KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU Court Annuls Russian Singer Polina Gagarina’s Sanctions Listing: the 16 September 2026 Judgment and How to Challenge an EU Asset Freeze From France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU Court Annuls Russian Singer Polina Gagarina’s Sanctions Listing: the 16 September 2026 Judgment and How to Challenge an EU Asset Freeze From France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 16 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union in Luxembourg delivered one of the most practical sanctions judgments of the year. In Case T-460/24, Polina Sergeevna Gagarina v Council of the European Union, the Court partly annulled the EU sanctions listing of the Russian singer: it upheld her initial listing of June 2024 and its first renewal of September 2024, but it annulled the renewals of March 2025 and September 2025. The reason is straightforward and reaches far beyond one singer. When the Council renewed the measures, its file did not show that her participation in state propaganda events was still regular on the dates those renewals were adopted. The most recent documented concert went back to 18 March 2024. A well-documented past, the Court held, is not enough: every renewal is a fresh decision that requires fresh proof. For anyone whose funds are frozen in France under EU restrictive measures — Russian, Belarusian, Iranian or Syrian nationals, businesspeople, relatives of listed persons, companies holding blocked accounts in Paris — this judgment is a working manual. It shows what the Council must prove, where its evidence files typically fail, and how a listing can be attacked before the EU courts while the frozen assets sit in a French bank. This analysis explains the ruling step by step and sets out exactly how to challenge an EU listing or an asset freeze from France.

The timing matters. On 22 September 2026 the Council extended the EU sanctions over Ukraine for a further period while removing two prominent names, a development widely reported by Reuters and analysed on this site in our analysis of the Usmanov and Fridman delistings. Renewals happen every six months, each one generating a new removable act. The Gagarina judgment of 16 September 2026, published by the Court and referenced on InfoCuria under Case T-460/24, tells listed persons and their banks precisely how to test each renewal. A parallel recent success before the same Court, concerning another Russian applicant, is examined in our Tokareva case analysis. Read together, these rulings draw a clear map of the Council’s weakest point: stale evidence.

I. Why Did the EU General Court Annul Polina Gagarina’s Sanctions Listing?

A. What Was Polina Gagarina Accused Of Under EU Sanctions Law?

Polina Gagarina was added to the EU sanctions lists on 24 June 2024 under two criteria. The decisive one, known as criterion (a), targets persons supporting actions or policies which undermine or threaten the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence of Ukraine, within the meaning of Article 2(1)(a) of Decision 2014/145/CFSP and Article 3(1)(a) of Regulation (EU) No 269/2014. The Council’s case was that she regularly performs in the framework of State propaganda events, for example to celebrate the illegal annexation of four Ukrainian regions or the anniversary of the annexation of Crimea. Under the second criterion, the Council added that she benefited from the Russian Government because her frequent appearances at state-sponsored events and programmes brought her significant revenue. The September 2024 renewal kept both reasons. The March 2025 and September 2025 renewals kept only the first criterion, with shorter reasoning. Each of those acts — the Council Decision amending Decision 2014/145/CFSP and the matching Implementing Regulation amending Regulation No 269/2014 — is a separate legal act that can be challenged separately, and Gagarina challenged each of them by adapting her original action.

The evidence behind the listing was concrete and recent at the time of the initial measure. The judgment describes, for example, an article published on 18 March 2022 reporting that the applicant sang at the concert held at Moscow’s Luzhniki Stadium on the anniversary of the annexation of Crimea, on a stage decorated with the slogans For Russia and For a world without Nazism, where she was wearing a white outfit adorned with the capital letter ‘Z’. Other exhibits documented further appearances at state-linked concerts through 2023 and up to 18 March 2024. Gagarina answered with four pleas in law, and the judgment records them exactly: she relied on four pleas in law, alleging (i) infringement of the obligation to state reasons and of the right to effective judicial protection, (ii) manifest error of assessment and infringement of the principle of legal certainty, (iii) infringement of the principle of proportionality and of fundamental rights, and (iv) infringement of freedom of expression and freedom of the arts. For the September 2025 renewal she added a fifth plea alleging procedural irregularities. The structure of the case already carries a first lesson for anyone listed: attack every act, plead in the alternative, and force the Council to defend each renewal on its own evidence.

On the initial listing, the Council won. The Court found a specific, precise and consistent body of evidence establishing the applicant’s participation in a number of State propaganda events over recent years and rejected the argument that she had performed at only two concerts during that period. It concluded that the Council has established, to the requisite legal standard and without infringing the principle of legal certainty, that the applicant had participated regularly in events intended to promote Russian State propaganda, so that the Council was therefore entitled, without any error of assessment, to conclude, by means of the initial acts, that the applicant was supporting actions undermining the territorial integrity of Ukraine within the meaning of criterion (a). For the September 2024 renewal, adopted less than three months after the initial acts, the Court added that the Council also did not make an error of assessment when it considered, on the basis of the same evidence, that the applicant continued to support such actions within the meaning of the same criterion. And since the restrictive measures against the applicant were not vitiated by an error of assessment, in so far as her artistic activities, which disseminated State propaganda in support of actions undermining the integrity of Ukraine, supported the conclusion that she fulfilled the conditions for the application of criterion (a), the applications against the 2024 acts were dismissed. The Court stressed that the fact that the applicant is not directly involved in any decision, action or policy relating to the illegal annexation of the Ukrainian territories is irrelevant, because the measures punished her active support through propaganda performances in her capacity as a famous singer. In short: performing repeatedly at state propaganda events can lawfully support a listing, even for an artist with no political role. The annulment came from somewhere else entirely — time.

B. Why Did the Court Hold That the Council’s Evidence Had Gone Stale?

The turning point of the judgment is the review standard. The Council enjoys discretion in deciding whether the listing criteria are met, but the Court recalled that the Courts of the European Union must ensure the review, in principle the full review, of the lawfulness of all EU acts, citing the judgment of 15 November 2023 in OT v Council, T-193/22. Full review means the judges verify the facts themselves; they do not defer to the Council’s file. For the March 2025 and September 2025 renewals, the Council relied on a first and a second evidence file, but the second file contained only two documents, both identical to material already produced with its defence. Gagarina’s lawyers made the decisive point: for the March 2025 renewal, the Council does not rely on any event which occurred in 2025, and for September 2025, the Council did not provide updated evidence in support of its decision to maintain her name on the lists at issue. The Council replied that the file showed conduct continuing beyond 2022 and 2023 and that her situation had not changed. The Court disagreed, and its reasoning now binds future cases.

The Court accepted that the Council may rely on old evidence, but only under strict conditions: it is not prohibited from basing its decision on the same evidence justifying the initial inclusion, provided that (i) the reasons for listing remain unchanged and (ii) the context has not changed in such a way that that evidence is now out of date, a context covering both the country situation and the particular situation of the person concerned. Relying on the Court of Justice’s judgment of 13 March 2025 in Shuvalov v Council, C-271/24 P, the General Court admitted that past material may establish continuity between, on the one hand, the previous situation of the person concerned and, on the other, his or her current situation. Then came the factual guillotine: the most recent State propaganda event at which the applicant performed is the concert of 18 March 2024, and the files do not refer to any other propaganda event in which it is alleged that the applicant participated since that date. Therefore the evidence does not demonstrate that the applicant’s conduct was still of a regular nature at the date of adoption of those acts or, more specifically, that she was continuing to perform regularly at State propaganda events at that date. The Council had not shown that regular appearances from 2022 to 2024 were enough to presume continued support a year later, so the Council did not present a body of evidence that was sufficiently specific, precise and consistent to establish that the applicant continued to satisfy criterion (a) on the date of adoption of those acts. Result: the second plea in law must be upheld and the March 2025 acts and the September 2025 acts must be annulled without it being necessary to rule on the first, third and fourth pleas raised by the applicant.

The operative part is surgical. The Court annuls Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/528 of 14 March 2025, Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/527 of 14 March 2025, Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 of 12 September 2025 and Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1894 of 12 September 2025, in each case in so far as they concern Ms Polina Sergeevna Gagarina, while dismissing the rest of the action and ordering each party to bear its own costs. Three practical consequences follow. First, the annulment covers only the period from March 2025 to March 2026; a later maintaining act, Decision (CFSP) 2026/696 running until 15 September 2026, was not before the Court and remains to be fought separately. Second, the Council can still appeal to the Court of Justice, and during appeal proceedings it may ask that the effects of the annulled acts be maintained — in this very case the Council had already requested that the effects of the contested decisions be preserved pending the regulation annulments taking effect. Third, and most important for listed persons, the judgment converts every six-monthly renewal into a new vulnerable target: if twelve months pass without a newly documented supporting act, the renewal file is exposed. Anyone considering a challenge should therefore calendar each renewal date in the Official Journal and demand the Council’s evidence file immediately.

II. How Can You Challenge EU Sanctions or a Frozen Bank Account From France?

A. How Do You Bring an Annulment Action Against the Council in Luxembourg?

The direct route is an action for annulment before the General Court under Article 263 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. The Treaty opens this remedy widely: Toute personne physique ou morale peut former, dans les conditions prévues aux premier et deuxième alinéas, un recours contre les actes dont elle est le destinataire ou qui la concernent directement et individuellement, ainsi que contre les actes réglementaires qui la concernent directement et qui ne comportent pas de mesures d’exécution. A person named in a sanctions annex is the textbook example of someone individually concerned. But the deadline is brutal: Les recours prévus au présent article doivent être formés dans un délai de deux mois à compter, suivant le cas, de la publication de l’acte, de sa notification au requérant ou, à défaut, du jour où celui-ci en a eu connaissance. Miss the two months from the Official Journal publication of the renewal and the act becomes final; Gagarina succeeded precisely because she adapted her action to each renewal through formal statements of modification, a procedural device the judgment records for the April and November 2025 filings. Representation by a lawyer entitled to practise before the EU courts is mandatory, the application must be drafted in the language of the case, and the Council must then disclose the evidence files on which it relied — the very files whose staleness decided this case.

Substance beats form, but form still matters. Gagarina pleaded four substantive pleas plus a procedural one; the Court decided the case on the second plea alone — error of assessment — expressly leaving the statement-of-reasons, proportionality, freedom-of-expression and procedural pleas undecided. That is a deliberate litigation tactic worth copying: stack independent pleas so that one solid evidentiary gap suffices, and the Court can annul without reaching the harder constitutional arguments about artistic freedom. Two companion arguments deserve a place in every file. First, demand the statement of reasons communicated at listing and compare it with the renewal reasons: where the Council shortens its reasoning at renewal stage, as it did here by keeping only criterion (a), any new gap becomes visible. Second, track the applicant’s current conduct positively — cancelled concerts, ended contracts, public distancing, relocation of activity — because the Court measures regularity at the adoption date of each act, not at the date of the oldest exhibit. Interim relief under Articles 278 and 279 TFEU, suspending the freeze while the case runs, is theoretically available but granted only on urgency and a prima facie case; in practice most applicants live under the freeze during the eighteen to twenty-four months a case takes, which is why parallel steps in France, described below, are essential. A prior request to the Council for delisting, with supporting documents, costs little and creates a paper trail that later exposes the Council if it renews without answering the new material.

Paris practitioners add a French layer that foreign applicants often miss. Even before any Luxembourg judgment, the French administration applies the EU freeze directly through French banks, and every difficulty — a blocked transfer, a closed account, a refused mortgage payment — generates dated evidence of the measure’s concrete impact, useful both for the urgency branch of interim relief and for a later damages action for unlawful listing. Conversely, a Luxembourg annulment does not automatically unblock a Paris account the same morning: the bank’s compliance department waits for the updated consolidated list and for its regulator’s signal, so counsel must serve the judgment on the bank, on the Directorate General of the Treasury, and be ready to seek summary relief from the French courts if the freeze lingers after the legal basis has fallen. The two recent French-linked successes — this Gagarina annulment and the Tokareva annulment examined in our earlier analysis — show that the Council’s files crack at the same place: renewals recycled without new proof. Check each renewal, demand each file, sue each act: that is the method.

B. What Happens in France When Your Funds Are Frozen Under EU Sanctions?

In France, an EU asset freeze bites through the banks, immediately and without a judge. Article L. 562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code provides that «Sont tenus d’appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation prévues au présent chapitre et aux articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 et d’en informer immédiatement le ministre chargé de l’économie»: every bank holding an account for a listed person must freeze it at once and report to the Minister for the Economy. The full official text of Article L. 562-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code details the persons covered, from individuals on national territory to companies operating in France. Banks must also build permanent machinery: Article L. 562-4-1 requires that «Les personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 561-2 mettent en place une organisation et des procédures internes pour la mise en œuvre des mesures de gel des avoirs et d’interdiction de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation des fonds ou ressources économiques prévues au présent chapitre», expressly including freezes ordered «par les règlements européens portant mesures restrictives pris en application des articles 75 ou 215 du traité sur le fonctionnement de l’Union européenne» (see Article L. 562-4-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code), and the implementing decree Article R. 562-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code specifies that «L’organisation et les procédures internes prévues par l’article L. 562-4-1 doivent permettre l’application sans délai des mesures de gel et d’interdiction de mise à disposition conformément à l’article L. 562-4». In practice this means a listed person’s Paris accounts are typically blocked within hours of a new EU regulation, with no prior hearing — which is exactly why the EU judge’s later full review of the file is the applicant’s real trial.

The prohibitions surrounding the freeze are deliberately wide. Article L. 562-5 states that «Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de mettre à disposition directement ou indirectement, ou d’utiliser des fonds ou ressources économiques au profit des personnes dont les fonds et ressources économiques font l’objet d’une mesure de gel» (see Article L. 562-5 of the Monetary and Financial Code), and Article L. 562-6 adds that «Il est interdit aux personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 562-4 de participer, sciemment et volontairement, à des activités ayant pour objet ou pour effet de contourner les mesures prises en vertu du présent chapitre» (see Article L. 562-6 of the Monetary and Financial Code). Family members, business partners and companies must understand that paying the listed person’s rent, routing salary through a relative’s account, or restructuring shareholdings to dodge the freeze can expose them personally. The freeze follows the assets against everyone: Article L. 562-10 provides that «Les mesures prises en vertu du présent chapitre sont opposables à tout tiers qui peut invoquer un droit sur les fonds ou ressources économiques faisant l’objet d’une mesure de gel, y compris lorsque ce droit est né antérieurement auxdites mesures» (see Article L. 562-10 of the Monetary and Financial Code). Alongside the EU regime sits a distinct national freeze power: Article L. 562-2 allows that «Le ministre chargé de l’économie et le ministre de l’intérieur peuvent décider, conjointement, pour une durée de six mois, renouvelable, le gel des fonds et ressources économiques» of persons linked to terrorism or, since recent reforms, interference and drug trafficking (see Article L. 562-2 of the Monetary and Financial Code), with definitions centralised in Article L. 562-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code and publication rules in Article L. 562-9 of the Monetary and Financial Code. Counsel must therefore identify on day one which freeze applies — EU regulation, national ministerial order, or both — because the court with jurisdiction and the deadline depend entirely on that answer.

French criminal courts punish whoever games the freeze. On 29 November 2023 the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in case No 22-85.867, ruled on two men convicted «pour soustraction aux mesures de gel des avoirs dans le cadre de la lutte contre le terrorisme», where the first had received «trois mois d’emprisonnement avec sursis probatoire, une amende douanière et une confiscation» and the second «deux mois d’emprisonnement avec sursis, une amende douanière et une confiscation» (see Court of Cassation, Criminal Chamber, 29 November 2023, No 22-85.867). The Court partly quashed on the penalties, recalling through Article 593 of the Code of Criminal Procedure that «Tout jugement ou arrêt doit comporter les motifs propres à justifier la décision. L’insuffisance ou la contradiction des motifs équivaut à leur absence» — a warning that cuts both ways: French judges must spell out why a freeze-evasion penalty is justified, and EU authorities must spell out why a listing is maintained. On the civil side, the most spectacular French sanctions case remains Bank Sepah: on 10 July 2020 the Full Court of the Court of Cassation, seized by the Iranian bank whose Paris assets were frozen under EU anti-proliferation regulations, stayed proceedings and referred questions to the Court of Justice, asking whether the EU regulations «doivent-ils être interprétés en ce sens qu’ils s’opposent à ce que soit diligentée sur des avoirs gelés, sans autorisation préalable de l’autorité nationale compétente, une mesure dépourvue d’effet attributif, telle une sûreté judiciaire ou une saisie conservatoire, prévues par le code des procédures civiles d’exécution français ?», and staying the appeals «jusqu’à la décision de la Cour de justice de l’Union européenne» (see Court of Cassation, Full Court, 10 July 2020, Nos 18-18.542 and 18-21.814). The lesson for creditors and listed persons alike: frozen does not mean untouchable, but every step over frozen assets in France needs the Treasury’s prior authorisation.

That authorisation is the daily key. EU Regulation No 269/2014 itself provides derogations — basic needs, legal fees, routine account maintenance — implemented in France through individual licences granted by the Directorate General of the Treasury after a reasoned application showing the funds’ destination. A listed person living in Paris should therefore run three tracks at once: the Luxembourg annulment action within its two-month window, the Treasury licence requests keeping life and the defence funded, and the French protective litigation if a bank over-blocks beyond the listed person’s own assets. Keep every bank letter, every refused transfer slip, every licence reply: the Gagarina file shows that cases are won on dated paper, not on rhetoric. And never reorganise assets to sidestep the freeze without counsel — the Criminal Chamber’s 2023 ruling proves that evasion turns a sanctions problem into a criminal record.

Conclusion

The Gagarina judgment of 16 September 2026 does not say that supporting state propaganda is lawful, and it leaves the 2024 listing intact. It says something more useful for every listed person with assets in France: the Council’s file has an expiry date. A concert in March 2024 cannot justify a freeze renewed in September 2025 without fresh proof of regular supporting conduct, and the EU judge will check the dates line by line under full review. Each six-monthly renewal published in the Official Journal is therefore a new opening — provided the two-month action deadline is met, the evidence file is demanded, and the applicant’s current conduct is documented. Combined with disciplined French steps — Treasury licences, precise identification of the applicable freeze, and criminal-risk hygiene for relatives and partners — the Luxembourg action gives frozen-out individuals a genuine path back to their accounts. The Council will keep renewing; after Gagarina, it must keep proving.

📄 Official circular