Your ex has just refused to let you take your child to London for Christmas, or to spend August with grandparents in New York. You live in Paris, the children go to school in France, and your separation agreement says nothing precise about travel. Can you go anyway with a passport and plane tickets, or would leaving expose you to a court case, a criminal complaint, or an order to bring the child back immediately? For English-speaking parents in France, this question comes up in two very different forms: the short holiday abroad that the other parent blocks at the last minute, and the permanent move abroad that one parent plans after a divorce. French law treats those two situations differently, with different judges, different papers, and very different risks.
This guide explains both paths in plain English. Part I covers holiday travel and short trips outside France when your ex refuses consent: joint parental authority, travel papers, exit bans, and what the family judge in Paris can order in an emergency. Part II covers relocation abroad and the international machinery that applies when a child is taken or kept outside France without consent: the 1980 Hague Convention on child abduction, European jurisdiction rules, and the French criminal offence of failure to hand over a child. Every French term is explained the first time it appears, and every decisive rule is linked to its official text so you can check it yourself or show it to a lawyer.
I. Can I Take My Child on Holiday Outside France When My Ex Refuses
A. How French Law Decides Holiday Travel After Separation in France
In France, separation or divorce does not automatically take parental authority away from either parent. The starting rule is joint parental authority, called in French autorite parentale conjointe, which means the father and mother exercise parental rights together even when they no longer live together. Article 371-1 of the Civil Code defines parental authority as a set of rights and duties aimed at the interest of the child, covering health, education, safety, and moral guidance. Article 372-1 of the Civil Code then states the default position after separation: as a rule each parent continues to exercise parental authority jointly, unless a court decides otherwise for serious reasons. For an expatriate couple in Paris, this means your ex keeps a legal voice on important decisions concerning the children even if the children live with you most of the time and even if you are the parent who handles school, doctors, and daily life.
The practical difficulty is that French law divides decisions into everyday acts and important acts. Everyday acts, called actes usuels, can be done by one parent alone, and the other parent is presumed to agree. School registration for the next year, a routine doctor visit, or a short domestic trip often falls in this category. Important acts, called actes non usuels, require the agreement of both parents when authority is joint. A first passport application, the choice of a school abroad, surgery, and many international trips fall on the important side, especially when the parents are in conflict. The official service-public.fr page on joint parental authority explains that each parent can perform everyday acts alone while important decisions require both signatures, and the page on travelling abroad with a child confirms that border officers and airlines look for proof that the travelling parent has the right to take the child out of the country. When relations are calm, one signed travel permission is enough. When your ex has said no in writing, you can no longer rely on presumed agreement.
Three papers dominate the daily practice at French borders and airports. The first is the identity document of the child: a national identity card for travel inside the European Union or a passport with a visa where required. Either parent with joint authority can normally request a passport for a minor, but the administration will block or flag the file if the other parent has filed a written objection, called opposition a la sortie du territoire, often shortened to OST. The second is the parental travel permission used when a minor travels without either parent, called autorisation de sortie du territoire, shortened to AST: a standard form signed by one parent with a copy of that parent identity document. The third group consists of court-ordered travel bans, pronounced by the family judge: an opposition a la sortie du territoire, the OST, which is temporary and protective, and an interdiction de sortie du territoire, the IST, which is longer and is entered in the national wanted-persons file. The service-public.fr page on holidays abroad with a child, updated on 5 June 2026, explains that a child travelling with one parent does not normally need an AST, because the AST is designed for travel without either parent, yet airlines, border police, and the other country may still ask for written consent from the second parent, a copy of the family record book, and the divorce order fixing residence. In a conflict, carry more proof than the minimum, not less.
An OST can be requested quickly when you fear that the other parent will leave with the child without telling you. Any parent can go to the prefecture, the local representative of the State, with proof of parental authority and reasons to fear an unlawful departure, and obtain an emergency OST valid for a limited period. The child is then flagged in police files and cannot lawfully leave France while the measure lasts. The IST is the heavier judicial version: only the family judge, called the juge aux affaires familiales and shortened to JAF, can order it, and it lasts longer and can be renewed. Parents sometimes confuse these tools with a general veto on all travel. They are not. An OST or IST blocks departure; it does not decide who is right about the holiday. Only the JAF decides the underlying question, by authorising a specific trip, setting conditions for return, or reallocating holiday dates.
The legal anchor for that judicial power is Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code, which provides in its current wording: “Le juge peut prendre les mesures permettant de garantir la continuité et l’effectivité du maintien des liens de l’enfant avec chacun de ses parents” (the family judge may take measures to guarantee the continuity and effectiveness of the child’s relationship with each of his or her parents). That single sentence explains the whole philosophy of French travel litigation: the judge protects the bond with both parents, not the travel plans of one adult. On 1 July 2026 the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the highest civil court in France, quashed an appeal decision in case number 25-21.064 precisely because the lower court had not examined that continuity correctly when an OST was at stake, recalling also the right to respect for private and family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The ruling is published at Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 1 July 2026, No 25-21.064. For an English-speaking parent, the message is direct: a judge who blocks or allows a trip must explain how the decision preserves the child link with each parent, and a decision that skips that analysis can be overturned.
Two companion provisions complete the picture. Article 373-2 of the Civil Code states that separation of the parents has no effect on the rules of devolution of parental authority, which is why your ex keeps joint authority after you stop living together unless a judgment says otherwise. Article 373-2-2 of the Civil Code governs the financial side of separation and reminds parents that maintenance duties continue regardless of travel disputes. None of these texts gives one parent a unilateral right to take a child abroad for a holiday when the other parent objects. The parent who wants to travel must either obtain written consent or obtain a court order before departure.
B. What to Do When Your Ex Refuses Holiday Travel From Paris
Start by fixing the exact nature of the refusal in writing. A vague message saying we will see is not a refusal. Ask your ex by email or text message for clear written consent for a defined trip: dates, flight numbers, address abroad, return date, school calendar showing the trip falls in your holiday period, and a commitment to be reachable. Keep the request short, polite, and child-centred. If the answer is no, ask for the reason in one sentence. Judges in Paris read these exchanges carefully. A parent who proposes precise dates, direct flights, daily video calls with the other parent, and a copy of return tickets looks responsible. A parent who announces a trip the day before departure, during the other parent school holiday time, or to a country with no return arrangement looks careless, even when the destination itself is safe.
Build your proof file before you go to court. Include the refusal message, your detailed travel proposal, the existing judgment or divorce agreement fixing the child residence and holiday sharing, the child school calendar, proof of tickets or bookings that can be cancelled, the address where the child will stay, health insurance covering the destination, and any evidence that the trip serves the child: language course enrolment, family event, or long-planned visit to grandparents. If your ex raises safety, answer it with documents rather than adjectives: vaccination records, the hotel address, and the name of the adult supervising the child at all times. If your ex fears non-return, offer concrete guarantees: return tickets in the child name, a written undertaking to return on a fixed date, enrolment proof for the next school term in France, and agreement that the other parent keeps the passports between trips. These details decide cases far more often than general statements about parental rights.
When consent is refused, the competent judge is the JAF of the judicial court, in French tribunal judiciaire, of the place where the child habitually lives. For most English-speaking families in Paris and the surrounding departments, that means the Paris judicial court on the Ile de la Cite for Paris itself, or the courts of Nanterre, Bobigny, or Creteil for the inner suburbs. You apply by summons, called assignation, or by petition to the family judge, called requete au juge aux affaires familiales, depending on urgency. In a genuine emergency, for example a trip in ten days with non-refundable tickets and a last-minute refusal, your lawyer can request an accelerated hearing, called audience en refere or requete a bref delai, and ask the judge to authorise one specific trip with conditions. Bring the proof file described above plus a copy of your identity document, the child livret de famille or birth certificate, and the last judgment fixing custody. Ask for precise orders: authorisation to leave France with the child from one date to another, permission to apply alone for any required visa, an order that the other parent hand over the passport forty-eight hours before departure, and a return obligation with a handover time and place.
Judges grant or refuse these requests by weighing the interest of the child, called interet superieur de l’enfant, against the continuity of links with each parent. A trip to London to see grandparents during your own holiday period, with return tickets and schooling in France secured, is usually authorised even over the other parent objection when no concrete danger is shown. A first trip to a distant country with no fixed address, during exam weeks, or immediately after a separation, is harder. The judge can also split the difference: shorter trip, different dates so the other parent keeps equivalent holiday time, daily video contact, or an obligation to register the return with the court. Accept these conditions gracefully. Refusing a reasonable compromise in the hearing room harms your credibility for the next dispute.
Never solve a refusal by travelling anyway and hoping the border will not check. French border police can refuse boarding when a child is flagged under an OST or IST, and airlines routinely deny boarding to avoid fines when papers are incomplete. Worse, leaving despite a clear written refusal can later be presented as proof that you disregard joint authority, which weighs against you in the next custody hearing. If no OST or IST exists and you believe the trip is an everyday act covered by presumed consent, take legal advice before departure and keep written proof that you informed the other parent of the full itinerary. The safer route remains a short court order authorising the trip. It costs less than cancelled tickets and protects the rest of your custody arrangement.
A final Paris practice point concerns passports held by one parent. When judgments are silent, the parent holding the child passport sometimes refuses to hand it over as leverage. The JAF can order handover for a defined trip and set a penalty per day of delay, called astreinte. Ask for that penalty expressly. Without it, an order to hand over the passport can arrive too late for the flight. With it, most passports appear on time.
II. Can I Move Abroad With My Child After a French Divorce
A. How the Family Judge Decides Relocation Requests and Habitual Residence
Relocation is not an extended holiday. Moving a child from Paris to London, Dublin, New York, or Tel Aviv changes school, language, doctors, friends, and the practical ability of the other parent to see the child. French law therefore treats relocation as an important decision requiring either the written agreement of both parents with joint authority or a prior court order. A parent who moves the child habitual residence without that agreement takes a legal risk even when the move looks justified by a new job or a new partner. Habitual residence, called residence habituelle, is the factual centre of the child life: where the child sleeps, goes to school, sees doctors, and has stable relationships. It decides which court has jurisdiction and, in cross-border cases, which country law governs custody. The European rule in force today is Regulation 2019/1111 on jurisdiction and the recognition of decisions in matrimonial matters and matters of parental responsibility, known as Brussels II ter, available at Council Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter (CELEX 32019R1111). Its predecessor on jurisdiction, Council Regulation (EC) No 2201/2003, known as Brussels II bis (CELEX 32003R2201), still appears in older French decisions and helps explain the case law you will find online. Under both instruments, the courts of the country where the child is habitually resident at the time of the application are normally competent for custody and access.
Before any move, check your existing judgment. Many Paris judgments fix the child residence with one parent and grant the other parent visitation and accommodation rights, called droit de visite et d’hebergement, plus a detailed holiday calendar. Some add an express clause forbidding either parent from moving the child outside a defined area, for example Ile-de-France, without the other parent written consent or a new court order. Breaching that clause deliberately is the fastest way to lose credibility and sometimes to lose primary residence. If your judgment contains such a clause, treat relocation as a modification case, called modification des mesures relatives aux enfants, and apply to the JAF before signing a lease or enrolling the child in a new school abroad. If your judgment is silent, the same advice applies in practice: apply first, move second.
The JAF relocation test is factual and child-centred. Judges examine why the move is requested, whether the reasons are serious and documented rather than a wish to distance the other parent, what the child loses and gains in schooling, language, health care, and stability, what concrete contact remains possible with the parent staying in France, and what the child thinks when old enough to express a view. A move for a permanent job with a salary increase, a signed employment contract, housing near the new school, enrolment confirmation, and a detailed plan for holidays with the French parent can succeed. A move announced by text message with no job, no school, and a proposal of video calls as the only contact usually fails. Distance matters less than the quality of the remaining relationship: Paris to London with extended holidays and shared travel costs is easier to defend than Paris to a distant city with two trips per year and no funding plan.
Prepare the relocation file the way a judge reads it. Show the legitimate reason with contracts and pay slips, not promises. Show the new home with a lease, photographs, and proximity to school and transport. Show schooling with an admission letter, curriculum, language support for a French-speaking child, and the calendar. Show health continuity with a paediatrician and insurance. Show the contact plan with exact holiday division, who pays for travel, flight frequency, daily call times, and handover airports. Show that you informed the other parent early and offered mediation, called mediation familiale, before filing. Mediation does not always succeed, but refusing it without reason looks rigid. Finally, anticipate the financial orders: child maintenance, called pension alimentaire, travel costs, and, where relevant, the compensatory payment owed on divorce, called prestation compensatoire, may all be adjusted when the child lives abroad. Link each request to a document. Judges trust paper more than adjectives.
English-speaking parents often ask whether the other parent can block any move forever. The answer is no, but the burden is on the moving parent to prove that relocation serves the child interest while preserving real links with the parent who stays. The Cour de cassation decision of 1 July 2026 cited above applies here with full force: under Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code, measures concerning children must guarantee the continuity and effectiveness of the child bond with each parent, because “Le juge peut prendre les mesures permettant de garantir la continuité et l’effectivité du maintien des liens de l’enfant avec chacun de ses parents” (the family judge may take measures to guarantee the continuity and effectiveness of the child’s relationship with each of his or her parents). A relocation order that empties access rights of substance, or a refusal that ignores a serious and documented family project, can both be challenged when the reasoning is missing. Read the full ruling at Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 1 July 2026, No 25-21.064 before you frame your arguments.
B. What Happens If a Parent Leaves Without Consent or Keeps the Child Abroad
When a child who lived in France is taken abroad or kept abroad without the agreement of the parent who holds custody rights, two legal systems react at once: the civil return system and the French criminal system. The civil system is the 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, whose full official text is published by the Hague Conference at HCCH, 1980 Child Abduction Convention, full text. Its core test appears in Article 3, which provides: “le déplacement ou le non-retour d’un enfant est considéré comme illicite lorsqu’il a eu lieu en violation d’un droit de garde, attribué par le droit de l’Etat dans lequel l’enfant avait sa résidence habituelle immédiatement avant son déplacement ou son non-retour” (the removal or the retention of a child is considered wrongful where it is in breach of rights of custody attributed under the law of the State in which the child was habitually resident immediately before the removal or retention). In plain English, if France was the child home and both parents held joint custody under French law, taking the child to another country without the other parent consent or a court order is normally treated as wrongful under the Convention. On 12 June 2025 the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected an appeal against a return order on exactly this ground, recalling the Article 3 test and ordering return, in a ruling published at Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 12 June 2025, No 24-17.787. That decision is the one to show any parent who believes that leaving first and negotiating later is a valid strategy.
A Hague return case is not a custody trial. The judge in the country where the child is now located does not decide where the child should live in the long term. The judge decides whether the removal or retention was wrongful and whether the child must be returned promptly to the country of habitual residence so that the custody courts there can decide. Return is the rule, and exceptions are narrow: grave risk of harm, the child objection when mature enough, settlement after more than one year, or consent given after the event. French courts apply those exceptions strictly, and litigation moves fast, with central authorities in each country transmitting files between parents, prosecutors, and judges. If you are the left-behind parent in Paris, contact a lawyer immediately, file a return application with the French central authority at the Ministry of Justice, and gather proof of habitual residence in France: school certificates, medical records, lease, extracurricular activities, and the judgment granting you joint custody. If you are the parent who left, understand that enrolling the child in a new school abroad or renting a flat does not create a new habitual residence that defeats return. Courts look at wrongfulness at the date of removal, not at facts created afterwards.
Alongside return proceedings, French criminal law punishes the refusal to hand over a child. Article 227-5 of the Penal Code, in the section on the failure to hand over a child codified at Penal Code, Book II, Title II, Chapter VII, Section 3, punishes any person who refuses without lawful reason to hand over a minor child to the person entitled to claim the child. The offence is often called non-representation d’enfant. It applies to parents as well as third parties, covers both missed handovers at the school gate and outright retention abroad, and can lead to arrest warrants, border alerts, and prison sentences. Complaints are filed with the police or the public prosecutor, called procureur de la Republique, at the place where the child should have been handed over. Keep every handover message, bailiff report, and travel document, because the criminal file turns on precise facts: the date, the place, and the refusal.
When the other parent has already left or threatens to leave imminently, act within hours rather than weeks. First, request an emergency OST at the prefecture if departure from France is feared but has not yet happened. Second, ask the JAF for an IST and for provisional custody measures under Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code. Third, file a criminal complaint for non-representation where a handover was refused, citing Article 227-5 of the Penal Code. Fourth, if the child is already abroad, launch the Hague return track in parallel through the Ministry of Justice central authority and a lawyer in the country where the child is located, relying on the Convention text at HCCH, 1980 Child Abduction Convention, full text and the Article 3 test confirmed in Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 12 June 2025, No 24-17.787. These tracks do not cancel each other. The JAF protects the child in France, the criminal judge punishes refusal, and the foreign judge decides return. Running them together is normal in international cases.
Parents sometimes hope that a foreign custody order obtained after leaving will fix the situation. Inside the European Union, Brussels II ter organises recognition of custody decisions but gives priority to the courts of habitual residence and to return orders in abduction cases, as shown in Council Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter (CELEX 32019R1111). Outside the European Union, recognition depends on bilateral treaties or on French private international law, and French courts remain cautious when a parent creates facts abroad in breach of joint custody. The order in which you act matters: the parent who applies first in the country of habitual residence, before any move, is usually in the stronger position. The parent who moves first and applies second spends the case explaining the move instead of discussing the child interest.
Conclusion
Do not treat a refusal as a formality. For a short holiday, French law starts from joint parental authority under Article 371-1 of the Civil Code, Article 372-1 of the Civil Code, and Article 373-2 of the Civil Code, and it gives the JAF the power to authorise or refuse each disputed trip under Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code by protecting the child bond with each parent. For a permanent move, the same judge applies a documented relocation test centred on habitual residence under Council Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter (CELEX 32019R1111), and an unauthorised departure can trigger a Hague return case under the Article 3 test confirmed in Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 12 June 2025, No 24-17.787, plus criminal liability under Article 227-5 of the Penal Code. In both situations the winning file is the same: a precise proposal, full papers, early notice to the other parent, and a court order obtained before departure. If your ex has just said no, keep the message, do not travel on force, and put that file before the right judge in Paris without delay.