On 9 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union dismissed Roman Abramovich’s third attempt to escape European sanctions. In Case T-358/25, the Luxembourg judges upheld the asset freeze and travel ban renewed against the former Chelsea owner in 2025, rejected his claim for one million euros in damages, and ordered him to pay the Council’s legal costs. The ruling matters well beyond one billionaire. It confirms that holding a large stake in a Russian steel and mining giant is enough to stay listed, even without proof of control over the company or influence over the Kremlin. And with the EU’s individual sanctions expiring on 15 September 2026, every listed person with property, accounts, or business interests in France is about to go through the same review. This analysis explains what Luxembourg decided, word for word, and what it changes in practice for frozen assets on French soil.
I. Why the General Court Kept Abramovich on the EU Sanctions List
A. How the leading businessperson test trapped a 28.64 percent Evraz stake
The story starts weeks after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The Council listed Abramovich in March 2022, freezing his funds and banning his entry into and transit through the European Union as a leading businessperson active in economic sectors viewed as a substantial source of revenue for the Russian government. He challenged the listing, lost before the General Court in December 2023 in Case T-313/22, challenged again, and lost again in September 2025 in Case T-1105/23. After receiving his observations, the Council adopted fresh acts extending the measures, first to 15 September 2025 and then to 15 March 2026. Abramovich attacked those renewal acts and asked for compensation for non-material harm. On 9 September 2026, the General Court gave its answer: In its judgment delivered that day, the General Court dismissed Abramovich’s action in full and upheld the Council’s renewal acts. The official press release is published here on the Curia website, and the case file is listed under Case T-358/25 Abramovich v Council.
The decisive criterion comes from the 2023 reform of the sanctions framework, introduced by Council Regulation (EU) 2023/1089 amending Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 and the parallel amendment to Decision 2014/145/CFSP. It targets leading businesspersons operating in Russia, in sectors generating significant revenue for the Russian government. The Court found these criteria objective, sufficiently precise, and proportionate, noting that those criteria single out leading businesspersons operating in Russia, a country where the main economic operators have close ties to the State. Size of the holding did the rest. The judgment recalls: he is in fact the majority shareholder in Evraz, the parent company of one of the leading Russian steel and mining groups. He also owns shares in Norilsk Nickel, one of the world’s leading producers of palladium and a key operator in refined nickel. And the figures backed the listing: the Evraz annual report for 2021 attributes 66.3 percent of the group’s yearly revenue to steel.
Three holdings of the ruling deserve attention from anyone advising sanctioned clients. First, the Council does not have to prove control of the company, support for Moscow, or influence over the Kremlin. Economic weight is enough. Reporting on the judgment notes a 28.64 percent stake proved sufficient, and Dublin City University sanctions scholar Niall Moran summed up the lesson: the evidential test applied to the Council is real, but the threshold it must clear is not especially demanding, in the assessment of Dublin City University sanctions scholar Niall Moran. Second, fame is not a defense. Abramovich argued he had been picked for his public notoriety. The Court answered that it was the application of the criteria, having regard to the importance of his capital holdings, which led to the measures, not a desire to exploit his profile. Third, the exit door the judges left ajar is narrow but real: Abramovich had failed to prove that selling his Evraz shares was impossible. A listed person who can document, with bank letters, refused clearances, and blocked closings, that every sale route is genuinely closed by overlapping EU, British, and American restrictions may one day reopen the debate. Assertion alone will not do. Files win these cases, not narratives.
The contrast with the week-old victory of another applicant sharpens the point. On 3 September 2026, the Court of Justice annulled the freeze imposed on a Lithuanian energy company in the Inter Rao Lietuva line of cases, as analyzed in our review of that ruling. There, the Council’s file did not support the listing. Here, audited revenue figures and a majority shareholding did. Same courts, same week, opposite outcomes: the difference is always the evidence in the file, never the headline on the case.
B. Why proportionality, one million euros in damages, and the who really decided claim all failed
Abramovich threw the full arsenal at the renewal acts: vague criteria, disproportionate restrictions, decisions supposedly taken behind closed doors by Council working groups, breach of human dignity, breach of free movement as a Portuguese citizen, and defective review of his situation. The Court rejected each one, and the reasoning now serves as a checklist for every future challenge.
On process, the judges refused to see a shadow decision-maker. The press release states that the Council had simply relied on that preparatory work to decide whether to adopt the contested measures, and that involving preparatory bodies such as Coreper, the COEST working party, and RELEX to simplify the final decision involving preparatory bodies in reviewing the measures does not mean the Council gives up or delegates its decision-making power. Lawyers hunting a procedural shortcut around the Council’s authorship of listings will need something far stronger than the routine preparation of files by working groups.
On substance, proportionality survived because the system contains safety valves. The Court held that the restrictions are founded on a legislative basis which clearly and precisely defines their scope, that they respect the essence of free movement since they provide for derogations and periodic reviews, and that they are proportionate and appropriate to promoting a peaceful settlement of the crisis in Ukraine. The release adds that Abramovich had proposed no less restrictive alternative capable of achieving the objectives pursued. That sentence is a direct message to future applicants: arrive with a concrete, workable alternative measure, or do not raise proportionality at all. The damages claim collapsed with the annulment claim, as it always does when the underlying acts stand, and the human-dignity plea, alongside a commissioned legal opinion about the impossibility of selling the Evraz stake, carried little weight against documented revenue figures.
One procedural detail matters for the calendar. The ruling is not the end of the road: an appeal limited to points of law may be brought before the Court of Justice within two months and ten days of notification of the General Court’s decision. Expect any appeal to focus on points of law, the interpretation of the leading-businessperson criterion, and the handling of the sanctions-trap argument, because the facts, the shareholding, and the 66.3 percent steel-revenue figure are now judicially settled. Meanwhile a parallel saga continues in London and Jersey, where the frozen 2.5 billion pounds from the Chelsea sale remain earmarked for Ukraine’s war victims, the British government warns the clock is ticking, and litigation over the Jersey investigation has already reached the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, whose case page is published here. Luxembourg, London, and Jersey are three fronts of one war over the same fortune, and each forum applies different rules.
II. What the 9 September 2026 Ruling Changes for Frozen Assets in France
A. How an EU freeze bites in practice on French bank accounts, villas, and companies
An EU listing is not a foreign event that France politely acknowledges. Council regulations are directly applicable in every Member State, which means the freeze ordered in Brussels operates in Paris, Nice, and Bordeaux without any French transposition. Article 2 of Regulation No 269/2014 freezes all funds and economic resources belonging to, owned, held, or controlled by listed persons, and forbids making any funds or resources available to them. French banks, notaries, insurers, and company registries apply it the same day the Official Journal publishes the name. For a client, the first sign is usually brutal and administrative: a blocked account, a refused transfer, a sale frozen at the notary’s office, an insurer suspending a contract.
France then adds its own national layer. Article L. 562-3 of the Code monétaire et financier provides that “Le ministre chargé de l’économie peut décider, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques : 1° Qui appartiennent à, sont possédés, détenus ou contrôlés par des personnes physiques ou morales” designated under United Nations Chapter VII resolutions or acts adopted under Article 29 of the Treaty on European Union or Article 75 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. The full text is available here on Légifrance. The terrorism track sits beside it in Article L. 562-2, and the definitions of funds and resources appear in Article L. 562-1. Compliance is not optional for anyone on French territory. Article L. 562-4 states: “Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre et aux articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 et d’en informer immédiatement le ministre chargé de l’économie” a duty enforceable against every person on national territory and every entity operating in France, as detailed here on Légifrance, and the obliged banks, insurers, and intermediaries covered are those listed in Article L. 561-2 of the same Code. And Article L. 562-5 adds the second lock: “Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel en vertu des articles L. 562-2 , L. 562-2-1 , L. 562-2-2, L. 562-3 , L. 562-3-1 , L. 712-4 ou L. 712-10” readable here on Légifrance. A well-meaning relative who pays the frozen person’s bills, a business partner who routes money through a side company, or a bank that releases a transfer one hour too early each risks criminal exposure.
In practice, three French mechanisms decide daily life under a freeze. First, the Direction générale du Trésor runs the national register of freezes and grants individual authorizations for basic needs, legal fees, and extraordinary expenses under the derogation articles of the EU regulations. A sanctioned person living in France can eat, pay rent, and pay lawyers, but only with written permission, file by file, euro by euro. Second, banks file reports and freeze first, asking questions later, because their own liability for breach is severe. Third, any sale of frozen property, a villa on the Côte d’Azur, a Paris apartment, shares in a French company, requires prior authorization, and the proceeds stay frozen. This is where the sanctions-trap warning flagged by Luxembourg School of Business scholar Francesca Finelli bites: overlapping regimes can create a sanctions trap in which a listed person cannot realistically exit the EU listing even by divesting, in the assessment of Luxembourg School of Business scholar Francesca Finelli. The General Court acknowledged no impossibility in Abramovich’s case for lack of proof, but the structural problem is real, and France is where it hurts most concretely, at the notary’s desk, when a buyer walks away from a deal the administration will not clear.
Comparison with the American track sharpens the French picture. Washington’s sanctions against the International Criminal Court’s leadership, analyzed in our review of the Akane sanctions, operate through dollar clearing and secondary pressure on banks worldwide. The EU freeze operates through direct legal prohibition inside France, enforced by French authorities and French criminal law. A client with assets in both systems needs two strategies, not one, and the European half is fought in French offices and Luxembourg courtrooms.
B. How to challenge a listing from France without wasting the one shot that counts
The Abramovich ruling of 9 September 2026 reads, for practitioners, as a manual of what not to do and a narrow map of what might still work. Four routes exist, and each has its own clock, its own judge, and its own evidentiary standard.
The first route runs to the Council itself. Every listed person may request delisting, submit observations, and demand the statement of reasons. This step is free, has no strict deadline, and builds the file for everything that follows. The Council reviews listings periodically, and the current cycle is unusually urgent: individual measures expire on 15 September 2026, days after the Abramovich judgment, which means renewal decisions are being prepared now. Observations that document a genuine change, verified sale of the qualifying stake, resignation from the relevant boards, independently audited revenue breakdowns showing the sector is no longer a substantial revenue source, belong in that file today, not after the renewal is published. The Inter Rao Lietuva annulment proves that thin files lose at the review stage and die in court, while the Kesaev litigation over a tobacco-sector listing, examined in our analysis of the General Court’s Kesaev ruling, shows how sector-based criteria are tested holding by holding.
The second route is the action for annulment before the General Court, within two months of notification or publication of the listing or renewal act. This is the route Abramovich took three times. The lessons of 9 September 2026 are blunt. Challenge the criterion with a concrete less-restrictive alternative, or drop proportionality. Attack the file, the shareholding percentages, the revenue attributions, the sector classification, with audited documents, or drop the manifest-error plea. Commissioned legal opinions about sale impossibility weigh little without bank refusals, failed closings, and regulator letters proving each exit was attempted and blocked. And remember that damages ride on annulment: the one-million-euro claim died the moment the acts survived. An appeal lies to the Court of Justice within two months and ten days, on points of law only, which means the factual findings on Evraz and Norilsk Nickel are now nearly untouchable, and only the legal reading of the criterion can still move.
The third route is French, and it is often overlooked by international teams. EU regulations apply directly, but France adopts national implementing measures, ministerial freeze orders, Trésor refusals of authorization, enforcement decisions, and those measures have French judges. A refusal by the Trésor to authorize the sale of a villa or the release of legal fees can be challenged before the administrative courts. The time limit is short: Article R. 421-1 of the Code de justice administrative provides that “La juridiction ne peut être saisie que par voie de recours formé contre une décision, et ce, dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée” as published here on Légifrance. Interim relief exists: Article L. 521-1 allows the urgent judge to suspend a decision when urgency is shown and a serious doubt about legality is raised, since the judge “peut ordonner la suspension de l’exécution de cette décision, ou de certains de ses effets, lorsque l’urgence le justifie et qu’il est fait état d’un moyen propre à créer, en l’état de l’instruction, un doute sérieux quant à la légalité de la décision” readable here on Légifrance. A blocked closing with penalty clauses running, an account frozen days before payroll, or a notarial deed about to lapse can each establish urgency. This French leg cannot annul the EU listing itself, only Luxembourg can do that, but it can unblock a specific authorization, force a reasoned decision out of the administration, and create the paper trail that later supports the Luxembourg action.
The fourth route is Strasbourg, and expectations must stay measured. The European Convention on Human Rights protects property under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, fair process under Article 6, private life under Article 8, and effective remedies under Article 13, and the EU’s own Charter of Fundamental Rights runs alongside. But the Strasbourg court grants States a wide margin in economic warfare waged through sanctions, and the Luxembourg courts have now built a full fundamental-rights review, essence of rights, derogations, periodic re-examination, into the listing system itself. Since the Kadi saga, which established that even United Nations-mandated freezes require effective judicial review in Europe, the trend has favored review in Luxembourg rather than second-guessing from Strasbourg. The Jersey strand of the Abramovich litigation, with its complaints about investigative fairness and data handling now heading toward human-rights arguments, will test those boundaries in a British and Channel Islands setting, but for EU listings the decisive battle remains the General Court, fought on the evidence, within two months, with audited numbers.
For families and business partners caught in the blast radius, one warning matters more than any other. The prohibition on making funds available covers indirect transfers, and French prosecutors read it broadly. Paying the listed person’s staff through an unfrozen company, routing dividends through relatives, or restructuring ownership on paper days after the listing invites prosecution for circumvention while achieving nothing for the delisting file. The only safe payments are those covered by a written Trésor authorization. Everything else must wait for the lawyer, not the accountant.
Conclusion
The General Court’s judgment of 9 September 2026 closes Abramovich’s third case and opens the season for everyone else. Its message is two-sided. For the Council, the leading-businessperson criterion is now battle-tested: documented capital weight in a revenue-generating sector sustains a listing without proof of control or Kremlin influence, and periodic review plus derogations carry proportionality. For listed persons, the judgment maps the only exits that still exist: prove a genuine, documented impossibility to divest rather than asserting it, propose a concrete less-restrictive measure rather than invoking proportionality in the abstract, and attack the numbers in the file rather than the fame of the name. With individual EU measures expiring on 15 September 2026, observations filed in the next days will shape the coming renewal cycle, and any annulment action must follow within two months of the new acts. From France, the practical sequence is a written Trésor authorization strategy for daily survival, administrative challenges against each refusal within the two-month French deadline with interim relief where urgency allows, and a Luxembourg action built on audited evidence, not press clippings. The sanctions trap is real, as scholars warn, but courts reward files that document every locked door. Build that file now, before the renewal ink dries.