KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Uganda–US Extradition Hearing: What the Katungi Weapons Case Tests Before August 28

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, criminal defence lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Uganda–US Extradition Hearing: What the Katungi Weapons Case Tests Before August 28

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Uganda’s Buganda Road Chief Magistrates Court is approaching a decision that reaches far beyond one defendant. On 28 August 2026, according to the latest report from Uganda Radio Network, the court is expected to decide whether Michael Katungi Mpeirwe should be surrendered to the United States to face federal charges linked to an alleged international arms and cocaine-trafficking conspiracy. A separate local report refers to a further merits date, so the public docket should be checked before treating the date as immovable.

The case is unusually newsworthy because the alleged route crosses Bulgaria, East Africa, Mexico, the United Kingdom and the United States, while the surrender decision is being made in Kampala. The American indictment alleges that military-grade weapons were meant for the Cártel Jalisco Nueva Generación, but an indictment is not a conviction and the allegations remain to be tested. The immediate legal question is narrower: has Uganda received a legally sufficient request, and have its courts followed the procedure required before a citizen can be sent abroad?

For French and European observers, the hearing is also a useful stress test. France separates the assessment of extradition conditions from the trial of the alleged offences, protects the person’s opportunity to defend himself, and applies a distinct judicial surrender regime inside the European Union. That comparison helps identify what the Kampala court is deciding, what it is not deciding, and why a procedural objection can matter even when the underlying allegations are grave.

I. How can Uganda decide whether to extradite Katungi to the United States?

A. What do the United States indictment and the August 28 hearing actually establish?

The public record begins with an American prosecution, not with a Ugandan conviction. The United States Department of Justice identifies the federal case as Eastern District of Virginia case 1:25-CR-102. The unsealed indictment itself is available from the Department of Justice as Case 1:25-cr-00102-AJT, Document 8. The document names Michael Katungi Mpeirwe among defendants accused of participating in a conspiracy that prosecutors say involved cocaine, firearms and material support for a designated foreign terrorist organisation.

The central factual allegation is that the defendants created or used a false end-user certificate to make a weapons shipment appear to be destined for a national military rather than for the intended criminal market. The indictment describes an initial shipment of 50 AK-47 rifles, magazines and ammunition. It also alleges that a later list of equipment, including highly destructive weapons, had a value of approximately €53.7 million. Those allegations explain the international interest, but they do not answer the extradition question. A court deciding surrender does not normally conduct the American trial in miniature.

The indictment’s allegation about Mpeirwe is specific. It states that, at a meeting in London, he “offered to illegally obtain firearms for future sale to the CJNG”. It further alleges that he claimed access to connections in Africa and Uganda and that he would receive a commission. The language matters. The document describes the prosecution case; it does not establish that the meeting occurred, that the statements were made, or that the proposed transaction became a completed offence.

The charges reported by the Department of Justice include conspiracy to distribute five kilograms or more of cocaine intended for unlawful importation into the United States, conspiracy to possess firearms in furtherance of drug trafficking, and conspiracy to provide material support or resources to a designated foreign terrorist organisation. The Department’s own release states that an indictment is merely an accusation and that each defendant is presumed innocent. That qualification should remain visible in every account of the Kampala proceedings.

The Ugandan hearing therefore has at least four possible layers. First, the court must examine the formal request and the documents said to support it. Second, it must determine whether the conduct alleged falls within a legal basis for surrender under Ugandan law and the international instruments invoked by the government. Third, it must deal with procedural objections, including objections about the participation of the Director of Public Prosecutions, the form of the application, disclosure and the authority of foreign witnesses. Fourth, it must decide whether the evidence meets the threshold applicable at an extradition hearing.

Recent reporting shows why the fourth layer cannot be separated from the second and third. Nile Post reported that the defence argued the court should resolve a legal challenge before proceeding to the substantive extradition hearing. Counsel’s concern was practical: if surrender happened first, a later constitutional ruling might have no effective way to bring the defendant back to Uganda. That is not an argument on whether the weapons allegation is true. It is an argument about sequencing and an effective remedy.

The hearing record also contains an evidentiary warning. Uganda Radio Network reported that the court expunged an affidavit from a United States witness who failed to appear for cross-examination. The legal consequence depends on the governing Ugandan rules and the precise order made by the magistrate. It would be inaccurate to treat the expunging of an affidavit as an automatic dismissal, but it could affect the material available to establish the request, the identity of the person sought, the reliability of the allegations or the procedural route by which the American case was presented.

There is a further complication in the public chronology. On 3 August 2026, the High Court’s Criminal Division decided Michael Katungi Mpeirwe v Director of Public Prosecutions, Criminal Revision 14 of 2026, [2026] UGHCCRD 51. The published case summary records the issue as “revisionary jurisdiction and prematurity”. The High Court dismissed the challenge as premature, remitted the matter to the magistrate and vacated the stay that had interrupted the proceedings. The judgment did not decide the American charges and did not order surrender.

That order narrows, rather than removes, the immediate dispute. The magistrate remains the forum for the extradition hearing. The High Court has not declared that every defence objection is worthless; it has held that the attempted revision was premature at that procedural stage. The practical question for 28 August is therefore whether the magistrate makes a final determination on the request, adjourns for a reason recognised in Ugandan law, or delivers an order that creates a new appeal or revision route.

The public reporting is not perfectly aligned on the next date. Uganda Radio Network reported a decision on or before 28 August after written submissions. Radio Sapientia separately reported a later merits listing. This is not a minor editorial detail. In an extradition case, the difference between a reserved ruling, a resumed evidentiary hearing and a directions hearing changes what a defence team must prepare. The authoritative electronic court record, rather than a headline, should control the next procedural step.

B. Can Uganda’s High Court stop a Magistrate’s extradition hearing before a ruling?

The answer supplied by Criminal Revision 14 of 2026 is a qualified no at the stage then presented to the High Court. The decision shows why the classification of an order matters. If a magistrate has only reserved objections for consideration after hearing the case, a higher court may regard an application to revise that interlocutory step as premature. The person sought is not left without a remedy; the point is that the challenge must arrive after the lower court has made a decision capable of review, unless an exceptional jurisdictional or constitutional basis applies.

This sequencing principle is familiar to international lawyers. Extradition is a coercive process, but it is not identical to the prosecution that may follow in the requesting state. The requested state must decide whether the request satisfies the applicable legal conditions. It generally does not decide guilt, sentence or the full credibility of every witness as if it were the trial court in Virginia. At the same time, the requested state cannot treat procedure as a formality. If a document is essential to the request and is not properly admitted, or if the person cannot challenge the material relied upon, the question may become one of legal sufficiency rather than mere weight.

The defence has reportedly challenged the role of the Ugandan Director of Public Prosecutions on the ground that extradition is a special form of proceeding rather than an ordinary domestic criminal prosecution. Nile Post described the objection as a challenge to the DPP’s standing. The court will have to identify the statutory allocation of functions, the route by which the United States request was transmitted, and the relationship between the executive authorities responsible for international cooperation and the judicial officer deciding the request.

Other reported objections concern the form of the evidence, the completeness of the supporting papers, the speciality principle and the effect of surrender on later constitutional relief. Each has a different legal function. A defect in the request may require rejection or correction. A dispute about disclosure may require an adjournment or a direction. A challenge to the legal standing of a participant may concern jurisdiction. An argument about speciality may concern the limits on the requesting state’s later prosecution rather than the threshold for initial surrender.

The magistrate’s decision should therefore be read in operative terms. Does it find that the request is legally receivable? Does it identify the precise offences for which surrender is authorised? Does it explain the evidentiary threshold and the documents relied upon? Does it address the expunged affidavit? Does it state whether the order is immediately enforceable or subject to a statutory appeal, revision or stay? Those questions will matter more than a broad statement that the case involves serious international crime.

The fact that Uganda’s government approved the request does not eliminate judicial review. Reports have referred to approval by government authorities and to the Extradition Act as part of the legal basis. An executive decision may initiate or support a request, but a court must still apply the conditions set by the relevant law. The distinction protects both sovereignty and individual rights: Uganda chooses whether to cooperate through its institutions, while the court decides whether the legal conditions for depriving a person of liberty and transferring him abroad have been met.

The court may also have to manage a tension between speed and effective review. International requests often arrive with a strong interest in avoiding flight and preserving evidence. The person sought, however, may need time to obtain certified documents, translations, foreign affidavits and advice on the law of the requesting state. A fast process is legitimate only if the defence can understand and answer the case. That is why the expunging of a witness affidavit, and the defence request to determine legal objections before the merits, deserve attention even though neither point automatically decides the outcome.

For an international audience, the most important caution is this: an order allowing extradition would not be a finding that Mpeirwe supplied weapons to the CJNG, imported cocaine or supported a terrorist organisation. It would be an order authorising a later American criminal process, subject to any appeal, stay, speciality undertaking or other safeguard in the applicable law. Conversely, a refusal could rest on an incomplete request or procedural defect without affirming the factual defence. The legal meaning of the order must be kept separate from the political meaning attached to it.

The case also demonstrates why an extradition file should be reviewed as a bundle rather than as a headline. A defence team should compare the arrest warrant, the indictment, the supporting affidavits, the treaty or convention relied on, the translations, the chain of certification and the domestic application. That is the practical purpose of an extradition-document checklist: not to retry the foreign case, but to test whether the requesting state has supplied the material the requested court is legally permitted to use.

II. What would a French or European extradition court test?

A. Which French safeguards would apply to a US extradition request?

France offers a useful comparison because its ordinary extradition procedure separates the international request, the judicial examination of the person sought and the final executive act. The starting point is the French Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 696-4. It lists situations in which extradition is not granted, including French nationality, a political character or political purpose, territorial jurisdiction in France and a requesting-state tribunal that does not provide fundamental procedural and defence guarantees.

The most important phrase for this comparison is the statutory refusal ground: “L’extradition n’est pas accordée”. Article 696-4 then includes the situation in which “la personne réclamée serait jugée dans l’Etat requérant par un tribunal n’assurant pas les garanties fondamentales de procédure et de protection des droits de la défense”. The French court is not required to decide that the requesting state’s allegations are false. It must decide whether surrender would be legally compatible with the safeguards governing extradition.

Formal sufficiency comes earlier. Article 696-8 requires the request to travel through the diplomatic channel and to be supported by a conviction, a judicial act or an arrest warrant setting out the facts, their date and the applicable law, with certified material and the relevant legal provisions. The precision requirement matters in a complex international file. The requested person must know which conduct is said to satisfy which offence, and the court must be able to compare the request with the applicable treaty and domestic conditions.

The person’s participation is not optional. Under Article 696-13, “Le ministère public et la personne réclamée sont entendus”, with counsel and an interpreter where necessary. The hearing may be public, subject to exceptions. In the non-consent route, the investigating chamber gives a reasoned opinion on whether the legal conditions are met. The structure is designed to make objections meaningful before any final surrender decision.

The Conseil d’État confirmed the constitutional importance of that opportunity in CE, 2nd–7th chambers sitting together, 19 October 2018, no. 421762. The case concerned an extradition to the United States under the France–US treaty. The court stated that “l’extradition ne peut être accordée sans que l’intéressé ait pu exercer sa défense”. It also held that French authorities do not ordinarily decide the merits of the foreign charges, save for an obvious error. That is the same conceptual line visible in Kampala: a serious accusation and a procedurally valid request are related, but they are not the same legal question.

Article 421762 is also a warning against importing domestic rules without checking the governing instrument. The Conseil d’État held that the France–US extradition treaty did not permit the government to add conditions beyond those provided by the convention in the circumstances before it. For a French lawyer reviewing the Ugandan file, the lesson is methodological: identify the treaty or multilateral convention first, then determine which domestic rules supplement it and which rules are displaced by the instrument.

A second decision, CE, 2nd–7th chambers sitting together, 21 December 2023, no. 476011, concerned an extradition to Albania under the European Convention on Extradition. The Conseil d’État held that the convention governed the handover and that the Code of Criminal Procedure rules had “un caractère supplétif”. That is directly relevant to any cross-border file: the legal answer cannot be reconstructed from a national code alone when a treaty or convention supplies the primary rules.

The French framework also shows how jurisdiction can be analysed without confusing it with surrender. Under Article 113-6 of the Penal Code, “La loi pénale française est applicable à tout crime commis par un Français hors du territoire de la République.” Under Article 113-7, French law may apply to a crime or imprisonable offence committed abroad where the victim was French at the relevant time. Those provisions do not create a universal French power to prosecute every international arms transaction. They identify specific connecting factors that may make a French prosecution possible.

Procedural conditions follow. Article 113-8 provides that, for the offences covered by Articles 113-6 and 113-7, prosecution of offences requires a request by the public prosecutor and must be preceded by a victim complaint or official denunciation. The text says that “la poursuite des délits ne peut être exercée qu’à la requête du ministère public”. Article 113-9 adds a double-jeopardy safeguard for a person finally judged abroad for the same facts where the sentence has been served or is no longer enforceable.

There are also treaty-based jurisdictional provisions, but they must not be overread. Article 689-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states that, under the international conventions named in the following articles, a person may be prosecuted in France when found in France for one of the offences covered by those conventions. The opening condition is “En application des conventions internationales visées aux articles suivants”. Article 689-2 concerns torture under the 1984 Convention. Neither provision automatically turns a weapons-trafficking allegation in Uganda into a French case. They illustrate why the connecting instrument and offence definition must be identified with care.

Finally, the French traditional extradition route includes a final executive stage. Under Article 696-18, in cases other than the statutory refusal route, extradition is authorised by decree of the Prime Minister on the justice minister’s report, and an application for judicial review must be filed within one month. That sequence differs from a purely judicial surrender. It also means that the defence must track several dates: the hearing, the judicial opinion, notification of the decree and the one-month challenge period.

B. Why would an EU European Arrest Warrant produce a different surrender route?

The European Arrest Warrant is not a faster name for ordinary extradition. It is a separate judicial cooperation mechanism between EU Member States. Article 695-11 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure defines it as a judicial decision issued by one Member State for the arrest and surrender of a person by another Member State for prosecution or execution of a custodial sentence. The key sentence is that “L’autorité judiciaire est compétente” to issue or execute the warrant under the chapter’s rules.

That design changes the institutional map. A US request to Uganda is an international extradition request presented through the route allowed by Ugandan law and the instrument relied upon. A European Arrest Warrant sent to France is ordinarily handled through judicial authorities under a framework of mutual recognition. There is no direct analogy between a US diplomatic request and an EAW merely because both seek the transfer of a person for criminal proceedings.

The EAW still has safeguards. Article 695-22 lists mandatory refusal grounds, including a final decision for the same facts and a warrant issued for discriminatory reasons. The statute states that execution “est refusée dans les cas suivants”. Other provisions deal with trial in absentia, proportionality-related information, speciality and the possibility of postponing surrender for serious humanitarian reasons. The mechanism is faster and more integrated than classic extradition, but it is not automatic.

For the Katungi case, the comparison highlights three questions. First, what is the exact legal instrument supporting the US request? Uganda’s public reporting refers to the Extradition Act and the 1988 United Nations Convention against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances. Second, does that instrument define the documents, offences and evidentiary threshold required for the requested court to act? Third, what remedy follows from a refusal, a conditional surrender or an order that contains a procedural error?

The French experience suggests that the answer will depend on the instrument’s allocation of roles. In CE no. 476011, the governing extradition convention controlled the handover and the domestic code was supplementary. In CE no. 421762, the France–US treaty shaped the conditions applied to the American request. The same discipline should guide analysis of Uganda’s file: identify the governing convention, read its procedural articles, then read the domestic statute as part of that system.

There is also a sovereignty point. A state does not surrender a person because the requesting state has a powerful indictment or because the alleged conduct is politically embarrassing. It surrenders when its own law, read with the relevant international instrument, authorises the transfer and the court is satisfied that the applicable safeguards have been respected. That does not make extradition an act of distrust toward the requesting state. It makes the requested state responsible for the legal conditions under which it exercises its sovereign power.

The transnational facts make that responsibility more difficult. Evidence may sit in several countries. The alleged meeting occurred in London; the alleged weapons documentation involved Bulgaria and Tanzania; the intended market was said to be Mexico; and the US charges depend on an American nexus. The court must avoid both extremes: treating the case as a purely local Ugandan dispute, or assuming that the foreign indictment resolves every domestic procedural question.

For lawyers monitoring the 28 August decision, the useful checklist is therefore short but demanding. Read the operative part, not only the reasons. Identify each offence for which surrender is authorised. Confirm whether the order addresses the challenged affidavit and the defence’s standing objection. Check whether it specifies the legal route for appeal, revision or stay. Record any speciality or fair-trial undertaking. Finally, distinguish an order authorising transfer from a conviction on the American charges.

That distinction will matter if Uganda’s court refuses surrender. A refusal may be based on an evidentiary or procedural defect and may leave the United States able to submit a corrected request if the governing law permits. If surrender is authorised, the defence may still seek review or a stay under Ugandan law, and the American case will still require proof beyond the extradition stage. If the date moves, the legal analysis does not disappear; it simply shifts from the reserved decision to the next hearing and the next record.

The larger lesson is that cross-border criminal cooperation is built from procedural links. A request can be politically urgent and factually serious while still failing because a document is uncertified, a witness is unavailable, a statutory function has been assigned to the wrong authority, or a remedy would be illusory after surrender. Conversely, a court can reject a procedural objection while leaving the requesting state to prove its case at trial. That is the legal architecture international media often compress into the single word “extradition”.

Conclusion

Michael Katungi Mpeirwe’s case is not yet a judgment on the alleged arms and cocaine conspiracy. It is a live test of how Uganda translates a foreign prosecution into a domestic surrender process. The 3 August High Court decision, [2026] UGHCCRD 51, returned the procedural dispute to the magistrate after finding the revision application premature. The next decisive order must be read against that history, the supporting documents, the expunged affidavit and the legal instrument invoked by the United States.

France’s extradition law supplies a disciplined comparison: verify the request, give the person an effective opportunity to defend, apply the governing treaty before relying on domestic assumptions, and keep surrender separate from guilt. The European Arrest Warrant shows a different model based on judicial mutual recognition inside the EU. Neither model answers the Ugandan case automatically. The answer will come from Uganda’s own law, the applicable convention and the reasons given by the court.

Until the operative ruling is released, the responsible position is precise rather than dramatic. The allegations are serious, the cross-border stakes are high, and the date is newsworthy. But the legal result will turn on documents, jurisdiction, evidence and remedy—not on the headline attached to the indictment.

📄 Official circular