On 10 September 2026, Al Jazeera reported that Tunisian pro-Palestinian activists detained in connection with the Global Sumud Flotilla remain in pre-trial detention in Tunis, and that the health of hunger striker Wael Naouar is deteriorating. Four men, Naouar, Nabil Channoufi, Ghassan Henchiri and Ghassan Boughdiri, are still held in Mornaguia prison, six months after their arrest, while three of the seven activists initially detained have been released. Three detained flotilla leaders have now joined Naouar in an open-ended hunger strike, according to a coalition press release dated 10 September 2026. The Tunis detentions are the landward side of a much larger cross-border legal battle. In May 2026, the coalition says, Israeli naval warships surrounded and intercepted its vessels in international waters, about 250 nautical miles from Gaza, weeks after a first interception more than 650 nautical miles out in which 181 volunteers aboard 21 boats were boarded and taken to Israel. French nationals sailed in these missions, and a French member of the European Parliament, Rima Hassan, was among the public figures involved in the 2025 sailing. For an international audience, and especially for French citizens who joined the flotillas or supported them, two legal questions now dominate: was the high-seas boarding lawful, and what can France concretely do for its nationals detained or mistreated abroad? This analysis answers both, from the law of the sea to the criminal courts of Paris.
I. Can a Gaza-bound flotilla lawfully be boarded on the high seas?
A. Freedom of navigation leaves only narrow grounds for stopping a foreign vessel far from shore
The starting point is simple and protects every civilian vessel on the planet: on the high seas, a ship is subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the state whose flag it flies, and no warship may board it unless an exception applies. The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, signed at Montego Bay in 1982 and ratified by France, enshrines the freedom of navigation and the exclusive jurisdiction of the flag state, and its article 110 lists exhaustively the cases in which a warship may exercise a right of visit: reasonable suspicion of piracy, of the slave trade, of unauthorized broadcasting, or that the ship is without nationality or refusing to show its flag. A humanitarian flotilla carrying doctors, journalists and unarmed volunteers matches none of these categories on its face, which is why the coalition insists that the May 2026 interception, 250 nautical miles from Gaza, and the earlier boarding more than 650 nautical miles out, occurred in international waters where only the flag states had jurisdiction. The distances matter legally: 250 nautical miles is far beyond any territorial sea of 12 nautical miles, beyond the contiguous zone of 24 nautical miles and beyond the exclusive economic zone of 200 nautical miles, so the interceptions, on the coalition’s account, took place on the high seas in the full sense of the Convention. Israel is not a party to the Convention, but its provisions on the high seas are widely regarded as reflecting customary international law binding on all states, and France, as a party, reads them as such. The state carrying out the interception answers with a different body of law: the law of naval blockade. Under the customary rules reflected in the San Remo Manual, a lawfully established and effectively enforced blockade may be maintained against vessels bound for the blockaded coast, including by visit and capture beyond the blockade zone, provided the blockade has been duly declared and notified, applies impartially, and does not bar access to neutral ports. Israel maintains that its naval blockade of Gaza meets these conditions; the flotilla, the United Nations fact-finding mission on the 2010 Mavi Marmara incident, and much of the legal literature answer that a blockade that collectively punishes a civilian population cannot be lawful, and that humanitarian vessels must in any event be allowed through or searched rather than seized with their passengers detained for weeks. Readers following international courts will recognize the pattern: the same clash between enforcement claims and humanitarian protections already structures the Gaza cases pending in The Hague, including the Nicaragua v. Germany proceedings on arms exports whose preliminary-objections hearings closed in The Hague on 10 September 2026, as covered in our analysis of Nicaragua v. Germany at the ICJ. The flotilla question is narrower but sharper, because it turns on verifiable facts: exact positions, flag states, prior notification, and what happened on deck.
B. Blockade, consent and the flotilla’s answer: the facts on deck decide everything
Even assuming a blockade could in principle be enforced, international law surrounds every boarding with hard limits, and the flotilla’s account alleges that each of them was crossed. First, proportionality and humanity: force used to enforce a blockade must remain necessary and proportionate, and civilians, the wounded and the detained must be treated humanely. The coalition states that during the earlier interception its participants were subjected to documented physical mistreatment in detention, and that the May 2026 operation encircled slow civilian boats with warships before boarding them. These are allegations, not judicial findings, and any lawyer must mark that distinction, but they are precisely the kind of allegations that trigger criminal jurisdiction in the volunteers’ home states, as explained below. Second, the treatment of detainees: civilians intercepted at sea must be released promptly once the military purpose is achieved, and prolonged detention, transfer to the intercepting state’s territory and deportation proceedings demand a legal basis that a mere attempt to sail to Gaza does not obviously supply. The coalition reports that 181 volunteers were taken to Israel, detained, and only gradually released or deported, and that ten volunteers seized with the land convoy near Sirte, Libya, were held for about thirty days before their release was announced. Third, the protection of specific categories: journalists, medical personnel and parliamentarians aboard the boats enjoy no immunity from a lawful visit, but any violence against them is an aggravating fact that domestic prosecutors weigh heavily. The precedent every practitioner cites is the 2010 Mavi Marmara boarding, in which nine passengers were killed: the UN Human Rights Council fact-finding mission concluded that the operation was disproportionate and that the blockade itself was unlawful, while Israel’s own Turkel Commission reached the opposite conclusion on the blockade. That split is instructive: fifteen years later, no international tribunal has settled the underlying legal dispute, so the practical fight has moved into national courts, with the flotilla’s legal team announcing criminal investigations across twenty countries. France is one of the natural forums for such complaints, because French law gives its courts unusually broad tools to judge facts committed abroad against French nationals, which is the subject of the second part of this analysis.
The history of the Gaza blockade explains why lawyers disagree so sharply. Israel declared the naval blockade in 2009 and notified it to the relevant maritime bodies, and the UN Secretary-General’s Palmer Panel subsequently found that the blockade as such had a lawful basis while condemning the 2010 boarding as excessive and unreasonable in its use of force. That split reasoning, blockade declared and notified on one side, boarding methods judged unlawful on the other, remains the template for every flotilla case since: the intercepting state invokes the declaration and the flotilla invokes the method. For the 2026 interceptions, the method is precisely what the coalition contests, citing encirclement by warships, sabotage of vessels and weeks of detention, and it is on those facts, positions, logs, videos and medical reports, that any future court, international or French, will rule.
II. Detained abroad after an interception: the French legal toolkit for flotilla volunteers
A. Consular protection: what the French state owes its nationals held in foreign cells
The first reflex of any family whose relative is detained abroad is to call the French authorities, and international law gives that call a real foundation. Article 36 of the 1963 Vienna Convention on Consular Relations provides that a detained foreign national must be informed without delay of the right to contact the consulate, that the consulate must be notified if the detainee so requests, and that consular officers may visit, converse and arrange legal representation. These guarantees apply whether the detention follows a high-seas interception or, as in Tunis, a domestic arrest: the four activists still held in Mornaguia prison include no French nationals as far as public reporting shows, but French volunteers seized at sea and transferred to Israel were entitled to French consular visits from the moment of their detention, and any failure to notify the consulate is itself a violation that France may protest through diplomatic channels. Within the European Union, protection goes one step further: Directive 2015/637 requires any member state represented locally to assist unrepresented Union citizens on the same terms as its own nationals, so a French volunteer detained in a country where France has no post could turn to another EU consulate. That said, honesty requires stating the limits clearly. Consular assistance is a state prerogative exercised with wide discretion, not an individual right that a court will enforce by ordering a government to extract its nationals; it secures visits, lawyers, information and pressure, not release. The French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs operates a crisis center that follows collective detentions of this kind, and parliamentary and press attention, such as the involvement of a French MEP in the flotilla saga, historically accelerates consular mobilization. Families should therefore do three things at once: formally seize the French consulate and the crisis center in writing, mandate a local lawyer immediately rather than waiting for the consulate to appoint one, and preserve every document, bracelet number, deportation order and medical certificate, because the same facts will feed the criminal complaint in Paris. Consular protection keeps the detainee safe and visible; punishment of the perpetrators, if the facts support it, runs through the criminal courts, and there French law is strikingly generous.
B. Complaining in Paris for what happened at sea: personal jurisdiction and universal jurisdiction
French criminal law follows French victims abroad, and it does so through two complementary doors that flotilla volunteers should understand. The first door is the personal jurisdiction of articles 113-6 to 113-8 of the Penal Code. Article 113-6 states that: “La loi pénale française est applicable à tout crime commis par un Français hors du territoire de la République.” It adds that French law applies to lesser offences committed by French nationals abroad only where the conduct is also punishable in the country where it occurred. Symmetrically, offences committed abroad against French victims can be prosecuted in France, but article 113-8 sets a procedural lock for lesser offences: for the cases of articles 113-6 and 113-7, “la poursuite des délits ne peut être exercée qu’à la requête du ministère public. Elle doit être précédée d’une plainte de la victime ou de ses ayants droit ou d’une dénonciation officielle par l’autorité du pays où le fait a été commis.” In plain terms, a French volunteer who suffered violence, illegal detention, theft of equipment or degrading treatment during a boarding can file a complaint in France, and for the most serious qualifications, crimes, no prior foreign complaint is needed. The second door is universal jurisdiction under articles 689 to 689-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Article 689 provides that: “Les auteurs ou complices d’infractions commises hors du territoire de la République peuvent être poursuivis et jugés par les juridictions françaises soit lorsque, conformément aux dispositions du livre Ier du code pénal ou d’un autre texte législatif, la loi française est applicable, soit lorsqu’une convention internationale ou un acte pris en application du traité instituant les Communautés européennes donne compétence aux juridictions françaises pour connaître de l’infraction.” Article 689-1 then states that: “En application des conventions internationales visées aux articles suivants, peut être poursuivie et jugée par les juridictions françaises, si elle se trouve en France, toute personne qui s’est rendue coupable hors du territoire de la République de l’une des infractions énumérées par ces articles.” And article 689-2 specifies that: “Pour l’application de la convention contre la torture et autres peines ou traitements cruels, inhumains ou dégradants, adoptée à New York le 10 décembre 1984, peut être poursuivie et jugée dans les conditions prévues à l’article 689-1 toute personne coupable de tortures au sens de l’article 1er de la convention.” The Cour de cassation confirmed the mechanics of this regime on 12 May 2023, in decision number 22-82.468, available on the Cour de cassation website, holding that: “Selon l’article 689-1 du code de procédure pénale, peut être poursuivie et jugée par les juridictions françaises, si elle se trouve en France, toute personne qui s’est rendue coupable, hors du territoire de la République, de l’une des infractions énumérées par les articles suivants.” It added that: “Aux termes de l’article 689-2 du même code, pour l’application de la Convention contre la torture et autres peines ou traitements cruels, inhumains ou dégradants, adoptée à New York le 10 décembre 1984, peut être poursuivie et jugée dans les conditions prévues à l’article 689-1 toute personne coupable de tortures au sens de l’article 1er de la Convention.” For flotilla cases, the practical qualifications to examine with counsel are unlawful arrest and confinement, violence by persons exercising public authority, and, where the documented facts reach that threshold, torture or inhuman treatment, the latter opening the universal-jurisdiction door whenever the suspect is present in France. Two further French provisions complete the picture. Article 223-6 of the Penal Code punishes the failure to assist a person in peril: “Quiconque pouvant empêcher par son action immédiate, sans risque pour lui ou pour les tiers, soit un crime, soit un délit contre l’intégrité corporelle de la personne s’abstient volontairement de le faire est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 euros d’amende. Sera puni des mêmes peines quiconque s’abstient volontairement de porter à une personne en péril l’assistance que, sans risque pour lui ou pour les tiers, il pouvait lui prêter soit par son action personnelle, soit en provoquant un secours.” This offence was at the heart of the Channel shipwreck case in which, on 4 November 2025, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation, decision number 24-86.781, available on the Cour de cassation website, reviewed proceedings conducted before an investigating judge of the Paris court, described as: “exerçant une compétence concurrente sur le territoire national pour les affaires de très grande complexité en application de l’article 706-75, dernier alinéa, du code de procédure pénale (dite « juridiction nationale de lutte contre la criminalité organisée » – JUNALCO)”. The lesson for flotilla volunteers is institutional: Paris hosts specialized judges accustomed to judging facts that occurred at sea and abroad. Complaints alleging torture, war crimes or crimes against humanity are directed to the specialized unit of the Paris judicial court under article 697 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which provides that: “Dans le ressort d’une ou de plusieurs cours d’appel, un tribunal judiciaire est compétent pour l’instruction et, s’il s’agit de délits, le jugement des infractions mentionnées à l’article 697-1.” A complaint with civil-party constitution before the Paris investigating judge interrupts limitation periods and forces a judicial investigation, provided the facts alleged are precise, dated and evidenced: boarding positions, hull numbers, names of units, medical certificates, photographs, and witness statements taken quickly before memories fade. The official texts cited here are freely verifiable: article 113-6 of the Penal Code, article 113-8 of the Penal Code, article 223-6 of the Penal Code, article 689 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, article 689-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, article 689-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and article 697 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, all on Légifrance. One caution closes this section: none of these avenues prejudges guilt, and French prosecutors regularly dismiss complaints where the evidence shows a lawful visit, proportionate force and prompt release. The strength of a flotilla file therefore depends entirely on the quality of the proof gathered in the first days, which is why volunteers should treat documentation as part of the mission itself.
In practice, counsel will often file the Paris complaint with constitution de partie civile, which triggers a judicial investigation and gives the victim access to the file, rather than a simple complaint left to prosecutorial discretion. Time limits depend on the qualification retained, with crimes against humanity imprescriptible and most other qualifications subject to limitation periods that run from the facts, so early filing matters as much as precise drafting. Witness statements should be collected within days, medical findings documented by forensic units, and every position, photograph and hull marking preserved, because a boarding that leaves no paper trail is far harder to judge years later.
Conclusion
The Tunis hunger strike of 10 September 2026 gives a human face to a legal confrontation that now spans three arenas: Tunisian pre-trial detention, where four activists have been held since March under money-laundering and fraud charges their lawyer calls political; the high seas, where two 2026 interceptions at 250 and more than 650 nautical miles from Gaza test the boundary between lawful blockade enforcement and unlawful boarding; and the courts of the volunteers’ home countries, where criminal complaints will succeed or fail on evidence. France occupies a distinctive place in this triangle. It cannot order the release of detainees held by Tunisia or Israel, but it must deploy consular protection for its nationals, and its criminal courts stand open to judge violence and illegal detention suffered by French citizens abroad, from personal jurisdiction to universal jurisdiction for torture. The next milestones are concrete and dated: the health of the hunger strikers in Mornaguia, the September 16 court session of Wael Naouar announced by the coalition, and the criminal investigations the flotilla’s lawyers say are moving forward in twenty countries. Anyone concerned, volunteer, family member or witness, should act now: secure consular contact, mandate counsel where the detention occurs, preserve every piece of evidence, and have the Paris complaint assessed by a lawyer before limitation or dispersing memories weaken the file. International law rarely delivers swift victories, but it rewards those who document early and file precisely.