KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Ex Won’t Let My Parents See Our Child: Grandparents’ Contact Rights in France for Expat Families

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Ex Won’t Let My Parents See Our Child: Grandparents’ Contact Rights in France for Expat Families

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your daughter has stopped answering your calls. Your son-in-law has told the children that visits with grandma and grandpa are over. Or the rupture is quieter: after the divorce, the parent who kept the children moved on with a new partner, and the grandparents on the other side slowly disappeared from the children’s lives. For expatriate families in France, the wound cuts deeper across borders. The grandparents may live in London, New York, Madrid or Milan while the grandchildren grow up in Paris, and one parent controls every phone call, every school holiday, every plane ticket. Many grandparents in this position assume they have no rights at all, because parental authority (autorité parentale, the set of rights and duties parents hold over their minor child) belongs to the parents. French law says otherwise. The child himself or herself holds a personal right to maintain relations with grandparents, and only the child’s own best interests can stand in its way. This guide explains, entirely under current French law, what that right covers, when a parent may lawfully limit contact, how grandparents seize the family judge (juge aux affaires familiales, universally shortened to JAF, the specialised judge inside each tribunal judiciaire who decides custody, residence, contact and support), what happens when the grandparents live abroad, and how a parent who faces an abusive or unsafe demand can defend the refusal. Every decisive rule below is quoted word for word from the official text, with an English translation immediately after, so that an English-speaking reader can check each statement against the source.

I. Blocked from your grandchildren: what French law actually guarantees

A. Your grandchild’s own right to see you

The foundation sits in a single article of the Civil Code (Code civil), article 371-4, available on the official Légifrance database. It provides: “L’enfant a le droit d’entretenir des relations personnelles avec ses ascendants. Seul l’intérêt de l’enfant peut faire obstacle à l’exercice de ce droit.” . In plain English: the child has the right to maintain personal relations with grandparents, and only the child’s own best interests can block that right. Two features of this sentence matter enormously in practice. First, the right belongs to the child, not to the grandparents. A grandmother does not sue to vindicate her own suffering; she asks the judge to protect her grandchild’s right to know her. That framing shapes every judgment: the court never asks who deserves contact, only what the child needs. Second, the barrier is unique. No parental disagreement, no family quarrel, no new spouse’s jealousy can lawfully justify cutting contact. Only proof that contact would harm this particular child can defeat the claim. The official service-public.fr information page, verified on 22 July 2025, states the rule in plain terms for the public: the minor child has the right to maintain personal relations with grandparents whether the parents live together or apart, and it may take the form of a right of visit (droit de visite, short stays and meetings) or a right of accommodation (droit d’hébergement, overnight stays, weekends and holiday periods). The page is worth reading before any step: Séparation des parents : relations entre l’enfant et sa famille ou ses proches.

The same article extends beyond grandparents. Its second paragraph provides: “Si tel est l’intérêt de l’enfant, le juge aux affaires familiales fixe les modalités des relations entre l’enfant et un tiers, parent ou non, en particulier lorsque ce tiers a résidé de manière stable avec lui et l’un de ses parents, a pourvu à son éducation, à son entretien ou à son installation, et a noué avec lui des liens affectifs durables.” . Put simply: where the child’s welfare so requires, the family judge organises contact between the child and a third party, related or not, especially where that person has lived with the child, helped raise or support the child, and built lasting emotional bonds. This covers the former step-parent who raised the child for years, the aunt who lived in the home, sometimes an older half-sibling. The constitutional challenge brought against this very paragraph failed. On 6 November 2019 the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Court of Cassation, France’s supreme court for civil matters), appeal no. 19-15.198, refused to refer the question to the Constitutional Council, holding: “l’article 371-4 du code civil ne saurait porter atteinte à l’exigence constitutionnelle de protection de l’intérêt supérieur de l’enfant dès lors qu’il fonde les décisions relatives aux relations personnelles de l’enfant avec un tiers, parent ou non, sur le seul critère de l’intérêt de l’enfant.” . Rendered into English, the holding is that article 371-4 cannot breach the constitutional protection of the child’s superior interest, because it makes the child’s best interests the sole test for contact with a third party, related or not. For expatriate readers, the message is that French grandparent contact is a constitutional-grade principle, not a favour the parents grant.

A concrete ruling shows how courts calibrate contact child by child. On 13 June 2019 the First Civil Chamber, appeals nos. 18-12.389 and 18-16.642 joined, dealt with a maternal grandmother who, according to the judgment, “a assigné sa fille, Mme I…, ainsi que MM. D… et M…-T…, les pères des enfants, afin d’obtenir un droit de visite et d’hébergement à l’égard de ceux-ci, adapté selon les relations établies avec chacun d’eux” — in English: she had summoned her daughter and the children’s fathers to obtain visit and accommodation rights tailored to the bond she shared with each child —. The Toulouse Court of Appeal had granted her ordinary visitation and accommodation for one child and supervised visitation (visite médiatisée, contact taking place in a supervised meeting place) for the two younger children, and the Court of Cassation rejected the parents’ appeals. Three lessons follow. Grandparents sue the holders of parental authority directly, by formal summons. The judge differentiates between children of different ages and histories rather than issuing a single blanket order. And supervised contact exists as a middle path where ordinary stays would expose the child to conflict: losing unsupervised weekends is not the same as losing the grandchildren.

B. When parents may say no, and when refusal breaks the law

Parental authority does include a power of supervision. Article 371-1 of the Civil Code defines it as follows: “L’autorité parentale est un ensemble de droits et de devoirs ayant pour finalité l’intérêt de l’enfant.” . In English: parental authority is a bundle of rights and duties aimed entirely at the child’s welfare. The official service-public.fr page draws the consequence: parents have the right and the duty to supervise their minor child’s relations and communications with family members and third parties, and they may limit or prohibit those relations where the child’s welfare requires it. A parent who discovers that visits systematically end with the child humiliated, manipulated against the other parent, medically neglected, or exposed to an unsafe household is entitled to act first and explain after, provided the explanation genuinely rests on the child’s welfare. The same article 371-1 adds a sentence that judges quote back to intrusive grandparents: “Les parents associent l’enfant aux décisions qui le concernent, selon son âge et son degré de maturité.” . Meaning: parents must involve the child in decisions affecting the child, in line with age and maturity. Grandparents who bypass the parents entirely, interrogate the child about the divorce, or organise secret trips, hand the opposing parent ready-made evidence that contact feeds the conflict rather than the child.

Refusal becomes unlawful the moment its true motive is punishment of the other generation rather than protection of the child. Because only the child’s best interests can obstruct the right, a judge will look past stated pretexts: the grandmother criticised the mother’s cooking, the grandfather voted differently, the new partner dislikes the former in-laws, the parents simply want a clean break with the past. None of these defeats the claim by itself. The parent who opposes contact must therefore build a child-centred file: dated incidents, messages showing pressure on the child, medical or school reports, proof of missed returns or alcohol problems during stays. Conversely, grandparents who can show years of steady presence, school runs, holiday photographs, paediatrician visits and a calm tone in writing arrive with the presumptions on their side. One asymmetry deserves emphasis. A parent’s own right of visit and accommodation can be refused to the other parent only on serious grounds, since article 373-2-1 of the Civil Code provides: “L’exercice du droit de visite et d’hébergement ne peut être refusé à l’autre parent que pour des motifs graves.” . In everyday terms: the other parent can be denied visit and accommodation rights only for serious reasons. Grandparents sit one rung below: their contact yields to a lower threshold, the child’s best interests alone, which is why even modest evidence of harm, instability or instrumentalisation can suffice to reduce contact to supervised meetings or correspondence, while mere dislike of the grandparents never suffices to erase it.

II. Getting contact ordered: the family judge, step by step, including from abroad

A. How grandparents actually seize the family judge and win contact

French procedure rewards the grandparent who tries agreement first and punishes the one who sues by surprise. Family mediation (médiation familiale, a structured negotiation led by a certified family mediator) can rebuild a schedule without a trial: a few sessions, a written agreement, and then homologation. The judge may be asked to approve (homologuer) the agreement, which gives it force exécutoire, meaning enforceability with the assistance of public force if necessary. The official service-public.fr page recommends this path expressly, and judges look kindly on grandparents who attempted it, because article 371-1 expects adults to associate the child with decisions rather than drag the child into war. Where dialogue is impossible, because the door is slammed, the letters return unopened or every proposal is refused, the grandparents file an assignation, a formal summons served by a commissaire de justice (the merged profession of former bailiffs and judicial officers) calling the parents before the JAF of the tribunal judiciaire for the place where the child lives. The service-public.fr page states two practical points without ambiguity: grandparents must seize the JAF of the court of the child’s residence by summons, and representation by a lawyer (avocat) is mandatory. Households with modest income may apply for legal aid (aide juridictionnelle), so a grandmother living on a pension is not priced out of the courtroom. The summons must name precisely what is requested: video calls twice a week, one weekend a month, half of each school holiday, pick-up and return logistics, who pays for train or plane tickets. Vague prayers for “access” produce vague judgments.

Before the judge, four evidentiary blocks decide the outcome. First, the history of ties: photographs, school records listing the grandparent as emergency contact, testimony from teachers or neighbours, proof of years of childcare. The 2019 grandmother ruling turned on exactly this, with contact adapted to the relationship established with each child. Second, the absence of danger: clean criminal record extracts where relevant, medical certificates, attestations that stays follow the child’s diet, treatment and bedtime. Third, neutrality in the parental conflict: written messages showing the grandparent never denigrates either parent in front of the child and returns the child on time. Fourth, the child’s own voice. Article 388-1 of the Civil Code provides: “Dans toute procédure le concernant, le mineur capable de discernement peut, sans préjudice des dispositions prévoyant son intervention ou son consentement, être entendu par le juge ou, lorsque son intérêt le commande, par la personne désignée par le juge à cet effet. Cette audition est de droit lorsque le mineur en fait la demande.” . In substance: any minor with sufficient maturity may be heard by the judge in proceedings concerning them, and the hearing is automatic whenever the child asks for it. A recent ruling enforces this strictly: on 16 February 2022 the First Civil Chamber, appeal no. 21-23.087, quashed an Orléans custody decision made after a mother’s move precisely because the child had requested a hearing and the court had neither heard her nor explained its refusal in the judgment, recalling: “dans toute procédure le concernant, le mineur capable de discernement peut être entendu par le juge et cette audition est de droit lorsqu’il en fait la demande.” — that is, a mature minor may be heard by the judge in any case concerning them, as of right when they request it — Grandparents should therefore never coach a child to demand a hearing, which backfires, but they may respectfully invite an adolescent to write to the judge in their own words. Our detailed guide to these hearings is here: Will the French Judge Hear My Child? Child Hearings in French Divorce.

The judge then weighs the file under criteria the Civil Code lists for parental-authority disputes and applies by analogy to third-party contact. Article 373-2-11 provides: “Lorsqu’il se prononce sur les modalités d’exercice de l’autorité parentale, le juge prend notamment en considération : 1° La pratique que les parents avaient précédemment suivie ou les accords qu’ils avaient pu antérieurement conclure ; 2° Les sentiments exprimés par l’enfant mineur dans les conditions prévues à l’article 388-1 ; 3° L’aptitude de chacun des parents à assumer ses devoirs et respecter les droits de l’autre” . The English sense: the judge weighs past parental practice and prior agreements, the child’s own expressed feelings, and each parent’s ability to meet duties while respecting the other parent’s rights, adding pressures or violence by one parent against the other as a sixth factor. In grandparent cases the decisive factors become the prior practice of contact, the child’s expressed feelings, and each side’s aptitude to respect the other’s place. The resulting order is a tailor-made schedule: weekly video calls at fixed hours, defined holiday fractions, handover points at stations or airports, allocation of travel costs between the parties, sometimes a review clause after one year. Where conflict runs hot, the judge can secure enforcement from day one. Article 373-2-6 of the Civil Code opens with the judge’s compass: “Le juge du tribunal judiciaire délégué aux affaires familiales règle les questions qui lui sont soumises dans le cadre du présent chapitre en veillant spécialement à la sauvegarde des intérêts des enfants mineurs.” . In English: the family judge decides the matters before the court with the protection of minor children as the constant priority. The same article allows coercive tools: a penalty payment (astreinte, a daily fine for each day of non-compliance), a civil fine up to 10,000 euros against a person who gravely and repeatedly obstructs a contact order, and, where abduction is feared, an exit ban: “Il peut notamment ordonner l’interdiction de sortie de l’enfant du territoire français sans l’autorisation des deux parents.” . Concretely: the judge can ban the child from leaving France without both parents’ consent. A grandparent who obtains holiday accommodation abroad can therefore ask that the order frame the trip with fixed return dates and, in tense files, reciprocal guarantees. Readers facing the mirror situation, a former partner who withholds the child after contact, will find the enforcement arsenal described in our companion guide: My Ex Blocks My Visits and Will Not Return Our Child After Contact. And where the dispute is really about who decides for the child day to day, the broader framework is here: Parental Authority in France for Expats: Joint or Sole, and the JAF.

B. When the grandparents live abroad: jurisdiction, recognition and the travel maths

Distance changes the logistics, not the applicable law, as long as the grandchild lives in France. Within the European Union, jurisdiction in parental responsibility follows the child’s habitual residence. Council Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter and applicable since 1 August 2022, provides in article 7: Under article 7 of Council Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, known as Brussels II ter, the courts of the Member State where the child habitually resides when seized hear parental-responsibility cases. In plain terms, grandparents in Dublin, Berlin or Rome seize the French JAF of the child’s home in France, and that judge applies French substantive law, including article 371-4. The regulation even anticipates lawful moves: article 8 keeps the courts of the former residence competent for three months after the move to modify an access decision, since Article 8 adds that where a child moves lawfully to another Member State, the former home courts keep power for three months to adjust an access order made before the move, provided the access holder stayed behind. where the access holder stayed behind. Enforcement across EU borders no longer needs the old exequatur declaration: a contact order from a French judge circulates and is treated as if given in the state of enforcement. Outside the European Union, for grandparents in New York, Montreal, Tel Aviv or Sydney, the French JAF remains competent while the child habitually resides in France, but the French order has no automatic effect abroad; whether a foreign authority will lend its force to video-call schedules or holiday stays depends on that country’s own recognition rules, so parallel advice from a local lawyer is indispensable before promising a child that “the judge said so.”

Cross-border contact orders live or die on travel maths, and French judges know it. Article 373-2 of the Civil Code, which governs separated parents but inspires third-party schedules, requires prior notice of any move affecting contact: “Tout changement de résidence de l’un des parents, dès lors qu’il modifie les modalités d’exercice de l’autorité parentale, doit faire l’objet d’une information préalable et en temps utile de l’autre parent.” . The practical meaning: any parental move that changes how authority is exercised must be notified to the other parent in advance and in good time. It then allocates the financial consequence of distance: “Le juge répartit les frais de déplacement et ajuste en conséquence le montant de la contribution à l’entretien et à l’éducation de l’enfant.” . In practice: the judge shares out travel costs and adjusts child maintenance to reflect them. Grandparents should plead travel costs explicitly: who books the Eurostar or the flight, who accompanies an unaccompanied minor, how video calls substitute for missed weekends, whether longer summer blocks replace monthly weekends once flights exceed a few hundred euros. A grandparent in London asking for one weekend a month in Paris without addressing the 200-euro return fare asks the judge to write an order nobody can fund. Propose instead half of every school holiday plus two video calls a week, with written proof of fares attached, and the schedule becomes enforceable reality. Where one parent plans to leave France with the child altogether, the analysis flips to relocation law, covered in our guide: My Ex Wants to Move Abroad With Our Child: How French Judges Decide Relocation Cases.

For families in Paris and the Île-de-France, three practical points complete the picture. First, the competent court is the Paris tribunal judiciaire on the Île de la Cité for children living in the capital, or the tribunal of the child’s suburban home in Nanterre, Bobigny or Créteil; filing in the wrong courthouse delays the summons by weeks. Second, Paris JAF dockets run heavy, so grandparents who arrive with a mediation attempt, a complete documentary file and a costed travel proposal are heard faster and better than those who file a bare two-page summons. Third, supervised meeting places (espaces de rencontre) operate across the region for cases where direct handovers would spark incidents, and legal-aid offices (bureaux d’aide juridictionnelle) sit in each courthouse for grandparents of limited means. None of this requires living in France: a grandmother in Manchester can instruct a Paris lawyer by power of attorney, attend interim hearings by video link where the court allows, and travel only for the decisive hearing and, later, for the holidays the order grants.

Conclusion

French law refuses to treat grandparents as legal strangers. The child holds a personal right to know them, enforceable before the family judge against parents who block contact without a child-centred reason, and adaptable to every configuration: weekends in the same town, video calls across an ocean, supervised meetings where trust must be rebuilt. The price of that protection is method. Attempt mediation and keep the written trace. Sue the right parents before the right court, through a lawyer, with precise requests rather than general grievances. Prove the history of ties, demonstrate neutrality toward the parental conflict, let an adolescent speak in their own words, and cost the travel so the judge can sign a schedule that survives contact with reality. Parents who oppose contact are not defenceless either: documented danger, manipulation of the child, or chronic instability can reduce access to supervised meetings, correspondence, or, in extreme files, suspension, because only the child’s best interests command. In both postures, delay is the enemy. Memories fade, children grow, tickets go up, and a judge deciding next year will ask why nobody acted this year. Whether you are a grandmother in London shut out of FaceTime, a grandfather in Paris told the holidays are cancelled, or a parent served with a summons you consider unjust, assemble your file now: messages, photographs, school attestations, fare estimates, and the exact history of who saw the children, when, and how it went.

📄 Official circular