KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Barred From New York for the Second Year: the Abbas UN Visa Ban, the 152-3 Video Vote and What France Would Do

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Barred From New York for the Second Year: the Abbas UN Visa Ban, the 152-3 Video Vote and What France Would Do

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

For the second year in a row, the president of the Palestinian Authority will address the United Nations General Assembly from a screen instead of the podium. On 16 September 2026, the United States State Department announced that it would deny visas to officials of the Palestine Liberation Organization and the Palestinian Authority, and a Palestinian official confirmed to Reuters the next day that Mahmoud Abbas himself was covered. The stated reasons included the pursuit of cases against Israel at international tribunals. On 17 September, the 193-member General Assembly voted 152 to 3, with four abstentions, to let Abbas and other high-level Palestinian officials take part by video over the coming year. The episode raises a question that is older than most of the diplomats involved: can the host country of the United Nations pick which delegations may enter New York? The answer sits in a 1947 treaty, a unanimous 1988 opinion of the International Court of Justice about the Palestine Liberation Organization itself, and a set of French court decisions that explain, better than any press release, how Paris reads immunities, recognition and visa refusals. This article reconstructs the ban, tests the American justification against the Headquarters Agreement, and sets out what France, as a host state, a visa authority and a cooperating State Party to the International Criminal Court, would do with the same file.

I. Can the United States lawfully shut the door of the United Nations?

A. “No impediments to transit”: what the 1947 Headquarters Agreement actually says

The legal starting point is not discretion but obligation. The Agreement between the United Nations and the United States regarding the Headquarters of the United Nations, signed on 26 June 1947 and brought into force on 21 November 1947, provides in its Section 11 that American authorities at every level “shall not impose any impediments to transit” to and from the headquarters district for representatives of Members, UN officials and their families. Section 12 removes the excuse Washington reaches for most readily: the transit privilege applies “irrespective of the relations existing” between the governments concerned and the United States. And Section 13 deals specifically with visas: American entry laws must not defeat the Section 11 privilege, and visas for covered persons are free and owed “as promptly as possible”. The full treaty text is published in the United Nations Treaty Series, volume 11.

Two consequences follow that the current controversy tends to obscure. First, the Palestinian delegation is covered. The delegation sits at the United Nations as the State of Palestine, an observer state with the same status as the Holy See: present in the room, without a vote. Observer invitees fall within the transit privilege, exactly as the Secretary-General argued in the 1980s when Washington tried to close the PLO Observer Mission in New York. In a letter of 13 October 1987, the Secretary-General told the American permanent representative that the contemplated legislation “runs counter to obligations” under the Headquarters Agreement: the members of the PLO Observer Mission, as invitees of the Organization under resolution 3237 (XXIX), were covered by Sections 11, 12 and 13, which created a treaty duty to admit them for their official functions.

Second, a disagreement about the Agreement is not settled by the host country alone. Section 21(a) sends any dispute over the Agreement that is “not settled by negotiation” for decision to “a tribunal of three arbitrators”: one named by the Secretary-General, one by the American Secretary of State, and a president chosen by the two or, failing agreement, by the President of the International Court of Justice. The United States does retain a domestic reservation, enacted in section 6 of Public Law 80-357, the statute that wrote the Headquarters Agreement into American federal law: nothing in the Agreement diminishes the American right to safeguard its own security and to control the entry of aliens into American territory outside the headquarters district. That reservation explains travel-radius restrictions around New York. It does not, on its face, authorize barring an invited head of delegation from the headquarters district itself, and that is precisely the line the 1988 precedent drew.

When Congress passed the Anti-Terrorism Act of 1987, which threatened the PLO Observer Mission with closure, the General Assembly asked the International Court of Justice whether the United States was bound to arbitrate under Section 21. On 26 April 1988, the Court answered unanimously that the United States, as a party to the 1947 Agreement, was bound to enter into Section 21 arbitration to settle its dispute with the Organization. The case file is public on the Court’s official page for the 1988 advisory proceedings. The lesson for today is narrow but solid: once the Secretary-General formally contests the consistency of an American measure with the Headquarters Agreement and seeks arbitration, Washington cannot lawfully refuse the procedure. Whether the Secretariat triggers that mechanism this time is a political decision. That the mechanism exists, and that it has already bitten once over this very delegation, is law.

B. Punished for going to court: why the stated American motives do not survive contact with the law

The State Department statement of 16 September 2026 did not name Abbas, but it named the grievances: the PLO and the Authority had, in Washington’s words, failed to reform, undermined the prospects for peace, internationalized the conflict through cases brought at the ICC and the ICJ, plus bids for unilateral recognition, and continued payments and glorification tied to terrorism. As Le Monde reported with Agence France-Presse, an official source placed Abbas himself under the measure. Three of these motives deserve a lawyer’s reading, because each of them misunderstands the forum it attacks.

First, bringing cases before international courts is not an abuse of the system; it is the system. The ICC Prosecutor obtained an arrest warrant in 2024 against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu over allegations of war crimes and crimes against humanity during the Gaza conflict, and those warrants remain fully valid, as this publication explained in its analysis of what an ICC warrant means for a leader travelling to New York. The Rome Statute, the Court’s founding treaty, states the point without ambiguity in its Article 27, which applies the Statute to all persons “without any distinction based on official capacity”: head-of-state status neither exempts from criminal responsibility nor mitigates the sentence. Nor, under paragraph 2, do official-capacity immunities “bar the Court from exercising its jurisdiction”. The official English text is published by the Court in the Rome Statute PDF on the ICC website. States Parties, which include France and every European Union member, must comply: Article 89 then obliges every State Party to comply with arrest-and-surrender requests under Part 9 of the Statute and its own national procedure. Penalizing a delegation for seising the very courts the Charter system built is, in legal terms, penalizing the exercise of a right. It is also self-defeating: the American response to the 2024 warrants, a campaign of sanctions against ICC officials including prosecutors and judges that this publication has already documented in its account of the American sanctions against the Court, has not suspended a single warrant.

Second, the non-recognition argument changes nothing. The United States does not recognize Palestine as a state; neither, for the purposes of the Headquarters Agreement, does it need to. Section 12 applies irrespective of bilateral relations, and the 1988 precedent concerned a PLO mission that enjoyed observer status only. French courts go further, and in a direction American readers often find surprising. On 25 July 2025, the Assemblée plénière of the French Court of Cassation, the highest formation of the court, annulled an arrest warrant issued on 13 November 2023 against a sitting foreign head of state prosecuted in France for complicity in crimes against humanity and war crimes. The Court held that “Le principe de l’immunité ne peut être opposé devant les juridictions internationales, dont les statuts écartent expressément toute immunité, et qui agissent au nom de la communauté internationale” (the immunity principle cannot be opposed before international courts, whose statutes expressly set aside immunity and which act in the name of the international community), while national courts must apply personal immunity strictly: “L’immunité personnelle, distincte de l’immunité fonctionnelle, est reconnue aux seuls chef d’État, chef du gouvernement et ministre des affaires étrangères, en exercice. Elle concerne tous les actes accomplis, tant à titre privé qu’à titre officiel.” (Personal immunity, distinct from functional immunity, is recognized only for the head of state, head of government and foreign minister in office. It covers all acts, private and official.) Read the full ruling on the Court of Cassation website, appeal 24-84.393.

The same day, the same formation drew the mirror line for everyone else. In appeal 24-84.071, concerning a state agent prosecuted for complicity in crimes against humanity and war crimes, the Court rejected the appeal and reset the balance in these terms: “Cette évolution de la coutume internationale, à laquelle la Cour de cassation entend contribuer, définit un nouvel équilibre entre les immunités et la lutte contre l’impunité.” (This evolution of international custom, to which the Court intends to contribute, sets a new balance between immunities and the fight against impunity.) The operative rule follows: “sous réserve des stipulations des conventions internationales, notamment celles relatives aux relations diplomatiques et consulaires, le principe d’immunité fonctionnelle de juridiction en matière pénale ne peut pas être opposé en cas de poursuites des chefs de génocide, crimes contre l’humanité et crimes de guerre” (subject to treaty provisions, functional immunity in criminal matters cannot be opposed to prosecutions for genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes). See the companion ruling of 25 July 2025, appeal 24-84.071.

The combined message is the French grammar of immunities: absolute protection for the narrow circle of incumbents before national judges, no protection for official acts amounting to core international crimes, and no protection at all before international courts. Applied to the visa file, the logic cuts one way. The Assemblée plénière added that personal immunity “ne soit pas liée à la reconnaissance de la qualité de chef d’État par l’État du for ou à l’existence de relations diplomatiques entre les deux États” (must not depend on the forum state’s recognition of the leader or on diplomatic relations), because conditioning immunity on recognition “aboutirait à attribuer à chaque État, démocratique ou non, la compétence discrétionnaire d’autoriser devant ses juridictions des poursuites pénales à l’encontre d’un chef d’État étranger” (would hand every state, democratic or not, discretionary power to authorize prosecutions of a foreign head of state). Paris refuses to let recognition decide who is protected. Washington cannot credibly let non-recognition decide who may enter. See again the ruling of 25 July 2025, appeal 24-84.393.

Third, the remaining motives, stipends and schoolbooks, however serious politically, are not Headquarters Agreement grounds. Sections 11 to 13 contain no conduct exception for the invitee; the only written American reservation concerns security and movement outside the district. A disagreement about Palestinian governance belongs before the Council and the Assembly, not at the consular window. Deputy Ambassador Tammy Bruce told the Assembly before the vote that the Authority must stop funding terrorism and trading governance for diplomatic theatre if it wants partnership treatment. That is a policy speech. It is not a Section 11 finding.

II. What happens now in New York, and what Paris would do with the same file

A. The remedies on paper: video screens, an arbitration that bites, and the advisory-opinion route

The immediate fix is already voted. By 152 votes to 3 with 4 abstentions, the Assembly authorized Abbas and any other high-level Palestinian officials prevented from travelling to address United Nations meetings and conferences by video over the next year, as recorded in the United Nations General Assembly proceedings of 17 September. Abbas spoke to the 2025 Assembly the same way. The fix preserves the voice and concedes the principle: the head of an observer-state delegation again opens General-Assembly week on a screen while 142 states, after the two-state conference co-chaired by France and Saudi Arabia, have endorsed the declaration for a Palestinian state, France having recognized Palestine itself in 2025.

The legal remedies sleep one level down. The Secretary-General can formally contest the measure, declare a dispute under Section 21, and demand the three-arbitrator tribunal, exactly as his predecessor did in January and March 1988 when the Attorney General’s determination to close the PLO mission was denounced as a clear violation of the Agreement. The Assembly can request a new advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice, the route it took on 2 March 1988 with resolution 42/229A, which produced the unanimous answer of 26 April. Neither route puts Abbas on a plane next week; both would put the United States in a procedure it has already lost once on indistinguishable facts. The reason neither has been triggered so far is not legal doubt but institutional prudence: Secretaries-General husband the arbitration weapon, and Assembly majorities prefer the video workaround to a confrontation with the host country. Readers should understand the trade. The video resolution solves September. Only Section 21 or the Court solves the precedent, and precedents, unlike speeches, compound: last year’s ban was the first, this year’s is the second, and every unchallenged year makes the third easier.

One clarification matters for the many readers who confuse the two courts. Nothing in this file asks any judge to rule on the underlying conflict, on statehood, or on the criminal responsibility of any leader. A Section 21 arbitration would decide only whether barring an invited delegation breaches the Headquarters Agreement. An advisory opinion would answer only the question put to it. That modesty is the point. The law of the headquarters is plumbing, not politics, and plumbers do not need a theory of the house to fix the pipes.

B. The French mirror: wide discretion at the consulate, strict control at the court

France is, in turn, a host country, a visa authority and an ICC cooperating state, and on each count its rules are written down. Start with the consulate window, because that is where an Abbas file would begin in Paris. French law provides that “Tout étranger souhaitant entrer en France en vue d’y séjourner pour une durée n’excédant pas trois mois doit solliciter auprès des autorités diplomatiques et consulaires françaises un visa de court séjour” (any foreigner wishing to enter France for three months or less must apply to the French diplomatic and consular authorities for a short-stay visa), under Article L312-1 of the Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners (CESEDA). What the statute does not do is list the cases in which the visa must be refused. The administrative courts have drawn the consequence for decades, and the Administrative Court of Appeal of Nantes restated it in a 2022 decision that every Paris immigration practitioner knows: “En l’absence de toute disposition conventionnelle, législative ou réglementaire déterminant les cas où un visa peut être refusé à un étranger désirant se rendre en France, et eu égard à la nature d’une telle décision, les autorités françaises disposent d’un large pouvoir d’appréciation à cet égard, et peuvent se fonder non seulement sur des motifs tenant à l’ordre public mais aussi sur toute considération d’intérêt général.” (Where no treaty, statute or regulation defines the cases for refusal, the French authorities enjoy wide discretion and may rely not only on public-order grounds but on any consideration of the general interest.) Read the decision on Légifrance, Nantes Court of Appeal, 21NT01934.

Wide discretion is not no control. In that same case, an Algerian businessman refused a long-stay visa by the consulate in Algiers, with the refusal confirmed on review, won before the Nantes administrative court, which annulled the refusal and ordered the visa issued; the government appealed, and the court of appeal examined the business records, the payroll, the timing of the appointment as co-manager, and concluded that the review commission had committed a manifest error of assessment. The refusal fell. The structure is the whole French answer in miniature: the executive decides freely, the judge reviews narrowly, and the narrow review bites when the file does not support the motive. A delegate barred from a Paris conference for having seised an international court would arrive before the Nantes judge with the strongest possible version of that argument, because punishing recourse to a court the French Republic itself supports sits at the outer edge of what “general interest” can carry. France’s posture in this very file confirms the point: Paris co-chaired the two-state conference, recognized Palestine in 2025, and belongs to the majority that voted the video resolution. A French visa ban on Abbas would contradict three settled positions at once, which is why no Paris government, left or right, has contemplated one.

Turn to the criminal side, where France’s strictness runs in the opposite direction and completes the picture. For ICC suspects found on French soil, the Code of Criminal Procedure states the principle bluntly: “Pour l’application du statut de la Cour pénale internationale signé le 18 juillet 1998, la France participe à la répression des infractions et coopère avec cette juridiction dans les conditions fixées par le présent titre.” (For the application of the ICC Statute of 18 July 1998, France participates in punishing these offences and cooperates with the Court under the conditions of this title.) See Article 627 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The provisions that follow apply to anyone prosecuted or convicted for genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes within the meaning of Articles 6 to 8 and 25 of the Statute. In plain terms, France built a dedicated surrender track for Hague suspects, and a Paris defence lawyer’s work consists of policing its deadlines, its manifest-error review and its detention guarantees, not of relitigating the conflict.

For ordinary extradition, the default regime is equally written and equally demanding of the requesting state. “En l’absence de convention internationale en stipulant autrement, les conditions, la procédure et les effets de l’extradition sont déterminés par les dispositions du présent chapitre.” (Absent a treaty providing otherwise, extradition is governed by this chapter.) See Article 696 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. And the chapter opens with a sentence Americans often overlook: “Le gouvernement français peut remettre, sur leur demande, aux gouvernements étrangers, toute personne n’ayant pas la nationalité française qui, étant l’objet d’une poursuite intentée au nom de l’Etat requérant ou d’une condamnation prononcée par ses tribunaux, est trouvée sur le territoire de la République.” (The French government may surrender, at their request, to foreign governments any person without French nationality who is prosecuted or convicted and found on French territory.) See Article 696-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. France does not extradite its nationals, conditions everything else on double criminality and specialty, and lets the chambre de l’instruction give a reasoned opinion that the government ignores at its political peril. The Court of Cassation enforces the grammar to the letter: in a 2020 extradition case, it annulled a Douai ruling for importing a foreign-consent condition the statute does not contain, holding that “le consentement de l’Etat étranger à l’extradition de la personne remise en vertu d’un mandat d’arrêt européen vers un Etat non membre de l’Union européenne n’entre pas dans les conditions légales visées par l’article 696-15 du code de procédure pénale” (the foreign state’s consent to extraditing a person surrendered under a European Arrest Warrant to a non-EU state is not among the legal conditions of Article 696-15). See the Criminal Chamber ruling of 2 December 2020, appeal 19-87.428.

Put the two halves together and the French position on the Abbas file writes itself. At the consulate, Paris claims wide discretion and submits to narrow but real judicial review, a review that punishes motives the file cannot carry. Before the courts, Paris surrenders ICC suspects through a dedicated statutory track, refuses to surrender its own nationals, and annuls procedures that invent conditions the code does not contain. Add the diplomatic record, recognition in 2025, co-chairmanship of the conference, yes vote on the video resolution, and a Court of Cassation that reads recognition out of immunity law, and the conclusion is not a prediction but an inventory: had this file landed in Paris, the delegation would have received its visas, the Assembly week would have proceeded normally, and any Hague suspect setting foot at Roissy would have faced the surrender track within days. That asymmetry, hospitality for delegates and severity for suspects, is the French idea of the international rule of law, and it is also, incidentally, why Paris remains the forum where cross-border defence work gets done.

Conclusion

The 152-to-3 vote solved September and settled nothing. Mahmoud Abbas will speak to the General Assembly by video for the second consecutive year because the host country barred him, citing among other grievances his recourse to the International Criminal Court and the International Court of Justice. The Headquarters Agreement says visas for invitees must be granted as promptly as possible, irrespective of bilateral relations. The Court said unanimously in 1988 that a dispute over that obligation goes to arbitration whether Washington likes it or not, in proceedings about this very delegation. And French courts, from the Assemblée plénière on immunities to the Nantes court on visas to the Criminal Chamber on surrender, apply a consistent grammar: recognition does not create rights, discretion does not excuse arbitrariness, and statutes mean what they say. The law of the headquarters has an answer for every page of this file except the one that matters most, which is political: who will trigger the procedure. Until the Secretary-General contests the measure or the Assembly asks the question, the precedent will keep compounding, one video screen per year. Delegations, counsel and journalists covering the next high-level week should read Section 21 now, because the third ban will arrive with the same press release and the same legal hole, and the lawyers who have the arbitration request ready will be the ones the cameras call.

📄 Official circular