On 16 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union dismissed the sanctions challenge brought by Russian businessman Roman Trotsenko and kept his name on the EU asset-freeze list. The judgment in Case T-459/24, Trotsenko v Council, handed down by the Fourth Chamber in Luxembourg, is the latest in a long line of rulings upholding the EU’s Russia sanctions, but it teaches a lesson no earlier judgment had spelled out so bluntly: telling the Council “I sold my shares” changes nothing unless the sale is proved with contracts, prices, payment records and corporate documents. Trotsenko said he had divested from coal, energy and infrastructure companies. The Court answered that he had produced no transfer contract, no transfer price, no payment arrangements and not even the articles of association of the companies concerned.
For anyone living with a frozen bank account, a blocked flat or a seized shareholding in France, this ruling matters directly. EU sanctions apply immediately in France, French banks enforce them daily under the supervision of the Treasury, and the only court that can annul an EU listing sits in Luxembourg. A Paris lawyer’s file therefore has to be built for two fronts at once: observations to the Council at each six-month renewal, and, where the listing is flawed, an annulment action under Article 263 TFEU within a strict two-month deadline. This analysis explains what Trotsenko argued, exactly why each argument failed in the Court’s own words, and what a person targeted by a freeze must do differently from France to stand a real chance.
The stakes go beyond one billionaire. Since the delisting of Alisher Usmanov and Mikhail Fridman, analysed in our earlier coverage of successful challenges, and the confirmation of Roman Abramovich’s listing, covered in our analysis of the September 2026 Abramovich ruling, the General Court has been drawing a sharper and sharper line between exits that work and exits that fail. Trotsenko now defines the failing side of that line, document by document.
I. The General Court’s Trotsenko Ruling of 16 September 2026: What Was Decided
By his action under Article 263 TFEU, lodged on 3 September 2024 and heard on 4 February 2026, Mr Roman Trotsenko sought the annulment of four successive sets of EU acts keeping his name on the Russia sanctions lists: the initial listing of 24 June 2024, the September 2024 renewal, the March 2025 renewal and the September 2025 renewal. Each set combined a Council Decision amending Decision 2014/145/CFSP with a Council Implementing Regulation amending Regulation (EU) No 269/2014. He raised six pleas in law, covering the rights of the defence, the duty to state reasons, the legality of the listing criterion itself, errors of assessment, proportionality and legitimate expectations. The Court rejected every one of them and closed with the classic sanction of failed sanctions litigation: it ordered Mr Roman Trotsenko to pay the costs.
A. Why Was Roman Trotsenko Listed? Leading Businessperson and Substantial-Revenue Sectors
The Council listed Trotsenko in June 2024 under Articles 3(1)(f) and (g) of Regulation (EU) No 269/2014, the two economic criteria of the Russia regime: persons supporting or benefiting from the Russian government, and leading businesspersons operating in Russia together with operators in economic sectors providing a substantial source of revenue to that government. The statement of reasons sent to him described him as a “leading businessperson operating in Russia”, with interests across iron ore and steel, coal, infrastructure and energy, and ranked him among the richest persons in the country. It identified him as a prominent shareholder in AEON Corporation and Vorkutagol JSC, presented as operators in sectors providing a “substantial source of revenue” to the Russian government, and as an important indirect shareholder of Group Russian Energy LLC held through other companies. On that double basis, the Council concluded that he met the leading-businessperson criterion and the substantial-revenue-sectors criterion at the same time.
That statement names three concrete assets: AEON Corporation, the holding company Trotsenko founded and in which he held 100 percent of the capital before the listing; Vorkutagol, a coal producer acquired at the end of 2021 or the beginning of 2022 through Group Russian Energy, in which he was the majority shareholder; and Group Russian Energy itself. The evidence file behind the listing contained twelve press and database exhibits, from Forbes and the Russian news agency Tass to the company registers rusprofile.ru and list-org.com. The exhibits described Vorkutagol as one of Russia’s largest coal undertakings, accounting for more than 10 percent or approximately 11 percent of national coal production, and the Court held that it was thus apparent from the file that the applicant had significant capital holdings enabling him to control companies operating in the coal and energy sectors, such as Arctic Energy Group, Northern Star, Group Russian Energy and Vorkutagol, and that those companies pursued non-negligible activities in those sectors.
Trotsenko attacked the reliability of that press-based evidence, and the Court’s answer restated two principles that govern every Russia-listing file. First, the activity of the EU Courts is governed by the principle of the unfettered evaluation of evidence, and the only criterion for assessing the value of the evidence produced is its credibility, judged by the origin of the document, the circumstances in which it came into being and whether on its face it appears sound and reliable. Second, in the absence of investigative powers in third countries, the assessment of the EU authorities must rely on publicly available sources of information, reports, articles in the press, intelligence reports or other similar sources of information, a difficulty aggravated because the conflict situation involving the Russian Federation and Ukraine makes it particularly difficult in practice to access certain sources and collect identified testimony. On that basis the Court accepted Forbes as a reliable source of information in the economic field and treated the file as specific, precise and consistent evidence.
The plea of illegality against the listing criterion itself failed as well. Trotsenko argued that the third prong of the amended criterion (g) was unforeseeable and disproportionate, and that infrastructure was not an autonomous economic sector. The Court replied that the Council is not required to follow the NACE statistical classification of economic activities, and that the infrastructure mentioned in the listing included transport infrastructure, which the applicant had understood without difficulty. The criterion survived, and with it every listing built on it.
B. Why Did the “I Sold My Shares” Defence Fail? The Divestment Burden of Proof
The heart of the case was divestment. Trotsenko told the Council he had sold out: Arctic Energy Group in December 2023, then his indirect holdings in Vorkutagol and Group Russian Energy, and finally his AEON Corporation shares, with completion claimed on 31 March 2025. He produced a legal opinion from a Russian auditing firm, registry extracts, depository operation reports and statements from company directors. The Court dismantled that file piece by piece, and its reasoning now reads as a manual of what not to do.
The starting rule is a split burden of proof. The Court recalled that it is for the Council to establish the validity of the reasons relied on against the person listed, but that where persons subject to restrictive measures, such as the applicant, claim that their personal situation does not correspond to that which appears from the evidence adduced by the Council, it is for the person concerned to provide evidence demonstrating that that situation is genuine. Trotsenko therefore had to prove a genuine exit, and he failed at every step. For Arctic Energy Group, the Court noted that he had not produced any evidence that would make it possible to assess whether the alleged disengagement implies that he has actually relinquished his prerogatives as a shareholder, adding that in particular, he does not provide any information on the arrangements for his disengagement from Arctic Energy Group, or on the consideration, in particular the transfer contract, the transfer price and the payment arrangements.
The same defect sank the Vorkutagol and Group Russian Energy sales. The April 2025 filing relied on three depository reports, shareholder lists before and after the alleged sale, a registry extract and another commissioned legal opinion. The Court held that those registry extracts and depository reports are not, on their own, sufficient to demonstrate the actual relinquishment of the applicant’s prerogatives as a shareholder, because the applicant has not produced the articles of association of the companies concerned or the transfer deeds for the shares held by A-Razvitie in Anthracite, nor has he provided any information on the price at which the shares were transferred or on the payment arrangements. Two aggravating facts finished the argument: the February 2025 filing had itself presented the divestment as not definitively completed, being subject to the lending banks’ agreement, so that on the date of the adoption of the March 2025 acts, no transfer of ownership had taken place and he had not therefore actually relinquished his prerogatives as a shareholder; and the Council’s 2025 evidence still showed the press presenting him as owner of AEON in June 2025, with a Tass article of 18 April 2025 describing him as capable of concluding agreements with a regional governor on behalf of AEON Corporation and Vorkutagol and therefore as still being capable of actively influencing their investment decisions.
Nor did the size of the remaining stake help. Trotsenko argued that his 25.075 percent indirect holding in Vorkutagol was a passive minority that proved nothing. The Court answered that even though the applicant claims that his shareholding in Vorkutagol was a minority stake, such a shareholding remains significant, with 25.075 percent of the shares in that company, and that without the articles of association he could not show the stake gave him no control. Statements from his own directors and opinions commissioned for the litigation were given very limited probative value, particularly where the underlying financial documents were never disclosed to the Court. Finally, timing defeated the legitimate-expectations plea: observations sent days before a renewal leave the Council no time for verification, the Council is not required to respond point by point to the observations and documents submitted, and the notion of leading businesspersons covers facts occurring both in the past and over time, so a last-minute sale does not automatically make a listing obsolete.
II. How to Challenge an EU Asset Freeze From France After Trotsenko
Trotsenko lost, but his judgment maps the only roads that can win. An EU listing is an EU act, reviewable only by the EU courts, yet it bites in France: accounts are blocked by French banks, property cannot be sold, dividends cannot be paid, and any request to use frozen money for daily life or legal fees passes through the French Treasury. A person targeted in France must therefore run the Luxembourg challenge and the French day-to-day management in parallel, with evidence strong enough to survive the exact tests Trotsenko failed.
A. How Does the Annulment Action in Luxembourg Work? Deadlines, Renewals and Winning Evidence
The direct route is an action for annulment under Article 263 TFEU before the General Court in Luxembourg, to be filed within two months of the listing or its notification, and a General Court judgment can then be appealed to the Court of Justice on points of law. Each six-month renewal is a separate reviewable act, which is why Trotsenko was able to attack four successive sets of measures from June 2024 to September 2025, and why every renewal is a fresh opportunity for a file that has genuinely changed. Between renewals, Article 14 of Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 gives the listed person the right to be told the grounds for listing and to present observations, with a Council duty to review its decision where observations are submitted or substantial new evidence is presented. Trotsenko used that procedure repeatedly, and the Court confirmed he had been in a position to make his views known before the March 2025 renewal, which defeated his rights-of-defence plea even though the Council ultimately disagreed with him.
The pleas that can succeed are those Trotsenko neglected to feed with evidence. The duty to state reasons requires the Council to disclose the actual and specific reasons for the listing, and the file must allow the person to understand what he is accused of and the Court to review it. Errors of assessment are reviewed against the whole evidence file, and press-based evidence, though admissible, must be specific, precise and consistent, which leaves room to contradict it with audited accounts, land and company registers, and independent reporting rather than commissioned opinions. Proportionality and fundamental rights remain the last wall: the Court recalled that the right to property, as protected by Article 17(1) of the Charter, does not constitute an unfettered prerogative, that the measures do not impose on the person an obligation to divest his shareholdings since the sole effect of the contested acts is to freeze all of the applicant’s funds and economic resources located within the territory of the European Union, and that the objective of maintaining peace and international security outweighs negative consequences, even considerable ones, for the person concerned. That reasoning follows the Court of Justice’s Kadi line, limiting Charter rights only where the essence of the right is preserved and the measure is necessary for an objective of general interest, the Melli Bank test that measures must be appropriate and not go beyond what is necessary, and the RT France framework for reviewing interferences with fundamental rights.
Translated into practice, the winning file after Trotsenko contains what his file lacked: complete transfer deeds with identified buyers unrelated to the seller, the agreed price with proof of payment through traced bank transfers, the amended articles of association and shareholder registers, resignations from boards and management, evidence that lender consents and regulatory approvals are final rather than pending, and public records updated so that no press outlet or registry still presents the seller as owner. It is filed early in the renewal cycle, not days before expiry, with a sworn translation and an independent audit trail, because last-minute filings give the Council a lawful reason to carry the listing over while it verifies. The Usmanov and Fridman delistings show that exits can succeed when the Council is persuaded the factual basis has genuinely disappeared; Trotsenko shows that self-certified exits with missing contracts do not.
B. What Happens in France? Treasury Freezes, Blocked Accounts, Derogations and Acting From Paris
EU regulations are directly applicable in France, so the freeze in Annex I of Regulation 269/2014 operates in Paris without any French transposition: the bank blocks the account, the notary cannot complete the sale, the insurer freezes the policy. The French layer sits on top. Under Article L. 562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code, the Minister for the Economy may himself order a freeze for six months, renewable, of funds belonging to or controlled by persons designated under EU acts, and Article L. 562-4-1 of the same Code obliges banks, insurers and other regulated entities to maintain internal freeze procedures, to enforce EU restrictive measures and the prohibition on circumventing them, including through their foreign branches. Definitions of the key terms sit in Article L. 562-1, a parallel joint freeze power shared by the Ministers for the Economy and the Interior exists under Article L. 562-2, and the duty to apply freezes without delay and report immediately is set by Article L. 562-4, implemented through the internal procedures required by Article R. 562-1 and the reporting channel of Article R. 562-3, with frozen persons recorded on the national register kept by the minister under Article R. 562-2. In practice the Treasury’s financial-sanctions teleservice is the gateway for declarations, exemption requests and transaction authorisations, and any person whose funds are frozen in France will deal with the Directorate General of the Treasury long before ever seeing a judge.
Frozen does not mean resourceless. Article 4 of Regulation 269/2014 allows the competent national authority to release funds necessary to satisfy the basic needs of listed persons and their dependent family members, including payments for foodstuffs, rent or mortgage, medicines and medical treatment, taxes, insurance premiums, and public utility charges, or intended exclusively for payment of reasonable professional fees or reimbursement of incurred expenses associated with the provision of legal services, plus routine custody fees and, with prior notification to the other Member States and the Commission, extraordinary expenses. Article 5 adds releases to satisfy arbitral, judicial or administrative decisions. These derogations are applied for in France through the Treasury, with supporting invoices, fee agreements and proof that no funds will be made available to the listed person beyond the authorised purpose, and a refusal can be challenged before the French administrative courts. The criminal risk runs in the other direction: moving, concealing or using frozen assets, or making funds available in breach of the freeze prohibited by Article L. 562-5, exposes the holder and any intermediary to prosecution, which is why every step, from paying the electricity bill to selling a minority stake, should pass through a documented authorisation request rather than a private arrangement.
For clients based in Paris and the Ile-de-France region, the practical sequence is therefore clear. First, map every frozen asset and every blocked relationship in France, because a French bank’s over-compliance often freezes more than the EU texts require, and each unjustified extension is contestable with the bank and, where needed, the supervisor and the courts. Second, secure daily life and the defence itself through Treasury derogation requests, since legal fees for the Luxembourg action can themselves be paid from frozen funds once authorised. Third, build the delisting file to Trotsenko standards from Paris, with French or international counsel coordinating sworn translations, independent valuations, traced payments and registry updates, and file observations with the Council in good time before each renewal. Fourth, where the listing is legally flawed, bring the Article 263 action in Luxembourg within the two-month limit while keeping the French administrative route open for national measures and refusals. Each of these steps is documented in the file, because as Trotsenko proves, sanctions litigation rewards files, not indignation.
Conclusion
The General Court’s judgment of 16 September 2026 in Trotsenko v Council changes no rule and overturns no listing, yet it is one of the most useful sanctions decisions of the year for practitioners. It confirms that press-based evidence, led by business publications such as Forbes, can lawfully support a listing where it is specific, precise and consistent; that the leading-businessperson criterion looks at facts past and present, so yesterday’s empire counts as well as today’s; that the right to property is limited by the objectives of peace and international security; and above all that a claimed divestment without a transfer contract, without a price, without payment proof and without corporate documents is worth nothing before the EU courts. For sanctioned persons with interests in France, the message is operational: freeze-management through the Treasury, derogations for basic needs and legal fees, early and documented observations at each renewal, and, where the grounds are genuinely gone, an annulment action built on complete, independent, verifiable evidence. The Court left the door open; it simply demands that those who walk through it bring the file with them.