Foreign nationals who hold a residence document from Italy, Spain or another European Union Member State may sometimes be ordered to leave France and be returned to that State. French law also allows the administration, in some cases, to add an interdiction de circulation sur le territoire français (ban on travelling in French territory). These measures are not identical to an OQTF and do not follow exactly the same litigation rules. Their legality depends on the legal route used, the document held in the other State, the evidence of the stay in France and the chronology of the readmission request.
This guide explains the practical issues for foreign residents, families, employers and advisers. It focuses on decisions returning a non-EU national to another Member State, especially Italy, and on the evidence needed to challenge an accompanying movement ban. It does not predict the outcome of any individual case. The first task is to identify the exact decision, the date and time of notification, and whether the person has been placed in administrative detention or assigned to residence.
For readers who need broader assistance with French immigration procedures, the firm’s English-language France immigration lawyer service in Paris provides a separate point of entry. The legal analysis below remains specific to return decisions and movement bans.
I. How a return decision and a movement ban operate
A. Identify the legal basis, the foreign residence document and the readmission file
The starting point is la décision de remise (return decision to another State). Article L. 621-1 of the CESEDA describes the mechanism as an exception to several ordinary removal procedures: a foreign national may be handed over to the competent authorities of another State under international conventions or European Union law when one of the statutory situations applies. The provision also requires a written and reasoned decision and an opportunity to submit observations. The current text is available in the official Article L. 621-1 of the CESEDA.
Article L. 621-2 concerns a person admitted to enter or stay in another Member State who has entered or stayed in France without complying with the applicable conditions. Article L. 621-4 addresses a more specific situation: a non-EU national holding a valid EU long-term resident permit issued by another Member State and staying irregularly in France. Those are different legal situations. A decision that cites the wrong provision may create an argument, but the court may examine whether another legal basis can lawfully be substituted if the procedural guarantees and the administration’s discretion are preserved.
The distinction mattered in CAA de Toulouse, 14 November 2024, no. 23TL02281. The applicant held a Spanish EU long-term resident permit. The prefect had relied on Article L. 621-2, whereas the court identified Article L. 621-4 as the relevant basis. The court stated that substitution was possible because the factual situation corresponded to Article L. 621-4, the substitution did not remove a procedural guarantee and the administration retained the same power of assessment. The practical lesson is that a challenge should not stop at the citation of an incorrect article. It should explain why the conditions of the alternative article are not met, or why the substitution would deprive the person of a guarantee.
The foreign document must therefore be identified precisely. A copy of an Italian or Spanish card is not enough on its own if the court cannot determine its category, validity, holder, duration or territorial effect. The file should include both sides of the card, the passport pages showing identity and travel, renewal evidence and, where relevant, an official translation or explanatory document. A long-term EU resident card is particularly important because it triggers additional protection against a movement ban under Article L. 622-2.
The readmission chronology is equally important. In the Italian cases, the relevant bilateral agreement required the request to be transmitted within three months of the discovery of the irregular presence. Its annex provided that the person could be handed over only after Italy had accepted the request. The CAA of Douai held in CAA de Douai, 27 June 2023, no. 22DA02093 that acceptance had to exist before the French authority could take, and a fortiori notify, the return decision. The court annulled the prefect’s decision because the file did not show a prior Italian acceptance.
The CAA of Marseille applied the same reasoning in CAA de Marseille, 27 October 2022, no. 21MA02607. The court held that the administration had to obtain prior acceptance of the readmission request and annulled both the return measure and the related movement ban. These decisions show why the notification date, the date of the request to the other State and the date of acceptance should be compared in a written timeline.
That timeline should not be reconstructed from memory. Ask the prefecture, police service or detention centre for every document supplied with the decision. Preserve the envelope, electronic notification, detention record, interview report and any document showing when the foreign authority was contacted. A person should not sign a document stating that its contents are understood if an interpreter was not provided or if the person needs time to read it. The signature may prove receipt, but it does not necessarily mean that every legal allegation is accepted.
B. Understand when a movement ban may be added
A return decision and a movement ban are separate measures, even when they appear in the same prefectural order. Article L. 622-1 of the CESEDA permits a reasoned ban of up to three years for a person holding a residence document in the State to which the person is to be returned, subject to the specific limits of Article L. 622-2. The text is available at Article L. 622-1 of the CESEDA.
The stronger protection applies where the return is based on Article L. 621-4, L. 621-5, L. 621-6 or L. 621-7. Under Article L. 622-2 of the CESEDA, a movement ban in those situations is lawful only if the stay in France constitutes an abuse of rights or the person’s personal conduct represents a real, current and sufficiently serious threat to a fundamental interest of society from the perspective of public order or public security.
The administration must also assess the duration of the presence in France, the nature and age of the person’s ties with France, any previous removal measure and the public-order risk. Those factors are stated in Article L. 622-3 of the CESEDA. A standard formula that merely repeats the existence of a foreign card or says that the person has stayed in France is not necessarily enough. The decision should identify the facts supporting the alleged abuse of rights or threat, and should explain the selected duration.
The 2024 Toulouse judgment is an important example. After substituting Article L. 621-4 for Article L. 621-2, the court applied Article L. 622-2 and found that the prefect had not produced facts showing an abuse of rights or a real, current and sufficiently serious threat. The court annulled the one-year movement ban, even though it did not annul the return decision itself. That distinction matters: a person may lose one claim and succeed on another.
The earlier Marseille decision also shows how the court examines a long-term EU residence card. In CAA de Marseille, 21 June 2021, no. 20MA03424, the court held that an EU long-term resident could be subject to a movement ban only if the stay constituted an abuse of rights or the conduct represented a public-order threat. The prefect’s references to the absence of proven family ties and strong links in the country of origin did not characterise either statutory ground. The ban was annulled.
Article L. 622-4 adds a different practical route. The administration may repeal the ban at any time. A request by the foreign national is normally admissible only if the person proves residence outside France for at least one year, subject to the statutory exceptions. The provision appears in the official Article L. 622-4 of the CESEDA. This administrative request does not eliminate the need to assess an urgent court challenge to the original decision, especially when removal or detention is imminent.
II. How to challenge the measures in practice
A. Build the evidence and choose the competent court and procedure
The competent judicial order is administrative. The initial challenge is normally brought before the tribunal administratif with territorial jurisdiction, usually the court connected to the prefect who issued the order or the place of detention or assignment under the applicable procedural route. An appeal may then be examined by the competent administrative court of appeal. The exact route depends on the measures combined in the order. A return decision accompanied by an assignment to residence or detention can fall under a special urgent procedure; the notification must be read with the procedural information supplied by the administration.
Article L. 623-1 distinguishes the routes where the person is assigned to residence and where the person is placed in administrative detention. It provides that, when the person is assigned to residence under Article L. 731-1, the return decision and accompanying movement ban may be challenged under Article L. 921-1; when the person is detained, they may be challenged under Article L. 921-2. The current statutory text is at Article L. 623-1 of the CESEDA. This is why the time limit printed on the notification must be treated as decisive. Do not assume that the ordinary two-month administrative litigation period applies to an urgent removal file.
The file should be organised around distinct grounds. First, challenge the legal basis and the factual prerequisites: Was the person really admitted to stay in the other State? Was the permit valid on the relevant date? Was the French stay irregular under the applicable rules? Was the person transferred from the State named in the order? Second, challenge the readmission chronology: when was the request made, what did the other State accept, and when? Third, challenge the movement ban separately under Articles L. 622-2 and L. 622-3.
Useful evidence may include:
- the complete prefectural order, every page and annex, with the notification date and signature record;
- the passport, foreign residence card, renewal receipt and proof of the card’s category and validity;
- entry and exit evidence, such as travel records, accommodation invoices, employment records and tax documents;
- proof of family life in France, including the spouse’s status, children’s schooling, medical needs and stable accommodation;
- evidence concerning work, employer duties, payroll, social-security registration and the practical effect of a ban on business travel;
- the police or administrative interview record and evidence of the opportunity to make observations;
- all correspondence showing the request for readmission and the foreign authority’s acceptance, refusal or silence.
The case law illustrates why each category matters. In CAA de Nancy, 1 April 2025, no. 23NC02824, the applicant held an Italian long-term residence permit and argued that the administration had not proved that he had stayed in France for more than three months. The court relied on his declarations about habitual residence in France, the location of his family and the absence of reliable evidence of his recent entries and exits. It upheld the return and movement ban, finding that the factual record supported the administration’s assessment of an abuse of rights. The case demonstrates that a foreign card alone does not decide the case; travel and residence evidence can be central.
By contrast, the case file may show that a person is entitled to a different French residence route. In CAA de Lyon, 15 February 2023, no. 21LY01500, the person held an Italian residence document but also received a French occupational-accident pension with a permanent incapacity rate of 30 percent. The court considered that the person was entitled to a residence card under the applicable provision and that the prefect had committed an error of law by ordering the return. The movement ban fell as a consequence. The lesson is practical: collect evidence of every potentially relevant French status before the interview or appeal, including work injury, family, medical and employment records.
Do not rely on general statements that France is the person’s home. The court will examine dates, documents and the legal category of each tie. A family certificate may prove a relationship but not daily care, cohabitation or the child’s practical dependency. A work contract may prove employment but not lawful authorisation or the duration of presence. The evidence should be linked to a precise legal argument and to the paragraph of the decision that is challenged.
B. Meet the procedural deadline and present a targeted request
The first practical deadline is the deadline printed on the notification. It may be extremely short when detention or an assignment to residence is involved. Article L. 623-1 confirms that those situations use the specific procedures in Articles L. 921-1 and L. 921-2. A person should therefore send the decision and all notification details to counsel immediately, including the exact hour when the order was delivered. If the person is detained, the detention centre and the court registry may also provide procedural information, but they do not replace an individual legal assessment.
The application should identify the decision precisely, request annulment of each contested measure and distinguish the requested relief. For example, the applicant may ask the court to annul the return decision because there was no prior acceptance by Italy; alternatively, to annul the movement ban because the conditions of Article L. 622-2 were not proved; and, where legally available, to order a fresh examination or issue the necessary document. A challenge that attacks only the general idea of removal may fail to address the independent reasoning for the movement ban.
Check the identity of the issuing authority and the stated legal provisions before drafting the claim. The order should normally identify the prefect, the person concerned, the foreign State, the residence document relied upon, the factual dates and the reasons for both measures. A missing page or an annex referred to but not delivered can affect the ability to understand and challenge the decision. The application should list those defects separately rather than treating them as a single complaint about insufficient explanation.
It is also useful to prepare a short chronology in two columns. The first column should contain the administration’s dates: the alleged entry, the identity check, the interview, the request to the other State, the acceptance, the order and notification. The second should contain the applicant’s proof: passport stamps, transport bookings, leases, payslips, school certificates and medical appointments. If the two columns do not match, the application should identify the exact contradiction and attach the document that resolves it. This format helps the tribunal distinguish a legal dispute from a general disagreement with the prefect’s assessment.
The notification record should also be challenged where the person was not given a real opportunity to make observations. In the Nancy case, the court examined the interview records and found that the applicant had been informed of the possible measure and had been able to make relevant observations. A successful argument therefore requires more than saying that the interview was short. It should identify what the person could not communicate, why the information was relevant and how it could have changed the decision.
Where the dispute concerns a bilateral readmission agreement, the request should ask the administration to produce the readmission request and acceptance. The Douai and Marseille judgments make the chronology legally significant. If acceptance arrived after the prefectural order, the applicant should place the dates side by side and explain why the defect affects the validity of the order rather than merely its later execution. If the administration cannot show that a request was made within the agreement’s period, that issue should be pleaded separately.
The remedy should also account for immediate consequences. A movement ban may affect a job requiring travel, an ongoing family relationship, medical appointments, schooling or a pending residence application in another State. Evidence should show the concrete consequence without suggesting that inconvenience alone automatically cancels the measure. The court will apply the statutory conditions and assess the facts; it will not replace proof with a general plea of hardship.
Finally, a person should preserve a copy of the filed application and proof of filing. The administration, the detention centre, the employer and family members should receive a consistent chronology. New evidence should be dated and explained. If the person later seeks repeal under Article L. 622-4 after living outside France for a year, proof of uninterrupted residence outside France will be essential, while that administrative route should not be confused with the initial court challenge.
Employers should take care not to advise an employee to ignore the order or to travel in breach of the ban. Instead, the employer can preserve the employment contract, explain the work-related travel requirement and provide a dated statement of the operational consequences. Investors and business owners should likewise separate company documents from personal residence evidence. A company registration does not by itself prove a lawful personal stay in France, but it may help establish the practical consequences of a restriction when combined with the person’s role and travel obligations.
Families should prepare evidence that is specific to the child or dependent relative concerned. School attendance, custody arrangements, medical follow-up, accommodation and the availability of care in the other State may all be relevant, but each fact should be documented. In the Toulouse case, the court considered the child’s nationality, schooling and family links in Spain and concluded that the decision did not disproportionately interfere with family life. That outcome does not mean that family evidence is irrelevant; it means that the evidence must address both the French ties and the possibility of family life in the State of return.
Translation and filing quality can be decisive under time pressure. Documents in Italian, Spanish or another language should be translated sufficiently for the court to understand the legal category, validity and relevant dates. Keep the original document with the translation and identify the translator or source. Scan every page in the correct order, including blank pages containing stamps or notes. A court cannot assess a residence document’s duration or status from an incomplete photograph.
Conclusion
A French decision returning a non-EU national to Italy, Spain or another Member State must be analysed measure by measure. The residence document held in the other State, the correct CESEDA provision, the proof of the French stay and the readmission chronology can each change the analysis. A movement ban is not automatic: for long-term EU residents in the situations covered by Article L. 622-2, the administration must establish an abuse of rights or a real, current and sufficiently serious threat, while also applying the assessment required by Article L. 622-3.
The safest practical response is immediate preservation of the notification, foreign residence documents, travel evidence, interview record and readmission correspondence. The challenge must be filed through the procedure and within the time limit stated for the person’s detention or assignment situation, before presenting focused arguments against both the return decision and any movement ban. The case law shows that courts may annul one measure while leaving another in place, or may uphold a decision where the evidence establishes habitual residence in France and an abuse of rights. The result depends on the exact documents, dates and legal grounds in the individual file.