KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My French Tenant Stopped Paying Rent: What an American Landlord Can (and Cannot) Do

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My French Tenant Stopped Paying Rent: What an American Landlord Can (and Cannot) Do

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your Paris apartment was supposed to pay for itself. Then the rent stopped coming. One missed payment becomes two, your emails go unanswered, and a friend tells you to just change the locks while the tenant is away. In Texas or Florida, you might already be at the courthouse filing for eviction. In France, following that instinct can destroy your case and expose you to criminal liability. French law treats the tenant’s home as nearly untouchable without a judge, and it surrounds every step of the eviction process with mandatory waiting periods, social services, and court-controlled second chances. The good news is that the system does work for landlords who follow it exactly: a precisely worded first notice, served by the right officer, starts a clock that ends with an enforceable court order and, eventually, the physical recovery of your apartment. This guide walks you through that path from the first unpaid rent to the final recovery of the money, with the exact statutes and court decisions that control each step, so you can act fast without making the one mistake that sends you back to the start.

I. My Tenant Has Not Paid in Two Months: How Do I Start the Eviction Clock Legally?

The single most important thing to understand is that in France, unpaid rent does not automatically end the lease. Your lease contains a termination clause, called a clause résolutoire (an automatic termination clause), but that clause stays dormant until you activate it through a formal procedure. Article 24 of the French statute of July 6, 1989, which governs residential leases, states the rule plainly: “Cette clause ne produit effet que six semaines après un commandement de payer demeuré infructueux.” In plain English, the termination clause takes effect only six weeks after a formal payment order, known as a commandement de payer (a bailiff’s formal order to pay), has gone unpaid. Until that document is served and the six weeks run out, you have no termination, no court case, and no eviction. Everything starts there.

A. What Is the Commandement de Payer and Why Does Its Wording Decide Everything?

The commandement de payer is not a reminder letter or an email from you. It is a formal legal document served on the tenant by a commissaire de justice (a sworn enforcement officer, the professional formerly known as an huissier de justice or bailiff). Only this officer can serve it, and the law punishes the smallest drafting error with nullity, meaning the whole procedure collapses and you start over. Article 24 provides that “Le commandement de payer contient, à peine de nullité :” followed by six mandatory items, and each one must appear in the document (see Article 24 of the July 6, 1989 statute).

First, the notice must state that “le locataire dispose d’un délai de six semaines pour payer sa dette” (Article 24 of the July 6, 1989 statute), that the tenant has six weeks to pay the debt. Second, it must give the monthly amount of rent and recoverable charges. Third, it must include a full breakdown of the debt, the décompte de la dette. Fourth, it must warn the tenant that failure to pay or to request payment delays exposes the tenant to a court action to terminate the lease and evict. Fifth, it must inform the tenant of the right to contact the fonds de solidarité pour le logement (the departmental housing solidarity fund, a public body that can grant emergency financial aid), with its address. Sixth, it must mention the tenant’s right to ask a court for a grace period under Article 1343-5 of the Civil Code at any time. Miss one of these six mentions and the tenant’s lawyer will have the order annulled.

The breakdown of the debt deserves special attention because it is where landlords most often lose. The tenant’s fundamental duty is set by Article 1728 of the Civil Code, which requires the tenant “De payer le prix du bail aux termes convenus.” to pay the rent price at the agreed terms. When you claim that duty was breached, the tenant must be able to check every euro. The Court of Cassation, France’s supreme court for civil cases, confirmed this in a decision of December 3, 2020 (Third Civil Chamber, appeal no. 19-22.011, read the official decision on the Court of Cassation website), where it upheld a payment order because “le commandement de payer comportait un décompte précis indiquant le détail des sommes réclamées par la bailleresse et identifiant chaque poste de créance.” the order contained a precise breakdown showing the detail of the sums claimed by the landlord and identifying each item of the claim. The lesson for you is practical: give your commissaire de justice a clean ledger with every month, every charge, and every payment received, and insist that each line appears separately in the order. A lump sum is an invitation to annulment.

Two related rules complete the picture at this stage. If a caution (a guarantor, often a parent or a bank guarantee company) secured the lease, the payment order must be served on that guarantor within fifteen days of service on the tenant, failing which the guarantor cannot be held liable for penalties or late interest. And the automatic termination clause itself must be drafted correctly in the first place: Article 1225 of the Civil Code provides that “La clause résolutoire précise les engagements dont l’inexécution entraînera la résolution du contrat.” the termination clause must specify which breached obligations will trigger termination, and that “La mise en demeure ne produit effet que si elle mentionne expressément la clause résolutoire.” the formal notice takes effect only if it expressly mentions the termination clause. In practice, nearly all French residential leases contain a standard termination clause, but if you used a custom American-style lease for your Paris apartment, have a lawyer verify that the clause exists and covers unpaid rent before you pay for service.

Finally, know that your payment order does not stay a private matter. Once the tenant has gone two full months without any rent or charge payment, or the debt reaches twice the monthly rent excluding charges, the commissaire de justice must report the order to the commission de coordination des actions de prévention des expulsions locatives, known as the CCAPEX (the local commission that coordinates action to prevent evictions). The state’s representative in the department, the préfet, then tasks a social agency with preparing a diagnostic social et financier (a social and financial assessment of the household) that will be sent to the commission. This is not a punishment for you; it is the system’s early-warning radar. But it means the tenant’s file is already being examined by social workers before you ever see a judge, which is one more reason your paperwork must be flawless.

B. Can I Just Change the Locks, Cut the Power, or Show Up With Help?

No. This is the cultural shock that costs American landlords the most. In France, a landlord who changes the locks, removes the front door, cuts electricity, or moves the tenant’s belongings to the sidewalk commits an illegal self-eviction, and the tenant can call the police, return to the apartment the same day, and sue you for damages. Article L411-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures states the monopoly of the courts without ambiguity: “l’expulsion d’un immeuble ou d’un lieu habité ne peut être poursuivie qu’en vertu d’une décision de justice ou d’un procès-verbal de conciliation exécutoire et après signification d’un commandement d’avoir à libérer les locaux.” Eviction from a dwelling can only be pursued under a court decision or an enforceable conciliation agreement, and after service of an order to vacate. Read that sentence twice: court decision plus a second formal order, both mandatory. There is no American-style three-day notice to vacate followed by a lockout. Only a commissaire de justice carrying a court order can physically remove an occupant, and if the occupant resists, only the police, authorized through the préfet, can lend force.

So what do you actually file, and when? Once the six-week payment period expires unpaid, your lawyer files an assignation aux fins de constat de la résiliation (a summons asking the court to officially record that the lease has terminated) before the tribunal judiciaire (the general civil court with jurisdiction over housing cases, in Paris the Tribunal judiciaire de Paris). But even this summons carries a trap that kills cases every week. Article 24 opens with the warning “A peine d’irrecevabilité de la demande” and requires notification of the summons to the state representative in the department “au moins six semaines avant l’audience” (Article 24 of the July 6, 1989 statute). On penalty of inadmissibility, the summons must be notified by the enforcement officer to the state’s representative in the department at least six weeks before the hearing. The social agency then completes its diagnostic social et financier, interviewing both tenant and landlord and transmitting the report to the judge before the hearing, and the tenant is formally told of the right to request payment delays. If your officer forgets the préfet notification or serves it five weeks before instead of six, your case is thrown out without any examination of the merits, and you refile and wait again.

At the hearing, the judge is not a rubber stamp. The judge first verifies every component of the claimed debt and the landlord’s own compliance with basic obligations, and invites both sides to disclose any pending surendettement proceeding, the French consumer over-indebtedness procedure governed by Book VII of the Consumer Code. Then comes the power American landlords least expect: even when the termination clause has legally taken effect, the judge may grant the tenant extra time to pay. Article 1343-5 of the Civil Code gives every civil judge a general power: “Le juge peut, compte tenu de la situation du débiteur et en considération des besoins du cr&eacuteancier, reporter ou échelonner, dans la limite de deux années, le paiement des sommes dues.” The judge may, considering the debtor’s situation and the creditor’s needs, postpone or spread payment of the sums due over up to two years. During that court-granted delay, enforcement is suspended and no late penalties accrue. In unpaid-rent cases specifically, Article 24 goes even further: the judge may grant payment delays of up to three years, provided the tenant is in a position to clear the debt and has resumed paying the full current rent before the hearing date, and the judge may verify each element of the rental debt on the court’s own initiative. In other words, a tenant who shows up, resumes paying rent, and presents a credible repayment plan will very often leave with a schedule instead of an eviction. Budget for this outcome from day one: the fastest victories come against tenants who ignore the summons entirely, while contested cases with a paying-again tenant routinely end in a court-approved payment plan that you must then monitor month by month.

II. The Court Ruled in My Favor: When Do I Actually Get My Apartment Back?

Suppose you win: the court records the termination, orders the tenant to pay the arrears, and authorizes eviction. Many Americans assume the apartment is theirs again the next morning. French law inserts two more waiting periods between the judgment and the moving truck, and one of them is the famous winter rule that freezes nearly all evictions for five months. Understanding these delays before you file lets you calendar the case realistically — often twelve to twenty-four months from the first missed rent to physical recovery, and avoids the rage of discovering in November that nothing can happen until April.

A. Why Can Winter and the Two-Month Rule Freeze an Eviction Until Spring?

The first freeze starts immediately after judgment. Article L412-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures provides that when eviction concerns a dwelling, “elle ne peut avoir lieu qu’à l’expiration d’un délai de deux mois qui suit le commandement,” it can only take place after a two-month period following the order to vacate. Note the sequence: judgment, then a new formal document, the commandement d’avoir à libérer les locaux (the order to vacate the premises), served by the commissaire de justice, then two full months during which the tenant may leave voluntarily or ask the judge for more time. That vacate order is itself strictly regulated: Article R412-1 requires that “le commandement d’avoir à libérer les locaux contient, à peine de nullité” The vacate order must reproduce, on penalty of nullity, the full text of Articles L412-1 through L412-6. Your officer knows this, but you should know it too, because a tenant who receives an order without those reproductions holds a nullity argument that buys months.

The second freeze is the trêve hivernale (the winter truce), the rule most foreign landlords have never heard of and that shocks them the most. Article L412-6 states: “il est sursis à toute mesure d’expulsion non exécutée à la date du 1er novembre de chaque année jusqu’au 31 mars de l’année suivante,” all not-yet-executed eviction measures are suspended from November 1 each year until March 31 of the following year, unless the occupants are rehoused in conditions preserving the family’s unity and needs. The suspension applies even to eviction orders that have become final and even after court-granted delays have expired. If your two-month vacate period ends on November 15, the physical eviction waits until April 1. There are narrow exceptions, notably for squatters who forced entry into someone’s home, but an ordinary tenant who simply stopped paying is fully protected. Calendar consequence: a judgment obtained in September realistically means a spring eviction, and a judgment in February means you may still act before the following November if you move fast.

On top of both freezes, the judge can add discretionary delays at the occupant’s request. Article L412-3 provides that “Le juge peut accorder des délais renouvelables aux occupants de lieux habités ou de locaux à usage professionnel, dont l’expulsion a été ordonnée judiciairement, chaque fois que le relogement des intéressés ne peut avoir lieu dans des conditions normales.” The judge may grant renewable delays to occupants whose eviction was judicially ordered, whenever they cannot be rehoused under normal conditions. Article L412-4 frames that discretion: “La durée des délais prévus à l’article L. 412-3 ne peut, en aucun cas, être inférieure à un mois ni supérieure à un an.” Those delays can run from one month to one year, and the judge weighs the good or bad faith of the occupant, the ages, health, family and financial situations on both sides, the efforts the occupant has made to find new housing, and even weather conditions. An elderly tenant, a family with school-age children, or a tenant who documents dozens of rejected rental applications will often obtain several extra months. The Court of Cassation polices the reasoning of these decisions closely, as shown in its March 5, 2026 ruling on termination-clause litigation (Third Civil Chamber, appeal no. 24-15.820, read the official decision on the Court of Cassation website), which dissected, step by step, whether the courts below had correctly applied the termination-clause mechanism. The message for landlords is consistent across the case law: the procedure rewards exact compliance and punishes shortcuts at every level.

For Paris and Île-de-France owners, add one local reality to the calendar. Eviction cases for Paris apartments go before the Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, one of the busiest housing courts in France, where hearing dates routinely sit months out, and the winter-truce and rehousing analysis bites hardest because alternative housing in the capital is scarce and judges know it. The préfet notifications and CCAPEX signalements run through the Paris authorities, whose social services are thorough and slow. None of this changes the law, but it means a Paris timeline almost always lands at the long end of the national range. If your apartment sits empty half the year while you live in the United States, consider this timeline before choosing between a long-term tenant and a properly registered furnished arrangement, whose tax and registration rules are explained in our guides to unfurnished rental taxation for Americans and furnished rental taxation and registration.

B. How Do I Recover the Unpaid Rent and Protect My Next Lease?

The eviction order almost always comes with a money judgment for the arrears, charges, and an indemnité d’occupation (an occupancy payment, the monthly sum the former tenant owes for staying after the lease ended, usually equal to the rent plus charges). Collecting that judgment is a second enforcement track, again handled by your commissaire de justice: wage garnishment, bank account seizure, and seizure of other assets, within the limits French law sets to protect a minimum subsistence income. Be realistic about recovery. A tenant who could not pay rent often has little to seize, and an over-indebtedness filing can restructure or partially erase the debt under court supervision. Your leverage is strongest before judgment, when the tenant still hopes to stay: that is the moment to negotiate a court-recorded payment schedule, a procès-verbal de conciliation (an official conciliation record), which Article L411-1 recognizes as enforceable exactly like a judgment. A tenant who signs a conciliation schedule and defaults can then be evicted without a full new trial, which is why experienced landlord counsel often prefers a solid conciliation over a dramatic trial.

Protecting the next lease starts with the guarantee you required at signing. If you took a personal caution, remember the fifteen-day service rule described above and serve the guarantor from the very first payment order, because a guarantor who was never properly notified will walk away from penalties and interest and fight the principal. Keep every proof of the guarantor’s solvency at signing, since a guarantee from someone with no French assets is paper armor when you later need to enforce in the United States. Many American owners instead rely on institutional guarantees or rent-default insurance, the garantie des loyers impayés, which pays the rent and handles the procedure for a yearly premium. Whichever route you chose, reread its conditions now: most institutional guarantees require you to act within strict deadlines after the first missed payment and to follow the Article 24 procedure to the letter, and missing their notice deadline can void your coverage even when the eviction itself succeeds.

Two final layers matter specifically because you are American. First, the French tax side does not pause while the tenant does not pay. Rent you are owed but have not received is generally not taxable until collected under most rental regimes, but the property taxes, the taxe foncière, the building charges, and any mortgage keep running, and the deductibility of unpaid rent and eviction costs depends on your exact tax regime. Our breakdowns of unfurnished rental income rules and furnished rental rules explain which regime you are in, and your American reporting follows separately with your United States accountant. Second, keep every document in both languages organized from day one: the lease, the payment ledger, the payment order with its six mentions, the guarantor notices, the préfet notification receipt, the social assessment, the judgment, and the vacate order with its reproduced articles. The official Service Public guide to unpaid rent and tenant eviction confirms each of these stages from the administration’s own side, and a file that mirrors that guide is a file that survives judicial review. French eviction law forgives tenants who fall on hard times; it never forgives landlords who skip steps.

Conclusion

French eviction law asks the American landlord to unlearn nearly every reflex from home: no lockouts, no self-help, no impatience with paperwork. The system moves slowly by design, six weeks for the payment order, six weeks of notice to the préfet before the hearing, two months after the order to vacate, and a five-month winter suspension, because it treats eviction as a last resort rather than a contract remedy. But the same system gives a landlord who respects each deadline a judgment that the full force of the state will ultimately enforce, from the commissaire de justice at the door to the police if resistance requires it. Start with a flawless commandement de payer, notify the guarantor and the préfet on time, take conciliation seriously when the tenant returns to the table, and calendar the winter truce before it calendars you. Handled that way, an unpaid-rent case in France is not a dead end; it is a long corridor with the exit clearly marked.

📄 Official circular