KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My French Bank Closed My Account Because I Am American: FATCA, the Two-Month Notice Rule, and How to Get Banking Back

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My French Bank Closed My Account Because I Am American: FATCA, the Two-Month Notice Rule, and How to Get Banking Back

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You opened a checking account when you moved to France, set up your rent, electricity, and health insurance payments on it, and used it for years without incident. Then a letter arrives: your bank is closing your account. The letter mentions American tax status, asks for a United States tax form, or simply gives you a deadline to move your money elsewhere. If you are an American living in France, this letter is rarely a mistake and rarely personal. French banks regularly close accounts held by United States persons because identifying, documenting, and reporting those accounts costs them money and exposes them to American penalties. That commercial logic does not give the bank unlimited freedom. French law lets a bank end an open-ended deposit account, but it imposes a strict procedure, including written notice of at least two months, and it gives you a fast-track right to a replacement account through the Bank of France. This guide explains why Americans receive these closure letters, what a lawful closure looks like, how to attack an irregular one, and how to get banking services back within days.

A deposit account (compte de dépôt) is the ordinary French checking account used for daily payments, direct debits, and salary deposits. The account agreement (convention de compte de dépôt) is the written contract between you and the bank that sets the fees, the operating rules, and the closing conditions. FATCA, the United States Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, is the American law that forces foreign banks to identify accounts held by United States persons and report them to the Internal Revenue Service. The right to an account (droit au compte) is the French statutory procedure that lets a person with no bank account force the designation of a bank that must open one. Keep these four definitions in mind, because every step below turns on them.

I. Can Your French Bank Really Close Your Existing Account Because You Are American?

A. Did the bank give you the two months of written notice the law requires?

Start with the uncomfortable answer: yes, a French bank is generally allowed to close your account even if you did nothing wrong. A deposit account agreement is a contract with no fixed end date, and either side can end it. Article 1211 of the French Civil Code states the general rule: “Lorsque le contrat est conclu pour une durée indéterminée, chaque partie peut y mettre fin à tout moment, sous réserve de respecter le délai de préavis contractuellement prévu ou, à défaut, un délai raisonnable.” In plain English, when a contract has no fixed term, each party can terminate it at any time, provided it respects the notice period set by the contract or, failing that, a reasonable notice period. Your bank does not need your permission to leave the relationship, and it does not need to prove misconduct on your part.

But the right to terminate is not a right to terminate overnight. For consumer deposit accounts, the Monetary and Financial Code sets a hard floor. Article L312-1-1, paragraph V, of that code provides: “L’établissement de crédit résilie une convention de compte de dépôt conclue pour une durée indéterminée moyennant un préavis d’au moins deux mois, fourni sur support papier ou sur un autre support durable.” In other words, the bank terminates an open-ended deposit account agreement only with advance notice of at least two months, delivered on paper or another durable medium. A closure letter that gives you thirty days, two weeks, or no stated period at all does not satisfy this text. An email can qualify as a durable medium, but a vague phone call, a message buried in an online mailbox you never check, or a notice handed to you without a date cannot prove the two-month period started running.

The notice period exists so you can protect yourself before the account disappears. Two months is the time the statute gives you to open a replacement account, move your salary and pension payments, transfer each direct debit (prélèvement) for rent, electricity, telephone, and insurance, order a new payment card, and keep a record of every standing instruction. If the bank cuts access early, checks and direct debits bounce, and the resulting fees and credit-file entries are losses you can document. Read the closure letter the day it arrives and check four points: the date printed on the letter, the exact date the account will stop operating, the medium used to notify you, and the reason given. If any of these points is missing or inconsistent, keep the envelope, screenshot the online mailbox with its dates, and save the letter, because the bank will carry the burden of proving it respected the two-month rule.

Your account agreement may set a longer notice period than the legal minimum, and the longer period controls. Pull out the fee and terms brochure (conditions generales et tarifaires) attached to your agreement and look for the closing clause. Some agreements promise three months. The bank cannot shorten its own promise. Conversely, the bank cannot hide behind a clause shorter than two months for a consumer account, because the statute overrides it. The practical test is therefore simple: count the days between the date you actually received the notice on a durable medium and the announced closing date. If the gap is under two months, the closure procedure is defective, whatever the bank’s commercial reasons.

French courts enforce this notice logic in both directions. In a widely cited account-closure ruling, the Commercial Chamber of the Court of Cassation, on 28 February 2018, appeal no. 16-19.136, reviewed a lower court that had called a bank’s termination of an open-ended current-account agreement abusive and disloyal. The lower court had held that the termination should have been preceded by six to twelve months of notice. The Court of Cassation quashed that reasoning with the holding: “alors que la banque a respecté le délai de préavis de soixante jours stipulé par le contrat d’ouverture de compte dans la limite de la loi.” Because the bank had respected the sixty-day notice set by the account contract, within the limit of the law, the termination could not be declared abusive on that ground. The lesson cuts both ways for an American account holder: a bank that properly serves the required notice is hard to punish for the closure itself, but a bank that skips or shortens the notice loses its main shield, and the closure becomes attackable.

One common confusion must be cleared up immediately. The two-month notice rule governs closure of an account you already hold. It is a different procedure from a refusal to open a new account, which triggers the right-to-an-account process described in Part II. Do not let your bank mix the two. A letter that closes your existing account cannot lawfully tell you that you have no rights because some other bank once refused you. Closure first, replacement second, and each step has its own statute.

B. Why do French banks send FATCA closure letters to Americans in the first place?

Banks close American accounts for cost and fear, not for politics. Under FATCA, a foreign bank that fails to document and report its United States-linked accounts faces a thirty percent withholding tax on certain United States-source payments and a credible threat of being frozen out of dollar clearing. For a French retail bank, one American checking account with a modest balance generates compliance work, annual reporting, software flags, and legal risk far above the revenue the account produces. When the bank’s compliance department decides that American retail clients as a group cost more than they earn, it launches a de-risking wave: standardized information requests, then closure letters to clients who do not return the paperwork or whose profile the bank no longer wants. Your letter is one file in that batch, and understanding the batch helps you respond.

The French legal framework behind the paperwork is explicit. France and the United States signed an intergovernmental FATCA agreement, implemented in France by Decree no. 2015-907 of 23 July 2015 on the collection and transmission of information by financial institutions under the agreement between the Government of the French Republic and the Government of the United States of America for the implementation of the law on compliance with tax obligations concerning foreign accounts (known as the “FATCA law”) and Article 1649 AC of the General Tax Code (Official Journal no. 170 of 25 July 2015, NOR FCPE1509317D). Under this framework, French banks must collect self-certifications of tax residence and United States status from account holders and transmit the reportable data to the French tax administration, which forwards it to the Internal Revenue Service. The official United States Treasury FATCA page describes the same architecture from the American side, and the Internal Revenue Service page on FATCA agreements with foreign governments lists France among the cooperating jurisdictions. When your bank asks for a Form W-9, a self-certification, or a United States taxpayer identification number, it is feeding this reporting chain, and an incomplete file is the usual trigger for the closure letter.

Two separate French anti-money-laundering duties reinforce the bank’s demand for documents, and you should not confuse them with FATCA. Article L561-5 of the Monetary and Financial Code requires banks, before entering a business relationship or assisting a transaction: “1° Identifient leur client et, le cas échéant, le bénéficiaire effectif au sens de l’article L. 561-2-2 ; 2° Vérifient ces éléments d’identification sur présentation de tout document écrit à caractère probant.” The bank must identify you and verify that identity against a probative written document. Article L561-15 then requires banks to report to Tracfin, the French financial intelligence unit: “les sommes inscrites dans leurs livres ou les opérations portant sur des sommes dont elles savent, soupçonnent ou ont de bonnes raisons de soupçonner qu’elles proviennent d’une infraction passible d’une peine privative de liberté supérieure à un an ou sont liées au financement du terrorisme.” These are crime-fighting duties, and being American is not a crime. A bank cannot lawfully dress up a FATCA cost decision as a Tracfin suspicion, and you should read any letter that vaguely invokes “regulatory obligations” or “compliance” with that distinction in mind: FATCA explains the paperwork, anti-money-laundering explains identity checks, and neither excuses skipping the two-month closing notice.

In practice, the closure sequence follows a pattern. First comes an information request: complete a self-certification, confirm whether you are a United States citizen, green-card holder, or tax resident, and provide a taxpayer identification number. Second, often after a reminder, comes a warning that the relationship will be terminated if the file stays incomplete. Third comes the formal closure letter with a deadline. Each stage is an opportunity. Returning a complete, signed self-certification with a copy of your passport and proof of address sometimes stops the process, because the bank’s file is then reportable and the compliance objection disappears. If you are not a United States person and the bank misclassified you, say so in writing with proof of nationality and tax residence. If you are a United States person, complete the forms accurately rather than ignoring them; silence converts a paperwork problem into a closure file. And in every case, answer in writing on a channel you can prove, because the bank’s later account of oral conversations will differ from yours.

Do not sign anything under pressure that you do not understand. Some closure letters arrive with a pre-filled transfer order, a fee schedule for “dormant” balances, or a form authorizing the bank to convert your balance into a cashier’s check mailed to an old address. You are entitled to clear, fee-free restitution of your own money at closure, subject only to the pro-rata rule for prepaid service fees in Article L312-1-1. Ask for a written statement of the closing balance, the fees deducted, and the destination of the funds. If the letter threatens to send the balance to the Caisse des dépôts (the public institution that holds unclaimed funds) while you are actively responding, treat that as a pressure tactic and answer immediately in writing, because consigning an actively claimed balance is difficult to justify.

II. How Do You Fight the Closure and Get a Working Account Again?

A. How do you challenge a closure letter that breaks the two-month rule?

Challenge the procedure before challenging the motive. A discrimination claim based on American nationality is emotionally satisfying and legally difficult: the bank will answer that it applies the same profitability and compliance policy to every costly file, and French courts have been cautious with such claims outside the refusal-to-open context. A notice defect is concrete, dated, and documented, and the 28 February 2018 Court of Cassation ruling shows why it matters. Where that bank had respected its sixty-day contractual notice, the termination could not be branded abusive; where your bank failed to serve two months on a durable medium, the termination lacks its legal foundation, and you can demand damages for the losses the early cutoff caused. Judges count days and read envelopes. Give them days and envelopes.

Build the file in the order a judge will read it. First, the closure letter with its envelope or digital timestamp, proving when you received it. Second, the account agreement and its closing clause, proving the notice your bank promised. Third, proof of the actual cutoff: the last statement, screenshots of blocked access, rejected direct debits with dates, and every fee charged after the announced date. Fourth, proof of your losses: rent arrears notices, utility late fees, employer queries about a missing salary transfer, travel costs to the branch, and the time spent rebuilding each payment instruction. Fifth, your written replies to the bank, sent by registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt (lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception) or by any traceable channel, asking the bank to confirm the legal basis, the exact closing date, and the restitution method. Send the first reply within days of receiving the letter, and state explicitly that you consider any cutoff before the end of the two-month period unlawful.

Your reply letter should make three demands. Demand one: written confirmation that the account will remain fully operational until the two-month notice expires, counted from your receipt of the closure notice on a durable medium. Demand two: a detailed closing statement with the balance, each fee, and the restitution method and date. Demand three: copies of the self-certification and information requests the bank claims to have sent, with their dates, so you can complete any genuinely missing document. This structure forces the bank to either cure the defect or create a paper trail of its refusal. If the bank answers that FATCA or internal policy justifies immediate closure, reply that neither the intergovernmental agreement nor the 2015 decree contains any provision shortening the Article L312-1-1 notice, and ask the bank to cite the exact text it relies on. It will not be able to do so, because no such text exists.

Parallel remedies run alongside the correspondence. Every bank must offer an internal complaints department (service reclamations) and then a free independent banking ombudsman (médiateur bancaire); the ombudsman’s contact details appear in your account agreement and on your statements. Filing with the ombudsman is free, suspends nothing by itself, but creates an independent record and often produces a settlement proposal within months. For regulatory misconduct, the Prudential Supervision and Resolution Authority (Autorité de contrôle prudentiel et de résolution), the banking supervisor housed at the Bank of France, receives complaints about professional-practice breaches; it does not award you damages, but a supervisor’s inquiry concentrates a bank’s mind. For damages themselves, the competent court is the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) of your place of residence or of the bank branch, with simplified procedures for smaller claims. Ask for the bounced-payment fees, the documented consequential losses, and, where the cutoff was brutal and unexplained, additional damages for the disruption. Attach the Cassation ruling logic: proper notice protects the bank, missing notice exposes it. The damages claim itself rests on Article 1231-1 of the Civil Code: “Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts soit à raison de l’inexécution de l’obligation, soit à raison du retard dans l’exécution, s’il ne justifie pas que l’exécution a été empêchée par la force majeure.” A bank that closes early cannot invoke force majeure for its own cost decision, so the bounced-payment fees and documented losses flow from the breach of the notice obligation.

While the dispute runs, protect the payment chain first and argue second. The day you receive the letter, list every incoming and outgoing flow: salary or pension, rental income, each direct debit, each recurring card payment, and each pending check. Open the replacement account immediately through the procedure in Part II.B, then move the flows in order of damage: salary first, housing and insurance debits second, everything else third. Keep the old account funded above zero until the new debits actually clear, because a premature transfer triggers the very rejections you will later ask a judge to compensate. Notify each creditor of the new bank details (relevé d’identité bancaire) by email and keep the confirmations. If a creditor charges you a rejection fee caused by the bank’s early cutoff, pay it, keep the receipt, and add it to the claim file rather than letting the debt grow.

B. How do you get a replacement account within days through the Bank of France?

This is the part of French law most Americans have never heard of, and it is the fastest solution in this guide. If you hold no other deposit account in France after the closure, or if a new bank refuses to take you because of your American status, you can force the system to bank you. Article L312-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides: “A droit à l’ouverture d’un compte de dépôt dans l’établissement de crédit de son choix, sous réserve d’être dépourvu d’un tel compte en France.” Anyone meeting the residence conditions who holds no such account in France has a right to the opening of a deposit account at the bank of their choice. The same article continues: “celle-ci peut saisir la Banque de France afin qu’elle lui désigne un établissement de crédit situé à proximité de son domicile ou d’un autre lieu de son choix” once a chosen bank refuses, with designation “dans un délai d’un jour ouvré à compter de la réception des pièces requises définies par arrêté.” One refusal, one referral, and the Bank of France designates a bank near your home or another place you choose within one business day of receiving the required documents.

The official service-public.fr page states the procedure in everyday language: “Une banque refuse de vous ouvrir un compte bancaire ? Dans ce cas, vous pouvez saisir la Banque de France pour bénéficier de la procédure du droit au compte.” It adds two facts Americans often need: “Si une banque ne répond pas à votre demande d’ouverture de compte dans un délai de 15 jours, cela est considéré comme un refus” and “La Banque de France désigne alors une banque, proche de votre domicile ou du lieu de votre choix, qui doit vous ouvrir un compte avec des services bancaires de base.” The Bank of France’s own pages confirm the speed: “A réception du dossier complet, la Banque de France désigne sous 24 heures une agence pour l’ouverture de votre compte. Cette désignation est valable six mois.” Twenty-four hours from a complete file to a designated branch, and the designation stays valid six months. This is not a favor the banks grant you. It is a statutory designation they must obey.

Run the procedure in this order. First, apply to one bank of your choice with a complete file: valid identity document, proof of address less than three months old, and, because you are American, a FATCA self-certification and taxpayer identification number ready to hand over. Apply at the counter and ask for a dated receipt, or by registered letter so the fifteen-day silence rule can run. Second, on refusal, or after fifteen days of silence, demand the written refusal certificate (attestation de refus); the refusing bank must provide it free of charge and without delay, and it must tell you about the Bank of France referral. Third, file with the Bank of France: the refusal certificate or proof of unanswered application, identity, address proof, and a sworn statement (attestation sur l’honneur) that you hold no other deposit account in France. File online through the Bank of France portal, at a Bank of France counter, or ask the refusing bank to forward the file for you, which Article L312-1 expressly allows it to offer. Fourth, take the designation letter to the named branch within its six-month validity and demand the account with basic services.

Basic services (services bancaires de base) are defined by Article D312-5 of the Monetary and Financial Code and they cover real life: opening, maintaining, and closing the account, one change of address per year, bank identity statements on request, direct-debit domiciliation, a monthly statement, cashing checks and transfers, SEPA payments, remote balance consultation, cash deposits and withdrawals, and a payment card usable for online payments and European cash withdrawals. The designated bank must provide these free of charge. As an extra protection, Article L312-1-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides that “celles qui bénéficient du compte assorti des services bancaires de base ouvert en application de la procédure mentionnée au III de l’article L. 312-1 se voient appliquer des plafonds spécifiques,” meaning irregular-operation fees are subject to specific caps for holders of a basic-services account opened through the Bank of France procedure. It will still ask for your FATCA documents, because designation does not exempt the bank from its reporting duties, so arrive with the self-certification completed. Refusing the FATCA paperwork at the designated bank restarts the same cycle, and this time the bank’s file will note that you were already designated once.

Two American-specific points close the loop. First, residence: the right to an account covers persons domiciled in France, including Americans holding a valid residence permit or receipt (récépissé), European Union residents, and French nationals abroad; bring your permit, passport, and address proof, and keep copies of everything. Second, the old balance: the closing bank must return your money. If restitution drags past the announced date, put the bank on formal notice (mise en demeure) by registered letter, then escalate to the ombudsman and, for larger balances, to counsel, because an unjustified retention of funds after closure is a separate fault from the closure itself. Never abandon a positive balance to “avoid trouble”: unclaimed balances eventually move to the Caisse des dépôts, and recovering them years later from the United States is far harder than collecting them now.

Conclusion

A French bank can decide it no longer wants American clients, but it cannot close your existing account by surprise, by phone, or in thirty days. The statute gives you at least two months on a durable medium, the courts protect banks that respect their notice and punish those that skip it, and the Bank of France can put a new account in your hands within a day of a complete file. Treat the closure letter as the start of a documented procedure, not as a final verdict: verify the dates, complete the FATCA paperwork, demand written confirmations, move your payment flows in order, and file the right-to-an-account request the moment you qualify. Americans who follow this sequence usually end up with the same daily banking they had before, sometimes at a better bank, plus a paper trail that supports a damages claim if the closure was irregular. The bank chose to end the relationship. The law decides how, and it gives you the tools to land on your feet.

📄 Official circular