KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Moved Back to the US and I Am Selling My French Apartment: the Departure Deadline, the Tax Representative, and How to Challenge the Notaire’s Bill

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Moved Back to the US and I Am Selling My French Apartment: the Departure Deadline, the Tax Representative, and How to Challenge the Notaire’s Bill

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You lived in France, you bought an apartment, and now life has moved you back to the United States. The Paris flat or Lyon studio that was your home is about to be sold, and the money will land in your American bank account. Between that sale and that transfer stands a French tax bill that surprises almost every American seller: France taxes the gain at the closing table, through the notaire, before you ever see the funds, and the United States will tax the same gain again on your federal return, with a credit for what you paid in France. If you left France months ago, a second clock is ticking: a departure-linked exemption can wipe out the French tax entirely, but only if you sell before a hard deadline and only if the flat sat empty or in your hands since you left. Miss the deadline, misstate the purchase price, or let the notaire apply the wrong status, and you can overpay by tens of thousands of euros with no easy way to get the money back after the deed is signed. This guide walks through the exact mechanics in the order that matters: first, what France taxes and which exemptions survive your move back across the Atlantic; second, the rates and surcharges that stack on an American nonresident seller; third, how the notaire collects the tax at closing, which papers prove your numbers, and why an American seller almost always needs a paid tax representative; and finally, how the France-United States tax treaty prevents double taxation and how to challenge a computation that looks wrong before it becomes final.

I. Can I still sell tax-free after leaving France, and what is my gain exactly?

A. Which exemptions survive your departure, and why the famous 150,000 euro break is not for Americans?

Start with the basic rule. French real-estate gains of individuals fall under article 150 U of the French General Tax Code, the Code général des impôts, which provides that gains on the sale for consideration of built or unbuilt real property are subject to income tax under articles 150 V to 150 VH. Read the scope sentence of that article here: article 150 U, Code général des impôts. Because you no longer live in France, a second provision takes over collection: article 244 bis A of the same Code, which submits nonresidents to a special withholding-style levy, the prélèvement, on French real-estate gains. The persons covered are stated bluntly in the Code: article 244 bis A, Code général des impôts. And France asserts the underlying right to tax through article 164 B, which counts among French-source income the real-estate gains defined in its paragraphs e bis and e ter: article 164 B, Code général des impôts. So the starting point is simple: your French apartment is taxable in France even though you now live in Ohio, Texas, or California.

From that starting point, exemptions can erase the bill, but each one has strict conditions, and American sellers routinely misunderstand two of them. The first is the main-home exemption, the exonération de la résidence principale. If the apartment was your principal residence on the day you sold it, there is no gain to tax. But you already left, so that classic version no longer helps. What many departing owners miss is the Code’s second chance: the sale of the dwelling that was your main home in France on the date you moved your tax residence, your domicile fiscal, out of France can also be fully exempt. The Code states it in these exact words: “Le premier alinéa du présent 1 n’est pas applicable à la cession de l’immeuble qui constituait la résidence principale en France du cédant à la date du transfert de son domicile fiscal hors de France dans un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou dans un Etat ou territoire ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales ainsi qu’une convention d’assistance mutuelle en matière de recouvrement ayant une portée similaire à celle prévue par la directive 2010/24/ UE du Conseil du 16 mars 2010 concernant l’assistance mutuelle en matière de recouvrement des créances relatives aux taxes, impôts, droits et autres mesures et qui n’est pas un Etat ou territoire non coopératif au sens de l’article 238-0 A.” That is the door. The deadline is the frame around it: “Cette exonération s’applique à la double condition que la cession soit réalisée au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle du transfert par le cédant de son domicile fiscal hors de France et que l’immeuble n’ait pas été mis à la disposition de tiers, à titre gratuit ou onéreux, entre ce transfert et la cession.” Text of the exemption: article 244 bis A, I, Code général des impôts. In plain terms, if you moved back to the United States in 2025, you must sign the sale by December 31, 2026, and the apartment must not have been rented out, lent, or otherwise put at anyone else’s disposal, free or paid, between your departure and the sale. A single year of rental to cover costs kills the exemption. Note also the geographic condition: the destination must be an EU or EEA state or a state holding both an administrative-assistance treaty and a recovery-assistance treaty with France. Before assuming the United States satisfies that pair, ask your counsel to confirm it in writing for your file, because the notaire will want a clear legal basis before granting an exemption.

The second trap is the provision American sellers hear about from well-meaning friends and even some foreign blogs: a 150,000 euro exemption for nonresidents selling a French home. It exists, but read whom it covers: “Au titre de la cession d’un logement situé en France lorsque le cédant est une personne physique, non résidente de France, ressortissante d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou d’un autre Etat partie à l’accord sur l’Espace économique européen ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales”. The nationality condition is explicit: a citizen of an EU member state or of another EEA state. An American citizen holding only a United States passport does not meet it, and the relief, which applies “dans la limite d’une résidence par contribuable et de 150 000 € de plus-value nette imposable”, is therefore closed to you. Full text here: article 150 U, Code général des impôts. If a general online guide told you that every nonresident gets 150,000 euros tax-free, that guide was describing Europeans. Your file needs a different strategy, which is exactly what the departure-deadline exemption above, or the holding-period relief below, provides.

Holding-period relief, the abattement pour durée de détention, is the workhorse that reduces most bills year by year. The mechanism is administered under article 150 VC of the Tax Code, and the French tax authority’s official commentary, the Bulletin officiel des finances publiques, sets out the schedule in force for sales since September 1, 2014. For income tax, the administration applies holding relief of 6 percent for each year of ownership beyond the fifth through the twenty-first, plus 4 percent for the twenty-second year, so that full income-tax exemption is reached after twenty-two years of ownership. For social charges, the schedule runs longer: 1.65 percent per year beyond the fifth through the twenty-first year, 1.60 percent for the twenty-second year, and 9 percent per year after that, so that full social-charges exemption is reached after thirty years. Source: BOI-RFPI-PVI-20-20, impots.gouv.fr. Count your ownership from the date on your original purchase deed. If you owned the apartment for, say, twelve years, seven years count toward relief at 6 percent each for income tax, which cuts the taxable base nearly in half before any rate applies. One asymmetry to accept: losses do not help. A capital loss on French real estate is simply ignored and cannot offset your gains, a principle the administration ties to article 150 VD of the Code in the same commentary.

The computation itself starts from a one-sentence definition in article 150 V: “La plus ou moins-value brute réalisée lors de la cession de biens ou droits mentionnés aux articles 150 U à 150 UC est égale à la différence entre le prix de cession et le prix d’acquisition par le cédant.” Text: article 150 V, Code général des impôts. Sale price minus purchase price, with each side adjusted by documented extras: notaire fees and registration duties on purchase, agency commission on sale, and proven renovation work by licensed contractors generally increase your cost base or reduce the proceeds, while personal labor and undocumented cash jobs do not. Because every euro of proven cost directly shrinks the taxable gain, assembling the paper trail before you list the property is the single highest-value task in the whole process, and it is developed in section II.A below.

B. What rate and surcharges apply to an American nonresident seller?

Once the taxable base is set, the income-tax rate for an individual seller is flat and familiar: “Les plus-values réalisées dans les conditions prévues aux articles 150 U à 150 UC sont imposées au taux forfaitaire de 19 %.” Text: article 200 B, Code général des impôts. As a nonresident you pay through the article 244 bis A levy instead, but individuals are held at the same level. The Code provides that “les personnes physiques, les associés personnes physiques de sociétés, groupements ou organismes dont les bénéfices sont imposés au nom des associés et les porteurs de parts, personnes physiques, de fonds de placement immobilier mentionnés à l’article 239 nonies sont soumis au prélèvement au taux de 19 %.” Text: article 244 bis A, III bis, Code général des impôts. A historical footnote worth knowing: differential rates once applied to sellers outside the EU and EEA, but the bracketed provisions were struck down, as the Code itself records with the note “[Dispositions déclarées non conformes à la Constitution par la décision du Conseil constitutionnel n° 2014-708 DC du 29 décembre 2014]”, see decision no. 2014-708 DC of December 29, 2014. Today the 19 percent individual rate is the figure your notaire will use.

On top of income tax come the social charges, the prélèvements sociaux, and this is where American sellers face the heaviest add-on. The contribution on wealth income, the contribution sociale sur les revenus du patrimoine, is assessed on the net amount used for income tax and expressly reaches capital gains: the base includes, in the Code’s words, “Des plus-values, gains en capital et profits soumis à l’impôt sur le revenu”. Text: article L136-6, Social Security Code. The combined social-charges rate applied to real-estate gains in the administration’s worked examples is 17.2 percent of the social-charges base, shown in the official commentary through a worked example applying 19 percent to the income-tax base and 17.2 percent to the social-charges base: BOI-RFPI-PVI-20-20, impots.gouv.fr. Whether a nonresident affiliated to the American system, rather than to any European social-security scheme, owes the full charge or a reduced solidarity levy, the prélèvement de solidarité, depends on residence, treaty status, and case-by-case affiliation proof, so treat the social charge as the main point to verify with counsel rather than as a fixed number. The direction of travel in the courts favors single-system logic: the Court of Cassation recently recalled that the European coordination regulations “consacrent le principe d’unicité de la législation de sécurité sociale, selon lequel la personne à laquelle les règlements s’appliquent n’est soumise qu’à la législation d’un seul Etat membre”, citing “(CJUE, arrêt du 26 février 2015, De Ruyter, C-623-13, point 35)”. Reference: Court of Cassation, Second Civil Chamber, September 25, 2025, no. 22-20.036. That line of reasoning was built for European mobility, not for American affiliation, so an American seller should expect discussion, not an automatic exemption, and should arrive with proof of United States coverage in hand.

A third layer hits large gains only: the surtax on high real-estate gains, the taxe sur les plus-values immobilières élevées, created by article 1609 nonies G. It applies to gains realized under article 150 U and under article 244 bis A for nonresidents, and it starts above a clear floor: “La taxe est due à raison des plus-values imposables d’un montant supérieur à 50 000 €”. The scale then runs from 2 percent to 6 percent of the total taxable gain across smoothing brackets, for example “De 50 001 à 60 000 2 % PV” at the bottom and “Supérieur à 260 000 6 % PV” at the top, with PV meaning the taxable gain. Text: article 1609 nonies G, Code général des impôts. A 60,000 euro taxable gain therefore attracts roughly 1,200 euros of surtax on top of income tax and social charges, while a 300,000 euro gain attracts about 18,000 euros. Because the surtax base follows the same holding-period relief as income tax, each additional year of ownership can pull a gain below a bracket threshold, which is one more reason to verify the ownership start date before signing anything.

Two threshold questions underlie everything and both turn on where you really live now. French domestic law treats as fiscally domiciled in France anyone meeting any one of three tests: “Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A : a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal”, plus professional activity and center of economic interests. Text: article 4 B, Code général des impôts. If your family, home, and daily life are now in the United States, you meet none of these, and France taxes you as a nonresident through the 244 bis A levy rather than through the ordinary resident return. Readers who left recently but kept deep ties should compare this with our guide on becoming American tax-resident in France and the treaty tie-breaker: American tax residence and the treaty tie-breaker. And if your departure also involved shares or securities, the exit-tax exposure is a separate file from the apartment sale: leaving France and the exit tax on shares. Keep the files distinct, because the apartment follows the real-estate rules explained here, not the securities rules.

II. How is the tax taken at closing, and how do I fight a wrong bill?

A. What does the notaire withhold, what papers prove your figures, and why do Americans need a tax representative?

In France a real-estate sale is not complete until a notaire, a public officer with a state-delegated monopoly on formal conveyancing, draws up or receives the deed. The Civil Code defines the instrument in one sentence: “L’acte authentique est celui qui a été reçu, avec les solennités requises, par un officier public ayant compétence et qualité pour instrumenter.” Text: article 1369, Civil Code. The notaire does not merely stamp papers. They verify title, mortgages, urban-planning and co-ownership documents, compute the capital-gains tax, withhold it from the sale price, and pay it to the Treasury when the deed is registered. You receive the net proceeds. That is why errors at this stage are so costly: the money is gone before you can object, and recovering an overpayment means a formal claim after the fact.

The collection rule for nonresidents is strict and it names a responsible person. The Code states: “L’impôt dû en application du présent article est acquitté lors de l’enregistrement de l’acte ou, à défaut d’enregistrement, dans le mois suivant la cession, sous la responsabilité d’un représentant établi en France, accrédité par l’administration fiscale.” Text: article 244 bis A, IV, Code général des impôts. In practice you, the American seller, must appoint a tax representative, a représentant fiscal, established in France and accredited by the tax authority, who signs the gain computation and answers for the payment. The waiver that Europeans use does not help you: “L’obligation de désigner un représentant fiscal ne s’applique pas lorsque le cédant est domicilié, établi ou constitué dans un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou dans un autre Etat partie à l’accord sur l’Espace économique européen ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales ainsi qu’une convention d’assistance mutuelle en matière de recouvrement de l’impôt.” The United States is neither an EU member nor an EEA party, so the waiver does not cover an American seller. Budget for the representative’s fee, typically a fraction of a percent of the price with a minimum charge, and appoint them early, because without their signature the registration of your deed can stall.

There is one piece of good news in the paperwork. Where the gain is fully exempt, whether through the departure-deadline exemption or through complete holding-period relief, the Code dispenses with the return: “Lorsque la plus-value est exonérée en application de l’avant-dernier alinéa du 1 du I du présent article ou du 6° du II de l’article 150 U ou par l’application de l’abattement prévu au I de l’article 150 VC , aucune déclaration ne doit être déposée, sauf dans le cas où le prélèvement afférent à la plus-value en report est dû.” But the deed itself must carry the legal reasoning, since “L’acte de cession soumis à la formalité fusionnée ou présenté à l’enregistrement précise, sous peine de refus du dépôt ou de la formalité d’enregistrement, la nature et le fondement de cette exonération ou de cette absence de taxation”. Both passages: article 244 bis A, II, Code général des impôts. In other words, an exempt sale still needs its justification written into the deed, and a missing or vague statement can get the filing rejected.

Build your evidence file around the five numbers the notaire must verify. First, the acquisition price and date from your original purchase deed, the acte de vente, plus the purchase-side notaire fees and registration duties shown on that deed’s statement of costs. Second, documented improvement costs: contractor invoices with the property address, proof of payment, and, for major works, the corresponding building permits or co-ownership authorizations. Third, the sale price and date from the preliminary contract, the compromis de vente, and then the final deed. Fourth, proof of your residence history: French tax notices from the ownership years, United States residence proof since departure, and travel records if the departure date is questioned. Fifth, proof of continuous control of the dwelling since departure: no lease, no free-occupancy arrangement, homeowner insurance in your name, and utility records showing vacancy or your own use. If you claim the departure-deadline exemption, the fourth and fifth items are the whole case, because the exemption turns entirely on the transfer date and on the absence of any third-party use. For the general mechanics of buying-side paperwork that sellers often need to reconstruct, see our companion guides: selling a French house as an American, general guide and capital gains and United States tax on the sale.

B. How do I avoid double tax in America and challenge an incorrect computation?

France gets the first bite and America the second, but the treaty ensures you do not pay full tax twice on the same gain. The France-United States income tax treaty of August 31, 1994, provides in its capital-gains article that gains from the sale of real estate located in a contracting state may be taxed in that state (Article 13(1)). Source: France-United States tax treaty, Article 13(1), IRS official text. France therefore keeps the primary right to tax your apartment gain. The same treaty then obliges the United States to relieve double taxation by allowing its citizens and residents a credit against United States income tax for the French income tax paid (Article 24(1)(a)). Source: France-United States tax treaty, Article 24(1)(a), IRS official text. On your federal return you report the worldwide gain and claim the French income tax as a foreign tax credit on the dedicated credit form, Form 1116: About Form 1116, IRS. Three practical warnings follow. The credit covers French income tax, so isolate the 19 percent component from the social charges and surtax when your American preparer computes the credit, and keep the notaire’s itemized tax statement, the décompte, as the supporting document. The credit cannot exceed the United States tax attributable to the same gain, so timing the sale in a year with sufficient United States tax liability matters. And currency matters twice: the French gain is computed in euros on French dates while the American gain uses dollars with its own basis rules, so the two gains are rarely identical and the credit rarely zeroes the American bill exactly.

If the notaire’s draft computation looks wrong, challenge it before the deed is signed, because after registration you are arguing for a refund instead of blocking a payment. Walk through this checklist with the draft décompte in hand. Check the base first: is the acquisition price the full original price plus documented purchase costs, are renovation invoices actually included, and is the sale price net of only allowable deductions, consistent with “La plus ou moins-value brute réalisée lors de la cession de biens ou droits mentionnés aux articles 150 U à 150 UC est égale à la différence entre le prix de cession et le prix d’acquisition par le cédant”, see article 150 V, Code général des impôts. Check the dates: does the ownership duration used for the taper match your original deed, and does the departure date used for the exemption match your actual transfer of tax residence. Check the exemptions: was the departure-deadline exemption even considered, was the 150,000 euro provision correctly set aside as EU-only, and was full taper relief after 22 or 30 years correctly applied where relevant. Check the rate stack: 19 percent income tax per article 200 B, Code général des impôts, the social-charges base and rate, and the surtax only where the taxable gain truly exceeds 50,000 euros per article 1609 nonies G, Code général des impôts. Check the collection: is a representative appointed as article 244 bis A, IV, Code général des impôts requires, and does the draft deed state the nature and basis of any exemption as paragraph II demands. Finally, remember the levy’s character: “Le prélèvement mentionné au I est libératoire de l’impôt sur le revenu dû en raison des sommes qui ont supporté celui-ci”, see article 244 bis A, V, Code général des impôts. Liberating means the French income-tax file on this gain is closed once correctly paid, which is precisely why getting the single payment right matters so much.

When the sale is behind you and something still looks off, do not let the file sleep. Ask the notaire for the complete computation packet: the gain return, the deed’s tax clauses, the payment receipts, and the representative’s engagement letter. Have an independent computation prepared from your own documents and compare line by line, because most disputes turn on a missing invoice or a wrong start date rather than on legal theory. If an overpayment emerges, the correction runs through a formal tax claim with supporting documents and strict time limits, which is a task for counsel, not for a second email to the notaire’s office. And keep every document for your American file too, since the IRS can ask years later how a large foreign credit on Form 1116 was computed. Readers who want the broader picture of French property taxation across the ownership years can consult our guide to annual French property taxes and their United States treatment: annual French property taxes for Americans.

Conclusion

Selling a French apartment after moving back to America is a two-country operation with one unforgiving timetable. France taxes the gain at closing through the notaire and the accredited representative, at 19 percent income tax plus social charges and, on large gains, a 2 to 6 percent surtax, with holding-period relief phasing the tax out after 22 years for income tax and 30 years for social charges. The departure-deadline exemption can eliminate the French tax, but only for a former main home sold by December 31 of the year after departure with no third-party use in between, while the oft-quoted 150,000 euro nonresident break is reserved to EU and EEA citizens and does not cover Americans. The treaty then moves the relief to the American side through the foreign tax credit, which is valuable but rarely perfect. Put the evidence together before listing, verify each line of the draft computation before signing, and treat the deed appointment as the last moment the numbers can still be fixed cheaply.

📄 Official circular