Your father was an American citizen who spent his last twelve years in Paris. He owned a two-bedroom apartment in the 11th arrondissement, kept a checking account at a French bank, and still held a brokerage account and an IRA in Ohio. He never signed a French will. There is an old California will from before the move, and there is a second wife — also American, living in Paris — plus two children from a first marriage, one in Cleveland and one in Lyon. Now the Paris notaire (the French public officer who settles every estate with French assets) tells you that French law may govern everything, including the Ohio accounts, and that the children may own fixed shares no will can take away. You wonder how a French judge could decide the fate of American accounts, whether the California will counts for anything, and what your stepmother actually inherits when not all the children are hers. This guide answers those questions in order: which court rules and which law applies when an American dies in France without a French will, and then how a written election of American law works, what safety net France keeps for children and the surviving spouse, and what the estate owes the French tax office before anyone touches the money.
I. Which Court Rules and Which Law Applies When an American Dies in France Without a French Will?
A. Your Father’s Last Habitual Home Decides Both the Judge and the Law
French succession law starts with a short sentence that surprises Americans used to state-by-state probate: “Les successions s’ouvrent par la mort, au dernier domicile du défunt” (successions open upon death, at the last domicile of the deceased) (Civil Code, Article 720). For cross-border estates inside Europe, that domestic starting point is completed — and for deaths on or after August 17, 2015, replaced — by a European regulation that France applies directly. Its jurisdiction rule is blunt: the courts of the Member State where the deceased had his habitual residence at death have jurisdiction to rule on the succession as a whole (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 4). Habitual residence, not citizenship and not the location of any single asset, picks the judge, and the same factor then picks the law, as Part I.B explains. If your father lived day-to-day life in Paris for twelve years — apartment, bank, doctors, friends, tax filings — his habitual residence at death was France, so the French courts rule on the whole succession and, by default, French substantive law governs it.
Habitual residence is a facts-first test, not a paperwork test. The regulation tells the authority handling the estate how to run it: the authority handling the estate must weigh the whole picture of the deceased’s life over the years before death and at death — length and regularity of presence in each country, and the conditions and reasons for it — to find the close, stable link the regulation demands (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, recital 23). The French Court of Cassation applies exactly that method. In a 2019 file, the deceased had died in New York leaving three children and a will disinheriting his daughter, who then sued her siblings before a French court for judicial partition, arguing his habitual residence had been Paris. The Paris court weighed the evidence and fixed habitual residence in New York, and the Court of Cassation approved, noting that “la cour d’appel, qui s’est déterminée par une appréciation souveraine des éléments de preuve, sans être tenue de s’expliquer spécialement sur ceux qu’elle décidait d’écarter ni de suivre les parties dans le détail de leur argumentation” (the court of appeal, deciding through its sovereign assessment of the evidence, without having to explain specifically the items it set aside or follow the parties through every detail of their argument), “a estimé que la résidence habituelle du défunt était située à New York, ce dont elle a exactement déduit que la juridiction française était incompétente pour statuer sur sa succession” (held the deceased’s habitual residence was in New York, from which it correctly deduced the French court had no jurisdiction over his succession) (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, May 29, 2019, No. 18-13.383). Duration and regularity of presence, reasons for it, family and social center, and a close, stable link with the country all count, and the assessment belongs to the trial judges, who weigh the evidence sovereignly.
Apply that test honestly to your family before assuming anything. Twelve continuous years in the Paris apartment, French tax residence, French health coverage, daily life organized from Paris: that file points to France, and the notaire will treat the succession as French-governed unless someone proves otherwise. The mirror case is the snowbird father who spent five months a year in a Paris pied-à-terre and seven months in Florida, voted in Florida, filed as a Florida resident, and kept his doctors and club there. There the regulation itself warns that some files are complex — alternating homes, travel without settling — and that in such cases nationality or the location of the main assets can tip the overall assessment (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, recital 24). Keep every factual exhibit the notaire will ask for: leases and utility bills in both countries, travel records, tax returns on each side, health-insurance affiliation, and proof of where family life actually happened. A passport never decides habitual residence by itself, but twelve years of Paris life plus French-centered paperwork makes contesting France an uphill case, and pretending the question does not exist is how families lose a year arguing jurisdiction before dividing a single euro.
B. One Single Law Now Covers the Paris Apartment and the American Accounts Together
The biggest shock for American families is the unity rule. Before August 17, 2015, France split estates: French real estate followed French law while movables followed the law of the last domicile, so a Paris apartment and an Ohio brokerage account could pass under two different laws. That world is gone for recent deaths. The regulation now provides that the law of the State where the deceased had his habitual residence at death governs the succession as a whole, unless the regulation provides otherwise (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 21(1)). One connecting factor, one law, one succession: if habitual residence was Paris, French law governs the Paris apartment and the Ohio accounts alike, including who counts as an heir, in what shares, and which gifts or will provisions survive. The old split survives only in the files of the past. The Court of Cassation still had to apply it to a 2013 death with a French-situated gift, upholding the application of French forced-heirship rules to buildings located in France, which the testamentary provisions made under the law of the deceased’s domicile could not set aside (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, April 14, 2021, No. 19-24.773). Read that decision as history, not as today’s roadmap: it shows how jealously French courts protected children under the old system, while your father’s 2026 death falls squarely under the single-law regulation.
French law then takes over the machinery of transmission. The Civil Code provides that “Les héritiers désignés par la loi sont saisis de plein droit des biens, droits et actions du défunt” (the heirs designated by law are seized as of right of the property, rights, and actions of the deceased) (Civil Code, Article 724), and that “La succession est dévolue par la loi aux parents et au conjoint successibles du défunt dans les conditions définies ci-après” (the succession devolves by law to the relatives and the surviving spouse entitled to inherit, under the conditions defined below) (Civil Code, Article 731). Seisin (saisine) matters in practice: lawful heirs step into the estate automatically at death, before any court order, which is why the French bank freezes the accounts on learning of the death and releases them only against the notaire’s paperwork, not against an American probate order. The Ohio brokerage will ask for its own American process, but on the French side the notaire works from French heirship as determined by the applicable law, and a California court order alone does not unblock Paris funds.
Two escape hatches exist, and both are narrower than families hope. First, where the whole picture shows the deceased was manifestly more closely connected with another country despite living in France — the classic file being a very recent move to France with everything else still American — the estate authority may apply that other country’s law instead of the residence law. The Court of Cassation described the fork exactly: once a court takes jurisdiction, it still applies the residence-state law “sauf s’il résulte de l’ensemble des circonstances de la cause que, au moment de son décès, le défunt présentait des liens manifestement plus étroits avec un autre Etat (article 21 du règlement) ou avait fait le choix exprès de la loi d’un autre Etat (article 22)” (unless the circumstances as a whole show that, at the time of death, the deceased was manifestly more closely connected with another State (Article 21 of the Regulation) or had expressly chosen the law of another State (Article 22)) (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, November 18, 2020, No. 19-15.438, referral to the Court of Justice of the European Union). Do not read that safety valve as a general option for long-settled expatriates: after twelve Paris years it helps almost nobody, and it can never be used merely because habitual residence was hard to pin down. Second, where the deceased lived outside any EU Member State — say Florida — French courts can still rule on French-situated assets, but only within the subsidiary jurisdiction the regulation grants over property located in the Member State (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 10). That is the reverse of your file: the habitual Florida resident who kept a Paris studio gets a French case about the studio, while your Paris-domiciled father gets a French case about everything.
II. How Do You Protect the Children, the Surviving Spouse, and the Estate From Double Tax?
A. Electing American Law in a French Will: the Choice That Lets Your Father Decide in Advance
European law lets your father override the default with a written choice, called professio juris (choice of law for the succession). The rule is short: any person may elect the law of a State whose nationality he or she holds — at the time of the choice or at death — to govern the succession as a whole, and a person holding several nationalities may pick any of them (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 22(1)). An American citizen living in Paris can therefore elect American law — in practice, the law of a given US state as determined through American conflicts rules — to govern the whole succession, Paris apartment included. The reason Europe restricts the menu to nationality laws is spelled out in the preamble: Europe limits the menu to nationality laws so the deceased keeps a genuine link with the chosen law and cannot pick a law merely to defeat the expectations of forced heirs (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, recital 38). A French-American dual national has two menus to pick from; a single-nationality American has exactly one alternative to French law, and a choice of, say, Swiss law by a pure American would be void.
Form is where American families win or lose the election. The choice must be made expressly in a declaration taking the form of a disposition of property upon death, or be demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition: the election must appear expressly in a declaration made as a disposition of property upon death, or at least clearly emerge from the terms of such a disposition (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, recital 39). Concretely, that means a will — and for a Paris estate, a French will, not vibes from an old California document. The old California will predating the move fails twice: it names no law, so no express choice exists, and its references to California community-property concepts do not demonstrate an election of American law within the meaning of the regulation, which looks for references to specific provisions of the nationality state’s law or an equivalent mention. A fresh French will fixes this in one paragraph: full identification, statement of American nationality, express election of the law of the United States (specifying the state whose law should govern, since inheritance is state law in America), then the dispositions. French form offers two vehicles. The holographic will (testament olographe), entirely handwritten, dated, and signed, costs nothing and is valid if the formalities are perfect — which is precisely why American hands, unused to French formalities, so often get it wrong. The notarial will (testament authentique), dictated before a notaire with witnesses and kept at the office, costs a fee and buys near-bulletproof form plus automatic registration with the French central will registry (FCDDV), so the will actually surfaces at death instead of sitting undiscovered in an Ohio drawer. For a Paris apartment owner, the notarial route is the only serious option, and the election should be re-signed after every major life event: move to France, marriage, divorce, new child, acquisition of the apartment.
Three warnings keep the election honest. First, the election must cover the succession as a whole; you cannot elect Ohio law for the brokerage account and French law for the apartment. Second, electing American law does not erase every French protection, because the children keep the compensatory safety net described in Part II.B and because the election is tested for validity under the chosen law itself. Third, an election interacts with the matrimonial side of the file: the apartment bought during the second marriage may be community or separate property depending on the couple’s matrimonial regime, and that question follows its own conflicts rules, not the succession election. Couples who bought together should read our guide to the gift between spouses that protects the survivor of a French home alongside this article, and surviving spouses worried about staying in the home should read the guide on keeping the French home against children who want a sale. In Paris practice, the competent notaire’s office opens the file, orders the registry searches, establishes heirship under the applicable law, and tells the family within weeks whether the election holds or French intestacy governs — which is exactly the analysis Part II.B now applies to the children and the widow.
B. The Safety Net France Refuses to Drop: Children’s Fixed Shares, the Compensatory Levy, and the Widow’s Quarter
French intestacy protects children first, and it does so with arithmetic, not discretion. The Civil Code defines the mechanism plainly: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent” (the forced heirship share is the portion of the estate assets and rights whose devolution free of charges the law guarantees to certain heirs called forced heirs, if they are called to the succession and accept it) (Civil Code, Article 912). The fractions that follow are mandatory reading for every American parent with a Paris asset: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre” (gifts, whether inter vivos or by will, may not exceed half of the donor’s property if he leaves one child at death; one-third if he leaves two children; one-quarter if he leaves three or more) (Civil Code, Article 913). With two children, each child’s combined forced share math works out to one-third of the estate, and only the remaining third — the freely disposable portion (quotité disponible) — can go wherever the will says, including entirely to the second wife. A California will leaving everything to the widow and nothing to the children collapses against this wall to the extent it touches a French-governed succession: the children sue for reduction (action en réduction), and the Code reserves that lawsuit to the protected circle, providing that “La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause” (reduction of inter vivos dispositions may be demanded only by those for whose benefit the law creates the forced share, by their heirs or assigns), with a limitations clock of five years from the opening of the succession or two years from learning of the infringement, never more than ten years from death (Civil Code, Article 921). Lifetime gifts count too: the Paris apartment donated to one child years ago re-enters the accounting through the fictitious hotchpot (rapport and réunion fictive) before shares are computed, so pre-death generosity never quietly defeats the other child’s portion.
Electing American law softens this wall but no longer removes it entirely, and this is the point families most often misunderstand. Since the statute of November 2, 2021, codified inside Article 913, France gives children a fallback levy when the foreign law governing the succession offers them no forced-share protection at all: where the deceased or at least one child was, at death, a national of an EU Member State or habitually resident there, and the applicable foreign law provides no reserved-share mechanism protecting children, “chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès” (each child or their heirs or assigns may take a compensatory levy from the existing assets located in France at the day of death), “de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci” (so as to be restored to the forced-heirship rights French law grants them, within the limit of those rights) (Civil Code, Article 913, compensatory levy). In your file the levy bites directly: elect Ohio law, disinherit the Lyon child, and that child restores a French-law forced share by levying against the Paris apartment and the French bank balance up to the French amount. The levy needs a French asset to bite on and a child connected to the EU, which your Lyon-based child satisfies effortlessly, and the Cleveland child may satisfy through the father’s own French habitual residence. An election of American law thus buys testamentary freedom for the American-situated wealth while leaving the Paris wealth exposed to top-up claims — a half-shield families must price before choosing. Where no election was made and French law governs everything, the children simply take their intestacy shares and the reduction action polices any excess gifts.
The second wife’s position turns on one brutal fact of blended families: not all the children are hers. The Code states the surviving spouse’s menu as follows: “Si l’époux prédécédé laisse des enfants ou descendants, le conjoint survivant recueille, à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens lorsque tous les enfants sont issus des deux époux et la propriété du quart en présence d’un ou plusieurs enfants qui ne sont pas issus des deux époux” (if the predeceased spouse leaves children or descendants, the surviving spouse takes, at his or her choice, the usufruct of all existing property or ownership of one-quarter where all children are the couple’s joint issue, and ownership of one-quarter where one or more children are not the joint issue of both spouses) (Civil Code, Article 757). Because the Cleveland and Lyon children predate the second marriage, the widow gets no menu at all: the Court of Cassation quashed an appellate court that had treated a widow in exactly this configuration as holding a usufruct option, holding that “en présence d’un enfant non commun, les droits légaux du conjoint survivant ne pouvaient être que de la propriété du quart des biens existants, sans faculté d’option pour l’usufruit de la totalité de ces biens” (where a non-joint child exists, the surviving spouse’s legal rights could only be ownership of one-quarter of the existing property, with no option for usufruct over all of it) (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, March 5, 2025, No. 23-11.430). One-quarter in full ownership of the whole estate, Paris apartment included — that is her intestacy floor, and the usufruct-over-everything outcome American couples casually assume requires either joint children only or an extra gift (donation entre époux or will) on top of the statute. Add the tax layer before anyone celebrates: heirs must file the French succession declaration within tight statutory time — “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas” (six months from death where the deceased died in metropolitan France; one year in all other cases) (General Tax Code, Article 641) — and the estate treaty between the United States and France, signed in Washington on November 24, 1978 and amended by the protocol of December 8, 2004 , published as US Senate Treaty Document 109-7 (estate and gift tax convention with France), decides which country taxes which asset first and how the other credits it. The official French public guidance describes each step of settling a succession. Our companion guides walk through the six- and twelve-month declaration and the treaty credit and what American families must prove about domicile under the estate tax treaty. Miss the French deadline from Ohio and interest plus penalties accrue while the Paris apartment sits legally frozen, which is why the notaire’s first letter always lists dates before it lists shares.
Conclusion
When an American dies in France without a French will, habitual residence picks both the judge and the law, and after twelve Paris years that points to France governing the Paris apartment and the American accounts as one estate. The children then hold fixed forced shares — one-third each with two children — enforceable by a reduction action, and a non-joint widow takes one-quarter in ownership with no usufruct option. A written election of American nationality law in a French will can restore testamentary freedom, but the 2021 compensatory levy lets EU-connected children top up from French-situated assets, so the election shields Ohio wealth far better than Paris bricks. File the succession declaration within six months of a French death, claim the treaty credit on the American return, and put the election in a notarial will registered in Paris rather than trusting an old California document. Do those five things in that order — prove residence, read the will for an election, compute the forced shares, fix the widow’s quarter, calendar the tax — and the family divides the estate instead of litigating it.