You bought a Paris apartment through your Delaware LLC for liability protection and privacy. Then a letter from the French tax administration arrives: France wants 3 percent of the apartment’s market value, every single year, under a tax you never heard of. This article explains that bill, what the French statute actually says, how the Cour de cassation applies it to foreign entities, and the yearly filing that, for entities meeting the seat condition, can legally bring the bill down to zero.
A limited liability company, usually called an LLC, is a business vehicle created under the law of an American state, such as Delaware, Florida, or New York. Owners use it to limit personal liability, keep their name off public records, and organize estate planning. None of that shields the French property. French tax law applies a special annual tax, called the taxe de 3 %, to legal entities holding French real estate, and its wording is deliberately broad enough to catch American LLCs. The good news is that the same statute offers a disclosure exemption: tell the French administration every year who owns the entity, and the tax does not apply. The bad news is that one missed filing can trigger the full 3 percent, and recent court decisions show the administration enforces it aggressively against foreign structures, including foundations and Luxembourg companies. Below is the complete picture, with the official texts and the court rulings that decide real cases.
I. Why Is France Charging My American LLC 3 Percent Every Year on a French Apartment?
A. What Is the 3 Percent Tax and Does It Really Apply to an American LLC?
The tax is set by Article 990 D of the Code general des impots, the French general tax code. The official text states:
“Les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits” (Article 990 D, official text).
In plain English: legal entities of any kind, including companies, organizations, trusts, and comparable institutions, that directly or through an intermediate entity own one or more buildings located in France, or hold ownership-type rights over them, owe an annual tax equal to 3 percent of the open-market value of those buildings or rights. Three French terms need explaining. An entite juridique is a legal entity, meaning any organization the law treats as able to own property. A droit reel is a right directly over a thing, such as full ownership or a usufruct, which is a lifetime right to use someone else’s property. The valeur venale is the open-market value, meaning the price the property would fetch in a normal sale between unrelated parties.
The statute goes further. It states that “Aux fins d’application du présent article, est réputée posséder des biens ou droits immobiliers en France par entité interposée toute entité juridique qui détient une participation, quelles qu’en soient la forme et la quotité, dans une personne morale, un organisme, une fiducie ou une institution comparable, autre qu’une entité juridique visée aux 1°, a et b du 2° et a, b et c du 3° de l’article 990 E , qui est propriétaire de ces biens ou droits ou détenteur d’une participation dans une troisième personne morale, organisme, fiducie ou institution comparable lui-même propriétaire des biens ou droits ou interposé dans la chaîne des participations. Cette disposition s’applique quel que soit le nombre de ces entités juridiques interposées” (Article 990 D), which means an entity is treated as owning French property through an intermediate entity whenever it holds any stake, of whatever form and whatever size, in another entity that owns the property or sits anywhere in the ownership chain, however many layers there are. The sentence carves out intermediate entities that themselves belong to the exempt categories listed in Article 990 E. Hiding the apartment one or two layers down changes nothing for the rest. An American LLC that owns a French apartment directly is caught by the first sentence. An American LLC that owns a French holding company that owns the apartment is caught by the second.
Some American buyers assume the tax cannot touch them because France has no such thing as an LLC. French law indeed has no LLC, and a French societe, which Article 1832 of the Code civil defines by stating “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter”, meaning a company is created when two or more people agree to put assets or work into a shared enterprise in order to share profits, works differently from an American LLC. But the 3 percent tax does not ask whether the foreign vehicle looks like a French company. The statute catches “personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables”, and the Cour de cassation reads that reach as covering “toutes les entités juridiques, quelle que soit leur forme” (Cass., com., May 10, 2024, case number 21-11.230), meaning all legal entities whatever their form. On that reading, an American LLC is the type of foreign vehicle the French administration seeks to tax. Two honest limits apply: no decision cited in this article tests a Delaware, Florida, or New York LLC by name, and American transparent-or-opaque tax treatment does not decide the French question. If your structure is unusual, have a French tax adviser confirm coverage before assuming anything.
The Cour de cassation, France’s supreme court for civil and commercial matters, confirmed this broad reading. In the reasoning of its May 10, 2024 decision, case number 21-11.230, the court states that “En premier lieu, selon l’article 990 D, alinéa 1er, du code général des impôts, toutes les entités juridiques, quelle que soit leur forme, qui possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits”, meaning every legal entity owes the 3 percent tax on the market value of the buildings it owns in France unless it proves it falls into one of the listed exemptions. The case concerned a Liechtenstein foundation, the Beaux-Arts Stiftung, and the court issued a “REJETTE le pourvoi”, a dismissal of the appeal, ordering the foundation to bear the costs. The lesson for Americans is direct: an exotic foreign vehicle, even a nonprofit foundation expecting to transfer its assets to an American charity, does not escape the tax by its nature. Only a listed exemption, proven by the entity, works.
Multilayer structures get no better treatment. In its May 28, 2026 decision, case number 24-18.404, the commercial chamber of the Cour de cassation dealt with Satofi, a company seated in Luxembourg, over 3 percent tax bills for 2013 and 2014. The court restated that entities “Selon le premier de ces textes, les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits”, and it ended with “CASSE ET ANNULE, en toutes ses dispositions, l’arrêt rendu le 30 mai 2024”, quashing the appellate decision in full. The technical fight in that case concerned procedure inside an ownership chain, but the message is stable: foreign companies in chains are inside the scope of the tax, and litigation turns on exemptions and procedure, not on escaping the statute’s reach.
B. How Much Will I Pay and When Is the Tax Due Each Year?
The rate is 3 percent of the valeur venale, the open-market value, of the French property or rights, assessed every year. A Paris apartment worth 1,200,000 euros generates a 36,000 euro bill each year the LLC holds it. A small studio worth 350,000 euros still generates 10,500 euros a year. There is no prorating for a mid-year purchase in the statute’s logic: Article 990 F of the tax code provides that “La taxe est due à raison des immeubles ou droits immobiliers possédés au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition, à l’exception des biens régulièrement inscrits dans les stocks des personnes morales qui exercent la profession de marchand de biens ou de promoteur-constructeur”, meaning the tax is owed on buildings or rights owned on January 1 of the tax year. Buy in February and the first bill covers the following year, but own on New Year’s Day and the full year is due.
The same article sets the yearly ritual (Article 990 F): “Les redevables ainsi que les entités juridiques mentionnées aux d ou e du 3° de l’article 990 E doivent déclarer au plus tard le 15 mai de chaque année la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles et droits immobiliers en cause”, meaning liable entities must declare, no later than May 15 each year, the location, description, and value of the buildings and rights at stake. The article adds that “Cette déclaration, accompagnée du paiement de la taxe, est déposée au lieu fixé par arrêté du ministre chargé du budget”, meaning the return, together with payment of the tax, is filed at the office designated by order of the budget minister. In practice the filing is made on form number 2746-SD, known as CERFA number 11109, available on the official tax website www.impots.gouv.fr, as the tax administration’s own published doctrine confirms. Mark May 15 on your calendar in permanent ink, because the exemption described below uses the same deadline, and missing it is how most bills are born.
Two more features make the tax unusually harsh. First, everyone in the chain can be chased: “Toute personne morale, organisme, fiducie ou institution comparable, interposé entre le ou les débiteurs de la taxe et les immeubles ou droits immobiliers est solidairement responsable du paiement de cette taxe” (Article 990 F), meaning any entity sitting between the tax debtor and the property is jointly liable for paying it. If your Delaware LLC owns a French property company, the statute keeps two qualities distinct: the tax is owed by the entity closest to the buildings that is not exempt, while any entity sitting between that debtor and the buildings is only jointly liable for payment. In the Satofi litigation the court examined procedure inside such ownership chains separately, so check which quality is attributed to each of your entities before answering a notice. Second, the tax is collected like registration duties, since “La taxe est recouvrée selon les règles et sous les sanctions et garanties applicables aux droits d’enregistrement”, meaning it is recovered under the rules, penalties, and guarantees that apply to French registration duties, which gives the administration strong collection tools, including liens. And there is no silver lining at income-tax time: Article 990 G states that “La taxe prévue à l’article 990 D n’est pas déductible pour l’assiette de l’impôt sur le revenu ou de l’impôt sur les sociétés”, meaning the 3 percent tax is not deductible from the income-tax or corporate-tax base. You cannot write it off against French rental income.
One narrow carve-out exists for professionals: property regularly held as inventory by companies in the business of dealing in or developing buildings is excluded from the base. That exception serves merchants of property, called marchands de biens, and developer-builders, not an American family holding a vacation apartment. Do not assume your situation fits it without written advice.
II. How Can an American Owner Legally Stop Paying the 3 Percent Tax?
A. Can I Get the Exemption by Disclosing Who Owns the LLC Each Year?
Possibly, but only if two cumulative conditions are met, and the first one needs professional confirmation for an American LLC. Article 990 E of the tax code lists the exemptions, and its paragraph 3, item d, covers entities seated in France, in a European Union Member State, or in a state that has signed an administrative-assistance treaty with France, which “Ou qui déclarent chaque année, au plus tard le 15 mai, au lieu fixé par l’arrêté prévu à l’article 990 F du présent code, la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles possédés au 1er janvier, l’identité et l’adresse de l’ensemble des actionnaires, associés ou autres membres qui détiennent, à quelque titre que ce soit, plus de 1 % des actions, parts ou autres droits, ainsi que le nombre des actions, parts ou autres droits détenus par chacun d’eux”. In English: they declare every year, no later than May 15, at the designated office, the location, description, and value of the buildings owned on January 1, plus the identity and address of every shareholder, partner, or other member holding more than 1 percent of the shares or rights in any capacity, plus how many each holds.
Three practical points follow. First, the seat condition is cumulative and comes first. The statute opens this door only to entities seated in France, an EU Member State, or a state that has signed an administrative-assistance treaty with France. This article does not establish that an LLC seated in Delaware, Florida, New York, or any other particular American state satisfies that condition, so have your French tax adviser confirm treaty coverage in writing before relying on disclosure at all: if the seat condition fails, the filing does not exempt you. Second, the threshold is 1 percent, so in a single-member LLC the American owner is always reportable, and in a family LLC every member above 1 percent must be named with addresses and holdings. Third, the filing is annual, not one-and-done: each year’s return covers the property as owned on January 1 and the ownership as known on that date. A related item, paragraph 3, item e, offers a lighter variant for entities that declare the owners known to them, but for an American LLC whose members you obviously know, item d is the natural path: full disclosure every May 15.
The courts show what happens when disclosure is vague. In the Beaux-Arts Stiftung case decided May 10, 2024, the foundation argued it had declared that it indirectly held the property, had no current economic beneficiary since its statutes planned dissolution after a 2007 death, and later named a charitable foundation that might receive the assets. The Cour de cassation dismissed the appeal. Naming a possible future recipient is not naming the actual holders above 1 percent. For an American LLC, the equivalent mistake would be listing a manager, a nominee, or a revocable-trust label while omitting the real individual members. Name the human beings, with addresses and percentages, exactly as the statute requires.
A Luxembourg case confirms that exemption fights reach the highest court on narrow provisions. On November 4, 2020, in case number 18-11.771, the commercial chamber quashed a Paris appellate judgment in a dispute between the French tax administration’s nonresident department and Lupa, a Luxembourg company, in litigation turning on Article 990 E, paragraph 2, of the tax code. The operative words were “CASSE ET ANNULE, en toutes ses dispositions, l’arrêt rendu le 6 novembre 2017”. The Lupa dispute was decided under the former numbering of Article 990 E, paragraph 2, as cited in the appeal ground, so it is mentioned here only to show that exemption disputes reach the Cour de cassation, not for the content of that paragraph. Under the current Article 990 E, paragraph 2 covers entities whose French real estate is a minor share of French assets or whose shares trade on a regulated market, situations that do not describe an LLC holding a single Paris apartment. The case still proves the administration litigates these exemptions hard, and that procedural precision decides outcomes.
The most useful decision for Americans who missed a filing came on July 8, 2026, case number 25-12.737, concerning a company called Le Bois dormant. The court restated the exemption rule: “Selon le premier de ces textes, la taxe prévue à l’article 990 D du code général des impôts n’est pas applicable aux entités juridiques qui, ayant leur siège dans un pays ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscale, déclarent chaque année, au plus tard le 15 mai, la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles possédés au 1er janvier, l’identité et l’adresse de leurs actionnaires ou associés à la même date, ainsi que le nombre des actions ou parts détenues par chacun d’eux”. Then it recalled the administration’s own published tolerance, doctrine reference BOI-PAT-TPC-30, section 20: taxpayers who qualify for exemption but failed to file form 2746-SD. The court quotes the doctrine as follows: “La doctrine fiscale (BOI-PAT-TPC-30, § 20) prévoit que les contribuables qui peuvent bénéficier d’une exonération de taxe en application des d et e du 3° de l’article 990 E du CGI mais qui n’ont pas, suivant les cas, souscrit les déclarations n° 2746-SD (CERFA n° 11109), disponibles sur le site www.impots.gouv.fr, ou pris l’engagement prévu au d, doivent être mis en demeure par l’administration de régulariser leur situation dans les trente jours. Si les contribuables remplissent leurs obligations dans ce délai, le paiement de la taxe n’est pas exigé. La même doctrine précise que cette mesure de tolérance ne s’applique qu’à la première demande de régularisation et pour l’ensemble des années non prescrites”. In English: they must first be formally ordered, through a document called a mise en demeure, to fix the situation within thirty days. If they comply in time, the tax is not demanded. That tolerance applies only once, for the first regularization request, covering all unexpired years.
The court then punished the lower court for ignoring this shield (July 8, 2026 decision, case number 25-12.737). It held: “En se déterminant ainsi, sans rechercher, comme elle y était invitée, si l’administration fiscale n’avait pas méconnu sa propre doctrine en enjoignant la société de payer la taxe dans la mise en demeure du 4 août 2015, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision”, meaning the appellate court gave its decision no legal basis by failing to check whether the administration had violated its own doctrine by demanding payment, rather than regularization, in the August 4, 2015 formal notice. The result was “CASSE ET ANNULE, en toutes ses dispositions, l’arrêt rendu le 4 décembre 2024”. This matters enormously in practice: if you receive a first formal notice, you generally get thirty days to file the missing 2746-SD returns, and timely compliance should kill the bills. But the shield has sharp edges. It works once, it covers only unexpired years, and it depends on a general legal protection stated in Article L. 80 A of the Livre des procedures fiscales, the French tax procedure code: “Il ne sera procédé à aucun rehaussement d’impositions antérieures si la cause du rehaussement poursuivi par l’administration est un différend sur l’interprétation par le redevable de bonne foi du texte fiscal et s’il est démontré que l’interprétation sur laquelle est fondée la première décision a été, à l’époque, formellement admise par l’administration”, meaning no reassessment of earlier taxes when the dispute concerns a good-faith interpretation of the tax text that the administration had formally accepted at the time. Published doctrine can be invoked against the administration, but only if you actually act within the deadlines and keep proof of everything.
B. I Already Got a Tax Bill: What Do I File, Pay, or Challenge First?
Start by reading exactly what you received, because French papers have different legal weights. A demande de renseignements is a request for information, not yet a bill. A proposition de rectification is a proposed adjustment explaining why the administration thinks the tax applies, to which you can respond with observations. An avis de mise en recouvrement, often shortened to AMR, is the actual collection notice. A mise en demeure is a formal order to comply within a stated delay, classically thirty days. In the Le Bois dormant case, the timeline ran from a May 2015 information request to an August 2015 formal notice to assessments for 2009 through 2014, and the whole fight turned on what the formal notice demanded. Your first job is therefore to sort your mail into these categories and note every date. Each paper states its own response deadline, so diary it immediately and have your adviser confirm how it runs.
If the paper is a first mise en demeure giving thirty days to file form 2746-SD, treat it as an emergency with a clear solution: file every missing return within the thirty days, naming all members above 1 percent with addresses and holdings, describing each property with its location, description, and January 1 value, and keep stamped proof of filing. Under the doctrine enforced in case 25-12.737, timely regularization means the tax should not be demanded for those years. Do not instead write a long explanatory letter without the forms, do not name only the LLC’s manager, and do not argue about American tax transparency in place of the French disclosure. The statute wants names, addresses, and numbers by May 15 each year, and the tolerance wants the actual forms, now, within thirty days.
If the paper is already an AMR, meaning the administration has moved to collection, ask your adviser immediately about timing: whether to pay first and then file an administrative claim, called a reclamation, and which arguments to raise. Useful material for that discussion includes the yearly 2746-SD filings if they exist, the thirty-day regularization doctrine with Article L. 80 A if this was a first enforcement and the formal notice demanded payment instead of regularization, and any seat-condition or valuation points. Attach everything to the file you bring: LLC operating agreement, ownership ledger, proof of each May 15 filing, property valuations, and the full correspondence chain. If the administration rejects the claim, the dispute moves to the courts, where the Satofi and Le Bois dormant cases show judges examine chains of ownership, filing history, and the exact content of formal notices with great care.
Then fix the structure so the problem does not return. Three paths exist, each with costs. Path one is to keep the LLC and file perfectly every year: calendar April preparation for the May 15 deadline, update the member list after every transfer or death, and have your French accountant confirm the filing office each year. Path two is to dissolve the American LLC’s French footprint by transferring the apartment to direct individual ownership, which ends the 3 percent exposure going forward but triggers French transfer taxes and possibly capital-gains procedures on the way out. Note that when the building is sold by an entity established outside the European Union and outside the European Economic Area states covered by French assistance and recovery treaties, “le représentant visé au IV de l’article 244 bis A est responsable du paiement de la taxe restant due à cette date” (Article 990 F), meaning the tax representative designated for the sale answers for any 3 percent tax still owed at that date, so the exit itself requires settling the arrears. Confirm with your notary whether your seller entity falls inside or outside that seat condition. Path three is to convert to a French vehicle, typically a societe civile immobiliere, known as an SCI, which is the standard French property-holding company, but an SCI owned by Americans must still satisfy the same yearly disclosure to escape the tax, and it adds French accounting and American reporting questions. None of these paths is free, and the cheapest compliant option for most families already holding through an LLC is usually path one: keep the LLC, disclose fully, and never miss May 15 again.
A final warning about American-side advice: your American CPA may correctly tell you the LLC is disregarded for United States federal income tax, meaning its rental income flows straight onto your personal return. That is true in America and irrelevant in France for this tax. France applies its own statute to the entity owning French land, and the Cour de cassation enforces it against foreign entities of every form. Likewise, do not confuse this annual 3 percent tax with other French levies on the same apartment: the yearly property tax called taxe fonciere, the wealth tax on real estate called impot sur la fortune immobiliere, rental-income tax, and capital-gains tax at sale all live in different articles with different returns. Paying one never excuses the others. Your French adviser should map all five onto a single calendar with your name, the LLC’s name, each property’s address, and every deadline, starting with May 15.
Conclusion
The 3 percent tax is not a mistake and not a scam. It is a deliberate French anti-avoidance tool that taxes foreign legal entities on the market value of their French real estate, and an American LLC holding a Paris apartment sits squarely inside it. The statute taxes all entities whatever their form, catches property held through intermediate companies, assesses 3 percent of market value every January 1, demands a joint return and payment every May 15 on form 2746-SD, makes intermediate entities jointly liable, and refuses any income-tax deduction. The way out, once an adviser has confirmed the seat condition for your LLC, is the disclosure exemption: qualifying entities that declare each year, by May 15, the property’s location, description, and value plus every owner above 1 percent with addresses and holdings, escape the tax. The courts confirm both sides of that bargain. A Liechtenstein foundation that named only future possibilities lost, while a company hit with a first formal notice won the right to be judged on the administration’s own thirty-day regularization promise. If you hold French property through an LLC, pull your filing history today, file anything missing within any running thirty-day window, and put May 15 on a recurring calendar with professional review. Done right, the disclosure costs a fraction of one year’s 3 percent, and it buys permanent peace.