An American who has moved to France may want to leave an old 401(k) plan and transfer it to a traditional individual retirement account, or IRA. In the United States, that transaction is commonly called a rollover. The practical question is not simply whether the money crossed from one American custodian to another. The legal question is whether the transaction was a direct rollover, a cash distribution followed by a redeposit, a Roth conversion, a required minimum distribution, or a payment affected by an outstanding plan loan.
France adds a second layer. A person can become a French tax resident while keeping U.S. citizenship, a U.S. bank account, and a U.S.-established retirement plan. French domestic law, the France–U.S. income-tax treaty, and the documents issued by the plan must then be read together. A rollover that is not taxable under U.S. rules should not automatically be described as a French-taxable pension, but the absence of French withholding is not a ruling that the transfer is invisible in France.
This guide addresses the narrow problem of a 401(k)-to-IRA rollover after an American settles in France. It does not replace the broader guide to retiring in France as an American. It explains the French terms, the treaty allocation, the forms, the evidence, and the points at which a rollover can become a different taxable event.
I. Is a 401(k) rollover taxable in France after an American moves there?
A. How does France classify the taxpayer, the plan, and the transfer?
The first question is the taxpayer’s status for the year of the transfer. French law uses the expression domicile fiscal, meaning tax domicile or tax home. It is not the same thing as a visa, a nationality, a mailing address, or the place where an American retirement account is held. Article 4 B of the French General Tax Code identifies several domestic tests. It refers to a person whose French “foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal” is in France, and it also looks at professional activity and the center of economic interests. The word foyer means the ordinary family home in this context.
The timing must therefore be written down before the rollover is analyzed. Record the date on which the American arrived, the date on which the French home became available, the location of the family, the place of work, the number of days spent in each country, and the date on which the plan administrator processed the transfer. Someone who was a French resident on the transfer date may have a different filing position from someone who completed the same transaction before becoming resident. A person resident in both countries must also apply the treaty tie-breaker rather than relying on a simple 183-day slogan.
French residence does not itself decide whether a 401(k) rollover is income. It determines which French domestic rules are initially relevant. Article 79 of the French General Tax Code places pensions and retirement benefits within the income-tax framework and expressly includes retirement benefits paid as capital. The statutory language refers to “pensions et rentes viagères” and to retirement benefits paid in capital form. That is a domestic starting point. The treaty may then allocate taxing rights away from France, or may require a different computation, if the payment fits its conditions.
A 401(k) rollover is not one single event in legal terms. A conventional direct rollover transfers assets from the former employer plan directly to a traditional IRA custodian. The participant does not receive the money personally. A trustee-to-trustee transfer is normally distinguished from a check payable to the participant who later deposits the money into an IRA. A distribution paid to the participant can create U.S. withholding, a 60-day deadline, and a question about the amount that was actually rolled over. The French file should preserve that distinction instead of using the word “rollover” for every movement of retirement money.
The U.S. rule is important evidence, but it is not the whole French analysis. The IRS explains that a rollover can occur when a participant receives cash or property from one qualified retirement plan and contributes it to another qualified plan or a traditional IRA within 60 days. The IRS also explains that a rollover is generally not taxable under U.S. rules but remains reportable on the official 401(k) rollover guidance. A direct rollover is usually cleaner because the funds go from the old plan to the new custodian without becoming available to the participant.
An indirect rollover carries more risk. If an eligible distribution is paid to the participant, the U.S. payer generally withholds 20 percent, and the participant must replace the withheld amount if the intention is to roll over the full distribution. The IRS describes the 60-day mechanics and the mandatory withholding in its official guidance. For a French resident, the bank statement, Form 1099-R, rollover confirmation, and IRA receipt should show exactly what happened. If a payment was partly retained, the retained part may have a different tax treatment from the amount transferred.
A rollover to a traditional IRA must also be separated from a conversion to a Roth IRA. A Roth conversion normally moves pre-tax retirement money into a Roth structure and can be taxable under U.S. law even when no cash is withdrawn. It should not be presented to the French tax administration as a neutral trustee-to-trustee transfer without examining the conversion documents. A qualified Roth distribution is another event again. The account label “Roth” does not answer whether the payment was a contribution return, a conversion amount, earnings, a qualified distribution, or a nonqualified distribution.
Other exclusions can change the analysis. A required minimum distribution generally cannot be rolled over. A hardship distribution, certain corrective distributions, a payment spread over the required period, or a payment connected to an outstanding 401(k) loan may be treated differently under U.S. rules. A plan loan that is not repaid can become a deemed distribution. Keep the plan’s loan statement, the date of separation from employment, the distribution code, and the plan administrator’s explanation. A tax authority or a court will examine the actual transaction, not just the taxpayer’s intention.
The French source question is also separate from the location of the receiving account. A U.S. plan paid into a French bank account does not become a French pension merely because the bank is in France. Conversely, a payment sent to a U.S. account can still be received by a person who is French-resident. The plan’s establishment, the payer, the former employment, the participant’s residence, and the legal character of the payment must be documented together.
The rollover should therefore be described in a short chronology. For example: “On 15 September, while resident in France, the participant instructed Plan A in the United States to transfer $400,000 directly to IRA B in the United States; no check was payable to the participant; no Form 1099-R reported a taxable distribution; IRA B confirmed receipt as a rollover contribution.” That chronology is much stronger than a bank statement showing an unexplained $400,000 movement.
B. What does the France–U.S. treaty say about a 401(k) rollover?
The current France–U.S. framework must be read with the treaty and its later protocols. The official consolidated France–U.S. income-tax and wealth-tax convention published by the French tax administration contains Article 18, titled “Pensions,” and the protocol language describing qualifying American plans. The relevant treaty text covers payments in periodic form and in a lump sum. It also links the source of a retirement payment to the retirement plan established in that state.
Article 18(1) uses the source-state rule: qualifying retirement payments arising in one contracting state and paid to a resident of the other state are generally taxable only in the first state. The treaty’s words are “ne sont imposables que dans le premier Etat.” For an American resident in France, a payment from a qualifying U.S.-established retirement plan may therefore remain allocated to the United States. That sentence concerns a payment under a retirement plan. It does not automatically classify every transfer, investment account, Roth conversion, or cash movement as a treaty-protected pension.
The treaty protocol is unusually specific about the type of American arrangement. It generally recognizes qualified plans under section 401(a), individual retirement plans, individual retirement accounts, and qualified plans under sections 403(a) and 403(b) as corresponding, in general, to a retirement plan recognized for French tax purposes. A conventional 401(k) is therefore within the relevant family, and a traditional rollover IRA may remain connected to that family when the documentation shows a valid continuation of the retirement arrangement.
CAA Versailles, 28 January 2020, no. 18VE03035, is a useful official decision because it reproduces the treaty’s list of American plans. The court referred to plans that “sont considérés de façon générale comme correspondant à un régime de retraite.” That decision concerned a pension trust and French-source dividends, not an individual’s ordinary rollover. It cannot be cited as a holding that every 401(k) transfer is tax-free in France. Its value is narrower: it confirms that plan classification is a technical treaty question and that recognition of a plan does not erase the character of every amount connected with it.
The distinction between a transfer and a payment is central. If the old plan sends assets directly to the new traditional IRA and the participant never receives them, the transaction may not be a pension payment at all. If the participant receives a distribution and then contributes cash to an IRA, the U.S. law may still allow a rollover, but France will need the documents to determine whether the event was merely a continuation of the retirement arrangement or a payment placed temporarily in the participant’s hands. A French return should not state “zero income” without explaining the legal event.
The treaty does not treat every retirement product alike. A taxable U.S. brokerage account may generate dividends, interest, or capital gains rather than pension income. A French assurance-vie, meaning a French life-insurance investment contract, is not a 401(k). A French plan d’épargne retraite, or retirement savings plan, follows French rules and cannot be treated as a U.S. IRA merely because it was opened for retirement. A mutual fund held inside or outside a retirement account can raise a separate U.S. PFIC issue. Each asset must be placed in the correct legal category.
Government pensions require a separate check. Conseil d’État, 8 August 1990, no. 72536, examined an older treaty version and held that a pension paid by the U.S. Treasury for prior services at the U.S. Embassy in Paris fell under the public-service provisions. The decision stated that the payments “relèvent de celles de l’article 19.” That case is not a 401(k) case, but it shows why a federal civil-service pension should not be placed automatically in the private-pension column.
The same caution applies to treaty amendments and tax years. The 2004 protocol and the 2009 amendment changed the architecture of Article 18. A memo should identify the year, the version of the treaty, and the provision being applied. The treaty also contains rules that allow the United States to continue taxing its citizens under U.S. law, subject to the treaty’s exceptions. An American living in France normally remains within the U.S. filing system even when the treaty prevents France from taxing a qualifying U.S. retirement payment.
A published French administrative response helps explain the practical result. In a 2020 written question, the French Senate recorded the government’s answer that payments from American retirement plans, whether periodic or paid in one amount, are taxable only in the United States under Article 18(1), while France may take them into account for calculating the rate applied to other income when the treaty credit mechanism is respected. The official Senate question and ministerial response is useful context, but it is not a substitute for analyzing the particular plan and transaction.
The safest treaty conclusion is therefore conditional: a direct rollover from a documented U.S. 401(k) to a documented traditional U.S. IRA is a strong candidate for treatment as a continuation of a qualifying retirement arrangement, not as an ordinary French pension payment. That conclusion should be stated with the transaction documents, the plan’s legal identity, the participant’s residence, and the treaty article. It should not be expanded to cover a Roth conversion, an early cash withdrawal, a government pension, a brokerage account, or a failed rollover.
II. How should an American report a 401(k) rollover in France?
A. Which French and U.S. forms and treaty records are required?
Reporting and taxation are different questions. The French tax administration’s official Form 2047 page explains that the form is the schedule for income received outside metropolitan France and the overseas departments by a person domiciled in France. Form 2047 is commonly known in English as the foreign-income schedule. It is attached to the main French income-tax return when the facts require it. The current form and notice must be used for the relevant year; box numbers and reporting instructions can change.
Article 170 of the French General Tax Code requires an income declaration and refers to “toute personne imposable audit impôt” filing the detailed information necessary to calculate income tax. That does not mean that every non-taxable transfer must be inserted as taxable income. It means that the taxpayer must identify the items and apply the domestic and treaty rules consistently. A direct rollover should be reported, if necessary, as a documented transfer or treaty-relevant event, not silently converted into a pension withdrawal.
The French return must distinguish three situations. First, a direct rollover may be a non-distribution under U.S. rules and may not create current pension income. Second, an indirect rollover may be reportable in the United States while the French classification depends on the documents and treaty analysis. Third, a taxable distribution or Roth conversion may be income that must be analyzed under Article 18, another treaty article, or French domestic law. The same Form 1099-R code cannot replace the legal explanation.
Article 158 of the French General Tax Code says that income categories are evaluated without distinguishing whether income has a French or foreign source. Its wording includes “sans qu’il y ait lieu de distinguer suivant que ces revenus ont leur source en France ou hors de France.” The treaty can then allocate the item or require a credit. This is why a U.S. retirement payment may need to appear in the French reporting analysis even when Article 18 prevents France from imposing ordinary income tax on that payment.
The taux effectif, or effective-rate method, is a frequent source of confusion. France may use treaty-exempt foreign income to calculate the rate applied to income that remains taxable in France. The exempt item is not necessarily taxed a second time, but it can affect the rate on French salary, rental income, or business income. The taxpayer should keep the calculation showing which amount was exempt, which amount was included for rate purposes, and which treaty rule supports that treatment.
The withholding rules are separate from the final return. Article 204 A states that income taxable under the rules for salaries, pensions, or life annuities can give rise to a prélèvement à la source, meaning a payment collected during the year. A U.S. custodian generally does not operate French withholding merely because the participant lives in France. Therefore, no French withholding on a direct rollover is not proof of a French exemption. Conversely, a U.S. withholding shown on a Form 1099-R is not a French tax assessment.
A French resident should also test whether the foreign-account reporting rules are relevant. Article 1649 A of the French General Tax Code requires certain foreign accounts to be declared and refers to “Les sommes, titres ou valeurs transférés à l’étranger ou en provenance de l’étranger.” The scope depends on the legal nature of the account and the implementing rules. Do not assume that every 401(k), IRA, trust, or custodial arrangement is treated identically to a foreign bank account. Ask what the plan legally is, who holds the assets, and which French declaration is actually required.
On the U.S. side, the taxpayer should preserve the plan’s distribution statement, Form 1099-R, the rollover confirmation, and the receiving IRA’s year-end statement. The IRS states that a direct rollover to an eligible retirement plan, including an IRA, avoids the default 20 percent withholding that applies when an eligible rollover distribution is paid to the participant. A Form 5498 or custodian confirmation may show the IRA rollover contribution. The Form 1040 should follow the applicable U.S. instructions, and a Roth conversion or taxable amount should not be reported as a direct rollover merely to avoid a tax result.
A treaty memo should use one table for each event. The table should contain the tax year, payment date, old plan, new account, payer, amount in dollars, euro conversion if used, recipient, transaction type, Form 1099-R code, U.S. treatment, French domestic category, treaty article, French form, and supporting document. If there was no money paid to the participant, say so. If the participant received a check, say when it was deposited and whether the withheld amount was replaced. Precision at this stage prevents an unexplained bank transfer from being treated as a retirement distribution years later.
B. What evidence protects the taxpayer if France questions the rollover?
The evidence should be assembled before the transfer, not after a tax notice. Start with the complete 401(k) plan statement and the summary plan description. Ask the administrator to identify the plan as a section 401(a) or 401(k) arrangement, the exact account owner, the distribution type, and the receiving institution. Obtain the IRA acceptance letter and the transaction confirmation showing that the receiving account is a traditional IRA if that is the intended result. Keep the instructions signed by the participant and the dates on which each custodian acted.
Second, preserve the U.S. tax trail. The file may include the last pay stub showing contributions, employer-plan statements, Form 1099-R, Form 5498, the relevant Form 1040 lines, the IRA custodian’s rollover letter, and any Form W-4R or withholding election. If a distribution code appears, obtain the plan administrator’s written explanation rather than guessing what the code means. If a plan loan existed, keep the loan balance and repayment history. If the transaction was a Roth conversion, keep the conversion statement and the contribution and basis history.
Third, preserve the French residence and filing trail. Keep leases, utility records, family-residence evidence, employment documents, arrival and departure dates, the French tax-number notice, filed Forms 2042 and 2047, and any correspondence with the service des impôts des particuliers, the French individual-tax office. A treaty claim is stronger when the taxpayer can show which country considered the person resident and why the plan payment arose in the United States.
Fourth, preserve the source and custody chain. A direct rollover should show an outgoing transfer from the old U.S. plan, a transfer instruction that names the receiving traditional IRA, and an incoming receipt at the new U.S. custodian. A check payable to the new custodian is different from a check payable to the participant. A cash withdrawal followed by an investment in a French account is not a direct rollover. The chain should identify any period during which the participant had control of the funds.
Fifth, separate tax character from account reporting. FATCA, the U.S. Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, concerns information reporting and financial institutions. A Form 8938 or FBAR analysis concerns U.S. reporting obligations. A French foreign-account declaration concerns French domestic reporting. None of those forms, by itself, determines whether a payment was a pension, a rollover, a conversion, or a capital gain. Put the tax-character memo next to the forms instead of treating a filed form as conclusive evidence.
Several fact patterns require immediate review:
- Direct 401(k)-to-traditional-IRA transfer: the participant never receives the money, the receiving account is a traditional IRA, and the custodians describe the event as a rollover. This is the cleanest fact pattern, but the file should still explain why no current pension payment occurred.
- Check payable to the participant: the participant receives the funds, 20 percent may be withheld, and the participant must replace the withheld amount to roll over the full eligible distribution. The 60-day deadline and the amount retained must be proved.
- Traditional 401(k)-to-Roth IRA conversion: the new account is a Roth IRA, and the U.S. tax treatment may include the converted pre-tax amount. This is not the same as a direct rollover to a traditional IRA.
- Required minimum distribution: the amount may not be eligible for rollover. It must be analyzed as a payment under the treaty and the applicable U.S. rules.
- Government or military plan: the payer and the former service may move the analysis toward the public-remuneration provisions. Do not rely on the private-pension conclusion.
- Plan loan or hardship distribution: the transaction may contain a deemed distribution or a taxable amount even if the taxpayer describes the movement as a rollover.
French case law illustrates why the category must be proved. CAA Versailles, 27 May 2015, no. 13VE01761, involved U.S. government retirement payments and treaty arguments. It is not authority for the proposition that a private 401(k) rollover is taxable or exempt. Its relevance is methodological: the taxpayer’s description of a pension cannot replace the court’s examination of the payer, the service, the treaty text, and the tax year.
If the French tax administration proposes an adjustment, read the notice line by line. Identify whether it treats the amount as a pension, a capital retirement benefit, a conversion, an unexplained foreign transfer, or another category. Then answer with the transaction chronology and the treaty provision, not only with the statement that “the money stayed in the United States.” If the notice relies on a Form 1099-R, explain the code and provide the plan administrator’s document. If it relies on a bank credit, show the direct custodian-to-custodian chain.
A response should also separate the amount in dispute from other retirement income. Do not combine a direct rollover, a required minimum distribution, a Roth conversion, Social Security, and a brokerage sale into one line. The French administration may accept the treaty position for a qualifying private-plan distribution while asking different questions about another amount. A precise, event-by-event response avoids turning a narrow question into a dispute over the taxpayer’s entire retirement portfolio.
The administrative response should be checked against the treaty in force for the year. The consolidated treaty text, the 2004 protocol, and the 2009 amendment should be cited by link and date. The taxpayer should state whether the new IRA is traditional or Roth, whether the transfer was direct, whether the old plan paid anything to the participant, and whether the participant was resident in France on the relevant date. If any of those facts cannot be proved, the treaty conclusion should be qualified rather than overstated.
The most useful final document is a short “rollover certificate” file for future tax returns. It should contain the one-page chronology, the plan classification, the old and new custodian letters, the tax forms, the French residence evidence, the treaty analysis, the euro conversion method if any amount was received, and a note explaining why the transfer is not a Roth conversion or a taxable withdrawal. Keep a copy in both English and, where a French authority requests it, a careful French translation of the operative documents. A translation should not change the plan’s legal identity or the wording of a distribution code.
That file also helps with later events. If the traditional IRA eventually pays a distribution, the later payment must be analyzed separately. The fact that the IRA was funded by a rollover does not make every future payment a non-event. The future payment may be periodic, a lump sum, a required minimum distribution, an inherited-account payment, or a Roth conversion. The source-state treaty rule may still be relevant, but the supporting evidence must follow the later transaction.
For a French resident, the answer to “Do I report my 401(k) rollover in France?” is therefore more precise than yes or no. Report the facts needed to establish the event and the treaty position. Do not report a direct rollover as ordinary pension income merely because an account statement shows a large transfer. Do not omit a cash distribution or Roth conversion because the money was later placed in another retirement account. The correct position follows the legal sequence and the documents.
Conclusion
A direct rollover from a U.S. 401(k) to a traditional U.S. IRA after an American moves to France can be materially different from a withdrawal, a Roth conversion, or a required minimum distribution. French domestic law begins with residence and the broad concept of retirement income. The France–U.S. treaty then asks whether a qualifying retirement payment arises from a U.S.-established plan and whether the source-state rule applies. The treaty’s recognition of 401(a) plans and IRAs supports careful classification, but it does not eliminate the need to prove the actual transaction.
The practical safeguards are straightforward: use a direct custodian-to-custodian transfer when appropriate; identify the receiving account as a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA; preserve the plan and custodian confirmations; separate a rollover from a conversion and a distribution; keep the French residence and Form 2047 file; and record the treaty article used for the relevant tax year. If a French notice arrives, answer the exact characterization proposed by the administration and attach the payment-by-payment chronology.