KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Am Selling My French House as an American: Plus-Value Tax, Holding-Period Allowances, Social Charges, and the US Treaty Credit

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Am Selling My French House as an American: Plus-Value Tax, Holding-Period Allowances, Social Charges, and the US Treaty Credit

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You bought the stone house in the Dordogne, the two-bedroom walk-up in the 11th arrondissement, or the farmhouse outside Uzès years ago, and now life has changed. Maybe you are moving back to Texas, settling an estate with your siblings, or simply cashing out after a decade of summers in France. The question that keeps American sellers up at night is simple: how much of my sale price will France keep, and will the IRS take another bite on top? Here is the short answer. France taxes the sale first, at a flat 19 percent income levy plus a 7.5 percent solidarity charge, with generous reductions the longer you have owned the place, and the United States then lets you credit the French tax against your American bill under the France-United States income tax treaty. You file twice, but you do not pay twice on the same dollars. Your French notaire (the public officer who alone can transfer real estate in France) computes the French tax, withholds it from the price on closing day, and sends it to the Treasury before you ever see the funds. This article walks through the whole path in two parts. Part I explains how France computes your taxable gain, which exemptions can wipe it out, and how the holding-period allowances, the 19 percent rate, and the high-gain surtax combine into a final number. Part II turns to the American side: how the treaty credit works on your Form 1040, when the $250,000 home-sale exclusion can shelter the gain entirely, and what actually happens on closing day in the notaire‘s office.

I. How France Taxes Your Sale: What Counts, What Is Exempt, and How Time Shrinks the Bill

A. Do I Owe French Tax When I Sell My French House as an American?

Start with the basic rule, because it surprises many Americans: France taxes the sale of French real estate no matter where the seller lives. Article 150 U of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts, the CGI, France’s master tax statute) provides that “les plus-values réalisées par les personnes physiques ou les sociétés ou groupements qui relèvent des articles 8 à 8 ter , lors de la cession à titre onéreux de biens immobiliers bâtis ou non bâtis ou de droits relatifs à ces biens, sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu” in the conditions set out in articles 150 V to 150 VH. In plain English, gains realized by individuals on the paid sale of built or unbuilt real estate are subject to income tax. The plus-value, literally “added value,” is the taxable capital gain: roughly your sale price minus your purchase price and certain costs. It applies whether you are a French resident, an American living in Lyon, or an American who has not set foot in France for ten years. If you are a nonresident, the tax takes the form of a withholding-style levy (prélèvement, a flat tax collected at the source) under article 244 bis A of the same Code, which states that “les plus-values, telles que définies aux e bis et e ter du I de l’article 164 B , réalisées par les personnes et organismes mentionnés au 2 du I lors de la cession des biens ou droits mentionnés au 3 sont soumises à un prélèvement selon les taux fixés au III bis“. The base is computed under the same rules as for residents; only the collection method and the rate differ, as we will see.

The most complete exemption is the one for your main home. The same article 150 U excludes from tax any building that satisfies the condition “Qui constituent la résidence principale du cédant au jour de la cession“, meaning property that is the seller’s principal residence (résidence principale, the home where you actually and habitually live) on the day of the sale. If the French house you are selling is genuinely your main home on closing day, there is no French capital gains tax at all, regardless of your nationality. American retirees living full-time in France use this exemption every year. But it is narrow in one decisive way: a vacation home, a pied-à-terre you visit twice a year, or a house you already moved out of does not qualify, and the tax office checks the facts, from utility bills to tax returns, rather than taking your word for it.

Two reliefs soften the landing for Americans who used to live in France and left. The first covers the case where the house you are selling was your principal residence in France on the day you moved your tax home (domicile fiscal, the country where you are resident for tax purposes) out of France. Article 244 bis A exempts “la cession de l’immeuble qui constituait la résidence principale en France du cédant à la date du transfert de son domicile fiscal hors de France” provided two strict conditions are met: “la cession soit réalisée au plus tard le 31 décembre de l’année suivant celle du transfert” (the sale must close no later than December 31 of the year after you left) and “l’immeuble n’ait pas été mis à la disposition de tiers” (the house must not have been made available to anyone else, rented or lent, between your departure and the sale). Move back to Chicago in June 2025, leave the house empty, and close the sale in October 2026, and the gain is exempt. Rent it out on Airbnb for the summer in between, and the exemption is gone. As the official Service-Public information site confirms in its English-language guide, the sale must close no later than December 31 of the year after departure, and the house must not have been made available to a third party in the meantime (official English-language guide).

The second relief helps Americans who never lived in the house as a main home, or who missed the one-year window. France grants nonresidents an exemption on the sale of another residence, within the limit of a €150,000 gain (official guidance), when the seller is a national of the European Union, the European Economic Area, or a State that has signed administrative-assistance and mutual-recovery tax conventions with France, and has been continuously resident in France for at least two years at some point. The sale must generally close no later than December 31 of the tenth year after the year you moved your tax home out of France, and the relief is granted once, for one property per taxpayer. Because the France-United States treaty itself organizes exchange of information and assistance in collection between the two countries, American sellers routinely fall within this provision, but it is your notaire who verifies eligibility at closing, so raise the point early rather than assuming it. Only the first €150,000 of gain is sheltered; anything above is taxed normally.

Finally, time itself exempts. France wipes out the income-tax portion of the gain once you have owned the property long enough: property held more than 22 years is fully exempt from that tax (official guidance). Social charges take longer: gains on property held more than 30 years are additionally exempt from social charges (official guidance). Hold the house 31 years and the French capital gains bill is zero. Between year 6 and year 30, the bill shrinks every year, which is the subject of the next section.

B. How Much Will I Really Pay? Allowances, the 19 Percent Levy, Social Charges, and the High-Gain Surtax

Computing the French bill follows four steps: determine the taxable gain, apply the holding-period allowances (abattements pour durée de détention, percentage reductions that grow with each year of ownership), apply the 19 percent levy and the social charge, then check the surtax on large gains. Take them in order.

Step one is the gross gain. The starting point is the sale price stated in the deed, minus the purchase price stated in your original deed, with adjustments both ways. On the purchase side you may add the real acquisition costs (transfer taxes and notaire fees, for their documented amount) or, if that helps you more, a flat 7.5 percent of the purchase price with no receipts required. You may also add documented improvement, construction, or extension work carried out by contractors (your own weekend labor does not count), or a flat 15 percent of the purchase price if you have owned the property more than five years. On the sale side you subtract the costs of the sale itself, such as energy-efficiency diagnostics and agency commission you paid. The notaire assembles all of this from your deeds and invoices, which is why keeping the original purchase file matters enormously: an American who bought in 2010 and lost the paperwork for a €40,000 roof replacement will simply pay tax on €40,000 of phantom gain.

Step two is where long ownership pays. Each full year of ownership beyond the fifth earns a percentage reduction, and the schedule differs between the income-tax base and the social-charges base. The official English-language table reads as follows: up to 5 years, no reduction on either base; from the 6th to the 21st year, 6 percent per year off the income-tax base and 1.65 percent per year off the social-charges base; for the 22nd year, 4 percent and 1.6 percent; beyond the 22nd year, full exemption from income tax with 9 percent per year continuing off the social-charges base; beyond the 30th year, “Exemption” on both. Two worked examples from the same official guide make the mechanics concrete. Sell after 10 years with a €10,000 gain and a 30 percent income-tax allowance (6 percent per year from the 6th to the 10th year) (official worked example), leaving €7,000 subject to income tax, alongside an 8.25 percent social-charges reduction (1.65 percent per year over the same years), leaving €9,175 subject to social charges. Sell after 25 years and the gain is fully exempt from income tax, with a combined 55 percent reduction on the social-charges base. The practical lesson for Americans timing a sale: the 6th, 22nd, and 30th anniversaries of your purchase deed are cliffs where waiting a few months can save thousands of euros, and your notaire can model the exact difference before you sign anything.

Step three is the rate. As a nonresident individual, you pay the flat levy rather than the progressive French income-tax scale. The Code states the rule plainly: “Toutefois, les personnes physiques, les associés personnes physiques de sociétés, groupements ou organismes dont les bénéfices sont imposés au nom des associés et les porteurs de parts, personnes physiques, de fonds de placement immobilier mentionnés à l’article 239 nonies sont soumis au prélèvement au taux de 19 %.” American individuals therefore pay 19 percent on the gain remaining after allowances. Alongside it come the social charges (prélèvements sociaux, France’s earmarked social levies on capital income). Here nonresidents get a meaningful break: while French residents pay 17.2 percent, nonresident sellers outside the European social-security system pay only the solidarity levy of 7.5 percent provided for in article 235 ter of the CGI, under which nonresident gains remain liable for the 7.5 percent solidarity levy (official tax-administration commentary). A concrete illustration: a €100,000 gross gain on a house held 10 years becomes €70,000 of taxable income after the 30 percent allowance, taxed at 19 percent (€13,300), plus €91,750 of social-charges base after the 8.25 percent allowance, charged at 7.5 percent (about €6,881), for a combined French bill around €20,181 before any surtax.

Step four is the surtax on large gains (taxe sur les plus-values élevées, an extra progressive tax on taxable gains above €50,000). Article 1609 nonies G of the CGI expressly extends it to nonresidents, and it provides that “La taxe est due à raison des plus-values imposables d’un montant supérieur à 50 000 €“. The rate runs from 2 percent on gains just above the threshold to 6 percent on gains above €260,000, applied to the full taxable gain with smoothing bands at each step. In the €100,000 example above, the €70,000 taxable gain falls in the 2 percent bracket and adds €1,400. Paris apartments held briefly can easily produce six-figure taxable gains where the surtax adds several thousand euros, so it must be part of every pre-sale estimate. Note that the surtax does not apply to gains on building land (terrains à bâtir, plots suitable for construction), a carve-out written into the statute.

Two procedural points complete the French picture. First, nonresident sellers must generally appoint an accredited tax representative (représentant fiscal, a professional established in France who guarantees payment of the tax) when the gain is taxable. The official guide states that nonresidents must appoint a tax representative as soon as the gain is taxable (official guidance), while listing automatic exemptions, including sale prices under €150,000, sellers covered by assistance conventions, and gains already fully exempt through holding period. Your notaire arranges this routinely, and the representative’s fee, typically a few hundred euros, is simply part of closing costs. Second, the 19 percent rate itself is the product of hard-won litigation. For years France charged nonresidents 33.33 percent, until the Conseil d’État (France’s supreme administrative court) held that a nonresident challenging a French tax under the free movement of capital is entitled to a comparison between the tax burden on a nonresident and that on a French resident in a comparable situation (Conseil d’État, decision no. 445785), with the higher nonresident rate found to restrict the free movement of capital between EU Member States and third countries, contrary to Article 63 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (Conseil d’État, 9th chamber, decision no. 445785). Americans benefit from the 19 percent rate that followed. If you want the full closing-cost picture on the purchase you once made, our guide to offers, cooling-off rights, and deposits explains the buyer-side mirror image, and our breakdown of annual property taxes and what the IRS lets you deduct covers the bills you stop paying the day you sell.

II. The American Side: Treaty Credit, IRS Reporting, and Closing Day

A. Will the IRS Tax Me Again on the Same Gain, and How Do I Claim the Treaty Credit?

The starting point on the American side is jurisdiction, not rates. Article 13 of the France-United States income tax treaty, signed in Paris on August 31, 1994, and published in France by decree no. 96-222 of March 15, 1996, provides that gains from selling real estate located in one treaty country may be taxed by that country (treaty Article 13, official consolidated version). Gains from selling real estate located in one treaty country may be taxed by that country. France therefore has every right to collect the 19 percent levy, the solidarity charge, and the surtax computed in Part I, and nothing in the treaty shields the sale from French tax. Because the United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide income, the same gain is also reportable in the United States. The treaty resolves the overlap the way all American treaties do: with a foreign tax credit rather than an exemption. Article 24 of the treaty states that, in accordance with United States law and subject to its limitations, the United States grants its citizens and residents a credit against American income tax for French income tax paid by or on their behalf (treaty Article 24, official consolidated version). You report the full gain on your American return, compute the tentative American tax, then subtract the French income tax you paid, dollar for dollar, up to the American tax attributable to that gain. You file twice; you pay the higher of the two bills, not the sum.

In practice the credit runs through Form 1116 (Foreign Tax Credit) attached to your Form 1040, with the French gain sitting in the general-category basket, and the mechanics reward careful timing. The French 19 percent levy and the high-gain surtax are creditable income taxes; the 7.5 percent solidarity charge is presented by France as a social levy, and American practitioners generally claim it as well, though your CPA should confirm the current IRS posture for your filing year. Because the credit cannot exceed the American tax on the same income, a year in which your American rate on the gain is lower than your French bill produces excess credits you may carry back one year and forward ten. Coordinate the closing date with your American tax year accordingly: a December closing that bunches the French payment into a low-income American year can strand credits, while your CPA may prefer to align estimated payments and the credit in the same year. One more American-only wrinkle: several states, California most famously, do not follow the federal foreign tax credit, so a California resident can owe state tax on the full gain with no offset for the French levy. And the 3.8 percent Net Investment Income Tax has no foreign-credit offset either, so high-income sellers should model it separately with their adviser.

Before reaching for the credit, check whether you owe any American tax at all, because the Section 121 home-sale exclusion can eliminate the federal bill entirely. The IRS explains that a qualifying seller may exclude up to $250,000 of the gain, or up to $500,000 when filing jointly with a spouse (IRS Topic 701). The conditions are American, not French: you must have owned and used the French house as your main home for at least two of the five years before the sale, with reduced exclusions available for moves driven by work, health, or unforeseen circumstances. The American retiree who lived full-time in Sarlat for six years and sells in year seven will often find the entire federal gain excluded, in which case the French tax, which has no equivalent exclusion for second homes, simply becomes an uncredited cost. Note the asymmetry in the other direction too: France exempts the main home completely while the United States caps the exclusion in dollars, so a $900,000 gain on a Paris apartment that was your main home owes nothing in France and up to $400,000 of taxable gain in the United States for a single filer.

The trickiest American trap is currency. Your French gain is computed in euros, but your American gain is computed in dollars, using the exchange rate on the purchase date for your basis (basis, your tax cost in the property) and the rate on the sale date for your proceeds. A house bought for €300,000 when the euro traded at $1.45 and sold for €350,000 when it trades at $1.05 produces a modest French gain and an American capital loss, because the dollar value of your investment fell. The reverse configuration manufactures taxable American gain out of a flat euro result. Keep every deed, closing statement, and wire confirmation showing the dollar amounts actually paid and received, and give them to your CPA alongside the notaire‘s French computation. Finally, remember that selling does not end your French tax story in the sale year: rental income received before closing, the annual taxe foncière (the French local property tax) apportioned with the buyer, and a possible final French income-tax return as a nonresident all survive the sale, and our guide to the French wealth tax, its calculation, and the American credit explains the related filing you may also be leaving behind. If selling is only one option among keeping, gifting, or bequeathing the house, our succession pillar on wills and electing American law for your French house maps the inheritance alternative.

B. What Happens on Closing Day in the Notaire’s Office?

French closings look nothing like American ones, and understanding the choreography prevents last-minute panic. There is no title company and no escrow agent as Americans know them: the notaire, a state-appointed public officer with a monopoly on authenticating real-estate transfers, draws up the final deed (acte authentique de vente, the notarized deed that alone transfers ownership), verifies title, mortgages, planning restrictions, and co-ownership records, collects the price from the buyer, pays off any existing mortgage, computes and withholds your capital-gains tax, and remits it to the Treasury when the deed is registered (enregistrement, the tax-office recording that makes the transfer enforceable against third parties). The Code assigns the notaire this collection role directly: “L’impôt dû en application du présent article est acquitté lors de l’enregistrement de l’acte“. You do not receive the gross price and pay the tax later; the tax is carved out of the funds in the notaire‘s account before the balance is wired to you, usually within days of signing. Unlike the American FIRPTA regime, which forces buyers to withhold 15 percent of the gross price when a foreign person sells United States real estate, France withholds only the computed tax on the gain, which is far kinder to sellers with large embedded basis, but it also means the computation must be exactly right before signing, because there is no later refund procedure worthy of the name.

The weeks before closing are dominated by paperwork you should start assembling the day you list the property. The buyer must receive the full technical diagnostic file (dossier de diagnostic technique, the bundle of mandatory surveys covering energy performance, lead, asbestos, termites, gas and electrical safety, and natural risks) before the preliminary contract, and a missing or expired survey can delay signing. You must produce your original purchase deed, proof of acquisition costs and improvement works with contractor invoices, your French tax number (numéro fiscal, the identifier the tax office uses to track you), evidence of continuous ownership dates for the allowance computation, and, where relevant, proof that the property was your main home or that the one-year or €150,000 reliefs apply. If a tax representative is required, the appointment and the representative’s guarantee must be in place before the final deed. Capital losses, by contrast, buy you nothing: a sale at a loss generates no French tax, but the loss cannot offset other income or be carried forward, so timing a loss-making sale has no French tax-planning dimension, whatever its American consequences.

The single most important precaution is also the one sellers most often skip: demand a written French tax computation from the notaire before signing the preliminary contract (compromis de vente, the binding pre-contract that locks in price and conditions months before closing), not the night before the final deed. French courts hold the notaire to a demanding duty to advise on tax. In a Bordeaux case decided on March 18, 2025, a seller complained that the notaire who handled both her preliminary contract and her final deed had never warned her about the capital-gains taxation of her land sale, telling her the amount only when she could no longer walk away. The court found that she had indeed been deprived of an informed choice: “Elle reproche ainsi au notaire d’avoir manqué à son obligation de conseil en n’attirant pas son attention sur les conditions pour bénéficier de l’abattement de 100 % de l’impôt sur la plus value prévue à l’article 150 U du code Général des Impôts” The court put the lost chance of walking away at 30 percent (“sera évaluée à 30 %” in the judgment) and held that “ouvre donc droit à réparation à hauteur de 25.247 euros” (Tribunal judiciaire de Bordeaux, 1st civil chamber, March 18, 2025, case no. 23/00043). The lesson for an American seller three thousand miles away is blunt: a €25,000 courtroom victory two years later is a poor substitute for a correct computation handed over with the draft compromis, so instruct your notaire in writing, send the complete purchase file early, and do not sign the preliminary contract until the estimated French levy, solidarity charge, surtax, and representative’s fee are stated in figures. The Finance Ministry’s nonresident desk (Service des impôts des particuliers non-résidents, the tax office in Noisy-le-Grand that handles nonresident individuals) and its online guide for sellers, the tax office’s official guide for nonresident sellers provides the official backstop if anything in the computation looks unfamiliar.

Conclusion

Selling a French house as an American is a two-country exercise with a strict order of operations: France computes and collects first, and the United States credits second. Start from the French base, because everything else follows from it. Confirm whether the main-home exemption, the one-year former-home rule, or the €150,000 second relief applies to you; count your full years of ownership against the 6th, 22nd, and 30th anniversary cliffs; budget 19 percent on the remaining income base, 7.5 percent on the social base, and the 2-to-6 percent surtax above €50,000 of taxable gain; and verify whether a tax representative must stand behind the payment. Then carry the French numbers to your American return, where the treaty credit on Form 1116, the Section 121 exclusion of up to $250,000 ($500,000 joint), and the euro-dollar basis computation decide your residual American bill. Get the notaire‘s written computation before the compromis, keep every deed and invoice since purchase, and align the closing date with your American tax year. Handled in that order, the sale produces no surprises: one French withholding at closing, one American return claiming its credit, and the balance wired home.

📄 Official circular