KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can a French Bank Refuse to Open an Account for You Because You Are American? FATCA, the Right to an Account, and the Banque de France Procedure

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can a French Bank Refuse to Open an Account for You Because You Are American? FATCA, the Right to an Account, and the Banque de France Procedure

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have signed your lease in Lyon, your work contract in Paris, or the preliminary sale agreement on an apartment in Bordeaux — and the French bank at the corner of the street tells you, sometimes politely, sometimes not, that it does not open accounts for “U.S. persons.” For Americans living in France, or about to move, this scene is depressingly common. Entire retail banks have quietly adopted policies of turning away American customers because of the U.S. legislation known as FATCA — the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act — which obliges foreign banks to identify and report the accounts of U.S. taxpayers. The compliance burden is real for the banks. But the refusal is not necessarily legal — and French law gives you a powerful and fast remedy that most Americans have never heard of: the droit au compte, the right to an account, guaranteed by Article L. 312-1 of the Code monétaire et financier (the French Monetary and Financial Code) and enforced through the Banque de France, the French central bank.

This guide explains, first, why French banks turn Americans away and what FATCA actually requires of them under French law — because the answer is not “we are allowed to refuse you.” It then walks through the enforcement procedure step by step: the refusal certificate you are entitled to demand, the one-business-day designation of a bank by the Banque de France, the three-business-day deadline to open the account, the basic banking services you must receive, and the escalation routes — mediator, banking regulator, damages — when a bank still will not cooperate. Every legal reference below has been checked against the official texts currently in force.

I. Why can a French bank turn you away as an American — and what does the law actually allow?

A. What FATCA really requires of French banks under French law

FATCA is the U.S. legislation that obliges foreign financial institutions to identify and report accounts held by U.S. taxpayers, under fiscal consequences in the United States that no major French bank can afford to risk. France operates this exchange through its own law: French institutions report not to the IRS directly but to the French tax administration, the Direction générale des finances publiques, which is then authorized to pass the data to the tax administration of a State that has concluded an automatic-exchange convention with France. The provision you will actually meet at your branch is Article 1649 AC of the Code général des impôts (the French General Tax Code).

That tax code article matters to you as a customer because it is the legal basis on which your bank asks for your documents. In its current version, in force since January 1, 2023, Article 1649 AC, I, of the Code général des impôts provides that “Les teneurs de compte, les organismes d’assurance et assimilés et toute autre institution financière” — account-keeping institutions, insurance organizations and any other financial institution — must report, on a declaration filed under conditions and deadlines set by decree, the information required for the application of “des conventions conclues par la France permettant un échange automatique d’informations relatives aux comptes financiers en matière fiscale” — the conventions France has concluded that allow the automatic exchange of information on financial accounts for tax purposes. The same paragraph adds that, to satisfy these obligations, institutions “mettent en œuvre […] les diligences nécessaires à l’identification des comptes, des paiements et des personnes” — they must carry out the due diligence needed to identify accounts, payments and persons — and must collect the tax residences and, where applicable, the tax identification numbers of all account holders. This is why the branch asks for your U.S. Social Security number and a signed self-certification of your tax residences, and why you will hear the phrase “W-9” (the IRS form through which you certify your U.S. taxpayer identification number).

Two consequences follow, and Americans should hold both firmly in mind. First, FATCA compliance is mandatory for the bank, not optional: a French institution cannot lawfully open your account while refusing to collect your U.S. indicia, and you cannot negotiate your way out of the reporting. Second — and this is the part banks get wrong — nothing in FATCA, in the 2013 agreement, or in Article 1649 AC authorizes a bank to refuse you as a customer. The regime imposes reporting duties on accounts that exist; it does not create a screening right at the door. FATCA is settled law in France — but it is a reporting regime, not a license to exclude.

So why do banks still refuse? Cost and risk. The due-diligence burden for “U.S. person” accounts is disproportionate to the revenue a retail account generates, a mistaken classification can expose the institution to sanctions, and some groups have simply decided the segment is not worth it. Certain online banks and fintechs also rely on banking partners whose own policies exclude U.S. customers. None of these explanations appears anywhere in the statute books as a valid ground of refusal. Understanding this gap — between a real compliance burden and an imaginary right to refuse — is what makes the remedy described in Part II effective.

There is one genuine legal limit you should know, and it is not FATCA. Under French anti-money-laundering law, Article L. 561-8, I, of the Code monétaire et financier provides that when an institution “n’est pas en mesure de satisfaire” its customer due-diligence obligations — because the customer cannot be properly identified, for example — it must not execute any transaction and “n’établit ni ne poursuit aucune relation d’affaires”: it neither establishes nor continues any business relationship. A bank that cannot complete its know-your-customer file is therefore legally barred from opening the account. But note what this rule requires: an inability to complete due diligence, not a policy preference. An American who presents a passport, proof of address, and a Social Security number is perfectly identifiable. A refusal based on a blanket “no U.S. persons” policy is not an Article L. 561-8 situation — it is a commercial choice dressed up as compliance.

B. Your right to an account under Article L. 312-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code

Against these refusals stands one of the oldest protections of French banking law, steadily strengthened over the decades: the droit au compte. Article L. 312-1, I, of the Code monétaire et financier, in the version in force since December 27, 2021, states that “A droit à l’ouverture d’un compte de dépôt dans l’établissement de crédit de son choix, sous réserve d’être dépourvu d’un tel compte en France : 1° Toute personne physique ou morale domiciliée en France ; 2° Toute personne physique résidant légalement sur le territoire d’un autre Etat membre de l’Union européenne n’agissant pas pour des besoins professionnels ainsi que toute personne physique de nationalité française résidant hors de France.” In plain English: any individual or legal entity domiciled in France — provided they do not already hold a deposit account in France — has the right to open a deposit account at the credit institution of their choice, as do individuals legally resident in another EU member state acting for non-professional needs and French nationals living abroad.

Read that formulation again, because it is where the FATCA refusal collapses. The test is domicile in France — or legal residence elsewhere in the European Union for personal needs — not nationality. An American who has moved to France, signed a lease, taken a job, or bought a home and is domiciled there comes squarely within the first limb. U.S. citizenship is simply absent from the statutory criteria. A bank that tells you “we do not take Americans” is applying a criterion the law does not contain, while the law commands that you have the right to open an account in the institution of your choice.

The same article then organizes what happens when the chosen institution refuses. Under Article L. 312-1, II, a bank that refuses must provide you, free of charge, on paper, with the reasons for the refusal — “les motifs de ce refus” — mentioning where applicable the right-to-an-account procedure. And under paragraph III of the same article, the refusing institution must hand you “systématiquement, gratuitement et sans délai” — systematically, free of charge and without delay — an attestation de refus d’ouverture de compte, a written certificate of refusal, and inform you that you may ask the Banque de France to designate an institution that will have to open your account. The bank must even offer to transmit the designation request to the central bank on your behalf, acting in your name. If you have ever been refused orally at a counter and sent away with nothing, the bank has already failed one legal duty: the refusal certificate is not a favor, it is an obligation.

Three structural features of this right deserve emphasis for an American reader. First, it is a right against the banking system as a whole: if your chosen bank says no, the State, through the Banque de France, will pick another bank that cannot say no. Second, the account you obtain is not a second-class shell. Under Article L. 312-1, III, “Les établissements de crédit ainsi désignés par la Banque de France sont tenus d’offrir au titulaire du compte des services bancaires de base” — the institutions designated by the central bank are bound to offer the account holder basic banking services whose content and pricing are fixed by decree. Third, the mechanism is supervised. The banking accessibility charter adopted by the industry association under the same Article L. 312-1 is binding on every credit institution, and compliance with it is policed by the Autorité de contrôle prudentiel et de résolution (ACPR), the banking and insurance supervisor attached to the Banque de France.

The right also has a protective tail once the account is open. Article L. 312-1, IV exhaustively lists the only situations in which the designated bank may unilaterally close a basic-services account opened through the procedure: deliberate use of the account for operations the institution has reason to suspect are illegal, inaccurate information supplied by the customer, loss of the domicile or residence condition, opening of a second deposit account in France that allows the use of basic services, repeated incivility toward staff, or the anti-money-laundering situations of Article L. 561-8. Outside that closed list, closure is not permitted, and any termination requires a free letter, a stated reason (subject to narrow national-security and public-order exceptions), a minimum two-month notice period except in cases of illegal use or false information, and notification to the Banque de France. A designated bank that later discovers — as it already knew — that you are American has no statutory ground in that list to close your account.

II. How do you actually enforce the right to an account after a FATCA refusal?

A. The Banque de France designation procedure, step by step

The procedure is administrative and fast on paper. Here is how to run it in practice when a French bank refuses you.

Step one: apply properly and keep the evidence. Submit a complete account-opening request — passport, proof of address in France (a lease, a utility bill, a title deed), proof of income or status, and your self-certification of tax residence with your U.S. taxpayer identification number. Do this in writing or keep dated proof of the branch visit. A file that is objectively complete removes the bank’s easiest counter-argument, namely that it was still waiting for documents.

Step two: demand the attestation de refus. If the answer is no — or an endless “the compliance department is reviewing your file” — ask in writing for the written refusal certificate that Article L. 312-1, III obliges the institution to deliver systematically, free of charge and without delay, together with the statement of your right to seize the Banque de France. Put the demand in a registered letter if the branch stalls. The certificate, or the bank’s documented silence in the face of your demand, is the key that opens the next door.

Step three: seize the Banque de France. With the refusal certificate (and your application file), you apply to the central bank — in practice through its branch network or its dedicated online channel for the droit au compte — and ask it to designate an institution. The statute is blunt about timing: the Banque de France designates a credit institution near your home or another place you choose, taking into account the market shares of the institutions concerned; under Article L. 312-1, III, it acts “dans un délai d’un jour ouvré à compter de la réception des pièces requises” — within one business day of receiving the required documents, whose list is set by ministerial order. One business day. You may also mandate someone to act for you: at your request, the département, the family allowances fund, the municipal social services center, or a nonprofit assisting people in difficulty or an approved consumer association may transmit the request in your name, which is useful if your French is limited or you are still abroad part of the time.

Step four: the designated bank must open the account. Once designated, the institution is bound to offer you the basic banking services, and the same Article L. 312-1, III, “Ils procèdent à l’ouverture du compte de dépôt dans les trois jours ouvrés à compter de la réception de l’ensemble des pièces qui lui sont nécessaires à cet effet” — designated institutions open the deposit account within three business days of receiving everything they need. The relationship is then governed by a written account agreement.

What exactly do you get? The basic services are fixed by Article D. 312-5 of the Code monétaire et financier, in force since April 1, 2018, which lists ten of them: the opening, maintenance and closing of the account; one change of address per year; bank identity certificates (relevés d’identité bancaire, the French equivalent of account details for receiving transfers); the domiciliation of bank transfers; a monthly statement of transactions; the cashing of checks and transfers; payments by SEPA direct debit, SEPA interbank payment order or SEPA credit transfer, including at the counter or remotely; remote access to the account balance; cash deposits and withdrawals at the counter or the institution’s ATMs; and a payment card usable in particular for online payments and cash withdrawals within the European Union. In other words: everything an American settling in France actually needs — receive a salary or a pension, pay rent and utilities by SEPA debit, hold a card, withdraw cash. You will not get an overdraft or a checkbook with credit facilities through this channel, and the card is typically a systematic-authorization card, but the account is real, functional, and legally guaranteed.

The pricing is capped too. Under Article R. 312-4-2 of the Code monétaire et financier, the specific ceilings applicable to account-incident fees for holders of a basic-services account opened through the designation procedure are fixed at 4 euros per operation and 20 euros per month — well below the general ceilings of 8 euros per operation and 80 euros per month that Article R. 312-4-1 of the same code sets for the account-incident fees of other customers. And the fragility regime of Article L. 312-1-3 adds a specific offer, at a controlled price, for customers in situations of financial fragility, which the bank must proactively propose when the criteria are met.

Does the procedure actually work when the designated bank drags its feet? The courts say yes — with a precision worth understanding before you claim damages. In Cour d’appel de Versailles, 16e chambre, 21 December 2023, n° 22/05426, a customer had been designated to a Crédit Agricole branch by the Banque de France on November 16, 2017, and the bank kept raising obstacles — including the prior closure of an old account and a mismatch in his birth records. The court of appeal confirmed the fault: once the customer had supplied, by letter received on January 13, 2018, all the explanations and documents needed, the bank could no longer lawfully refuse, and a designated bank could not validly oppose the earlier closure of an account “y compris au motif d’impayés non recouvrés” — even on the ground of unrecovered arrears. The judgment ordering the bank to open the account under a penalty payment was upheld, and so was the award of 2,000 euros in repair of the “préjudice moral consécutif au maintien à ce jour du refus d’ouverture de compte de la banque sans motif légitime” — the moral prejudice resulting from the bank’s unjustified refusal maintained up to that day. But the customer’s larger claim failed, for a reason that disciplines your own demand: the court noted that payment products of the “Nickel” type remain open to everyone, including persons under a banking prohibition, and provide a bank identity statement, an IBAN, online transfers, deposits and card payment, so the alleged prejudice of being deprived of those services could not result from the refusal, “bien que fautif” — albeit wrongful. The lesson is double. An unjustified refusal by a designated bank is a civil fault that costs the bank money. And the compensable prejudice is the unjustified refusal itself, so build your claim on the duration and concrete impact of the refusal, not on the theoretical unavailability of basic payment services.

B. Escalation beyond designation: mediator, supervisor, damages — and the real limits

Suppose the procedure jams. The branch refuses to issue the refusal certificate; the designated bank invents new document demands every week; or your account is opened and then, months later, the bank’s “U.S. persons policy” resurfaces in a closure letter. French law offers a graduated arsenal.

First, the internal and mediation track. Start with the bank’s customer-relations service, then escalate to the médiateur bancaire, the banking ombudsman. Article L. 316-1 of the Code monétaire et financier states that “Tout consommateur a droit de recourir gratuitement à un médiateur” — every consumer has the right to refer a dispute with a credit institution to a mediator free of charge — for litigation concerning the services provided and the performance of contracts within the banking title of the code. The same article requires each mediator to send an annual activity report to the governor of the Banque de France, which keeps the channel visible to the central bank that also runs the designation procedure. In parallel, you may alert the ACPR, which supervises compliance with the banking accessibility charter — including the model refusal certificate and the information duties of Article L. 312-1, III — through the formal-notice and injunction procedure of Article L. 612-31 of the same code, under which the supervisor may order any supervised institution to take, within a set deadline, all measures needed to bring it into compliance. A supervisory complaint does not itself award you damages, but a bank that receives a regulator’s letter about a droit au compte file tends to rediscover its obligations promptly.

Second, the judicial track. The Versailles decision discussed above is the template: the bank’s fault lies in refusing or delaying without a legitimate ground, and the moral prejudice resulting from the refusal maintained over time is compensable — 2,000 euros in that case, where the bank had held out for years after the designation. Document everything from day one: the dated application, the documents handed over, the refusal (or the absence of any answer to your written demand for the certificate), the designation letter, and every subsequent exchange. Judges decide these cases on paper trails, and the statutory deadlines — one business day for the designation, three business days for the opening — give you objective benchmarks against which delay is measured.

Third, know the boundaries so that you do not waste a claim. Three refusals are lawful. A bank may refuse if you already hold a deposit account in France: the right to an account is a right of last resort, and even a joint account does not block you, since Article L. 312-1, I specifies that holding a collective account is no obstacle to the right to an individual account — but a genuinely existing personal account in your name does. A bank may refuse if you are not within the personal scope: neither domiciled in France, nor legally resident in another EU state for non-professional needs, nor a French national abroad. A non-resident American buying a holiday home, for instance, is outside the statutory right while still in the United States — the protection attaches to your installation, not your passport. And a bank must refuse where Article L. 561-8 genuinely prevents the business relationship because due diligence cannot be completed. Being American, again, is none of these things.

There is also a strategic point worth stating plainly. If one bank has refused you for FATCA reasons, nothing prevents you from trying a second institution while the Banque de France procedure runs its course: the right to an account is a safety net, not an exclusive remedy, and several French retail networks do accept American customers with complete FATCA documentation. If you already hold a French account but the bank has frozen it over a missing W-9 certification, that is a different problem, with different mechanics — our guide on remedies when a French bank freezes your account over a missing W-9 covers it. And if the banking problem arises in the middle of a property purchase — the most common trigger, since the notaire’s escrow, the bridging loan, and the direct debits all presuppose a functioning French account — the coordination with your acquisition timeline is addressed in our legal checklist for Americans buying property in France. For retirees who need a French account to receive a pension and are still sorting out their French tax status, our guide on obtaining a French tax number and filing a first French tax return explains the fiscal side of the installation.

One last nuance on proof. Banks rarely write “we refuse because of FATCA.” The certificate they must deliver will typically invoke an internal commercial policy or no reason at all. That does not weaken your position: the droit au compte does not require you to prove that the refusal was discriminatory or FATCA-driven. It requires you to prove that you asked, that your file was complete, and that the bank said no or stayed silent. The cause of the refusal is the bank’s problem, not yours; the remedy runs regardless.

Conclusion

FATCA explains why French banks are nervous about American customers; it does not excuse turning them away. The reporting architecture anchored in Article 1649 AC of the General Tax Code obliges banks to declare accounts to the French tax administration for automatic exchange under France’s international conventions — it does not authorize them to refuse customers, and Article L. 312-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code gives any person domiciled in France, regardless of citizenship, a right to a deposit account at the institution of their choice. When the institution says no, the attestation de refus, the Banque de France designation within one business day, the account opening within three business days, the ten basic services of Article D. 312-5, and the fee caps of Article R. 312-4-2 form a complete and court-enforced remedy — as the Versailles Court of Appeal reminded a reluctant bank in December 2023, with an order to open the account under penalty and damages at the end.

The practical sequence for an American refused in France is therefore: complete written application; written demand for the refusal certificate; seizure of the Banque de France; account opening at the designated institution; and, if obstruction persists, mediator, ACPR complaint, and a damages action on the strength of the statutory deadlines. None of this requires litigation against FATCA itself. It requires only the methodical use of rights that already exist.

📄 Official circular