

B. What filing roadmap and proof should an American use after moving to France?

A defensible file can be built in eight steps.

First, establish the residence year. Record the date the French home became available, the days spent in each country, work and family location, departure from the United States, and any treaty residence analysis. Separate a short visit from the date French domicile fiscal began. If both countries claim residence, preserve the treaty tie-breaker documents rather than choosing a country based only on the number of days.

Second, inventory the account. Identify the HSA trustee or custodian, account number, legal agreement, opening date, current address, cash and investment options, beneficiary designation, and any employer contribution arrangement. Determine whether the account can issue Form 5498-SA and Form 1099-SA, whether it is a bank or a nonbank custodian, and whether a separate brokerage subaccount exists. A single “HSA” label can conceal more than one reporting relationship.

Third, create a transaction ledger. For every contribution, interest payment, dividend, sale, fee, reimbursement, nonqualified withdrawal, rollover, and transfer, record the U.S. dollar amount, date, euro conversion method, and document source. The ledger should identify the balance before French residence began. It should also identify whether an investment transaction was inside the HSA or whether money left the account. A year-end balance alone is not enough to reconstruct the tax events.

Fourth, collect medical proof. Keep invoices, prescriptions where relevant, payment confirmations, reimbursement records, insurance statements, and a short note connecting each medical expense to the HSA withdrawal. French documents may be in euros and may use a different description from U.S. forms. Translate the legal and financial significance in the file without altering the original document. If an expense was incurred before the withdrawal, retain proof that the U.S. rules allow the later reimbursement and state the date clearly.

Fifth, compare the U.S. forms. Request Form 1099-SA, Form 5498-SA, Form 8889, the account statements, and the relevant Form 1040 schedules. If a withdrawal was reported as qualified in the United States, keep the supporting expense records. If it was nonqualified, record the U.S. taxable amount and any additional charge separately. The French return should not copy a U.S. form mechanically, but a French position that contradicts the U.S. account history should be explained.

Sixth, decide the foreign-account reporting position. Apply Article 1649 A to the actual account and custodian. Review the French administration’s guidance on accounts held abroad, and determine whether Form 3916, Form 3916-bis, another declaration, or a documented non-filing position is appropriate. If the HSA is held through a bank or brokerage platform, the reporting risk is more obvious. If it is held by a trustee with a medical-benefit structure, obtain the legal agreement and consider asking for a written analysis rather than relying on the absence of a familiar French form field.

Seventh, map the income filing. Determine whether a Form 2047 entry, a Form 2042 entry, or another schedule is relevant for each item. A contribution, an investment return, a reimbursement, and a nonqualified distribution should not be merged. Use the exchange rate consistently and preserve the source of the rate. If a treaty credit is claimed, identify the treaty article, the U.S. tax paid, the French income category, and the computation that limits the credit. If no credit is claimed, record why the U.S. amount was not a creditable income tax or why the treaty does not allocate the item that way.

Eighth, prepare an explanatory memo. The memo should answer: when did French tax residence begin; what is the legal nature of the HSA; what income arose after that date; what withdrawals matched medical expenses; what was reported in the United States; which French forms were filed; and which point remains uncertain. Attach the treaty text, the relevant CGI articles, account agreement, statements, medical proof, and U.S. forms. A short, chronological memo is more useful than an unexplained spreadsheet or a screenshot of an online account.

The filing decision should be made before the return deadline, not after a bank transfer has attracted a question. If the HSA contains significant investments, if the taxpayer is claiming treaty protection under Article 18, if the account was closed after the move, or if the HSA was used to reimburse medical expenses over several years, obtain a French–U.S. tax analysis before submitting the return. That review can distinguish a reasonable uncertainty from an omission that creates a penalty risk.

There is also a practical privacy and banking issue. A French bank may ask why an HSA distribution arrived from the United States, especially if the payment is large or the account holder is opening a French account. Provide a concise explanation supported by the custodian statement and medical documents. Do not describe the payment as a pension if it was a medical-account reimbursement. Do not describe it as a reimbursement if it was a nonqualified cash distribution. Consistent language across the bank file, French return, U.S. return, and treaty memo reduces the risk of a preventable contradiction.

The same caution applies to FATCA and automatic exchange. FATCA reporting by a financial institution and the individual’s French income or foreign-account declaration are not interchangeable. A custodian’s compliance classification may tell the IRS or French administration that an account exists, but it does not decide whether a particular withdrawal is capital, income, reimbursement, or a treaty-protected pension. The account holder remains responsible for the personal return and for retaining the evidence supporting it.

When the French administration asks a question, answer the actual question with the document that proves it. If the request concerns a foreign account, produce the account identification and reporting explanation. If it concerns income, produce the transaction ledger and U.S. forms. If it concerns a treaty position, identify the article and explain why an HSA does or does not fall within it. Avoid sending a bare account balance that hides medical reimbursements and investment transactions.

Conclusion

A U.S. HSA does not disappear when an American moves to France, but its U.S. tax advantages do not automatically become French tax advantages. France first asks whether the individual is tax-resident, then examines the account’s legal nature and the events that occurred after residence began. Contributions, investment income, medical reimbursements, nonqualified withdrawals, and closure must be separated. Foreign-account reporting under Article 1649 A may be a different question from income reporting under Articles 12, 13, 156, 158, and 170 of the CGI.

The France–U.S. treaty’s Article 18 is written for pensions and retirement arrangements, and the protocol’s examples do not expressly name HSAs. That makes an automatic 401(k)-style classification unsafe. Article 24 may provide a double-tax relief mechanism when its conditions are met, but a U.S. tax form or penalty is not, by itself, a French exemption or a credit. The correct position depends on the account agreement, the payment, the medical proof, the U.S. treatment, and the treaty analysis.

Before contributing after the move, withdrawing for a French medical expense, transferring investments, or closing the account, preserve the arrival-date balance and build a complete ledger. Keep Form 1099-SA, Form 5498-SA, Form 8889, the U.S. return, custodian statements, medical invoices, payment proof, exchange-rate calculations, and the French forms. If the account is substantial or the classification is uncertain, obtain a written position before filing. That is the most reliable way to protect the account’s history and avoid treating a specialized U.S. healthcare account as a French product it was never designed to be.

We can help you separate foreign-account reporting, French income-tax questions, U.S. forms, and the documents needed before a transfer or closure.

📄 Official circular