You are an American living in France, or an American who owns a house, a bank account, or family memories in France, and your will says one child gets everything while another gets nothing. Under the law of most American states, that choice is yours to make. Under French law, it may not be. France protects children through a system called the forced share, known in French as the réserve héréditaire, which is the part of your estate the law guarantees to your children no matter what your will says. If your succession touches France, that guarantee can override a California trust, a New York will, or a lifetime of gifts, and since a 2021 statute it can even reach into French real estate to top up a child whom a foreign law left with nothing.
This guide explains, for an American reader with no French legal background, how much France reserves for your children, how a French notaire, the public officer who settles every French succession, finds and reverses gifts that invade that share, whether choosing American law in your will can protect your plan, and when a disinherited child can still collect from property located in France. Every French term is explained the first time it appears, and every decisive legal statement is tied to the exact French statute or court decision that supports it, with links to the official texts.
I. How Much of Your French Estate Must Go to Your Children
The starting point is simple and unsettling for an American trained in testamentary freedom: when French law governs your succession, you cannot disinherit a child. You can favor one heir over another only inside a limited free portion, called the quotité disponible, which is the share of your estate the law leaves you free to give to anyone. Everything else belongs, by force of law, to your children. Understanding who counts as a protected heir and how large the protected slice is will tell you whether your current estate plan survives contact with France.
A. Who Counts as a Forced Heir and How Large Is the Reserved Share
French law defines the mechanism in one sentence. Article 912 of the Civil Code states that: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” In plain English, the forced share is the part of the inheritance that the law guarantees, free of conditions, to certain heirs called forced heirs, provided they step forward and accept the succession. The same article adds the mirror concept: “La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” The free portion is whatever is not reserved, and only that part can be given away freely by lifetime gifts, called donations, or by testamentary gifts, called legs.
Only children are forced heirs today. Parents and grandparents lost that status in the reform of June 23, 2006, a change the Court of Cassation itself described as part of the modern evolution of the institution in its September 27, 2017 rulings. Your surviving spouse is not a forced heir either when you leave children, although spouses enjoy other protections, including a one-year free stay in the family home, a possible lifetime right to use it, and the special spousal gifts described below. Brothers, sisters, unmarried partners, and friends have no reserved share at all. For an American family, the practical consequence is sharp: if you leave even one child, that child holds a legal claim against any plan that gives everything to your spouse, to a new partner, or to a single favored child.
The size of the reserved share depends only on how many children survive you. Article 913 of the Civil Code sets hard ceilings on your freedom: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Read from the children’s side, the math is the following. With one child, the child is guaranteed one half of the estate and you may freely dispose of the other half. With two children, the two children together are guaranteed two thirds, meaning roughly one third each if everything is divided evenly, and your free portion is one third. With three or more children, the children together are guaranteed three quarters, divided equally among them, and your free portion shrinks to one quarter. A concrete illustration helps. Suppose your estate, as recomputed under French rules, is worth 900,000 euros and you leave three children. The three children together must receive at least 675,000 euros, or 225,000 euros each, and all of your gifts and legacies combined cannot exceed 225,000 euros. A will that leaves the entire 900,000 euros to the oldest child would be cut back by 450,000 euros to restore the two younger children’s shares.
Two refinements matter for American families. First, a child who formally renounces the succession, a step called renonciation, generally drops out of the headcount, but Article 913 keeps a renouncing child in the count when that child is represented by his or her own descendants or still owes an accounting for a lifetime gift under Article 845 of the Civil Code, which provides that: “L’héritier qui renonce à la succession peut cependant retenir le don entre vifs ou réclamer le legs à lui fait jusqu’à concurrence de la portion disponible à moins que le disposant ait expressément exigé le rapport en cas de renonciation.” In other words, a child who walks away can still keep a lifetime gift within the free portion, and in some configurations that child still counts when the shares are computed, so renunciation is not a reliable tool for engineering a disinheritance. Second, gifts between spouses obey their own ceiling. Article 1094-1 of the Civil Code lets a spouse who leaves children give the surviving spouse: “soit de la propriété de ce dont il pourrait disposer en faveur d’un étranger, soit d’un quart de ses biens en propriété et des trois autres quarts en usufruit, soit encore de la totalité de ses biens en usufruit seulement.” Here usufruit means a lifetime right to use property and collect its income, while the bare ownership, called nue-propriété, passes to the children. An American who wants the surviving spouse to keep the French house for life, with the children taking full ownership later, can therefore combine the forced-share rules with a gift of the whole estate in usufruit to the spouse, a classic French planning tool that works inside the system instead of against it.
The bottom line of this first section is a number you can take to your own situation. Count your children, apply the one-half, one-third, one-quarter ladder for your free portion, and ask whether your will, your trust, and your past gifts fit inside it. If they do not, French law does not shrug. It provides the notary and the disinherited child with a precise machine for clawing the excess back, and that machine is the subject of the next section.
B. How the Notary Finds the Breach and Takes the Excess Back
In France, successions are not settled by private agreement alone. A notaire, a public officer with a monopoly over estate settlement, opens the file, collects the titles, values the assets, and checks every lifetime gift and testamentary legacy against the forced share. When the officer sees a possible invasion of a child’s guaranteed portion, the law now tells the officer to speak up. Article 921 of the Civil Code provides that: “Lorsque le notaire constate, lors du règlement de la succession, que les droits réservataires d’un héritier sont susceptibles d’être atteints par les libéralités effectuées par le défunt, il informe chaque héritier concerné et connu, individuellement et, le cas échéant, avant tout partage, de son droit de demander la réduction des libéralités qui excèdent la quotité disponible.” The remedy has a name, réduction, meaning the legal cutback of excessive gifts, and the notary must warn each known affected heir, individually and before any division of the property, that this remedy exists. An American heir who receives such a letter from a French notary should treat it as the starting gun of a deadline-driven procedure, not as routine correspondence.
The cutback starts with an accounting exercise that surprises many Americans, because it pulls lifetime gifts back into the picture. Article 922 of the Civil Code directs that: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur.” The officer builds a fictional total mass: everything owned at death, plus every lifetime gift fictitiously reunited with the mass at its value on the day of death, minus debts and charges. Only on that enlarged mass does the officer compute the free portion by applying the one-half, one-third, one-quarter ladder to the quality and number of the heirs. The consequence is that a house given to one child ten years ago, or college funds and down-payment help structured as formal gifts, can resurface at today’s value and push the total gifts over the ceiling, triggering a cutback even though the will itself looked modest. Lifetime generosity and testamentary freedom draw from the same limited bucket.
Only the protected people can pull the trigger. Article 921 of the Civil Code states that: “La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause : les donataires, les légataires, ni les créanciers du défunt ne pourront demander cette réduction, ni en profiter.” Only the forced heirs, or their own heirs and successors, can demand the cutback of lifetime gifts. Donees, legatees, and creditors of the deceased can neither demand it nor benefit from it. The same article sets a strict clock: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” In practice, the disinherited child has five years from the death, or two years from learning of the invasion, with an absolute ten-year ceiling from the death. Missing that window kills the claim, which is why American heirs who learn late about a French death must move quickly to get the notary’s valuation and the list of reported gifts.
The cutback follows a fixed order that protects the deceased’s last wishes as much as possible while restoring the children’s shares. Article 923 of the Civil Code provides that: “Il n’y aura jamais lieu à réduire les donations entre vifs, qu’après avoir épuisé la valeur de tous les biens compris dans les dispositions testamentaires ; et lorsqu’il y aura lieu à cette réduction, elle se fera en commençant par la dernière donation, et ainsi de suite en remontant des dernières aux plus anciennes.” Testamentary legacies are reduced first, and only when they are exhausted does the law touch lifetime gifts, starting with the most recent gift and walking backward to the oldest. And the remedy is normally paid in money, not by tearing property apart. Article 924 of the Civil Code states that: “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” The over-gifted beneficiary, whether an heir or a stranger, owes the forced heirs a cash payment equal to the excess, with a forced heir who received too much accounting first by taking less from the shared mass. When the over-gifted beneficiary is insolvent and has already sold gifted real estate to an innocent buyer, the law can even follow the property into the buyer’s hands after the debtor’s assets have been discussed, under Article 924-4 of the Civil Code, which opens: “Après discussion préalable des biens du débiteur de l’indemnité en réduction et en cas d’insolvabilité de ce dernier, les héritiers réservataires peuvent exercer l’action en réduction ou revendication contre les tiers détenteurs des immeubles faisant partie des libéralités et aliénés par le gratifié.” For an American buyer of French property, that trailing liability is one more reason to demand a clean notarial title history before signing anything.
So the French machine has three stages: rebuild the mass with lifetime gifts, compare it to the ladder, and cut back legacies first and recent gifts second, in cash, at the demand of the protected children, within the five, two, and ten-year clocks. If French law governs your succession, no American-style disinheritance clause survives that machine. The real question for most American families is therefore whether French law has to govern at all, and that is where the European choice-of-law rule and the famous California cases enter the story.
II. Can an American Escape the Forced Share by Choosing American Law
Many Americans assume the answer is yes: write into the will that California law, New York law, or Texas law governs the whole succession, and the French forced share disappears. European law does allow that kind of choice, and French courts have upheld it even when it left French children with nothing. But a 2021 French statute built a safety net behind it. This second part explains the choice-of-law tool, the two 2017 decisions every American family should know, and the top-up claim that can still catch French property when the chosen foreign law offers children no protection at all.
A. Picking the Law of Your Nationality in Your Will and What French Courts Did With Two California Estates
Since August 17, 2015, successions connected with France are governed by European Union Regulation No. 650 of July 4, 2012, on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions in matters of succession, known as Regulation 650/2012 of July 4, 2012. The default rule points to the law of the country where the deceased had his or her habitual residence at death, meaning the place of the close and stable center of life, not merely a mailing address. The exception that matters for Americans is the choice-of-law option, called professio juris by lawyers: a person may choose, in a will or a separate declaration, the law of the country of his or her nationality to govern the whole succession, including real estate. An American citizen can therefore choose American law, and because the United States is not a single succession-law jurisdiction, the designation in practice leads to the law of the relevant American state, such as California or New York, as determined by that state’s own rules. French courts accept that the choice can cover the entire estate, French house included, and the French notary is bound to apply the designated foreign law to the shares, subject only to the narrow safety valve of French international public policy, called ordre public international.
The reach of that safety valve was tested in the two most famous Franco-American succession cases of the last decade, decided by the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation on the same day, September 27, 2017. The first case, pourvoi number 16-13.151, concerned a French composer who had lived in California for nearly thirty years, married there, placed all of his property in a California family trust benefiting his wife and, after her, their two young daughters, and died in Santa Monica leaving four older children from earlier relationships with nothing. The older children asked the French courts to set aside California law, which has no forced share, and to restore their French guaranteed portions. The Paris Court of Appeal refused, and the Court of Cassation rejected the appeal, laying down the rule that still governs today. Decision 16-13.151 of September 27, 2017 holds that: “une loi étrangère désignée par la règle de conflit qui ignore la réserve héréditaire n’est pas en soi contraire à l’ordre public international français et ne peut être écartée que si son application concrète, au cas d’espèce, conduit à une situation incompatible avec les principes du droit français considérés comme essentiels”. A foreign law chosen by the conflicts rule that ignores the forced share is therefore not automatically contrary to French international public policy. It can be set aside only if applying it in the concrete case produces a result incompatible with the principles of French law considered essential.
Applied to the facts, the Court found no such incompatibility. The judgment notes that California was the law normally applicable, that none of the four older children, all adults at the death, was shown to face economic precarity or need, that the composer had lived in California for almost thirty years, that his three youngest children were born there, and that all of his real estate and most of his movable wealth sat in the United States, with the trust benefiting his wife, the mother of their two daughters who were still minors. On those findings, the Court concluded that California law, which had allowed the composer to leave everything to a trust for his wife with nothing reserved for the older children, did not offend French international public policy. The companion case decided the same day, decision 16-17.198 of September 27, 2017, applies the identical principle on similar reasoning, confirming that the outcome was not an accident of one file: where the concrete application leaves no heir in precarity or need and the family’s center of gravity sits in California, the foreign law stands and the French forced share falls away. Later decisions have kept the European framework coherent in the same spirit. In the succession jurisdiction sequel of pourvoi 19-15.438, the First Civil Chamber drew the consequences of the Regulation’s subsidiary jurisdiction: decision of September 21, 2022 holds that a French court seised of a succession must raise of its own motion its subsidiary jurisdiction when the deceased was a French national who owned property in France, even though habitual residence lay abroad, following the Court of Justice’s April 7, 2022 ruling in case C-645/20. French courts therefore stay in the game whenever French nationality and French assets are present, but they apply the foreign law designated by the European rule unless the concrete result shocks the essential principles of French law.
For an American drafting today, the lesson of the California cases is double-edged. A clear written choice of American law, combined with a real American center of life, American-situated wealth, and adult children who are not left destitute, can genuinely defeat a forced-share claim in France. But the test is concrete and case by case. A court will look at precarity or need, at the ages and situations of the disinherited children, at how long the deceased lived in the United States, at where the children were born and live, and at where the real estate and the movable wealth sit. An American who retires to Lyon, buys an apartment in the 6th arrondissement, keeps the children in France, and inserts a boilerplate choice of New York law while living a fully French life should not expect the California outcome. Habitual residence analysis could already point back to French law, and even if the choice of American law is honored, the 2021 safety net described next may restore the children’s shares out of the French assets anyway. The choice-of-law clause is a powerful tool, not a magic wand, and it must be drafted, signed, and stored with the same care as the rest of the will, in a form valid under the Regulation, expressly designating the law of your nationality for the whole succession.
B. When France Tops Up a Disinherited Child Anyway Out of Property in France
Parliament responded to the 2017 cases with the statute of May 24, 2021, whose mechanism now sits inside the Civil Code itself. The second paragraph of Article 913 of the Civil Code provides that: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” In English, when the deceased or at least one of the children is, at the time of death, a national of a European Union member state or habitually resident there, and the foreign law governing the succession offers children no protective forced-share mechanism at all, each child, or that child’s own heirs or successors, may make a compensatory levy, called prélèvement compensatoire, against the existing assets located in France on the day of death, so as to be restored to the reserved rights French law grants, within the limit of those rights.
Four conditions therefore unlock the top-up, and each must be checked before anyone promises results. First, a European anchor must exist at death: the deceased or at least one child holds the nationality of a European Union member state or habitually resides there. French nationality counts, and so does habitual residence in France, which covers a large share of Franco-American families. Second, the foreign law applicable to the succession must offer no protective forced-share mechanism for children whatsoever. A foreign system that gives children a fixed support claim or a need-based family provision may or may not satisfy that test, and the notary and the courts will examine the foreign statute rather than assume the answer. Classic American intestacy and elective-share rules for spouses do not protect children, which is why ordinary American state law typically meets this condition, but the analysis must be done state by state and on the statute in force at death. Third, the levy can only be taken from existing assets situated in France on the day of death: the Paris apartment, the Lyon house, the French bank accounts and securities accounts, the French-registered business interests. American-situated wealth is out of reach of this particular remedy, and lifetime gifts already gone are not its target either. Fourth, the child recovers no more than the French reserved rights, computed with the one-half, one-third, one-quarter ladder on the French-situated base combined with the overall accounting. The top-up restores the guarantee; it does not punish the favored heir beyond it.
The procedure runs through the French notary settling the succession. The disinherited child asserts the compensatory levy against the French assets during the settlement, the notary verifies the European anchor, identifies the applicable foreign law, confirms the absence of any child-protective mechanism under that law, values the French-situated property, and computes the French reserved portion the child should have received. Disputes go to the French courts, where the foreign law must be proved, often with a certificate of custom, called certificat de coutume, or an expert opinion on the American state’s statute, because French judges do not take foreign law on faith. American families should also keep the tax layer in view without confusing it with the civil layer. The civil question of who gets what is separate from the fiscal question of who pays transfer tax and how much. The France-United States estate and gift tax treaty of 1978, with its later protocols, allocates taxing rights and offers credits between the two countries, but it does not create or erase a forced share. A child can win the civil top-up and still owe French transfer tax on it, subject to the treaty credits claimed on the American side, which is why the notary’s civil computation and the tax filings must be coordinated rather than handled in isolation.
What should an American family actually do with these rules? Start with an audit. List every child, including children from earlier relationships, because the ladder counts them all. List every lifetime gift and every trust funding, with dates and values, because the fictitious reunion can pull them back into the mass if French law governs. List every French-situated asset, because that is the base the 2021 top-up can seize. Then decide on the choice-of-law strategy with eyes open. If your life is genuinely anchored in the United States and you want American law to govern, insert an express, signed professio juris clause choosing the law of your American nationality for the whole succession, keep proof of your American habitual residence, and revisit the clause after every move, marriage, divorce, or birth. If your life is anchored in France, assume the forced share and the 2021 top-up will apply, and plan inside them: use the free portion deliberately for the spouse, partner, or favored child; consider a gift of usufruit to the surviving spouse under Article 1094-1 so the spouse keeps the home for life while the children’s bare ownership is preserved; fund the children’s shares with life insurance, called assurance-vie, whose beneficiary designations sit largely outside the succession mass and follow their own allowance rules; and document every gift’s valuation date so the notary’s later reunion exercise holds no surprises. Revisit beneficiary clauses after each birth, because a new child changes the ladder and can turn a compliant plan into an invading one overnight. And never ask a French notary to witness a disinheritance clause that French law forbids. The officer will refuse, the clause will fail, and the file will record an attempt that later colors every negotiation among the heirs.
Conclusion
An American can disinherit a child under the law of most American states, but that freedom stops where French succession law starts. When French law governs, each child holds a guaranteed portion measured on the one-half, one-third, one-quarter ladder, the notary rebuilds the estate with lifetime gifts to find any invasion, and only the protected children can demand the cutback, in cash, in a fixed order, within the five-year, two-year, and ten-year clocks. A written choice of American nationality law under the European Succession Regulation can displace that whole machine, and the two September 27, 2017 decisions prove that French courts will honor the choice, even for a California trust that left four children with nothing, when the concrete result leaves no heir in precarity or need and the family’s life sits across the Atlantic. Yet the 2021 compensatory levy means the victory can be partial: whenever a European anchor exists and the applicable foreign law gives children no protective mechanism, each disinherited child can still collect the French reserved share out of assets located in France. The safe path is therefore an honest one. Map your children, your gifts, and your French assets; choose your governing law expressly if your American anchor is real; and if France is your home, build your plan inside the forced share with the free portion, spousal usufruit, and insurance designations rather than against it. Done early, that work turns a cross-border shock into an orderly transfer. Done late, it turns a will into litigation.