A French bank may ask an American customer for a Form W-9, a U.S. tax-identification form, when it is updating the customer’s tax-residence information under FATCA, the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act. That request is usually a compliance step, not proof that the customer has committed an offence. It can nevertheless become urgent when the bank blocks card payments, transfers, withdrawals, or access to online banking. French law draws a careful distinction between identifying a customer, reporting a financial account for tax purposes, restricting operations because required information is missing, and terminating an existing account. Those are different legal events with different evidence and remedies. This guide explains what an American with an existing French bank account should ask for, what documents to prepare, how the France–U.S. reporting rules interact with French anti-money-laundering duties, and when a refusal or closure may be challenged. It does not decide whether a particular tax form is correct for your U.S. filing position; a tax adviser may need to review that question separately. The immediate objective is to create a written record, restore lawful access where possible, and avoid signing away claims before the bank has stated precisely what it is doing.
I. Why is a French bank asking an American customer for a W-9?
A. What do FATCA and French auto-certification actually require?
FATCA is a United States federal law designed to identify financial accounts held by U.S. taxpayers outside the United States. It is not a French tax and it does not make every French account taxable in France. France and the United States implement the system through an intergovernmental agreement signed in Paris on November 14, 2013. Under that arrangement, French financial institutions collect information, determine which accounts are reportable, and transmit the required information through the French tax administration rather than sending every customer’s file directly to the Internal Revenue Service. The official French text of the France–United States FATCA agreement is the starting point for the international framework.
The word “W-9” is often used loosely in cross-border banking conversations. IRS Form W-9 is the U.S. Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification. A French bank may ask for the actual IRS form, a U.S. Social Security number or Individual Taxpayer Identification Number, or a French bank’s own form that collects equivalent information. Those documents are not interchangeable. A U.S. citizen normally should not sign a form designed to certify that the customer is a non-U.S. person. Conversely, a person who is not a U.S. taxpayer should not describe the account as belonging to a U.S. person simply because the person once lived in the United States. Ask the bank exactly which document it needs and why its secure channel identifies it as a W-9.
French law uses a broader concept called auto-certification, meaning a customer’s statement of tax residence and, where applicable, tax identification number. The official French tax administration FAQ on tax residence and tax identification numbers calls the request “Il s’agit de la demande d’auto-certification.” That French expression should be explained, not treated as a request for a full income-tax return. The bank is trying to establish where the account holder is tax resident and which tax number should be associated with that residence. U.S. citizenship can be an indicator of U.S. status, but citizenship, residence, and the place where income is earned are separate questions.
Article 1649 AC of the French General Tax Code requires financial institutions to carry out the steps needed to identify reportable accounts and the persons connected with them. The statute says that institutions “collectent à cette fin les éléments relatifs aux résidences fiscales” and, where relevant, tax identification numbers. It also requires account holders to provide the information needed to identify their tax residences and numbers. In plain English, a French bank is not asking for a W-9 because the bank has already calculated that an American owes French tax. It is asking for information that allows the institution to apply automatic exchange-of-information rules correctly.
The account can be relevant even when it contains no U.S.-source income. The administrative guidance explains that a reportable financial account can include a deposit account, a custody account, certain insurance contracts, and other financial products. A normal French checking account can therefore create a FATCA documentation question even if the customer uses it only to pay rent, utilities, insurance, or household expenses. The French tax guidance on the FATCA agreement and financial accounts describes a deposit account as including current, savings, and checking accounts. The fact that a customer’s balance is small does not by itself answer whether documentation must be refreshed.
An American who has moved between the United States and France should prepare a residence timeline. List the dates of moves, the address used with each bank, the countries where the customer was tax resident, and the tax numbers issued by those countries. A person can be a U.S. citizen while being resident for French tax purposes. A person can also have a French home without being French tax resident for every year. The bank’s question concerns the status that must be reported for the relevant period, not a simple label such as “expat.” If a spouse, trust, company, or other person controls the account, identify that person as well; the bank may need information about the bénéficiaire effectif, the natural person who ultimately owns or controls the funds.
The official French FAQ also describes a timing rule after a second request. It states that the account holder has 30 days to respond after that second request and that the bank may communicate the customer’s identity to the tax administration if the information is not supplied. It also records a specific exception to the €1,500 penalty where the customer could not provide an auto-certification because of U.S. tax residence or U.S. nationality and could not provide a U.S. Tax Identification Number. That exception does not mean that an American can ignore a bank’s request. It means that the customer should explain the precise difficulty instead of silently allowing the file to be classified as a refusal to cooperate.
Article L102 AG of the French Tax Procedure Code describes the information transmitted after a second request and the expiry of 30 days, while expressly addressing the France–U.S. FATCA agreement. Article 1740 C of the French General Tax Code refers to a €1,500 penalty for a failure to provide the required information, but its text also contains the FATCA-related exception. These provisions should be read with the customer’s facts and the current bank notice. They do not authorize a customer to select a tax status merely to unlock an account, and they do not convert every administrative delay into a criminal accusation.
It is also important to separate FATCA from the France–United States income-tax treaty. The treaty allocates taxing rights and addresses double-taxation questions; it does not guarantee access to a French bank account. The French government publishes the France–United States convention on income and wealth taxes separately from the FATCA agreement. A customer may need the treaty for a tax-residence or income question, but invoking an article of the treaty will not replace a missing customer-identification document or answer the bank’s operational question about which account holder controls the funds.
Finally, understand what the bank is allowed to retain. Article L. 561-12 of the French Monetary and Financial Code requires regulated institutions to preserve customer and vigilance documents for five years after the account is closed or the relationship ends, subject to more demanding rules. This does not give a customer a veto over lawful record keeping. It does mean that a customer can ask what information is missing, which purpose it serves, and through which secure process it should be provided. Keep the bank’s request, your response, and the submission receipt together. That file may later show whether the issue was a simple data mismatch or a genuine dispute about account access.
B. Does the request itself authorize a freeze or closure?
No general rule says that an existing French account must be frozen merely because its American owner received a W-9 request. The legal analysis depends on the bank’s stated action and on the information that remains unresolved. A request for tax residence is one event. A message saying “payments temporarily unavailable” is another. A notice terminating the account is a third. Before arguing about the merits, identify which of these has occurred. A customer who calls every event a “closure” may miss a short deadline for supplying documents or may overlook that the bank has already begun a contractual notice period.
French anti-money-laundering rules add a separate layer. Article L. 561-5 of the French Monetary and Financial Code requires the relevant institutions to identify their clients and, when applicable, the beneficial owner, and to verify the information with a probative written document. The statutory wording includes “Identifient leur client et, le cas échéant, le bénéficiaire effectif.” A passport can establish identity, but it may not establish the source of funds, the controlling person, the tax residence, or the reason for a large incoming transfer. That is why a bank may request several documents at once.
Article L. 561-6 of the same Code requires continuing vigilance throughout the business relationship. It describes a “vigilance constante” and an attentive examination of transactions so that they remain consistent with the institution’s updated knowledge of the relationship. An American customer who has changed address, become a French tax resident, started receiving pension payments, sold property, or transferred a large inheritance can therefore trigger a review years after opening the account. The review may be lawful even if the customer has never missed a payment and the account has always been in credit.
If the institution cannot meet its customer-identification obligations, Article L. 561-8 of the Monetary and Financial Code says that it does not execute operations and does not establish or continue a business relationship. The text uses the words “n’établit ni ne poursuit aucune relation d’affaires.” This provision explains why a bank may restrict operations when a genuine identification failure remains unresolved. It does not establish that an American’s nationality, by itself, is an identification failure. Nor does it answer whether a bank that has already received sufficient information acted proportionately when it blocked all access without explaining what was missing.
Tax-reporting identification has a more specific provision. Article L. 564-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code says that an institution unable to identify tax residence and, where applicable, tax identification numbers “n’établit pas de relation contractuelle.” The second paragraph expressly states that the first paragraph does not apply to implementation of the France–United States FATCA agreement signed on November 14, 2013. The provision is therefore not a simple statutory instruction to close every existing American account when a W-9 is late. It must be reconciled with the FATCA arrangement, the bank’s customer contract, the anti-money-laundering rules, and the precise operational restriction imposed.
That distinction between a new relationship and an existing one is central. Article L. 564-1 speaks about not establishing a contractual relationship. An account that has operated for years already has a convention de compte, meaning the written account agreement between the customer and the bank. The bank may still have legal grounds to restrict operations, request updated information, or end the relationship, but the customer should ask the bank to name the ground rather than accepting the shorthand “FATCA requires us to freeze you.” A demand for the exact clause and the exact missing item is reasonable and makes the discussion more precise.
For an ordinary indefinite deposit-account agreement, Article L. 312-1-1, V of the Monetary and Financial Code states that the bank terminates with at least two months’ notice supplied on paper or another durable medium. The French text says: “L’établissement de crédit résilie une convention de compte de dépôt conclue pour une durée indéterminée moyennant un préavis d’au moins deux mois.” This is a rule about termination of the account agreement, not a promise that every transaction must remain available during an anti-money-laundering investigation or a judicial seizure. Read the notice, the account terms, and the stated effective date together.
The Cour de cassation, France’s highest court for private-law disputes, applied that notice logic in a banking dispute decided on June 12, 2024, commercial chamber, no. 22-13.226. In the official decision, the bank had blocked a card and transfers before the second notice period that the bank itself had set had expired. The Court held that the lower court could find a fault that justified compensation. The ruling is not a FATCA decision and does not prevent a bank from acting under a valid anti-money-laundering or judicial restriction. Its practical lesson is narrower: a bank should not announce a contractual end date and then ignore that date by disabling ordinary account use without a separate legal basis.
The opposite risk is also real. In a commercial-account case, the Cour de cassation rejected a claim on February 14, 2006, commercial chamber, no. 04-16.464. The official decision described unusually large and unexplained transactions and held that the bank had not abused its right to terminate the indefinite account relationship without notice in that fact pattern. The Court’s wording refers to a bank that “n’avait pas abusé de son droit de rompre, même sans préavis.” That case involved a company and evidence of suspected transaction circuits, not an American individual who merely received a W-9 request. It is useful because it shows why the factual reason for a restriction matters: a documented transaction risk is not the same as a nationality flag or a missing tax form alone.
A third decision, commercial chamber, November 3, 2010, no. 09-69.533, concerned a joint account in the context of redressement judiciaire, the French court-supervised reorganization procedure. The official Légifrance decision discusses the interaction between the account relationship, insolvency rules, and the contractual notice provisions of Article L. 312-1-1. It should not be cited as a FATCA rule. Its value for an American customer is methodological: an account freeze can be governed by a special regime, and the correct answer depends on the event the bank is relying on. If the notice mentions a court order, seizure, insolvency, fraud concern, or sanctions screening, the customer needs advice on that stated ground rather than a generic argument about W-9 forms.
Do not assume that the bank must disclose whether it filed a suspicious-transaction report. Article L. 561-15 of the Monetary and Financial Code governs declarations to the French anti-money-laundering service, Tracfin, when the institution knows or suspects that sums or operations arise from specified offences or tax fraud. The existence of that statutory reporting channel is not proof that a W-9 request concerns suspicious activity. A bank may be unable to give the customer every internal reason, but it can still identify the operational documents required, the status of the account, the available complaint channel, and the process for transferring undisputed funds.
The “right to an account” is often misunderstood in this situation. Article L. 312-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code gives certain eligible people a right to have a deposit account opened, provided they are without such an account in France. The text begins: “A droit à l’ouverture d’un compte de dépôt” and provides a Banque de France designation procedure after a refusal. The official Service-Public explanation of the right to an account describes the refusal certificate and the Banque de France process. That mechanism generally addresses refusal to open a new account. It does not automatically reopen the existing account that a bank has frozen, and eligibility for an American living outside France must be examined separately.
The strongest first argument is therefore usually not “FATCA is illegal.” It is: “Please identify whether this is a document request, a temporary restriction, a termination notice, or a final refusal; identify the missing item and the legal or contractual basis; confirm the actions still permitted; and give me a secure way to respond.” That request preserves cooperation and creates a record. It also prevents a customer from sending a tax form to the wrong address, disclosing a Social Security number in an unsecured email, or signing a closure document without knowing whether a two-month notice period has begun.
II. What can an American do when access to a French account is frozen?
A. Which documents and written steps should come first?
Start by classifying the restriction in writing. Save the bank’s message, the date and time the restriction appeared, screenshots of any online-banking warning, the last successful card or transfer operation, and the names of employees or departments involved. Ask whether the account is fully blocked or whether only particular services are unavailable. Ask whether incoming transfers, salary or pension payments, direct debits, card payments, cash withdrawals, and transfers to another account are each treated differently. A customer should not guess whether “frozen” means that funds cannot leave the account, that a card is disabled, or that the bank has already given notice of termination.
Use the bank’s secure portal or the address identified in the account agreement. Verify the domain before sending a Social Security number, passport, or tax form. If the bank permits secure upload, keep the upload receipt and the file names. If it asks for an email response, request confirmation of the approved channel. A W-9 contains sensitive personal information. Do not send it to an estate agent, an employee’s personal address, or a number copied from an unverified text message. If a translation is requested, preserve the original English document and ask whether a translation must be certified. Do not alter the substantive answers merely to make the form look more “French.”
Build a clean identity and tax-residence pack. It should normally contain the following, adapted to the bank’s request:
- A valid passport or other identity document, with the name matching the account record.
- Proof of current address and, where relevant, the French address used for the account.
- A written list of every tax residence for the period requested by the bank.
- The U.S. Social Security number or Individual Taxpayer Identification Number, if the customer has one and the bank requires it.
- The French tax identification number, if one has been issued, and the date on which the customer became or ceased to be French tax resident.
- The requested Form W-9 or the bank’s own auto-certification form, completed consistently with the customer’s actual status.
- Information identifying a joint holder, trustee, company, or other person who controls the funds.
- Evidence explaining a recent change, such as a move, marriage, inheritance, property sale, retirement, or change in employment.
Do not attach a full tax file unless the request calls for it. A tax residence certification is not automatically a request for every return filed in the United States. If the bank needs income, source-of-funds, or transaction evidence under its anti-money-laundering review, it should say so. Those documents may include a closing statement for a French property, probate or inheritance records, pension statements, brokerage statements, loan documents, or evidence of a transfer from a U.S. account. Give the document that answers the question. An unexplained 200-page archive can conceal the relevant evidence and create unnecessary privacy risk.
Reconcile names and addresses across documents. American records can contain a middle name, a former married name, a state abbreviation, or a mailing address that differs from the residence address. French records may use a second family name or a different order of names. Prepare a short explanation for each mismatch and attach proof of the change when available. If the bank’s automated system rejects a valid number because of formatting, ask a human compliance department to review the file. The fact that an online form fails does not establish that the customer refused to cooperate.
Answer the tax-residence question precisely. If the customer is a U.S. citizen living in France, say so and identify the relevant French tax residence if that is the factual position. If the customer has returned to the United States and retains a French account, do not continue to describe the French address as the only residence if that is no longer true. If the customer is a dual citizen, explain the status in the bank’s requested format. The bank is not asking the customer to choose the country with the lower tax. It is asking for a factual certification used in reporting.
If the customer lacks a U.S. TIN, explain why and ask what alternative evidence the bank accepts. The official French tax guidance recognizes that some Americans may be unable to provide a TIN, and the statutory penalty provisions contain an exception connected with U.S. residence or nationality. That does not mean every bank system will unlock automatically. A written explanation, proof of the application for an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number where relevant, and a request for a temporary compliance solution are more useful than leaving the field blank without comment.
Send a focused written request. It can say, in substance:
Please confirm whether the restriction concerns an outstanding tax-residence or tax-identification document, an anti-money-laundering review, a contractual termination, a judicial measure, or another reason. Please identify the account services currently restricted, the documents still required, the secure channel for delivery, and the date by which the response is needed. I am ready to provide the requested information and ask that the account remain operational to the extent permitted while the review is completed. If the bank intends to terminate the account, please send the formal notice, the effective date, the contractual clause relied on, the procedure for transferring the remaining balance, and the complaint and mediation contacts.
That wording is deliberately neutral. It does not accuse the bank of discrimination, threaten a regulator, or admit that the customer breached the account agreement. It asks for a classification and a remedy. If the bank has already sent a formal closure notice, respond before the deadline in that notice while reserving the right to challenge the restriction. If no deadline is stated, ask for one. Keep the response in English if that is the working language, and add a French translation only if the bank requires it or if counsel advises that it will reduce ambiguity.
Keep a dated chronology. Record when the bank first asked for the W-9, when the customer supplied it, whether the bank requested a second form, when access was blocked, and whether any payments were rejected. Identify direct consequences: rent, mortgage, tax, insurance, healthcare, payroll, or utility payments that could not be made. Save evidence of fees, returned payments, exchange-rate losses, and emergency borrowing. A claim for compensation usually needs proof of a wrongful act, causation, and an actual loss. A spreadsheet with dates and documents is more persuasive than a general statement that the freeze was stressful.
Separate account access from U.S. tax reporting. A French bank’s FATCA file does not by itself determine whether the customer must file an FBAR, Form 8938, or another U.S. return. Conversely, having made every U.S. filing does not prove that the French bank has current customer-identification information. If the customer is unsure whether to sign a W-9, obtain U.S. tax advice before signing. If the question is whether the bank’s freeze, notice, or refusal complied with French contract and banking law, obtain French legal advice. These questions often overlap, but one professional should not be assumed to answer both.
If a transfer is urgent, ask the bank to identify a permitted route for essential payments. That might mean allowing direct debits, transferring funds to an account in the customer’s own name after verification, or arranging a controlled withdrawal. Do not ask a friend or intermediary to receive the funds merely to bypass the restriction. A third-party transfer can create a new beneficial-owner and source-of-funds issue. If there is a genuine court seizure or a sanctions restriction, attempting to route money around it can worsen the situation. Make the request in writing and ask the bank to state what remains legally available.
B. Which remedies apply to a refusal, freeze, or closure?
Use a staged escalation. First, submit a complete response to the bank’s operational or compliance department. Second, make a formal complaint to the bank’s service réclamations, the complaints department identified in the account terms. The complaint should attach the request, the customer’s documents, the proof of delivery, the freeze notice, and a short chronology. Ask for a case number and a written answer. A complaint that simply says “FATCA is unfair” makes it easy to respond with a template. A complaint that identifies a missing document, a notice date, a blocked transfer, and a requested correction gives the bank something to investigate.
Ask the bank to distinguish three outcomes: restoration of normal access, continued restricted access while documents are reviewed, or termination with a transfer of the balance. A customer may accept a lawful account closure while still challenging an unlawful period of blocked access or an inaccurate report. Conversely, accepting a new account elsewhere does not necessarily waive damages or a request for records. State which outcome is sought and which rights are reserved. If the bank says that it cannot explain an internal suspicion, ask it to identify the documents and practical steps it can disclose without requesting the content of a possible suspicious-transaction report.
If the bank sends a termination notice for an indefinite account, check the notice method and effective date against Article L. 312-1-1, V and the account agreement. The notice should not be treated as interchangeable with a temporary review message. In the 2024 decision no. 22-13.226, the Cour de cassation focused on the fact that the bank blocked card use and transfers before the end of a notice period the bank had itself set. The customer should identify whether the same timing problem exists, while recognizing that a separate statutory restriction can change the analysis.
The next route may be the bank mediator. In France, a médiateur is an independent dispute-resolution contact designated under the bank’s customer process. The account documents and the closure letter should explain how to contact the mediator and whether the complaint must first be made to the bank. Mediation can be useful for a communication failure, a disputed notice date, a request for documents, or compensation for a proven service error. It may not decide every matter involving anti-money-laundering secrecy, a judicial seizure, sanctions, or a commercial account. Send the mediator a concise record and do not assume that starting mediation automatically suspends a closure date.
The Autorité de contrôle prudentiel et de résolution, known as the ACPR, is France’s banking and insurance supervisory authority. A customer can report a difficulty through the appropriate public channel, but the ACPR is not a private court and normally does not order a bank to pay damages or reopen a particular account on the customer’s demand. A supervisory report can still be useful when a bank repeatedly gives contradictory information, fails to use the required complaint process, or appears to disregard an applicable customer-protection rule. Treat it as a regulatory signal, not as a substitute for a formal claim or an urgent application.
The Banque de France “right to an account” procedure is available only in the situations defined by law. Under Article L. 312-1, the person must generally be eligible and without a qualifying deposit account in France. The bank that refuses a new account must provide a refusal certificate and information about the Banque de France designation procedure. An American who still has a French deposit account, even if access is restricted, may not satisfy that condition. An American living in France may have a different eligibility analysis from an American who lives in California and keeps a French account for occasional travel. Establish eligibility before presenting the procedure as a solution.
If the bank has closed the account or refused access to funds and the dispute cannot be resolved, a French civil claim may seek one or more of the following, depending on the facts: performance of a contractual obligation, compensation for a wrongful restriction, return of funds, correction of inaccurate information, or an order concerning the notice process. An urgent interim application may be considered when the evidence shows an immediate and serious harm, but emergency relief is not automatic and a court will examine the bank’s stated legal basis. The claim should identify the contract, the precise operation blocked, the documents supplied, the bank’s response, and the measurable consequence.
The 2006 decision no. 04-16.464 shows the evidentiary problem from the bank’s side. The official ruling accepted the absence of notice in a commercial case because the bank had concrete reasons to suspect abnormal transaction activity and the customer had not adequately explained it. That does not make every bank’s suspicion correct. It does mean that a customer should answer source-of-funds questions with actual records, not only a statement that the money is legitimate. If the bank’s request concerns a property sale, inheritance, trust, or business payment, send the document that connects the funds to the customer.
Conversely, the customer should challenge a freeze that has no intelligible scope or end point. Ask for the date of the next review, the documents needed to complete it, and the mechanism for making ordinary essential payments. If the bank says it is terminating the account, ask when the balance will be transferred and whether the customer must provide a receiving account in the same name. If the bank refuses to confirm whether a transfer is pending, preserve the unanswered request. Silence can become important evidence when the customer later proves that the bank was given a reasonable opportunity to correct an operational error.
Be careful with a proposed release or closure agreement. A document titled résiliation amiable may end the relationship by consent. A décharge may release claims. An avenant may change the account terms. A customer should check whether the document confirms the reason for closure, waives compensation, authorizes disclosure of tax information, or permits the bank to retain fees. Do not sign simply because the bank promises that the money will be released. Ask for the release date, amount, deductions, destination account, and the legal effect of each clause.
If a bank has reported an incorrect tax residence or U.S. status, ask for correction through the bank’s data-protection and complaint channels. Article 1649 AC requires information about potential transfers of personal data in the automatic exchange system, and the current text states that the account holder supplies the information needed for that identification. A correction request should specify the incorrect field, the correct information, the supporting document, and the date by which the customer needs confirmation. Do not assume that correcting a tax-reporting field alone will resolve a separate anti-money-laundering concern.
When a customer believes the restriction is discriminatory because of U.S. nationality, the evidence should focus on the treatment and the comparator, not the label alone. Gather the bank’s written explanation, the documents requested from similarly situated account holders if lawfully available, the timing of the restriction, and any statement that the bank will not serve U.S. citizens. A bank can make a risk-based decision under its regulatory duties, but it should not be allowed to disguise an operational error as an unexplained nationality rule. A French lawyer can assess whether the facts support a contract, consumer, data, or discrimination claim and which forum has jurisdiction.
For future account openings, ask questions before transferring substantial funds. Confirm whether the institution accepts U.S. citizens, which FATCA documents it uses, whether it will keep a nonresident account, how often it refreshes tax-residence information, and how it handles a customer without a U.S. TIN. Keep a second payment route for rent, insurance, taxes, and healthcare. Do not make the backup account a way to hide ownership or bypass a lawful restriction; it is simply protection against an operational interruption. A written onboarding answer can also be valuable if the bank later changes its position.
A written French account agreement should be treated as evidence, not background paperwork. Locate the clauses on termination, notice, card suspension, transfers, customer information, complaints, mediation, and the destination of remaining funds. Compare the French text with any English translation. If the bank refers to a clause, copy the complete clause and the version in force when the account was opened or amended. The Cour de cassation’s decisions show why the chronology and contractual wording matter. In a dispute, a bank’s general statement that it may “close at any time” does not answer whether the notice, method, timing, and reason were lawful in this customer’s circumstances.
Finally, keep the practical objective in view. If access can be restored by supplying a correct auto-certification, respond quickly and keep proof. If the bank will not continue the relationship, arrange a lawful transfer of funds and challenge any separate wrongful freeze. If the bank’s explanation concerns suspected transactions, provide source-of-funds evidence and obtain advice before making allegations. If an urgent payment has failed, quantify the loss and seek a proportionate remedy. The best case file tells a court, mediator, regulator, or new bank exactly what happened, what the customer supplied, what the bank did next, and what remains unresolved.
Conclusion
A French bank’s request for a W-9 or other FATCA documentation does not automatically prove misconduct and does not automatically authorize a blanket freeze of an existing American customer’s account. French law separates tax-residence reporting, customer identification, continuing anti-money-laundering vigilance, contractual termination, and judicial or regulatory restrictions. Start by asking the bank to classify the action and identify the missing document, legal basis, affected services, deadline, and secure response channel. Provide a consistent identity and tax-residence pack, preserve every receipt, and document the direct consequences of the restriction. If the bank closes an indefinite account, compare the notice and timing with Article L. 312-1-1 and the written account agreement. Use the internal complaint process, mediation, regulatory reporting, or a French court according to the bank’s stated ground and the urgency. The right to an account may help an eligible person who has been refused a new account, but it is not a universal mechanism for reopening an existing frozen account. The legal answer will turn on the notice, the documents, the chronology, and the difference between a genuine compliance obstacle and an unsupported operational decision.